The people in the comments do not understand that animation quality includes art style, how characters are drawn, and manga adaptation quality. animation doesn't just refer to the frame rate/smoothness it is the sum of every detail, lighting, shading, character accuracy and what not. this video is a legitimate criticism.
as for season 3 I'd rather the studio change a third time considering the likely hood of JC shitting the bed on the quality again isn't very low, though there's no doubt in my mind its gonna stay jc. It doesn't have to be MAD house or basically any other reputable animation studio.
Dude anime art and manga art are never exactly the same and the others like lighting and frame rate your right about but the video did not talk about that it only showed how the art is a little bit different look at God of high school they have good animation but the art is not the same that's why people are complaining cause It did not show anything about the animation being shit just the art being change we wasted people time
Solo _King.vibezz He did address the frame rate at the beginning at 0:01 and of course the anime and manga won’t look exactly the same but u can see the objective downgrade, the characters faces looked completely different compared to the manga. you can’t tell me at 2:22 that’s just a art style change, that just looks bad. he’s not pointing out the difference run art or that’s what i believe he’s not trying to emphasize, it’s a clear objective down grade in quality, not just a “difference”.
@@charliefelsburg208 Ik I'm saying that the video did not explain the downgrade in frame rate or anything a better video would had been him making a comperssion of the fights in season 1 and the fights in season 2 to explain the downgrade all he showed was the art in manga and the art in the anime I'm not saying his wrong about season 2 animation is a downgrade of season 1 I'm saying the video did not show anything to prove the point of the downgrade in animation to show something is better than the other you always compare the 2 side by side the best why is to compare one punch man punches in season 1 to his punchs in season 2
Yeah, that's literally my only problem. Everything else looks pretty fine to me and some parts where people act like they're litteraly SDS or Berserk 2016 are at least "okay"
What are you on about? Murata loves using soft gradients to texture and fill out 3d shapes, look at any of his colour artwork and you'll see gradients being used everywhere to render different textures
Garou's face in the manga is very realistic. You could clearly imagine him as an 18 yr old. While in the Anime he looks like an old man. Now i know why the kid with an almanac calls him old dude 😂🤦
It’s still insane how good the animation is for something made in a little over a week. They had 6 months for 12 episodes. For comparison a favourite anime of mine, Mob Psycho 100 has 6 months for ONE EPISODE
If one punch man was some other normal anime, I don't think people would be mad. The reason it makes us mad is that one punch man is the golden standard for what good animation should be, the one that every aspiring animators look at for inspiration and JC staff shits on its dedicated fans.
@SAMURAI I'd say one of the only examples of an anime being better than the manga is Attack on Titan (I'm only including the story up to where season 3 part 2 ends, because season 4 isn't out yet). It's just the overall art style that makes the anime better, and the godlike animation also helps elevate the show. There are other shows that in my opinion exceed the manga, eg. Haikyuu but those are only outliers. Generally I do indeed agree that the manga is more often than not better than the anime. Sorry if my response was too lengthy.
@Milkias Simon 1. Mangakas have all the time in the world to put details into their still frames and they only have to focus on drawing ONE frame at a time...that's like you saying "A written novel has more details put into it than a movie", that's like duh, they have different methods for making them and different circumstances, so comparing different mediums is unreasonable (especially considering the mangaka isn't working on the anime). And guess what, anime doesn't have to be a carbon copy of the source material to be a good adaptation; ever seen movies/shows like Lord of the Rings, Game of Thrones, First Blood and how much did they have to cut and change from their source material, yet are still considered some of the greatest adaptations in cinema history? You see, the problem is that manga fanboys are too clingy to the source material and don't understand what an "Adaptation" is...and think that a good adaptation has to be a carbon copy of a book of still images or a book of text.
If they don't get the season 1 animation team and director back for season 3, I'm going to be genuinely upset. If you've seen the manga, you know that it needs to be done justice, especially the battles.
@@bluecrabgaming Umm, no, not really? animation means movement...mangas aren't drawn in a way to give the illusion of movement...you have to use your imagination when it comes to manga to fill in the blanks...with anime you don't have to do that because the movement is there.
@@Miyakolover I guess I need to explain it in a more simple way. The manga is well drawn, season 1 was well animated while season 2 was not. I am hoping that they get the season 1 animation team back for season 3 to do it the justice it deserves and to make it look as good as the manga. I never said the manga was animated.
@@bluecrabgaming I don't agree with you that season 2 is "Not well animated" and I hope you're not forcing your opinion on me as an objective fact like many elitists I see around here...though just so you know, I acknowledge season 2 is not as good as season 1, I only disagree regarding it being "Bad" or "Shit". And just for the record, not even season 1 looked as good as the manga (Atleast when it comes to art style and details, but that is natural).
They couldn’t get garous face down at all, which made him seem very generic in the anime as some common thug while in manga you can see many different faces he makes and understand how immature and mischievous he is. Also somn I wish you would of shown was how slim he is in the manga compared to being sorta overly beefy in anime in certain scenes
Mawar Princess ya the animation was really good especially the garou fights and saitama serious punch in the end was amazing. Was there something that I didn’t notice??
I want to say that OPM season 2 is not exactly bad animated, It was great animated, But the standard of the anime goes high because of the season 1 that has been TOO GOOD.
The fights were pretty bad though. Like don't get me wrong the animation overall is not bad, but when you have fights and especially with martial arts and flashy movements, they shouldn't look like 2 people just flopping their arms at each other.
@@TheFracturedfuture The reason of it would be the time. The studio that made the anime have a very short time to produce the anime, We can't really blame the studio for this. I still think Garou's fight vs. Rank A Heroes is greatly animated.
Guys gotta understand that the animation isn’t even bad or trash it’s just not as good as S1 that’s the problem like you can clearly see jc team actually has a lot of good animation movement and fights scenes but it’s nothing compared to season 1
IDK how there are so many useful idiots defending season 2 after the literally industry redefining season 1. I'm sure if fans had been asked would you wait another 4-6 years for a 24 episode season 2 with season 1 quality and attention to detail, it would have been an overwhelming majority said yes.
Atleast Be happy that we got a season 2, If you don’t really like the anime then go for the manga. I’d hate it more if you are someone that uses illegal sites to watch animes like One punch man s2 and still complains about the bad animation.
I'm hella hyped hype for season 3, don't know whatchu talking about, they had 6 months to animate season 2 and imo it still was good, now they have way more time for season 3
at some point in the very near future, all of it will be fixed by a dedicated fan with AI, going frame by frame and fixing all the mistakes, you watch.
I was worried that this would just be more unnecessary hate, but you really did point out some objectively bad/weird bits of animation, while not discrediting the parts where they did a decent job. One thing I noticed about season 2 is that the animation kept getting better as the season progressed. The fights at the end of the season may not have been season 1 quality, but they were still dang good.
