The dramatic life story of Bella Goth// The biggest Sims mystery

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 26. 07. 2024
  • I’ve been wanting to make a video on Bella Goth for a while now and I’m so glad I finally got around to it!
    This video is an overview of the life and death of Bella Goth and the factors that contributed towards her mysterious disappearance.
    You can find the full fan theory that I mentioned here: alexplayssimsnstuff.tumblr.co...
    I really hope you enjoyed this video and if you did, please like and subscribe to my channel 😊
    If you enjoyed this video, you might like some of my others:
    Breed out the weird: • breed out the weird......
    Sims 4 Life Tragedies: • The Life Tragedies Mod...
    Sims 4 DURK Let’s Play: • NEW LET'S PLAY! // DURK
    Disney Princess Legacy challenge: • The Fairest of them al...
    If I asked you to name the most iconic character in the sims franchise, most of you would probably say Bella Goth.
    And you’d be right! Everyone knows that Bella Goth is the unofficial queen of The Sims! But despite her glamorous exterior and wealthy husband, life hasn’t been too great for our Bella.
    In this video I’ll be taking you through the whole life story of Bella Goth and how she became the centre of the biggest unsolved mystery….in the sims!
    We first meet Bella Goth in The Sims 1. She is wearing her now signature red dress and is married to Mortimore goth. Bella and Mortimore have 1 child, a daughter names Cassandra and they live at no 5 Sim Lane.
    Bella Goth in The Sims 1 is pretty vague, there isn’t really any sign at this point that she would become the centre of the biggest mystery in the sim’s games. So, moving on to where it gets a lot more interesting…
    The Sims 2 is based 25 years after the sims 1 and boy has a lot changed! Bella and Mortimer had a second child, Alexander, but you’d only know this by checking the family tree because guess what? Bella herself is missing.
    The last place Bella was seen was at Don Lotharios house, she was on the rooftop with him when he tried putting it on her and she turned him down.
    If you play as the goth family and investigate their memories you can see that child sim Alexander does not have the memory of Bella being abducted, but Mortimore and Cassandra do, so he could have only been a baby when this happened. Interestingly though, when looking at their memories Cassandra has a negative memory of her mother going missing, meaning it clearly caused her much upset. Mortimore on the other hand remembers Bella’s disappearance, but actually has a positive memory of this.
    If you wonder around strange town long enough you will probably bump into a version of Bella Goth. I say version because if you look at the face of Strange town Bella Goth, she looks completely different to the Bella Goth from Pleasant view, which is the Bella that went missing. Some believe that Strange Town Bella is simply a clone, however there is a chance that it is the real Bella and the difference in appearance is just an oversight from the creators.
    Oversight or not, there are still 2 versions of Bella Goth in the Game. There are also many small reminders of Bella’s disappearance in The game. There’s the Bella Squared painting that can be purchased in the build and buy catalogue. There’s also Bella’s face on milk cartons and a figure standing in the hot air balloon that looks like Bella. Now you could argue that were just looking for Bella everywhere, but considering the emphasis put on Bella’s distinct look, the dark hair and red dress, it’s hard to believe this was an accident….
    So, timeline in a nutshell (presumed) after the sims 1, Bella and Mortimore have another baby, alexander. Bella’s sister in law Dina caliente moves to pleasant view with her sister Nina after Bella’s brother Michael bachelor dies. Not long after the sisters arrive, Bella goes to don lotharios house, don tries it on with Bella, she turns him down and then mysteriously disappears.
    Along comes the sims 3 In pleasant view we’ve taken a step back in time as Bella is now a child and has her maiden name, bachelor. In the downloadable extra world of lunar lakes, which is a world set in space in a later timeline , there is a large gravestone, and who does that grave belong to? Bella Goth.
    It has been officially confirmed that the deceased Bella goth in lunar lakes, is the same Bella that has been the centre of the biggest mystery in the sims. Whilst we do know that she is dead, the saddest part is that we don’t know if she was ever found and ever reunited with her husband and children.
    Opening animation: Free Stock Videos by a target="_blank" href="www.videezy.com"Videezy
    Opening music: www.bensound.com
    1st background music: Juan Sanchez: Now the silence
    2nd background music: • Epic Cinematic Dramati...
    Instagram: / whiny_brit1
    Twitter: / britwhiny
  • Hry

Komentáře • 694

  • @WhinyBrit
    @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +490

    Huge Thank you to these people for supporting this channel on Patreon:
    Melissa
    Ashley Houlihan
    Lozza
    💜💙💚💛🧡

    • @kyngjiga9909
      @kyngjiga9909 Před 3 lety +2

      So the Twins Nina and Dina never like Bella goth/bachelor?

    • @theflowerbunny
      @theflowerbunny Před 3 lety +3

      Mortimer is happy because of Bella's abduction because he has Knowledge aspiration.

    • @ertin24
      @ertin24 Před rokem +2

      Today I got don pregnant by another dude who cheated on him with his fiancé girlfriend other gf other other gf and his bf so dons parter has a lot of other partners btw I got that idea from you and I did it all day and now I’m happy

  • @zirie3291
    @zirie3291 Před 3 lety +5276

    they missed a huge opportunity to make strangerville reveal things about bella goth’s mystery

    • @TheCuteInExecute
      @TheCuteInExecute Před 3 lety +199

      I wouldn’t mind if they continued the story from the psp version where she sold her house

    • @calvinadams5935
      @calvinadams5935 Před 3 lety +12

      Great point!

    • @hooshoof714
      @hooshoof714 Před 2 lety +92

      Yes! Especially it being a remake of the iconic sims neighborhood. You think they would include references to Bella Goth

    • @anonimkullanc489
      @anonimkullanc489 Před 2 lety +70

      Sadly, Sims 4 is just an alternate timeline

    • @idkjustwatching8117
      @idkjustwatching8117 Před 2 lety +7

      maybe theyll do something with the new update coming up like please TT

  • @andyenglish4303
    @andyenglish4303 Před 3 lety +4689

    Me, discovering this video.
    "Wait, the Sims has a plot!?"

