This is the Most Pretentious Anime Tier List Ever

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
  • How pretentious is it? Let's find out!
    THE LIST: tiermaker.com/create/redditco...
    Edited by Luke: / lukecraigphoto
    #theanimeman #joey #japan
    SUPPORT ME ON PATREON: / theanimeman
    MY CLOTHING BRAND: nonsense.jp/
    Twitter: / thean1meman
    Instagram: joey.the.an...

Komentáře • 935

  • @brisikog
    @brisikog Před 24 dny +1526

    no way Joey talking about anime lol

    • @matercan5649
      @matercan5649 Před 24 dny +36

      not even on his main channel too

    • @TheFehergandalf
      @TheFehergandalf Před 24 dny +12

      It's an SSR pull, im here for it

    • @monkey39128
      @monkey39128 Před 24 dny +13

      He's been doing it plenty lately. Even did that manga video on the main channel. Seems like he's easing his way back into it.

    • @ohhh_wenhasfun
      @ohhh_wenhasfun Před 24 dny

      😱

    • @user-te7sm4nf9c
      @user-te7sm4nf9c Před 24 dny +2

      no way the anime man talking abt anime

  • @rafacastillo9611
    @rafacastillo9611 Před 24 dny +869

    Joey, if you uploaded this as it is on your MAIN CHANNEL, without any more editing, and literally the same effort into the title and description of the video, people would stop bullying you about not talking about anime on the "The Anime Man" channel. The war would stop.

    • @Yoora_Miller
      @Yoora_Miller Před 24 dny +58

      I completely agree, it's by owning who he actually is, our pretentious anime boy, that he will find the greatest success imo

    • @ShotterGames
      @ShotterGames Před 24 dny +71

      Tbf I don't think he even cares about it anymore, at the very least it doesn't look like he wants the 'Anime Man' title but just accepts being recognized as such.

    • @TheSlithice
      @TheSlithice Před 24 dny +9

      The video is uploaded either way, not sure why you're obsessed with it being uploaded to his other channel.

    • @honklaugh2
      @honklaugh2 Před 24 dny +27

      @@TheSlithice Imagine going to a channel called The Anime Man and expecting anime content damn bro that's crazy

    • @likestosleep225
      @likestosleep225 Před 24 dny +3

      Nah, people would then complain saying he has no business doing anime content

  • @FlareOfLegacy
    @FlareOfLegacy Před 23 dny +165

    Full list:
    Absolute favourite: Bakemonogatari (and presumably all the other Monogatari series besides Katanagatari as that's got its own entry in the list)
    One of a kind: Legend of the Galactic Heroes, Mononoke, From the New World, The Tatami Galaxy, Ping Pong the Animation, Princess Mononoke, FLCL (first one), Serial Experiments Lain, Clannad (+ After Story), Perfect Blue
    Amazing: Monster, Cowboy Bebop, Neon Genesis Evangelion, Samurai Champloo, Wolf Children, Attack on Titan, My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU/Oregairu, Katanagatari, Hyouka, Gurren Lagann, Mushishi, K-On!, Aria, Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinju, March comes in like a lion, Made in Abyss, Girls' Last Tour, A Silent Voice
    Great: Toradora!, Jojo's Bizarre Adventure , Code Geass, Non Non Biyori, Welcome to the NHK, Madoka Magica (TV series only), Fate/Zero, Steins;Gate, Gintama, Nichijou, Re:Zero, Mob Psycho 100 (first 2 seasons, though doubt the ranking would drop even with S3), Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid, Your Name., Land of the Lustrous, Bunny Girl Senpai, Grand Blue, Violet Evergarden, Fullmetal Alchemist (the image used is Brotherhood, with discussion regarding of it being at the top of lists so would assume that entry over 2003 FMA), Kaguya-sama: Love is War, Revolutionary Girl Utena, Sound! Euphonium
    Good: The Devil is a Part Timer, Your Lie in April, Symphogear, KonoSuba, Anohana, Overlord, Penguindrum
    Okay: Ergo Proxy, Texhnolyze, Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (ufotable adaptation), Yuru Yuri, One Punch Man, Tsukigakirei, Darling in the Franxx, School Live!, That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime/Tensura
    Mediocre: My Hero Academia, I Want To Eat Your Pancreas, Zombie Land Saga, The Promised Neverland
    Bad: Goblin Slayer
    Dogshit: N/A
    No opinion: Hunter x Hunter, Flip Flappers, Tsuredure Children, A Place Further than the Universe/Yorimoi, Hitoribocchi no Marumaru Seikatsu, Revue Starlight

    • @readyPlayrOne
      @readyPlayrOne Před 23 dny +4

      You are doing god's work mate 🤝

    • @patchwicked
      @patchwicked Před 23 dny

      You're a Messiah bro. Thanks! Here's your 🌸

    • @viktorv22
      @viktorv22 Před 21 dnem +18

      Katanagatari isn't related to Monogatari at all, it's just the same author

    • @longpigpie3584
      @longpigpie3584 Před 20 dny +1

      From the new world was awesome. My poor rat babies. Monster, eva and code geass are my top 3 probably i enjoyed them so much.

