Top 10 MOST EVIL Warrior Cats Characters

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 1. 02. 2019
  • There are plenty of villains in Warriors, but which ones do their job the best?
    Cat art by Missy Dakota!
    Her Patreon: / missydakota
    Her DeviantArt: www.deviantart.com/missydakota
    Intro was made by Lapis Feder: / @lady_luzifer
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 2,5K

  • @avery6691
    @avery6691 Před 5 lety +2230

    But you know whats kinda sad? *Mapleshade still visits her kits on the border of starclan*
    //yall idk if this is even true i was in 6th grade pls stop liking it.-dec 2021

    • @1lainfan348
      @1lainfan348 Před 5 lety +109

      Fading Echos
      Awwwh! ;-;

    • @Dragonemperess
      @Dragonemperess Před 5 lety +70

      I don't remember that in the books. Where is it?

    • @wouldwulfie
      @wouldwulfie Před 5 lety +165

      @@Dragonemperess It isn't in the books, but I believe it was confirmed by one of the authors. I don't have any proof, though.

    • @Alexa-rz8nf
      @Alexa-rz8nf Před 5 lety +55

      Awww that's so sad!!! 💖😭

    • @pasteldragons0788
      @pasteldragons0788 Před 5 lety +44

      Wait therea a border? And she does?

  • @Neonnotecards
    @Neonnotecards Před 4 lety +805

    The true villain of the series:
    *Daddy issues.*

  • @meatcat7070
    @meatcat7070 Před 5 lety +661

    All cats on this list: "I'm so evil!"
    Mapleshade: *Slams door coming in*

  • @nutellaanimates8222
    @nutellaanimates8222 Před 5 lety +285

    Mapleshade be like:
    Clans - Suffering
    Enemys - Dead
    Goal - Achieved
    Hotel - Trivago

  • @saddo6448
    @saddo6448 Před 5 lety +725

    Stick no.1 as he killed hawkfrost and stole jayfeather's heart.

    • @hxrtbrxker862
      @hxrtbrxker862 Před 5 lety +6

      OnePunchMario64 the master okey :3 *yes*

    • @uglyferalcat149
      @uglyferalcat149 Před 5 lety +38

      No, Tree is No.1 cause he killed Longtail and injured Briarlight.

    • @chaos9608
      @chaos9608 Před 5 lety +10

      Allie Cat and he burned firestar

    • @kingscourge5514
      @kingscourge5514 Před 5 lety

      Frost not ftost

    • @jewelsthecat5331
      @jewelsthecat5331 Před 5 lety +17

      OnePunchMario64 the master okey :3
      The rabbit that blinded Longtail is BY FAR the most evil character in Warriors, don’t tell me otherwise

  • @toboe9173
    @toboe9173 Před 5 lety +644

    In my opinion Brokenstar is the most evil.
    He forced three moons old kits to fight and murdered his own dad.
    But I understand that most people think Tigerstar is more evil.
    I honestly don't think Mapleshade is that evil.
    I mean, atleast not while she was alive.
    She only seeked revenge.
    But what she did when she was in dark forest is definetely evil!

    • @maple1034
      @maple1034 Před 5 lety +4

      I agree with you.

    • @louisebeggs9711
      @louisebeggs9711 Před 5 lety +10

      Ahornschwinge Warrior Cats not to mention how BrokenStar was planning with TigerClaw for rouges to invade Thunderclan thankfully Riverclan came aka MistyFoot Stonefur Leopardfur and One other cat I can not remember I think it was blackclaw

    • @salami9432
      @salami9432 Před 5 lety +14

      Who is mapleshade? I only heard of Shaplemade

    • @dogsandcatsrule3856
      @dogsandcatsrule3856 Před 5 lety +1

      Ahornschwinge Warrior Cats I honestly couldnt agree more or have said it better myself!

    • @Witheredrobux
      @Witheredrobux Před 5 lety +12

      #0 is Rock because he is naked. Very evil for a cat indeed!

  • @axel_playz967
    @axel_playz967 Před 4 lety +153

    Cats: im am the evilest of all
    Scar: *whos first*

    • @berryselection9381
      @berryselection9381 Před 4 lety +10

      Scar isnt evil!!!1!!!!1!!!11!!! >:(((

    • @berryselection9381
      @berryselection9381 Před 4 lety +10

      Sophie Bryant My comment is a joke LMAO

    • @nirock2550
      @nirock2550 Před 4 lety +1

      Scar, yeah he is so evil

    • @berryselection9381
      @berryselection9381 Před 4 lety +6

      also scar didn’t really do anything bad..? all he did was only kill one cat.

    • @nirock2550
      @nirock2550 Před 4 lety +2

      hurricule • And took over the whole pride lands, got hyenas in and driven other animals out, mean to others and almost killed Simba?!

  • @alexismyers6053
    @alexismyers6053 Před 5 lety +143

    After hearing that description of Darktail's goals, all I can picture is this: Darktail sticking a mouse on a stick, holding it over the endless landscape or hellfire that has become the lake territories, and sing "Burn, baby, burn!"

    • @ricktoq
      @ricktoq Před 4 lety +2

      Alexis Myers you legend😂

    • @_beanbag_2545
      @_beanbag_2545 Před 3 lety +2

      Holy Hera, I need to draw that now

    • @alexismyers6053
      @alexismyers6053 Před 3 lety +2

      @@ricktoq Thanks, but I partly blame my 8th grade history class. On a mock test, the quest was what happened when someone was burned at the stake and one possibly answered was that the choir would sing. During the review, when the tea her read that, the class just started singing "burn, baby, burn"

    • @alexismyers6053
      @alexismyers6053 Před 3 lety +1

      @@_beanbag_2545 Glad I could inspire you lol XD

    • @alexismyers6053
      @alexismyers6053 Před 3 lety

      @Starlight_Feather I don't understand either reference, but it made me laugh lol

  • @erikakittypetjaguire6484
    @erikakittypetjaguire6484 Před 5 lety +1170

    #1 most evil cat goes to.... .....
    FireStar.
    ... feeding rouges? Keeping vital secrets that could save everyone a lot of grief? Sending your friend to a farm far, far away? Being kind?!? Blasphemy! What kind of monster does such things???
    *jk*

    • @RNKel1
      @RNKel1 Před 5 lety +36

      Before I saw the jk I was like “you are definitely Tigerstar/claw” but I see now

    • @Bugsy-hd7we
      @Bugsy-hd7we Před 5 lety +6

      Oof XD

    • @jayxen994
      @jayxen994 Před 5 lety +14

      Now that you put it that way.....