@@williamschlass4598 I didn't want to assume it was a joke, lots of people use art and animation interchangeably.... With little time after they acquired it and limited experience in the area, JC Staff did quite well. Season one was easily the best animation of any media period IMO, but the animators were incredibly overworked, one man even to the point of suicide. It's best to just be glad that season one is as good as it is, and hope for the best going forward. Looking into it you'd find that there's no possible way that another passion project like season 1 will happen again, especially considering Madhouse's tendencies towards that. So why not just appreciate what we get? Season 2 was rough around the edges and plain bad at times, but those times were limited, and it had some really great moments too.
JC actually did great job , but the only flaw is because The ghosting and darkening are just measures that had to be used in the TV version to prevent epileptic seizures because japan rules and registration and all that, now Jujutsu Kaisen season 2 had the same problem , i wish streaming service could acquire the unfiltered version direct from the studio , not taking the filters Tv version to streaming 😢
People don’t seem to understand that anime isn’t a recreation of the manga, it’s an adaptation. Also quality of faces n shit depend of the animator doing that scene.
The things I hated most about this season was the lost of impact during fight scenes, everything is so stiff or a cut away from the strike, wich completely removed the power of all the fight scenes. Also character just standing look akward as shit because they don't sketch out a pose, all they do is draw the muscles directly on the frame wich removes all the Dynamics from the body and results in bad anatomy (a chest 5× bigger than the head, legs that are too long compared too the rest of the body, crooked faces, etc.) The colors are another issue, I don't know why so many animation studios use the same gradient and almost dirt like color patern on everything, don't they realize that everything has a different surface with different gradients(hair, skin,walls,tiles,sand,etc.)? I also would recommend them too use more "extreme" colors too give a nice contrast( like the old animes who used colors that were at extremities on their palet instead of picking the color right underneath the initialy color used ( for example: red-> slightly darker red❌, red->->-> way darker red✅.) And now for those weird blurs during a fight scenes and terrible sound effects. Jesus, who decided that vibrating the whole screen too create some sort of impact? I can't even tell you how terrible the fight scenes are because because I can't even see what's going on, it feels like I'm going thru a seizure every time it happens. And the sound effects are just a guy punching a bag or rice then they reverb and base boost the whole thing, then they just add a couple of party poppers too the thing, they were as bad as toei animations sound effects.
I know right, they went on a simplistic art direction whom they are used to, but that thing just ruined the whole thing since that direction is extremly limited to only slim guys and girls, the textures Are washed out making things like metal looks like a weird mercury looking mess
Not as bad as Seven deadly seasons season 3 😂 But I can definitely say, they definitely didn't add the greater details like in the hair and got kinda lazy on the shading and be missing some the badass poses.
I think they were doomed from the moment the series switched animation studios. It’s really not that much more of a downgrade than most manga when translated into animated form, but that’s kind of the problem. The series is legendary because of how fantastic every aspect of it was in the first season. So for season two to have very run-of-the-mill animation issues is a massive disappointment.
Huh... Mappa's animators are pretty good. Check out jujutsu kaisen, the only reason they use too much cgi on Attack on Titan cause they only have a year to animate it.
@Milkias Simon While very closely related, they aren't the same. Many shows have great art direction and bad animation (example Jojo's), or vice versa (I'd give an example for a show with great animation and bad art direction but art is too subjective to be able to find any example that a lot of people would agree with.)
Considering the fact that they had a whole 3 years to make a season 2 knowing the hype surrounding one punch man is why people are complaining. It was still an alright season and still enjoyable for what it is alone but it’s so trash compared to what we all expected because OF WHAT IT ONCE WAS AND WHAT ITS CAPABLE OF BEING. My Hero Academia is able to have 25 episodes seasons back to back yearly with incredible animation but opm can’t even get a 12 episode season with incredible animation after THREE YEARS? If they ever release a season 3 they better make it 36 episodes done by both studio bones and madman combined, they better hire some crazy fucking directors and animators and give it a crazy high budget with season2 remastered being one 3rd of the 36 episodes I don’t care if this takes them a fucking decade it’s worth it
J.C. Staff only had a couple of months for the production since no animation studio wanted to risk with OPM, I enjoyed the second season and I am a manga reader so I don't know why they complain they gave the best they could in a few months of production, I respect them for that.
You’re not talking about animation you’re talking about art style here and how it’s not the exact same as the manga. I agree it’s not nearly as good as season one but it’s not horrible either you’re making out to be the worst thing that’s happened in anime ever which is just not true
@@gianfi_ the animation is sometimes bad but mostly good. What he said was true and the fluidness is what matters anyways. The later half of suiryu's fight with saitama was actually really well animated and same goes for garou vs tank top for the entire fight tbh. But dont go saying its the worst thing ever that you dont get so see manga version of art styles cause king was more similar to the manga in S2 than S1 anyways. And no studio can even come close to yusuke murata's artstyle while consistently animating it so every frame looks exactly from the manga.
Garou is such a great and interesting character. And he looks really good in the manga and like an actual 18 year old. In the Anime they made him look like an old dude with super big muscles. xD Metal bat also looks way younger in the manga.
except it is bad, watch it again and pay attention to camera movements instead of animation, rotations of still frames, afterimages, sfx instead of details etc. it's cheap and looks only okay when you dont know what good animations look like.
@@Jayfym912 POV: you no absolutely nothing about how difficult animation is and when you find some random thing you don’t like about 1 frame of animation out of 1000 in an episode you complain about it on the internet and then someone says “there’s nothing wrong with the frame” and thus you have the brilliant realization that the only possible conclusion is that they are 12.
To be fair, the first season had like, one of if not the best animation studio for the job, so I wouldn't say that the animation is bad, it's only bad if compared to the first season animation...unlike Seven Deadly Sins S3...
@@zapzap9610 yes they had the time, as these contracts always start at specific times a year for the different release seasons. They all have the same production time depending on episode count.
yea the art is different bc is absolute shit compared to S1. The studio has changed? I know, I'm not the first to say that animations have gotten worse, I don't care if the animators are changed, the fact is: the new studio should review its staff.
@@gianfi_ I don’t know what you expected? The studio and animators working on the anime have changed. The former studio ,Studio Madhouse, was in charge and was amazing because of the animators they had. The new studio don’t have that same staff so it’s going to look diffrent. Season 2 looks perfectly fine. Yes it is a piss-take that Madhouse handed OPM to J.C staff and it is a *definite* downgrade but I think you’re just being too spoilt. You got a taste of greatness and now because of that you can’t except normal quality.
@@f.9948 idk, i mean if they were to adopt an anime that had a good reputation on its first season (and also made us wait for 2-3 years) they should at least make it better. them not having good animators isn't really an excuse since they pretty much did a very good job with konosuba the movie at the same year. If the reason behind this "dissapointing animation" is due to different directors and animators then they should've handed the opm s2 in a much capable and skilled animators and directors, since this anime has been anticipated for a very long time. Them doing this low quality texture no one can help but feel dissappointed. Its like they just adopted a highly named anime with no season 2 and gave them to some rookies and let them do whatever the heck they want with it without giving consideration on how good its previous season was At this point, reading the manga is more enjoyable than watching this season
Tbh this remind me a lot of aot season 4 where people calls the animation "shitty" just outright rude..yes it is a downgrade but it's still insanely enjoyable for me
Even though I don’t watch AOT, I agree about what you’re saying. I personally care more about what’s going on rather than how good it looks (one of the reasons I liked season 5 of MHA more than most people). Based off of story alone, I think I kind of like this season more.
