I cannot comment on the more technical aspects of Anna Netrebkos voice, but I rate her extremely high because of her ability to bring the personas she portray on the scene out to us all, make them come to unforgettable life. Few in todays world of opera does exactly that better than AN. Singing isn't only about hitting the right notes absolutely spot on but is also a matter of performance.
It's really difficult to accept all the negative, at times contemptuous comments people have for Anna Netrebko, when the reaction from the audience in this video & that of those around the world, is clearly in total contrast. Of course there will always be the purists who show bias towards their own personal favourite/s & pick the bones out of all others. It's mostly cruel, unnecessary & often without foundation. I do feel the criticism of her is often rather sinister, unwarranted & nothing to do with her actual ability, but haters will hate! I listen to them all & am constantly in awe of anyone who spends their life honing a skill to her extraordinary level. For me, she is simply spectacular & an absolute delight on the ear!
@@dianasanchezbravo637 Dear Ms. Brava, i am a sorry, clumsy klutz! When i made my silly reversal word-play compliment i did not realize your surname was not Sánchez, please accept my apologies, i had no notion of offence when i made the tart remark; kind regards…s.
Анна Нетребко чудо природы. Оценивать именно эту арию и именно в этот вечер, не стану Но, все и всегда ее появление вызывает просто восторг. Ее неповторимая легкость на сцене, ее вокальная и актерская Свобода и естественность восхищают. Хочется пожелать этой исключительно одаренной певице Здоровья, покоя и радости от работы и материнства., Счастья в любви., безусловно.
Anna Netrebko ???!!! Divine voice !!! Divine soprano !!! Brilliant soprano !!! Great voice !!! Great talent !!! Great actor !!! She is simply born for the scene !!! Of course and very beautiful woman !!! Anna is Pride for Russia !!! Anna is Pride for the world culture !!! God bless the wonderful Anna Netrebko ! Always with a lot of love and light from Bulgaria
La musique est superbe, l'interprète est divine et les mots..?Réalisez tous que chanter à cette tessiture nécessite une technique parfaite et que la prononciation est secondaire."L'articulation est la mort de la musique". Alors BRAVO à cette interprète majestueuse et si professionnelle. Agnès
one argument has not been spoken about yet, she is getting new public and young people into the opera with her great voice and her strong, powerful and charming acting. Thanks FOR DOING THAT !!
What a beautiful instrument she has! Bravo! Her voice and vocal performance has moved me to tears. Just listen, enjoy her gift and hope such continual praise will not affect her.
The best Violetta I've come across, Nebtrbko's soprano encompasses all of that fach's subtypes): spinto, coloratura, lyric - an incredible performance of an aria that is really three arias with each section calling upon different vocal skills and powers. The thunderous applause is well-deserved.
INCREDIBLE BEAUTY !!! MAMA MIA SHE IS SIMPLY DIVINE !!! SIMPLY NUMBER 1 IN THE WORLD !!! BRAVO !!! BRAVO !!! ENDLESS BRAVO DEAR, DEAR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ANNA NETREBKO !!! ESPECIALLY HEART GREETINGS FOR THE FANTASTIC MUSICIANS !!! BRAVO MAESTRO !!! THE PLEASURE IS FULL !!! I LOVE YOU ENDLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESS !!! Nadya Mirkova Your eternal fan from Bulgaria
sung in 2007, July, in Paris. Audience reaction can't be ignored, they loved her. Also another way to tell, is watch the orchestra after aria has finished. If orchestra members are applauding, singing was good. Can't fool them, professional musicians. Ytube not reliable.
To have a great voice like AN is obviously only a start to a great performance in singing. She expresses the emotions in the song. That is enhanced by great acting. Hard to find another one with similar capabilities. I feel lucky to be able to listen to such a magnificent performance from the convenience of my home. Thanks for putting this performance on youTube.