    • @Eternal-Theory
      @Eternal-Theory Před 5 lety +11

      You got me! I almost chewed your butt out!

    • @just7326
      @just7326 Před 5 lety +8

      Lol I was ticked when I started reading this but was the end and busted out laughing 😂

  • @SunnoDunno
    @SunnoDunno Před 5 lety +307

    Me: Let me guess, Tigerstar as 1.
    Wait, Mapleshade?
    I'm wrong :')

    • @SunnoDunno
      @SunnoDunno Před 5 lety +6

      @WolfShadow 23 True, he was killed by a cat 2x smaller than him. lol

    • @emiled8409
      @emiled8409 Před 5 lety +2

      Lol when i said mapleshade is evil my friend allmost didn't want to be friends anymore bc i didn't know the backstory XD
      (shes my fav luw u mapleshade uwu)

    • @doggstaranimations8426
      @doggstaranimations8426 Před 5 lety

      SunSpark well hello there. 😂

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +1

      Mapleshade really wasn't evil at least I don't see her to be,she killed Appledusk because he cheated and lied, frecklewish watched her kits die,Raven something spilled the secret and by killing it seemed to be freeing the spirit of her kits

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +1

      @@emiled8409 Mapleshade is my favorite character sure she was evil bc she helped df try to kill clans but she just wanted vengence for her kits

  • @grimsleyswitch
    @grimsleyswitch Před 5 lety +210

    Akira: "You probably already know who this is."
    Me: "It's Mapleshade!"
    Akira: "Ashfur!"
    Me: *"IT'S MAPLESHADE, YA STANK!!!"*
    Akira: "Just kidding! It's Mapleshade."
    Me: *"YEET!!!"*

  • @starby2468
    @starby2468 Před 4 lety +99

    BGA: Whos that pokemon?
    Everyone: ITS MAPLESHADE
    BGA: Its ASHFUR
    EVeryone: *triggered*

    • @tickingfoox2366
      @tickingfoox2366 Před 3 lety +1

      ASHFURE IS WEAK. WE NEED MORE STRONK FEMALE VILLIANS LIKE MAPLESHADE.

  • @jackyoshi4379
    @jackyoshi4379 Před 5 lety +215

    Moonkitti’s gonna be mad that Breezepelt isn’t on here.😶

    • @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb
      @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb Před 5 lety +16

      lol
      *i like breezepelt as a character kill me*

    • @Dragonemperess
      @Dragonemperess Před 5 lety +10

      He got better. Besides, if Ashfur isn't on here, then Breezepelt shouldn't be either.

    • @jackyoshi4379
      @jackyoshi4379 Před 5 lety +3

      Dude, it’s a joke. If you’ve watched Moonkitti then you would know he used to be her least favorite character

    • @Dragonemperess
      @Dragonemperess Před 5 lety +3

      @@jackyoshi4379 I saw her video on him. He WAS an absolute s**tlord. XD I'm glad he got better. Also, can't tell if someone is joking well on the internet without emoticons. Lol.

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety

      @@jackyoshi4379 it's actually difficult to tell when someone's joking on like the internet

  • @autumnleaf4380
    @autumnleaf4380 Před 5 lety +163

    “The cat who never got attention.”
    TAKE A HINT TAKE A HINT

    • @hannahsilcott5996
      @hannahsilcott5996 Před 4 lety +3

      Scourge right

    • @scourgesboyfriendrockstome987
      @scourgesboyfriendrockstome987 Před 4 lety +3

      Wander why scourge hates everything, never talked about at all lol but really 1 out of all of the WC characters never heard from

    • @jaatelojaateloannos3499
      @jaatelojaateloannos3499 Před 4 lety +4

      Hannah Silcott No, Sleekwhisker. There was a map made about her with the song "Take a Hint", so thats why they said "TAKE A HINT TAKE A HINT"

    • @fluffjuice5743
      @fluffjuice5743 Před 4 lety +5

      *I AM NOT YOUR MISSING LINK, LET ME TELL YOU WHAT I THINK, I THINK YOU COULD USE A MINT, TAKE A HINT, TAKE A HINT-*

    • @mareknieckarz3788
      @mareknieckarz3788 Před 3 lety

      ~~~~~~~~~~

  • @problemchild6758
    @problemchild6758 Před 4 lety +249

    Because of this CZcamsr I started reading the warrior cats books let me tell you there amazing!!!

    • @Silent.69
      @Silent.69 Před 4 lety +5

      Pastel Kitten I started reading them in first grade

    • @patrickv.m.7209
      @patrickv.m.7209 Před 4 lety +6

      How far did you come already? And what was your expection and what did you feel while reading?

    • @problemchild6758
      @problemchild6758 Před 4 lety +10

      @@patrickv.m.7209 I felt exit mentioned and adventure there is so much detail in the books so it's almost like you're actually there and experiencing it!!

    • @patrickv.m.7209
      @patrickv.m.7209 Před 4 lety +2

      @@problemchild6758 and how far did you come in only one month?

    • @problemchild6758
      @problemchild6758 Před 4 lety +1

      @@patrickv.m.7209 quite far were waiting for seasone 2 but they detail be cauz of the carona virus

  • @ballingerjl1
    @ballingerjl1 Před 5 lety +96

    One eye: YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
    Rules: You can’t do that
    One eye: SCREW YOU

    • @maleman4079
      @maleman4079 Před 4 lety +1

      rules: *no u*

    • @4DD3R
      @4DD3R Před 4 lety +2

      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      One eye: no u
      Rules: no u
      Ouch it’s a loop

  • @HeartgoldHarmony
    @HeartgoldHarmony Před 5 lety +303

    And that why mapleshade is popular and number #1

    • @user-uq3bt3gg4v
      @user-uq3bt3gg4v Před 5 lety +1

      Same too

    • @razzmatazz6125
      @razzmatazz6125 Před 5 lety +5

      And that’s how the mafia works

    • @peculiarity3111
      @peculiarity3111 Před 5 lety

      www.deviantart.com/ourartpassion/blog/# This will tell you why she was not gulity

    • @todorokitheunicorn705
      @todorokitheunicorn705 Před 5 lety +1

      Mapleshade is probably the most evil cat because she is a master of manipulation... Though why she didn't use the fact that no one remembered her to her advantage is a mystery to me.

