If the Moon were replaced with some of our planets
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 01. 2013
- In order show:
Mars
Venus
Neptune
Uranus
Jupiter
Saturn
Mercury is intentionally left off as it isn't Much bigger than our Moon (and hence is boring)
Everything is correctly scaled. The Axial tilts are not particularly accurate.
the moon that flies in front of Saturn is Tethys. It is Tiny. but very close
Dione would be on a collision course, it's orbital distance from Saturn is Nearly identical to our Moon's orbit around Earth
Titan, which is Larger than our Moon, is outside the orbit of Dione
****************
on Jupiter, you might be able to make out the 4 big moons, They all have orbits larger than our moons orbit. but I stuck them on the far side of jupiter so that they could be seen so it looks as if they are closer (to Jupiter) than they really are.
***************
Video creation method
I created an Earth Moon system in 3dsmax, with accurate sizes and accurate orbital distances.. I than matched video of the real Moon with my video camera, against my model. I also researched the correct FOV of my video camera. I used both methods to verify my Virtual camera's FOV (around 47 degrees). I next modeled up the rest of the planets in proper scale (Real values) set at the distance of the moon (also real values), created the animation of them rotating around, and composited the whole bunch.
***************
Faq:
Scales used in Visualization:
Celestial Body Radius (in km)
Moon: 1738
Mars: 3397
Venus: 6052
Neptune: 25,269 (equatorial) 24,340 (polar)
Uranus: 25,559 (equatorial) 24,973 (polar)
Jupiter: 71,490 (equatorial) 66,854 (polar)
Saturn: 60,268 (equatorial) 54,360 (polar) (not including rings)
Distance to Moon 384,000km
Faq: (will expand as needed)
1, We would not be engulfed by Jupiter or any other planet, Jupiter's radius is 71,490 km and the distance to the Moon is 384,000km
2, Saturn is not larger than Jupiter. Saturn + RINGS is larger than Jupiter
3, We would suffer from really really horrible tides, and Volcanoes And some pretty bad Radiation from Jupiter. It could strip away our atmosphere, but haven't done the math. Eventually our planet would become tidally locked (that is the same side of Earth would always face Jupiter. we would Still have some bad tides and volcanoes from being in a slightly ellipitical orbit, and from the other moons of Jupiter, and the Sun having tidal influence. I have not calculated how bad the Tides would be. A Simple guess would be at Least 300 times more exaggerated than they are now, This figure could be way off, it's simply an educated guess.
4, We would not be in the rings of Saturn. Or to rephrase that, we would not be in any of the Visable rings of Saturn, There are some very very faint rings that strech out far that we would be in, but i did not model them.
5, We would not be crushed by the Gravity of Jupiter, This is not how orbiting works!.
However, at the Roche limit, we WOULD become a new ring system, The Roche limit is about 36,000km above the "surface" of Jupiter or 106,000km from the center of Jupiter. So, to reiterate if the center of Jupiter was 106,000km away from the center of the earth, Our planet would become a new Ring system of Jupiter.
6, I did not model the Ring of debris around Uranus (this faq will be deleted in a few days)
7, This is not an ad for any beer company, no one has endorsed me, or this animation, It's just the traffic that drove by.
8, There is Ring Shine on Saturn, but it is very faint, the Rings are reflecting light onto Saturn in the animation. The moon that flies by is Tethys
9, I love Pluto, and Mercury. They are left off because they are too small. Pluto is smaller than our Moon, and Mercury is not significantly larger than our Moon.
10, The "Sun" i used for lighting the planets is slightly off from reality, this was done so that they weren't totally dark and boring
11 FOV is about 47 degrees
12 Orbiting! Yes! we would be a moon of Saturn, Jupiter, Uranus, and Neptune. They are much more massive than the Earth. Venus is about the same size of the Earth and we would orbit around a center point between us
13 Rotation rates and axial tilts are not accurate to anything
14 Radius of the Sun is 695,500 km, and hence if it were where our Moon is, we would be engulfed by it - Věda a technologie
Y’all wanna replace me now? 😭
Nooo
ikr moon is a better
Moon you wanna stop creating accounts just for attention first?