Thank You Dear Anna !!! Thank You Dear musicians !!! Thank You Dear Maestro !!! I listen, listen. . . . . . . . . . . . . endless the all this beauty !!! The my heart and the my soul are full with this beauty !!! God bless You !!! God bless Your fantastic talents !!! Big, big, big thanks for very, very, very the beautiful emotions for us - the fans in all World !!! Always with a lot of love love and light Your eternal fans Nadya Mirkova and friends from Bulgaria
Her dinlediğimde tüylerimi diken diken ediyor..Hanımefendide nasıl bir ciğer var bir türlü nefesi bitmiyor..Temizlik işçiliğinden böyle bir yeteneğin keşfedilmesi bir mucize..Maşallah..Bizim de Feryal Türkoğlu'muz var çok şükür..
Its not that I haven't heard better singers, its simply that no one else makes me dream, quite like Netrebko. And maybe thats almost as important as the voice and technical abilities.
One can admire, breathless, the beauty of say the Mona Lisa, or bring one's magnifying glass to study the signs of its deterioration. Those who think that analysing opera, works of art is the right focus, have forgotten how to enjoy opera and other art. Opera, other art forms, are to immerse oneself in and experience the ecstasy. If you do not like one, jump straight out try one you can enjoy. While you argue, I continue to bathe in the delight, exhilaration of performances of Anna and others!
I agree with you. Anna has one of the most beautifull voices to come along in a long time. I don't understand the comparisons between her and Diana Damrau as they have VERY different voices. The thing is that Anna keeps singing a repertoire to light for her voice. She's becoming more and more of a full lyric soprano and just doesn't have that light and blade-like sound of coloratura sopranos.
Anna Nebtreko is one of the best sopranos of our time on my opinion. Endowed also with stunning beauty, acting ability, the gift of becoming her operatic characters, her coloratura, lyrical soprano voice is velvet, fluid and agile and shimmering silver tones. I love the very feminine Anna with the dramatic virile Rolando Villazon with whom she has such great chemistry.
@@robert111k You are correct that Netrebko does not have natural coloratura. In other respects, she is an operatic goddess. Her voice is huge, with very secure high notes. Her acting and ability to get into character is top rate. Within her physical limits, she has good vocal technique. Sure, her vocal agility cannot be compared to, say, Callas. She is still a very exciting singer.
la diva Netrebko, est un don du ciel, c'est un bonheur de la regarder et de l'ecouter, et a ceux qui parle de technique, la technique j'en ai rien a foutre.
Es un moustro!!!! su voz es de otro mundo,es imprecionante cada detalle de su tecnica, sus gestos,como actua,como matisa,como transmite sensaciones,y por supuesto su voz es explosiva,enorme,completa,hermosa...
Unbelievable voice,looks,figure,acting ability,totally charismatic,what more is there to say,the finest and most beautiful soprano I have ever heard or seen. IKnow from reading the many thousands of comments on You Tube that she has her critics, I am sorry I cannot understand why.There have been many fine sopranos both past and present but this young lady surpasses them all by a million miles.
She sings it very well and show her rich tessitura. People can pick on anything, but they can't sing it like her. She is a good model for young singers and her renditions are the best. She is highly respected in her own country too and won a President's award for contributing to Russia's international cultural standing. No way to call her performances poor.
I tend to leave all the negative comments about Anna Netrebko to the purists & refrain from reading them, preferring instead to simply enjoy listening to a voice which gives me the chills! It's all subjective & a question of personal taste anyway.
This is absolutely stunning and flawless. For you critics, you are what's wrong with Opera culture. More people attend opera to criticize the singers than to enjoy the experience. The end result has been on ongoing habit for directors and singers alike to spend less time dramatizing and embodying the character and more time standing still on stage focusing on nothing but technique. This culture of criticism has led to opera's ongoing slow death.
I agree with you, 100 percent. It should not be denied that she is a both accomplished and good singer. Whether one prefers a darker tone (like Anna's) or a lighter one, a slower vibrato (like Anna's) or a quicker one, is all a part of art's subjectivity.
She's fucking amazing and whoever says otherwise is seriously jealous. There are lots of good sops who can sing the shit out of this aria. Anna not only sings the shit out of it but this is a gorgeous voice coming out of a gorgeous woman... makes a world of difference. Love u
Remarkable... She is great, in voice and performance, taking into account that the aria is very demanding. Also, terrific couple with Rolando! (The Traviata performed in the 2006 Salzburg Festival is a jewel)
yes absolutely !!! her voice is Metallic !!!! and two metals come to mind...LIQUID MERCURY and purest GOLD !!! this is sensational on every level and in about fifty different languages !!!
