TOBY, TRUCKS & TROUBLE (RWS vs T&F) (Spot the Differences)
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2024
- The Railway Series #32
Thomas & Friends: Special Attraction
The soundtrack of this video are cover versions of music created by Mike O'Donnell & Junior Campbell: / mavism
Hard to believe you’ve reached the end! Been following this series since 2018 and I’m glad to see you complete it!
And maybe stories like Edward the really useful engine was a complete rewrite of super rescue.
It wasn’t a bad episode, but if that was the case, I wish they went with the original version.
@@ciarangleeson2880 yeah
@@ciarangleeson2880 like Derek as bear
Yeah likewise I completely forgot this was the last book to be half adapted for television he’s has indeed reached the end!
It's hard to believe we're really at the end! Been following this series for so long!
I do hope you do one last comparison with "The Adventure Begins" movie since it was a retelling of the first two books, but if this is the last video, I'll be happy with it!
Bulstrode also returned to the new reboot show around the same year it started, after 26 years of his absence in the T&F franchise. And his personality was changed from grumpy and disagreeable to a kind barge.
😐
He almost returned for the last few seasons of the model series, but his model wasn’t built due to budget cuts.
@@ciarangleeson2880 i know
I wish there was a story were Sir Topham Hatt finds Bulstrode and gives him a new job back in the water. Similar to Bulgy Rides Again.
@@mariobabbo3497 I guess we can assume that happened off screen hence the change in personality
And… that’s it. That’s all the books. Except maybe the spin-off books like Christmas Party and Missing Christmas Tree. Great series Jeffrey
Edit: Yup, thought so
But that’s another story
We’ve still got the 2 Christmas books adaptations, and also not forgetting The Adventure Begins!
Regardless, I am very surprised this final main Railway Series comparison ended on a high note! Thank you The Finest Cocoa, you really showed your stuff!
Can't believe it's over!
I will definatly miss this series, these videos always made my evenings better.
Same
Wow, we’ve finally reached the end of the Railway Series adaptations. What a journey!
On one hand I'm kind of sad to see this series end but on the other hand judging by the end of the video it shows that you'll be taking a look at the one-off annual stories. But in the meantime I begged the series a good day.
Thank you so much for this series! I've been watching for years! As for this adaptation, what a strange one it was. Weird how Percy basically got away with trying to drown a sentient boat (unintentionally, yes, but it would seem he should have at least been given a stern talking-to). I wonder if maybe they never adapted the Mavis story because they thought it was too frightening and perhaps they thought Toby derailing was too similar to Thomas Gets Bumped and Time for Trouble.
Well done on wrapping up to all the main books of The Railway Series, compared with the TV series. I remember reading the book with my grandparents on my dad's side...but forgot how different it was, having never had the book myself. And real shame to see that, alongside The Small Railway Engines, being one of the last books to be adapted, before Mattel has replaced Thomas & Friends with All Engines Go now. And I thought "Special Attraction" was pretty nice.
are you proud of Gordon 4 James 5 percy 6
@@robokeefeprotutions I guess.
A great way to end the main series Jeffrey. Well done. I prefer The RWS versions, as there was more sense and realism. Never realised a few points you pointed out till now, such as Percy being irresponsible in the TV Series episode.
It's a shame not more books got adapted.
@@supermariof0521 Agreed. In CGI they could have done them wonders, if it wasn’t for BWBA.
@@josephmarrison4606 Indeed. Like what books do you think would've worked wonders in CGI?
@@supermariof0521 Mountain Engines, Very Old Engines, Jock The New Engine, Thomas and The Great Railway Show, Thomas Comes Home etc.
@@josephmarrison4606 Sweet.
4:14
Percy: "Who's Bullstrode?"
Subtitles: "who's ball stroked"
Nice that you have wrapped up this series. You Should do a “ the three railways and Thomas the tank engine vs the adventure begins” episode as a finale.
Nooooooo! The last one. So sad 😖
Love how nobody ever talks about how Percy essentially ruined someone's life.