    • @KingDingDong69
      @KingDingDong69 Před 18 dny +3

      Only thing I’d change is JoJo in one of a kind considering how old and iconic it is, also the manga for part 7 and 8 are really really good

  • @atharvakamboj350
    @atharvakamboj350 Před 24 dny +166

    Dude there's a new Mononoke movie coming up and I literally can't wait for it, loved the video btw ^^

    • @foregroundeclipse8725
      @foregroundeclipse8725 Před 24 dny +8

      Yooo I've seen the trailer for the new Mononoke and I'm hyped! What a classic . I wasn't expecting a older classic to be brought back, but I'm here for it . I'm surprised Joey hasn't talked about it yet. I finished Mononoke on Netflix . It's very good.

    • @theotherguy9397
      @theotherguy9397 Před 23 dny

      I wish they would make an entire season 2 of it it's so good and underrated

    • @TheShadowedkiss
      @TheShadowedkiss Před 22 dny +1

      Hope it’ll be in cinemas overseas

    • @CornishCreamtea07
      @CornishCreamtea07 Před 21 dnem

      @@foregroundeclipse8725 It spun off from an anthology show called Ayakashi: Samurai Horror Tales, so if you want to watch some more, you should check out the last three episodes of that show.
      Edit: You might know this already, I'm just guessing you haven't based on the fact you saw it on Netflix.

  • @Eltarionus
    @Eltarionus Před 23 dny +83

    How Joey massacred Ergo Proxy is beyond words. Apart from that, it's sad that we are not getting stuff like Ergo Proxy or Serial Experiments Lain nowadays.

    • @btchiaintkidding7837
      @btchiaintkidding7837 Před 22 dny +15

      everytime someone destroys ergo proxy my lifespan increases by 6 months.
      Ergo Proxy is the most preachy pretentious poorly paced overrated MEH aniem ever.
      i adore SEL
      (which is a S++ , 11/10 masterpiece) and apparently both SEL and EProxy is made by the same key individuals which boggles my mind.

    • @reishin6
      @reishin6 Před 22 dny +16

      @@btchiaintkidding7837 Some people should not be allowed to have opinions

    • @Swix_FGC
      @Swix_FGC Před 21 dnem +2

      Its dog water fam

    • @CornishCreamtea07
      @CornishCreamtea07 Před 21 dnem +1

      @@btchiaintkidding7837 They have a different director and writer, they are made by different studios. So I don't know about that

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev Před 20 dny

      I plan to rewatch it. It's certainly not the most entertaining anime. A lot of philosophy talk and religious background.
      But it's at least good and it's very unique, which makes it better than just good. Certainly better than just okay.

  • @SirLakeside
    @SirLakeside Před 24 dny +136

    Suggestion: When you make these sort of vids discussing various anime, I'd suggest you ask your editor to include clips of some of the shows you talk about, just so viewers who've never seen the anime will at least some idea of what the show looks like visually. It'd add a lot to the viewing experience imo.

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev Před 20 dny +22

      Or at least show the name, and maybe say it in English.

    • @jasonmp85
      @jasonmp85 Před 12 dny +4

      “Hey I think you should do an *insane* amount of work for the least engaged viewers”

    • @fymale
      @fymale Před 11 dny +1

      that's why pretentious, you should already know the op and ed by heart

  • @dpolaristar4634
    @dpolaristar4634 Před 21 dnem +14

    Complete ass take Girls Band Cry, BangDream, and Bocchi are not trying to replicate K-On at all they have completely different tones and stories not just from K-On but from each other.

    • @mikhaelmadriaga5457
      @mikhaelmadriaga5457 Před 7 dny

      and they're not as good as K-ON so moving on

    • @dpolaristar4634
      @dpolaristar4634 Před 7 dny

      @@mikhaelmadriaga5457apples and oranges.
      I personally think K-on and Bocchi are both equal in quality but I think both are overrated but I love Girls Band Cry.

  • @pingpong5877
    @pingpong5877 Před 24 dny +53

    There will never ever be another anime like FLCL. The newer FLCLs don't count. They have no heart and soul and only try to bank on the name alone. FLCL is a good vibes anime. Incomprehensible plot but deep meaning. Animators experimenting and animating in different styles and mediums. It's an art for art's sake anime. Or animation for animation's sake masterpiece. Definitely a one of a kind anime.

    • @tpsam
      @tpsam Před 22 dny +1

      I know it gets clowned a lot but Fireworks are they flat or rounded?
      That movie that was hyped and turned out people enjoyed only the song
      I think that movie tried to do exactly what you said
      Art for art sake incomprehensible plot but deep meaning
      And vibes shut up don't think absorb the vibes
      Obviously it didn't succeed on the scale like flcl but in my opinion it did a decent job with that assignment and I enjoyed it even though apparently I'm the only one everyone else hated it

    • @0ptriX
      @0ptriX Před 20 dny +1

      When I watched it the incomprehensible plot made me not find any meaning in it, so I didn't like it

    • @oliver-04
      @oliver-04 Před 20 dny +2

      Well its fun but its not deep

    • @cricket4life241
      @cricket4life241 Před 18 dny +1

      Flcl has the most entertaining animation

  • @zacharyware9083
    @zacharyware9083 Před 24 dny +34

    Shouldn't this be on "The Anime Man" Channel.

    • @livinghuman2085
      @livinghuman2085 Před 22 dny +3

      low amount of editing for the normal channel,feels low effort for his standards

  • @animagamer2
    @animagamer2 Před 22 dny +43

    This whole video is a giant like a giant list of anime recommendations on shows I might have missed out on over the years. Man, videos like these take me back to the 2010s- the start of my anime journey. Good times.

