Tribal People React to Opera for the first time ft
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 01. 2022
- Tribal people reacting to Opera music for the first time feat. Elizabeth Zharoff @TheCharismaticVoice
Our patreon: / trybals
Buy Adnan a coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/trybalse...
Merch: trybals.myspreadshop.com/
Follow us on:
Facebook: / trybals-105923538317572
Instagram: / trybals_official
Twitter: / trybals1
Please note that this is a reaction video and contains commentary.
For the original video please click here:
• Elizabeth Zharoff- Ma...
Subscribe to Elizabeth:
/ thecharismaticvoice
If you are the original copyright owner and would like this video to be taken down please reach out to me at trybalsofficial@gmail.com
All the participants in this video are from Sindh, Pakistan.
Make sure to leave a like and valuable suggestions and please support our channel by hitting that subscribe button. Thanks for watching
www.copyright.gov/fair-use/
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
#TribalPeopleReact #Opera #TheCharasmaticVoice
This is SO AMAZING!!! Thank you so much, and I'm just floored and honored by the comments, and especially humbled to be the first taste of opera for others. Especially laughed at the "possessed" comment. This is really just surreal. :-D
OMG OMG OMG. Lol, hey Elizabeth, lots of love ❤️ please send me an email with a mailing address, we would like to send you an Ajrak and a Sindhi hat for your husband too.
@@TRYBALS That is so kind of you ❤️
Umm... She was not mic'd for that performance or did I just miss that?
WHAT, thats YOU? I didn't even notice it, what a great performance!
@@MoroVanator Opera singers don't use mics...they don't need them.
Something totally random; 'even the old lady is clapping'. That old lady was the former queen of Belgium, queen Fabiola.
She had really big hair.
@@littleredhairedgirlsteph3922 Lol!
Cool. I wondered.
good to know. thought she is her mom
@@drmorcoch9338 Haha not all
The guy with the turban is kinda serious and expressionless which makes him seem kinda cold at first but he was listening the closest and had wise words to say, he was paying attention to every detail. Mad respect.
Yes. I thought something similar: he has what we used to call "gravitas". Rarely see that in the West . . . any more.
BTW: chances are probably high . . . that he's a Sufi.
Saw the same thing. I couldn't wait to hear what he would say each time. But I loved all these guys' takes. It's great learning about humans' varying character, by watching them react to alien styles of music. I like the kids' reaction videos for that aspect as well.
Yes I also thought the same! I would love to see them react to some baroque music. Like Bach's Christmas oratorium (I mean not the full thing but some parts) or St. Johns passion. Either classically sung by a boy choir or adults. I think it would be so much fun sice the music has a lot of dramatics and also somber/calm moments even if it was written to praise god or maybe because of that. Also the orchestra is comprised of a different set of instruments. They seemd to love the opera!
Yes, he really embodies the virtues of a man in his culture. My husband is from an Eastern majority-Muslim culture and I have learned a lot from him. In cultures like this man's and my husband's (they are very different cultures, but have much in common still), respect is basically the most important virtue a man needs to show in his dealings with other people and with other cultures. Wise men listen carefully and speak carefully, & this is very important to the cultural idea of what it means to be an honourable person. In cultures like Abdul Aziz Rind's, every able man is strongly expected to be capable and willing to stand up for his own dignity and honour and/or that of his family/culture/etc., so men learn to be careful and deliberate about what they say of others. In the West we often hear only bad things about what being a man means or looks like in tribal cultures, especially in Muslim tribal cultures, and we get a totally incomplete and unfair picture. Videos like this help us to better see the full picture and appreciate the virtues of other ways of life.
7:37 wow, this man stated that "she is using three types of vocal ranges" which is pretty accurate. singing in 3 ocatves in western music theory. And this man pointed out conducting volume patterns in 5:49. very smart man
And at first he seemed so stern like he was not enjoying it at all!
@Kiki Kiki brown people lol....
@Kiki KikiA pathetic response.