Well,it’s not like he didn’t deserve it.
@@ciarangleeson2880 Yes, because being cantankerous is enough justification for you to be severely damaged and decommissioned through no fault of your own.
If that’s sarcasm, cut it out.
Oh, of course, I'll cut it out.
No matter if you read the railway series so many times it's till special and still amazing
Well done you've given a good outlook on the books and the TV series well done mate can't wait for the Christmas stories
Welp… I guess that’s the end… thanks for making these videos! I learned so many things I didn’t know and I can’t wait to see what your future videos will be about!
Wow, I didn’t even realize this was the end, well I’ll always miss this series, I can always go back and rewatch it but it’s sad there will be no new installments, but it was a great series nonetheless
What’s gonna happen to this channel once all the books are covered?
If Special Attraction was extended, Henry should have had 1020’s role because he’s always ill, He should have been takin some passengers to the Special Attraction and would be short of steam, and Toby would help him to the seaside station where the passengers praise them for their actions, And there should have been a night scene of The Fat Controller congratulating Toby for helping Henry to the Seaside Station on time. And Toby would fall asleep and wake up to go to the Special Attraction.
Not yet you still have 2 Christmas railway series stories too go
Man we really got to the end.
Parting such a sweet sorrow! But you did all these “spot the differences” very well!!
Not yet you still Christmas stories To go
It’s been a wonderful journey, it’s always great to be part of the Finest Cocoa community. You’ve created a great community and make some wonderful videos
I read online that the reason Thomas was not in this book was that it was set parallel the following book Thomas and the twins, where Thomas is sent to work on Edward's branch line due to the bridge over the river on Thomas's needing repairs and Thomas exceeded the weight limit Sir Topham Hatt set on it during its repairs
That final line was very enjoyable, if a little sad. I will continue to watch your thomas spot the difference vids for years to come :3
I’m gonna miss these videos :(
Don't be sad it's over, be glad it happened.
Other differences you didn't discuss:
1. Bulstrode in his namesake RWS story has two hulls. In the adaptation ("Special Attraction"), he's got just one.
2. Four freight cars loaded with what was falsely described as stone in the Railway Series fell into Bulstrode. In the adaptation, there were five correctly described as carrying stone instead of slate.
3. In the adaptation, the cars face Percy before turning their faces away but in the book they were facing away from Percy all the time. They probably detected Percy's presence by puffing sounds.
I think the reason The stationmaster walked away shaking his head was because he heard that the festival don’t want Toby as their festival Attraction.
There will never be anymore adaptations of Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends. The only thing we can do is cherish the ones we have while also watch fan content of those who remember and respect the shows of their childhood.
Mattel should try hiring older Thomas fans to work for them. At least then they might start making some actual progress.
Hard to believe that this is the end.
I’m glad you pointed out the big differences between the episode and the adaptation.
Jeffery a big congrats to the 4 years you contributed to making these vids it’s been an enjoyable experience overall and I look forward to your future vids
8:14 But that's a story for a later season.
You did really well to do every single book adapted for the television series finest Coco I respect you
Thomas & Friends has to have original stories in it and not just adaptions all the time.
it's kind of sad were at end game
Cool, I Will Love To See More Of This Series :D
This might be the final episode tho.
It’s so sad that it’s the end. I’ve been watching since the beginning. This series was great
Toby's burnt looking window was a goof for the episode. Though if it was meant for the story and episode, it would make sense for Toby to be unwanted in the parade.
7:58 Ah, so that's why you didn't mention that phrase in the previous video! I also like how you've hinted about comparing the two standalone Christmas books in future.
So now what? The Adventure Begins? Pretty please?
Not you still 2 more to go
Funnily enough, Bulstrode had been brought back in All Engines Go, after not appearing again in the original show.
It’s amazing how many one time Thomas characters left a big impact on the series.
Well that's the last episode thank you for this we well continue to make Thomas grow better
Bulstrode was a jerk but his punishment was undeserved, I also kind of hate that Percy didn’t face consequences for what he did.
