Berliner Philharmoniker Violin Master Class: Mozart, Symphony No. 40

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 10. 2016
  • Berliner Philharmoniker First Concertmaster, Noah Bendix-Balgley, coaches Ann Yu on Mozart, Symphony No. 40, First movement.
    To watch more master class videos visit: bit.ly/2f0wwy6
    Select members of the Berliner Philharmoniker led three days of master classes focusing on orchestral repertoire and audition preparation. Participating young artists had the opportunity to sit on stage with the orchestra during their dress rehearsal and attend the Berliner Philharmoniker in performance, led by Sir Simon Rattle in Carnegie Hall.
    To learn more about Workshops and Master Classes at Carnegie Hall visit: www.carnegiehall.org/Education/Workshops-and-Master-Classes/
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 279

  • @DrewBarnard94
    @DrewBarnard94 Před 7 lety +394

    I've been reading the comments on a lot of these master class videos, and I'm getting tired of people bashing the teachers. A master class is designed for the teacher to provide constructive criticism for the student, not ooh and aah about the student. Noah Bendix-Balgley is kind and helpful, with a delightful sense of humor. And yes, obviously the better musician. Ann Yu certainly spent hours practicing her piece to prepare for her audition, while Bendix-Balgley is just walking up and perusing the score without warmup.
    The twaddle you read in the comment section sometimes... Goodness.

    • @portischarles
      @portischarles Před 7 lety +41

      This teacher gave brilliant insights and is a true master, as well as gentle demeanour.

  • @langkuai6387
    @langkuai6387 Před 7 lety +902

    Why I am watching this. I am a pianist

    • @tabithasegree3067
      @tabithasegree3067 Před 7 lety +14

      蒯浪 if ur a musician them it's fine

    • @gafhadly4616
      @gafhadly4616 Před 7 lety +56

      蒯浪 why not? I watch history documentaries and I'm not an historian. We can learn something from everything

    • @langkuai6387
      @langkuai6387 Před 7 lety +2

      Gaf Hadly That is right

    • @portischarles
      @portischarles Před 7 lety +17

      This video is filled with wonderful little insights for any musician.

    • @Joint145
      @Joint145 Před 7 lety

      Lang Kuai omg right?!

  • @sandrolubis2290
    @sandrolubis2290 Před 7 lety +150

    He is a real musician. His interpretation is stunning..

  • @ceoraaa
    @ceoraaa Před 7 lety +216

    His violin literally sings!! It's beautiful!!

  • @gagamin2
    @gagamin2 Před 7 lety +212

    I like this man. he is absolutely right.

    • @tifanyt.387
      @tifanyt.387 Před 4 lety +1

      @Ramesses II Setepenre I think she's holding her violin lower and not as upright as he is. A violist tends to hold their instrument lower due to the length, so I think that's why

  • @kerumble
    @kerumble Před 7 lety +417

    This guy's comments are world class critique

    • @gcg8187
      @gcg8187 Před 7 lety +2

      kerumble yes!!! :)

    • @vla179
      @vla179 Před 5 lety +16

      If you ever take any lesson from Berliner philharmonic you will know they all like that.... No matter what and how you will play it is never good for them...

    • @yzxt7535
      @yzxt7535 Před 5 lety +1

      Lmao

    • @yzxt7535
      @yzxt7535 Před 5 lety +6

      Vla Music it’s to make sure the cycle continues and if they teach to others no one ever is said to completely mastered it so the violin continues and is open to play and for lots of practice lol.

    • @SchinkenBrother
      @SchinkenBrother Před 4 lety +7

      @@vla179 I had the luck to be conducted by one of their second violinists, Stanley Dodds, and to work with different members from Berlin Philamonics as soloists and it may be true: music is never finished or perfect for them. But what I saw with all of them was that they all care for young musicians and try to teach as good as possible. And to be honest in 14 years of violin lections i never learned as much as in the few orchestra rehearsals with Mr. Dodds. So maybe, its never perfect for them, but they will always encourage and help you to get to your best version.