Callas didn't have the greatest voice but she created a sensation with her audience. Netrebko is doing the same in our present day. She has something to say and share let her share it. Thanks for the clip!
Me gusta la Netrebko. Hermoso timbre de voz para el personaje, y ahora desde hace un tiempo hasta se anima con el mi bemol, cosa que antes no hacía; se nota que hay estudio y ensayo (le decimos profesionalismo), Muy bien.
Sorry, all this fuss about singing technique, sustaining of the voice and even looks...She may not be the best - technically speaking, she may look fantastic, but to draw a bottom line: The impact she has on her listeners' hearts and ears, the artistic depth, the sheer joy of performing is outstanding!
@@robert111k no soy presunto si que amo la opera, supongo que será alguno de sus críticos, o de los que se meten en los comentarios para armar gresca...en fin
OK people, back to what this clip is really about: the ASTOUNDING performance by Anna N of this amazing scene which, years ago, instantly converted me to opera. At the time marvelously performed by Eliana Cotrubas but I agree, comparing is pointless, this is fabulous singing and ANNA RULES!
Начинаешь слушать и невозможно оторваться. Хочется еще и еще...
Как же приятно смотреть и слушать молодую Нетребко
I cannot comment on the more technical aspects of Anna Netrebkos voice, but I rate her extremely high because of her ability to bring the personas she portray on the scene out to us all, make them come to unforgettable life. Few in todays world of opera does exactly that better than AN. Singing isn't only about hitting the right notes absolutely spot on but is also a matter of performance.
there are some who can do both. everyone should me able to do both. "a million reflexes".
Fabulous
It's really difficult to accept all the negative, at times contemptuous comments people have for Anna Netrebko, when the reaction from the audience in this video & that of those around the world, is clearly in total contrast.
Of course there will always be the purists who show bias towards their own personal favourite/s & pick the bones out of all others. It's mostly cruel, unnecessary & often without foundation.
I do feel the criticism of her is often rather sinister, unwarranted & nothing to do with her actual ability, but haters will hate!
I listen to them all & am constantly in awe of anyone who spends their life honing a skill to her extraordinary level.
For me, she is simply spectacular & an absolute delight on the ear!
@@dianasanchezbravo637 Brava!…s.
@@dianasanchezbravo637 Dear Ms. Brava, i am a sorry, clumsy klutz! When i made my silly reversal word-play compliment i did not realize your surname was not Sánchez, please accept my apologies, i had no notion of offence when i made the tart remark; kind regards…s.
she feels what she sings.That is what makes her so fantastic.
Анна Нетребко чудо природы.
Оценивать именно эту арию и именно в этот вечер, не стану
Но, все и всегда ее появление вызывает просто восторг.
Ее неповторимая легкость на сцене, ее вокальная и актерская
Свобода и естественность восхищают.
Хочется пожелать этой исключительно одаренной певице
Здоровья, покоя и радости от работы и материнства.,
Счастья в любви., безусловно.
Anna Netrebko ???!!! Divine voice !!! Divine soprano !!! Brilliant soprano !!! Great voice !!! Great talent !!! Great actor !!! She is simply born for the scene !!! Of course and very beautiful woman !!! Anna is Pride for Russia !!! Anna is Pride for the world culture !!! God bless the wonderful Anna Netrebko ! Always with a lot of love and light from Bulgaria
Nadeto Mirkova m
die Frage t
O voce care poate ajunge pana la angels.Te electrizeaza ! Superb !
La musique est superbe, l'interprète est divine et les mots..?Réalisez tous que chanter à cette tessiture nécessite une technique parfaite et que la prononciation est secondaire."L'articulation est la mort de la musique". Alors BRAVO à cette interprète majestueuse et si professionnelle. Agnès
Oui c'est un air terriblement difficile et redoutable ,et elle le sert très bien ,sans rien esquiver .
Lindo demais,que voz perfeita que ela tem,espero que continue cantando e encantando a todos a sua volta.Uma soprano excelente!!!!Bravíssima.