    • @tinogudelj5803
      @tinogudelj5803 Před 4 lety

      @@echotowne3018 stfu

  • @ineffablesparrow4269
    @ineffablesparrow4269 Před 5 lety +219

    I think Thistleclaw should’ve been a bit higher up on the list, because in Spottedleaf’s heart, he’s basically a child predator, which is SUPER evil, but hey! Apart from this minor thing, I totally agree with this list! I’m glad you included lesser known villains like One Eye too, because when I read DOTC, he was such a cool, interesting villain!

    • @theunknownfate9388
      @theunknownfate9388 Před 5 lety +4

      I agree

    • @kneelessnightcat9164
      @kneelessnightcat9164 Před 5 lety +12

      I know. When he gave everyone a mark on their paw pads I had to put the book down. I’m Christian, and with the fact prey and cats got these weirds sores on them, I immediately thought of Revalation. Basically, it seemed like The Erin’s where making illusions to Revalation and One-Eye is the Antichrist.
      I was spooked to say the least.

    • @AquawindxOP
      @AquawindxOP Před 5 lety +4

      This gives me even more excuse to hate him even more

    • @vickikalvakis272
      @vickikalvakis272 Před 5 lety +3

      I still have nightmares because of that book.

    • @Lauren-yl4yy
      @Lauren-yl4yy Před 5 lety +1

      Yes thank you for noticing

  • @scarajia
    @scarajia Před 5 lety +55

    "So Ashfur, get out of here"
    ME: -dies from laughter-

  • @RowletRampage
    @RowletRampage Před 4 lety +95

    I thought you were gonna say the most evil cat was Berrynose

  • @maggiehydeck8182
    @maggiehydeck8182 Před 5 lety +307

    I personally think Darktail is a very relatable villain. Tigerstar, Brokenstar and Hawkfrost, all wanted power for the sake of power. Darktail however, wanted vengeance because his father was too much of a coward to call him his son. Mapleshade is very relatable villain as well, because every major character in her novella is a jerk.

  • @pinkbunnygirl43
    @pinkbunnygirl43 Před 5 lety +386

    Very nice! This has to be my favorite analysis video of yours yet!

  • @Epiccatqueen-un1ew
    @Epiccatqueen-un1ew Před 4 lety +22

    1:56 I thought he was talking about the other one-eye and I was very confused 😂

  • @titaaguilera3269
    @titaaguilera3269 Před 4 lety +13

    1:51 When he said One-Eye, I thought he meant the ThunderClan elder and I was so confused and then I realized it was the villain in Dawn of the Clans.

  • @blookp
    @blookp Před 5 lety +262

    My favorite warrior cat is the most evil?
    Good, the best villain is female, finally

  • @Evelyn_onfire
    @Evelyn_onfire Před 5 lety +73

    Shadowclan needs to stop getting taken over

    • @juneberry6607
      @juneberry6607 Před 5 lety

      Lmao

    • @jhaw1017
      @jhaw1017 Před 4 lety

      Lol you earned a like

    • @flamindorito
      @flamindorito Před 4 lety +2

      They either have evil cats within or are being taken over by evil cats...
      Ya see kids, ShadowClan is called ShadowClan for a reason... They are shady cats lol

    • @Featherfamilygirl
      @Featherfamilygirl Před 28 dny +1

      True!

    • @airy214
      @airy214 Před 20 dny

      its cus their logo makes no sense

  • @oblivion_7029
    @oblivion_7029 Před 4 lety +88

    *the most evil cat goes to*
    *ashfur*
    Me: ARE YOU KIDDING ME, I WATCHED THIS FOR THAT
    *JK Mapleshade*
    Me: YESS

    • @mareknieckarz3788
      @mareknieckarz3788 Před 3 lety

      I may sound stupid but I dunno why Mapleshade is bad cause I don't know much about this

    • @subbingtoeveryonewhosubsto8124
      @subbingtoeveryonewhosubsto8124 Před 3 lety +2

      Marek Nieckarz short story, she killed lots of cats

    • @Oakhaze
      @Oakhaze Před 3 lety

      Marek Nieckarz She killed, killed and killed.
      And she called that a “revenge” for her children dying

    • @drswag0076
      @drswag0076 Před 2 lety

      her actions were justifiable. after all, it's Oakstar's fault. sure he was grieving over the death of his son but that still didn't give him excuse to kick her and her kits out because she was Appledusk's mate. he didn't do anything wrong.

    • @ethanexehascrashed
      @ethanexehascrashed Před 2 lety

      @@drswag0076 killing isn't justified wtf, I mean yeah I agree with the oakstar thing but-

  • @RowletRampage
    @RowletRampage Před 4 lety +43

    Thistleclaw is the only reason Tigerclawstar is evil, because he was a horrible mentor ALSO He trained with Silverhawk not Mapleshade, I read Crookedstars Promise EDIT FORGOT MAPLESHADE

    • @2cat4life
      @2cat4life Před 2 lety +1

      he also trained with shredtail so maybe they rotate idk

    • @user-cp8uj1yr4y
      @user-cp8uj1yr4y Před měsícem

      Tigerkit/paw/claw/star's father, mother siblings abandoned him, he wanted some revenge aswell

  • @twodogsandacat2573
    @twodogsandacat2573 Před 5 lety +69

    Nah... number one is the tree that killed Firestar. Or if you think he died of injuries, Tigerstar’s biggest claw!

    • @tempestousshadow2810
      @tempestousshadow2810 Před 5 lety

      Who killed Firestar?

    • @ahws3051
      @ahws3051 Před 5 lety +2

      Firestarter was an annoying character and I'm glad he died after all this time.

    • @waffleweirdo1252
      @waffleweirdo1252 Před 5 lety +1

      Firestarter?

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +2

      Firestar is the second worst character (hollyleaf the worst) he's an annoying Mary Sue life was more or less handed to him on a silver platter sure a few times he had to do stuff but I still don't like him

    • @harepaw9914
      @harepaw9914 Před 5 lety +3

      Firestar is hunting with Starclan now....

  • @CherriGriffon
    @CherriGriffon Před 5 lety +87

    Is it bad that half of these are on my top ten favorites

    • @thearttrashbin1656
      @thearttrashbin1656 Před 5 lety +5

      Nope, I like them too

    • @catlady307
      @catlady307 Před 5 lety +7

      ALL DA VILLAINS ARE AWESOME

    • @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb
      @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb Před 5 lety +3

      nope, not at all!