    • @btchiaintkidding7837
      @btchiaintkidding7837 Před 22 dny +3

      Angel's Egg
      Balladona of Sadness
      these are two other shows that definitely should have been on this list(for positive reasons), watch these too

    • @animagamer2
      @animagamer2 Před 22 dny

      @@btchiaintkidding7837 Added to the list, boss. Kanashimi no Belladonna looks trippy. Might watch it this week when I have time since it's only an hour and a half.

    • @ryana5435
      @ryana5435 Před 20 dny +1

      Cuz most of those shows are 2010s or 2000s shows and Joey watched most of those anime

  • @Void-qd2qy
    @Void-qd2qy Před 24 dny +43

    damn texhnolyze shafted :(

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev Před 21 dnem +2

      It's awful. Boring, tedious and depressing.

    • @Void-qd2qy
      @Void-qd2qy Před 21 dnem +20

      @@NoidoDev im guessing your favorite anime is my hero academia.

    • @guessdeeznuts
      @guessdeeznuts Před 20 dny

      @@NoidoDevno u

  • @lcsen
    @lcsen Před 24 dny +99

    Texhnolyze is so underappreciated. It's peak. It's slow, but there's nothing as raw and bleak in the entire medium, so unique. One of the best endings of all time as well.

    • @fattiger6957
      @fattiger6957 Před 24 dny +11

      That anime left me depressed. The nihilism on display was really overwhelming.

    • @robertsneddon731
      @robertsneddon731 Před 24 dny +18

      Haibane Renmei is my favourite Yoshitoshi ABe series. I always wanted more but, well, Yoshitoshi ABe.

    • @DP-mv7ph
      @DP-mv7ph Před 24 dny +12

      And i also loved that guy with a moustache that came from above and started gang wars just to see what would happen 😭😂 bro was a menace just for the fun of it

    • @fattiger6957
      @fattiger6957 Před 24 dny +8

      @@DP-mv7ph Makes perfect sense when you consider that he came from a world so boring that everyone just wandered through life in a daze

    • @DP-mv7ph
      @DP-mv7ph Před 24 dny +1

      Ive read a theory that the city of Lux is supposed to represent Babylon and at the end its supposed to be like the ninth circle of hell where they all freeze in place but idk how good that theory is 🤷‍♀️

  • @stonie3216
    @stonie3216 Před 23 dny +13

    There’s some opinions I disagree as always. But I’m sorry, weathering with you is no where near as good as your name 💀

    • @racingmaniacgt1
      @racingmaniacgt1 Před 15 dny +1

      same for me. The 3 Blockbuster Shinkai, I think Weathering with You is the weakest, though I think the Radwimps songs for that is the strongest.

  • @deerine
    @deerine Před 24 dny +218

    ready to get pissed lol

    • @Che1seabluesdrogba11
      @Che1seabluesdrogba11 Před 24 dny +4

      15 mins in and its fine so far 😅

    • @73a73
      @73a73 Před 24 dny +1

      @@Che1seabluesdrogba11how did it go two hours later sir

    • @user-sg6ii3eo9i
      @user-sg6ii3eo9i Před 24 dny +2

      Did you watched it?

    • @SetiKt
      @SetiKt Před 23 dny +3

      Putting konosuba below toradora 😂

    • @3_14thon7
      @3_14thon7 Před 23 dny +33

      @@SetiKt and putting K-on above Jojo, Steins Gate, Mob Psycho, Code Geass and Gintama... it's a hot take to say the least

  • @pneumonyx
    @pneumonyx Před 23 dny +19

    When you just gave the Monogatari series the thumbs up, I paused & took it outta fullscreen to give this video a nice thumbs up too. 👍

  • @bretturbina2753
    @bretturbina2753 Před 24 dny +14

    more anime content from Joey? damn we eating good

  • @Artahe
    @Artahe Před 24 dny +8

    I'm curious, you said you prefer Weathering with you over Your Name (I did too), but what did you think of Suzume?

  • @EvElYnFoReSiS
    @EvElYnFoReSiS Před 23 dny +14

    Not pretentious, so much as refreshing. It's nice to see a tier list of Anime i've actually watched. a lot of recent anime, and safe classics, often smother out some cult favourites. I like that the list had a bit of everything, and Joey has continued to prove his excellent taste. Also, shout out to the Houseki no Kuni Manga; The animie is actually a trailer.

    • @UnhappyPensFan
      @UnhappyPensFan Před 18 dny

      Rewatched the anime with a friend the other day and it's definitely a trailer, well said. Silently praying for season 2 😢

  • @maestrozaverick
    @maestrozaverick Před 24 dny +8

    I’m surprised you put Mononoke on one of those shows because it is in my all time favorite anime list! I can’t tell you how excited and pumped I was for what would happen next. I have never been on the edge of my seat for an anime since Symphogear. Thank you for recommending it to me!

    • @Marnige
      @Marnige Před 20 dny

      You're surprised? Even though mononoke is THE Joey anime? I know and love mononoke because of Joey.

  • @mwatsy
    @mwatsy Před 24 dny +10

    You could also post stuff like this on main channel, would be a welcome addition.
    Last one that you didn't know was Revue Starlight.

  • @johnnypollack3243
    @johnnypollack3243 Před 24 dny +3

    Love the video Joey keep up the awesome work and videos

  • @sevillaa6532
    @sevillaa6532 Před 19 dny +8

    MHA is one of the very few shōnen that i care for, but even i have to say the 1st season without the context of the next seasons feels pretty meh. It doesn't explore the hero society yet, so i understand how Joey isn't that excited for the story.

