Good show. For anyone interested in the RMW gardener, have a look at the Gammon. Same last and build, but the Vesta leather is much more scratch resistant than the greasy Kip.
One of the great mysteries of life in my opinion is why anyone thinks a white wedge sole is a good idea, I simply hate them. I have a pair of Dievier Nomads with the black sole which should be considered on any list of comfortable moc toe boots. I heard a rumor that Redwing is going to introduce additional colors with black soles in addition to the green ones. Rant over, nice review
My comfy boot list (random order)... Allen Edmonds 1757 last Higgins Mill in CXL and Patton in kudu; Grant Stone Edwards in suede; Parkhurst old 18 last fully lined Delaware in kudu; Caswell Lisbon in CXL.
Yes higgins mills and the patton in kudu are very comfortable. I'd say the Frye philips leather sole is up there for me also. Parkhurst fits well but its not next level like the Frye Philips or Higgin Mills.
As far as comfort id put my leather soled boots ahead of my wedge soles, second with the Eugene sole from Truman and Commando soles last. Rough out and suede gets first place for comfort from me for uppers.
Excellent information! Saving for Viberg's Service Boot. Scary spending that much money without an in-person fitting at the source then ending up with a bad fit.
Whites MPs are super comfortable. I have them in black waxed flesh with a Dainite sole. I have a few other boots that are very comfortable (notably the Allen Edmonds Higgins Mill and a Truman 55 last boot in Rio Latigo leather) but my Whites are by far my most comfortable
Thank you for another informative video! While my boot modest boot collection doesn't include high dollar brands, my comfort boots are very similar to your selections. Thursday's moc toe Diplomat & Grant Stones's Brass are foot favs here. Chelseas in chromexcel are easy wearing & my leather soled, veg tanned Diesel maybe stiff, but still comfy too I'll add that in general all of my boots - whether service, moc toe, chelsea, combat, hiking and even western styles are more supportive & comfy than regular low-cut shoes. Heck, except for summer days in river sandals or sneakers - I never wear regular shoes anymore! Cheers
I have the pair of Grant Stone Ottawa’s in 9.5 EEE Black CXL and it is an amazingly comfortable boot and very stylish. It’s weird feeling the extra length in the toe without my feet slipping forward. The Leo last cups my heel, ankles, and ball of my feet perfectly while allowing plenty of room for the toes. I guess that is what a combination last like their Leo or even Alden’s Truebalance last feel like.
@drzaius844 they are absolutely amazing! Waxed flesh was already one of my favorite leathers and the mp last is very comfortable. Compared to my other service style boots I would say they're probably the most well put together in design, shape and actual build quality and durability. For reference since ordering my mp's I wore my IRs for about 1mil steps, my GS diesels for roughly 500k and my Truman's for about 700k steps. With the mp's at around 500k steps aswell.
Great round up. One day I'll buck up and get myself a pair of white's MPs, I'm currently a bit of a Nick's boots fanboy and waiting on my 3rd pair to be delivered.
I'd be interested in the most comfortable boots regardless of price, sounds like the Indonesian boots were close to bespoke? Unfortunately my RM Williams gardners boots are one of the most uncomfortable when worn on hard surfaces, not bad when walking in paddocks or turf surfaces and they fit properly.
Thank you so much for your well-informed, entertaining videos! I really appreciate your input on the RMW Gardeners, as I'm headed to Oz in a few weeks and will pick up a pair in Cairns. For US buyers looking for RMW boots or other Aussie brands, consider some of the online vendors in Oz. You'll benefit from (often) more competitive prices than those shown on RMW's or others own websites less the GST.
And as a tourist to Australia you can get a refund of GST when you leave. It’s called the Tourist Refund Scheme. That makes an AUD 649 boot cost AUD 590
@@Bootlosophy Yes, very good point. Here's a helpful tip I was recently given about the TRS. Claims may be made for purchases that exceed AUD 300 from the same vendor for goods removed from AU. So, even if you made two purchases for AUD 150 each, as long as the combined total exceeds AUD 300, the 10% GST can be rebated. Next, the goods purchased have to be shown, along with the invoices pertaining to them, to the ABF before boarding a flight or ship. This used to be a real pain, as there's a limit to what can be carried on board, but now it's possible to visit ABF to make one's claim, show them what was purchased, and then put the goods into bags that'll be checked through to your final destination. This is available in Sydney, Brisbane and other cities. You may need to check and extra bag, but at least you can get it on board vs. carry-on limits. Finally, there's an iOS app available that allows invoices, etc. to be summarized in advance of visiting ABF. Instead of filling out a claim at the airport, the app summarizes your invoices and lets ABF scan the QR code in the app for the details. Goods still have to be presented, but the app expedites the process. Be advised that depending upon one's destination, e.g., LAX, there may be long lines at the ABF office, so plan ahead, arrive early and take an extra bag if you plan to check your goods after visiting the ABF.
