F1 Drivers FURIOUS At FIA After UNFAIR RULES At Miami GP!
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 05. 2024
- ■ Kevin Magnussen has been on the receiving end of things during the Miami GP, amassing a total of 35 seconds of penalty in the matter of 19 laps. However, his reckless driving - although nearing him to a race ban - is something that we could see a lot more often if something doesn’t change with the rules, and if this turns out to be the case, the question arises: Will a lot of drivers sacrifice their own race so that their teammate can score points? And more importantly, is there any way that the FIA can prevent this other than the long-accumulating penalty points?
■ Watch the entire video for more information!
■ For business inquiries, copyright matters or other inquiries please contact us at: formulef77@gmail.com
#f1 #formula1 #f1news - Sport
What is your opinion about the driving style Magnussen used to protect his teammate for getting points?
THATS WHAT RACING IS ABOUT. It was brilliant and exciting.
Magnussen should be black flagged.
I think it isn't that hard to fix. Magnussen is driving like this to keep the car behind him behind him. When he cut the corner to break DRS rather than a 10 second penalty he should have been told to give up the position, just like if he'd have passed in that manor. If he refused then a driver through penalty would be assessed. If nothing is done this will escalate at the back of the grid where one car scoring is all you need to finish above the 'rest'.
I hate it when there is action/unpredictability on a race track I just want 20 cars to time trial for 2 hours keeping a safe distance from one another
No crash, collision; no harm, no foul. Stop making new rules. Do better job making calls according to the rules. This isn’t the floppy NBA
Aggressive driving? This was probably the most exciting GP since 2022
Let em race! This is not ballet, what they did to Alonso and Sainz is a joke which i don't find funny. Or FIA really wants em to wear short white mini dress??
Stroll can rear end someone during a safety carr, but Mag can defend DURING a race?
The only ones to stay at home are the stewards. Sorry guys, you often are ruining a race. You have different degrees of penalties, depending on who's the guy. Let them race for gods sake!
As long as he drives defensively within the rules than its fine. Aggressive defense and offense are legal.
If they want to be very strict on defensive driving then they should do the same up front. Then we have no race.
Exactly that was the most entertaining shit in the past 2 years. Isn’t that what f1 is about? Fighting tooth and nail and now everyone is crying about safety?
Are they seriously complaining about the most spectacular bit of Miami? The rest of the show was pretty lame...
The race incedent with sargeant was fully sargeants fault, but Kmag cant fart in the cockpit with getting 10 second penalty.
I think it is b*llshit, because Bottas did it multiple times for Hamilton by Mercedes. And K mag defends allways hard.
Alonso did it against Hamilton without defending anything in 21-22?
Perez did it for Verstappen too
Hamilton takes out 2 drivers, no penalty. Magnussen never touches Hamilton, gets 35 seconds penalty.
K-Mag did what his team asked him to do - how does that warrant a penalty against him personally? If he does what they want, he gets multiple penalties and possibly a race ban. If he doesn't do what they want, he gets kicked to the kerb in favor of someone more compliant. It's lose-lose for him.
FFS let them race, this is getting ridiculous
Verstapen raced exactly the same way Magnussen did, especially when he tried to fight for podium. Its was «just racing» before. Remember that drivers are allowed to push others out of track just because thats how verstappen raced 2-5 years ago. These days he doesnt have to fight a lot, he just drives past on straight. Comes to mind verstappen vs Leclerc in Austria 3 years ago
Yes, Max was worse but got away with it. His driving provoked many accidents. Magnussen is even more blatant.
Racing isn't just driving behind each other and giving way when an other driver approaches. The way Max and Magnussen drove is what we want to see. Not only driving around like sissies...
Exactly, Max does it fighting for a podium. Kev does it fighting for 15th.
It will be a big shame if Magnussen is racing next year and Bearman misses out
F1 rules full of crap... Biased and Shows clear favorite ism...
Simplyfy the rules, be fair and Let them race
So much snowflaking nowadays....
Everyone talking about Magnussen, who got punished as per the current rules. Yet no-one mentioning Hamilton, who made a move seen in a low-ranking online sim race, flying down the inside into T1 from P12, causing a a domino effect, resulting in Norris being eliminated from the race, only to emerge in P8, with no penalty. I was expecting an instant ban after seeing it happen.
Yeah, I don't know. From a driver/team perspective, the fact that 2 points could potentially mean $10mil in earnings, that's the root of the problem right there. Secondly, FIA should probably take responsibility for fatal flaws in car design that directly affect how race-able they are. What did they expect when they made these cars the size of a limousine and the only feasible way they have of overtaking is DRS? It's partially why drivers feel like they need to make desperate moves like the one Magnussen made on Logan to cause their crash in Miami. If he didn't attempt a move there, he'd be waiting 4-5 more corners until a DRS straight.
