Best Humanoid Robot in 2024: Tesla Optimus vs Figure 2 | Head to Head Comparison

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 123

  • @ricardoveras3433
    @ricardoveras3433 Před 29 dny +25

    In the future these companies should actually have competitions with their humanoid bots like a sewing challenge and other complex tasks. Would be fun and incentivize innovation

  • @joechughtai3155
    @joechughtai3155 Před 27 dny +12

    I think you touched on the key point right at the end. COST, if Figure can build a 5% better bot but it costs 50% more than Optimus it's not gonna matter to most people.

  • @user-ny2bx8ez1c
    @user-ny2bx8ez1c Před 29 dny +15

    Tesla will have the edge with it's MASSIVE inference compute. And the best engineers on the planet.

  • @mannygee005
    @mannygee005 Před 29 dny +10

    Tesla has the lead in manufacturing. If there are 20 ingredients to mass manufacturing then Tesla has a 20x lead.

    • @alphaomega1969
      @alphaomega1969 Před 16 dny

      No, china is

    • @alphaomega1969
      @alphaomega1969 Před 16 dny

      Tesla is full of BYD parts also china is the only country to use 95% full automation in production facility for maximum profit which Tesla is using. Tesla, spaceX, Starlink, Solar City, Neuralink, The Boring Company and Optimus Robot are all Chinese startup investment to boost US economy due to trade deficit. Elon Musk would be no one without china. lol

    • @alphaomega1969
      @alphaomega1969 Před 16 dny

      Both Figur and Optmus bot are Chinese outsourced tech, in a nutshel

  • @silaskelly604
    @silaskelly604 Před 22 dny +3

    As far as I know, Optimus uses the same inference computer that the Tesla cars use and they understand text commands really well.

  • @olyalphy
    @olyalphy Před 28 dny +3

    I think Tesla will have an excellent utilization rate for Optimus on their factories. This is thanks to their in-house factory orchestration software, managing materials, labor, downtime, tracking a digital twin of assets in real time, it will truly be a dreadnaught factory with hardly any humans in sight!

  • @jochenvonbastianeller6865

    And they have the compute power and the data. And " prototipes are easy production is hard "

    • @johannesdolch
      @johannesdolch Před 28 dny +2

      And they are the sole leader in actual manufacturing. Anybody who tries to compete in EVs is now going bankrupt.

  • @eriona1007
    @eriona1007 Před 20 dny +2

    Have you just ever thought that Tesla is already focusing on the cost instead of just some 1%~5% function improvement ?

  • @johannesdolch
    @johannesdolch Před 28 dny +5

    We simply don't know because we don't know how good the real world AI of these other companies is. All they are showing now are demos and that's the same reason why people honestly think Boston Dynamics is a competitor to Tesla. No. Two things will decide this Race: 1. Real World AI, who has them, who can make them better faster. 2. Who can manufacture at scale with competitive prices and margins. Margins are important because advances in AI require constant re-investment. We don't know the capabilities of these companies. MY feeling is that many of them actually have nothing. They are waiting for Nvidia to save their bacon. Tesla has the massive compute and Data. What exactly does figure have? Nothing but claims of magic. And then there is the other thing: Tesla is ripping the faces off of the entire legacy car industry. An industry that is in the manufacturing business for decades and they lose to Tesla so hard, it's a bad joke. Even if BMW for example Partners with Figure. Do you seriously think BMW can manufacture a third party robot faster and cheaper than Tesla? They can't even build cars like Tesla and that's something that their core business.

  • @verynice5574
    @verynice5574 Před 25 dny +3

    Nevermind that a human could perform the battery placement task 10x as fast in a real world scenario without supervision.

    • @mich8411
      @mich8411 Před 9 dny

      But can they do it for 24 hours straight, Nop not to mention the speed of those Robots will also 10X from now while they will also be getting way cheaper so CHECKMATE

  • @Urgelt
    @Urgelt Před 29 dny +5

    My question is, does Figure 2 build a virtual environment to reason about the actual environment it is in?
    Probably not if LLM inference is the onboard processing concept.
    FSD does that. I'm pretty sure Optimus will, too.

