THE SUNNI VS SHIA DEBATE
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 06. 2017
- This debate allowed both a Sunni and Shia representative to espouse their own case for their respective theologies.
VISIT OUR PARTNERS - www.twelvershia.net & nahjul-balagha.net
To clarify an important point , in the discussion two individuals came in and interrupted threatening the Shia . These were two people (both black) who came in and were stopped . Point to note :
1- The person who appeared in the Rafida video (Hassan Burachid ) was not the person who came in and interrupted the debate as may be assumed .
2- The allegation that Hassan is associated with Anjem Choudhary is completely unsubstantiated, since I have confirmed that brother Burachid happened to be present at a anti-Iran demonstration and Choudhary came in.
3- Burachid is completely disassociated with Choudhary and his cronies.
#shia #sunni #debate - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Some guys came in during this debate trying to attack the Shia and we stepped in to prevent this from happening. The guys that came in were two local black men who had seen that it was a Shia and Sunni debate and wanted to attack the Shia. The Shia debaters inappropriately attributed the blame to an Iranian convert to Sunnism. They accused him of being associated with the likes of Anjem Choudhary. I can confirm that these converts are not associated with Choudhury at all and have nothing but resentment for him.
story of Ahmed ibn hambal:
there was a meeting between Sunni and shia. All the scholars of shia attended, however only one Sunni scholar attended. the Sunni scholar walked in late with his sandals under his armpits. the scholar of the shia looked at him and said :"why have you entered holding your sandal" . The Sunni scholar replied: " i heard the shia in the prophets time used to steal sandals"
so the shia scholars looked at each other confused and replied: "THERE WAS NO SHIA IN THE PROPHETS TIME".
the Sunni scholar then replied : " This ends our discussion"
Moral of the story : THERE WAS NO SHIA WHILST THE PROPHET WAS ALIVE.
I've Never Knew that Shia's believe that Quran is Not Preserved... Shocked
The guy turned up with robes, stacks of books, reading glasses and tissues. And got his ass kicked by a guy with a golf shirt.
First things first I believe in oneness but not when it comes to electronic equipment. Please, next time get 2 mics it's so annoying!!
Born and raised in a religious Shi'i Muslim family, to be honest Muhammad Hijab is a great person and has an amount of patience. The point here is that "my" beliefs are almost the same as my Sunni brothers.
Although this debate was great, I don't agree with some points that the Shia brother makes and even agree more with Hijab.
Again this is "my" point of view!
"The Imams are higher than the prophets"??? I didnt know that. I learnt some new about shia. These people are very weird.
Well done brother Mohammed Hijab!!
Notice how the Shia debater didn't use a single time any verse from the Quran to back up his claims. While the Sunni debater quoted many verses from the Quran to prove his points.
ALWAYS WATCHING YOUR VIDEOS.....SALAM FROM EAST JERUSALEM PALESTINE..........
An hour and 27 minutes later and I'm still waiting for the Shia to actually make a valid point...
AstigfirAllah for anyone to celebrate the death of anyone is wicked let alone a women who Muhammad sws said he loved most out of anyone. Do we hate who Muhammad loves? Humans are not perfect but if this man met Aisha he would be embarrassed and shamed. Aisha despite how they feel about her is more rich in charity, prayer, fast, knowledge, fiq, piety than any women living today or in our past with the exception of Muhammad's daughters and beloved Khadijah (ra) How dare we say such wicked things about a Believing Women! This saddens me very much about Shia. I've spoken to a couple Shia gf I have and as a women I simply can't understand how another women could hold these opinions about a women that Allah sws put in our Prophets life as a companion a lover, a friend....
may Allah aza wajal shower his blessings and peace upon my beloved rasool Muhammed Sallahu alahi wasalam, his entire family and his entire companions.
one think I realised is that sunni core beliefs can be found in the Quran and hadiths but Shia core beliefs except a few, aren't found anywhere
He misquoted yasir qadhi about the burnt ahruf ... Yasir qadhi said the wrong ones wer burn and Uthman would write multiple manuscripts that allowed the multiple ahruf. The shia guy lied through his teeth
What's really funny is that the Shia guy has so many books piled up on his desk yet he fails every single time to bring one single evidence from the books to support his claims. Sorry to say but, Laughing Stock. He is good at raising his spectacles to his forehead and putting them back on his nose. I give him points for that.
