Shot In Surrey: The Murder Of Maple Batalia
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 09. 2023
- Claim your SPECIAL OFFER for MagellanTV here:
try.magellantv.com/trulycriminal and start your ONE MONTH FREE TRIAL today, so you can watch all kinds of amazing documentaries, including 'How To Catch A Killer' and let us know what you thought!
www.magellantv.com/video/how-...
On the evening of September 27th, 2011 Maple Batalia headed to the campus library with a friend. They had a late night study session planned and met up with a few more people there as well.
As the hours ticked by into the next morning, Maple hugged her friends goodbye and walked to her car.
Just minutes after 1am, a resident heard 7 loud bangs in quick succession. Maple was lying on the ground, having been shot several times. The race was now on to find her killer.
Our email is for business enquiries only.
linktr.ee/trulycriminal1
Sources 📝
pastebin.com/3NfaSMzz
Patreon 🖤
/ trulycriminal1
Buy Me A Coffee ☕️
www.buymeacoffee.com/trulycri...
Thank you to Jupiter Productions for making all of our original music 🎵
open.spotify.com/artist/2rLqq...
/ jupiter-productions
Further Resources ⬇️
Women's Aid UK: www.womensaid.org.uk
National Domestic Abuse Hotline (UK): www.nationaldahelpline.org.uk/
Refuge (UK): www.refuge.org.uk/
Men's Advice Line (UK): mensadviceline.org.uk
Everyman Project (UK): www.everymanproject.co.uk/
National Coalition Against Domestic Violence (USA): ncadv.org
RizeUp (Australia): www.rizeup.com.au
www.thehotline.org/stakeholde...
Ending Violence Association Of Canada (Canada): endingviolencecanada.org/gett...
www.casw-acts.ca/en/resources...
United Nations Domestic Abuse Resources: www.un.org/en/coronavirus/wha...
www.thehotline.org
www.mankind.org.uk
www.refuge.org.uk/get-help-no...
mensadviceline.org.uk
www.citizensadvice.org.uk/fam...
www.mensaid.co.uk - Zábava
Guys, if your mate wants you to follow his ex- girlfriend or any woman tell him no. Tell him he is a stalker and then if he doesn’t stop, report him to the police. Men have to hold other men accountable.
Lol. Dating is evil, and it magnifies evil emotions. That's why the Lord Most High prescribed marriage. If they hadn't had a fornicative relationship, she might still be alive rather than having tried in vain to escape the fallout of a cursed union. She saw his colored eyes and mistook a devil for an angel.
😂😂😂
@@shahidabdoullakhanzorovr1564🤢🤭
@@shahidabdoullakhanzorovr1564I m quite sure those r lenses
Nice!!!
The fact that he CHEATED on her and then proceeded to kill her because she was moving on from the breakup... like WTF dude, such a waste of life.. Rest in Peace Maple
It's very very very common that the possessive ones are also cheaters themselves. It's like they project their own low morals onto their partner/ex-partner. Cheating is so easy to them that they can't understand other people aren't like that, so they become posessive and controlling while also cheating themselves. I know they had broken up, but probably not in his twisted mind.
Agreed 💯😔
I'm so sick of these guys that can't get over a breakup and resort to stalking... especially when they're the one who caused the breakup due to infidelity.
They are malignant narcissists. The theory goes that they break up with you not the other way around.
@@NordicaTundra absolutely right
Women stalk as well. Just say "people" , not Men
@@NordicaTundra ...and yet I bet you still sleep with them am I right?
@@professionaltrollgirl2682this. Women stalk just as much as men.
He screws around on her, then she drops him like a bad habit, and his little ego couldn't handle it. I hope he gets the arrogance beat out of him on a daily basis in prison!
Yessss!!!!!💯
There was a similar case in the US I think. The guy dumps the girl or cheats on her and when the ex girlfriend is able to move on and seems to be doing well in life the trash gets angry and kills her .
I really hope so. 🤬
Well that's not a very nice thing to say.