I wouldn't call season 2 of opm "bad", when the blu-ray version was released a lot was cleaned up. But the reason season 2 was held in such low regard is because of the standard that the first season set. Season 1 was a passion project working with an outstanding director who had good connections within the industry, unfortunately this director couldn't come back for season 2. What I'm trying to say is that the second season wasn't objectively bad, the conditions of its productions were just different.
I like how everyone is talking about how the artstyle is not good in season 2 when in reality the original artist/mangaka art style is not even the same as the anime
I never understand the hate of one punch man S2. I watched both seasons together and never felt any problems in watching. I love both seasons equally even the animations. You all have very high demands for better animation and art style
I agree with you AND the person who replied before me. Too many people are spoiled by anime with such high quality art and animation nowadays. Yet people still consider the original DBZ as one of the best animes out there even though the art and animation isn’t as good as a lot of what we see today (it’s still very good though, especially for its time).
I always noticed the character designs were kinda off but it never hindered my experience with Season 2. It still looks (nearly) accurate to the official Manga Art it’s just the head shapes are more slim than full so I can see why it’s kinda off putting for some people
You didn’t explain why garou’s muscles were bad. I mean I’m not anatomy expert but I think they get the point across to the audience. You also didn’t explain a lot of other things as well. I think this is just a vent video to let people know that you can’t get over the fact that they can’t pay the same guest animators a bunch of money twice in a row.
Once again, another moronic defender of this trash season. Shingo Natsume and his crew of freelancer's did not cost "a bunch of money" They made season 1 with an average budget. It was simply a work of passion and of course Natsume's experience/connections to other veterans of the industry. They 100% could have waited for Natsume to free up before making season 2 but they thought they'd lose more money waiting and letting hype drop so they went with the mediocre studio/team and it shows to anyone with two brain cells to rub together.
They need to change the studio before s3 man..the manga is now has amazing art and details......i don't think jc stuff can even animate one of the chapters from the manga.....the worst part i hate about s2 is bad animation and cgi stuff ....I'm afraid if they animate orochi into a cgi .....that will be the end for opm .....i have alot of things to say about s2 but I'm fucking tired right now so i will keep it simple.....i just want them to do justice to the manga thats all i need......
This video is so stupid, they barely had any time to do the whole anime and they did a really good job for the little time they had, also, comparing S1 to S2 is so unfair, even just comparing S1 to a bunch of other anime, S1 had way more time and a lot of extremely experienced artists and animators, S2 did as well but to a much lesser extent, and a lot of scenes/animations had to be simplified and watered down because of time and resources. Over-all I just feel like whoever did this video is not seeing the whole picture and is nitpicking for next to 0 reason.
you guys are criticizing the animation, which appears to be fine btw. the only problem you guys are discussing is the Art itself of the anime and that has nothing to do with the good animation
Fine doesn't justify manga which is top notch Fine is not a benchmark here because animation detail is critical in OPM where scenes like fighting and action is given much emphasis. AOT manga was sh%t yet they gave the best detail and visuals in the anime.
I think these aren't really bad animation (apart from the genos reflection on saitama's head) but just off-character-model shots which need the face redrawn
I don't know why people are just hating without any reason . I didn't find anything too baad in season 2. And every anime have some bad frames, so why it's a big issue ?? These same people supports Naruto shuch consists so much bad animation scenes .
I low-key hope they re-animate this season with a better studio some time in the future. (I mean, it's not Seven Deadly Sins kind of bad, but OPM deserves so much better.)
News flash...still images are not animation. You could make an argument for artstyle, but you can't expect it to match the manga's level, especially considering that mangakas have all the time in the world for their high quality still frames.. Ironically, when they traced some frames the manga people still whined about it even if it was being faithful to the source material.
@@Miyakolover manga has better animation than season 2. notice how the art in season 1 was fucking amazing in addition to the animation, direction, sound effects, choreography etc. all of it was amazing. it comes down to the details which tend to make an impression. do you remember the transition clips used in the middle of the episodes? even those were all high quality. but no youre right. how mature of you to correct someone whose pointing out flaws because he used the wrong terminology. what an adult you are.
@@williamschlass4598 There is no such thing as "animation" in manga; so before mocking me for being as "adult" how about YOU become an adult and learn how to use the correct terminology first? So no, manga DOESN'T have better animation than season 2. Period. You can criticize something all you want, but when you use the wrong terms and terminologies you should be corrected on it. I can accept you saying "manga has better art than anime" because you can easily put more details into still images, but calling artstyle "animation" and insisting on it is sheer stupidity. You can over-praise the art and animation in season 1 all you want; it doesn't make season 2 a bad season in anyway.
I came here because I heard that people weren’t much of a fan of the s2 animation, but if this is it then I genuienly cannot see the problem. I’m really not trying to come off as rude here (I apologize if I am), but frames being drawn differently from the manga doesn’t make it bad. Maybe i just don’t have an eye for this stuff, but everything shown here (apart from Garou’s mouth at 2:20) looks comepletely fine to me, I just don’t understand the problem
The art is nowhere near the manga, but considering how rushed this season was it could've been way worse. Let's just hope they're taking their time with season 3.
Damn, now i notice how theres a big misconception between animation and the general art of the frames. Like the guy pinned by the creator of the video said, animation quality does indeed include art style but that does not apply to and especially still images. Having an image with a badly drawn anatomy/facial structure/etc and doing minimal movement isnt really bad "animation". Lets take a character blinking and staring into the distance. That character is badly drawn but it blinks. Do we just call the whole piece a bad animation just because it has slight movement in the eyes? Or do we call out of art itself which is the base of that "animation" to be corrected. This subject is a bit subjective but in moments where the character barely moves and barely does anything, i dont think we can just call it "bad animation". Its just bad art.
no he doesn't have the right to remove comments. that's the most idiotic thing anyone can do. if you can't explain your point removing a comment makes you the bigger idiot
@@banako420 no if you are a dickhead, I remove your comment, there is nothing to explain about the video, it's all clear for people with a brain. Text me hatefull stuff and I remove you with no effort
Bananko420 how does it make you a bigger idiot? I say removing comments that are delusional and repetitive is pretty smart, besides it’s even more idiotic to argue over such petty matters. Turnabout is fair play
The things that he pointed out do seem a little weird now I see them, but there are some parts in number 2 that look AMAZING, like the explosions and stuff, and some fight scenes. I thought on average the animation in 2 was better. Like the backgrounds, the details etc.
Yeah... Can't deny that. But the season failed to pack the same punch as season 1 and that I'm saying not in terms of the plot or story but in terms of the graphics and the way they animated it.
If you can't convince people that season 1 was objectively better in every way (not just animation), then they are either legally blind and should have their driver's licenses revoked or you're not making the comparison properly. EVERYTHING was off about season 2: animation, art, direction, sound effects... etc. etc. of course even these things can be broken down into more detailed things but the best way to demonstrate this is to simply watch both seasons back to back or even just watch one episode of s1 and then an episode of s2 right after and it's impossible to miss.