YO TENGO it’s a joke :|
No we love you moon 🌙 you will stay with us
no one is talking how good the editing was
Good
100th like
😬😠
That actually was amazing editing
woah 162
Saturn looks scarily big but beautiful at the same time
WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY PLANET😲
Not scarily it’s scary
@@Ahad_RobloxYTBer This isn't school, idc about grammar or spelling
to be fair, if it wasn’t dangerous to us at all, seeing some of the larger planets in our sky would be nice.
Agreed
we would die very fast to the gas giants
What would happen ?
@@Ilvxe Everyone dies 😂
@@HuCuRuS why ?
Had a dream of planets coming closer to the earth when I was young and it was creepy af ...and they were dancin'
Lol nope, it was just a weird dream XD
Oh man that's way too weird
I actually had a dream where we can see Saturn and all the other planets from earth. It was a pretty cool dream
I had the exact same dream but I was in my backyard laying in the grass scared like a cat! It felt like the earth was pushing towards the planets and I was going to fall in the solar system and die :P
Nothing in Particular yeah
Am I the only one who feels extremely anxious when I see anything large in the sky in general, specially saturn
same
Same...
But it looks beautiful
sameeeee
sometimes when I see a big cloud, I like to imagine if it were actually something solid, like a big alien creature or a spaceship
I have to admit the editing on this video is so amazing I thought each one was a real picture 🤣🤣🤣 that was an awesome video I hope you make it to Hollywood or another movie production city, they would hire you in a heartbeat
I love how the drivers of the cars are just looking at the moon changing in terror
Everyone: *Mentions Saturn like it's the largest planet*
Jupiter: "Am I a joke to you?"
I know right
:(
with its rings it looks bigger
@@lillynordicpale yeah, i hope its rings gets destroyed
@@Yesnt0073
haha rude. you need to get along with your sister. lol
Legends watching after 8 years....
Hehehe
Yes
Yes
Did u call meh...?
Sss🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm no expert but I can't fathom the gravitational impact these planets would have if they were that close to us
if you were an expert it would be easier to fathom? or you meant you're not an expert in logic?
@@TheCBC1984 Don't you have more productive things to do than to post a mean little reply to a year old comment😂?
was it mean? i apologize. @@VS-kr4qm i was going for funny.
If we were in orbit around them it would be fine - although we might be tidally locked and would definitely get daily eclipses
No one:
Mercury: „Am I a joke to you?“
If Saturn was the moon, we would actually be its moon
Clorox Bleach good thought
Clorox Bleach inception
คLקHค MคLє you are a complete moron. Earth's moon has an atmosphere itself, along with many other moons in our solar system. The original statement is correct.
Actually planets can't orbit other planets, planets are classified as bodies orbiting a star. A moon can have an atmosphere so who lied to you?
gregory erickson you do realize that the moon also orbits the star?
That would be so cool to see Saturn through your window at night
Haha I know...but you would be as good as dead if Saturn was actually that close to us; the gravity would destroy Earth.
Yeah , but if it was just like the moon it would be awesome lol
+kingkhanmsk1 I'm sure I heard somewhere and it was confirmed by yeti dynamics (I think don't take my word for it) that it would t crush us.
Lol its to big so the gravity would suck the earth and we would go in the rings and rip the earth and human all meteors would destroy us
Titan seems to be doing all right.
Nah I would have an INSTANT heart attack with Jupiter 💀
Love, blessings and best wishes always to those involved in good work❤️
Other planets: We are huge!
Saturn: Hold my rings.
The planet Uranus also has rings but not included here
@@corkystorky It turns vertically,hence it wouldn't do anything to Earth.
*Khaby Lame*
นะมะตฃะ
Sldv
Hd
Lsjdksndlsmlsks
Saturn and Jupiter literally gave me goosebumps
Yeah same
Ata bhua kotha
Same
N¹∅wⁿ)] typed as are ready
Why? why sorry i gave you Goosebumps
:(
Super editing. I learnt that we can edit like this also
Y’all this is so fire and so cool I love it so much ❤
Jupiter: ...Holy...
Saturn: HOLY MOTHER OF--
The sun
Yes I am very giant.