  • @arieltales8952
    @arieltales8952 Před 3 lety +3270

    I don't know if it was a glitch of my game, but when child Mortimer reads "Where's Bella" and "Murder in Pleasantview" he stops reading a lot of times and his fun doesn't increase. It doesn't happen with other books.

    • @kennedy3788
      @kennedy3788 Před 3 lety +402

      that’s interesting

    • @Volzotran
      @Volzotran Před 2 lety +193

      It's not a glitch as far as I know

    • @envy2069
      @envy2069 Před 2 lety +61

      Woah

    • @Definetly_Not_Cyn
      @Definetly_Not_Cyn Před 2 lety +80

      Maybe his future self Is giving him flashbacks of what he will live and that He shouldn't read it, even tho that the theory Isn't true

    • @Katzykeens
      @Katzykeens Před 2 lety +88

      Seems kind of fishy that the sims devs are claiming this ISN'T canon, even though they went through all this trouble to add easter eggs like that to the game o.O

  • @kelbifrugia4157
    @kelbifrugia4157 Před 3 lety +4282

    I hope they bring back memories in the Sims 5

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +296

      100% yes! Me too

    • @Belle-on7vd
      @Belle-on7vd Před 3 lety +447

      Maybe they will charge 5 dollars for memories pack

    • @emoscotchtape
      @emoscotchtape Před 3 lety +224

      @@Belle-on7vd Nah, memories expansion packs.

    • @Mcrismylifehelp
      @Mcrismylifehelp Před 3 lety +82

      And flash backs I don't know why I want them

    • @Chillax083
      @Chillax083 Před 3 lety +46

      Slice of life mod allows memories..

  • @GuessImHereNow
    @GuessImHereNow Před 3 lety +1075

    I personally think that when Bella was abducted in the Sims2, the aliens traveled back in time with Bella to the Sims3 so that they couldn’t be followed.
    This was when they began cloning her. But one clone, however, somehow escaped and accidentally traveled into that same time machine back into the Sims2. The clone then settled in Strangetown.
    After years and years of being cloned a concerning amount of times, plus living in an environment she wasn’t built for, the original Bella Goth’s body gradually changed and grew sickly overtime. Eventually, she died.
    This is my theory on why there’s a second Bella in the Sims3 Lunar Lakes,
    and why there’s a clone of her in Strangetown.

    • @cara9851
      @cara9851 Před 3 lety +35

      Why doesn’t this have more likes it’s soooo good

    • @stephanienader7604
      @stephanienader7604 Před 3 lety +36

      That's actually kind of sad now that I think about it, but a good theory!

    • @iffajbd6079
      @iffajbd6079 Před 2 lety +13

      Now that makes sense even more!

    • @avalongaisbauer8501
      @avalongaisbauer8501 Před rokem +2

      Incredible theory! 👏

    • @kristianamarie6762
      @kristianamarie6762 Před 9 měsíci +1

      One question, why? Why would that have been done?

  • @Ahallman30
    @Ahallman30 Před 3 lety +1531

    in my legacy challenge in sims 4. my settings were set to other sims in the game would age overtime. The goth family all aged besides Bella. Even after my sixth generation she was still a young adult. Hm.

    • @calvinadams5935
      @calvinadams5935 Před 3 lety +84

      Thank you for this information!

    • @Uliulihoku
      @Uliulihoku Před 3 lety +46

      Waaaaaaah i wanna try

    • @JuliaGullig
      @JuliaGullig Před 2 lety +33

      Well, i’m trying this the first thing in the morning

    • @Dana-ki6vs
      @Dana-ki6vs Před 2 lety +4

      @@JuliaGullig update?

    • @meltedprincess
      @meltedprincess Před 2 lety +97

      She aged and died in my first sims 4 playthrough lol sorry to burst your bubble

  • @Jody577
    @Jody577 Před 3 lety +742

    I wonder if people like Bella are going to be in the Sims 5, since Bella has been in every Simsgame so far

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +133

      I really hope so, if they get rid of her now I'll have such a strop on!!

    • @queenc8667
      @queenc8667 Před 2 lety +59

      I mean Bella Goth, and the Goth Family in general is truly an icon. Bella herself is an icon, a Queen and we wanna know what happened to her since there are a lot of holes to fill up between the time she got abducted & died on Lunar Lakes.

    • @kasraz.s1061
      @kasraz.s1061 Před rokem

      If there is going be a sims 5

    • @Jody577
      @Jody577 Před rokem

      @@kasraz.s1061 It‘s probably pretty likely they‘ll have another sims game, the question is when

    • @zsariah858
      @zsariah858 Před rokem +1

      @@kasraz.s1061 there is rumors of a sims 5 coming, but from what I've read, won't won't for a few more years. As they say, sims 4 has a lot of life in it yet.

  • @ksizzzle
    @ksizzzle Před 3 lety +2493

    The sims 4 *has never* and *will never* have as much lore as the previous games. Now I know the Sims 4 is an alternate universe and I believe they tried to market it as “create your own memories” but they did a shit job at that because that could’ve opened up the potential for SO MUCH LORE, especially for people who don’t like to create their own timelines and story lines

    • @maiazoicas5469
      @maiazoicas5469 Před 3 lety +132

      ikr they should've kept the goth story

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +183

      Who knows, they may be quietly learning a lesson from feedback form the players. We can only hope for the lure to come back in The Sims 5!

    • @anti-usernamesaltaccount3623
      @anti-usernamesaltaccount3623 Před 3 lety +39

      I read a theory about how the sims 4 is actually just a dream.