    • @tamarabikic3217
      @tamarabikic3217 Před 14 dny +2

      Same here, I'm usually not a shonen lover but MHA has something special to it

    • @idirbouchdoug1567
      @idirbouchdoug1567 Před 4 dny

      Quite the opposite for me, after watching many shonen over the years , MHA is pretty standard with very little unique aspects. it just takes the usual formula and does it well(most of the time).
      HxH is that "special" shone for me personally.

  • @gf3321
    @gf3321 Před 24 dny +68

    Surprised Vinland Saga and Death Note didn't make the list

    • @sergiudana8716
      @sergiudana8716 Před 22 dny +11

      That's not pretentious, is normal

    • @btchiaintkidding7837
      @btchiaintkidding7837 Před 22 dny +6

      They are really normie friendly.
      not pretentious at all

    • @lisace5916
      @lisace5916 Před 22 dny +16

      Dont think vinland saga is normie at all. if MHA and OPM can be on this list, so can Vinland Saga

    • @gf3321
      @gf3321 Před 22 dny +8

      Fullmetal Alchemist is the most basic choice, so Death Note and Vinland could have been in the list as well

    • @Dantethedemon16
      @Dantethedemon16 Před 22 dny +1

      @@lisace5916 100% agreed. i mean so many ppl disagree on season 2's quality because of its more seinen approach.

  • @gergotakacs5973
    @gergotakacs5973 Před 24 dny +65

    when he called yuriyuri 'cute and funny' i literally started sobbing 😭😭😭😭😭 UOOOOHHHH

  • @sean1000-7
    @sean1000-7 Před 24 dny +68

    You have no idea how long I have waited for this man to recommend Hyouka. It is truly such an underrated masterpiece. Thank you joey.

    • @tpsam
      @tpsam Před 24 dny +7

      I think it's like the first anime I watched fully on CZcams
      Here in Asia we have muse Asia which uploads legally licensed shows
      This was truly amazing and basically the poster child of why I think jjk is mid
      Sure for shounen standards jjk is a great show but in the grand scheme of anime overall when underrated shows like hyouga and girls last tour Aquatope on the white sands babysitting club this season jellyfish can't swim at night
      Arte
      Etc
      Jjk is mid

    • @TheSpongyMallard
      @TheSpongyMallard Před 24 dny

      I think it’s old, rather than under rated. It’s also by Kyoto Animation, so it’s not like no one knows about it.

    • @animusswtor4822
      @animusswtor4822 Před 24 dny +10

      there isn't a single anime episode in existence that I have watched more times than Hyouka episode 19. It's just 2 people, sitting in a room doing nothing but talking for 25 minutes but it's just so incredibly engaging because of the contents of the talk aka their theorizing and their character dynamic, and I'll take something like that over the "most hype fight of the century" (that's gonna get dethroned about a month after) *_any_* time I have the choice

    • @Che1seabluesdrogba11
      @Che1seabluesdrogba11 Před 24 dny +1

      Man I wish they animated more of it 😭😭

    • @TheSpongyMallard
      @TheSpongyMallard Před 24 dny +2

      @@Che1seabluesdrogba11 Same. I was like, “that’s how it ends? I need more!”

  • @jidusea4327
    @jidusea4327 Před 21 dnem +7

    reading through and finishing Girls Last Tour left me empty and listening to Dark Ambience for hours on end wondering why it had to end in the first place. It killed me

  • @monkey39128
    @monkey39128 Před 24 dny +1

    Wow, the manga video on the other channel and now another anime one here, plus the recent manga and anime content on Trash Taste. Great to see these types of videos from you again. Love the other videos as well but I'm glad you've not given up on the classic content.

  • @cirthael7141
    @cirthael7141 Před 21 dnem +6

    Having been in the anime sphere for 10+ years and not having watched a lot of these makes me realize I need to go back to watch these. As Glass reflection would say ''watch more anime''

  • @Monika-di7vv
    @Monika-di7vv Před 23 dny +5

    I'm happy I recently watched the Monogatari series because it's now my all-time favorite. Absolute masterpiece.

  • @fatalitydx8688
    @fatalitydx8688 Před 23 dny +6

    no berserk on the list? thats surprising

  • @elizabanzourkova1035
    @elizabanzourkova1035 Před 24 dny

    Joey! When will the results from the top anime survey come out?

  • @noahpauley
    @noahpauley Před 24 dny +31

    As someone that loves K-on, I don’t agree with your opinion that Bocchi hasn’t reached the same level or higher. IMO K-On walked so Bocchi could run.

    • @awmetoo4085
      @awmetoo4085 Před 22 dny +3

      we not finna do this. Watch girls band cry, Better bocchi entirely. And K on is the full package.

