Is Micah Parsons calling Brock Purdy a 'Top 15 QB' an insult instead of a compliment? | NFL | SPEAK
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2023
- Brock Purdy came back like he never left, as he threw two touchdowns in the San Francisco 49ers 30-7 win over the Pittsburgh Steelers. Micah Parsons had some words, saying quote: 'I just don't think that we should sleep on Brock Purdy anymore. I think Purdy is a Top 15 QB. There are things we want to still see from Purdy, not when Purdy is winning but when he is down.' Emmanuel Acho, Joy Taylor, LeSean McCoy and James Jones react to Parsons' comments, then discuss whether he is actually taking a shot at Purdy and not complimenting him.
#Speak #NFL #MicahParsons
SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from Speak: sprtspod.fox/SUBSCRIBEtoSpeak
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4uouolb
►Watch the latest content from Speak: sprtspod.fox/TheLatestonSpeak
▶ The Carton Show's CZcams channel: sprtspod.fox/SubscribeCartonShow
▶ First Things First's CZcams channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeFIRSTTHINGSFIRST
► UNDISPUTED’s CZcams channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeUNDISPUTED
▶ The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s CZcams channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeTHEHERD
► The Skip Bayless Show CZcams Channel: sprtspod.fox/SUBSCRIBESkipShow
► What's Wright? with Nick Wright CZcams channel: sprtspod.fox/whatswright/youtube
See more from Speak: foxs.pt/SFYFoxSports
Like Speak on Facebook: / speakonfs1
Follow Speak on Twitter: / speakonfs1
Follow Speak on Instagram: / speakonfs1
Follow Speak on TikTok: / speakonfs1
About SPEAK:
The revamped SPEAK takes over the airwaves with Emmanuel Acho, LeSean McCoy and Joy Taylor covering the day’s hottest topics in sports and offering their unfiltered takes.
Is Micah Parsons calling Brock Purdy a 'Top 15 QB' an insult instead of a compliment? | NFL | SPEAK
• Is Micah Parsons calli...
Speak
/ speakonfs1 - Sport
Subscribe to The Carton Show now: sprtspod.fox/SubscribeCartonShow
49er and Brock Purdy well be fine and see you in the playoff.
The carton show is weak😂
Joy, is more than a host and a commentator. She's right about most subjects and logical. Joy is very logical, plus she's the woman of my dreams but yeah right in my dreams only
Acho take was the definition of moving the goalposts
How so?
That’s quite literally almost every Acho take on every show.
Yep. By his reasoning, Dak should be mad too, since, Micah didn't say "and so is Dak".
Being called a top 15 QB in the NFL, while not even have a full 17 games under your belt, is an enormous compliment.
Purdy being called a top 15 qb is not shade.
Name 14 better QBs
@@mroctober3583you name them
@@mroctober3583I’d name 20
@@garriethsmith8362 Do it then.
it aint shade but it aint a compliment
Joy shut them down real quick hahahaha
Joy killed them with her take! 😂
how? you think Purdy is sitting there like, "yeah he's right, I'm average"
how ? because there are 10 QB's that are better then him right now and him being in the top 15 is completely acceptable. @@boricuafrican1
Stop it she worst analyst on tv
She was spittin!! 😂😂😂
They glitched a lil bit 🫨 LoL
Joy came with the facts. Top 15 is not an insult. He is literally saying he is better than half the starting QB's in the league lol
bro, that's average then...
do backups not count? is he not top 15 out of 64 potential QBs????????@@boricuafrican1
@@boricuafrican1no it’s not there are 32 teams, math is hard.
this and more coming up next on "Athletes do math"
@drew318 so... you would say Purdy is the minimum denomination possible above average.. when you could have called dude average?
Sensibility is hard.
i’m sorry but being top 15 in the world at one of the hardest things to do in sports is a compliment no matter how you try to spin it😭🤦🏻♂️
Exactly!!!!
This is one of those slow days/late draft topics 😭
So calling Tom Brady Top 15 All-Time QB is a compliment ACCORDING TO YOU... THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE SAYING😂🤣
@@str8rippi yep.. not complicated 😭🤦🏻♂️
@@zwoptf Bruh you're tripping lol 😂🤣😭
Never thought I'd see Joy defending Purdy she been kinda pushing him off and she's finally embracing him and these fools are just dismissing her logical, well thought out take 😂 Poor Joy
She wasn't defending him in any way lol
As a 49ers fan, I tend to be very sensitive to any hateful comments towards the 49ers. However, I took the "top 15" comment by Micah Parsons as a compliment. If Parsons had said Purdy top 5, he would lose credibility and get laughed at. Even top 10 is a stretch. And top 15 doesn't mean exactly 15th. To me it meant somewhere between 11 and 15. Which seems quite reasonable and right on the money.