    • @angelacooper8973
      @angelacooper8973 Před 3 lety +9

      But the thing is there’s already lore. They should have kept the lore or maybe they have and are keeping it secret

    • @stephanienader7604
      @stephanienader7604 Před 3 lety +12

      @@anti-usernamesaltaccount3623 ..that's actually really interesting. It would explain why all the previous events from 1-3 aren't continued in 4. I doubt that's the case but still an interesting theory overall, thanks for sharing

  • @Briansgate
    @Briansgate Před 3 lety +737

    I only just no started playing the Sims. I had no idea that there were actually backstories for these people.

    • @erzakc5737
      @erzakc5737 Před 3 lety +92

      dont feel bad, ive been playing ever since i can remember and i had no idea there was lor until just now

    • @toricobb7914
      @toricobb7914 Před 3 lety +29

      If u go into the the panel when u click on the house it gives backstories for the OG Sims 😅

    • @deesenuts8730
      @deesenuts8730 Před 3 lety +4

      @@toricobb7914 THANKS

    • @SirenUndine
      @SirenUndine Před 2 lety +6

      Oh, you have much to learn grasshopper. So much lore! Have fun learning it all.

    • @Briansgate
      @Briansgate Před 2 lety +2

      @@SirenUndine I do appreciate the Grasshopper reference.

  • @oakisap
    @oakisap Před 3 lety +803

    The sims 3 lunar lakes one is my favorite. It’s so,, scary. Seeing her rotten corpse is even worse when you ressurect her because you’re bringing back a person that’s been dead for hundreds of years.
    Adding on to this, THE SCARIEST PART ABOUT THIS, Bella may have been tortured in lunar lakes, and that’s why she looks so malnourished.

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +124

      I've never actually played in Lunar Lakes, but I feel like it would be interesting for sure! Thanks for the info

    • @moongem4489
      @moongem4489 Před 2 lety +90

      There's an easter egg in Sims 3: Showtime which suggests that Bella was worshipped as "Empress Bella Goth" by the aliens who abducted her...which is possibly how she lived out the rest of her life in Lunar Lakes. This only makes it creepier, because it's possible that whatever form of "worship" the aliens performed may have harmed her and caused her altered appearance.

  • @maiazoicas5469
    @maiazoicas5469 Před 3 lety +1542

    Omg i felt like i was watching some type of Oscar winning movie. I mean honestly this was the best video I've ever seen about Bella and her family. This makes me wanna buy all the sims games just to see the mystery. I rlly hope EA decides to continue the mystery of Bella goth!!!

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +95

      Oh wow what a compliment! Thank you! i'm glad you enjoyed it! I really enjoyed making this video, i'm thinking about doing similar stories like this for other characters, like The pleasant twins or Donny boy.

    • @jesschristabel4900
      @jesschristabel4900 Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@WhinyBritI agree! Made me super nostalgic... want to relive the Sims 2! Great video, it was captivating

  • @luvley5226
    @luvley5226 Před 3 lety +472

    I've gotta say, I honestly think if Alexander did go back in time then he is the hero of the story...

    • @sanjarsocool
      @sanjarsocool Před 2 lety +35

      It would explain why sims 4 is alternate and doesn’t have any drama

  • @mat_kinasa2947
    @mat_kinasa2947 Před 3 lety +90

    In the sims 3 there is a book called Murder in Pleasantview written by Alexander Goth, and since his parents were still children in that game there is a theory that Alexander used a time portal or time machine to investigate the disappearance of his mother, and maybe the reason the Sims 4 is set in an alternate universe is because he saved his mother and changed the reality, like some kind of butterfly effect

  • @cyanidefilledcandy2
    @cyanidefilledcandy2 Před 3 lety +430

    Whenever I played The Sims, I just made up my own characters and storylines. Finding stuff like this makes me so upset that I missed so much lore! xD

    • @angelreilly8312
      @angelreilly8312 Před 2 lety +31

      Same, I never played the Sims families already in the game - I kinda want to now, and download lunar lakes

  • @Larjus
    @Larjus Před 3 lety +799

    Knowledge sims get positive memories when they (or someone in the family) is abducted by aliens, so it's only expected Mortimer's memory is positive as well.

    • @ritaleena
      @ritaleena Před 3 lety +32

      @Yuna NosTale actually you can assume that... the sims 2 wasn't that mastermind of storytelling and continuity, it 100% was just because maxis forgot to change it to negative and all knowledge sims have it as positive
      there's a shit ton of mistakes maxis did in sims 2, I mean they treated strangetown bella like she was the *true* bella and didn't even bother to clone her appearance using the body shop or whatever tool they had
      and there's also clones of nervous subject, skip broke and michael bachelor on the game files lol, olive specter doesn't even remember giving birth to the true nervous subject, she remembers the beta clone one

    • @owlproblem7230
      @owlproblem7230 Před 2 lety +8

      @Yuna NosTale they didn't change that. Death memory being green was an actual oversight

  • @PhoenixRoseYT
    @PhoenixRoseYT Před 3 lety +881

    I just started playing the Goth family in Sims 3 and I’m just gonna make them live happily ever after ;-;
    Also dead Bella Goth from Lunar Lakes is creepy af

    • @Im_not_creative
      @Im_not_creative Před 3 lety +6

      So since I only have Sims 3 I'm making the whole goth family and making the timeline I'm also doing it were bella and Mortimer are as kids

    • @ashc4167
      @ashc4167 Před 2 lety +3

      @@Im_not_creative you can play as Bella in the future and bring her back like I did, I revived all of the ghosts too

    • @xsuns7508
      @xsuns7508 Před 2 lety

      ​@Don't Take It Personal omg i was thinking that too

  • @d159inu
    @d159inu Před 2 lety +75

    Bella literally CARRYING the sims franchise rn. I’m over the sims honestly, sims 4 and EA money grab ruined it for me. Let’s all get on Paralives!!!