Saturn only looks bigger because of it’s rings, but I am bigger bigger.
Hi
x camila Uranus: OOOOOHHHHHHHHH
kya
I love how everyone is casually driving by this celestial phenomena
You're joking?
@@olivetism1 you Joking too? Or you dont understand jokes?
@@Tenguinha I'm just asking if the person is joking or being serious. I don't want to say anything mean if the person is joking.
R/wooooosh
@@olivetism1 Man, obviously he/she is joking, cant you see that?
okay so i have a horrible phobia of anything to do with the sky or planets, and this just made me nearly wet myself. 10/10 amazing editing
saturn was the planet that unlocked that new fear
❤❤❤❤❤🎉
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@juker. Saturn isnt the biggest though
watching anything related to cosmos, especially on big screen, is like a horror movie for me.
seeing Saturn in the sky would be well cool
It wont cause if they it falls down we all die that is the biggest planet in the universe we wouldn't want that to happen
Jupiter is the biggest planet I don't know what you learned in school.
+Mirwais Barak (TheSecondSon) He probably still has half of school ahead of him.
+Mirwais Barak (TheSecondSon) does it matter if it is the biggest planet?
Mirwais Barak who you referring to?
Idk why but I find these kind off things so cool
The edit is so real and the drivers:wth what is that guy doing??
we could just stare at saturn and jupiter the whole day. beautiful
You couldnt do that due tue high amount of radiation life on earth will die prety fast
ionut ionut without the science
why you stare at me?
i dont want to get stared by anyone :(
@@polskapika7552 your not Jupiter cause you can't use Wi-Fi in space your just a normal being -_-
@malia the cookie unicorn tade why? stop bullying me :( or ill get my friend the sun
and also dont stare at me
If Saturn was the moon we whould get meteor rain everyday.
Esthella, husbands of your own a lot through you and the same is outgoing ugdc,s,😉😉😊😋😋😁😂🤣
Anthonymuthu anthony r/ihadastroke
Anthonymuthu anthony r/ihadastroke
Ttdtetjf
Anthonymuthu anthony 🤯
Very well Editing as it clearing the concepts🤤👍.
Wow.....that is cool ! Thank You
Therapist: Saturn moon isn’t real, it can’t hurt you
Saturn moon:
1000 Subscriber’s without any Content
ok.
>:{
@@blayeg8716 Oh hey there saturn!
Fr legit lookin like he’s coming to hit us
LMAOO
saturn and jupiter first gave me goosebumps, than creeped the sh...t outta me 😳😳
Why??...😂
@@rosepetalz4203 Some people have astrophobia, including me.
@@wheres_c3 Ohhh I'm very sorry if i offeneded you x
@@rosepetalz4203 what you didn't offend me lol
Man i feel the same way. I started getting a little anxiety so i had to stop the video
Hey this was great thanks.
Scary,but lv the comparison,thank u!
If I ever saw Saturn that close.I would have passed out.
Me too!
Okay guys Jupiter have way stronger gravity than Earth and me. If he was replaced w Earth's moon, it will be more dangerous for u. I mean, i am dangerous if i am Earth's moon, but Jupiter is the most dangerous planet in our Solar System, so now i hope u understand ^-^
Saturn good job defending yourself I would love it if it was our moon
@@iamsaturn539 I want to see you someday...
@@iamsaturn539 where are you now i want to see you
When I was a kid, I had a dream that looked just like this video's thumbnail! ☺️💜 I never forgot it. I had walked out of my house at night, and the night sky was filled with giant saturn. Beautiful video!
I had a similar dream but with the Moon
@@mr.mcnuggies Sounds like a nice atmosphere!
@@mr.mcnuggies i had a simalar one with mars being the size of neptune
But mine one was with a Neptune like planet but way bigger
I were asking on my mind: is there more planets out of the Galaxy?
Omg when i was kid i always watch this everyday
This is INCREDIBLE HOW
Hey wheres my Pluto?
Mercury: You aren't the only one left out, Pluto.