1:04:00 The argument by the shia man regarding Ali naming his sons Abu Bakr and Umar was ridiculous. Abu Bakr is a kunya and both names were not that common. Thus, it cannot be a coincidence that Ali named them that due to the infrequent nature of these names. Also if Ali truly cursed Umar and Abu Bakr, he would have despised these names to the point of not even thinking about them. It makes no sense whatsoever. And by him comparing it to Hasan naming his son Abdur Rahman (killer of Ali ibn Abi Talib) he doesnt realize that the name in itself withholds a beautiful meaning. Its quite embaressing for him to make such an argument. Having a slave of Ar Rahman as a name is honorable and holds no comparison to the names of Abu Bakr and Umar. May Allah swt be pleased with them all.
A Sahaba RA went to Aiysha RA and said the Shia say "you are not their mother" Aiysha RA replied "they are right I am the mother of Muslims"
Shias will be sorted out on Yaumul Qiyamah. They have so much hate for the beloved Sahaba of RasulAllah (ﷺ) it's unbelievable.
The Shia are in a race with the evangelical Christians to a race to the bottom. How can they say the companions of the prophet have apostatized when the Quran says God has prepared for them special gardens in paradise and he is pleased with them????????
Never seen anyone beat around the bush as this Shia imam. He can't answer a straight question ever...
why are shia disliking the video?Just for mohammed hijab made more sense???dont blind follow
Rather than a set time each, it should be question-answer. Cause there's too much dodging, ducking n diving....
he didn't even answer most of the questions the Shia , but mohammad answered his questions
OMG THE SHIA ISJUST EVADING THE QUESTIONS
Mashaa Allah,
If you have no chain of the Quran, you have no Quran, you have to rely on our Sunni Quran!!!
PERFECT WORDS!!!!
I have never seen Br muhammed hijab this passionate and emotional MashAllah
THIS LEVEL IS TO HIGH FOR ME, I CANT FOLLOW.
its sad so many disliked this. dawah has been given to shia in both harsh way(anti majos) or respectful way(brother hijab). up to them to listen or not, jazakalaah brother hijab
Iam a Shia muslim and i love all sunni muslims as my fellow brother we are all one I Love the ahlulsunnah and the ahlulbayt
The Shia spotted the biggest difference, Tawheed....and shirk
And, that's why I like the "Speaker Corner" format, confronting format.
That's because
-you can get answers real quick
-without going into circles and loops
-ending up with no real answer to the question
-and get us wasting our time.
I can't believe if the Shia don't see light now they will be questioned on the last day.
Shias never give you a direct reply. Look at the books he needs to try prove his false religion as it is lol.. he's lost 100%. The Shia hasn't even made any points that make sense.
The sunnis have made their Aqeedah apparent in my books in many tafasir, books of ahadeeth, books of aqeedah, books of fiqh you name it. But CAN THE RAFIDAH CLARIFY THEIR AQEDDAH? Everytime I see a rafidi speaking he is just denying what his scholars is saying, what do yall really believe? Do yall believe like us?
At minute 12:20 he doesn't assert a person who believes in the interpolation of Quran as a kafir! I wonder why? Obviously because he knows many of the Shia stalwarts upon whom Shiaism is based were of the opinion that tampering has taken effect in the Quran.
I honestly dont know why the rafidi even turned up, terrible understanding, terrible orator, terrible debater. The Rafidi got absolute schooled on every point, simple way to analyse the "debate" is see Muhammad hijab directly answer and ask direct questions throughout the debate, compare that with the rafidi who just sits and deflects as much as he can without actually answering anything. This is what the rafida are famous for, they always send their ignorants to debates so when they are embarrassed like here they will just say hes a ignorant and does not represent us(rafidism). Bring us some real competition next time.
Take away points in brief:
Major Classical Raafidi Scholars believe Quran was corrupted.
Raafida Rely on sunni chain and preservation of Quran
Raafida have no Ilm ul Rijaal (science of men)
Raadida have no record of Aasim(one of the main transmitters of Quran)
Raafida believe running from battle expels one from islam(and they call us takfiris)
Raafida believe most sahaba apostated minus a dozen or so(again who are the takfiris?).
Ali(ra) love Abu bakr(ra) and Umar(ra) so much he named his children after them.
Quran is known as the book of Uthman(ra)
The Rafidi 'Debater' doesn't know basic Quranic Arabic rules on huroof etc.