    • @btchiaintkidding7837
      @btchiaintkidding7837 Před 22 dny +10

      ​@@awmetoo4085
      Girls band cry aint even better than "euphonium" or "Jellyfish cant swim".
      G TFO
      Bocchi is in its own league. it is more than just a CGDCT or SoL.
      Bocchi and Frieren is made by the same director who is basically a rising star of the anime industry , that director Cooks. so cease your slandering at once😎

    • @kubo-samabanbankai562
      @kubo-samabanbankai562 Před 22 dny

      ​@@btchiaintkidding7837 Bang Dream It's My Go >>>>>> all

    • @ryana5435
      @ryana5435 Před 19 dny

      @@awmetoo4085 bruh girls band cry is more on the twisted teenager side and realistic side. why would you compare girls band cry to bocchi and k-on

    • @ryana5435
      @ryana5435 Před 19 dny

      @@btchiaintkidding7837 seeing people comparing very different shows and genres always give me headache smh

  • @eugenefindit
    @eugenefindit Před 24 dny +3

    The fact that list has shows like Aria The Animation and Sound Euphonium in the mix already catches my attention. 😁

  • @xanecosmo5061
    @xanecosmo5061 Před 21 dnem +7

    Another weird take from Joey about Bocchi the Rock.
    Bocchi the Rock is NOT trying to be like K-On!
    K-On! focused on "moe" stuff.(I'm honestly not a fan of that part)
    K-On!'s "plot" is so chill and slow to the point it's almost boring.
    For the story, Bocchi the Rock is much better.
    But I prefer the songs from K-on! over Bocchi the Rock.

    • @jacques9515
      @jacques9515 Před 20 dny +1

      k-on mogs bocchi

    • @mayank.7368
      @mayank.7368 Před 14 dny

      yea but bocchi literally works BECAUSE of k-on, and that's why Joey has a salty side towards bocchi which imo I understand

    • @mikhaelmadriaga5457
      @mikhaelmadriaga5457 Před 7 dny

      bocchi the rock is cheesy and cringey and k-on is the exact opposite

  • @keorux489
    @keorux489 Před 20 dny +2

    What makes hyouka special to me is the friendship dynamic between Satoshi and Houtarou. Satoshi takes everything up a notch with how much information he can provide, how he knows the protagonist, Houtarou, inside out and the complexity of his character as a whole. He is always there to do something for Houtarou whenever he is about to trip on his own feet. Houtarou also holds his own ground quite well with how he tries to come to terms with his feelings about his lifestyle, mostly thanks to Satoshi and Chitanda, and his deductive capabilities which let him come up with the most plausible answers to all the mysteries that challenge him.
    On the flip side, the girls Mayaka and Chitanda fall short compared to the boys since Mayka is too hung up on herself to actually look inside others' heart and all Chitanda do throughout the story is showing how feminine she is and starting things saying she is curious except in those two moments where they each shake up their boy with one punchline later in the story. The girls' purpose is just to stir things up and make the story more engaging because the boys act too mature. I have to say though, they are more realistic compared to the counterpart.
    Just as The Anime Man said, the quality is the last thing you need to worry about.
    It is such a rare gem where the story does not dive too deep into something but have the right dose of everything that stay faithful to slice of life, word by word.

  • @seankidney6235
    @seankidney6235 Před 23 dny +6

    I get your opinion on My Hero, but give it another chance. I personally gave season 1 a 6/10 when I first watched it. But every season since I have given around a 9/10.

  • @usmaanilyas8639
    @usmaanilyas8639 Před 24 dny +37

    Wheres Belladonna of Sadness, Angels Egg, Ghost in the Shell, and Jin Roh. That would be perfect for a list like this

    • @simonchasnovsky1835
      @simonchasnovsky1835 Před 23 dny +8

      Imma be real with you dog, Belladonna and Angel's Egg are pretentious AND objectively bad. The only people who I could see enjoying them, don't enjoy those movies as movies, but as philosophy study material to autistically obsess over. Ghost in the Shell goes from mediocre to great depending on which of the 18 different releases you're talking about. Jin-Roh is just meh

    • @usmaanilyas8639
      @usmaanilyas8639 Před 23 dny +4

      @@simonchasnovsky1835 Don't get me wrong I agree with you. A lot of them give off that "modern art" vibe kind of like how people will look at a banana taped to a wall and call it a masterpiece. I just wish they were on the list cuz they are fun to talk about.

    • @EximiusDux
      @EximiusDux Před 23 dny +2

      Ghost in the shell and GIT SAC are some of the most celebrated mature anime one could think off. Jin Roh is nice too. Newer anime fans seem to be more into childish cute stuff or unrealistic drama to obsess over to nearly incomprehensible levels.

    • @usmaanilyas8639
      @usmaanilyas8639 Před 23 dny +5

      @@EximiusDux agreed. Even modern shows like Vinland Saga which modern anime fans label as mature barely stands a chance to how mature a lot of the older stuff was like. Vinland feels like an imitation. Im not trying to gate keep by saying that. I know a lot of people will disagree with that take and I respect that

    • @BlekDimonn
      @BlekDimonn Před 23 dny

      @@simonchasnovsky1835 Oh yeah, totally. I watched Belladonna and Angel's Egg because I love philosophical anime, but I did not end up liking them; I half fell alseep during Angel's Egg and I did not enjoy it, Belladonna on the other hand, while was a little better and I did enjoy it to a small extent, it still was just not to my liking. They are more so like a form of art, rather than the part of entertainment medium.

  • @laurielsp
    @laurielsp Před 22 dny +4

    So many good recommendations on this list! I stopped watching anime for a while since having a baby so this list is perfect to get me back into it and revisit some older titles that I heard of before but never got to watch. I had never heard of Shin Sekai Yori but will definitely watch!