  • @laracroftvideos
    @laracroftvideos Před 3 lety +88

    The reason the storytelling in The Sims 2 is so great in spite of the tools being quite simplistic is because nothing is explicitly stated or spelled out, but there’s just enough clues scattered throughout the different households for the player to draw their own conclusions and theories. A lot of weird sh1t went down in Pleasantview: Skip Broke’s “accidental” drowning, Bella’s disappearance, Dina and Nina being alien hybrids, and let’s not forget all the clones of certain Sims that appear in memories/family albums (most of which have had their character files deleted during the development).

  • @Adricircle
    @Adricircle Před 3 lety +186

    The fact that my sim married don and had 2 kids with him -

    • @cheyenneeagle4815
      @cheyenneeagle4815 Před 3 lety +4

      My friend's sim also married Don and has 3 kids

    • @Elliott540
      @Elliott540 Před 3 lety +15

      In my cousin's world he made a kidnapper and tried to kidnap don but he escaped 2 times

    • @lololol5691
      @lololol5691 Před 2 lety +10

      I didn’t know Don & the caliente sisters were dating 😭 In TS4 I got Nina’s daughter pregnant by him & when I told Nina the news she was so angry & I couldn’t figure out why 💀

    • @_Biscuitbear
      @_Biscuitbear Před rokem

      @@Elliott540 stan your cousin

  • @BELLA-vb7qh
    @BELLA-vb7qh Před 3 lety +172

    Why am I so emotional about a Sims character!? 😭

  • @vasiamanoledaki
    @vasiamanoledaki Před 3 lety +317

    This story can make such an amazing Netflix series!

  • @tcitvrn
    @tcitvrn Před 3 lety +27

    Wait- the reason why bella looks different in strange town is because that's the version you encounter in the sims 2 for psp! the psp version is more of a story driven game but you encounter bella at the beginning and she tells you she got abducted and is trying to find her way back home. you also unlock 3 secrets of hers by doing a friendly, romantic and mean interaction where she spills some tea about her and mortimer which can explain his positive memory to her abduction.

  • @laurendoyle2235
    @laurendoyle2235 Před 3 lety +471

    Imagine
    Sims4 the graphics
    Sims3 the CAS
    Sims2 the memories
    Sims1 the realism
    All put together and made in the sims 5
    PLEASE YALL TOOK THIA SO SERIOUSLY 💀
    I DONT WORK FOT EA PLEASE QUIT WITH THE MEAN CRAP CAPM DOWN MY GOD

    • @tishaprnucedteasha
      @tishaprnucedteasha Před 2 lety +45

      i would say a mix of sims 3 and 4 cas like how u can mold ur sim

    • @ds549
      @ds549 Před 2 lety +69

      im sorry but the only good thing about the sims 3 cas is the color wheel and the eyelash slider everything else is ugly af

    • @laurendoyle2235
      @laurendoyle2235 Před 2 lety +4

      @@ds549 that’s what I meant the colour sliders were really nice

    • @laurendoyle2235
      @laurendoyle2235 Před 2 lety +3

      @@tishaprnucedteasha I totally agree

    • @staceylikescats
      @staceylikescats Před 2 lety +27

      I need sims 3 open world too

  • @ks20227
    @ks20227 Před 3 lety +175

    Another theory I came up with (before the Sims team said anything) was that the TS4 Goth family was Bella’s “paradise” after she died.

  • @katigamer4019
    @katigamer4019 Před 3 lety +190

    I found a Theory online. Bella Goth was dead in Luna Lakes, but of old age right? If Mortimer was a lot older than Bella either by natural causes, or by his science project, it's not likely that Matilde Goth would've been alive at the time if she was Mortimer's older sister. When Bella went missing, she got a lot of attention, and I think it's pretty obvious the Aliens are working against Bella, and was sent by either the Calienté sisters or by Mortimer Goth. Maybe Mortimer or the Calienté sisters wanted to make a Clone of Bella, and send the clone back to earth in order to cover up what really happened, and get rid of unwanted attention around her. But unfortunately for them, the cloning experiment went wrong because Bella was pregnant and there for, the aliens dumped her in Luna Lakes where she lived the rest of her life with her daughter. Another thing I'm wondering, is if Matilde wasn't Mortimer's child, but could've belonged to Don Lothario.

    • @stringcheese6833
      @stringcheese6833 Před 3 lety +41

      Matilde also looks a LOT like Bella, just blue instead of red. It would be uncanny (and kind of weird) if Mortimer married a women that looks so similar to his sister.

    • @typicallyusual6984
      @typicallyusual6984 Před 2 lety +15

      @@stringcheese6833 Maybe Matilde IS Bella but she had her face altered by aliens and the other Bella was a fake

    • @air8223
      @air8223 Před 2 lety +6

      THIS

  • @nenemew6076
    @nenemew6076 Před 3 lety +153

    "I wouldn't be suprised if this game inspired "Love island"," hahahaha!!! This was awesome, a lovely way to show us memories, I miss them sooo much in the Sims 4!

  • @imogenlwilliams
    @imogenlwilliams Před 2 lety +28

    An interesting quirk in my Sims 4 game: with the story progression I wasn't playing the Goth household, but my Sim recommended to Bella that she have another baby. Without my interfering she had a boy and named him Michael, after her brother perhaps?

  • @summerhope4419
    @summerhope4419 Před 2 lety +48

    I'm so confused, I remember playing this as a kid but I had memories of playing Bella in Pleasantview and the game prompt me to have Bella use the telescope which soon went to a cutscene of her getting abducted. I remember because that scene scarred me, I waited for her to return (like they usually do when sims get abducted) but she never did. It really scared me because I thought the game broke or something but I couldn't find Bella at all. So playing the sims 2 again really confused me because Bella was already gone in the Goth household.

    • @djlethargic
      @djlethargic Před 2 lety +5

      Huh... that is very creepy if that's true

    • @Potato_Wynn
      @Potato_Wynn Před rokem +8

      I also vividly remember playing as Bella (in Strangetown, though) and her never returning after getting abducted. But the Sims 2 released when I, myself, was 2, so I just assumed I misremembered something.