Grandissima vice e grandissima Interprete, mi ha commosso, non avevo mai udito una Violetta così. 🌹🌟
one argument has not been spoken about yet, she is getting new public and young people into the opera with her great voice and her strong, powerful and charming acting. Thanks FOR DOING THAT !!
Simply amazing! This part of la traviata take me away from this world. Greetings from México.
What a beautiful instrument she has! Bravo!
Her voice and vocal performance has moved me to tears.
Just listen, enjoy her gift and hope such continual praise will not affect her.
Unbelievable that a human can sing this majestic flowery notes. Bravo!
Шикарно! Великолепно! Обожаю всем сердцем!!! Счастья и Любви, АННА!
Не могу оторваться !Любимая ария в исполнении Анны!
Wow!!! What a magnificent voice!!! and what a beautiful girl!!!!!!!!!!!
Exceptionala, magnifica, frumoasa doamna Anna Netrebko si o iubesc foarte mult ! Mult succes si putere de a canta pe marile scene ale lumii
The best Violetta I've come across, Nebtrbko's soprano encompasses all of that fach's subtypes): spinto, coloratura, lyric - an incredible performance of an aria that is really three arias with each section calling upon different vocal skills and powers. The thunderous applause is well-deserved.
😂🤣🤣 what???
@@maximillian6222 probably he's deaf🙉
INCREDIBLE BEAUTY !!! MAMA MIA SHE IS SIMPLY DIVINE !!! SIMPLY NUMBER 1 IN THE WORLD !!! BRAVO !!! BRAVO !!! ENDLESS BRAVO DEAR, DEAR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ANNA NETREBKO !!! ESPECIALLY HEART GREETINGS FOR THE FANTASTIC MUSICIANS !!! BRAVO MAESTRO !!! THE PLEASURE IS FULL !!! I LOVE YOU ENDLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESS !!! Nadya Mirkova Your eternal fan from Bulgaria
sung in 2007, July, in Paris. Audience reaction can't be ignored, they loved her. Also another way to tell, is watch the orchestra after aria has finished. If orchestra members are applauding, singing was good. Can't fool them, professional musicians. Ytube not reliable.
To have a great voice like AN is obviously only a start to a great performance in singing. She expresses the emotions in the song. That is enhanced by great acting. Hard to find another one with similar capabilities. I feel lucky to be able to listen to such a magnificent performance from the convenience of my home. Thanks for putting this performance on youTube.
Thank You Dear Anna !!! Thank You Dear musicians !!! Thank You Dear Maestro !!! I listen, listen. . . . . . . . . . . . . endless the all this beauty !!! The my heart and the my soul are full with this beauty !!! God bless You !!! God bless Your fantastic talents !!! Big, big, big thanks for very, very, very the beautiful emotions for us - the fans in all World !!! Always with a lot of love love and light Your eternal fans Nadya Mirkova and friends from Bulgaria
loving the drama and the power in her performance
Anna is wonderful beyond my expectation and fun.
Brava.
All energy and power and quality.
Never be another like this.
Love Anna and Rolando! They really inspired each other!
What an amazing performance, talent and extraordinary music. Bravo to Verdi, Anna and the Orchestra - and sound recording - BRILLIANCE !!
De toute beauté. Quelle incroyable soprano !
Красавица ! Голос ! Талант !
Мы гордимся тобой !!!
Maravillosa, la mejor, la unica, 1er. Premio del Awards de Opera.
The perfect voice, and appearance, for this aria. Thank you Verdi for composing it.
Her dinlediğimde tüylerimi diken diken ediyor..Hanımefendide nasıl bir ciğer var bir türlü nefesi bitmiyor..Temizlik işçiliğinden böyle bir yeteneğin keşfedilmesi bir mucize..Maşallah..Bizim de Feryal Türkoğlu'muz var çok şükür..
Its not that I haven't heard better singers, its simply that no one else makes me dream, quite like Netrebko. And maybe thats almost as important as the voice and technical abilities.
SUPERB! GREAT NETREBKO!
MAGNIFIC !
Her best years ❣️❣️
FANTASTICA ANNA!!!!!!!!!