Me too
Pluto is not a planet, I'm really sorry but it just isn't
r/woooooosh
@@vortex7804
Careful, you might have woooshed yourself there pally
Suuuuuuuuurrreeeeee
If I came out of my house and saw Saturn in the sky I be frightened as hell. I'd run back in the house screaming my head off
me too
Same
Yeah, that looks terrifying. I'm sure we'd get used to it eventually but it looks so surreal.
@@thebatman4279 yes I would just ejaculate just by looking at the sight 😂
Actually I would just stare into the sky all the time every day. Saturn looks so amazing.
Very Cool! Great work!
I remember watching this at school, years ago, and someone or me asking, “where’s earth” and I remember someone telling that person “it’s because where *on* earth”… though I would have liked to see that anyway…
All those poor people on the road have no idea what's coming.
@@TheAiRizzler ?
HAHA i love this comment
😂👌🏻
You shouldn't tell poor people
🤣🤣
*Imagine going on an evening walk and finding Saturn in place of moon*
Same recently I had a dream that when I was walking at night I got to see Saturn and venus and I was very scared
@@DineshKumar-gt4wk Sameee
Nd it's my dream😅
Selfie time!
@@yasminemobley7858 Let me join!
It’s so nostalgic.. its been a while since i first saw this video(like 8 years or more)…
It would be cool to see Saturn and Jupiter at night ngl ^^
Sunday - day of the sun
Monday - day of the moon
Tuesday - day of Mars
Wednesday - day of Mercury
Thursday - day of Jupiter
Friday - day of Venus
Saturday - Day of Saturn
So french days are based on the planets lmao
* english language is not from greek or latin, but from nordic culture:
Tuesday = Day of Tyr
Wednesday = day of Odin
Thursday = day of Thor
Friday = day of Freya
Thursday - day Jupiter
Friday - day of Venus
Saturday - day of Saturn
goodbye etymology, it's been a pleasure to have met you
my favorite planet is basically everyones favorite day (it is right after the day of venus)
Wouldnt that be lovely to wake up to in the morning looking out of the backyard to see saturn in the sky big and beautiful
With Saturn in the sky there would be hardly any difference between night and day lol, that thing would illuminate the "night" sky like crazy.
AhzekAhriman Probably illuminate the sky "too" much DX
yesssss
ProRoblox Plays I would be scared to death
The ocean's tides would be devastating
Well, if the Moon was replaced by larger planets then Earth would become the moon itself.
Wow, that view of Saturn!
Replaced by jupiter:
Earth: stops revolving round the sun and starts revolving around jupiter.
WTF.
Ithu sharikum ullatha
ugh no me
@MAMAOU 4Life its possible.. I believe one of the jupiter's moon is about earth size and has similar distance with earth-moon distance.
@MAMAOU 4Life oh right.. It os about roche limit right?
@MAMAOU 4Life but i think you need to re check your calculation, since roche limit depends on the density of the satellite. And we know earth has very high density, even higher than any of jupiter's moons. This will make the roche limit distance shorter. And fyi, io, jupiter closest moon, is only 421,000km away from jupiter. So it is very possible for earth to orbit jupiter from 384,000km away. (i didnt calculate the roche limit yet, but if you have, please tell me the number instead just saying it isn't possible, hehe)
FUCK!!!!!!! This is what most of my nightmares look like!! I don't know why I have these dreams about going outside and there's a gigantic saturn or jupiter in the sky.... shit shit the saturn one in the video made me shiver and tear with horror I've only seen it in my dreams so far
Yeah, I had 1 or 2 dreams about that.
well, if it was like this from the beginning of time, (saturn being in the horizon and us being a moon) we wouldnt know any different :P
I get the same thing
KennLOSANGELES really? it scares you that bad also?
I know how you feel
Saturn would be cool. If we had to choose one. Thanks for sharing. Have a great weekend. 😎
Nice edit
Wow jupiter setting are looking good on earth
I feel so scared just watching this... it's a weird feeling actually something that big in our skyes that could literally obliterate us at any minute. Is fascinating and super scary at the same time.
Got a heart attack when I saw saturn
Mohamed Kurbanov ikr
Mohamed Kurbanov ikr
So now you are commenting from Hell...