Even if you don't know anything about animation and can't notice the change, you'll surely feel the difference between s1 and s2, s1 animation had a big impact while s2 is just, boring to look at.
You don't have to know how to cook something to understand it doesn't taste good lol. Think if someone gave you raw chicken at a resteurant and you had to eat it and say it was good beacause you can't cook ahahah that's stupid.
@@alessandroscortichini8664 that's just your perspective on yourself. and I do agree if someone who judge the food is bad is a world famous food tester who really knows food. but what is the one I'm talking about is someone like Karens, who need no reason to throwing their tantrum because they're not satisfye by small thing?
@@alessandroscortichini8664 What I'm gonna say is, Someone who says OPM S3 will be bad bcs it's JC Staff again is definiely a Karen. If they can show the others that they can make animation and theirs are better than JC Staff, then I will stfu.
@Just a kengan fan stop trying to act like the company needs to do every single thing just like the manga frame by frame. If that was the case, then shows would rarely come out due to how long it would take.
Exactly. It’s more of an artwork issue, but I still wouldn’t call it “bad”. Simply not as good as the manga or first season (which are incredibly hard to beat anyway).
![One Punch Man: Season 2 - Fan Edit Comparison [Blu-ray vs. Serious Sounds]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BKzWaDN8y7E/mqdefault.jpg)
The people in the comments do not understand that animation quality includes art style, how characters are drawn, and manga adaptation quality. animation doesn't just refer to the frame rate/smoothness it is the sum of every detail, lighting, shading, character accuracy and what not. this video is a legitimate criticism.
as for season 3 I'd rather the studio change a third time considering the likely hood of JC shitting the bed on the quality again isn't very low, though there's no doubt in my mind its gonna stay jc. It doesn't have to be MAD house or basically any other reputable animation studio.
Thank you, I appreciate
Dude anime art and manga art are never exactly the same and the others like lighting and frame rate your right about but the video did not talk about that it only showed how the art is a little bit different look at God of high school they have good animation but the art is not the same that's why people are complaining cause It did not show anything about the animation being shit just the art being change we wasted people time
Solo _King.vibezz He did address the frame rate at the beginning at 0:01 and of course the anime and manga won’t look exactly the same but u can see the objective downgrade, the characters faces looked completely different compared to the manga. you can’t tell me at 2:22 that’s just a art style change, that just looks bad. he’s not pointing out the difference run art or that’s what i believe he’s not trying to emphasize, it’s a clear objective down grade in quality, not just a “difference”.
@@charliefelsburg208 Ik I'm saying that the video did not explain the downgrade in frame rate or anything a better video would had been him making a comperssion of the fights in season 1 and the fights in season 2 to explain the downgrade all he showed was the art in manga and the art in the anime I'm not saying his wrong about season 2 animation is a downgrade of season 1 I'm saying the video did not show anything to prove the point of the downgrade in animation to show something is better than the other you always compare the 2 side by side the best why is to compare one punch man punches in season 1 to his punchs in season 2
"Manga is better"
Dude the manga was drawn by MF Murata, that guy's a beast
THAT GUY MURATA IS THE BEAST OF THE BEAST, MAN
I MEAN LOOK AT HIS ART
DUHHH ITS STUNNING LIKE HECK
Murata is a GOD
One drawing better.
@@unsadfedan.9761 no💀
Murata needs to turn in Murata: Cosmic Fear Mode to even stand a chance against ONE's drawing skills
Why did they use blending instead of hard lines, is the real question. That’s the basis of Murata’s work, extreme linework.
Yeah, that's literally my only problem. Everything else looks pretty fine to me and some parts where people act like they're litteraly SDS or Berserk 2016 are at least "okay"
It’s weird how some scenes do have hardline and others don’t. The hard line scenes are always the best out of them
"Harder?".,.
What are you on about? Murata loves using soft gradients to texture and fill out 3d shapes, look at any of his colour artwork and you'll see gradients being used everywhere to render different textures
They got a extremely short time to make the season 2 sooo
This is still a masterpiece compared to Seven Deadly Sins S3
SDS was never at the level of opm s1 animation , that why us as fans were very disappointed about the ridiculous shameful animation s2 has
Every anime animation is better than SDS S3 lol.
@@seraji3799 Berserk 2016-2017 ??????? its better huh?
@@DavidoMAMO yea just look at their studio.. and s3 was a disaster.. s1 and 2 were enjoyable..
dont sin
Garou's face in the manga is very realistic. You could clearly imagine him as an 18 yr old. While in the Anime he looks like an old man. Now i know why the kid with an almanac calls him old dude 😂🤦
sadly, yes
you're so right lol
Look at bang and you’ll realise he looks like a young man in comparison 😂
Wait, he's 18 during S2? TIL
Fr every time I saw him I thought of rick from rick and morty
It’s still insane how good the animation is for something made in a little over a week. They had 6 months for 12 episodes. For comparison a favourite anime of mine, Mob Psycho 100 has 6 months for ONE EPISODE
yep true that
Imagine Snk Part 4 with 8 months for 16 eps, and just judging for 2D animation is still better than average anime
@@Horneto12 well it's mappa, one of the best animation studios out there (overwork too)
what episode was it
jjk (overworked workers)
The Best Thing in Season 2 is "Garou"
he's got the best fights imo
Garou and Genos battles are the best.
His character makes up for it.
Ur right he is the best
You shouldn't be see small mistakes you dummy
If one punch man was some other normal anime, I don't think people would be mad. The reason it makes us mad is that one punch man is the golden standard for what good animation should be, the one that every aspiring animators look at for inspiration and JC staff shits on its dedicated fans.
The studio just dont have enough time.They did the best they possibly could,but it just does not pay off well.
I think baki has better animation then season 1
Mitchell Kies lies
@@loveonepieceforever8203 i think ufotable fate has better animation
@@GioGio7209 you kidding right ? ufotable has worst character movement animation. They only good in high quality art style.
When the manga is better animated than the anime
nah this aint 7ds lol
@@SpeedyPoison774 Fair point
@SAMURAI I'd say one of the only examples of an anime being better than the manga is Attack on Titan (I'm only including the story up to where season 3 part 2 ends, because season 4 isn't out yet). It's just the overall art style that makes the anime better, and the godlike animation also helps elevate the show. There are other shows that in my opinion exceed the manga, eg. Haikyuu but those are only outliers. Generally I do indeed agree that the manga is more often than not better than the anime. Sorry if my response was too lengthy.
Love the double standards of manga fanboys...they whine about animation in anime yet they over-praise books of still images.
@Milkias Simon 1. Mangakas have all the time in the world to put details into their still frames and they only have to focus on drawing ONE frame at a time...that's like you saying "A written novel has more details put into it than a movie", that's like duh, they have different methods for making them and different circumstances, so comparing different mediums is unreasonable (especially considering the mangaka isn't working on the anime).