The Rafidi "Debaters" primary source of proof is a Mosque Imam in London.
Allah(swt) confirms the Imaan of he sahaba unequivocally in the quran.
Raafida disagree on how many Imaams there are 12, 7, 13 etc.
Jafar Sadiq said the companions of the prophet(saw) were on the Haq(Truth).
Authentic Hadith from Qomi confirms 12,000 Sahaba.
Rafidah believe Imaams are equal to or higher than the Prophet(saw)
The rafida turned on the taqqiya mode and turned off the logic mode
Im a SHIA MUSLIM AndI DO NOT CURSE THE SAHABA, I DO NOT HIT MYSELF IN MUHURRAM,
I DO NOT CALL UPON MY IMAMS FOR HELP ONLY ALLAH!
I DO NOT SEE MY 12 IMAMS IN A HIGHER POSITION THAN THE PROPHETS!
SO AM I STILL A KAFIR?
the Shiia brother was just using debate tactics to get around his points. It didn't seem he wanted to listen or discuss who is right or wrong. But Allah guide him.
Br Mohamed hijabs facial expressions throughout this argument/debate just makes the debate better 😭😂
Brother Muhammad Hijab has done an excellent job highlighting the critical flaws of the Shia beliefs. Moreover, the flaws were made apparent by the Shia scholar avoiding key questions to the Shia faith.
From a neutral perspective it looked like the Shia scholar was purposefully avoiding questions as he did not want the Shia faith to be exposed.
key point is "Bring your evidences from the Qur'an and Sunnah".
In sha Allah that discussion will open many Shia3's eyes.
Why are Shia speakers so cold and emotionless.
This guy got rinsed and he wanted to debate asrar rashid he would have got slated by asrar even further fair play to brother hijab real lion
mashallah brother mohammed u r well educated about this matter
The Shia should join Jay Smiths ministry or David Woods if they have not done so already. No wonder the come to us in speakers corner thinking they have found some revelatory evidence to refute us with when they only come with falsehoods they can dig up from Shia erroneous teachings.
Mashallah brother. Just one point, though; to make it easy for people just getting into the religion, would you be able to explain some of the jargon briefly. Jazakallah khair.
look at him avoiding mohammads points because theyre not in the video BUT ITS THE SAME POINT!!
Shia petty why have a condition of not sending blessings on companions
no need to dialogue with munafiq and shia are the biggest munafiq of the world
Alhamdulillah brother Muhammad Hijab totally destroyed the Shia. Keep it up bro you are doing well. Jazakallahu Khairan
essalamu alikom finally i'm so excited to watch this debate after all the build up
baraka allaho fik brother mohammed
The Truth has come and Falsehood has perished perfectly said this guy was just some doylem dragged in with absolutely no answers
48:35 savvvvaaage
Lol is it just me or does the video keep getting longer 😂
Great job bro Mohammad. Honestly, this debate could've been more fruitful if the Shia was sincere.
well done but I have to say it's always too easy to win debates against Shia,lol.
when Mohammad hijab is talking why is he always acts like he's busy 😂
Regents Park Mosque?! Loooooooooooool I was creasing
What kind of shia is this???
Shi'isim - Gone with the Wind
Just searched the whole house for a second pair of headphones.
Did all of Shiite followers come here to dislike the video or what? :/
Great debate Muhammed Hijab. The Shia scholar evaded a lot of the main points
Shia rafidah are kufur .who are you to have a opinion .(saying that Quran is incomplete is kufur ,hating sahaba and slandering then.beliving angel jibril made a mistake.how are they Muslim AstagfirAllah.
I had doubts over what sort of shias would actually go to hell... Now I know... Guys like these who instead of giving proper reference and talking about chains and stuff just mixing up stuff and adding stories lies... As an example... He just took Hijabs general statement that some sahaba committed sins and heaped it on all of them and ignored entire hadith books for it... I mean that is stupidity at another level
Mashaa Allah bro. May Allah preserve you and always grant you increase in knowledge Ameen. Always appreciate your even-handed and respectful method of da'wah but it was long overdue for the gloves to come off with this Rafidi. All our love and duahs from South Africa.