I don't want people to be hypt on my team too much.
Same as a 49er fan as well. Brock coming off injury and completing 9 games i took top 15 as a compliment. You can only play in the scheme you are in with the team you have. If he goes 4-1 / 5-1 to start year with good QB play i think he jumps into the bottom TOP 10.
Same here as a Niners fan. There are plenty of QBs I'd love to be our QB over him, but he's great where he is right now in his career. He's really gonna grow.
Insult 🤨 he was literally the last pick. If he said top 10 he’d just be lying. Brock never even expected to start in his career so saying he’s top 15 is praise. Being top 15 doesn’t mean he’s 15
Name 10 better
@@mroctober3583 You name them
Brock has not played enough games to say what kind of QB he's going to be by the end of his career, but anyone who says Brock isn't playing like a top 5 QB right now is either blind or stupid. Will that continue into the future? Who knows. Right now though you can't argue with the performances that he's putting together.
@@spcmegreg it’s been one game 🤨 how tf is he top 5?? He’s literally just doing his best Jimmy G impression when he was with the Patriots
@@spcmegregtop 5 is wild bro, don't know what you smoking
Shady is top notch again, grounded, give me names, give me reasons, no fake politeness
He's nearly always spot on in spite of his allegiances.
Facts. These other dudes doing way too much lol
Lmaooo spot on about what??? Found the Eagles fans lmao
@@TheDakAttackShow Couldn’t be more wrong.
I love how they all was silent and just looked at her when she told herself she was right 😂 2:56
They just don't want to tell her the truth that she's dumb.
They dont hear a word she say as they undress her with their eyes
she was right tho LOL
@@xTidus24xxnah they're being gentlemen. I wish they'd say how they really felt 😂
She’s a joke, she’s only there cause the show wants “inclusion” she asked how many teams were on the league. 😂😂😂
Omg. I am a 49ers fan. And I agree with shady and joy.
2nd best in the nfc bro.....im a 9ers fan and that cap as of right now bro
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 ffg guy jurassic buzzwords av Buzzcocks
❤
@areoinstylz4724 u saying that like it's alot of good qbs in the nfc😂it's only like one and we all know who that is and it ain't purdy
So telling someone is top 15 at they position is an insult?😂😂😂
That’s telling sum body your average
@@luckitae7592so telling the truth is insulting now?🤔
@@evileyevalausin this world nowadays are you actually questioning it?
@@Raven.Bloodrot 🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️ you right my question is more outlandish then anything huh 😭
@@luckitae7592someone who was picked last in the draft, who won out QB1 over a 1st overall pick, and only played in 9 games in the league being placed in top 15 above 17 other QBs who majority of them has had a larger body of work....... that's not saying someone is average. He hasn't shown he's top 10 YET so how tf would you be able to put him in that tier?
Joy is the smartest person on this show, she's the only one that always makes sense
acho and james occasionally speak the truth but shady always has wild takes
She's the only one that doesn't
She said she trust the Bill's and Bengals in the playoffs more than the Cowboys based on history....Bills and Bengals both have a combined 0 Superbowls while Dallas has 5
Do you know how bad it would look if she was the dumb one?
U think she gonna see this 😂
Man, i really appreciate the way Shady put that.
Ill keep this in mind when i listen to him in the future.
And Joy always brings us back down to earth. Lol
I dont care whatever rank they put purdy. Winning is what really matters and that’s what he does.
Joy is spot on in this take!
She doing to much smh & she wrong 😂😂😂 Micah was calling him average
@@luckitae7592how she doing too much?
Joy is the biggest NINER hater EEEEEVER!!!!! Point blank always riding shady D lmfao clown as female
@@princecheck11being literal when it fits her and figurative when it doesn't then getting frustrated and not responding when called out on it
@@MapleGlazedDonuts how exactly? example ??
Joy’s take was the most level headed and accurate
It’s Purdys ability to process and execute whatever play is given to him. It doesn’t matter if he has Shanahan or any other OC in the league. His awareness is what’s keeping him to good. His peripheral vision is top notch as well. He understands when to leave the pocket or stay in. He makes the OCs job much easier.
Dumb topic.... Easy Answer.