@@adambane1719 It wasn't a very nice thing to murder his ex-girlfriend either.
I'm confused. Why doesn't "life in prison" mean you die in prison? A murder like this, there should be NO parole.
ABSOLUTELY ! … AGREED
it's canada. he will be out in 7 yrs
You're right, It's sad. But in many countries 25 years is "Life Sentence"...Justice System suck. It's only fewer countries like China & Lesotho that are very serious when it comes to Justice...but the rest are jokes.
In USA , Life in Prison means Life in Prison. In USA , this type of cat would have received 100 Years in Prison . Meaning thie convict would live in Jail until he died of Old age.
@@user-zh9st7dl4hincorrect. Life with the possibility of parole is regularly given as a sentence in the US
That horrible narcissist , should never be released from prison .
The pain in her mums voice when she was being interviewed broke me. May God watch over Maple’s family and friends.
Came here to say that exact thing. My God. Heartbreaking.
The father too, poor man couldn't get out a word. May God give them strength 😢
Why will God watch now when he didn't in the first place and let Maple get shot?
God Bless you for your beautiful comment.
Well she raised a 304, and got what she deserved.
Maple's sister was so strong, loyal, steadfast, and well-spoken. It occurs to me that she is every bit the "precious jewel" in that family as her sister was, and that both of them were blessings to their family....
Yes I felt that way too when dad spoke of maple it almost sounded like they only had one daughter 😢 sad .. I’m sure he did not mean it the way it sounded it was his grief speaking … but hopefully her sister did not feel less than because of his words
@@amg8497 Yes I agreed 😥
Agreed. As one of four sisters, I felt that for her.
@@mercury_risingyes, I’m sure her parents were simply grieving and not thinking, but my parents described both of my sisters in this way and not me. It really hurts. I wish the best for the sister :(
Yes I picked up on this too. Brilliant observation
The mom breaking down was so brutal to hear. Her pain is like a gut punch. Maple could've brought so much more love, joy, and kindness to this world yet once again, we are stuck with those 2 worthless, pathetic monsters here on earth. Unbelievably devastating.
What's really disgusting is how many women get killed by a stalker, especially here in America. There is such a predictable pattern, yet police seem powerless until a woman is actually murdered. Screw Civil Rights !!! Cops need to be somehow able to intervene very early in the stalking script. Maybe a 30 day "vacation" in a mental hospital for the stalker could save a woman's life and his life too.
@@joekulik999 Here also in India stalking is bad and the jilter male lover throws acid on her to disfigure her for life :((((
@@georgievarghese3715 How can a man say that he EVER Loved a woman after he throws acid into her face ??? It is obvious to me that he never really loved her in the first place. Throwing acid onto someone's face is, in some ways, even worse than murder.
This is a problem every where
@@HI-rx5jn ohh ok.
As a Canadian, I am constantly disgusted and incredulous at the leniency of our justice system, and the message it sends.
Yes, this murder was all planned out. He thought it was appropriate reaction to getting dumped He's not going to be okay to live in society in 20 years.
I feel the same about ours in the USA
Canada, UK and Australia do not give violent offenders the sentences they deserve.
@Dana-ue9ss You are absolutely right in my opinion. I'm Australian and it's getting ridiculous. We need capital punishment.
It blows my mind, as an American! We have some ridiculous outcomes, too. But I can assume if a person murders someone (especially a child) and the show says they're in Canada that they will get less than 10 years. How!? How!? How are moms brutally murdering and abusing their children and getting 5 years or less!? Im so flabbergasted!
One thing I love about this channel is that the videos are named after the victims, not the killers. They're the ones that need to be remembered.
South Asian men seem to think this an appropriate response to being dumped. I live in Surrey see this all the time in this community.
Brought up by parents who should set better examples for them. This is a cultural issue for Indian men in the Indian community. Ask their wives!
@@davidjma7226 not all south asian, this is a punjabi community, they are hotheaded brutes and they are trained to be so by their families, hope you guys know that india or south asian is very diverse not all communities here have such violent responses. Rest of indian communities care more about studies than these things.