  • @mucha4937
    @mucha4937 Před 3 lety +103

    Man I was not prepared for this murder/abduction mystery type stuff...literally got goosebumps.

  • @joeibh
    @joeibh Před 3 lety +383

    Love this little sims documentary 😅😍 Apparently Mortimer's "pleasant" memory is because of his knowledge aspiration 🤷‍♂️

    • @kawaiipop5953
      @kawaiipop5953 Před 3 lety +33

      Storywise it is still peculiar that he was happy about it. Though I’m pretty sure the sims team for TS2 may have overlooked that (Btw I’m not saying that they did that on purpose, alternatively I think that because they were making all the content the team probably did not think about that when making the game at that time).

    • @loribrillante
      @loribrillante Před rokem

      Is there a memory tab in Sims3?

  • @cracmar03
    @cracmar03 Před 3 lety +15

    Eh Sims 4 is alternate universe. The very same one which is caused by actions of Alexander Goth I imagine. Alexander was time travelling in 1-3 timeline, hence odd books in 3's eerily resembling story of Bella's abduction. He was trying to prevent Goth's family falling apart. Sims 4 is more or less a sad, alternate reality of past games Alexander hopes and dreams.
    The hope that through his time travelling actions, somewhere somehow there in timeline there is a little Alexander surrounded by happy family. Not Goth's marriage falling apart, gold digger sister-in-law setting herself on Mortimer, none womanizer trying to woo Bella and neither is Cassandra engaged to said womanizer. If you meddle in timeline ... you always change the timeline.
    And Alexander wanted to change A LOT to prevent future from happening.
    Story of 1-3 was erased and replaced with that version. And while original Alexander probably did managed to return to his correct time version, married some girl (Cecilia ?) family told him to and probably lived to old age in his mediocre profitable marriage, he wouldn't regret it because of Sims 4 hope.
    The hope that he prevented another version of him from having their life ruined. Somewhere there is better reality for Goth's, and maybe even for other families. It would be difficult to say how long in past Alexander travelled to prevent all of this. We probably would have to look at details that changed in all families to know exactly where did meddling started.
    I suspect he would change Goth's, Kaliente's and Lothario's pasts to fully prevent future.
    The good ending for Goth family by lore, is basically to erase Goth's history past Sims 1 from lore.

  • @blackeyedincubus
    @blackeyedincubus Před rokem +13

    they really need to continue her story. It's probably the most exciting thing in Sims' history

  • @nadinerusso0808
    @nadinerusso0808 Před 3 lety +16

    i prefer the theory that Alexander went back in time and changed history. It would make sense too.
    my headcanon is he became obsessed with Sim World/Sixam/Space relations when he got older and maybe traveled to Lunar Lakes as an adult and that's where he discovered the truth about what happened to his mother, that she died naturally on an alien world after being abducted and taken there. Up until then Mortimer had always told him that Bella was murdered or died when Alex was a baby because Mortimer was ashamed of his minor involvement in the truth. After learning the truth, he figures out how to build a time machine and goes back in time to the events right before Sims 2, is able to somehow stop Bella - who is pregnant with Alexander in her time - from going to Don's house and getting abducted.
    The aliens, one of them being Dina and Nina's grandfather, encountered Mortimer while Mortimer was working as a mad scientist. Mortimer offended them with his experiments, especially after he stole a youth serum that had been created by alien technology to work on by himself, and this was their revenge plan. The Calientes' alien grandfather knew that his granddaughter Nina was involved with a man who lived in Pleasantview, nearby to the Goths, and also discovered that by pure chance, Dina had very recently married the aging Michael Bachelor and was now Bella's sister in law. He asked Nina to convince Don to seduce Bella so that the aliens could come and kidnap her as revenge for Mortimer's theft. Nina was loyal to her family and agreed. Dina, who had squandered the little money she inherited after Michael's death (unfortunately for Dina, he decided to leave most of his money to his sister and the rest of his extended family), decided with Nina to expand the plan. They planned to move to Pleasantview once Bella was out of the way, so Dina could seduce Mortimer herself and get some of that money in her pockets. Nina is of course unaware that Dina has been going behind her back with Don, but that's their problem and unrelated to the plan, but she figures if Don seduces and marries Cassandra and they made Cassandra "disappear" just like they did with Bella, both Don and Nina would be able to enjoy the inheritance once Mortimer died of old age.
    Alexander disguised himself as a repairman, set a fire or shocked himself while repairing something, and Bella was too distracted at home dealing with this and cancelled her plans to see Don. After the plan fell through, the Calientes refused to leave Oasis Springs for Pleasantview out of fear that their connection to both the Bachelors and the aliens would be discovered, so Don left for Oasis Springs to live with the Calientes. The only thing I can't explain is why Dina's a teenager in Sims 4, unless she married Michael when she was 18 and he died like... a month later.
    The Sims 4 "alternate universe" is really just the alternate timeline that Alexander created by ensuring Bella never got abducted. After Bella narrowly escapes abduction, Future Alex tells Past Mortimer about what could happen if Mortimer doesn't stop messing with the aliens with his mad scientist career. Mortimer quits and focuses on his true passion that he shares with his son, writing. Bella gives birth to Alex later on, and the Goths leave for Willow Creek to get a fresh start and a more "conventional" life, and Future Alex returns to his own timeline, aka Alex as an adult in Sims 2. Because Bella was never abducted, relations between the Sims and the aliens remained civil and they allowed for more free communication, hence why space is more accessible in Sims 4.

  • @maples8237
    @maples8237 Před 3 lety +70

    I am so sad that Sims 4 lacks a little bit of the story behind everything :(

  • @ahhgeez
    @ahhgeez Před 3 lety +36

    actually sitting down and thinking about this is such a mind fu k lol
    also it's really sad but sweet that alexander missed his mom so much he went back in time to make sure her life played out like it should've. i love these theories lol

  • @crysims5608
    @crysims5608 Před 3 lety +40

    Honestly someone should beg the sims team to just give us the story , btw , i never played other sims games , only the sims 4 so i didnt know a thing about Bella ...