And guess what, anime doesn't have to be a carbon copy of the source material to be a good adaptation; ever seen movies/shows like Lord of the Rings, Game of Thrones, First Blood and how much did they have to cut and change from their source material, yet are still considered some of the greatest adaptations in cinema history?
You see, the problem is that manga fanboys are too clingy to the source material and don't understand what an "Adaptation" is...and think that a good adaptation has to be a carbon copy of a book of still images or a book of text.
If they don't get the season 1 animation team and director back for season 3, I'm going to be genuinely upset. If you've seen the manga, you know that it needs to be done justice, especially the battles.
Yeah, because a bunch of still images is "animation".
@@Miyakolover I mean... it is. That's all cartoons and anime are, still images. They're still classified as animated.
@@bluecrabgaming Umm, no, not really?
animation means movement...mangas aren't drawn in a way to give the illusion of movement...you have to use your imagination when it comes to manga to fill in the blanks...with anime you don't have to do that because the movement is there.
@@Miyakolover I guess I need to explain it in a more simple way. The manga is well drawn, season 1 was well animated while season 2 was not. I am hoping that they get the season 1 animation team back for season 3 to do it the justice it deserves and to make it look as good as the manga. I never said the manga was animated.
@@bluecrabgaming I don't agree with you that season 2 is "Not well animated" and I hope you're not forcing your opinion on me as an objective fact like many elitists I see around here...though just so you know, I acknowledge season 2 is not as good as season 1, I only disagree regarding it being "Bad" or "Shit".
And just for the record, not even season 1 looked as good as the manga (Atleast when it comes to art style and details, but that is natural).
Bro just remember the jc animators only had about 6 months to make season 2
I do not know when they started making opm3, but i am almost sure they had 2+ years to do it. So if opm3 is shit, they'll have no excuse
@@roirraWremaGthere excuse is they only do slice of life and romance animes making a battle shonen is completely out of there leauge
@@TheOneGoatasu Nah dude, they made some good action animes, just look up in MAL. Opm is just too much them
@@TheOneGoatasu Nah dude, they made some good action anime, just look up in MAL. Opm is just too much for them
@@roirraWremaGit has only in production for a few months. The announcement in 2022 wasnt when they started
But the episode 11 and 12 is already well done animated
Yes they are
@@gianfi_ oh yeah fubuki had more cooler designer in jc staff than madhouse
@@isthisanemergencyfood3919 I don’t think fabulist was ever animated by madhouse, maybe I’m wrong idk
@@drdoofus9453 she was
@@isthisanemergencyfood3919 nope madhouse design in ova was more appealing than jc staff cancer
They couldn’t get garous face down at all, which made him seem very generic in the anime as some common thug while in manga you can see many different faces he makes and understand how immature and mischievous he is. Also somn I wish you would of shown was how slim he is in the manga compared to being sorta overly beefy in anime in certain scenes
I say they focused to much on metallic shiny things which is cool but it only distract me to the not so good art style
I thought I downloaded a low video quality version at first ,then I found out theres really a change in making the anime lols
Tbh I don’t care if they changed the animation but the problem is they make their jaw to long for example: Garou
Thats what you noticed on the whole season smh
Mawar Princess ya the animation was really good especially the garou fights and saitama serious punch in the end was amazing. Was there something that I didn’t notice??
Giga Chad Garou
it fits garous masculinity
bold choice to set season 2 in an alternate reality where garou aged rapidly
the multiverse of madness
I want to say that OPM season 2 is not exactly bad animated, It was great animated, But the standard of the anime goes high because of the season 1 that has been TOO GOOD.
The fights were pretty bad though. Like don't get me wrong the animation overall is not bad, but when you have fights and especially with martial arts and flashy movements, they shouldn't look like 2 people just flopping their arms at each other.
No it was bad. Yes season 1 was fantastic but its not the reason why season 2 looks like crap.
@@TheFracturedfuture The reason of it would be the time. The studio that made the anime have a very short time to produce the anime, We can't really blame the studio for this. I still think Garou's fight vs. Rank A Heroes is greatly animated.
@@lephilthedegenerateweeb833 Well yeah, Garou vs A class heroes and Genos is the best animation in the whole season
@@lephilthedegenerateweeb833 yeah, i still blame the studio for how they chose to storyboard some of this.
"musculature of Garo that seems designed by an amateur" Those muscles literally look better than anything I can and will ever draw.
bro these things are so incredibly pointless i don't even know if you're serious at this point
Then why are you watching it,
@@garbagepotatothat’s not the point lol
@@garbagepotatoYou put a comma instead of a period btw
@@garbagepotato Because how could he fucking know he would be putting stuff that's not bad animation in a "bad animation" video.
Guys gotta understand that the animation isn’t even bad or trash it’s just not as good as S1 that’s the problem like you can clearly see jc team actually has a lot of good animation movement and fights scenes but it’s nothing compared to season 1
IDK how there are so many useful idiots defending season 2 after the literally industry redefining season 1. I'm sure if fans had been asked would you wait another 4-6 years for a 24 episode season 2 with season 1 quality and attention to detail, it would have been an overwhelming majority said yes.
exactly
True
So True
agreed !
Atleast Be happy that we got a season 2, If you don’t really like the anime then go for the manga. I’d hate it more if you are someone that uses illegal sites to watch animes like One punch man s2 and still complains about the bad animation.
Brace yourselves for round two. 😔
😂😂
Its joever 😢
There is no round 2
Bro🤦♂️ ok whatever u say they were rushed, but think what u want.
I'm hella hyped hype for season 3, don't know whatchu talking about, they had 6 months to animate season 2 and imo it still was good, now they have way more time for season 3
at some point in the very near future, all of it will be fixed by a dedicated fan with AI, going frame by frame and fixing all the mistakes, you watch.
Bro MIGHT have a vision.
I was worried that this would just be more unnecessary hate, but you really did point out some objectively bad/weird bits of animation, while not discrediting the parts where they did a decent job. One thing I noticed about season 2 is that the animation kept getting better as the season progressed. The fights at the end of the season may not have been season 1 quality, but they were still dang good.
Agreed
the manga has better animation than every fight in season 2, except of course the last saitama punch which they ripped from season 1 finale/opening.
@@williamschlass4598 the manga, by nature, has no animation at all....
@@blueman4232 yes genius thats the point
@@williamschlass4598 I didn't want to assume it was a joke, lots of people use art and animation interchangeably....
With little time after they acquired it and limited experience in the area, JC Staff did quite well. Season one was easily the best animation of any media period IMO, but the animators were incredibly overworked, one man even to the point of suicide. It's best to just be glad that season one is as good as it is, and hope for the best going forward. Looking into it you'd find that there's no possible way that another passion project like season 1 will happen again, especially considering Madhouse's tendencies towards that. So why not just appreciate what we get? Season 2 was rough around the edges and plain bad at times, but those times were limited, and it had some really great moments too.