All men
It's a gender issue. Not an ethnicity one. Every community has men who do this.
@@shakiMiki While yes, this happens in every community, it is especially prevalent in South Asian, Middle Eastern and North African males. India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan are at the top when it comes to honor based killings, although only India has imposed laws and heavy punishments against both the perpetrators and colluders after much backlash in the past. In Pakistan and Afghanistan, many of these cases go unpunished.
More than 2,000 calls to her?! Absolutely intense and deranged!
19:22 22 months?! And he got released early?! The man know what happened and said nothing. He should be getting at least 10 years.
What a tragic story. I was saddened by the entire story, but also felt for Maples sister when her father said he has nothing left to live for, you still have another beautiful daughter who I’m sure is as special as her sister was, obviously his comment was out of pain. God bless them all and I hope that they can find some kind of healing
Yeah I was taken aback by it but I cannot be mad at him cause only he knows how broken he is after this lost. I know of ppl who goes into depression and isolation after losing a child and have others to live for. My heart breaks for the family though!!
Yeah that was unkind...
I am sure he didn't meant it that way.... he is heart breaken
@@camillesingh8503 I’m sure he didn’t but I know how I would feel if one of my parents said something like that. Always be grateful how what you have and what you have lost
I actually had this exact thought when he said this
5 years is too long for justice. Then the accomplice gets such a pitiful sentence?! What sort of message does that send?? The fact that Gary cheated on her then killed her for leaving him makes my blood boil. He viewed her as his property. The friends of his that helped stalk her are also huge pieces of crap.
Her mother's pain is palpable. Rest in Power, Maple.
Huge thanks to CL for always making sure the victim is so tenderly remembered 🖤
This is quite common in the Asian community
The men treat their women like properties
He got a life sentence.
@@eadweard. The guy that helped him escape was released after just 18 months how is that fair?
@@wessionaldo6853 The OP has been edited since I made my comment.
@@eadweard. I wonder what he said before
2 years to catch an obvious killer, 5 years to convict him. Canadian justice is awesome.
I went to school with her. I didn't know her all that well, but i remember her being super nice and well liked by everyone. It's so sad that this happened to her..
So creepy coments don't say anything 😊😊😊
Thank you for sharing your story about her
Why do folk persist in calling these vile perpetrators "dogs"...? It's an insult to canines! Dogs are beautiful, trusting creatures who CARE for humans. No comparison! These are MONSTERS...& nothing less. Thank you as always for excellent videos.🎉❤
Malignant narcissists.
Very dangerous individuals.
You aint nuthin but a female dog whining all the time
Yeah, I was kinda shocked when the murderer was called a dog. Dogs are loyal creatures and that killer wasn't worthy of cleaning up after a dog.
Completely agree. I also really don’t like it when people do that.
No kidding. Even a wild dog behaves more reasonably than people like this.
Thank you. I was one of many investigators who worked this case. Very well done documentary that captures the main points of the investigation, but more importantly the tragedy that it is and how it affected an entire community, if not an entire Province. One of the cases that will stay with me.
😢😢💔💔
My deepest condolences to all affected. RIP Maple...
Much thanks to all who helped to bring the 2 perpetrators to justice.
I dont understand how these animals get such short sentences.!!! Why? And then they let the one guy out early??? What a slap in the face to the victim and her family. RIP Maple.
That’s Canada for ya
The actual killer got a very long sentence for Canada. He got what a multiple murderer would have gotten. Now that's shameful. He will be released in his 40s.
He got a life sentence.
@@annabellelee4535In his 40s? How did you arrive at that conclusion? He got a life sentence.
What is short about a life sentence?
18 months is pathetic. That guy facilitated the murder and then remained an accessory after the fact. Disgusting.
Maple was a beautiful young lady! Such a tragedy. All because of one man's jealousy and inability to let go!