  • @nikhildeo5998
    @nikhildeo5998 Před 7 lety +270

    Stop being critics 😂😂
    You do know he is the concertmaster of Berlin Phil right?

    • @tabithasegree3067
      @tabithasegree3067 Před 7 lety +4

      Nikhil Deo really?

    • @nikhildeo5998
      @nikhildeo5998 Před 7 lety +6

      Yes, go search it up or read the description

    • @TheCma6
      @TheCma6 Před 6 lety +35

      I agree. For the concertmaster of the planet's greatest orchestra, you should give serious consideration to what he says. I asume this was not an audtion for the Berlin Philharmonic.

    • @aidanmccormack5443
      @aidanmccormack5443 Před 6 lety

      Read the description oh my god

    • @yzxt7535
      @yzxt7535 Před 5 lety

      Oh

  • @thecommonoutdoorsman6366
    @thecommonoutdoorsman6366 Před 7 lety +104

    This guy is great! Anyone who has played a while can see how technically she played it. Instead of stating such he instantly broke down her technique, gave her context, and gave her the tools to make her instrument have a voice and sing!

    • @TheCma6
      @TheCma6 Před 6 lety +2

      Exactly right. With respect to Ms. Wu, she seemed to be playing notes with hardly any sense of the line of the melody.

    • @classicalperformances8777
      @classicalperformances8777 Před rokem +1

      But it is not a concerto for solo violin. It is tutti orchestra... I m a bit 😕

  • @Imants625
    @Imants625 Před 7 lety +105

    I am not a professional musician - just a lover of music and Mozart in particular, but I watched this video with a huge interest. Now I start to understand why the same composition sounds completely differently in performance of different orchestras. Thank you!

  • @martin1024
    @martin1024 Před 6 lety +103

    Why am I watching this? I'm unemployed

  • @user-xe4oy5sj8z
    @user-xe4oy5sj8z Před 6 lety +23

    This guy’s staccato is perfect!!

  • @bluepool210
    @bluepool210 Před 7 lety +36

    his sound 😍

  • @harrymullany3294
    @harrymullany3294 Před 5 lety +26

    What a great teacher, great student and genius Mozart!

  • @Funmodescondidas
    @Funmodescondidas Před 7 lety +35

    im a double bass player and this helped me so much , thanks for uploading this

  • @cdtj1265
    @cdtj1265 Před 6 lety +14

    His tone is amazing

  • @amandagrace6957
    @amandagrace6957 Před 4 lety +13

    Her violin has such a deep gentle tone! I love it. I play violin in an orchestra and these techniques help a lot because I play a lot of mozart too!

    • @rickyanthony
      @rickyanthony Před rokem +1

      Drowned easily in an orchestra but great for intimate playing

    • @amandagrace6957
      @amandagrace6957 Před rokem

      @@rickyanthony very true, I'm top choice for solos and the first violinist so in times where I'm playing alone it will work

  • @zerpaviolin
    @zerpaviolin Před 7 lety +29

    He´s Great!

  • @nickyork8901
    @nickyork8901 Před 6 lety +9

    Great playing Ann Yu - nice sound, excellent intonation, fine technique.

  • @2ears1mouth786
    @2ears1mouth786 Před 3 lety

    Noah's got a great attitude. Love it.

  • @elisaragli5038
    @elisaragli5038 Před 7 lety +10

    Just amazing !

  • @DrYeraLeeViolinStudio
    @DrYeraLeeViolinStudio Před 4 lety +1

    Great job, both Ann and Noah!

  • @audiowatches5750
    @audiowatches5750 Před 4 lety +1

    He is a very very musical violinist, superb!
    She is catching up really nice compliments.

  • @hoot2416
    @hoot2416 Před 4 lety

    Watching the bow is mesmerizing to me.

  • @ViolindEva
    @ViolindEva Před 7 lety +13

    Enjoyed this very much!