The only real blunder was not from Magnussen but from the organisation.
That was the SC situation where the SC did NOT catch the fromnt runner but the second..
Givinbg with that Norris a free pitstop .
Depending if t,he SC could have been on track in time before Norris passed along or not (the second option meant that the SC would come in one lap later) Norris would (first option) NOT have a free pitstop or (second option) at least not the track position at restart (second or third on track).
Not sure if that would differ the outcome but we had seen that Norris had problems woth passing Perez.
Oh..I loved how Magnussen and Lewis were racing. No reason for any other penalty for that driving ...
Beating holy Lewis N. Hamilton is now a punishable offense...
yeah why wasn't Hamiltons move in the first corner of the sprint race not penalised. He wreck 3 other peoples race because he saw a gap
I would say the points were harsh except for one thing, the final time Magnessun went off the track to defend he came in really hard and ran into Hamilton's car. You should be allowed to defend, but never break track limits to do so as that isn't defending it is simply breaking racing rules. But to do so in such a manner that you are shoving another car out of the way with your own is far beyond anything, and points are deserved because of that behavior.
Hülkenberg isn't actually more consistent. Fact is kev more frequently scores points than Hülkenberg, but Hülkenberg scores more points when he does. Kevin is actually the most consistent of the two.
Lulu fanboys videos, another way to cry online
they are supposed to be racing drivers not taxi drivers
I'm a big kmag fan so im probably a bit biased on some things but I think kevin was extremely aggressive (and stupid) and didn't do well this weekend but penalties in my opinion are way too harsh this season and its ruining the race. F1 is not about racing anymore. Also the FIA seriously just hate him and treat him unfairly, compared to other drivers.
I wouldn’t trust the stewards to hand out sweet, let alone penalty points! The drivers are on the most part doing great with the equipment they’ve got and driving standards are really good these days. At the end of the day, it’s racing, and if anything the rules should encourage wheel to wheel action as much as possible, because that’s what fans want to see.
Just take points from the team if unsafe driving is happening.
Kmag did nothing wrong. Just the track itself is bad for overtaking and its way to easy to "block" any overtakeing.
More points from up to 12th place and smaller cars with better tracks. Then we can have better racing.
Mags races hard but not dirty. Him becoming as wide as he can to give his stablemate an advantage is legal be the letter of the law. He needn’t apologize for doing so.
As a Northern Irish man, Eddie Irvine was a fantastic team mate for Schummy... If you are a good team mate and make it work. Fair play
How many times do these guys simply give way because there aren't racing the faster car
"penalties" have been a problem for years now I doubt there's a solution
Just take points from the team if something like this happens it'll force the team to not allow this to happen.
Drive -Thru penalties!!
Kmag is one of the few making this season remotely entertaining
Watch how Perez, defended against Louis to help Max. That’s the way you do it.
I only have an issue when both cars are over the white line that's when it's gone too far and there needs to be penalties.
It is called racing...... only the media calling it dangerous driving....now, who gonna jump the gun to punishment against k-mac
That sound you just hear was KMag officially crossing the finish line
Come Kmag!! Rooting for you buddy
You fix this issue by changing the point system. Make it resemble MotoGP or supercross point awards and you will get people fighting for points all the way down. It’s dumb that only 10 drivers get points. It absolutely removes all incentive to keep racing hard if you can get 10th. Stop with punishment to adjust the behavior and give incentives.
No. F1 doesn’t need or want participation points
I don’t think it’s participation trophy points. They don’t want to hand out money at the end of the year. They keep paying out to the top teams. It can be fixed but no one wants to make the hard decisions. If you want to see racing make refueling available
Yes, let's reward the garbage teams in 17-20 for some pity and participation points.
Should they also get a star and pat on the head as well?
Yes, make each overtake worth something
Haha sounds like some leftest shit like kids sports now oh you all get a trophy points should stay to top 10 positions
but they wanted drivers to go for it more in the sprint race. I don"t like how dirty they did Sainz again in the main race, he and Piastri touchet both times but the diference is that he gave way and Piastri didn"t.
We saw some good racing for a change, and people want to stop that?
Racing is a competition, not a parade. Perez defended pretty wildly to in 2021 against Hamilton. It's a part of racing in a team. Sergeant on the other hand could have been more aware of his surroundings. Magnussen probably gave him too much credit, probably thinking sergeant would know he was there. I've seen that scenario play out many times without a crash. Sergeant should have been watching his mirrors when he knows he's in a battle.