To call someone a Top 15 QB after being in the league for not even a full year is major compliment. Acho being Acho
Joy makes the most sense period
Definitely a compliment! There is a difference between comparing vets to Qb that are in year two. Micah knew if he had said top 10 or top 5 would have the media in a frenzy. I think they were off on this one. I’m glad joy understood it.
Z z x 3: 4:48
A bczv zzz
6:08 6:14 6:17 6:18
8:32
some ppl say double sided compliments like females . he is top 15 instead or just saying he’s good i want to see more . nope . they need to learn from marshawn lynch .
I love James Jones on this show with them. He balances everything out. He doesn’t compromise his opinion to be in cahoots with Joy Taylor or anyone else, and that elevates everyone’s takes.
He played only 9 or 10 games , if somebody says he’s top 15 or 15th QB , that’s a compliment.
Shady being more reasonable than acho and the other dude is wild😂
The awkward silence when joy hit them with basic math 😂 Joys take won this segment.
According to her “math” there would be only one average qb in the nfl. The rest are below or above.
He went from last pick in the draft to better than half the starters in the NFL i mean id say thats a compliment
Joy really had a good point she made everyone rethink their opinions
Considering Purdy was the LAST pick in the draft, calling him a top 15 QB is absolutely a compliment. This guy is playing at the highest level of football where only the most talented athletes play, he was on the fast track to being an unsigned free agent. To go from that to a starting QB in this league, to then being called a top 15 is nothing short of a compliment and it you take it any other way is ridiculous and entitled. Especially while in this era of great quarterback play.
Love this show when everyone doesn't talk over everyone.
Joy killed them on this one
Goin from Mr. Irrelevant to a top 15 QB is a pretty big jump
Acho and James in their feelings for another man’s opinion lol 😂
Shady every day
This was a really great debate
Joy and Shady is 100% right here. How was this shade? He was giving props to Purdy saying he's better than 17 other starters in the league
32 teams, every team has at least 2 QBs. That’s at least 64 QBs but closer to 70 QBs on rosters. 15 is very fair for now and much higher than most Purdy doubters have him. It’s a compliment for now.. if he plays the whole season the way he’s played thus far than at the end of the year anything lower than 6th would be a diss.
You ain’t telling me I ain’t the best qb I know Tom Brady stand for it even in his rookie season no one wanna be told someone better than you no matter if you telling me I’m better than 20 other guys
He played as a game management. He wasn't really asked to do much. Because they had a running game. He'd need more than one more year to prove to me that he belongs in the top 10. But these idiots here will put a quarterback in the top 10 if he has one good season they did it to the eagles quarterback and he's shown this year so far he doesn't belong there. In purdy's career work shows he doesn't belong in the top 10.
This clown said 6th lmao
@@georgeyarbrough88still have to throw the ball ,, numbers don’t lie
@@LakerJet numbers can be skewed by weather. And he still hasn't proved anyting.
The reason its hard to judge how good he is is cuz kyle shanahan will make any decent qb look great and they have an amazing run game and defense. I could see 15 qbs who would thrive as their qb.
Acho irks me with his takes, he's right there with Skip 😂😂😂😂
Shady is below skip
He looks ridiculous with his pink suit
Acho is trash
The disrespect to stafford is disgusting
They stay disrespecting my QB1.
Seriously the man just won the superbowl
Dude that panel is crazy
I got jokes to
You guys deserve the job
Great chemistry
After the death of someone I wasn't watching any more sports
Starting to come around a bit
Check his RATING!!! He doesn’t play for a team that throws 40 times a game and he’s still tearing it up.
He’s also on a overpowered team with stars on both sides of the ball. Nothing wrong with him being called a top 15 qb until he proves otherwise.
@@dmvbawse4265 look at his RATING he makes all the right decisions. Look at Dak he has nothing but talent around him, look at Justin Herbert, look at anybody you think is better than him… they should have a better rating if they are as good as you think. QBs have to make decisions quickly and that’s when most of them mess up and can’t get the job done. Brock is super smart.
Cuz the 9ers is probably the only team who don't build on offense they build on defense..
@@MVPTCYou sound like Skip.
@@dmvbawse4265Nobody was saying that when Jimmy was the quarterback!! Jimmy is a above average quarterback, Purdy has “IT”. Purdy has the potential to be top 10 that’s why this is even a discussion.
2:19 don't forget Micah played against him last year so he is basing his opinion off what is saw on the field
Yup. Because even though the niners won that game it wasn’t because of Brock Purdy. Brock really didn’t even have a good game so Micah putting him top 15 is real respect because he could of easily put him lower after facing him head to head
Yeah considering Purdy didn't have a great statistical game against the Cowboys says a lot.