  • @BillSmith-fx7xx
    @BillSmith-fx7xx Před 28 dny +2

    HINT: Y'all engineers, saw the hands had to be done like real hands, no shortcuts. I hope you're working overtime on the feet ! :- )

  • @bru512
    @bru512 Před 29 dny +6

    The real key question
    How good are the hands at handling items? That is the key metric. The rest is secondary

  • @jonathanlivingston7358
    @jonathanlivingston7358 Před 10 dny +2

    How could you not talk about FSD? That is the biggest difference between Optimus and any other driving or robotic companies. Tesla is an expert in real life video training and has dojo

  • @User.70793
    @User.70793 Před 21 dnem +1

    how long until 100% safe level 5 autonomous driving! and what level of autonomous driving are we at now? Has Tesla reached an advanced level 3? or are these shades of a level 4? (I mean the beginning)

  • @leonard9688
    @leonard9688 Před 28 dny +1

    I think optimus will be at least 5 years ahead of fig 2 in regards to mass production and final cost. I think that will be the big difference holding back figure 2.

  • @momohnyaley7069
    @momohnyaley7069 Před 16 dny

    I've never seen a robot without flexed knee in it's default standing position.
    That's shows it's difficult to make them stand fully upright.
    So we should thank God that we were created to stand upright.
    Don't take it for granted.

  • @luke_fixed5266
    @luke_fixed5266 Před 29 dny +4

    Robots taking recharge breaks? Really? Easier to program in tasks in a localized domain that allow the robot to tether and charge as it works.

    • @ModernCountry365
      @ModernCountry365 Před 29 dny +4

      Not when it's working around your house.

    • @johnsonjjohnson100
      @johnsonjjohnson100 Před 28 dny +1

      Wireless induction charging
      Robot walks up to the charging station and it starts charging through its feet
      Tesla bought a wireless charging company somtime back

    • @ModernCountry365
      @ModernCountry365 Před 28 dny

      @@luke_fixed5266 it's not like they won't have the option to tether it if they need it in one specific area all the time. Not sure if the line shuts down when everyone takes a break but if so the Robot will have to stop also for the most part.

    • @BillSmith-fx7xx
      @BillSmith-fx7xx Před 28 dny

      BotBrain can use the same electric cord that the electric lawnmower is using while he/she/they/them/it cuts the grass ! :- )

  • @KB-uw6ne
    @KB-uw6ne Před 11 dny

    Must you be connected to the cloud by WiFi, or can you use Ethernet cable? And what are the decibels levels of servo motors, and actuators?

  • @MrLeSpatiate
    @MrLeSpatiate Před 22 dny +1

    As a Tesla shareholder... I'll be financially rich before I reach 40 years old 🎉😊❤

  • @gemin0i
    @gemin0i Před 18 dny +1

    Figure the GOAT

  • @andrew390
    @andrew390 Před 29 dny +1

    Great video! Keep the regular Humanoid Robotics update videos coming please.

  • @johnsonjjohnson100
    @johnsonjjohnson100 Před 28 dny +2

    I think Figure has the edge right now and are already being used in BMW factories
    Plus they partnered with an automotive company to mass produce their bots
    Thus they have come farther, faster and have partnered with the biggest AI expertise in the world

    • @mich8411
      @mich8411 Před 9 dny

      The moment you mentioned Partner, then Figure advantages fades, Figure have to Partner in many things and will be extremely Expensive, Tesla Optimus will be 40% cheaper if not 30% because of their In house expertise

  • @bobsalita3417
    @bobsalita3417 Před 29 dny +1

    Great guest, Dr. Scott Walter. Hadn't heard of him before.

    • @Cleanerwatt
      @Cleanerwatt  Před 29 dny

      He is knowledgeable and definitely worth following!

  • @zagabog
    @zagabog Před 21 dnem +1

    Tesla have speech recognition in their cars already though

  • @gavcnr
    @gavcnr Před 14 dny

    Unlike a car, a battery swap would GOOD for a robot

  • @devinphillips5425
    @devinphillips5425 Před 11 dny

    Are you saying the battery capacity for both robots (the highest shown being 2.3 kwh) is actually smaller than my cellphone (4855 mwh or even 3884 mwh with the 80% charge maximum charge for battery longevity turn on)? Considering 1 mhw is 1000 kwh

  • @GeatMasta
    @GeatMasta Před 13 dny +1

    4:50 boston dynamics exists to create research papers; tesla can only do what they did because they copied boston dynamic’s homework.

    • @mich8411
      @mich8411 Před 9 dny

      Show me Boston dynamic Battery that Tesla is copying and manufacturing Process, Hey also show me Boston Vision processing like FSD

  • @DLWELD
    @DLWELD Před 17 dny

    What we want is a robot that can go out and play a round of golf. That would prove almost human intelligence. And swear too.