One more thing - the TRS doesn't cover purchases for hotels, drinks, food, etc consumed within Australia. They have to be removed from Oz to be eligible.
Thank you for sharing your experience with us ! I am also looking for most comfortable boots. How would you rank them from most comfortable to least comfortable ?
I'd love to get my paws on those Strider boots, but I'm not so sure about having to text them to order? 🤔 Also I wonder if they'd do a version without speed hooks. That'd be awesome.
Another great video. I've learned a lot watching your videos. I do wonder, do you own or have you tried any moccasin constructed boots? I would think something from Rancourt or Russell Moccasin would rate well in comfort. I also think they might be a best of both worlds, offering immediate comfort like Thursdays as well as lasting comfort like Whites.
Nice reviews! Quick question, thoughts on the Grant Stone Brass Boot Wedge Sole in terms of comfort and break-in vice those mentioned? Keep up the great work!
I don't have a pair of Brass in the wedge sole but the (same) one on the Field Boot is squishy and easy to break in. Softer than RW 875 but a little less than Thorogood's.
Hi, Next year I'll be taking a trip to Italy. I'll be walking around through museums, streets, etc. all day long for a couple weeks. I really don't want to wear tennis shoes. I'd rather wear boots. My Clinch boots are quite comfortable for daily wear, but I do not think they will be comfortable enough for walking around all day long on hard surfaces. Do you think the boots in this video will suffice? Any recommendations on boots maybe you don't have? Thanks
@@tipsy6269 I think that may depend on the boot, I have Dainite on some boots with thin cork and midsole layers and that can be hard in shock absorption.
I really enjoy your content, it’s very informative for a newbie to the boot world like me. I did have a question for you; As a fellow Aussie I am having some trouble locating where to purchase Venetian shoe cream here in Australia. Where do you purchase this product from?
Great channel and videos! One question: how do you manage to get all those niche brands such as PNW brands to Australia? Do you order them online, paying duties and risking ordering a basicakly non returnable wrong size?
@@Bootlosophy I think it gets easier and easier the more boots and brands you own. It can be tricky for beginners who have little exerience with each brand, as the fit of each can very quite a bit. My favourites are White's and Nick's Handmade, when it comes to high end and very structured boots.
@@Bootlosophy I was just wondering because you mention that MP is the grail boot, and the 2030 is equally if not more comfy that the MP. Anyway, I'll be sure to check all of your vids out. I'm fairly new into the world of leather boots and your contents is phenomenal!!
Well you got that wrong. As an American, you should educate yourself and Google “Acknowledgement of Country in Australia” and do self educative things like look at the Acknowledgements embedded in Australian company websites like R M Williams. But then, you probably never left your home town, right?
@@Bootlosophy you think you did something there huh? lmao I'm not an American first of all... but bold of you to assume. Second, I'm indigenous Saami from Lapland. All indigenous people I know (which is hundreds) just laugh at self righteous and virtue signaling liberals like you.
We appreciate the shoutout, happy to hear you're loving Diplomats!
Good show. For anyone interested in the RMW gardener, have a look at the Gammon. Same last and build, but the Vesta leather is much more scratch resistant than the greasy Kip.
One of the great mysteries of life in my opinion is why anyone thinks a white wedge sole is a good idea, I simply hate them. I have a pair of Dievier Nomads with the black sole which should be considered on any list of comfortable moc toe boots. I heard a rumor that Redwing is going to introduce additional colors with black soles in addition to the green ones. Rant over, nice review
Man I'm loving those Fortis roughouts
My comfy boot list (random order)...
Allen Edmonds 1757 last Higgins Mill in CXL and Patton in kudu;
Grant Stone Edwards in suede;
Parkhurst old 18 last fully lined Delaware in kudu;
Caswell Lisbon in CXL.
Yes higgins mills and the patton in kudu are very comfortable. I'd say the Frye philips leather sole is up there for me also. Parkhurst fits well but its not next level like the Frye Philips or Higgin Mills.
You should put titles or headers on the screen so someone can constantly see what boot you are talking aboit. Other than that, excellent sir.
As far as comfort id put my leather soled boots ahead of my wedge soles, second with the Eugene sole from Truman and Commando soles last. Rough out and suede gets first place for comfort from me for uppers.
Excellent information!
Saving for Viberg's Service Boot. Scary spending that much money without an in-person fitting at the source then ending up with a bad fit.