@Kiki Kiki No, they're not. They are saying that the older gentleman who was exposed to Opera for the first time was observant and has musical knowledge. He was able to make accurate comments that were in line with western music theory(which is how Opera is described in the introduction).
the dude was thrown into the 9th dimension when she hit that third range, he was absolutely meditating and enjoying the F out of this piece
'Look how beautiful my sister is.' What a pure, generously loving comment, straight from this gentleman's heart. I cannot stop watching these! Truly beautiful souls these lovely people have.
your sister? she is indeed beautiful. she sang to dominate... loved it!
I loved this as well. It was really a window into the way he sees the world, and it’s a much more lovely way to see it.
@@drmorcoch9338 it's a kindly form of address I think
I agree! Such pure responses! So kind!
And one of them compared her voice to a bird. Just gorgeous!
The older man with reading glasses and the mustache has music in his soul. He can't help but vocalize when he listens.
It is interesting. I have watch quite a number of these videos. While watching this one I said to myself he has music in his soul. He enjoys it and his body and sometimes his voice tells you that.
Love that guy and how expressive he is!
Every time when they watch something music related you can see it in his gestures and face
Possessed, that made me laugh, that was really funny!
Thought the same. But the oldest guy too, and the bigger fellow as well ... no, they all had plenty of interest.
Nobody is talking about how the gentleman in the red hat recognized that string players in symphony orchestras all use the same bowings when performing. They play “in synchronization.” Yes, in fact, the concert master (the first violin) decides the bowings for the first fiddles, and sometimes for the 2nds and violas as well. Very astute observation.
It's called unison and the Chicago Symphony under Reiner had the best!
I learned this when I played cello in school. I was 10 years old at the time. I gave it up because as I learned more complex pieces, I couldn't stay focused. I respect any musician of any "genre" of music because it takes effort to become good enough to perform professionally.
And don't get me started on singing! Wow, I love a powerful voice!
I'd love to show them a video with only an orchestra. They were super interested in that part!
czcams.com/video/Tmuk5Zh_SPc/video.html@@AmythefirstA
That comment about her voice being like birds chirping hit the mark. Sopranos can imitate that sound very well and their voice is used to that effect in many arias. One that comes to mind is Ophelia's Mad scene in Ambroise Thomas' Hamlet
@Ron Malcom Perhaps they will. Their humble reactions have really touched me.
Yes! He has a real ear for musical storytelling; you could see his eyes light up as he "got it" with every change. I loved this. :)
Yeah, that's a perspective I never would've thought of. For sure I hear birds chirping all the time, but I never pay much attention to birds in the course of my modern industrialized life. Mostly I know springtime has arrived when I hear birds chirping at 5am and interfering with my sleep.
yess literally the second I saw him say that I came here to say how profound that is!
That and every Disney movie princess singing with birds, like Fiona or Snow White.
For anyone wondering, she performed that song in front of actual royalty, and received just about the greatest royal head nod in the last thirty years! What a beauty, what a voice! Elizabeth is the best, and so unbelievably well versed in vocal technique, control, and power.... Simply the best!
Have looked but can't find when this featured performance was and where. It looks like you may know.
@@m.c.master4622 I think if you search for Elizabeth's videos, it's one of the higher viewed and rated ones. I believe she was in like Sweden or Switzerland, somewhere where they speak a dutch language. Phenomenal performance, and more amazing when you realize she did this all without being mic'd up!
This performance was in Brussels (Belgium) as part of the 'Queen Elisabeth' competition (named after former Belgian queen Elisabeth who founded it) The 'old lady' show in the audience at the end was another former queen, Fabiola (she past away a couple of years ago)
@@garretisla5282 Do you mean germanic languages? Because in neither of those countries they speak dutch, which is spoken mostly in Neatherlands(Holland)
You made me laugh, so thank you for that.
@@angleofshadow9818 yeah, I meant Germanic. My mind just kept going to dutch, and I wasn't sure where she was playing at, so I just went with what my mind thought it was.. I know that dutch and Germanic aren't the same, although they do share a common and lineal ancestry.