    • @1lainfan348
      @1lainfan348 Před 5 lety +2

      Chirri-io
      Same XD
      Especially Mapleshade! She’s my absolute favorite cat! ~w~
      I said Ravenpaw on a different comment, but they share top spot UwU

    • @theoumber6604
      @theoumber6604 Před 5 lety +1

      Nope. Sol's my favorite cat.

  • @fastfox1013
    @fastfox1013 Před 4 lety +52

    Mapleshade was automatically my favorite cat as soon as my sister told me about her. I like good cats, but sometimes I just need a good villain to like to. Go Mapleshade!!!!!

    • @anonmouscat2086
      @anonmouscat2086 Před 4 lety +1

      Mapleshade is the best!

    • @blackkat312
      @blackkat312 Před 3 lety +1

      she's so badass i love her too

    • @tickingfoox2366
      @tickingfoox2366 Před 3 lety

      SHALL I MAKE A TEAM MAPLESHADE DISCORD?

    • @evelynschwalb7603
      @evelynschwalb7603 Před 2 lety +4

      I get the "having a villian to like" part, but "GO MAPLESHADE?" really? like do you have any idea what she has done to cats?

  • @aydensings4258
    @aydensings4258 Před 5 lety +19

    I didn't know half the cats I'm still on the new prophecy, when you mentioned ash fur i was like ".....What?! Answers!!"

  • @Nyxystix
    @Nyxystix Před 5 lety +195

    #1 most evil cat.........
    Berrynose.... jeez hes just, SO ANNOYINg AND MEAN

    • @thearttrashbin1656
      @thearttrashbin1656 Před 5 lety +1

      Moontail 12 yup

    • @swagishpug
      @swagishpug Před 5 lety +3

      I love Berrynose, rip

    • @taylorclark778
      @taylorclark778 Před 5 lety +1

      Agreed

    • @loading...3850
      @loading...3850 Před 5 lety +14

      Nah #1 should have gone to breezepelt because he's just so good at pissing me off!

    • @shototodoroki1974
      @shototodoroki1974 Před 5 lety +4

      yes berrynose is also a player dun dun dunnnnn he mated with two females also THE TWO FEMALES WERE SISTERS

  • @oofoof7518
    @oofoof7518 Před 5 lety +42

    I think the books would be better if STICK was evil breaking the branches of the dark forest by night and breaking Jayfeather's heart by day.

  • @elpii_pm3600
    @elpii_pm3600 Před 5 lety +31

    I believed that you would point out that Thistleclaw manipulated Spottedpaw (Spottedleaf). I was surprised you did not mention it as a factor, but it is ok. Kate said that this was the real reason Thistleclaw was evil and sent to the Dark Forest.

    • @nonomen6665
      @nonomen6665 Před 3 lety +2

      That was probably something he was too uncomfortable with to talk about

  • @catpineconekit3490
    @catpineconekit3490 Před 5 lety +7

    Scourge is more evil than Tigerstar. Scourge made a whole clan from a lie, which then eventually became true. He killed Tigerstar and took one of Firestar's lives, and he is also no bigger than an apprentice.

    • @jewelsthecat5331
      @jewelsthecat5331 Před 5 lety +1

      VØLTAGE IsKITCAT
      He also killed a innocent shadowclan cat, and tried to kill barleys sister.

    • @candytvstudios7742
      @candytvstudios7742 Před 4 lety +1

      He also managed to take over the entire forest and the clan territories.

    • @nightshademasquerade4703
      @nightshademasquerade4703 Před 2 lety

      Lol apprentices are pretty much fully grown

  • @dragonfruitssu2983
    @dragonfruitssu2983 Před 5 lety +80

    MapleShade, Sleekwhisker and Darktail are my favourite evil cats (in the list)

    • @todorokitheunicorn705
      @todorokitheunicorn705 Před 5 lety +2

      My personal favorite is Hawkfrost... My friend's influence is wearing off on me...

    • @harepaw9914
      @harepaw9914 Před 5 lety +3

      Mine is Mapleshade and Blackstar

    • @rowyn2643
      @rowyn2643 Před 5 lety +1

      SHAPLEMAID you meant Right? Yes thats what you meant

    • @SkyMurphy77
      @SkyMurphy77 Před rokem

      same

  • @thatmomentwhen597
    @thatmomentwhen597 Před 5 lety +29

    I just finished Shattered Sky and Darktail is legitimately terrifying and torturous. I agree with you about the Blazing Star, too

  • @teenyfroog6851
    @teenyfroog6851 Před 4 lety +16

    The argument for Tigerstar doesnt make sense, him "following the rules" was all part of his plo

    • @evelynschwalb7603
      @evelynschwalb7603 Před 2 lety +1

      I TOTALLY AGREE! Tigerstar was much worse than this guy is making him out to be

    • @nightshademasquerade4703
      @nightshademasquerade4703 Před 2 lety

      Brokenstar too. So what if he didn't achieve his goals? He sent kits to their deaths. Knowingly. More than once.
      And thistleclaw, who didn't become leader but tried to groom a VERY young spottedleaf. The criteria he's working with seems kinda wonky.

  • @tetamusenja8945
    @tetamusenja8945 Před 5 lety +18

    I love Mapleshade even thought she's evil.

  • @cresentgaze8812
    @cresentgaze8812 Před 5 lety +41

    *One Eye* thank you for adding a dawn of the clans character :3

  • @asteroidalassassin6949
    @asteroidalassassin6949 Před 5 lety +78

    Sometimes I wish the story was re-engineered so Pinestar turned out to be Jake, Firehearts father. It would make the whole dynamic with Tigerclaw much different.

    • @waffleweirdo1252
      @waffleweirdo1252 Před 5 lety +2

      WE NEED AN AU ABOUT THIS, STAT!

    • @Alistair-The-Grox
      @Alistair-The-Grox Před 5 lety +8

      but the only problem is-
      PINESTAR KNEW JAKE SO HOW CAN HE BE JAKE?
      but yeah this au would be coool

    • @dio44492
      @dio44492 Před 4 lety +1

      YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS ID LOVE TIGERSTAR TO BE FIRESTARS HALF BROTHER

    • @markusbirkholz9401
      @markusbirkholz9401 Před 4 lety +1

      yes. I was hoping actually after I figured out that Scourge is Firestar's Half-brother. Intristing coincidence

    • @thepurplepaw2231
      @thepurplepaw2231 Před 4 lety +2

      Sooo... Tigerstar was killed by his brother?