  • @yolulu
    @yolulu Před 19 dny +1

    the thumbnail already told me everything i needed to know about this video, peace

  • @A_NormalWeeb
    @A_NormalWeeb Před 11 dny +1

    Loved this! Joey should make more videos like this it's nice to see some refreshing anime content

  • @booksandocha
    @booksandocha Před 24 dny +49

    Off the top of my head, series seriously missing from this list:
    - Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex
    - Lucky Star
    - Honey and Clover
    - His and Her Circumstances
    - Genshiken
    - Azumanga Daioh
    - Kara no Kyoukai
    - Uchouten Kazoku
    More famous shows like Durara or Black Lagoon seem to be pretty conspicuously missing, too, since there are many similar level shows there too. Even Suzumiya Haruhi should be included, I think.

    • @RenatoArmas-cf7yc
      @RenatoArmas-cf7yc Před 24 dny +8

      Boogiepop too

    • @TheSpongyMallard
      @TheSpongyMallard Před 24 dny +4

      Stand Alone Complex is the best GitS series. The first movie is good, but it felt incredibly rushed.

    • @73a73
      @73a73 Před 24 dny +3

      Shiki too

    • @aeirie-ii1993
      @aeirie-ii1993 Před 24 dny +2

      Genshiken lover, great taste especially if u read manga

    • @rafal5863
      @rafal5863 Před 24 dny +1

      Youio Senki

  • @SandraPhillips-cb5og
    @SandraPhillips-cb5og Před 24 dny +61

    You're smashing it, keep it coming!

  • @FreddieLane9001
    @FreddieLane9001 Před 24 dny +2

    This is the vid I been waiting on❤

  • @doraimisuto698
    @doraimisuto698 Před 24 dny +1

    loving the uploads joey!! I wish tho these anime list had WolfRain on it cus I definitly thinks it was one of a kind

    • @dejakiller69
      @dejakiller69 Před 24 dny

      Hell ye another traumatized kid that should not had watched that so young

  • @zasquatsch
    @zasquatsch Před 24 dny +4

    As soon as i saw the ANIME man upload a video about ANIME and have SENJOUGAHARA at the top of the tierlist i knew i had to watch it 😭😭💯🔥

  • @_KizzMia
    @_KizzMia Před 24 dny +5

    I’d really appreciate if you wrote the titles on the screen! I’m still kinda new to anime and I don’t know what you’re saying, so I can’t search for them to watch/read!! ❤

    • @alexprus7953
      @alexprus7953 Před 21 dnem +3

      One of the top comments listed out all the titles, hopefully it helps

  • @sephinarose420
    @sephinarose420 Před 24 dny +2

    Could someone write all the anime names on a list. I am blind in one eye and I'd like to see the ones I haven't seen but it's hard to write these down. Thanks so much.

  • @loganpops4487
    @loganpops4487 Před 23 dny

    I've seen more anime than most of my friends so it's always nice to see a list and have watched maybe half of it before and Joey comes out and hasn't seen 6 of them.

  • @ArcadeAce21
    @ArcadeAce21 Před 24 dny +7

    Me who hasn't seen 90% of these shows: "Yeah this tierlist seems about right"

  • @robkoper841
    @robkoper841 Před 16 dny +5

    Everybody...we all know that the real title/thumbnail of this video is officially: JOEY CALLS BOKU NO HERO 'MID'
    That's the crawl banner news alert.

  • @stikzlevel857
    @stikzlevel857 Před 24 dny +1

    I think we need a video of you on your anime man channel explaining why this is not on the anime man channel.

  • @user-wy6ni4oe4k
    @user-wy6ni4oe4k Před 24 dny +6

    Just started watching Shinsekai yori recently. It hits differently for sure. Looking forward to where it’s going

  • @andrewpappas9311
    @andrewpappas9311 Před 24 dny +6

    Was definitely happy to see K-On! on here, it was the first music anime I got into being a musician myself and I completely agree with Joey's takes on it. It was such a great show and definitely had its funny moments but the best part of the series imo was the music and every time I still listen to the OST it still makes me wish I could come up with riffs like that because those fucking slap and is up there with Beck (criminally underrated series, it was so good) and Bocchi (from when I watched it last year) as some of the best music anime

  • @Yoora_Miller
    @Yoora_Miller Před 24 dny +13

    Joey, am SO happy you're back to covering anime stuff, yes, be pretentious, I love you being pretentious, just be who you actually are

    • @canti7951
      @canti7951 Před 24 dny +9

      True, pretending to be not pretentious is just a whole other level of pretentious

  • @PhantomOverlordX2
    @PhantomOverlordX2 Před 24 dny +2

    Oh shit. The Anime Man lives.

  • @TheDJRobbyC
    @TheDJRobbyC Před 24 dny

    Joey, if you end up coming across this comment
    I recently watched for the first time Tamako Market and Tamako Love Story, both by Kyoto Animation. I really enjoyed them way more than I expected and if you haven't seen them I'd highly recommend.
    All around, actually pretty good takes on your list here. Happy to see you enjoying the memories of these shows as you went through them.

  • @SavantGardeEX
    @SavantGardeEX Před 24 dny +5

    33:07 "it wasnt as amazing as people made it out to be" me watching The most beautiful anime ever video where he called it amazing in the first week of its realease.

  • @azuzix2295
    @azuzix2295 Před 24 dny +5

    guy watched one season of mha and called it mid 🤣

  • @brianna3275
    @brianna3275 Před 24 dny +1

    Honestly, this list is really good. Sooo many bangers

  • @warwicker22
    @warwicker22 Před 23 dny +2

    Monster and Mushi-Shi getting love brought me so much joy!!! That and all the wonderful things you said about FLCL.