  • @ayushvinesh
    @ayushvinesh Před 6 lety +5

    this world is just beautiful

  • @metlin
    @metlin Před 3 lety +8

    That was so amazing. So helpful! I loved the part about adding a bit more character and phrasing, and I loved how he actually demonstrated that.

    • @carnegiehall
      @carnegiehall  Před 3 lety +4

      Thank you for watching, and we're glad you enjoyed it.

  • @DavidWDNO
    @DavidWDNO Před 7 lety +3

    What a fabulous session! Thank you so much for uploading!)

  • @ErikWilliamsviolin
    @ErikWilliamsviolin Před 7 lety +165

    I can't get over this height difference.

  • @joshroyeca
    @joshroyeca Před 2 lety +5

    Very helpful masterclass. Noah is kind and smiling, I think he’s teaching style is effective and inspiring to students. Thank you for sharing! ☺️🇵🇭

    • @carnegiehall
      @carnegiehall  Před 2 lety +2

      We're glad to hear you found this Master Class helpful!

  • @NikkiMindlessMe
    @NikkiMindlessMe Před 4 lety +2

    She is such an amazing student and I would absolutely love for him to teach me. He is truly great at what he does. Kudos!!!

  • @tokyochemist
    @tokyochemist Před 4 lety +2

    I need to remember the idea of frames. My runs always get muddy so separating things into frames will definitely help especially as a reset if I need to correct a run midway through.

  • @stefanhiemer751
    @stefanhiemer751 Před 6 lety +1

    Although I am an amateur trombone player I enjoyed this one. He seems a nice guy and it was interesting to see them work together.

  • @vinithkumar7245
    @vinithkumar7245 Před 4 lety +2

    He is incredibly knowledgeable😍

  • @zeniktorres4320
    @zeniktorres4320 Před 5 lety

    Beautiful playing.

  • @mary949120
    @mary949120 Před 6 lety

    I'm violist, and we are playing this piece, thank you :D

  • @alyssag8146
    @alyssag8146 Před 7 lety

    Christ. You two are so talented.

  • @kays1213
    @kays1213 Před 6 lety +5

    A great coach with cute smile😃

  • @VictorMinchihLee
    @VictorMinchihLee Před 5 lety

    Well done, Noah! Good to see you now on the other side of the master classes :)

  • @audreym9001
    @audreym9001 Před 7 lety +31

    she has a very nice voice...she only said sorry at first but still

  • @derik2nicolai584
    @derik2nicolai584 Před 4 lety +2

    So interesting, the student is also professional, but the teacher is super amazing 😉

  • @gil-evens
    @gil-evens Před 7 lety +26

    I am a pianist but this makes me happy. I don't know why

    • @sabrinaschantz
      @sabrinaschantz Před 5 lety +1

      Henri Roy No, piano is more beautiful. Especially the bass in piano, plus piano doesn’t involve screeching.

    • @sabrinaschantz
      @sabrinaschantz Před 5 lety

      Henri Roy Yes, you can be more expressive, but you can also be expressive on piano. You can also imitate a string quartet if you wanted to. On violin, its just solo and thats it.

    • @sabrinaschantz
      @sabrinaschantz Před 5 lety

      Henri Roy Well, of course you can play two different notes at the same time... i still prefer piano over violin, though.

    • @annalangenbach5097
      @annalangenbach5097 Před 3 lety

      @Henri Roy piano is the most beautiful Instrument because of all the different Sounds you can make it stands on it’s one

  • @enzocypriani5055
    @enzocypriani5055 Před 3 lety +1

    Thanks for upliading this great masterclass!

  • @drandrewtan
    @drandrewtan Před 5 lety

    Amazing!

  • @fluteshop6439
    @fluteshop6439 Před 7 lety +17

    Lol just watched this entire video at 1,25 speed, didn't realize until I opened another video. Damn that was :D

  • @muratbozdag8440
    @muratbozdag8440 Před 7 lety +4

    amazing 👏👏👏

  • @musico981
    @musico981 Před 4 lety +2

    The Student have a great Violin too!