  • @brokenoven9404
    @brokenoven9404 Před 5 lety +15

    I think Brokenstar’s a *wussie.* He sent *kits* out into battle instead of manning up himself

  • @dahlias_gacha_planet8948
    @dahlias_gacha_planet8948 Před 4 lety +10

    I like how there was a cat that lookedlike swiftpawasareal cat playing with a to for a ad at the beginning

    • @junebugthehivewing8124
      @junebugthehivewing8124 Před 3 lety

      My cat looks like Swiftpaw that’s why when I’m alone with him I call him Swiftpaw and he responds😯

  • @SleepyCoffeeCup
    @SleepyCoffeeCup Před 5 lety +45

    Why is the evilest cat one of my favorite characters?

  • @sp_rks8481
    @sp_rks8481 Před 5 lety +43

    Every cat on the list seems to have justified reasons, I know that they’re not REALLY good reasons to kill a cat or want to take over a clan but it just seems reasonable for them to be evil.
    Tigerstar’s father left him when he was a kit to be a kittypet, and I mean that itself could mess someone up a lot.
    Thistleclaw’s ambition was influenced by Mapleshade and his grief turned into anger when Snowfur died.
    Mapleshade was kicked out of her clan, watched her kits die, and then got rejected from Riverclan, they didn’t even want to bury the kits near their deceased clanmates.
    I think the most evil cat has to be Brokenstar from the moment he was born he was evil and he gave no reason on why he was like that. He had a loving father yes, and Lizardstripe wasn’t the best mother I get that. Lizardstripe and her kits didn’t have an influence really on Brokenstar because he was already born with evil intentions and strong emotions. All the other villains seem pathetic compared to him, because they only are driven by usually grief or anger which honestly is getting old.

  • @Lamrabetnouha
    @Lamrabetnouha Před 5 lety +15

    I came here just to see who is more evil between Tigerstar and Darktail.

  • @Channlw
    @Channlw Před 4 lety +149

    pretty cringe comment, innit bruv

  • @lotorious4769
    @lotorious4769 Před 5 lety +36

    “His defeat in Sunrise..”
    Wait
    I’m reading that book right now!! >:C
    No it’s okay don’t worry I’m not mad xD

    • @JonniShandor
      @JonniShandor Před 3 lety

      I hwd to look. Thwt up bease i thought it in the second seris lol

    • @drswag0076
      @drswag0076 Před 2 lety

      i haven't read any of them.

  • @muddochips3419
    @muddochips3419 Před 5 lety +15

    I agree about BlazingStar being underrated. All of Dawn Of The Clans is rather underrated even though they have amazing development.

  • @midakaisilvers1677
    @midakaisilvers1677 Před 4 lety +6

    I can't remember well, but in Leafpool's Secret Yellowfang confirms that the reason Brokenstar was evil was because he was raised by a cat who hated him. Starclan can't make some cat automatically evil- but they understand how things will turn out when there's no other choice. Brokenkit literally had to beg to be fed, and Tigerkit was fed with dark thoughts by Mapleshade and Thisleclaw.

  • @mcytfan1415
    @mcytfan1415 Před 3 lety +7

    Akira: Ashfur failed miserably
    The Broken Code: let me introduce myself

    • @user-cp8uj1yr4y
      @user-cp8uj1yr4y Před měsícem

      Ngl I was rly -Mad- when Akira said Ashfur is num 1 but then I lost it when he said Mapleshade.

  • @alicewonderswan3936
    @alicewonderswan3936 Před 5 lety +28

    I love Mapleshade! (SHAPLEMAIDDDDDD)

  • @jillian5775
    @jillian5775 Před 5 lety +20

    I paused before you said sleekwhisker, so it said slee-
    And for a moment, I thought u were gonna go sleeping beauty....

  • @christinamcclendon5789
    @christinamcclendon5789 Před 4 lety +8

    She is not a villain her kids died and her husband abandoned her and said it was all her fault that they were dead it wasn’t her fault she couldn’t get them in time!

  • @tigerseye1002
    @tigerseye1002 Před 5 lety +10

    I think that Dawn of the Clans is extremely underrated. I don't know if it's just me, but I NEVER see anyone talking about how good this arc is.

  • @crocuspetals5510
    @crocuspetals5510 Před 5 lety +76

    definitely LITTLECLOUD *PLOT TWIST*

  • @videokedisi1389
    @videokedisi1389 Před 5 lety +28

    Scorge is realyyyyyy strong he killed tigerstar 8times at once

    • @stevepalubiski8608
      @stevepalubiski8608 Před 5 lety +8

      Video Kedisi *cough* Nine *cough*

    • @videokedisi1389
      @videokedisi1389 Před 5 lety

      Steve Palubiski sorry little keyboard

    • @kck4y
      @kck4y Před 5 lety +2

      Except when he gets killed with a swipe of a paw from his half brother.

    • @chf.j4233
      @chf.j4233 Před 4 lety

      Using a dogs tooth

    • @felekiwa_7296
      @felekiwa_7296 Před 4 lety +1

      He never had 9 lives. He never went to the Moonstone. The Erin's want us to find out

  • @Lenore4175
    @Lenore4175 Před 2 lety +5

    Video: Ashfur never tried to destroy the clans
    The Broken Code: Ashfur destroys the clans, possesses bramblestar and controls dead cats with his mind

  • @kellyli7925
    @kellyli7925 Před 4 lety +38

    Mapleshade is actually my favorite cat in the series, i can understand her

    • @zorsti
      @zorsti Před 4 lety +3

      Kelly Li You can understand a murderer? Idek if this is a joke, but if it isn’t, all Mapleshade did was kill, kill, and kill some more, for not reasons that are really justified.