  • @delilah_mercury
    @delilah_mercury Před 3 lety +103

    Actually it's not really suspicious that Mortimer has a positive memory of Bella being abducted because he's a knowledge sim and those sims are really interested in stuff like that

  • @heyfell4301
    @heyfell4301 Před 2 lety +36

    Oh man. As a newcomer, i was honestly like... "Bella who?" when i found her on Sims 4.
    I maximized the friendship and the romance bars with her untill i realized she was married (i'm an idiot), at that point, to follow the roleplay, i decided that my Sim would break up with her and never disturb her family (my Sim has the Good trait). After watching this video, specially the Sims 2 part, i regret doing it. Even tho this isn't really canon on Sims 4, screw it, i would have called the husband to my house and locked him into the pool if i knew that earlier.
    Also, Alexander is a little big chad.

  • @shellyleduc1
    @shellyleduc1 Před 3 lety +54

    This us why I told you that you deserve to be a CZcamsr. This was one of the best story’s my lord girl you could read the phone book and make it exciting. I am so glad you hanging in. Please don’t ever stop. Thank you Whiny. This was Bloody brilliant my friend. I have tipped my hat for you. Please stay safe and take care your fan Michelle 😇🇨🇦 from Canada

    • @shellyleduc1
      @shellyleduc1 Před 3 lety +4

      Oh and I shared this

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +6

      Thanks Michelle, it really means a lot! glad you liked it 😊

  • @asleep2250
    @asleep2250 Před rokem +4

    But what if: the sims 4 is located some months/years before the sims 2 happened? Cassandra is still a teen and mortimer looks a little bit younger than the one in the sims 2.... So maybe in sims 4 Bella's disappearing has to happen in the future and they give us strangerville with all the aliens stuff as an inch?
    Sorry for the bad english

  • @witchsunoo8304
    @witchsunoo8304 Před 3 lety +8

    in sims 2 psp it takes place in strangetown and you can actually find bella goth at the convenience store at the beginning of the game. she goes on about aliens and alien abductions, panicked and all. she eventually would offer you her house in strangetown (for all the money you have, depends on how much you have on you when you decide to purchase). her house is haunted, though. so, beware! there’s a bunch of minigames at strangetown (the furthest i got was dealing w a zombie infestation and running suspicious errands for people). never finished as i played it when i was younger and got bored w it.

  • @Hellokali
    @Hellokali Před 3 lety +90

    I'm behind on watching some vids, but I love this! BEST telling of Bella history I've seen so far. I hope you do more in the future. ❤❤

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +7

      Aw thank you, I really enjoyed making this one so I reckon there will probably be more to come!

  • @owonyoki5110
    @owonyoki5110 Před 2 lety +4

    No that last theory is on point. Because you see the funny thing about time traveling is that, if you tamper with a timeline, it’ll likely not effect YOUR timeline, destiny is already set in that universe. But, what Mortimer did likely created a new timeline, an alternate reality, that branched out into what we know as the sims 4. So even if he couldn’t bring his mom back in his universe, Mortimer time traveling caused the sims 4 to exist and allowed Bella to exist there. :)

  • @babylalita4554
    @babylalita4554 Před 2 lety +7

    So crazy how obsessed I was with all of those games. Sims 2 was such an incredible game because of the storylines. I miss the mystery so much. I forgot about how the sims 2 looked & the graphics were definitely not that bad back then.. I do wish they could’ve Expanded these stories into the sims 4… I still play all the time but it doesn’t have that same feeling as before. Still love it tho!

  • @mishi6626
    @mishi6626 Před 3 lety +11

    I never pay attention to the description of Sims4 families before. It is interesting indeed. Thanks for the info!

  • @SydStatic
    @SydStatic Před 3 lety +11

    I've stumbled back into the Sims CZcams algorithm and honestly I'm glad bc it lead me to this video. Super well done and well researched, really fun to watch

  • @victorvvc1925
    @victorvvc1925 Před 2 lety +10

    Thank you for explaining all this story, I´ve heard lots of things about Bella Goth's disappearance, and I was so confused, but I finally realized her name was changed in the Spanish version (which I play) as "Elvira Lápida", and her maiden's name also changed to "De la Soledad". Even Mortimer's name changed to Homero, which I think is a hint to Gomez Addams (also called "Homero" in the Spanish dubbing).... Hell, this is confusing! Why do they change the names?

  • @timeea.i19
    @timeea.i19 Před 3 lety +13

    I love your voice! This actually feels like a documentary

  • @1LauraMeow
    @1LauraMeow Před 3 lety +3

    Just got out from underneath my rock and found this channel, I’m in love 😍😍😍
    Also I need the memories and the storylines baaaack, they made the game so much more interesting. And the theory about Alexander Goth saving Bella literally made me tear up

  • @HighBarbiee
    @HighBarbiee Před 3 lety +1

    I've been playing the Sims since I was a kid, Sims 1 to Sims 4. So I absolutely love seeing videos like these! 😍😍 Thank you so much, awesome content 🔥

  • @yenisoediro
    @yenisoediro Před 3 lety +18

    7:37 "her icon is in color, that means she is alive" or is that what they want you to believe?? and strangetown bella is just an impostor 🤔🤔

  • @theflowerbunny
    @theflowerbunny Před 3 lety +29

    Mortimer is happy because of Bella's abduction because he has Knowledge aspiration.

  • @iirachelmadness8677
    @iirachelmadness8677 Před 3 lety +97

    To Mortimer's defense, knowledge sims are known to get positive memories from family members getting abducted by aliens. Also might've been overlooked by Maxis.