Shie man have a lot of book 📚 I thought he'd answer anything but not even 1 yet properly 😉 time to read something like bro Mohammad hijab
Ma sha Allah Brother Muhammad Hijab 👌🏻💯
Brother Muhammad mentioned an event called lagana can anyone elaborate on it?jazakAllah
With all the clear evidence from Quran, they can't even prove Imamah from Quran which is Usool Ul Deen to Shias (Aka followers of Ibn Saba). They have the concept of Imamah from " twelve Tribes of Israel" this is same concept Ibn Saba played on which later developed into twelwer Shia. This is important messages to Shias who wanna seek truth. Not even Jews or Christians in modern area would insult prophets wife or companions, just know that these ppl have no hayah for their mothers or sister at home, and that their punishment on this earth. Really a shame!!!
ياخي والله انك وحش يا محمد حجاب اخوك من الإمارات keep it up bruf الله يعطيك العافيه اخوي
man like mo hijab .... bro u killd him... and i felt every bit of emotion while u was talking ... i dont understand their point of view at all may allah guid them
lool Br Mohammed's face at 26:22!! Good job brother you make us proud!
Im a shia and Im NOT agree with this guy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great vid akh but the shia yute didn't answer the questions. Beating around the bush or suttin smh 🤦🏾♂️
the raffia doesn't know what to answer he is making taqiyya
Mashallah brother Mohammed Hijab! May Allah bless you! That guy couldn't take it lol. He didn't answer one single question. May Allah help the Shias and us all. Ameen.
"You obviously dont read Farsi your Arab...'' LOL Can people not read and understand multiple languages? haha Maybe he knew for a fact that Mohammed didnt but the statement was a bit...presumptuous.
absolute domination with only 1 day to prepare. My man is the Connor McGregor of debates. Always shows up and never backs down from a discussion. 😂
am surprised the shia havent messaged. they r very active on their channel. Lool
MashaAllah bro Muhammad Hijab!
Subhanallah. I never realised how heretic Shia beliefs were.
Loved this debate :) Please do a Muslim vs Ahmaddiya. Thank you Brother Hijab.
26.21 Hijabs face expressions are classic!!!!
Mo is hilarious Wallahi, this was a very good debate, regardless of which side you side with, I respect anyone who can debate, "especially" while fasting.
All the best to you bro...
there is no islam except the islam of ahlussnnah. i am hanafi sunni. it is true that all. muslim beleive that abu bakar is the best after the prophets. shiaism is rooted in jewish phelosophy. yes it is true that some shia rabis have concoted the myth that abdullah bin saba was a mythical figure. but their myth is crashed through historical facts about ibn saba.
masha Allah brother Mohummad May Allah S.W bless you.
and may Allah S.W guide that pastor towards the right path.
and may Allah make this video a source of guidance for the astrayed people (shias).
The tiger of our Ummah. Alhamdulillah for him! HE is an 'ayatullah'.
I know you love the number 12 lmao
Long live Hijab 🖤🤲🏼 continue to educate these lost ones for they’re Akhira
Brother Moe thank you for this debate, your the best. The things said from the Shia guy is crazy, how can he consider himself a muslim? What is going on in his mind to even think like this? i knew it was bad but dam i didnt think it was this bad and this is how Shias think.
You said that you don't consider the mass populace of shi'a to be kuffaar (today), that is a huge and dangerous mistake. Generally the masses of the shi'a today, regardless of sect, call upon other than Allah, and the very best of them that you may find (if you really search) don't call upon other than Allah yet they see it as halal or do not make takfir on those who do. Takfeer of the mushrikeen is an essential part of the shahada. Also, what one may understand when you say the masses are Muslim is that you make takfir upon their scholars; what evidence do you use to make that distinction? There is no excuse of ignorance in asl ad-din, and even if there was, their scholars are ignorant according to the sharee'ah anyway.
Mohammed the Lion
You absolutely ruined him Mohammed.
Great Debate MasAllah!
ماشاء الله
57:20 onwards thug life moment
mashallah
Brother Mohammed again patient and may allah give you more knowlegde. personally i think shias are not even muslim.
thats not up for you to decide who is muslim and who isnt...
Yes, Hijab won. But not because Shia theology is not able to respond his questions and accusations. They just have chosen wrong person. He was not enough educated and very week regarding debate skills. Even I knew the answer to many of Hijab's questions
Where is Sayed Ammar when you need him.
Br hijab donned this Shia fool thinking he was clever with all his books respect br hijab wallah I love you brother for the pleasure of ALLAH