    • @zorsti
      @zorsti Před 4 lety +3

      Jay_ Wingzz_ Finally, someone shares my thoughts, those are my exact reasons, I appreciate

    • @moist_dust
      @moist_dust Před 3 lety +1

      Jay_ Wingzz_ not try to start a fight but here are my reasons why I feel bad she was kicked out of tc tried to go to her mate for help when she tried to explain what happened Apple desk cut it off and made it sound like she meant to kill the kits and Apple dusk got to stay and she had to Leave she didn’t even get to say goodbye to her kits Just my opinion

    • @moist_dust
      @moist_dust Před 3 lety

      Jay_ Wingzz_ It’s been a while since I’ve read it I don’t remember every part

    • @CPRCUS
      @CPRCUS Před 3 lety

      I like her too, but I hafta say I like Tallstar more in terms of any character, my favorite villian is probably Sol

  • @Peskygob
    @Peskygob Před 5 lety +4

    Ashfur didn’t try to kill the kits because of love... it’s because squirrelflight stole his hairspray...

  • @kayleejones3570
    @kayleejones3570 Před 5 lety +9

    And, number 1, ASHFUR!
    Me: WHAT?!?! WHERES MY MAPLEBAE?

  • @CatztheEquestrian
    @CatztheEquestrian Před 2 lety +3

    “Ashfur never tried to destroy the clans”…..
    That aged well!!!

  • @scourgesboyfriendrockstome987

    Maple shade: I know you love me.
    Ashfur: this is a joke right?
    Viewers: hahaha
    Scourge: (sigh) I'm lonely,no one loves me
    Me: I'm on your side😍
    Scourge: 😖 thank you two leg, thank you so much!
    Scourge: make me #1
    Me: no that's evil.
    Scourge:sh$t

  • @martha6651
    @martha6651 Před 5 lety +35

    I think Finleap needs a mention. Yes, he didn't kill or murder a Clan or anything, but he emotionally abused and forced Twigbranch to have kits with him if they were going to be mates. This made Twigbranch depressed. bad boy.

    • @dovefilms
      @dovefilms Před 5 lety +10

      and plus it's implied in the end that twigbranch is possibly pregnant
      and if she is, that means....
      god finleap is just disgusting

    • @martha6651
      @martha6651 Před 5 lety +9

      @@dovefilms oh god i remember that... i really liked him as little chirpy quirky finpaw who followed around twigbranch like a lost puppy and i felt like they actually had chemisty and then BAM toxic disgusting forcing she-cat to have kits tom. :/ if finleap did that to her...

    • @kevingawthorp1605
      @kevingawthorp1605 Před 5 lety +1

      This is my dad's account.
      Oof I just read River of Fire and fin seems like a nice bean
      CONSPIRACY

    • @madisonwtf
      @madisonwtf Před 4 lety

      I know this is late, but you're so right

  • @kieravermeal9127
    @kieravermeal9127 Před 5 lety +8

    Another point for Thistleclaw is that he got into a relationship (and manipulated) Spottedleaf when she was an apprentice. And started hitting on her when she was a kit...
    Yeah...
    Also, you think training kits under 6 moons to fight to the death isn't evil enough for Brokenstar? Wow...

    • @noyolk5039
      @noyolk5039 Před 5 lety +1

      He also the reason why for Tigerstar's ambitions.

    • @PinkSalsaGirl
      @PinkSalsaGirl Před rokem +1

      what book is the thistleclaw one?

  • @karimakou154
    @karimakou154 Před 4 lety +2

    BrokenStar was abused AND neglected by LizardStripe, his foster mother.
    Some say he despised every cat around him because of this.
    MapleShade carried out her vengeance against the 3 cats who indirectly/directly killed her kits. MapleShade tried to save her kits, they were her whole life when they were alive. Then, Maple has hallucinations of her deceased kits, this event made her want to make it up to her kits.
    You forgot some deets .-.

  • @Thatgeeky_Artist
    @Thatgeeky_Artist Před 5 lety +5

    I agree with your list, the sad thing is that Mapleshade is my favourite character, I mean, yes she was super evil, but she did it all for her kits no hesitation... how many more mothers could you find that’ll do the same thing for her kits?

  • @s0ckk
    @s0ckk Před 5 lety +95

    Don’t you mean shaplemaid?
    edit:Woah thanks for the likes!! :)

    • @hanakosprite
      @hanakosprite Před 5 lety +2

      Shay’s Animations no

    • @ax3247
      @ax3247 Před 5 lety +2

      WTF XD

    • @rowyn2643
      @rowyn2643 Před 5 lety +2

      SHAPLEMAID!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!🙃

    • @kung-tenghuang8144
      @kung-tenghuang8144 Před 5 lety +2

      Shay’s Animations huh?

    • @_ranger__
      @_ranger__ Před 4 lety

      For those who dont understand, it is a reference from Akira’s “Cats who shouldn’t have gone to the dark forest”

  • @nightshade7792
    @nightshade7792 Před 5 lety +31

    I feel like it would be really cool if either Hollyleaf or Blossomfall became a villain. It would be an interesting plot twist. I mean picture it.

    • @chloecopeland7361
      @chloecopeland7361 Před 5 lety +1

      Nightshade I have a evil hollyleaf au!

    • @1lainfan348
      @1lainfan348 Před 5 lety

      Nightshade
      An evil Blossomfall AU is what we need tbh UwU

    • @ax3247
      @ax3247 Před 5 lety +1

      Hollyleaf could've became an actually interesting character. And a female villain that isn't ridiculously crappy.

    • @ZaneEnthusiast
      @ZaneEnthusiast Před 5 lety

      *gasp* why.... Why would you say that hollyleaf is my favourite cat *oof* she is tho (my opinion Ashfur is my lest favourite cat)

    • @huedotexe8785
      @huedotexe8785 Před 5 lety

      Yeah, it would also *give Hollyleaf a purpose in life*. I absolutely hated how she got all her hopes up to be "One of the most powerful cats" just to DIE while her brother Lionblaze who was so full of himself was granted partial immortality? I mean come on she deserved better :(

  • @meremoo
    @meremoo Před 5 lety +3

    i honestly thought they'd mention maple's whole crookedstar deal from crookedstar's promise.

  • @BubblesTheBabyGoat900
    @BubblesTheBabyGoat900 Před 9 měsíci +5

    POV:
    Ashfur watching this video:
    Takes over Brambleclaw's body as a ghost, manipulates and controls all the Clans, convinces them to abandon a medicine cat and deputy, nearly succeeds in destroying ShadowClan, driven made by love and betrayal.
    "Am I #1 now?"

  • @ciricebriar
    @ciricebriar Před 5 lety +30

    Mapleshade was once my favorite....