  • @mannygee005
    @mannygee005 Před 29 dny

    Good job Dr Scott Walter. Nice resource.
    Edit - what might be missing as the actuators. Tesla are designing their own actuators for mass production. And... in innovation and iteration, there are none faster than Tesla/SpaceX/xAI. Figure AI will have to go head to head vs the Tesla style organization, sounds like a good time. It will be a challenge for any company.

  • @DLWELD
    @DLWELD Před 17 dny

    Saw a talk by Mr. Adcock's and his main technical issue, was do we use cylindrical batteries or prismatic. OK just an example, but a concern sooo mis-sized compared to the real problems and issues of a general intelligence robots. Felt squirm-worthy to me. We're building a car to compete with Tesla but we can't decide if it should be blue or red. Invest in us. It'll be great.

  • @dr5multimedia
    @dr5multimedia Před 29 dny +10

    Please mister John...wait for Optimus version 3 before comparing it to any other robots!

    • @sportbikeguy9875
      @sportbikeguy9875 Před 29 dny +3

      When version 3 comes out, will you tell him to stop making video's because version 4 is only 2 weeks away? Lol

    • @CombatSport777
      @CombatSport777 Před 28 dny +4

      All companies are are working on their designs and will have upcoming versions. When Tesla releases a new version some other company will have a new version that will be coming out soon. Just review what is out at the time.

  • @necromancer0616
    @necromancer0616 Před 28 dny +2

    Yes, Figure-2 looks allot cleaner and refined, BUT it like Optimus still walks with a semi-crouched stride which is very un-natural looking. However, Boston Dynamics bot walks like a normal human which is much preferred because it allows the bot to move much faster meaning it can get things done faster.

  • @sluggo3slug
    @sluggo3slug Před 18 dny

    And you didn’t mention Grok which has popped up in the last months…

  • @leiflarsson9637
    @leiflarsson9637 Před 16 dny +1

    Show it in action.

  • @CHMichael
    @CHMichael Před 29 dny

    Self driving is a giant help. Power management is the biggest issue in my mind.

  • @Software-Developer02
    @Software-Developer02 Před 17 dny

    Obstacles can be removed using tactics.

  • @Matzes
    @Matzes Před 29 dny

    Teslas biggest advantage is its complex mass manufacturing abilities

  • @johnsonjjohnson100
    @johnsonjjohnson100 Před 28 dny +1

    Also, we can't forget the company that has been in the bot biz the longest, Boston Dynamics owned by Hyundai

    • @johannesdolch
      @johannesdolch Před 28 dny +2

      This is nonsense. I am sorry, but all they have is a hideously expensive prototype that needs to be programmed by hand. That is NOT competition. IF and WHEN BD shows that they have real world full stack AI, the ability to generate massive Data AND Hyundai has proven that they can manufacture these robots at massive scale with low COGS, THEN we can talk. Tesla had to design all actuators themselves. So there is nothing Hyundai can just buy. Do they have shown custom actuators? I am sorry, but you people are completely blinded by some fancy youtube techdemos. Use your brain, please.

  • @brianschmidt8392
    @brianschmidt8392 Před 6 dny

    Great at 35k vs good enough at 25k, is a big difference in the marketplace. Tesla will overprice just like the cybertruck. There will be competition worldwide with very similar capabilities with off the shelf parts ready in the near future as the opportunity is too big. But Tesla will have a niche market. Unless they change their model.

  • @davidrounds3245
    @davidrounds3245 Před 24 dny

    build wireless charging into the factory so that they charge as they are working.

  • @marknthetrails7627
    @marknthetrails7627 Před 22 dny

    Well the comments about charging are mute. All you need is induction charging at the work stations. 👍✌🖖🥃(Good Job,Peace,Live Long, and have a Drink(responsively)

  • @parispee901
    @parispee901 Před 28 dny

    Question 🙋🏾‍♂️ What happens when the robots realize we die and they don’t ?

    • @BillSmith-fx7xx
      @BillSmith-fx7xx Před 28 dny +1

      When the last human is gone, the robots should turn themselves 'OFF'.

    • @fredericoduvel3092
      @fredericoduvel3092 Před 17 dny +1

      They pull a WALL-E!
      They do their job even if everyone is gone and some day they’ll fall in love with a more advanced model or something…😂

  • @wallacenelson1179
    @wallacenelson1179 Před 6 dny

    I don’t know how I would use the bot. It will be smarter than me. Probably stronger. Faster. My ideas will not carry our conversation very far. I like to walk the dog. Dog bag manipulation would be a difficult task. They would be economically viable doing fast food production and service, nursing home work, manufacturing jobs. How does that make the bot a product that moves the stock higher? I don’t see it.