Mohamed Kurbanov I know! I wish our sky looked like that! I'd love to see Saturn everyday!
are u alive?
Your day off at the end of July but I'm still here for you to much.
very eerie - and cool, especially the big planets. Should also show them at nite!
To people who say Jupiter would cover the entire sky, please read this. Angular measure (in degrees) in the sky = (180/π)*d/D. Jupiter: diameter, d = (140,000 km); Moon: average distance, D = (384,400 km). Angular measure (in degrees) in the sky = (180/π)*d/D = 20.9°. That's nowhere near filling the sky. Another way to look at it, to get an approximation is: Jupiter (d = 140,000 km), Moon (d = 3475 km). Jupiter has roughly 40 times the diameter of the Moon, therefore would appear 40 times larger if it were at the same distance. The Moon is known to have an angular diameter of about 0.5° (it varies as it moves between apogee and perigee). 40*0.5° = 20°.
Well that escalated quickly
Well that shut me up!
Yes. I agree completely
this is absolutely correct
"Jupiter: diameter, d = (140,000 km); Moon: average distance, D = (384,400 km)"
Way to give some perspective at Moon's distance from Earth some of us lack. Wow. I had no idea.
You can fit all planets between earth and moon
Actually, just checked, it's true. Apologies to the commenter, it just seemed so unreal! But yes, all the planets can fit between the earth and the moon
Richard, he is right. If you lined up the planets end to end and put them inbetween the earth and the moon, the distance between the earth and moon is enough to house all 8 planets, and you could even fit Pluto in there too. So Richard, maybe you should look stuff up before you start calling people stupid.
Richard Sanchez lol, you're the moron here.
Richard Sanchez roflmao
sorry guys, I am type of sensetive people on internet, especially when someone disagrees with my opinion
Can you do one of these for other stars if they were the distance of our own sun?
This is very interesting idea, the bigger planet the more thrilling the view. The rings of Saturn wouldn't be seen tho, I think.
When I see
Saturn
I was really 😮
Anyway
Editing was super
Me to broo
Wow¡¡¡¡¡¡
Rk Fan?❤️🙂
ᴍᴇ 2
Yes me too
😱😱
saturn is such a badass!
+swissaviation thanks
+swissaviation not as much as uranus
What does that make uranus. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
They see me Rollin
They hatin
They tryin ta catch me ridin dirty
lol
What a good editing 👍
I will respect that person who making the video for kid.👍
Saturn is the scariest looking one to be that close.
+Christian Hickman jupiter 2nd
Eyesaur Guy agreed!
agreed! Everybody else was saying Jupiter, but Saturn looks so much more massive, it would gravity us up the ass & kill us all!
+joshhill212 XD
yeah but its moon is like our last chance behind mars if we wanna live
man it just looks so nice to see a planet that close with a ring LIKE THATS ADDICTING TO ME someone stop me
I like how everyone started speeding up when Saturn appeared
The cars just casually driving
Just fucking imagine if Saturn was replaced with the moon.....I wouldn't be able to live with myself 0-0
You mean if the moon is replaced by Saturn?
It could be both ways because then saturn would be here
EXACTLY DUDE, WELL SAID!
Well its impossible. so don't worry lol
Wolf Eh, not really. Replacing means that you get rid of something and then put something else in its place.
I couldn't breath when I saw Jupiter and saturn
Rage gamer Gamer Same LOOOL
Rage gamer Gamer
Breathe*
Rage gamer Gamer asthma?
Yea same here
TUBE sauce #sauce coo
Or
Sa
Soat coria
This is way more accurate then the others ones
sartun is very beautiful
Karpaga Valli what if you were to live there.
GODLOVE MWABENA you can't, its gaseous.
GODLOVE MWABENA the outer exterior is full of violent storms. We wouldn't even be able to get past the first 10% of the planet.
yeah it is whole
We are fucking under attack by Saturn
If Saturn was our moon you'd hear very scary sounds during the day.
+ThisFaceWillMakeYouMadGuaruntee oh jesus christ like it wasn't a scary enough idea before
how?