  • @qutubhashmi1656
    @qutubhashmi1656 Před 4 lety

    Wow amazing violin 🎻

  • @ridenbib8098
    @ridenbib8098 Před 3 lety

    Very talented ❤

  • @enzocypriani5055
    @enzocypriani5055 Před 3 lety +1

    Great!

  • @carolineandtigger
    @carolineandtigger Před 7 lety +2

    Very nice.

  • @TroppiSilente
    @TroppiSilente Před 2 lety

    Fantastico!

  • @chigozie424
    @chigozie424 Před 5 lety +2

    I need more classical music suggestions

  • @SERGIOHernandez-vq2ik
    @SERGIOHernandez-vq2ik Před 4 lety

    perfect

  • @susanamelody7319
    @susanamelody7319 Před 2 lety

    Wonderful musicians thanks for uploading !!!! Which level of difficulty is this symphony?

  • @theheadachehorse9928
    @theheadachehorse9928 Před 6 lety +4

    What microphone that you used for record this video?

  • @senpai2610
    @senpai2610 Před 4 lety +1

    I know I'm not at their level, not even close but this still helps violinists at all levels like me

    • @annaf2828
      @annaf2828 Před 3 lety

      I have to play the end of her excerpt and further for an audition and this really helped my phrasing

  • @MarceloRodriguez-tu6im
    @MarceloRodriguez-tu6im Před 6 měsíci

    Hermoso

  • @fatihyalcn8796
    @fatihyalcn8796 Před 6 lety +54

    I just imagine what would be his critics about me when I played to him. Probably he would advice me to give up playing violin

  • @madesusena96
    @madesusena96 Před 7 lety +62

    Her bridge is angled a bit forward. She should fix that soon.

    • @samanthab6642
      @samanthab6642 Před 7 lety

      Made SG Putra because you say so? Ha

    • @madesusena96
      @madesusena96 Před 7 lety +5

      s B i don't think I'm understand

    • @cdtj1265
      @cdtj1265 Před 6 lety +1

      Well spotted!

    • @jpbaugh
      @jpbaugh Před 5 lety +9

      @@samanthab6642 He's not criticizing her technique. He's pointing out that the bridge on her violin is angled forward. It should be perpendicular with the front of the violin

    • @W8in12
      @W8in12 Před 4 lety

      I don't know if this really work on the sound, but I know a violist that put the bridge a little backward angled, arguing that the strings get a different tone with this bridge position.

  • @fredericlinden
    @fredericlinden Před 4 lety +2

    What a sensational music lesson !!!! (I also hope she practices to use her entire body to play the instrument, not just the a bow and fingers).

  • @acordeonpianoulloa2771
    @acordeonpianoulloa2771 Před 2 lety +1

    Primer comentario en español latino jjajaka puros gringos se nota que hay pocos weones que escuchan esta máster class en Chile puros weones flaites que les gusta el reggeaton, cumbia, ranchera el rap y el rock y nadie a menos que uno estudie llega a esto pero es una pobreza que nadie comente en Chile bueno decir que la chica toca muy bien y el maestro a cargo es excelente ojala hubieran maestros así por estos lados ya que los que hay son muy pa dentro no dan el conocimiento a cualquiera y son precios muy elevados para acceder a sus clases hay mucha gente que le encantaría aprender pero eso es una limitan te para los que no poseen recursos creo que la música del violin es esquisita y tocar mozart es todo un privilegio que gozan algunos pero esto debiera ser materia de estudio en los colegios y universidades no sólo es música es inteligencia al tocar y cultura rica en conocimiento los genios deben saber esto para finalizar mi comentario debo mencionar a otro genio que creo está al nivel de mozart y digo esto con todo mis respeto a paganini luego hay muchos pero en fin al que se dio tiempo de leer esto denle like y compartan!!!!