One of the best performances of her
*"..of hers"
Trevor T of her best:) loved that CD back in 2000s
That’s true ... but this doesn’t mean she’s good
Fantastic...Yes!
@@operafan9162 Why? You got my attention.
One of God gifted voice..❤️🙏
Bravíssima! Simplesmente maravilhosa. Queria muito assistir também as outras árias deste recital.
Eu tenho. Feliz divanato pra vc tb.
Assolutamente ha ragione, bellissima e brava!
Pochi soprano riescono a fare questi acuti, quindi mia cara sei stupenda!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Outstanding performance! Amazing voice.
I did not know this was humanly possible, she blew my mind! I love her.
Me too -- she lifts me of the chair even when I watch youtube - let alone when I watch her live
Sem dúvida uma gas grandes vozes do nosso tempo
прекрасная музыка в прекрасном исполнении..Браво!!!!
Fantástica Anna y bellísima
One can admire, breathless, the beauty of say the Mona Lisa,
or bring one's magnifying glass to study the signs of its deterioration.
Those who think that analysing opera, works of art is the right focus,
have forgotten how to enjoy opera and other art.
Opera, other art forms, are to immerse oneself in and experience the ecstasy.
If you do not like one, jump straight out try one you can enjoy.
While you argue, I continue to bathe in the delight, exhilaration of performances of Anna and others!
c'est du Netrebko, c'est marveilleux a entendre et a regarder...n'en deplaise au grincheux qui viennent poluer les vidéos de la magnifique Anna.
Она не просто хорошо поет - она постоянно в образе, даже в концерте это не демонстрация вокальных данных и платья, а настоящая живая Виолетта.
I think, it`s her best interpretation of this song on CZcams. BRAVA!!!
You must have good sense of humour.
Awesome. She nailed it!
I agree with you. Anna has one of the most beautifull voices to come along in a long time. I don't understand the comparisons between her and Diana Damrau as they have VERY different voices. The thing is that Anna keeps singing a repertoire to light for her voice. She's becoming more and more of a full lyric soprano and just doesn't have that light and blade-like sound of coloratura sopranos.
barleggero `
gyönyörű, köszönöm. élmény volt.
Bravissimo Anna you have mastered the finest art in the world, love those high notes.
Hands down one of the best arias ever written.
Anna Nebtreko is one of the best sopranos of our time on my opinion.
Endowed also with stunning beauty, acting ability, the gift of becoming her operatic characters, her coloratura, lyrical soprano voice is velvet, fluid and agile and shimmering silver tones.
I love the very feminine Anna with the dramatic virile Rolando Villazon with whom she has such great chemistry.
Coloratura? Agile? Have you ever listened to this aria sung by somebody who masters the craft?
@@robert111k You are correct that Netrebko does not have natural coloratura. In other respects, she is an operatic goddess. Her voice is huge, with very secure high notes. Her acting and ability to get into character is top rate. Within her physical limits, she has good vocal technique. Sure, her vocal agility cannot be compared to, say, Callas. She is still a very exciting singer.
Her have always loved her Traviata...
Anna has both looks and voice! A perfect combo!
I love Anna!!! She is one of the best opera singers I have heard!!
just beautifull!
il bel canto all'ennesima potenza. Meravigliosa!
i love her voice and performance! i love her love her!
la diva Netrebko, est un don du ciel, c'est un bonheur de la regarder et de l'ecouter, et a ceux qui parle de technique, la technique j'en ai rien a foutre.
Astonishing. Merveilleux
Обожаю Анну Нетребко за её талант и красоту
I LOVE HER!!!
Es un moustro!!!! su voz es de otro mundo,es imprecionante cada detalle de su tecnica, sus gestos,como actua,como matisa,como transmite sensaciones,y por supuesto su voz es explosiva,enorme,completa,hermosa...
Qué disparate.
Unbelievable voice,looks,figure,acting ability,totally charismatic,what more is there to say,the finest and most beautiful soprano I have ever heard or seen. IKnow from reading the many thousands of comments on You Tube that she has her critics, I am sorry I cannot understand why.There have been many fine sopranos both past and present but this young lady surpasses them all by a million miles.