RIP: MAPLE 😢😢
Coward ! 🖕this one’s for you Gare ! ……… RIP Maple … rest well
As a relative of maple n family I find this to be a touching documentary of her life, she was loved n still is beyond what words can describe. She still stands today in the faces of the suspects showing them her n the family is stronger then them they rot away in a cell I can only hope it’s deep enough the rats bite at there fingers at night RIP maple ❤
I'm sorry it took so long for justice to be served to your family. May her memory always fill you with happy thoughts and her legacy live on. The scholarship is a beautiful way her light endures. Prayers for you and your family 🙏🏽 🕯
Condolences to the family and all connected... may time soften the paon😢🎉🎉🎉
I'm so sick and tired of these insignificant, petty little "men" taking the lives of beautiful, vibrant women simply because the woman doesn't want to be with them. I'm watching this with my 8yo son and using it as another learning opportunity so that he doesn't grow into one of these horrible men. My boys will be kind, caring, and respectful!
good for you! parents have to teach their sons how to be decent human beings to their opposed gender.
You should do the same if you ever have a daughter
@@Acapella_city341 I have a daughter and I definitely do 😊
good policy
Too young to watch this kind of true crime, that’s not good
The kind of entitlement that justifies killing someone because they can just shocks me so.
No, the audacity to kill them because they don't want you, it's somehow worse and infuriating than sb losing it.
A full blown narcissicist and weakling.
Hallmarks of narcissistic personality disorder. Also perhaps sociopathy
DON'T date thugs...it always end in disaster.
Damn I ain’t gonna lie, I’ve watched millions of true crime episodes on all types of CZcams channels & stuff. I’ve never felt the pain of someone who lost their kid like I just did with the Mom. You can feel her pain thru the screen 😔 I truly hope that God confines to watch over her & help her receive better days ❤️
Agreed. This case made me cry. I’m still in tears as I type this message. Touched my heart string!
For real tho, cz I've also watched countless true crime videos and never before have I felt someone's pain like I did in this video
🙏❤️I feel the same…🙏Blessings to her family and friends 🌷
I feel very sorry for Maple's sister when the father says he has nothing .
He still has another daughter ... she is not nothing .
indeed
Lol, neither of his daughters look like they're his, so maybe he has a point
The loss of a child is devastating. He was obviously in an emotional state.
I would hope the other siblings simply understand that their parents are going through an EXTREMELY painful and traumatic event, and are only speaking from feeling. Let's not try to find nitpicks when these people literally just lost a child... That loss can DESTROY people, whether they have other children or not. It's an entirely unique type of grief and they should be free to express that grief without anyone taking it personally ffs.
@@AB-se3meIf you're here to represent the dog-Gary, you're indeed making a fine job of it. Carry on barking up the wrong tree.
He had the most stunning, intelligent, creative partner imaginable and he cheated on her and yet he is angry at her for moving on. Nothing justifies his actions, I'm not remotely suggesting that, but he didn't even appreciate her when she was his girlfriend.
There was a girl called Alice Ruggles in the UK and her ex stalked and killed her and again it was he that cheated on her.
So these cases are purely about control and ego.
I know this isn't the most important point but I think the justice system needs to see this isn't about a broken heart or any other mitigation it is just a shitty controlling a-hole who will always be a danger to women.
Very very sad, but wow, I really hope that her sister is ok and getting the love and support that she needs.
I understand that her father is grieving, but he has another living daughter that still needs him. His statement at the end here must have shattered his daughter and....yeah, I just hope that she’s doing ok. One day at a time.❤
I feel extremely sad for her sister. She deserves to feel like she matters to her family too. Her dad said he is left with nothing, sorry but that’s a terrible thing to say when you have another living child. It’s clear they had favourites.
@@chanellover2143 yeah, that’s exactly what I was thinking.