    • @DoctorWhoXIII
      @DoctorWhoXIII Před 5 lety +1

      Once i liked her
      Then i read Mapleshade Vengance and i hated her lol
      Kinda hate how she was behind Thistleclaw and Tigerstar.... Can we got a villain beside Brokenstar that was not pushed to be evil because of Mapleshade ?
      Please im hopin Sleekwhisker dont have ANY link with her.....

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +7

      Mapleshade still is my favorite only after Mapleshades vengence though

    • @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb
      @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb Před 5 lety +4

      *she still is my favorite*

    • @ciricebriar
      @ciricebriar Před 5 lety +2

      @@Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb I don't understand why, but ok

    • @articwolfie9545
      @articwolfie9545 Před 5 lety +3

      Nah Mapleshade is my favorite villan.

  • @jackyoshi4379
    @jackyoshi4379 Před 5 lety +12

    You guys realize that Thistleclaw was the ONLY area on for Tigerstar to be evil. This is because in Tigerclaw’s Fury, Tigerclaw meets Mapleshade. We know Mapleshade did not influence him because he said “Who are you.”

    • @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb
      @Cobbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb Před 5 lety +5

      mapleshade whispers evil thoughts in his ear, but doesn't actually train him in the dark forest.

  • @n4taliee365
    @n4taliee365 Před 5 lety +10

    You forgot Tigerstars BIGGEST accomplishment...
    Bramblestar and tawnypelt :)

    • @astronic9979
      @astronic9979 Před 4 lety

      :Throws Bramblestar in the trash and puts down Mothwing:

    • @olly_lmao
      @olly_lmao Před 4 lety

      Not Mothpool?

  • @jocelynh4432
    @jocelynh4432 Před 4 lety +9

    When he said ashfur I thought he was serious and I was about to do my happy dance

  • @josebonilla4249
    @josebonilla4249 Před 5 lety +6

    Number one for me:
    Maplshad
    Who needs MapleShade? *WE HAVE MAPLSHAD*

  • @crystalcolors2229
    @crystalcolors2229 Před 5 lety +36

    im so surprised Clear Sky isnt here lmao
    hes an abuser + basically every warrior cat villain ever

    • @reshikawarriorsamino3379
      @reshikawarriorsamino3379 Před 5 lety +2

      Clear Sky flip flopped for me.
      First 4 books(DOTC) I hated him and wanted him to burn.
      Last 2 books(DOTC) I liked him.
      Moth Flight's Vision
      Wait Moth Flights Vision took place between book 2 and 3 in DOTC right?!(This is part joke because he acted so much like his old self in the start of Dawn of the Clans, even though it was after it ended.

    • @crystalcolors2229
      @crystalcolors2229 Před 5 lety +1

      moth flights vision happened AFTER the events of the arc, meaning Clear Sky literally never improved and went back into being a shitty cat (:@@reshikawarriorsamino3379

    • @reshikawarriorsamino3379
      @reshikawarriorsamino3379 Před 5 lety

      @@crystalcolors2229 Seriously? Are you actually kidding me.
      I K N O W
      I even said that in my comment.

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +4

      I *HATED* clearsky in mothflights vision every book but especially mothflights vision he was half responsible for Micah's death if Micah didn't stay in the tree someone would die also wasn't the cat that would have died his brothers mate and a friend to him I can't remember so the last part is prob wrong

    • @jewelsthecat5331
      @jewelsthecat5331 Před 5 lety +2

      CrystalColors
      To me I don’t feel like he is necessarily evil, but a narcissist with a huge ego. He cared about his territory and the power of his Clan, but he was heartless to most cats too. To me that sounds a bit more narcissistic than evil. And he started to get better later on in the series, as he deeply cares about his new mate and his Kits. But I completely respect your opinion, and I used to think he was evil myself, actually.

  • @nochannel6349
    @nochannel6349 Před 3 lety +2

    Akira: the cat who never got attention
    Also Akira: *makes a Sleekwhisker song called Attention*
    She's got it now

  • @kyndallrudder5856
    @kyndallrudder5856 Před 4 lety +8

    I really wanna read MapleShades Vengeance now

  • @invaderjulius1359
    @invaderjulius1359 Před 5 lety +12

    I think the most evil cat is...
    MapleShade.
    She killed three cats because she betrayed ThunderClan and that her kit's drowned. She is also a Yandere
    There.

    • @juneberry6607
      @juneberry6607 Před 5 lety +1

      Yeah he put her as number 1 already

    • @Alistair-The-Grox
      @Alistair-The-Grox Před 5 lety

      i don't define mapleshade as yandere...

    • @juneberry6607
      @juneberry6607 Před 5 lety +1

      Espoir lol in the book it literally says in the first chapter “Appledusk is mine, Reedshine. Don’t take him away From me” but yeah. Were all entitled to our own opinions, so I’m not gonna say you’re wrong, I’m just pointing out my opinion. (I’m only saying this because literally every time someone says something like this people get triggered so DiScLaiMeR)

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety

      I don't find mapleshade evil she killed three caygs for good reason frecklewish watched her kits die Raven something spilled a secret that was hers and hers alone and Appledusk cheated and lied
      Also as she killed cats she somehow freed her kits spirits and she meets them at the border of starclan and darkforest

    • @DoctorWhoXIII
      @DoctorWhoXIII Před 5 lety

      @@davidzelia2814 The spirit of the kits has been confirmed it was hallucination....

  • @tjtheentertainer9376
    @tjtheentertainer9376 Před 5 lety +8

    Even though he still got to go to StarClan, I think Clear Sky/Skystar could’ve been a good villain. He rejected his own family members, set up extreme borders, and even made to Clans go against each other. Similar case with Onestar

  • @holly.eq78
    @holly.eq78 Před 5 lety +5

    As the drumroll came I whispered mapleshade and then when ashfur came up I screamed at the screen

  • @bbus4447
    @bbus4447 Před rokem +3

    The Joke about Ashfur beeing the Most Evil really aged well

  • @flakeyartist3533
    @flakeyartist3533 Před 5 lety +8

    The way you describe Tigerstars "evilness" really impresses the notion on me, that the list was more about the most violent villans, than the most evil cats - You can be evil and still follow the rules, in this case it even made more sense for him, since he wasn't bent on destroying the clans in his lifetime, but wanted to lead all of them. If he didn't gain leadership the "right" way, he would quickly be leader of no clan once they banded together under him, since they wouldn't trust in his leadership. (I really got into that more than I should have, lol)

  • @theoumber6604
    @theoumber6604 Před 5 lety +6

    I don't think Sol is actually evil....He's just angry and hurt and I think it's not his fault he had such a sucky life.
    My little sister is watching this. She hasn't read Sunrise. I indicated a space about five feet around and told her how it ended. Hollyleaf darted around slashing at Sol from every side while Sol flailed at random shadows. Wow, Sol. You are SUCH a good fighter.