Your videos have turned into must see TV for me. Another great one! I would love to see your means of storing all these boots someday.
Whites MPs are super comfortable. I have them in black waxed flesh with a Dainite sole. I have a few other boots that are very comfortable (notably the Allen Edmonds Higgins Mill and a Truman 55 last boot in Rio Latigo leather) but my Whites are by far my most comfortable
Thank you for another informative video! While my boot modest boot collection doesn't include high dollar brands, my comfort boots are very similar to your selections. Thursday's moc toe Diplomat & Grant Stones's Brass are foot favs here. Chelseas in chromexcel are easy wearing & my leather soled, veg tanned Diesel maybe stiff, but still comfy too
I'll add that in general all of my boots - whether service, moc toe, chelsea, combat, hiking and even western styles are more supportive & comfy than regular low-cut shoes. Heck, except for summer days in river sandals or sneakers - I never wear regular shoes anymore! Cheers
I have the pair of Grant Stone Ottawa’s in 9.5 EEE Black CXL and it is an amazingly comfortable boot and very stylish. It’s weird feeling the extra length in the toe without my feet slipping forward. The Leo last cups my heel, ankles, and ball of my feet perfectly while allowing plenty of room for the toes. I guess that is what a combination last like their Leo or even Alden’s Truebalance last feel like.
All three pairs of your low-priced boots are very attractive. I like the wedge Cristie soles. It looks like they would all be comfortable too!
Great video- you went in every most important detail you need to know about boots
You should update this video with your excellent collection!
Just found your channel and really enjoy the videos!
Great video! Makes me even happier than I'm waiting 18 or so more weeks for my own pair of MPs. I went with the MP-sherman dainite in brown wf.
How do you like them?
@drzaius844 they are absolutely amazing! Waxed flesh was already one of my favorite leathers and the mp last is very comfortable. Compared to my other service style boots I would say they're probably the most well put together in design, shape and actual build quality and durability. For reference since ordering my mp's I wore my IRs for about 1mil steps, my GS diesels for roughly 500k and my Truman's for about 700k steps. With the mp's at around 500k steps aswell.
@@ethanbaran6158 nice! Glad to hear it. I need to try out some waxed flesh Chelsea’s or maybe a Truman boot.
@drzaius844 ohhh man now that you mention it, some tan waxed flesh Chelsea's from nicks on the 55 last would be a dreeeeaaaaaam!
Great round up. One day I'll buck up and get myself a pair of white's MPs, I'm currently a bit of a Nick's boots fanboy and waiting on my 3rd pair to be delivered.
Thoroughly enjoyable & helpful~~
I love my thorogood boots. I recently bought some Irish setter wingshooters, I highly recommend them for comfort as well! Big fan of the channel! 🥾
We must have very similar feet. The MP and 2030 are my favorite lasts as well.
I have the same Diplomats in black! I agree, quite comfortable.
And I'm going to duplicate this idea for a video soon! 😊
Go for it my friend! Look forward to your choices
Brilliantly explained
I'd be interested in the most comfortable boots regardless of price, sounds like the Indonesian boots were close to bespoke? Unfortunately my RM Williams gardners boots are one of the most uncomfortable when worn on hard surfaces, not bad when walking in paddocks or turf surfaces and they fit properly.
Great video again!
Indy 👏🏽
Awesome informative video.
Thank you so much for your well-informed, entertaining videos! I really appreciate your input on the RMW Gardeners, as I'm headed to Oz in a few weeks and will pick up a pair in Cairns. For US buyers looking for RMW boots or other Aussie brands, consider some of the online vendors in Oz. You'll benefit from (often) more competitive prices than those shown on RMW's or others own websites less the GST.
And as a tourist to Australia you can get a refund of GST when you leave. It’s called the Tourist Refund Scheme. That makes an AUD 649 boot cost AUD 590
@@Bootlosophy Yes, very good point. Here's a helpful tip I was recently given about the TRS. Claims may be made for purchases that exceed AUD 300 from the same vendor for goods removed from AU. So, even if you made two purchases for AUD 150 each, as long as the combined total exceeds AUD 300, the 10% GST can be rebated. Next, the goods purchased have to be shown, along with the invoices pertaining to them, to the ABF before boarding a flight or ship.
This used to be a real pain, as there's a limit to what can be carried on board, but now it's possible to visit ABF to make one's claim, show them what was purchased, and then put the goods into bags that'll be checked through to your final destination. This is available in Sydney, Brisbane and other cities. You may need to check and extra bag, but at least you can get it on board vs. carry-on limits.