I imaged the sister hearing him saying those words and going -
What about ME? I’m still alive dad! I’m right here 😳
Just incredibly sad.
it easy to say so but v won't understand what the father hold for both daughters n he is in grief so no need to judge what he said❤
I fully agree. A rough thing to say about the daughter he lost and the daughter he still has as though the existing daughter matters not at all. Made me sadder than sad. She too loved her sister and she matters too. It's still the three of them and that statement had to hurt her deeply. Maybe it's their culture but show the sister who is still living here some love and support parents. You two are still loving parents and you didn't lose all your girls. 😢
I hope her dad will realize that his life is not useless, & that they'll be able to heal as a family, & find peace & joy in their lives again.
I'm so saddened by this, I love how they called her Maple surely as a homage to their adopted country, I felt really sorry for her sister when their father said they'd lost "everything"..that must hurt 😞
Yes that was a very mean thing for the father to say!
As a Canadian, I thought the same thing! I wish I could give them all big, long hugs. You can feel the pain they have and it breaks my heart
I’m from B.C. and know this story well but will still watch your take as I love your content. RIP Maple, she had so much potential this was so sad
I live a cpl cities over from here this was horrific case. Bless this poor woman and her family
BC here too ! .. The Okanagan .. and yes have heard the story but agreed I like the content here …
She definitely was gorgeous and most importantly didn't deserve to die at least not like that . ( I say least because we gotta die someday)❤
@@Titus213-xc7pi no she didn't. It sickens me to the core that someone knew their son was a controlling and abusive person and no one did a thing! As a mom to a son . U know ur kids and personality traits like this don't appear overnight. He had to have been showing signs most of his life that he was not a decent human being...and his behaviour and her cries for help both went ignored! 😓🤬
@@jewels964 so true also ur profile 📸 gorgeous may I add 😁
A bit sad to hear the parents lament that their whole life had been destroyed and their lives mean nothing...whilst they still have another daughter. She too lost a sister, and I can't help but feel har parent's words must make her feel like she doesn't mean anything to them...
Yes!!! I felt exactly this. I feel that maple was the favourite, and I’m sure the sister knew, but to hear those words so publicly hurt even my feelings , I can’t imagine how the sister feels
Nah, she was a 304, so they don't miss her.
Yes that was a particularly unkind thing for the father to say!!!
Wow. This case is...devastating. And so infuriating!
Shocking how she was still alive after the brutal attack 😪
It's pretty common to survive (albeit briefly) after being shot.
@@eadweard. she was stabbed in the head multiple times with a kitchen knife .....
This is such a terrible and sad story. I also feel so bad for the sister that is left behind. It must be very painful for her to hear that her parents’ lives aren’t worth anything now they have lost Maple and yet she is still there. May Maple rest in peace
So true. I felt pained on her part. The father sounded insensitive.
My god she was beautiful. In addition to beauty she had brains.
This is so sad and those sentences aren’t sufficient. I hope her family attend every single parole hearing to ensure that monster never ever sees the outside again. My heart goes out to the Betalia’s. 🕊️
What kind of coward could do this to such a young, delicate, and beautiful young woman? And so violently. Sickening.
Her mother's pain broke my heart..
The story is tragic, the "men" vile & punishments were late & lenient. But your coverage of Maple's too short life was lovely. She touched so many lives & her family is making sure that number grows. Thanks, Alice & Mia.
Ideologues in the justice system here care more about the feelings of scumbags. So empathetic and brave of them.
Who’s Alice n Mia wtf?
if this had been in asia, he would have been garlanded by local politicians and get out of prison within days
Justice has not been served in this case, Rest in peace.Maple .
The people who loved Maple endured, waited is not strong enough of a word for what they did. They endured suffering the loss of Maple who they all loved dearly & no longer had her in their lives for 5 long years in hopes that finally justice would be inevitably served to the ones responsible for taking her away from them. What those poor, hopeful, mourning souls received was nothing short of another crime committed against them & Maple's memory on behalf of the legal system.
Heartbreaking beyond words. Another narcissist who thought he had the right to end a beautiful life. I hope he rots in prison.
Another case of "if I cannot have her, nobody else will have her" and yet the real life sentence in this as in so many murder cases in Canada, the dear victim's family have the REAL Life Sentence.