  • @andrepita4067
    @andrepita4067 Před 21 dnem +8

    When was this recorded ??
    It makes me think like 2020
    😭

    • @Andres-tn8oo
      @Andres-tn8oo Před 10 dny

      Why

    • @FreezeFroid
      @FreezeFroid Před 10 dny +1

      He talks about Bocci the rock, so definitely after 2022, but he also said that FMA is at the top of MAL, so it's between 2 years old and 6 months old I'd say.

    • @vaine6360
      @vaine6360 Před 7 dny

      ​@@FreezeFroidhe mentioned girls band cry which is currently airing this season so it's probably recent

  • @thetoastedpotato1618
    @thetoastedpotato1618 Před 24 dny +5

    Doesn't know Revue Starlight as what. An amazing anime. One of the greatest endings I've ever seen.

  • @antonbalfe6349
    @antonbalfe6349 Před 24 dny +1

    Wait did I wake up in 2004 the anime man talking about anime again is so nostalgic please Mr anime man sir talk about anime more often

  • @nuggetAC
    @nuggetAC Před 21 dnem +1

    hey the anime man talking about anime! what a surprise

  • @MadMax-ph1rl
    @MadMax-ph1rl Před 23 dny +2

    Joey I am waiting for your new manga collection video . Plz make one

  • @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos

    never knew having good taste was pretentious

    • @lcsen
      @lcsen Před 24 dny +53

      If you don't like seasonal generic slop you are pretentious, I guess lol

    • @Ash_Wen-li
      @Ash_Wen-li Před 24 dny +31

      There's a lot of people with good taste that are pretentious. But unfortunately if you like something that's not mainstream enough, you may get called pretentious

    • @juanblanco7898
      @juanblanco7898 Před 24 dny +2

      Always has been

    • @DrJones0801
      @DrJones0801 Před 24 dny +27

      @@lcsen If your favorites consist of SEL, Haibane Renmei, Tatami Galaxy, Mushishi, LoGH, and Mononoke there is no beating the pretentious allegations.

    • @TheFirehands150
      @TheFirehands150 Před 24 dny +18

      It's almost like have any taste at all makes someone pretentious. It's so stupid.

  • @hakami360
    @hakami360 Před 24 dny

    Oh my God, Joey.
    What time is it

  • @Carface03
    @Carface03 Před 24 dny +1

    Joey has been isekai'd into anime tier lists.

  • @ReggieSanMiguel
    @ReggieSanMiguel Před 24 dny +3

    Tatami Galaxy is one of my faves! Which is why I gotta point out it was by Madhouse. Tatami Time Machine Blues is the one by Science Saru.

  • @kirbyjoe7484
    @kirbyjoe7484 Před 23 dny +4

    I hate to admit it, but this anime list is fire. Not everything on it is a masterpiece, but many are and I don't think there is one bad anime here. I'm not sure there are more than a handful I would personally rate worse than good, and there are more than a few that I would put on my list of all time favorites or in the one of a kind tier.

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev Před 20 dny

      Most of them are great or at least very good, but some are very overrated or absolutely not my taste. Technolizxe, Bunny Girl Senpai, ...

  • @qplatium9381
    @qplatium9381 Před 21 dnem

    Thank you for giving me some anime to watch and rewatch!

  • @peld5762
    @peld5762 Před 24 dny +2

    Woah, is this Joey man talking about Anime rn?

  • @vc4961
    @vc4961 Před 24 dny +22

    ergo proxy was awesome, wtf u smoking bro

    • @fattiger6957
      @fattiger6957 Před 24 dny +4

      I liked it quite a bit when I saw it when it was first coming out, but I could see why people wouldn't like it. It's one of those slow-paced, contemplative, somber sci-fi anime that was popular from that time period.

    • @guessdeeznuts
      @guessdeeznuts Před 20 dny

      crack

  • @user-_o
    @user-_o Před 23 dny +3

    8:28 W take. Shinsekai yori is one of those animes that really stick with you. There's many great or amazing shows/anime I've watch that I love but Shinsekai yori is one of the few that sticks with me for a long time and I see remember the feels I had while watching it.

  • @palegrey444
    @palegrey444 Před 24 dny +1

    oh this list was def made for someone like me, it holds majority of my favorite anime ever like I can use half this list for my top 20 anime ever

  • @lugasalexander4852
    @lugasalexander4852 Před 20 dny

    Joey please do more anime tier lists!

  • @Aeterin
    @Aeterin Před 24 dny +5

    We got joey talking about anime before Gta 6
    Is this joke overused? yes. Do i care? No

  • @lemoxmemo1223
    @lemoxmemo1223 Před 24 dny +4

    Video idea: “making the most pretentious anime tier list”

  • @mikhaelmadriaga5457
    @mikhaelmadriaga5457 Před 7 dny

    34:32 can someone please tell me what's the title of this anime in english?