  • @Officialgovernmenthater
    @Officialgovernmenthater Před 5 lety +3

    In my opinion, Rainflower should've gone to the dark forest due to child neglect, but hey, Ashfur tried killing an entire family but went to Starclan

  • @cindyxgam3s312
    @cindyxgam3s312 Před 4 lety +7

    When u said ashfur i said DANG IT! but u changed it and i was like YES!

  • @user-dv9ip6bq9b
    @user-dv9ip6bq9b Před 5 lety +5

    But, you know, if Ashfool succeded...
    Shaplemade was exiled, lost her kits and her mate broke up with her. She killed three cats and ended up in the DF. She killed cats who responsible for the death of her kits and her exile. and her mate.
    Ashfool didn't have any dead kits, lived in Thunderclan, but teamed up with a riverclan cat to kill his own leader, then tried to burn three cats alive because their mother and his niece used to hang with him for a week to make her bf jelaous. He went all yandere and tried to murder four guiltless cats just for sake of taking pleasure in Squirrel's suffering. That would be more evil if he succeded and killed them.

    • @upsidedowndogg
      @upsidedowndogg Před 5 lety +1

      Mapleshade herself played a massive role in kits' deaths as well, literally being the one who made the kits swim across dangerous waters in the first place.

    • @frostdragon64
      @frostdragon64 Před 5 lety +1

      @@upsidedowndogg They were literally swimming in the river the day before. The only reason Appledusk had to save one was because one got tired. They literally could swim. So she assumed they would be okay. If you blame mapleshade, I hope you also blame Bluestar for Mosskit's death.

    • @upsidedowndogg
      @upsidedowndogg Před 5 lety

      @@frostdragon64 - They could swim, but only vaguely. They were obviously not going to make it safely across a swollen river, especially unaided (Mapleshade swims behind them).

    • @letb5569
      @letb5569 Před 5 lety

      @@upsidedowndogg You do know the only reason the kits didn't make it across was because a dam up the river broke and the area was overwhelm while they were swimming across. They didn't drown because they couldn't swim, they drown, because they get swept away by the massive swell of water. Mapleshade only made it herself, because she was pulled out of the water.

    • @upsidedowndogg
      @upsidedowndogg Před 5 lety +1

      @@letb5569 - The flood was visible, Patchkit even points it out. Mapleshade could've at least attempted a safer alternative, such looking for another route across, or waiting out the storm somewhere.

  • @jackyoshi4379
    @jackyoshi4379 Před 5 lety +4

    Your One Eye drawing is really good!!!

  • @jolandaanderson202
    @jolandaanderson202 Před 5 lety +6

    p-p I've been practically just staring at DarkTail and akira and thinking "why Does Akira look like DarkTail?"

  • @Funsheeps
    @Funsheeps Před 4 lety +5

    My genuine reaction to number one:
    “It’s ashfurrrrrrrrr”
    *oh*
    “Just kidding it’s maple shade”
    *YEAHHHHHHHHHHHH-*

  • @gladionfan
    @gladionfan Před 5 lety +5

    #1
    Jayfeather
    he broke stick

  • @brooklynngrimes3525
    @brooklynngrimes3525 Před 5 lety +3

    When Akira said Ashfur I actually thought he meant it 😹

  • @tonyyu8335
    @tonyyu8335 Před 2 lety +3

    “Ash’fur never achieved anything in the clans and never destroyed anything, and he went to Starclan”
    The Broken Code would like to speak with your manager.

  • @newchannelcalledtrimmyframe

    You are SO cool! Thanks for making these videos, I love warriors! (ALSO I LOVE MAPLESHADE)

  • @caralynp9996
    @caralynp9996 Před 5 lety +3

    Tiger star is my favorite cat I really don't know why, I just think he is a well developed villain.

  • @davidzelia2814
    @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +23

    I don't fine mapleshade evil she just wanted vengence for her kits,Appledusk cheated and lied to her,frecklewish watched her kits die in a river,and Raven something spilled her secret and made it so she was banished she had her reasons and she never told anyone birchface was her mate frecklewish just assumed it and told everyone else also it seemed like by killing those three cats she was somehow freeing her three kits

    • @m0ssteeth639
      @m0ssteeth639 Před 5 lety +3

      Thank you for preaching this truth.

    • @moonkai973
      @moonkai973 Před 5 lety +4

      Yeah, she was more insane than evil. There’s a difference

    • @currentlydrinkingcoffee6713
      @currentlydrinkingcoffee6713 Před 5 lety +7

      She committed three counts of premeditated murder. She is evil, and after she gets to the dark forest, she does more evil.

    • @alyssafulp2716
      @alyssafulp2716 Před 5 lety +8

      No, she was evil and knew what she was doing. It says right in her own book that Mapleshade planned Freckle, Raven and Apple's deaths. How was she not evil? This comment makes no sense. Do not say she isn't evil just because you sympathize with her. You can have sympathy for a villain, but that doesn't make her innocent. A bad past doesn't excuse what she's done. She knew what she was doing.

    • @davidzelia2814
      @davidzelia2814 Před 5 lety +1

      @@alyssafulp2716 I *NEVER* said she didn't know and her book is *LITERALLY* what I'm going off

  • @icylemonwolf6715
    @icylemonwolf6715 Před 2 lety +4

    Bright Guardian Akira: Ashfur really didn't try to destroy the clans.
    Ashfur in The Broken Code: I shall use this young Shadowclan apprentice to kill the a-hole who stole my love, then turn the clans against each other which then I'll kidnap the daughter of the legendary dorito so I can be with her finally. (I honestly see Ashfur as a yandere for Squrrielflight.)

  • @Demon_doggo
    @Demon_doggo Před rokem +2

    9:20
    Ash fur now: destroyed all clans including starclan, successfully took over a leaders body, made a new barrier between starclan and the dark forest, killed and imprisoned lots of cats while driving the clans into anarchy