  • @nocturnallsnake4228
    @nocturnallsnake4228 Před 4 lety +1

    How should we play it for an orchestra audition: like it is really properly played in the section or rather like a solo?
    Because nobody is going to play like a soloist in the section (but perhaps sometimes the concert master). Also, couldnt it be a mistake by the judges to hire a musician to sit in the section who cannot play well those delicated soft passages but is more used to play full blown (like everybody is ordered to play all the time)?

  • @m.s.4725
    @m.s.4725 Před 2 lety

    The sound of the girl's violin is so brillant

  • @listen3b
    @listen3b Před 7 lety +13

    Her sound is rough and dull in many places, not sure if it is the instrument, bow, or recording albeit that's why she is on the master class. Apparently, the professional player demonstrates the articulation. Enjoyed it. Thanks!

  • @hananhumidan7064
    @hananhumidan7064 Před 3 lety

    i wish i have someone to teach me
    like him

  • @tyjuanbenton7243
    @tyjuanbenton7243 Před 3 lety

    I have never had a violin and have always wanted one, DO you have extras , lbs.

  • @sanjosemike3137
    @sanjosemike3137 Před rokem

    I "hear" the accompaniment in my mind as she plays. Do some of you too?
    Sanjosemike (no longer in CA)

  • @lunetelalune2783
    @lunetelalune2783 Před 3 lety +4

    Wow, what a dramatic improvement in phrasing the second time around.

    • @carnegiehall
      @carnegiehall  Před 3 lety +9

      The benefits of practice, practice, practice!

    • @bobbiecat7139
      @bobbiecat7139 Před 2 lety +1

      @@carnegiehall ooooo Carnegie Hall listens to TwoSetViolin...PRACTICE...like LingLing who practices 40 hours a day lol

  • @classicalperformances8777

    I m confused. So, in auditions , should we play the tutti like solo or not?

  • @One.violin
    @One.violin Před 7 lety +10

    what orchestra plays the student in?

  • @hihihihahaha4281
    @hihihihahaha4281 Před 5 lety

    That's so hard.

  • @aleema2933
    @aleema2933 Před 5 lety

    സൂപ്പർ

  • @adrianfernandez894
    @adrianfernandez894 Před 6 lety +16

    "Articulation" he said it about 38296392739 times but still a great violinist

  • @arcana830
    @arcana830 Před 6 lety +4

    Is he playing Nigel Kennedy's old violin?

  • @roberts932
    @roberts932 Před 3 lety +1

    Give her a seat among the masters, and in a couple of years she‘ll be a one herself.

  • @susampson278
    @susampson278 Před 5 lety +4

    The master has a better fiddle; tone is less harsh

  • @sunnyyang9040
    @sunnyyang9040 Před 4 lety +1

    When the phone rings tho lol.

  • @vla179
    @vla179 Před 5 lety

    Why did you delete a viola master class?

  • @evanpyne4426
    @evanpyne4426 Před 5 lety +5

    Why do they call him “first concertmaster?” Is that the same thing as concertmaster?

    • @Ickguenthrasil
      @Ickguenthrasil Před 5 lety +5

      The berlin philharmonic has several concertmasters

    • @matthewv789
      @matthewv789 Před 4 lety +6

      The titles are a little different. A “principal” or “concertmaster” is what in America we’d call an associate or assistant principal. The actual “principals” as we would think of them have “First” before their title, so First Principal Cello or First Concertmaster. (Some German orchestras instead give them a “solo” title.)
      In addition, in most sections there is also more than one First Principal. Most sections have two, and there are three First Concertmasters.

  • @jayecurry2049
    @jayecurry2049 Před 6 lety

    What was the second piece she played called?

    • @summerscent9064
      @summerscent9064 Před 6 lety +1

      Jaye Curry Symphony No 40 in G minor Finale (Allegro assai)

    • @jayecurry2049
      @jayecurry2049 Před 6 lety +1

      summer scent Thank you!!😄

  • @user-xh2kj4ui4r
    @user-xh2kj4ui4r Před 11 měsíci

    I would feel there might have been definite differences between student and coach. especially bowing articulation, sound making with bow length. student might be thinking only f and p. (soon be 91yrs.Japanese) sorry strange English.