  • @Annie1962
    @Annie1962 Před 23 dny +1

    I wish you had just put the titles in the video because I had a hard time finding them if they weren't in English

  • @animusswtor4822
    @animusswtor4822 Před 23 dny +3

    nooooooooooooo, Joey you *_need_* to watch Revue Starlight (the show right before Utena in this list), it's a f'ing masterpiece

  • @DavidTheFatGuy
    @DavidTheFatGuy Před 24 dny +3

    I'm pretty sure you're only a year older than me and I fuckin love MHA lol

  • @jochenwuerfel
    @jochenwuerfel Před 24 dny

    Ohhh, now that you mentioned it.. Ergo Proxy had a banger soundtrack - now that's something I'm gonna listen to for the next weeks 🔥

  • @caioellery9117
    @caioellery9117 Před 17 dny

    i started watching anitube because of Joey's tierlists back in the day, this is bliss

  • @Qrofol
    @Qrofol Před 23 dny +3

    I disagree with a lot of Joey's opinions, but all is forgiven due to his W takes on Monogatari, K-On, 3-gatsu no Lion and CLANNAD.

  • @sonicya
    @sonicya Před 24 dny +6

    Now thats a pretty banging list, wouldnt change too much around myself except a few of course. It was really cool to see your takes on some of these shows you haven't talked about in a while, even on the trash taste podcast! As for my personal favorite, its gotta be gurren lagann. Love your content, Joey.

  • @uurjitdebbbaasu7314
    @uurjitdebbbaasu7314 Před 23 dny

    Oh man I’m so glad to see joey recognising the greatness of hyouka it’s extremely underrated and not to say kyoani doing wonders with the adaptation along with the ost is just the cherry on top also the fact that it came out almost a decade ago but still looks better than most of the stuff that we get today is mind blowing to me.

  • @Jason-jo1vv
    @Jason-jo1vv Před 23 dny +2

    Can someone help me find the anime he mentions at 34:30 😅 having a hard time finding it, thanks (:

    • @alexprus7953
      @alexprus7953 Před 21 dnem +4

      You mean "Land of the lustrous"? The Japanese name is "Houseki no Kuni"
      The one after that is "Girls' Last Tour" (shoujo shuumatsu ryouko)

    • @Jason-jo1vv
      @Jason-jo1vv Před 14 dny

      Yeah the second one, you’re a real one thanks man!

  • @Dan-gs7cz
    @Dan-gs7cz Před 24 dny +7

    Although Joey didn't watch Revue Starlight, I am still glad to see that it is on the list. What a hidden gem!
    Especially the movie is a fucking masterpiece, one of the most visually stunning thing I've seen in the media.

  • @ausreir
    @ausreir Před 23 dny +3

    How can you have a pretentious list without Planetes?!

  • @jhf1495
    @jhf1495 Před 24 dny +2

    43:12 Utena is my single favorite anime of all time, love the themes that it tackles, changed me for the better, helped me through tough times :)

  • @JarlQboyq
    @JarlQboyq Před 15 dny +2

    I also think s1 and s2 of MHA was mid, but the rest of the seasons brought it back a little bit with the flailing and dark theme being prevalent.

    • @Scott-xb1ku
      @Scott-xb1ku Před 11 dny

      nobody thinks s2 is mid ffs. That's your weird opinion.

  • @delix787
    @delix787 Před 24 dny +4

    I’m so confused I thought Joey and Garnt have been saying Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is overrated. 🤔

    • @mizuki2264
      @mizuki2264 Před 24 dny +1

      No matter what anyone says about FMAB, there’s this thing about it where you just cannot deny its legacy. In my opinion, it’s an anime series that’s aged well. (And the remake was more loyal, that ticked the boxes for me)

    • @TheSpongyMallard
      @TheSpongyMallard Před 24 dny

      I think it’s over rated, but it’s still the best typical shonen I’ve watched.

    • @ryana5435
      @ryana5435 Před 24 dny

      You don’t know the concept called “plays devil’s advocate”?

    • @user-sg6ii3eo9i
      @user-sg6ii3eo9i Před 24 dny +1

      Yeah its overrated, but not like its bad. Its overrated in a sense comoared to how other people rate it, but its not bad in any means

    • @aissaaissa3080
      @aissaaissa3080 Před 23 dny

      Garnt didn't watch fmab it's kinda of joke for him saying it is the best.

  • @TTigrex
    @TTigrex Před 24 dny +6

    Wrong channel Joey!

  • @NoidoDev
    @NoidoDev Před 20 dny +1

    11:10 - What?!
    28:14 - Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu
    34:34 - Girls Last Tour
    40:50 - Weathering With You

  • @phengooogaming
    @phengooogaming Před 22 dny

    Josh slowly going back to his og haircut every upload.

  • @darik1107
    @darik1107 Před 24 dny +3

    Joey totally missed the point that this list was made for dead anime youtuber Digibro. That's why there was some odd choises in some places.

    • @FanTalks1
      @FanTalks1 Před 23 dny

      Who?

    • @dvillines26
      @dvillines26 Před 22 dny +1

      if you hang out on r/anime for an extended length of time, this list makes an astonishing amount of sense. in particular the Symphogear and Hitoribocchi mentions, as both shows have small but extremely dedicated cults.

    • @darik1107
      @darik1107 Před 22 dny

      @@dvillines26 No thx, I pass.

  • @arkodas2361
    @arkodas2361 Před 24 dny +6

    correction fmab does not stay on top of mal. its frieren baby.

  • @KingMacbean
    @KingMacbean Před 24 dny

    lol Joey did the push glasses up when he asked to specify on FMA or Brotherhood

  • @shadowreacts5618
    @shadowreacts5618 Před 24 dny +1

    Pancreas is my favorite anime film of all time but i havent seen the other versions of it so i respect your take