I think he did get what he deserved. Plus it wasn’t really Percy’s fault.
They could have at least given a more clear cut explanation to how it happened.
Maybe Percy’s brakes could have been acting faulty, and probably could have been foreshadowed once or twice, and then they could have stopped working while he was pushing the trucks. Does that work for an explanation?
Can’t believe we reached the end
Love your series thought
Sad it all finished
Awesome. Love watching your series
Good bye Mr finest coco.
7:00 What Does That Have to Do with Me Drowning a Disgruntled Boat
7:59 It is Time for the Finest Cocoa to Leave,He Had Seen Everything
You still 2 more to go
Wait in season 6 Edward the really useful engine is it kinda like a super rescue hmm (:/
It’s too bad they did not turned the rest of them into episodes! 😢
You know, I heard on the Thomas wiki that this book took place at the same time as the next one, Thomas And The Twins, where Thomas went to work on Edward’s branch line, and that’s why he was absent from Toby, Trucks, And Trouble.
7:40 My eyes are bleeding.
All good things must come to an end, but it nice while it lasted, hiatuses and reuploading certain episodes on to this channel notwithstanding.
NOOOOOOOO 😭
With this series done, what books do you think deserve to be adapted in the revival era? I know I would pick Mountain Engines and Very Old Engines. As for Christopher’s books, let’s discuss it here.
How does it feel now that this series is over.
6:36 wait dose mean bulstrode died?!
GG's
Brilliant way to end matey! ;) 👍
👏
I do wish you could do "Spot the Differences" videos for the Railway Series books of "Thomas' Christmas Party" and "Thomas and the Missing Christmas Tree".
Most of Christopher Awdry’s stories were not televised. Some had new characters and stories but they probably weren’t merchandisable.
1988-89
1987(1939)
What r u going to do now
I'm always under the impression that Toby was daydreaming in Toby's Seaside Holiday.
Maybe they could have adapted it by having Toby tell the story to Thomas and Percy.
@@ciarangleeson2880 That could've actually worked.
Andy Pandy goodbye music at the end :P
Series 4(1994-95) and 5(1998)
Narrated by: George Carlin and Alec Baldwin
Great series!
I’m so sad that the finest cocoa
So trains do die .
When are you going to do more?
This is the end of the line. I guess...😮💨😥
Despite bulstrode character trademark small merch until All engines go has slow talking style of shelbourne salvage from Theodore tugboat
Noooo!!!!!!
Farewell Finest Cocoa
I hate that, after Mind That Bike, The Railway Series and Thomas and Friends became separate entities. So much missed potential.
Me too. So many stories to adapt, completely ignored.
What is that jingle at the end from?
It's such a shame this was the final Railway Series book adapted for the TV series. Oh well, at least we can do more un-adapted Railway Series on CZcams.
Also, I'm inspired to do my own series like this. And I'm still trying to buy this book (it's quite expensive though).
No BFF, This Wasn't The Final Railway Series Book Adpated.
@@ValentinSparkle16 oh yes! The two Christmas Spinoffs were adapted! My bad.
@@thomasegcouplesandships1956 Yep!
@@ValentinSparkle16 love you BFF!
7:58 or 7:59
Wow
Will you ever do "Spot the Differences" videos for the Railway Series books of "Thomas' Christmas Party" and "Thomas and the Missing Christmas Tree"?
But... But I don't want to go. I haven't finished my cocoa yet. ;~;
Also does anyone know where that jingle at the end is from? It sounds familiar.
8:04
sooooo... now what?
Is levied
I think Special Attraction is the worst adaptation in the show. It’s just two plots shoved into one episode and it fails to make them both relevant.
Either that or Trouble With Mud. That adaptation was also really messy
@@DaimosZ It was.
Is this about Gordon seemingly acting out of character?
@@ciarangleeson2880 Yes. That altered much of the original stories plot progression being a follow up to Off The Rails.
This video (like all the rest)will become CZcams kids videos!!!
Well sensational and wow I didn’t expect a send off at the very end! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️