Increasing the penalty wouldn’t do much. Multiple penalties should result in an immediate drive though.
Sportsmanship? F1? 🤣
If they used tracks you could pass on ‘ this would not happen.
Give them a stop and go penalty for causing a collision.
I don't understand if you get a time penalty you have to serve it immediately not when you chose ? As soon as you get one come in serve it .
Instead of time penalty, get a loop or bypass they have to drive wich takes 5-10 sec. Then they are away from the track and racers can pass
So if I understand this right, people don't want them to race. The hell happened to good old racing?
What's the point of driving for a "team" if you can't drive as a team player...
Although it wasn't good racing, he was within the rules in that he knew the consequences and accepted them as part of the team strategy.
Do I want to see rule changes to stop that? Yes I suppose. But I also would like to see a category where the are basically no rules, just build a car that is the fastest you can design and build and get around the track the fastest way possible.
That would be outrageously expensive for sure and likely you'd never get enough teams to enter but if you could get 20 cars, just think of how different the engineering could be?
The penalty system within F1 and does go adverse outcomes. The best one is the penalty for changing an engine goes down the more you use. Surely you should be penalised more for each engine.
WTF did Magnussen do, that all the other drivers havent done previously ?????? Reckless drivning??????? Are you kidding me ??????
In the Sprint, cry baby Hamilton wasn't penalized for his spearheading into Alonso that took out Stroll and Norris, watch it frame by frame Hamilton is not turning into the apex but torpedo Alonso and that's not aggressive driving? Max and Kvyat are masters of this art, good thing Max is out front where he is no longer a menace.
How do you get to cry baby??
I think the shite he puts up with he might get vocal,he's not a bully like some out there and one time he does something out of character he's a cry baby it don't figure....
Hamilton literally said he loved racing hard like that, I don't see not a single cry baby here🤷
I am hughe fan off magnussen but i didnt like the defence when he goes out over lines the only penalty that will change ppl to not give back position is a drive thru that way will it not pay off not to give back position and defend that way
I think it was amazing to watch 😂. It was a little aggressive but I think overall that is what makes for good racing.
Why not give points to every car that are finishing the race? and these kind of tactics will disapare by it self and problem is
solved?
Good on you Kevin💪
It's a double edge sword..... you should be able to defend your position but you should not cause wrecks or make a unsafe situation in the moment
yeah but defending within limits. what he was doing wasn't defending
@@TheMrakic 35 minutes of penalties is wild
Great driving by Kev. That's what makes racing so exciting and that´s why I like to watch it. I thought F1 is dead, but Kev proved it's not. What a shame he got penalties for that, he made the race.
What did Lewis say about this after the race?? I think other drivers who are in the mix should have at least a voice.
hulkenberg has signed for audi so magnusson has nothing to fear from his current teammate, in terms of a new contract
Yes yes, the best part of the race needs to be penalised.. We wouldn't want hard racing, would we!? No, I say we penalise overtakes too!
All this lawyering by FIA is soooo annoying. Races should be decided on the track, this is the essence of the sport.
How about drive-through and 10-second stop go penalties come back. These times, pentlties are just stupid.
Just get the driver to do a Pitstop penalty he would looses track position
Taking seconds off is fine. Driver points should only be handed out for wreck less driving that causes accidents. Similar to Hamilton diving to the inside at turn one at Miami causing drivers to retire.
Drivers shouldn't be penalised for driving defensively. Collisions are different, and putting someone else in danger is also not on. But apart from that he shouldn't be punished for playing the team game. Otherwise, what's the point? Just wave everyone through? I didn't see anything particularly aggregious when he was dueling with Hamilton.
FIA institutes penalties for unsportsmanlike conduct.
Magnussen, "Fine, I'll take the penalties and drive how I want."
FIA, "Thats unsportsmanlike."
Magnussen, "Gimme another penalty then."
Any driver likely to be out of the points with both a teammate in the points and a faster car behind should be discouraged from driving like this. If not, it will have cascading effects on the sport. Also, it wasn't just Hamilton who was held up. Say, Max has an engine change and starts P15. Then every driver with a teammate in the points should drive like K-mag. This is bad for the sport.
Only sorry Mag did not get smarmy off the track Like smarmy has done to others
Let them race!!!
As long as he's defending within the rules, Only moving Once on straights etc, It's just hard racing. Lewis needs to stop crying everyone is against him every race.
I’m looking forward to next year so we can have whole season of races not being ruined by Magnussen. It’s not just Miami, his while career has been spent ruining the races of drivers who actually want to go fast. Every time it’s the same, as soon he pits the following ten cars are freed up to race. But by then the whole race has been turned into a bore-fest.