  • @wulfbana
    @wulfbana Před 3 lety +58

    Super concise and interesting video, I loved it! Bella Goth sure is queen. Thanks so much for always making great content!

  • @sarahcarruthers3457
    @sarahcarruthers3457 Před 3 lety +2

    this was a fun watch! you have a great voice and the background music was engaging. great work!

  • @peruviangringa
    @peruviangringa Před 2 lety +6

    i really do love bella goths story, i really wish the sims 4 continued the story line! hopefully in the sims 5 they will continue the lore!! bella is prob my favorite sim ever lol.

  • @teebree0
    @teebree0 Před 3 lety +39

    i lovee your channel ! this video was so interesting & i have never played the other sims games but they seem to have a better storyline than the sims 4, the sims 4 had such a great setup for a good storyline and an open world & they just threw it all away, but u definitely need more subscribers asap .

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +4

      Aw, thank you! I know, it's such a shame that they missed that opportunity to carry on the storyline...
      I'm glad you like the video!.

  • @animaltheangrymuppet9455
    @animaltheangrymuppet9455 Před 2 lety +3

    I just recently discovered your channel and every video is awesome so far, still have ways to go until I'm caught up. The Goth family was also in The Sims Bustin' Out and no children. Bella was in the Movie Star career and Mortimer was a Mad Scientist. That was a good game on the PS 2.

  • @Jesuslovesmeeandyouu
    @Jesuslovesmeeandyouu Před 3 lety +4

    OMG!! This is so good!! And your voice is so soothing 🥺 you've earned a new subscriber 💜💜

  • @tanyamark3259
    @tanyamark3259 Před 3 lety +1

    I loved this video, thanks for sharing it! It's absolutely brilliant.

  • @martinebk
    @martinebk Před 2 lety

    I'm a bit late here, but how you talked the Bella Goth mystery, got me so interested again! Thanks for this amaze video! Loved it

  • @bopperette7260
    @bopperette7260 Před 2 lety +1

    Right that's enough for me today lol Just binged 3hrs worth of your content. You are funny & enjoyable to listen to but RL calls. Happy Simming. I look forward to your next upload 😊

  • @martycosplay
    @martycosplay Před 3 lety +6

    I had chills throughout the entire video!!

  • @e3xiii315
    @e3xiii315 Před 2 lety +12

    I’ve been playing the Sims like 20years and I’ve never paid attention to the stories. I always like to do my own thing when i play.But I knew there was some kind of lore behind the game From the Goths, Caliente, Landgraab etc. The Sims 4 version of the Goth family is my favorite, but this will be my first time sitting down and listening to the story behind them.

  • @S_lex_reacts
    @S_lex_reacts Před 3 lety +5

    I never even knew the sims had stories like this, (could be because I never played Sims 2) but this is very interesting to me. Also I started playing my Sims 3 pets game on my PS3 again and after watching this video I noticed my sim was reading a book called “Where’s Bella” i never would’ve realized the book was about one of the game’s characters if i didn’t watch this

    • @irishduchess7577
      @irishduchess7577 Před 2 lety

      That book was written by Alexander Goth if I’m not mistaken

  • @happihippii
    @happihippii Před 3 lety +6

    this was actually incredibly interesting!

  • @Nat-mu4bt
    @Nat-mu4bt Před 3 lety +1

    Thank you for this video, it was super enjoying!

  • @fabiennevanessen573
    @fabiennevanessen573 Před 2 lety +2

    even after a year this is so interesting to watch, the makers did a really good job making background stories so amazing. I loved how this video was explained bus the story gave me a complete mindfuck just because there is so much behind it

  • @___Artemis___
    @___Artemis___ Před 3 lety +7

    ...I have never played the sims and tbh didn't know it was a thing before I started seeing let's plays of the Sims 4, so I didn't even know there was lore and mystery and connection between any of the games.

  • @FeatheredWingz
    @FeatheredWingz Před 3 lety +43

    I was relatively young when ts2 was at it's height. I only played it once or twice at friends' houses, so I never got too deep into it. I was 12 when ts3 released and that was my first sims game to own. So, like with ts3 and ts4, was it possible to move sims families to new towns? Even the EA-made sim households? If so, has anyone tried moving the Pleasantview Goths to Strange Town to see what happens if they bump into that version of Bella?

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +13

      Hi there! In the Sims 2 you couldn't move households between worlds as far as I know. so It was wouldn't have been possible to do that unless you are using some kind of software or cheats to do it.

    • @AndSoWeLaughed
      @AndSoWeLaughed Před 3 lety +4

      I had mine meet and and they did nothing. It was as if she wasn’t actually her and a different person.

  • @dannyswanger1211
    @dannyswanger1211 Před 2 lety +13

    I always made Bella my own wife in The Sims 3. I had no idea she was made to marry Mortimer Goth 😂

  • @hannahkeene1647
    @hannahkeene1647 Před rokem

    This is such a thorough yet fun and interesting analysis, so well told as well. New subscriber! (: Bella and Cassandra are my favourites in the game

  • @sebwilkins
    @sebwilkins Před 3 lety +49

    Timeline: sims 1, sims 2, sims 3 (when Alexander travveled back in time) sims 4

  • @brewedbeauty6324
    @brewedbeauty6324 Před 2 lety

    Quote literally the best lore video for the sims I've seen in a long time!

  • @ellastrong6167
    @ellastrong6167 Před 2 lety

    Amazing video I’m obsessed with your chanel

  • @PrincessQ-fj9ly
    @PrincessQ-fj9ly Před rokem +1

    You know, when I first started playing The Sims franchise, I never knew that Bella Goth had existed. My first Sims was the Sims 3 on console. When I first saw Bella Goth in The Sims 4, I couldn't help but get Morticia Addams vibes, because she has a gothic and glamorous sense of style and has a rather outlandish life. Not to mention She and Morticia have 2 children with their husbands. Now that I've gotten to know Bella's life story, I am deeply fascinated and enchanted with Bella Goth! 💕 I can see why people love the lore in The Sims Franchise. It's so fascinating! I really hope Bella Goth is in The Sims 5! ❤️

  • @chichiori7265
    @chichiori7265 Před 3 lety +14

    I totally forgot the Sims games actually have a story

  • @gabriellebarros3049
    @gabriellebarros3049 Před 3 lety +6

    This video is so good, it should get more views! Great job ;)

  • @turinoma6471
    @turinoma6471 Před 3 lety +1

    Great vid! Never knew all this about Bella. Very nicely done!