  • @lexsitt1090
    @lexsitt1090 Před 7 lety +2

    I like his violin. Can anyone tell me the violin is by who?

    • @TurboBinch
      @TurboBinch Před 7 lety +6

      Lex Sitt it's a 1732 Bergonzi.

    • @Ickguenthrasil
      @Ickguenthrasil Před 5 lety +1

      Henri Roy it's publicly available knowledge

  • @laurides1267
    @laurides1267 Před 4 lety +37

    *Ling ling confirmed*

    • @ramekin4797
      @ramekin4797 Před 4 lety +2

      Uma Anônima TWOSEEEEET

    • @daniel3231995
      @daniel3231995 Před 4 lety +2

      Please shut up

    • @moonjellyf00l
      @moonjellyf00l Před 3 lety +1

      its being blatantly racist for me :)

    • @yes1635
      @yes1635 Před 3 lety

      @@moonjellyf00l omg no its an inside joke of like a youtube channel and 'lingling' is like someone who practices 40 hours a day and beats all people and everyone wants to play like lingling

  • @benestwice
    @benestwice Před 7 lety

    Hello ! Doigté : in mes 65 the note A is with the 2 ? in mesure 66 the second note low D is with 1 ; mes 67 f# is with 1 ? a good fingering is alway very important !

  • @namkeren7297
    @namkeren7297 Před 4 lety +7

    Why i am watching this i am a painter

  • @rimonhanna6671
    @rimonhanna6671 Před 4 lety +1

    This man is ammmmmmazing , what's his name ?

  • @warmcupofbatteracid
    @warmcupofbatteracid Před 4 lety +1

    How old is she and how do you get into this master class situation?! XD god I lessons

  • @danieldeiparine1616
    @danieldeiparine1616 Před 5 lety

    is that a viola

  • @cangjie12
    @cangjie12 Před 5 lety +9

    She’s starting the trills on the wrong note whereas the guy is doing it correctly. He doesn’t seem to notice that. Btw I agree that he has a much better instrument than hers.

  • @Bl0ck3dz
    @Bl0ck3dz Před 5 lety +1

    Is it by pure professionalism that his violin sounds better than hers, or is that more because of the bow, strings and such ?

    • @jonathanmay4625
      @jonathanmay4625 Před 5 lety +5

      Ivan Siderov probably a little bit of both, the violin he is playing is incredibly nice, if I had to guess old French or Italian so it probably sings a little bit better than hers but he’s also obviously a better player too

  • @natejohnson1083
    @natejohnson1083 Před 6 lety +4

    that guy looks like a giant next to her lmao

  • @nekocafe8420
    @nekocafe8420 Před 3 lety

    Im watching this because a play the violin.

    • @carnegiehall
      @carnegiehall  Před 3 lety

      Thank you for visiting our channel and listening!

  • @nishanthmandala1574
    @nishanthmandala1574 Před 5 lety +1

    I’m pretty sure there’s no vibrato in the long notes

  • @MS-so5xb
    @MS-so5xb Před 3 lety

    14:05

  • @charlesteixeira7451
    @charlesteixeira7451 Před 2 lety

    You can take everything this guy is saying to the bank!

  • @gagamin2
    @gagamin2 Před 7 lety +13

    by the way her sound is very similar with oistrakh

  • @sebast2530
    @sebast2530 Před 3 lety +1

    Why I am watching this. I am a chemist

  • @user-kk5qe9fj2l
    @user-kk5qe9fj2l Před 3 lety

    her hair looks liker her fingerboard. exactly the same color

  • @nishanthmandala1574
    @nishanthmandala1574 Před 5 lety +1

    Her vibrato sounds Bach

  • @LudwigvanBeethoven2
    @LudwigvanBeethoven2 Před 6 lety +3

    Dilidilidilidilidili