If people randomly did that here on the street some of us would also think they were possessed :)
😆
My eldest sister is an opera singer. I went to a ball game with her once and when the national anthem was played, she sang the words so profoundly people around us were amazed. She was far better than the person singing down on the field. XD
I know right. When she said that, it was the funniest thing to see her expression.
That was funny
In some cultures women are forbidden to sing in public, or to a mixed audience, or wear revealing clothes in public. This video may have made Parvati a little uncomfortable.
LoL I agree with my sister there. First time my grandma listened to an opera singer she was so perplexed and definitely thought the singer was possessed by something. Grandma said every time the singer's voice rose, her heart would beat really fast 😂. She kept saying, "She is bewitching me! She's bewitching me!"
I was trying to figure out what she meant as possessed. Your description of your grandmother's reaction to high note singing clinched it for me. It makes sense. Thanks.
Der Hölle Rache
Queen of the Night
Diana Damrau
As someone who has been deeply rooted in opera and classical music since about the ages of 13-16, their insights were so enlightening. Especially one of their comments on how there is a mutual respect between her, the orchestra, conductor and even the audience. When he mentioned her bowing to the people as a sign of respect, it dawned on me. Of course! That's why we bow. As a sign of respect for the people coming to listen, for the musicians and conductor. I can't believe I never really thought of it that way. And the singing? Sublime. Wonderful!
That's the beauty of having outsiders bringing a new look on something. They'll notice those tiny things we don't.
Right? It's so amazing seeing people that have to context of an opera or an orchestra or any part of this part of our culture and it's history. It's gives such a pure reaction to it and alot of details show that some things are truly universal.
I understand why you never thought of it. I believe you come from Western culture where respect and reverence is not very ingrained in daily conduct through rituals. Whereas tribal most tribal cultures do have that deeply ingrained. As such, his observation was a natural link from what he knows, whereas the depth of the act of bowing was lost to you due to the culture you come from.
Yes, that bowing observation blew my mind!
I cried when one of them compared her volume control to birds singing as they fly away.
One of my favorite things about Opera singers is how strongly they can project their voice, meaning they can reach this whole theatre of people with no microphones over a live orchestra! So much power behind their singing!
That's the point. It was developed before microphones.
@@VeryCherryCherry Yeah, I know that. All I said in my comment was that it’s my favorite part about Opera. I didn’t act like it was a new concept in my comment, I just referenced the microphone aspect to really drive home how powerful their voices have to be. That was the entire point of what I said, so I don’t know what is being pointed out to me???
@@destineeryan6773 Lol! This happens all the time. Reading comprehension is non-existant these days.
It's crazy! I just started vocal training and sang this duet with my teacher for Christmas. She toned her voice down and it still came out WAY louder than mine haha Mad respect for them!
@@destineeryan6773 It's amazing but not "unhelped" either. In modern day it can even be hard for opera singers to adapt. The venues were built for that stuff. The accoustics of an Opera House (like where Elizabeth is singing here, the royal Chapel of Laeken, next to the Royal Palace of Belgium, designed for sacred music) are designed to not require mics. Modern concert halls are hard to wire for that. And their voice being so strong, mics don't really like opera singers either. So yes, they project immensely, but you wouldn't hear them as well were it another type of room. And the orchestra as well: the way they are placed, and the shape of the stage, directs the sounds in a way that allows the singer to project.
I'm a classical musician. This video was such a pleasure to me. I feel like, in a different world, Muharam could've been a conductor. He has very good musical instinct.
Man, ....these people have me speechless. They are so appreciative of different kinds of music. No matter how old, or how young they are. They are all very polite and they are good observers. I can learn from them.
Me too. I hope they can have our comments translated.