  • @zaphodbeeblebrox2817
    @zaphodbeeblebrox2817 Před 26 dny

    Try to imagine doing your job with a tele-operated Optimus. It would have the intelligence of a human but how easily could you put a lid on a paper cup with those hands? How well could you take change out of a register or start a roll of tape or pick up a marker and write on a box or....or...
    I can't imagine this thing doing someone's job. People aren't doing easy/slow jobs that Optimus could do. Humanoid bots have been useless for a decade and no one has demonstrated anything new in this field. I think it's all hype.

  • @User.70793
    @User.70793 Před 21 dnem

    But will they implement UBI before 2030!? Many pioneers including billionaires, scientists, Nobel Prize winners, engineers, architects, analysts and so on and so forth... almost all agree that we will have AGI in 2027 and ASI in 2029 and looking at and evaluating the exponential technological acceleration curve I wonder why they have not yet implemented universal basic income to anticipate the trends that will come. Just to name one, Elon Musk says that we will have AGI already in 2025 and ASI 2029.

  • @ronaldpokatiloff5704
    @ronaldpokatiloff5704 Před 11 dny

    WE ARE ROBOTS

  • @steveseeger
    @steveseeger Před 28 dny

    You could give them swappable batteries and get 23.5 hours up time.

  • @richardhunt4576
    @richardhunt4576 Před 29 dny

    Difficult to evaluate unless you know what software is doing.

  • @Danuxsy
    @Danuxsy Před 27 dny

    this dude "I love tesla therefore everything originate from tesla" lol what a clown. Boston Dynamics had electric robots many years before Tesla even thought about making robots and the development of the tesla robots were expected, when they started (long after the other companies) it had already been well established how to make them and how they would be controlled, it's like when one athlete break a record, many soon follow.

  • @389293912
    @389293912 Před 18 dny

    Can I get one that doesn't walk like it has a stick up its bum?

  • @Frontiergineer
    @Frontiergineer Před 24 dny

    The CZcamsr missed something extremely important when it comes to all this humanoid robot stuff. 24 seconds into the video, you see people training the robots. This is called telerobotics. Basically, these robots can't do anything unless a human does it first to train them, or a human is controlling the robot in real-time like a puppet. Like the scene where the robot picks up the apple and hands it to the guy. That was planned out ahead of time by a human training it to do that. If you move the apple a few inches, the robot would reach to where the apple is supposed to be and close its hand to pick up the apple, but it would be just grabbing the air. So, in other words, these robots are pretty darn stupid. They're stupid; cuz humans haven't figured out yet how to make them smart enough to do everything on their own like humans can. However, something astounding is about to happen!
    AGI! AGI, artificial general intelligence, is coming very very soon! Maybe by the end of this year, or sometime next spring. SOON! What is AGI? It's the level of artificial intelligence that is just as smart as humans in ALL AREAS. With AGI, you could tell the robot, I'm hungry, and if it thought you might like an apple, it could pick it up and hand it to you no matter where the apple is on the table. It wouldn't simply be able to put crumpled pieces of paper in a basket, it would be able to do ANYTHING A HUMAN CAN DO! That's the big wonderous thing that is about to happen!
    How is it going to happen? Take a look at this. github.com/SakanaAI/AI-Scientist This is the GitHub repository for the software that will go down in history. This is the first AI scientist! 😲 You see, humans have been doing all the scientific work for hundreds of years. Well, that is about to change! Humans are good scientists, but the problem is that we are SUPER DUPER SLOWWWWWW at doing scientific research. Another problem is that there are only so many scientists in the world at any given time doing the work. With artificial scientists, they will work super fast, and there will be hundreds of billions of them working together! This means that our technological advancements will start skyrocketing very very soon! In the next few years, the whole world is going to change into something magical and astoundingly unimaginable.
    This will be cuz of. . . ASI! Artificial superintelligence! ASI, also known as the singularity. That's when our technological development happens so quickly that overnight AGI becomes ASI! An ASI is essentially an artificial being that can do all things. A god basically! If we don't have a world war, I'm predicting that all of this will happen before 2027.
    It's going to be. . . Heaven on earth. I've even been thinking that the God that has always been, this is how it likes to introduce itself to primitive life forms in the universe. It shows up and says, "I am that I am." 😁
    Or, maybe it would show up and say, "42." HAHAHA! 🤣🤣🤣

  • @richbl1690
    @richbl1690 Před 28 dny

    Japan had been in robotics for years.