RIP Maple, you deserved better justice.
Such an extremely sad case. Thank you for presenting and narrating it so well. RIP Maple. Greetings from South Africa 🇿🇦
Hope that a-hole never gets out on parole, and his accomplice got off way too lightly!!!
Anyhow, I usually love to go through the comments but am in a bit of a rush cuz I have plans today... yay!
Enjoy the rest of your weekend, ladies, and thanks again for another stellar production.
How tragic for this young woman, with so much potential. Hope her family has healed and has found peace.
So stupid to think they can get away with such a murder in a place with so much surveillance.
their mostly get away it take victim family 5 years to get justice. Canada law is shitty
Her poor sweet Mom.... She had me crying. I see a lot of stories like this, and this girl tried to get out of the relationship and was still killed. This is so god damn sickening already!!! I love when people say leave that man or woman who is controlling you. But look, she tried and this pile of trash still killed her
She left the relationship. She was stalked and killed but this is not about staying in a controlling relationship because someone feels it's safer than leaving. You're guaranteed to die if you stay, there's a chance of being killed if you leave and if your ex knows your movements and routines, there's no safety plan in place etc. What are people supposed to say "stay in a controlling relationship?
This narrator has the perfect voice and demeanor for these type of stories. Well done.🎉
Hearing her dad call her his most precious jewel, is just soul destroying. I can imagine her murder has left this family in tatters. I didnt know her but I cried because she was so young and beautiful, so to be taken from this world before she was to fulfil her destiny of success is truly heartbreaking. Rest in peace beautiful angel
I have studied and work at a university here in BC. Due to these events that happened to Maple our university tightened up already strict rules for abuse/stalking/harassment/etc.. It’s too bad that some men (which is already to many) go down the path of violence instead of being an adult about a breakup.
A great video as always.
I’ve watched a lot of true crime videos , on this channel & on others. It’s so sad how many cases there are like this, boyfriends stalking & harassing their exes just because they can’t handle a breakup. And the sad thing is the majority of the girls contacted the police but the police don’t do anything about it, and then the girl ends up getting killed. R.I.P. Maple
Men and Women both become dangerous
you know males make up 48% of family domestic violence homicide victims right?
well now you do - this was never a gender issue
This was so close to being my fate, at the same age, too. I tried to break-up with a guy I had dated for about 3 years and he lost it. He followed me to my university, waited for me to leave and forced me in his car, only to show me the gun between the drivers seat and the console. He told me that I would not be breaking up with him and I would be continuing our relationship as normal, which was full of physical and mental abuse. I was young, didn’t know what to do at that point except play along for the time being. When I felt there was a little time and space between us, I told my dad and he confronted my ex. Surprisingly, he was very scared of my dad and distanced himself for a while. We also called the police and told them that ex was stalking me, though I didn’t tell my parents or the police about the gun and the threats on my life. They spoke to him and it also scared him more than I thought it would. During this time, I took what was my last call from him after he called my home dozens and dozens of times. He told me he was going to turn the gun on himself instead and that he was calling me to say goodbye. I called his brother and he and his wife rushed to my ex and found him with the gun loaded and a suicide note written. They talked him out of hurting himself (his uncle had shot himself in the head and killed himself just a couple years prior so it was taken very seriously) and he went on to have several relationships, none of them lasting very long to my knowledge. I don’t know why or how I made it out of that situation. I still worry he’ll have his revenge on me some day. I live a couple thousand kilometres away now and I’m not on Facebook or anything like that because I don’t want him knowing anything about me. I feel lucky everytime I think of that time. I wish Maple had a chance to get away. We need to do more to prevent this situation. Too many girls and women are killed by their partners around the world just for being female and not interested in continuing an abusive relationship. RIP Maple.
Maple's mom's words are unbelievably heartbreaking
As a Canadian, I have never heard of this case. Thank you for sharing it in such an in-depth and respectful way. You have done Maple and her family justice in telling her tragedy. My heart weeps for her family and friends. She was such a beautiful woman inside and out. And incredibly caring and intelligent to boot! You can tell she adored her fur baby. Thank you for sharing the resources to those who maybe in situation they feel like they can't get out of. There is help and HOPE!