Yes! They have such a pure way of observing and real attention span without phone distractions!
hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha...they are people, like any other people, so yes they can appreciate music! What were you expecting, a bunch of guys saying uga uga??? hahahaha
@@andreartigas8308 say andre, if we play their traditional music to you, are you seriously trying to tell anyone that you would appreciate it? Translation for Andre "uga uga"
@@fatdad64able i have no idea if i would or not. Show me and i tell you, but i dont see the relation. The thing is that you talk about others in amazement because they behave and have the abilities that any other person has. You know what it means, dont you?
Everyone thats apart of Trybals is just so genuinely sweet and respectful. Like, you can tell, from the bottom of their hearts they respect everyone and wish well for everyone. Its just the best.
who are the tribals?????? hahahahahgahaha What is that, some underground new york group? Some english football fanatics??? hehehehehehehe
Muharam just FEELS music! I love watching him let the music flow through him. It makes me smile every single time. 💚
So much yes!
This comment so much!!!!! ♥️ He is my kindred spirit ♥️♥️♥️
Three tenors "o sole mio" Next, please 💕
I particularly appreciated the elderly guy's comments, very precise, very intelligent. Understanding and appreciating each other's culture is the real form of spiritual enrichment (while mixing everything up in one single mish-mash means killing all cultures).
agreed great comment
One of Mozart's favorite hobbies, testing the limits of the female human voice. Elizabeth performed extraordinarily.
I read that there was one soprano Mozart took a real dislike to. He wrote a part for her that alternated high and low notes, so when she sang it her head bobbed up and down like a chicken.
@@brendaconry140218th century trolling😂
There is an Indian heavy metal band that I recently found out about named Bloodywood that I think would be perfect to show these guys.
I would also like to say thank you for this channel, I have absolutely fallen in love with it. Everyone's compassion, understanding and curiosity has been extremely heartwarming to me and has helped me to lift my mood (I suffer from depression and the state of the world certainly doesn't help things) on more than one occasion and that is something that I am not fully able to express my gratitude for.
Please pass on my deepest thanks and respect to everyone who you feature on the channel for showing me that humanity and compassion are not completely gone from the world.
With love and deepest respect from England, Billy.
Their tunak tunak cover is awesome, and they probably know that song
Abdul Aziz Rind is so positive about things. I like listening to him so much. He's able to recognize the good side to everything. I wish him health and happiness for many years to come.
He also appears quite analytical and smart. Understanding the the Conductor's movements led the volume and tempo of the orchestra.
That last guy is my favorite. So calm and generous. Mohammad Riaz Jutt I think the start tagged him as.
The insight the old man had into something he encountered for the first time was admirable. It really showed his wisdom, but also his openness to new concepts.
It is very comforting that regardless of language our hearts are touched by the same aspects oin the music.
And the one fellow compared her vocal artistry to the great Pakistani Sufi singer, Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. If you haven't heard him check him out. Unbelievable.
" I'm afraid she will bite him". That just tickled me so much because he's right, she did look like she wanted to bite someone for a minute there lol. I enjoy this channel. Each of you always has an interesting observation that I may not have noticed or thought about before. Thanks to each of you.
The singer you're showing in the first screen is an Opera singer named Elizabeth Zharoff. And she happens to be my vocal coach! She teaches anyone willing to work hard, how to sing. And she has a fantastic reaction channel herself!
amazing vocals she's got! Just blew me away!
Where do you live?
@@Karawoolfe Atlanta. Elizabeth lives in Arizona, and can be found here on CZcams at The Charismatic Voice
@thecharismaticvoice
I love how sweet their comments are and how receptive to a different culture they were willing to enjoy and respect. this was very heart warming 💗
This episode brought such joy to my heart today! Thank you so much. The cherry on top was that Ms Elizabeth Zharoff actually saw the reaction and has posted a beautiful comment below. Blessings to all who read and hear! :)
The human vocal chords are a miracle!
Just 2 tiny strips .... Opera singers are like Olympic sports people - using a special select set of muscles. ... but no less extraordinary strength and training ... and artistry!
I am going to be the wise-ass here. XD
It's actually not 2 but 4 strips and 2 folds.