  • @theminisimmer
    @theminisimmer Před 3 lety +60

    Here's the tea: according to a secret in the sims 2 for PSP, she only married Mortimer for the money 👀

    • @nananom_
      @nananom_ Před 2 lety +3

      That’s what I originally thought because (not sure I can’t remember that much) she’s got certain traits that would be typical for a gold digger wife. I can’t remember if I’m mixing another wife and husband sims and the Goths but I think that’s it. (Sims 4) I’ve never played any other sims games though either so seeing sims 1 2 was hella weird 😂

  • @danielle4025
    @danielle4025 Před 3 lety +16

    am i crying over a fictional character from a game who deserves better?
    yes i am.

  • @abigaildorismae
    @abigaildorismae Před 2 lety

    i really hope they build on these theories in the sims 5.. nice video!!

  • @julianhugo3949
    @julianhugo3949 Před rokem +3

    i literally get sad thinking of her dissapearence and how unfair everything was for her, she deserved much better

  • @julieposey268
    @julieposey268 Před 2 lety

    This was amazing! 🤯 I have been playing Sims from the start. How did I never explore all of this? Too busy playing with my own sims, I guess. I also never got Into the Future (it was always on my wishlist), so there is that. I love the Goths too. I can’t believe myself. Lol Thanks for making this video!

  • @floriduhboi
    @floriduhboi Před 3 lety

    Absolutely loved the video!

  • @CaptainsMorning
    @CaptainsMorning Před 3 lety +1

    Watching this at 1am, your background music in this video makes the murder plot so creepy lol
    I need to find something else to watch now so I can sleep😂

  • @jennaf4129
    @jennaf4129 Před 2 lety

    this is the best most engaging youtube video I've ever watched

  • @hridyanadappattel4400
    @hridyanadappattel4400 Před 3 lety +4

    May I suggest the butterfly effect? Could suggest why the Sims 4 is an alternate universe. Also amazing video, I had no idea there was such a big plot involved behind the Goth family!

  • @hblackburn5580
    @hblackburn5580 Před 2 lety +1

    OMG Bella Goth, my nostalgia of my dark, angsty teen years when the first Sims came out is hitting hard 😆 I forgot how intricate these characters are.

  • @sades466
    @sades466 Před rokem

    this has got to be the most interesting video i've ever watched haha, awesome

  • @antsareinterestinganimals3665

    Wow this video was amazing this channel is hardly underrated ! But to be honest I love the fan theory it really makes sense to me. I mean sure the creators of the sims 4 told us that it doesn’t fit in the storyline but who knows if the sims 4 world is even real. Ok this part is gonna be a conspiracy theory but that’s just to much fun haha. Like for example all the memories are gone and the gots are living their best lives. The Caliente sisters are living with Don Lothario but no one of them is as far as I know related to any aliens I mean the family tree is sadly missing too. But the whole world is just less complex. Like an idealized world of young Alexander who’s probably dreaming about a better life haha. I mean i know it’s more than unlikely but thinking about it was very fun. And btw sorry for all the mistakes but since I’m from Germany I still do some Mistakes. Have a good day !

    • @WhinyBrit
      @WhinyBrit  Před 3 lety +1

      Thank you! i'm glad you enjoyed it. I think the storytelling in the sims 4 was just plain lazy, but I in fairness I think the sims team honestly thought that we wouldn't care and they'd get away with it! Maybe i'm too optimistic but I really think we can expect more from the sims 5.

  • @trplowlife4536
    @trplowlife4536 Před 3 lety +11

    Ok but no one ever talks about why Bella went to Don’s in the first place 👀 sus

  • @JT60613
    @JT60613 Před 2 lety

    it's the first time I hear about a time machine! I had no idea we could do this... but I'd vote that it makes sense!
    I love hearing these theories, as a child this mystery has always intrigued me... I even went to Strangerville to get Bella again back to her family several times (of course I had to make her and Mortimer fall in love again :D)
    anyways loved this video! I think it fits

  • @vanilija6680
    @vanilija6680 Před 2 lety

    i never knew sims had so much in depth! this is interesting :D

  • @jichupichu9162
    @jichupichu9162 Před 3 lety +14

    People really overlook the sims 2 for psp. It continues the story of Bella after she’s abducted by aliens. She bought a house that was haunted and you find her in a gas station where you also
    Learn secrets from her based off the game mechanics where she admitted she only married for money

    • @lillychanelo6444
      @lillychanelo6444 Před 3 lety +1

      YESSS!! I had the game on my psp I wish I had the game but I only have the psp

  • @theasinclaire52
    @theasinclaire52 Před 3 lety +11

    Wait wait wait...you can build a Time Machine in Sims 2? I must know more!

  • @AndSoWeLaughed
    @AndSoWeLaughed Před 3 lety +19

    Didn’t realise Dina really couldn’t give a fuck. It’s weird though everyone says the 2 sims 2 versions look different - the do not. In one she’s smiling. But no one questions the painting, she’s literally white in the painting. That’s not her.
    Not only is the sims 4 set in another reality but they’re a lot younger...

  • @loveangel6562
    @loveangel6562 Před 2 lety +1

    Amazing video as always, lysm

  • @tauriel_brisingr3936
    @tauriel_brisingr3936 Před 2 lety

    This is amazing! I want to go back and play the goth family in all the sims games in order