@@kingdre6397bro purdy got sacked the first play of the game vs cowboys and didn’t get phased. Most QBs would of been phased for sure. Purdy mite not have the best game but he lead drives down the field. And won the game. No int either
Michael Parsons has no filter. He call it like he see it.
This one was a GREAT discussion, i wish it would've gone on longer.
Micha is correct, you can't put him in the top 10 yet
Yeah bro....i dont get it, its like they mad micah told the truth
This conversation is hurting my head 😂
Man Micah is not throwing any shade. Purdy wasn’t drafted at an average player so he moved up as an “average player” come on bruh Micah just saying Purdy is the real deal and we have to treat him that way.
Gang nem was wilding today😂😂 love the vibes! 🤝🏾
Acho criticizing Joy for hyperbole when he moves the goal posts like every take lol. Joy and Shady slayed this segment.
Joy always hits you with the truth
As a 9ers fan, I’ve seen plenty of quarterbacks who cannot execute Shanahan’s system and fail. His system requires elite timing, recognition, anticipation and accuracy to get the YAC from guys like Deebo and CMC. Doing that consistently (see Jimmy G) is really hard. As a bonus, Purdy has excellent evasiveness and scrambling ability because Shanahan often leaves free rushers coming right at the QB. So far, so good. Purdy’s biggest challenge will be staying healthy behind so-so pass blocking.
😂😂😂
It's funny that when JJ talked Hurts he brought up the 2 #1 WRs, the defense, the line, TE, and RBs. But Purdy has all that as well. Nobody ever mentions it when it comes to Purdy though.
They racist right? 😂
Shady made a good point. Brock Purdy playing like the second overall pick and zach wilson playing like the last pick of the draft
Shady usually annoys me but hes getting better at this. He and Joy were the only ones making sense.
Acho ended her with the “be literal” since she just called them out for the same thing
This one of the good segments where everyone made actually good football points fir their arguments
Big fan of these debates!
Purdy is going to be high up there watch !!!!!! 🎉
It amazes me how much hype Purdy gets.
Facts given he has only played 9 games!!!!!! Another point I want to make is how Josh Allen has been the sole player of costing his team not to advance in the playoffs but they have him on a high pedestal compared to Dak!!!
The only player to throw for 2 TDS in every regular season game he started in HISTORY
It's because of when he was taken in the draft AND he passes the eye test. He has poise and good arm talent. Showed he had a much better handle of the SF offense and the NFL level than a 1st overall pick.... THATS why he's getting this much hype
Facts, it's who e ever the media hypes up until they're proven wrong
@@imendoza4065you put Dak on that bills team they win 5 games, put Josh on that cowboys team and they win a Superbowl.
That was the best segment yall ever had ctfu
I think everybody put Brock Purdy physical appearance is top 15. He doesn't have biggest arm or faster than Lamar. But his mind and QB IQ is ELITE, top 5. His STATS say his #1 or #2 in 9 games in the NFL.
He has been accurate since highschool
Joy be killing em. If it wasn’t for her this show will be 💀 😂
A realistic gauge to determine Purdy on the list is how many decent defenses has he beaten in those 9 games. At the end of the day, it’s about the playoffs, where you face the best defenses in the league. If we want to base how he played against elite defenses in a playoff situation we could say so far, he’s an average to slightly above average QB. Parsons is probably right.
They are being very selective as to how they are breaking this down. Last time I checked most teams have at least 2 QBs which being in the top 15 puts you in the top 25% minimum. For someone who was the last person picked in the draft saying they are in the top 15 is no slight. They however have chosen to make it about the starting quarterbacks so they can drum up some controversy.
Josh Allen would be freakin crazy with the 49ers the best all around back in the league the best all around tight end 2 great receivers and more in Buffalo he has 1 good receiver that's it
12:27 Acho…. the niners would be INSANE with Josh Allen at QB. (if Kyle doesn’t run him into the ground, but Josh would more than likely do that to himself lol)
Problem is Josh doesn’t read as fast as Purdy.
Yup. Allen has a million dollar arm, but a 10 cent heard.
Shady is the most accurate objective real analyst of all time. He is the 2nd best in the nfc and basically undefeated. When trey Lance and garrapolo was there they didn’t cook how purdy did
Because Purdy was Drafted Last & bc he's So Talented & Modest Team Veterans Love him So Much that the Whole Team has Picked Up Their Playtime Intensity in Support of Him making the San Francisco 49ers Absolutely Unstoppable!