She sings it very well and show her rich tessitura. People can pick on anything, but they can't sing it like her. She is a good model for young singers and her renditions are the best. She is highly respected in her own country too and won a President's award for contributing to Russia's international cultural standing. No way to call her performances poor.
Божествено!!
божественно вот так будет по русски
Fantastic!!!!
She comes v close to Verdi's adorable heroine, I think. All the depth of her personality.. in the music... is there. Brava, Anna!!!
No, it is not. Netrebko was never agile enough for Violetta.
I tend to leave all the negative comments about Anna Netrebko to the purists & refrain from reading them, preferring instead to simply enjoy listening to a voice which gives me the chills! It's all subjective & a question of personal taste anyway.
Ana Netrebko的女高音歌唱家声音很振撼！享受！👍🌹
This is absolutely stunning and flawless. For you critics, you are what's wrong with Opera culture. More people attend opera to criticize the singers than to enjoy the experience. The end result has been on ongoing habit for directors and singers alike to spend less time dramatizing and embodying the character and more time standing still on stage focusing on nothing but technique. This culture of criticism has led to opera's ongoing slow death.
I agree with you, 100 percent. It should not be denied that she is a both accomplished and good singer. Whether one prefers a darker tone (like Anna's) or a lighter one, a slower vibrato (like Anna's) or a quicker one, is all a part of art's subjectivity.
She's fucking amazing and whoever says otherwise is seriously jealous. There are lots of good sops who can sing the shit out of this aria. Anna not only sings the shit out of it but this is a gorgeous voice coming out of a gorgeous woman... makes a world of difference. Love u
This is close to perfect. Her voice is absolutely fitted for this kind of pieces. Wonderful!!
Es una bella voz ,bella figura, studiosa y se pone retos y los esta cumpliendo canta mucho mejor que en el 2003. Felicitaciones!!!!
Remarkable... She is great, in voice and performance, taking into account that the aria is very demanding. Also, terrific couple with Rolando! (The Traviata performed in the 2006 Salzburg Festival is a jewel)
Maravillosa interpretación
yes absolutely !!! her voice is Metallic !!!! and two metals come to mind...LIQUID MERCURY and purest GOLD !!! this is sensational on every level and in about fifty different languages !!!
Callas didn't have the greatest voice but she created a sensation with her audience. Netrebko is doing the same in our present day. She has something to say and share let her share it. Thanks for the clip!
The power of those notes just capture my soul.
Me gusta la Netrebko.
Hermoso timbre de voz para el personaje, y ahora desde hace un tiempo hasta se anima con el mi bemol, cosa que antes no hacía; se nota que hay estudio y ensayo (le decimos profesionalismo),
Muy bien.
Sorry, all this fuss about singing technique, sustaining of the voice and even looks...She may not be the best - technically speaking, she may look fantastic, but to draw a bottom line: The impact she has on her listeners' hearts and ears, the artistic depth, the sheer joy of performing is outstanding!
Eterna Ana 💖
Cuando se retire los que amamos la opera quedaremos huérfanos. Larga vida a la Diosa.
Maedelamorhermoso, a lo que ha llegado la ópera cuando sus presuntos amantes dicen estas... cosas.
@@robert111k no soy presunto si que amo la opera, supongo que será alguno de sus críticos, o de los que se meten en los comentarios para armar gresca...en fin
REally this is amazing!!! I loveeee her!!!!!
Impeccable - as good as it gets!!!
absolutely amazing!
OK people, back to what this clip is really about: the ASTOUNDING performance by Anna N of this amazing scene which, years ago, instantly converted me to opera. At the time marvelously performed by Eliana Cotrubas but I agree, comparing is pointless, this is fabulous singing and ANNA RULES!
BRAVİSSİMA...
Bellisimo! Bravo Anna!
Stupenda! E che finale... da pelle d'oca!
Gyönyörűséges, erőteljes, éteri hang öröm nézni és hallgatni.
A powerful soprano in her best..I think her interpretation as Violetta is one of the best.
No, it is not.
Maravilloso!!!!
tand de beauté, tand de talent, une voix sublime, je comprend qu'il y a des jaloux.
Great Performances!! I love you Anna Netrebko!!
I surpose, that her voice is the best!!!!!!