But yes, the human voice is amazing. Imagine a horse being able to produce as much sounds as us. Absolutely baffled.
@@MsDrientje I accept and appreciate your correct 'wise assing' :)
No less a miracle instrument regardless of actual anatomy.
And of course, diaphragm, tongue and facial etc muscles all working in trained unison.
As much as I admire e.g. opera singers, I'm utterly fascinated by ventriloquists ..and even more so by throat singers.. especially those who make 2 different concurrent harmonious sounds.
I could be mistaken, but I believe that "the old lady" who was shown applauding after the performance was the queen of Belgium and the host of the musical competition.
The official title is "Queen of Belgians", not "of Belgium". Sorry, as a Belgian I had to correct. Have a good day.
@@Leopold_van_Aubel Doh! I stand corrected. I knew the correct title but it totally slipped my mind as I wrote my comment.
@@nahadoth2087 she was española.
@@nahadoth2087 yes.
How could you not enjoy someone’s first anything? Pure absolutely pure!
I love this video!!! As someone who is studying Opera in the US, I admittedly forget that Opera and Western Music isn't the "end all be all". I love that each culture had specific music that means do many different things to their life. Thanks for sharing, this is beautiful!
A like that even though they don't fully understand what they listen to, they can still have appreciation for it and recognize the hard work.
I like Opera and I don't understand a word either lol
I can rarely understand opera even if it is sung in my native language.
@@Catlily5 Although I love music, I never understood opera. Then one day, while watching TV, I flicked onto an opera performance, and really wanted to understand the emotion it portrays. I shut off my mind, and within a minute, tears were streaming down my face. I guess trying to understand it was blocking the effect it had.
That was the only time it hit home, other than Susan Boyle singing I Dreamed a Dream from Les Miserables.
@@Caperhere The emotion is through the music rather than the lyrics.
Who does understand it? It took me half the video to get that the song is in german 😳 I am german… guess that’s what librettos are for
It always opens my eyes to the wider world, when I see the Trybals seeing something, most of us have grown up with and is quite normal to us. I also sing and studied opera for 20 years.... and their reactions bring tears to my eyes. To see the joy and slight confusion of hearing Opera for the first time. The thing about opera... you will either love it, or hate it. If you love it, it is part of your soul....like it is mine.
Where can I see your performance?
@@TRYBALS I wish I had a video to share. I performed in my local, small home town in Arkansas. I never had national fame. However, I did sing at many weddings, funerals and other special events. However, this was back in the day before everyone had a camera.
@@LadyDragonsblood Record something for them! Here's your chance.
@@brandonheald9624 I wish I could, but I don't have a way or means to do so.
I am more a rock person, but my father introduced me to Opera when I was a little girl. I studied lyrical chant to for several years too and I hope, someday, I have time to back to it again. I used to sang in a choir and it was the best part of my life when I was in my twenties.
I wish everyone could hear opera for the first time in person in a classroom or small theater. It is a different experience than a recording when you can be up close and feel the someone's operatic voice. I hope you all experience it someday!
Fantastic video! I especially loved how much they intuit CORRECTLY about the mechanisms of singing, the music itself, and the relationships between artists, conductor and audience. I could not have loved this video more. Thank you.
Dude noted her tongue wasn't moving!!!! Do you know how hard it is to get vocal students to recognize this?! Amazing.
Loved this reaction video. “What if he had to scratch an itch”. Made me laugh out loud!
lol
Elizabeth is going to love your reactions to this. As a fan of her channel I'm looking forward to her commenting on this. You all made great observations. "bite her uncle" lol!
To see the uncle in the red tunic get so excited about opera really made my day! Beautiful to see such enjoyment from anyone!
I loved how observant the are; saying she sings like birds, understanding the connection between maestro's gestures and the tonality of the music, the voice range she shows and the hardwork she has put in. These people can appreciate her and the orchestra's talent more than we could.
This video has now popped up in The Charismatic Voice's Discord. So, Elizabeth will probably see it. I hope she will, bcs this is lovely. Such respect.