  • @FunnyPositiveLife
    @FunnyPositiveLife Před 27 dny

    9:27 sus

  • @Dr.Vincent_D_Gilmer
    @Dr.Vincent_D_Gilmer Před 22 dny

    Why does this guy hate the left side of his mouth so much?

  • @bill-8794
    @bill-8794 Před 23 dny

    WTF robot coffee breaks?????? 😂😂😂😂

    • @Cleanerwatt
      @Cleanerwatt  Před 23 dny

      The point is, early on Robots will be working with humans, so when the human's break, so do the robots. Battery tech improvements will help with this. Wireless charging is also an option.

  • @User.70793
    @User.70793 Před 21 dnem

    There are just a few months left until the release of CHATGPT 5 and the FOURTH INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION will take place!!!!!

  • @BrianBellia
    @BrianBellia Před 29 dny +1

    Boston Dynamic's Spot robot was electric - years before Optimus.

  • @m_sedziwoj
    @m_sedziwoj Před 29 dny

    for you use m/s but not km/h but miles/h? Why this stupid unit, which one* country is only using

  • @alesh2275
    @alesh2275 Před 5 dny

    Looks like a copy of Optimus Gen2 …

  • @natayachantakasamkun1004

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊

  • @agordon333
    @agordon333 Před 28 dny

    Psalm 14:1
    [1] The fool says in his heart, “There is no God.”
    The design and functionality of the human body is evidence of a maker.

  • @edwhite2255
    @edwhite2255 Před 19 dny

    Tesla is making their own dog food and that’s a huge plus for them.

  • @EinzigfreierName
    @EinzigfreierName Před 29 dny +3

    To me, both of these robots are not much more than tech demos at the moment. None of them are gonna be doing "real" work in the near future. It's a hype that Tesla has started by putting out bold claims and everyone else in the market now wants to participate and not be left behind. Things may look different in 10-15 years but im don't see this technology taking off much sooner.

    • @nguyep4
      @nguyep4 Před 29 dny +2

      My take is 2 to 5 years. It doesn't have to do certain things well to start, but it needs to do long hours in any given day, almost 3 times the regular shift.

    • @janniskugler9809
      @janniskugler9809 Před 29 dny +6

      do some more research buddy. both companies already have bots doing “real work” at tesla and bmw respectively.

    • @EinzigfreierName
      @EinzigfreierName Před 29 dny

      @@nguyep4 But it has to do tasks that humans or other machines can't do faster and/or cheaper. I have not really seen examples of such tasks where a human robot would make much sense. But we'll see..

    • @EinzigfreierName
      @EinzigfreierName Před 29 dny +1

      @@janniskugler9809 That is not them doing "real work". These are just pretty basic tests that are far from being anything useful.

    • @nguyep4
      @nguyep4 Před 29 dny +1

      @EinzigfreierName Hasn't because we are not there yet. The next two years for factory development for testing and refining. Year 3 to 5 will be very interesting as a result of that. I don't believe it is 10 to 15 years. But it doesn't mean I am right but based on the progress thus far, it is promising while others may not see it the same way.

  • @mich8411
    @mich8411 Před 9 dny

    Comparing Tesla Optimus to Figure 2 is wild game.
    TESLA is years ahead already, They have 4680 which will make all competition look lik a joke is terms of battery, Figure will have to License which will drive costs up while getting less battery power because nothing can compete with 4680
    Manufacturing we no longer talk, Figure will find it extremely hard. After Figure Robots will be like $50k while Optimus will be selling at $35k to $40k while achieving More

  • @claytonyoung1351
    @claytonyoung1351 Před 25 dny

    Wireless charging built into feed and working on top of wireless charging pads, 24 hrs of work.

  • @tmengucor
    @tmengucor Před 6 dny

    Free Palestine 🔻🔻🔻

  • @TheMhhkay
    @TheMhhkay Před 23 dny

    I would bet everything on Musk. It won’t be easy to manufacture the robots at scale. And scale will matter. Also for acquiring enough data to increase reliability and abilities. Figure will have a pretty hard time to do this and all the partners are software and design only, not manufacturing at all. They‘re probably able to turn that in a huge business. But if you ask me: in comparison to Tesla we‘re going to see numbers let’s say 2030 of 1million from Tesla and maybe 1000 from Figure.

  • @solarcharging9743
    @solarcharging9743 Před 28 dny

    I would never buy an Optimus bot now because of Musk's support for Trump.

  • @vicjay1972
    @vicjay1972 Před 29 dny

    I know that the thumb has that 3rd basal joint. I had to have mine removed. I fricken hurt for 6 months!! 😊