JC actually did great job , but the only flaw is because The ghosting and darkening are just measures that had to be used in the TV version to prevent epileptic seizures because japan rules and registration and all that, now Jujutsu Kaisen season 2 had the same problem , i wish streaming service could acquire the unfiltered version direct from the studio , not taking the filters Tv version to streaming 😢
Use aniwave they have unghost version for opm
Petition for WIT to animate the third season 😭
People don’t seem to understand that anime isn’t a recreation of the manga, it’s an adaptation. Also quality of faces n shit depend of the animator doing that scene.
The things I hated most about this season was the lost of impact during fight scenes, everything is so stiff or a cut away from the strike, wich completely removed the power of all the fight scenes. Also character just standing look akward as shit because they don't sketch out a pose, all they do is draw the muscles directly on the frame wich removes all the Dynamics from the body and results in bad anatomy (a chest 5× bigger than the head, legs that are too long compared too the rest of the body, crooked faces, etc.)
The colors are another issue, I don't know why so many animation studios use the same gradient and almost dirt like color patern on everything, don't they realize that everything has a different surface with different gradients(hair, skin,walls,tiles,sand,etc.)? I also would recommend them too use more "extreme" colors too give a nice contrast( like the old animes who used colors that were at extremities on their palet instead of picking the color right underneath the initialy color used ( for example: red-> slightly darker red❌, red->->-> way darker red✅.)
And now for those weird blurs during a fight scenes and terrible sound effects. Jesus, who decided that vibrating the whole screen too create some sort of impact? I can't even tell you how terrible the fight scenes are because because I can't even see what's going on, it feels like I'm going thru a seizure every time it happens. And the sound effects are just a guy punching a bag or rice then they reverb and base boost the whole thing, then they just add a couple of party poppers too the thing, they were as bad as toei animations sound effects.
Yes and it doesn't feels powerful unlike season one
I know right, they went on a simplistic art direction whom they are used to, but that thing just ruined the whole thing since that direction is extremly limited to only slim guys and girls, the textures
Are washed out making things like metal looks like a weird mercury looking mess
it was still a good season overall
just for Garou
The animation was good in my opinion
bad opinion
@@albertken9078, You are stupid there is no bad opinion everyone has his own opinion and it can't be bad or good it's just his opinion jackass
Not as bad as Seven deadly seasons season 3 😂 But I can definitely say, they definitely didn't add the greater details like in the hair and got kinda lazy on the shading and be missing some the badass poses.
@@YRO. One Piece is garbage of thousands episodes lol
@@albertken9078 That's what you think, I'm not going to argue with you
This is probably not too bad, Saitama's head shape is okay, And Genos looks pretty okay 0:38
I think they were doomed from the moment the series switched animation studios. It’s really not that much more of a downgrade than most manga when translated into animated form, but that’s kind of the problem. The series is legendary because of how fantastic every aspect of it was in the first season. So for season two to have very run-of-the-mill animation issues is a massive disappointment.
everybody gangsta till mappa animates opm season 3
Oh sht no please
Oh hell no
Huh... Mappa's animators are pretty good. Check out jujutsu kaisen, the only reason they use too much cgi on Attack on Titan cause they only have a year to animate it.
I see this as a win, and a loose due to the fight thats currently happening in the manga.
@@flaze2606 nah jjk was made by a different team
Finally a use for having taken Italian classes
GAROU, THE BEST VILLAIN OF OPM
We know
@@anarsistdevletci tampoco es que tuviera mucha competencia
@@CoolDog3042 Understandable have a great day
nah Boros is my favorite
@@starsilvaXtrue
They made my boy Garou dirty. He is handsome as hell in the manga
what? garou was done so well in episode 11 and 12. you complain too much over the smallest of things.
Showing a face isn't animation it's a drawing get it right
Sorry King, my bad
@Milkias Simon While very closely related, they aren't the same. Many shows have great art direction and bad animation (example Jojo's), or vice versa (I'd give an example for a show with great animation and bad art direction but art is too subjective to be able to find any example that a lot of people would agree with.)
Considering the fact that they had a whole 3 years to make a season 2 knowing the hype surrounding one punch man is why people are complaining. It was still an alright season and still enjoyable for what it is alone but it’s so trash compared to what we all expected because OF WHAT IT ONCE WAS AND WHAT ITS CAPABLE OF BEING. My Hero Academia is able to have 25 episodes seasons back to back yearly with incredible animation but opm can’t even get a 12 episode season with incredible animation after THREE YEARS? If they ever release a season 3 they better make it 36 episodes done by both studio bones and madman combined, they better hire some crazy fucking directors and animators and give it a crazy high budget with season2 remastered being one 3rd of the 36 episodes I don’t care if this takes them a fucking decade it’s worth it
True they should have hire again the madhouse or just hire studio bones instead of jc staff
J.C. Staff only had a couple of months for the production since no animation studio wanted to risk with OPM, I enjoyed the second season and I am a manga reader so I don't know why they complain they gave the best they could in a few months of production, I respect them for that.
Its prolly because of low budget and shitty schedule
no. they did not have a whole 3 years. Get your facts straight.
TRUE
2:04 now I see why they called him egghead.
These aren’t so bad. People need to stop complaining. It’s not like the animation is like the web-comics
You’re not talking about animation you’re talking about art style here and how it’s not the exact same as the manga. I agree it’s not nearly as good as season one but it’s not horrible either you’re making out to be the worst thing that’s happened in anime ever which is just not true
No.
Gianfi _ yeeees!
@@gianfi_ the animation is sometimes bad but mostly good. What he said was true and the fluidness is what matters anyways. The later half of suiryu's fight with saitama was actually really well animated and same goes for garou vs tank top for the entire fight tbh.
But dont go saying its the worst thing ever that you dont get so see manga version of art styles cause king was more similar to the manga in S2 than S1 anyways. And no studio can even come close to yusuke murata's artstyle while consistently animating it so every frame looks exactly from the manga.
@@gianfi_ cgi in genos was trash tho lol
@@gianfi_ Sheesh, you like every comment that's sides with you, it's like you can't accept criticism without the opinion of others.
Bro its good
Garou is such a great and interesting character. And he looks really good in the manga and like an actual 18 year old. In the Anime they made him look like an old dude with super big muscles. xD Metal bat also looks way younger in the manga.
Do you even know what animation is?
Still better than anything I could make lol
The animation isn't even bad it's just that the manga art is so good that almost no studio can replicate it
idk man I think season 1s studio did like really good
@@buildingboy4196 ya it was really I should've re worded differently
except it is bad, watch it again and pay attention to camera movements instead of animation, rotations of still frames, afterimages, sfx instead of details etc. it's cheap and looks only okay when you dont know what good animations look like.
@@Vinclum you clearly don’t know how BAD animation looks then.
@@depressoespressoedits That seems to be the case for you.
thats not bad animation lol
It is
these are the weirdest nit picks ive ever seen tbh. i dont see anything wrong with any of the clips shown.
Because you’re 12 kid
@@Jayfym912 POV: you no absolutely nothing about how difficult animation is and when you find some random thing you don’t like about 1 frame of animation out of 1000 in an episode you complain about it on the internet and then someone says “there’s nothing wrong with the frame” and thus you have the brilliant realization that the only possible conclusion is that they are 12.