+sidneyyclaire its in a video called "Planet sounds"
+Dank Memes I thought soundwaves couldn't go through vacuum of space
+Akira Leelarapin yes! They don't
Jupiter would be legit scary because of its size
Nice editing
Bruh when I was a kid I got so scared by this I had to check outside to make sure everything was normal lol
Well did not have to do anything and I’m a kid
Btw I'm recommending it 8years ago
Means my sychology says it's recorded
2013
I am wrong
Lmao
xD
@@realronnyxpro9318 bruh 😂😂😂
Same xD
“gameing”
Imagine standing on one of Saturn's moons and looking up in the sky. It would be such a beautiful sight
actually it wouldnt with rocks being shot at that moon due to its rings.
I would b scared ;w;
:(
nobody likes me :(
I think it would be amazing, just beautiful ❤️
Well, the orbit of the moon you're on would need some inclination or else the rings would look like a straight line
Last night i had a dream of just like this video😮 its so amazing and creepy, wonderful like a real thing😊 But i cannot cover at a video that things...oh i don´t know what happened last night?😂
saturn is cool until you realize there will be 403 asteroids pelting you
Saturn moon isn’t real, it cant hurt you.
me:
What
@@Capade its a meme
So I guess 'me' isn't a part of the English language?
*Oi, George, I think we transported universes*
Something is telling me that you interrupted their joke wrong.
Go figure it out yourself. You might learn how to tell some 4th grade jokes.
😮 I'm watching this again without my glasses.
It was looking so scary when the Saturn arrived
Can't believe that it is 6 years old 😯
@@blackr7772 actually it is 8 years old 😂
Yes
Yes I can't believed it's 8 years old still CZcams recommends me in 2021.
Also Jupiter
Seeing a giant planet go by the sky everyday would be terrifying. But also makes me wonder how bright the night would be if Saturn was visible at the time.
Same with Jupiter bro
Wouldn't really have a night anymore. Only 1 side of the earth would be facing saturn. The other would be dead frozen. Earth would orbit around it while it gets destroyed and fall apart due to the diverse effects of having such a strong gravitational force pulling on earth.
my name is Joshua
@@erenhidiroglu7889 oof 😵
oofy moon 🌙
Nice job!
So beautiful
0:41 the moon in movies be like. WoW tHanKs fOr 500 LikEs
@Diya Tandel yes 😂😂
That's no moon that is a space station
And in games. The moon moves that fast too in games
@@charisma7268 blacklung
@@Goldrunner1169 rat
OMG! Saturn would be so beautiful if it was closer to earth... T__T
Of course that would probably fuck up our planet, but whatever... xD
Our planet will be fucked up eventually anyways haha
LOL we would become a moon...
Actually I take that back. We would become another ring.
Our planet is already fucked up... Especially America...
*****
I'm saying that America is really racist and has the most rapist/murderers blah blah blah
Yeah, that's because we have a good government and president that actually helps society instead of ruling it (we are limited government) I'm saying that we have lots of criminals and bad, messed up people that acts like they WANT to go to jail
Man, I really didn't need to see the moon replaced by Uranus...
I'm so scared of saturn bc he so big and he can touch to the world...
Ok, i got scared when Saturn showed up for a reason
Me too..
ufo
Yeah I got scared
Saturn is the scariest!
Idk why i am so scary, but ok. It is ur opinion. For my opinion i look pretty cute, but ok, ur opinion is completely fine ^-^
No one :
Literally No one:
CZcams: Recommending it after 8 years....
LSA
A
Lwlslaa
@))@0@sllalawllwslaall
Some kid: MOMMY WHERE IS THE CAMERA THOSE CIRCLES LOOKS PRETTY
any planet or moon would look very large depending on distance and also given if it was positioned in between earth and the sun it would be pretty much pitch black outside , and also taken in to effect distance gravity would be massively messed up.
I'm just surprised that the people driving by didn't stop and gawp in amazement. Must've been really busy :)
Its because they dont give a shit to new moons :(
this video almost made me heartattack
Nabajit Sutradhar same
Nabajit Sutradhar how?
Nabajit Sutradhar why ?
why bich
HAHAHAHA it was cool for me lol awesome!
I wanted to see how small pluto would be😂