Every other driver tries to get ahead of the others, Magnussen tries to keep the others behind him. And he plays dirty to do it.
170 races for 1 podium … just shuffle off and close the door behind you.
Hamilton was "cool" with Magnussen's defence, however, I think if a driver is persistently performing illegal manoeuvres during the race, a drive-through penalty should be imposed to be taken on the next lap.
F1 is a teamsport, Its teamwork in my opinion...it happend before (recently Alonso-hamilton in Hungary for ocon win & Perez-Hamilton for the championship at Yas Marina.
Its like football, getting a yellow card to prevent a attack. You take it for the team. Sometimes you will get away with it but you also may risk a a red card.
i don't see a problem....
If the fia would have given Hamilton his 20 sec penalty, sooner, this was a verry simple penalty to give. Magnussen would have known and would not have defended this much
FIA is so unbalanced. This is an excuse to have more overtakes. Discouraging drivers to be more defensive for the sake of “viewership”.
5 sec Penalty for Magnussen💀
This isn’t an adapted driving style for kmag. He’s driven like this since 2017
I agree Kevin's style in general is quite aggressive, but he only did this to make sure Nico gets the points, and it really doesn't matter how many penalties Kevin gets because he's out of the race anyways.
Although, he does need to watch out with the total penalty points he has for a potential raceban hahaha
interesting that Magnussens driving is considered dangerous, yet Lewis took out three drivers at the start and it wasnt even looked at.
You know what the sprint race wasn't: Boring.
So. Yeah. I'll take that any day.
Talk about penalties? No. Let's reduce car width by 20cm, car length by at least 50cm, and put the cars on a 100kg diet.
It’s easy… drive under GBR flag and you won’t get any penalties. If you add more rules, you’ll have more issues governing them. You add some then you must remove other ones.
They are racing teams. Checo gets lauded and named the Minister of defense for ensuring Verstappen wins. Kmag gets dumped on for doing everything he can to give his teammate a chance at 1 point?
When the drivers support it, team principles should keep their mouths closed. Their thoughts about driving are irrelevant at best.
Maclaren is turning into the Macrybaby.
Drive thru penalties!!!!
What about Max
Or....if a driver received penalty points, in the next race if he commits ANY infraction its an IMMEDIATE BLACK FLAG!
kmag drives like nascar lol
Where's your critique of Hamilton or even Perez for damgerous driving?
Meanshile, Hamilton is allowed to end the race of multiple drivers in turn one, lap one, of the race without penalty.
Drive through penalties. Within 3 laps of an infringement. Simple. Effective. Gets the car out of the way for the guys behind.
after the race Lewis remarked that he enjoyed jousting with KMAG
The sport is being castrated in favor of the big teams
Until Hamilton ever gets a penalty,I don't want to hear about it!!!!
Fighting is one thing, making dangerous moves that can injured or kill someone is over the limit.
The problem is the back markers NEVER will catch up to Red Bull given the rules. Until F1 changes and allows cars to be DEVELOPED over the year in a meaningful way it is just a parade. Until there are at least 3 teams with a real chance of winning each race F1 will continue to be a joke. I have stopped watching and know many others who also have given up on F1 for other series.
Ban the others and go racing
Oh my god, he disobeyed the golden rule, which is, When Sir is behind let him through, when Sir behind is infront do Not overtake.
I am starting to agree with alonso: his uk passport protects him from repercussions from his lunatic torpedo start of the sprints... imagine if he were not f1 royalty....
*Hamilton's UK passport....if that wasnt clear 😅
I'd be jealous of a superior passport too if i was in alonso's shoes
That same behaviour was encouraged from Max when Lewis was winning every year. Now that he's going to Ferrari, they're shifting respect levels. These people and their rules are a joke!! F1 needs more competition. The product has become predictable & political beyond belief..
Black& white flag is specifically for this, used for unsportsmanlike behaviour. It seems they are using it for track limit infringements these days. There is also the three strike system they use that goes with it. It is possible that you could tactically use the three strikes in order to tactically advantage your own or someone else’s race or to tactically disadvantage an opponent. Perhaps this type of driving should be dealt with the same way as weaving.
Conclusion is that there is an obvious difference between genuinely running off the track or whatever and tactically doing something. These races are supervised by vastly experienced stewards. There is a system of penalties available at each event, time penalties, drive through penalties and stop/go penalties. Incidents are analysed during races and this type of thing should be dealt with. It’s the lack of intervention which caused this specific situation. Ironically from my point of view I am guilty of feeling that penalties are too readily and harshly given, let them race etc however in this instance it seems that intervention was necessary but didn’t happen.
Too many pak rules and penalties let them race already to many restrictions