@@rustedcrabtm6438 bro still says POV in 2024 says a lot about you.
@@Jayfym912 that means actually nothing?
@@Jayfym912What a stupid comment.
To be fair, the first season had like, one of if not the best animation studio for the job, so I wouldn't say that the animation is bad, it's only bad if compared to the first season animation...unlike Seven Deadly Sins S3...
Seven deadly sins didn’t have much time tho
@@zapzap9610 yes they had the time, as these contracts always start at specific times a year for the different release seasons. They all have the same production time depending on episode count.
S1 is impossible to repeat. It was just a lot of animators who were friends with the directors doing a lot of work for art's sake.
garou’s face is so tragic in the anime
Your point in this video is the arts are different bc the studio has changed and not the animation.
yea the art is different bc is absolute shit compared to S1. The studio has changed? I know, I'm not the first to say that animations have gotten worse, I don't care if the animators are changed, the fact is: the new studio should review its staff.
@@gianfi_ I don’t know what you expected? The studio and animators working on the anime have changed. The former studio ,Studio Madhouse, was in charge and was amazing because of the animators they had. The new studio don’t have that same staff so it’s going to look diffrent. Season 2 looks perfectly fine. Yes it is a piss-take that Madhouse handed OPM to J.C staff and it is a *definite* downgrade but I think you’re just being too spoilt. You got a taste of greatness and now because of that you can’t except normal quality.
@@f.9948 ah ah S2 is PERFECTLY fine, alright then 😐
@@gianfi_ Ok.
@@f.9948 idk, i mean if they were to adopt an anime that had a good reputation on its first season (and also made us wait for 2-3 years) they should at least make it better. them not having good animators isn't really an excuse since they pretty much did a very good job with konosuba the movie at the same year.
If the reason behind this "dissapointing animation" is due to different directors and animators then they should've handed the opm s2 in a much capable and skilled animators and directors, since this anime has been anticipated for a very long time. Them doing this low quality texture no one can help but feel dissappointed. Its like they just adopted a highly named anime with no season 2 and gave them to some rookies and let them do whatever the heck they want with it without giving consideration on how good its previous season was
At this point, reading the manga is more enjoyable than watching this season
Honestly I don’t care about the animation style, I just want something to watch.
Tbh this remind me a lot of aot season 4 where people calls the animation "shitty" just outright rude..yes it is a downgrade but it's still insanely enjoyable for me
People just search for things to complain about.
Even though I don’t watch AOT, I agree about what you’re saying. I personally care more about what’s going on rather than how good it looks (one of the reasons I liked season 5 of MHA more than most people). Based off of story alone, I think I kind of like this season more.
Someone did a fan project fixing all the issues
J.C staff Just makes Murata sensei's masterpiece worse 😂
I wouldn't call season 2 of opm "bad", when the blu-ray version was released a lot was cleaned up. But the reason season 2 was held in such low regard is because of the standard that the first season set. Season 1 was a passion project working with an outstanding director who had good connections within the industry, unfortunately this director couldn't come back for season 2. What I'm trying to say is that the second season wasn't objectively bad, the conditions of its productions were just different.
Stop judging man have you ever made an anime before?People want the anime to go out as soon as possible and this is what you get!
I just wish OPM has those same vibe of that manga when a hero is being badass :(
Opm season 2 was really good, it was just the animation that had problems. They still carried with entertaining us
When it comes to Anime Animation Quality, everyone becomes a Critic
I like how everyone is talking about how the artstyle is not good in season 2 when in reality the original artist/mangaka art style is not even the same as the anime
it don't need to be the same lol, just needs to be good
doesnt need to be the same to have good quality
The stuff you just said proves nothing, congratulations 😂
I don’t get what’s wrong with it? You get an anime but complain about how bad it’s getting. Don’t even complain and watch.
I never understand the hate of one punch man S2. I watched both seasons together and never felt any problems in watching. I love both seasons equally even the animations. You all have very high demands for better animation and art style
I agree with you AND the person who replied before me. Too many people are spoiled by anime with such high quality art and animation nowadays. Yet people still consider the original DBZ as one of the best animes out there even though the art and animation isn’t as good as a lot of what we see today (it’s still very good though, especially for its time).
I always noticed the character designs were kinda off but it never hindered my experience with Season 2. It still looks (nearly) accurate to the official Manga Art it’s just the head shapes are more slim than full so I can see why it’s kinda off putting for some people
You didn’t explain why garou’s muscles were bad. I mean I’m not anatomy expert but I think they get the point across to the audience. You also didn’t explain a lot of other things as well. I think this is just a vent video to let people know that you can’t get over the fact that they can’t pay the same guest animators a bunch of money twice in a row.
"you didn't explain", ok
Ohhhhhhhhhhhh!1!1!1!!1!1!1!
Once again, another moronic defender of this trash season. Shingo Natsume and his crew of freelancer's did not cost "a bunch of money" They made season 1 with an average budget. It was simply a work of passion and of course Natsume's experience/connections to other veterans of the industry. They 100% could have waited for Natsume to free up before making season 2 but they thought they'd lose more money waiting and letting hype drop so they went with the mediocre studio/team and it shows to anyone with two brain cells to rub together.
@@williamschlass4598 no reason to call me moronic for being okay with average animation.
@@biggycheese6575 i think its the perfect reason
Loved Season 2
So glad Season 3 is the same studio
Ew
They make faces too long and fights are not visible
They need to change the studio before s3 man..the manga is now has amazing art and details......i don't think jc stuff can even animate one of the chapters from the manga.....the worst part i hate about s2 is bad animation and cgi stuff ....I'm afraid if they animate orochi into a cgi .....that will be the end for opm .....i have alot of things to say about s2 but I'm fucking tired right now so i will keep it simple.....i just want them to do justice to the manga thats all i need......
nah
@@loveonepieceforever8203 👁👄👁.hmhm
still my favourite anime 🙂
Ah Shit Here We Go Again
They did the whole characters dirty for no reason INCLUDING this whole animation bruh 🤦🏽♀️
This video is so stupid, they barely had any time to do the whole anime and they did a really good job for the little time they had, also, comparing S1 to S2 is so unfair, even just comparing S1 to a bunch of other anime, S1 had way more time and a lot of extremely experienced artists and animators, S2 did as well but to a much lesser extent, and a lot of scenes/animations had to be simplified and watered down because of time and resources.
Over-all I just feel like whoever did this video is not seeing the whole picture and is nitpicking for next to 0 reason.
you guys are criticizing the animation, which appears to be fine btw. the only problem you guys are discussing is the Art itself of the anime and that has nothing to do with the good animation
Fine doesn't justify manga which is top notch
Fine is not a benchmark here because animation detail is critical in OPM where scenes like fighting and action is given much emphasis.
AOT manga was sh%t yet they gave the best detail and visuals in the anime.
@@dominicj7977 whatever you say elitist
I think these aren't really bad animation (apart from the genos reflection on saitama's head) but just off-character-model shots which need the face redrawn
“Why the long face?”