I hope she does, we need to get her a Sindhi Ajrak soon
I like how you're stepping towards bohemian Rhapsody by making them aware of opera first
I would love to see them reacting to that.
I wish someone had filmed ME when I heard that song for the first time
Excellent singing, the person in the Turban I think really appreciated and understood her amazing vocal ranges.
They should react to the Queen of the Night Aria sang by Diana Damrau! It's one of the most impressive sounding arias out there and it's beautiful!
Everyone there at Trybals seem so kind and welcoming. It's a pleasure to see them enjoying the music. Thank you.
Mr Rind is my favorite by far, he seems like such an incredibly patient, open minded and humble man. And that he starts every other sentence with Sir just shows how respectful he is as well
I know but I feel bad when he calls me that. I love when he calls me "Baba" which you would call someone who's like your child
He clearly has a vast life experience based on the comments he makes. I would be very interested in hearing some of his stories one day.
@@TRYBALS I do have to say, I love the way you communicate with your audience and your relationship with them. I also love the way you explain things to them. It feels really personal compaired to other channels of this sort and I' here for it. That's what keeps me watching your videos and why I much prefer them.
@@doraspoljar697 I am pretty much the same in person, more shy though lol. I have become so comfortable around most of them that I make myself look like a silly child sometimes 😃
@@TRYBALS I think we would all also like to see you in front of the camera more often. That's why CZcams is amazing. It brings out the shy people's personalities.
The elderly gentleman wearing the turban was very respectful. He also demonstrated that the silent student learns the most, because he is the only one who knew what the conductor was doing. God bless these people.❤
Trybals and The Charismatic Voice unite! Great, how had I missed this, been a sub to both channels for months...
You must let them hear Luciano Pavarotti. May I suggest Nessum Dorma.
I already mentioned Pavarotti to Parvati and others :D
Will let them listen to it someday soon for sure
I really hope Elizabeth sees this she's so wonderful
I love that the older man in the turban. He's just like glued to the screen the entire time and then says the wisest things out of all of them. It's kind of fun.
How beautiful! I loved every comment but especially the delight in their faces as they watched this wonderful performance. Bravo to all!
Daaaang that IS Elizabeth! I’ve never heard her sing !
Her speaking voice is so soft and lower .
It's heartening how much appreciation there is here for the respect given at the end of the song: bowing, thanking the audience and the orchestra. It's not done so much in modern music and it didn't occurred to me until now how big of a deal it actually is.
Yes!! The order of the bowing is always very specific :) my experience is with choir, but in that setting typically the director bows first, moves aside, and gestures to the singers who then bow. If there is a soloist they bow second following the gesture from the director. In a solo setting, like in a recital, I always bow with one hand over my chest. It looks like I am extra appreciative of the audience, but it also serves to cover my chest so that they don’t get a full view down my gown lol. Sometimes I’ll gracefully lay my hand on the edge of the piano for a little extra balance so i don’t fall in my heels lol. You learn a lot of little tricks like that.
Wow! This is the 1st time I have listened to an Opera song all the way through.
Thank you so much everyone for teaching me something new today. 🙏
Abdul's beard is top notch! Wish I could grow mine that well. Great video by the way.
I didn't expect Elizabeth to be featured here! Awesome! 🙂
Please show them “The 3 Tenors” - Luciano Pavarotti, José Carreras, and Plácido Domingo.
Now you're talking. That was not the best introduction to opera.
Nobody is better than Pavarotti for introducing Opera.
Oooh yes!
Los tres tenores habría sido una gran elección
Or maybe Placido Domingo singing E Lucevan Le Stelle. Yeah!
These people are so generous with their praise and admiration for this music from another culture. I only hope we would show the same respect and admiration for their music.