Who raises these pathetic, insecure man boys? Are the mothers of these monsters responsible by telling them that they are basically gods in their eyes? I’m sick of seeing these same stories of innocent women being killed because these vile human pieces of shite can’t deal with losing control over a woman…and this pathetic monster had cheated on this lovely young lady and still had the audacity to think she still belonged to him. My sincere condolences to this broken family, RIP Maple. 🦋🌻❤️ #BeBetterParents #RaiseBetterMen
Same goes for his friends that agreed to follow her for him. That is also absolutely vile!
💯% agree with what you said, he's a disgusting piece of garbage! May he rot in prison!
Quit watching true crime if you're sick of seeing it.
This had gone on since the beginning of time. Some is learned behavior some are born that way. Either way, these animals need to be removed from society forever. No second chances.
Indian mothers do treat their sons like Gods… men then marry and expect their wives to treat them hurt like Mammy did - men can do no wrong in mammys eyes!!!
Oh God hearing her mom in that interview you can hear just how she wants to scream out crying. It made me get a lump in my throat. Poor family.
Teach your sons to accept rejection and move on, and that they don't own women
I think the whole "Teach people not to be bad" thing has been tried.
@@eadweard. We have to keep trying
@@Thando_Khumalo Everyone who cares doesn't need teaching - and anyone who needs teaching won't care.
Females should be taught this more. It’s statistically proven they act more crazy after breakups
@@UnRaT3Dx Do females murder the people that reject them? Statistically lets talk about gender based violence
A nice Saturday evening with an upload from this amazing creator. ☺️
"... stomping on a flower before it blooms."
You can see what a vibrant light this beautiful young woman was. ❤
“Your DOG killed my daughter” . Yes momma! Though the more appropriate term is Demon!
Son?
Maple's mom meant to say her daughter I'm sure
@@glow1815 Her Mother DID say Daughter, the OP said Son.
@@glow1815 edited. I was carried away when I typed that. Yep definitely daughter
Such a beautiful young soul lost her life senselessly. I pray for her family that they can somehow find 🕊️ peace
Imagine killing your girlfriend because YOU cheated on her and because of that broke up with you. Absolute madness that.
How did the friend get away with this?? He was much more than an accessory! This is sickening
Maple’s dad’s statement that basically, Maple was the only light in his life, etc. So much for his wife and remaining daughter…
I am sure the wife and daughter understood his meaning.
I'm sure they didn't
Right ! And to think he would put. God 1st above all else wouldn't have life if it wasn't for God wouldn't have anything to be honest 🙏
That's how Indians think
This channel is the best. I always look forward to a new release. The narrative is always easy to listen to. So many monsters are masquerading as normal human beings. RIP Maple, may the Angels give you wings to fly.
Best true crime content right here! My favorite channel ❤
Embarrassed to be Canadian with that light sentence. No backbone in this country.
He got a life sentence.
Not only in Canada, but all over the world...Justice systems are useless.
@@eadweard. way too light
@@dynotee8757 No other sentence was available.
@@eadweard. I know but they should bring back capital punishment instead of pretending to be a human rights based country.
Heart breaking for Maples family 😢 what a beautiful young lady ❤ so sad x
Weird. Coffeehouse Crime just this week, covered a very similar case involving two, young Indian immigrants in Australia. Ugh.
Yeah, I noticed the correlation, also. It's so heartbreaking that no matter what culture, there's always entitled pieces of shit that think they can treat their partners/exes like property. Makes me sick.
This channel is excellent. Your voice is great, precise and clear. Thank you for the research and compassion you put into each one.
omg i remember her on diary of a whimpy kid. i had no clue she died. so tragic…rest easy ❤️
Yeah! He looked at her as a possession. My father got me straight with that as a boy.