One punch man season two was good way better than the Seven deadly sins s3
They should’ve gave S2 to Studio Bones
Fr, their art style and animation matched one punch man
i think there were a couple points that were a bit nitpicky
I don't know why people are just hating without any reason . I didn't find anything too baad in season 2. And every anime have some bad frames, so why it's a big issue ??
These same people supports Naruto shuch consists so much bad animation scenes .
Naruto is the most depressing and delusional anime ever created. No I do not support that
Y'all complain this much and expect to get another season?
Not really most of us just read the manga instead
@@artsanime5259 I still see people saying "can't wait to see this fight animated" in manga discussions
@@MrThecrazyzombie I said most of us not all of us
edit: And yes it is natur al for us to wait for it to get animated
It has to look perfect
I low-key hope they re-animate this season with a better studio some time in the future.
(I mean, it's not Seven Deadly Sins kind of bad, but OPM deserves so much better.)
So like a blu ray
You are so picky if you believe this needs to be reanimated.
where's your like to dislike ratio?
This is miles better than seven deadly sins.
The nightmare season 3 gonna make by same studio season 2💀
Hey that Trailer was amazing tho. JC seems to have picked up their shit
News flash...still images are not animation.
You could make an argument for artstyle, but you can't expect it to match the manga's level, especially considering that mangakas have all the time in the world for their high quality still frames..
Ironically, when they traced some frames the manga people still whined about it even if it was being faithful to the source material.
News flash... shut the fuck up
@@pirate6616 Aww, the little baby is butthurt by the facts?
How about you come up with an actual rebuttal instead of being a child?
@@Miyakolover manga has better animation than season 2. notice how the art in season 1 was fucking amazing in addition to the animation, direction, sound effects, choreography etc. all of it was amazing. it comes down to the details which tend to make an impression. do you remember the transition clips used in the middle of the episodes? even those were all high quality. but no youre right. how mature of you to correct someone whose pointing out flaws because he used the wrong terminology. what an adult you are.
@@williamschlass4598 There is no such thing as "animation" in manga; so before mocking me for being as "adult" how about YOU become an adult and learn how to use the correct terminology first?
So no, manga DOESN'T have better animation than season 2. Period.
You can criticize something all you want, but when you use the wrong terms and terminologies you should be corrected on it.
I can accept you saying "manga has better art than anime" because you can easily put more details into still images, but calling artstyle "animation" and insisting on it is sheer stupidity.
You can over-praise the art and animation in season 1 all you want; it doesn't make season 2 a bad season in anyway.
@@Miyakolover no, it’s just that no one actually gives a shit
I came here because I heard that people weren’t much of a fan of the s2 animation, but if this is it then I genuienly cannot see the problem. I’m really not trying to come off as rude here (I apologize if I am), but frames being drawn differently from the manga doesn’t make it bad. Maybe i just don’t have an eye for this stuff, but everything shown here (apart from Garou’s mouth at 2:20) looks comepletely fine to me, I just don’t understand the problem
Agreed
The art is nowhere near the manga, but considering how rushed this season was it could've been way worse. Let's just hope they're taking their time with season 3.
This animation is great, it's just held to a high standard it cant achieve.
In S2 Episode 8, you can see Saitama with his wig on after it flew off. So I guess wigs can teleport now. Cool.
😓😓🤮
Damn, now i notice how theres a big misconception between animation and the general art of the frames.
Like the guy pinned by the creator of the video said, animation quality does indeed include art style but that does not apply to and especially still images.
Having an image with a badly drawn anatomy/facial structure/etc and doing minimal movement isnt really bad "animation".
Lets take a character blinking and staring into the distance. That character is badly drawn but it blinks. Do we just call the whole piece a bad animation just because it has slight movement in the eyes?
Or do we call out of art itself which is the base of that "animation" to be corrected.
This subject is a bit subjective but in moments where the character barely moves and barely does anything, i dont think we can just call it "bad animation". Its just bad art.
Better than Berserk 2016 CGI 😭😭😭
Why are people so salty in the comment section? You have every right to remove those hateful and repetitive comments, keep up your good work
Thank you 🙏🙏🙏
no he doesn't have the right to remove comments. that's the most idiotic thing anyone can do. if you can't explain your point removing a comment makes you the bigger idiot
@@banako420 no if you are a dickhead, I remove your comment, there is nothing to explain about the video, it's all clear for people with a brain. Text me hatefull stuff and I remove you with no effort
@@gianfi_ censoring the internet wont do shit
Bananko420 how does it make you a bigger idiot? I say removing comments that are delusional and repetitive is pretty smart, besides it’s even more idiotic to argue over such petty matters. Turnabout is fair play
Im still having a hard time tryna show friends that the graphics really really went downhill in season 2...and still they do not believe me. 😔
The things that he pointed out do seem a little weird now I see them, but there are some parts in number 2 that look AMAZING, like the explosions and stuff, and some fight scenes. I thought on average the animation in 2 was better. Like the backgrounds, the details etc.
Yeah... Can't deny that. But the season failed to pack the same punch as season 1 and that I'm saying not in terms of the plot or story but in terms of the graphics and the way they animated it.
If you can't convince people that season 1 was objectively better in every way (not just animation), then they are either legally blind and should have their driver's licenses revoked or you're not making the comparison properly. EVERYTHING was off about season 2: animation, art, direction, sound effects... etc. etc. of course even these things can be broken down into more detailed things but the best way to demonstrate this is to simply watch both seasons back to back or even just watch one episode of s1 and then an episode of s2 right after and it's impossible to miss.
Even if you don't know anything about animation and can't notice the change, you'll surely feel the difference between s1 and s2, s1 animation had a big impact while s2 is just, boring to look at.
They’re fucking blind, man
Where’s the bad animation?
give the poor mappa animators a break
WHEN YOU SAY THE RESTAURANT FOOD IS BAD, BUT YOU CAN'T EVEN COOK💀
LMAO 💀
You don't have to know how to cook something to understand it doesn't taste good lol. Think if someone gave you raw chicken at a resteurant and you had to eat it and say it was good beacause you can't cook ahahah that's stupid.
@@alessandroscortichini8664 that's just your perspective on yourself.
and I do agree if someone who judge the food is bad is a world famous food tester who really knows food.
but what is the one I'm talking about is someone like Karens, who need no reason to throwing their tantrum because they're not satisfye by small thing?
@@alessandroscortichini8664 What I'm gonna say is,
Someone who says OPM S3 will be bad bcs it's JC Staff again is definiely a Karen.
If they can show the others that they can make animation and theirs are better than JC Staff, then I will stfu.
@@dragulia_venaro You speak like heavy weapons guy
I dont see anything bad in this animation
@Just a kengan fan stop trying to act like the company needs to do every single thing just like the manga frame by frame.
If that was the case, then shows would rarely come out due to how long it would take.
Exactly. It’s more of an artwork issue, but I still wouldn’t call it “bad”. Simply not as good as the manga or first season (which are incredibly hard to beat anyway).
I don't even know Italian yet I'm still reading the subtitles. My brain got used to it
watching the anime i didn't even notice a single flaw with the animations lmao