The man with the tin hat is a real sport. His sense of appreciation is enjoyable. The man with the long beard is analytical and very dignified. These reactions show how important it is for people to become acquainted with each other's cultures, even if it is just fleeting. It builds mutual respect and understanding which harmonizes life.
sarah brightman and andrea bocelli singing time to say goodbye you want to show them that video thanks
She plays a character scorning her impending torture.
I like how freely and openly they express their appreciation. It's really uplifting to watch their reactions.
I love watching the enthusiasm of the gentleman in the red vest. He completely responded to the art. They are all so respectful.
I like to see everyone appreciate different kinds of music. It would be interesting to see how they would Mariachi music from México
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!
Oh my goodness yess!!!!
So lovely! And I hope Elizabeth does see this, I love her channel as well and it would be so awesome to see two of my favorite channels reacting to each other. ❤️
That would be cool!
I’ll bet if we posted the link on her channel she will watch !
@@ssshadowwolf6762 sure do, I sent her an email before posting this video 5 days ago but no response yet. Also sent her another email with this video and left a message on her Instagram as well. Fingers crossed
@@TRYBALS I notified her in the comment section of her latest video. Lets hope she sees and loves it! 🙏🏻🥳🥰
@@ssshadowwolf6762 I posted this in the Charismatic Voice discord as well, they will probably see this!
the best thing about these reactions is the reactors are really taking in what they are seeing and honestly listening, a lot of people don't do that, but these people are entirely about what is being shown to them out of respect.
I’m glad YT recommended this vid to me. I love opera and I’m studying ethnology because I am interested in tribal societies. And the other day I wondered: "How would they react from hearing opera ?" And now I have an answer :D Thank you
They are so wholesome. One man was so into it, it made me happy 😄
The beauty of a trybal video, is that we all the same. These are troubled times we live in. We are all both better and worse than previous generations. But when I see random people that I don't know, born half the world away, and having some of the same reactions that I do...it gives me hope.
I was a drum major in high school and I absolutely loved when he asked “what happens when you have an itch?” The simple answer, you just don’t. And most often you are too focused to ever notice something like that.
Lol, I know Michael. I was just trying to lighten up the environment. That's part of my job 😃
@@TRYBALS yea, you did great. Great video and you should look into The Magic Flute - Queen of the Night aria, if you react to more opera. Hands down, one of the best opera performances. The high notes are impressive.
This is such a heart warming video! CZcams and humanity at it's best! And YES! We all love Elizabeth! She's phenomenal at everything she does! ❤
"If someone sang like that here they'd think they were possessed ...." at time 2:33. And then Parvatti laughs. It was her true impression of opera. Many people agree with her. Opera is definitely a cultivated taste.
I love how open to new experiences you all are. After watching this one, please have them watch the duet Sull'aria Le nozze di Figaro. Makes me cry every time I hear it. The subject of the song is mundane, but the music transcends language.
Not at all ! The subject is not mundane but perfectly fits with the plot. The music doesnt trancend language...it is miraculously in full harmony with the text....and this is why it makes the listener in a feeling 9f levitation.
I sure hope that Elizabeth Zharoff sees this video and leaves a comment! 💕 I learn a lot from these people and their reactions to different things. They're observing through new eyes and always open my eyes up to things I've missed before. There is also a humanity and kindness in every one of them that touches the humanity and kindness that is often buried in others.
What a beautiful video of beautiful people! This is really who we are...all the same...we share music, language, food, and we all care for each other.
I wish I could sing for these folks although I don't opera! I sing older jazz standards! What a wonderful reaction and appreciation these folks had for her. Wonderful! I just love all these people!! I love how the one gentlemen said she was like his sister! Wow!
Please thank them for their kindness.
Congrats to The Charismatic Voice! You were superb!!!
watched her react to vids, I did not know she did opera
Opera is kind of bizarre to me, and I'm a composer and grew up with it (thanks, Bugs Bunny and music appreciation classes!), so I can only imagine how weird it must sound to these good souls. Very astute observations by all. Of course there is much more accessible "opera", including ones based on eastern music, but this was a fantastic example and performance by Elizabeth Zharoff of classical opera. This singer is a very personable performer.