Finally, there's an iOS app available that allows invoices, etc. to be summarized in advance of visiting ABF. Instead of filling out a claim at the airport, the app summarizes your invoices and lets ABF scan the QR code in the app for the details. Goods still have to be presented, but the app expedites the process. Be advised that depending upon one's destination, e.g., LAX, there may be long lines at the ABF office, so plan ahead, arrive early and take an extra bag if you plan to check your goods after visiting the ABF.
One more thing - the TRS doesn't cover purchases for hotels, drinks, food, etc consumed within Australia. They have to be removed from Oz to be eligible.
Curious what you think about the Trumans?
Thank you for sharing your experience with us ! I am also looking for most comfortable boots. How would you rank them from most comfortable to least comfortable ?
I'd love to get my paws on those Strider boots, but I'm not so sure about having to text them to order? 🤔 Also I wonder if they'd do a version without speed hooks. That'd be awesome.
You can customise
Another great video. I've learned a lot watching your videos.
I do wonder, do you own or have you tried any moccasin constructed boots? I would think something from Rancourt or Russell Moccasin would rate well in comfort. I also think they might be a best of both worlds, offering immediate comfort like Thursdays as well as lasting comfort like Whites.
The closest I’ve come were real moccasin shoes in the 70’s
Nice reviews! Quick question, thoughts on the Grant Stone Brass Boot Wedge Sole in terms of comfort and break-in vice those mentioned? Keep up the great work!
I don't have a pair of Brass in the wedge sole but the (same) one on the Field Boot is squishy and easy to break in. Softer than RW 875 but a little less than Thorogood's.
How does the African Ranger in your collection?
Not the most comfortable for me although others say it is - depends on foot shape and last
Hi,
Next year I'll be taking a trip to Italy. I'll be walking around through museums, streets, etc. all day long for a couple weeks. I really don't want to wear tennis shoes. I'd rather wear boots. My Clinch boots are quite comfortable for daily wear, but I do not think they will be comfortable enough for walking around all day long on hard surfaces. Do you think the boots in this video will suffice? Any recommendations on boots maybe you don't have?
Thanks
Obviously I can’t comment on boots I don’t have, but most of the boots on the list would suit what you described
Love the channel. I'm also a watch guy as well as a boot guy. Which watch are you wearing in this video?
It’s a Seiko, not sure of model
For the MP's do you prefer the Dainite sole or the half sole.
I'm curious, my thoughts would be the half sole. In my experience they flex better than full soles.
I prefer the half sole for grip, the Dainite for comfort
Interesting. I read post's claiming how hard and, uncomfortable the dainite sole was for some. I'll take your word though.
@@Vultain good point
@@tipsy6269 I think that may depend on the boot, I have Dainite on some boots with thin cork and midsole layers and that can be hard in shock absorption.
I really enjoy your content, it’s very informative for a newbie to the boot world like me.
I did have a question for you; As a fellow Aussie I am having some trouble locating where to purchase Venetian shoe cream here in Australia. Where do you purchase this product from?
Some good cobblers will have it, but I usually buy from Amazon. Check the links at the bottom of the description box below this video.
@@Bootlosophy thank you Sir
Great channel and videos!
One question: how do you manage to get all those niche brands such as PNW brands to Australia? Do you order them online, paying duties and risking ordering a basicakly non returnable wrong size?
I order online and I know my sizes. If in doubt I contact the brand.
@@Bootlosophy I think it gets easier and easier the more boots and brands you own. It can be tricky for beginners who have little exerience with each brand, as the fit of each can very quite a bit.
My favourites are White's and Nick's Handmade, when it comes to high end and very structured boots.
Compare between the 2, Viberg 2030 and White's MP, which one do you prefer over the other?
I have made 4 videos where I called my MPs my Grail.
@@Bootlosophy I was just wondering because you mention that MP is the grail boot, and the 2030 is equally if not more comfy that the MP. Anyway, I'll be sure to check all of your vids out. I'm fairly new into the world of leather boots and your contents is phenomenal!!
What a gigantic virtue signal right out of the gate.
Well you got that wrong. As an American, you should educate yourself and Google “Acknowledgement of Country in Australia” and do self educative things like look at the Acknowledgements embedded in Australian company websites like R M Williams. But then, you probably never left your home town, right?
@@BootlosophyHe’s too busy burning the books he should be reading Teik.
@@Bootlosophy you think you did something there huh? lmao
I'm not an American first of all... but bold of you to assume. Second, I'm indigenous Saami from Lapland. All indigenous people I know (which is hundreds) just laugh at self righteous and virtue signaling liberals like you.
🤦♂️ It’s called respecting traditional custodians
@@daviddenyer756 read my reply.... I'm first nation ya ding dong