That's a compliment for a last pick rookie that is really still a rookie like Joy was getting at so im sure he's happy about that saying from Micah.... now what Acho was saying about the scheme this is what got Jalen Hurts looking good we'll this year may be ok put hurts on Chiefs, cowboys, Greenbay, Bengals he would be Trash.... but micah and Joy on him right...
Hurts would thrive in any system!! Put some talent around him and some consistency as far as coaching scheme is concerned and he'll make it work. His work ethic, and determination would overcome.
Most of nfl quarterbacks is system quarterbacks. Only a few that move to other team or system that are winning championships.
Hurts would be amazing with those weapons on the cowboys and bengals smh 🤦
@@reignsupreme7686 No sirrr not if he wasn't schemed he wouldn't... & I can prove it by saying his rookie year he wasn't that great than that next year they added weapons & scheme for him than he looked good & got them to the super bowl only to lose to Mchomboy & company.... & he definitely wouldn't have made it on the Bengals do to the oline & amount of pressure that would have been on him picks everywhere....
These guys are reading to much into it
It IS their job, lol
Great segment from Joy tbh
Context, Purdy has the 49ers defense to help him out. Even Rex Grossman went to the Superbowl with a great Bears defense. :D
I like how Acho tried to cut off a few qbs to justify his incorrect point 😂
And even if Micah specifically said 15, for the last pick in the draft to be the 15th best QB vw/in less than a full season of games is not an insult
If I was in the upper half of the only 32 people on planet earth that start at quarterback in the NFL I couldn’t be bothered or insulted by anything. Lol
I am a cowboy fan through and through.... With that said If Purdy offended of being called top 15 after 9 games. He needs to get hungry and prove my man Micha wrong. When I see those 2 teams head to head I want to see blood sweat and tears. I'm excited for this season not just for the cowboys but for the thrill of the game.
If someone said that James or Acho were top 15 players at their positions they’d be grinning from ear to ear for months.
Joy's doctorate is showing with the common sense. Loving it.
It’s honorary😂
Joy sounds like an idiot. 3 NFL guys disagree with her and she continues to argue. WTF she think knows how NFL players feel what a rookie is or not than 3 former players?
Joy is right on this
James did Major Disrespect to Tua and hes is a lot better than most of those he named in the middle of 11-20
That "jesus christ" on russel being 11 sent me 😅😅
Opening was crazy 😂
Brock played very well. He has overachieved to epic levels. That being said, it is a stretch to say he's in the top 15. That team is ridiculously talented. Kyle shanahan is a fantastic offensive coach. The defense is insane. Put brock on the giants against the cowboys. I doubt he looks much better, if at all than daniel jones. Situations matter. Brock has played very very well for sure, but he is somewhere in the kirk cousins range.
Cousins better than Purdy today imo but purdy can be better than him and Goff with time I think. Nothing is forsure tho. Purdy plays with a whip and they haven't asked him to tear it up lol. Cousins shoulders the vikes offense same with goff.
I love listening to joy talk football. Definitely the top female sports analyst of all time for sure.
U dumb
They hate asking shady hard questions lmao. “If we’re not talking about resume he’s second best in the NFC” but if we’re not talking about resume and just the first game, Purdy is literally the best in the NFC
Here she goes again but us 49er fans are gonna be wanting to hear her with that same energy end of season 💯
What did she say that was wrong?
Lmao you’re stupid she said nothing wrong
Compliment!!! His resume isn't long enough to put him over Carr, Goff, Cousins, etc.
Thank you Joy. I finally agree with you when it come to my 49ERS lol
"Well there are 32 QBs in the league so if he is top 15, he is technically above average (she says for the 3rd time), but we are arguing semantics."
No Joy, you're arguing semantics, everyone else is on topic. You're the one caught up in the wording.
😂😂 This is such a forced topic and fake outrage.
Shady wants to skip the "system QB" talk because he knows Hurts is as system as it gets 😂
Who knew the woman would be thr most knowledgeable on the panel. Spoke facts everytime she opened her mouth. 👏
He started off 3rd string, he’s played 9 games, he has moved from whatever from let’s say 60th ranked qb to the top 15 in 9 games, that’s amazing…and he’s still climbing..
Idk. I seriously think Micah ultimately meant it as kind of a compliment -something like to be picked last, not supposed to play, and now already in the top half of starters in the league.
McCoy preaching PURDY top 2 in NFC? Love it.
PARSONS WAS JUST GIVING PURDY HIS PROPS.
This the equivalent of accusing someone on Twitter of hating pancakes because they said they liked waffles
I’m so glad she straightened them