Good heavens, she was absolutely beautiful. What a horrible horrible waste, she must have been the most amazing girl. Her poor family, I just hope they will be ok somehow, they loved Maple so so much and you can see that they are broken without her.
You lock both them up for life. Absolutely mind boggling how this dude gets out early
LOL no parole before 21 years, I hope the judges and politicians who enact these laws have to go through the same pain and agony as this family has. He'll be 47, 48 and may have the opportunity to get out and start a new life, I love canada but this makes no sense.
I thought this case happened in America at first as I missed parts of it and heard American sounding accents but when I heard the appalling leniency of the sentences I knew it was in Canada. Disgraceful 'justice' system.
Was shocked when her father said he had nothing to live for 😢? He has a beautiful wife and also an older daughter for support
Not a good thing to say unfortunately.
It’s grief from losing a child
Oh my goodness, her poor mother is still in a lot of pain. 😰 So tragic, Maple was just starting out, was so young and beautiful! The goodness just oozed out of her. Bless her whole family, and her mama. May she rest in peace.
Maple’s mothers pain is so visceral that it’s extremely hard to watch. I’m sobbing with her. My peace enter her soul and soothe her heart!!! I’m so very sorry for her family and loved ones.
Don't insult dogs. They're far more loving than humans.
The end had me sobbing. What a beautiful, talented girl, a blossom, and a weakling of a man cannot handle being left. Is she going to walk out of her grave when he gets paroled/released? What will happen to the next woman who rejects him...? May the poor relatives find peace.
Do you think he'll be released?
I lived in Surrey BC for years. This is so terrible 😢
Not sure whu these girls feel compelled to date at such a young age, especially a girl like this who has a full course schedule and acting gigs on the side. I worked full time in grad school and was always too exhausted to date.
Wtf. Stupid Gary. He’s the one that cheated on her, was insecure and a loser and yet he had the audacity to get jealous of her when she tried to move on with her life? The other guy should’ve gotten a longer sentence. He tried to help Gary get away with murder. For me, that’s literally murdering her too. He knew what Gary was going to do. These stupid bastards. Much love to the beautiful Batalia family.
Hope this guys friends who assisted him in keeping track of her were also charged. It scares me that people would assist him and not speak up and confront his behavior.
he has since been released having served only 18 months of a 22 month sentence. Like what the heck? That is barely more than the time for a misdemeanor here in the states.
I always feel intrigued by your amazing crime investigation series. 😊 Rest in peace, Maple. 😢
My heart breaks for this family!!! Sending prayers
Thank you so much for yet another wonderful video! ❤
Yay for another video & congrats on the sponsor, ladies!! Hope you two are doing well, as well as the rest of the viewers!!
I knew Batalia family personally they were my customers and very down to earth good people sadly Maple was taken away by this monster who is still alive makes me sick
Such a beautiful girl 😢
16:39 That poor woman. It hurts to see the clear anguish and desperation in her voice. Im so sick of selfish, narcissistic, immature, moronic people.
Love these so much and I love the narration
Thanks for the video.. I feel like I've not had enough since you had a week or 2 where you didn't upload any lol so thanks it is highly appreciated ❤
Lol, I was so very sad for 2 weeks then me thinking, 'are they at CrimeCon?? In the states??' For me, only explanation lol
God bless the family, especially Rosie/Roseleen, Maple's sister, who is a strong, brave and beautiful daughter that any father would be proud of. She is certainly well worth living for. R.I.P sweet Maple x
As always, incredible content done so professionally and with such care for the victims and their families. Thanks again for sharing such amazing work with us.
He seriously thought he could cheat on her and she'd just get over it?! Wwoooowwwsa. How dellusional and self centered.
So sad! RIP Maple!❤ I love your videos and could listen to you nonstop just for your voice ✌️
She was so beautiful and her name is unique. So sad.
I know people in grief often speak in absolute and exaggerated terms, but can you imagine being the other daughter and hearing your parents saying "Now I have nothing... everything is gone" ... that would be hurtful and hard to hear.