I'm sad future generation won't be introduced to opera like I was. By a crossdressing rabbit.
Impressed by the dignity and openness of these pure people.
Everyone is so respectful and well spoken but mister Abdul is always the one I'm looking forward to hearing. He has great insight, he picks up every little detail really fast and says very wise things. He must have wonderful stories to share.
So interesting that you chose The Charismatic Voice for this! You definitely won't get a block or strike, lol.
What amazing observations. I've seen Elizabeth's reaction videos but have never heard her perform before. To see a complex Mozart composition performed out of context of the story it is part of...wow...Wonderful video. It is, indeed, like birdsong and, yes, I'm sure we would sound posessed to anyone not familiar with the form. LOL. Not all opera is like that...To notice that she is sweating under the hot lights and because the range, speed and power of her singing is very challenging....There is such benefit to seeing other people react to something they are seeing for the first time but is familiar to you from your culture. It gives me new eyes too. Wonderful.
Wonderfully said!
4:20 It is EXACTLY that, thank you dear sir! Firts humans were listening to birds and trying to copy them, that is exactly where music comes from. I loved this video, thank you so much for sharing it :)
These people are so humble, kind and honest. Enjoyed this!
We all need music ❤️ 👍🏻
Ha! I was just watching her react to a Tool song and this come up. She’s great. 🤘🏼
This conversation is so fascinating. It is not easy to listen to opera because it is usually in a different language. The voice itself is used as a musical instrument. But all human beings have the emotions the performers are trying to express with their voices and bodies, their hands and faces. We can follow the story telling no matter where we come from or what out culture may be, even if the performance seems very strange and new to us in our different cultures.
this channel always warms my heart
I'd love to see their feelings and reactions toward native American history, songs and dance.
Throat singing by the Inuit and their culture would be its own episode as well!
It always brightens my day to see people enjoying new thing ☺
Fascinating watching this from their perspectives. Thank you.
I do so love these videos, such respect and shared joy in experiences.
Love that a couple knew who Elizabeth is. I am sure she will adore this. ❤️
If I remember correctly, her performance here was part of a competition.
Yes, it was from a competition in England I guess
@@TRYBALS hopefully enough of us will share this with her that she watches. Going to post on her IG now. Have a blessed day.
@@TRYBALS Hi, if I refer at 8:52 we can see the former belgian's queen Fabiola, so I guess it was from the "queen elisabeth competition" a classical music competition held every year in Belgium. There is a rotation every year betwwen cello, piano and voice contestants.
It’s a supreme pleasure to to see the Trybals reacting to western opera, and Elizabeth’s commanding performance in particular. I performed with her at an LA Opera event several years ago, and now she’s a CZcams celebrity! Wild.
I am a retired opera singer and voice teacher, and Abdul Aziz Rind is correct, she is using three types of vocal ranges. That was very astute of him and indicates he has an excellent ear. Usually only people who study singing understand this.
So much to learn from them and their openness! I loved this video, thank you!
So I’d been watching Elizabeth’s The Charismatic Voice analysis videos for a while now but I’d never heard any of her actual opera performances she’s phenomenal! It’s so different than her normal speaking voice.
I suggest to watch the whole performance. The intensity in her face gets to insane levels, it's really quite impressive the amount of passion and vocal work she puts in.
Ditto
Every time I see one of these Trybals videos I am so moved by the grace and kindness of these people; their observations and the respect they demonstrate for others. It is a lesson for me. And it gives me a different perspective into my own culture. Thank you for connecting our two cultures.
Carol T., we need this in every genre and with every age group throughout the world, especially now. When we can engage in this intimate, comfortable way and learn from each other it will all "give us a different perpective into our culture and theirs." (I stole your phrase there!) Trybals is such a wonderful start!!
I just discovered this channel and I love it so much!! I also really like that it is the same people being interviewed so you feel you get to know them better.
Thanks for doing these videos. I truly feel a connection with these people. I think they are all amazing people!