the video entitled "Joachim Meyer - Zornhut: 6. Stück" on Björn Rüther's channel shows a counter against an unterhau from ox i suppose the other thing ox is good for is driving into a thrust and you can parry that with a downward cut (if you get there in time anyway)
That's not what's meant by "not static stances". Means you should not just stay in the same stance until something happens. Guards are key points in movements/actions
I appreciate that you need to keep moving when sparring, but for the purposes of making a video about the guards, small movements are distracting. Instead, it would be helpful to hold position, at least for a few seconds, ideally while the camera rotates around you to show different angles. A useful follow up video would show how to transition into or out of these guards when using them to attack/defend. Blood and Iron HEMA channel have made some of these.
Hi. It is really interesting intepretations. Since our traditional aproach based on for instance Meyer´s 1570 treatise differs a lot in many aspects. Why do you stand in a line with your feet? Why do you tend to jump in and out, when it is cleary stated in the text, longsword operates the main strikes in hand and leg synchronization. So stand with left foot forward and right leg goes with the right side strike... Your way seems like a mutation adapted for modern sport tournaments, but it is contradicting the text it self. I suggest to disconnect such intepretation form the original concept. It is apaprently ment for different use. I dont dare to say its bad or wrong. It isnt. But at the same time it has nothing to do with what Meyer writes about and how fencing works as martial art. I hope you understand our perspective. This is not an offensive word or insult, on the contrary. We wish you many victorious events and great fun! If you d like to discover more about traditional aproach without mask and gear, come and join some of our international events in Europe. God speed!
I want to learn hema so bad. I feel like it would be my favorite hobby. But its so hard to get started. i feel like , id love to learn longsword, Messer, rapier, saber and spear. Im already a pretty good archer. But im evan more faszinated with cqc. Its art in my eyes . And every man should have a favorite sport in my opinion .but its so expensive... Thats such a let down since i dont have any spare mony most of the time .. That makes me sad.
There are cheap ways to get started. Host HEMA schools are a bit pricey (like any martial art) but there are organizations like the SCA that don't charge people to come and practice Rapier for example. Most even have loaner gear to get you started. If you're lucky you can find HEMA clubs that are similiar, or only just getting started with low prices for entry and loaner gear while you save up for your own.
I love the video but my constructive criticism would be that all the movement is a bit much and too over exaggerated. Got very distracting and difficult to watch. Imo of course.
This is correct enough form. In very few situations do you want to stand still and rigid. Staying moving allows you to better react to your opponents actions, as it is easier to move off center or intercept if your weight is already in motion.
Most of the stances are unstable and executed poorly. It's not the fault of Mr. McSweeney but the fact that he took how k ow ledge from the Internet. Example is the hangetort. Here, the l crossguard needs to be behind the wrist for additional stability. This could also come from a faulty translation. Let's take the zornhau as an example. Meyer describes the Zornhau as follows (transcribed) . "Der zornhau ist ein schlimmer hau.". without taking old German and different meanings of words into account, it would translate to, " the wrath strike is a nasty strike." however, "schlimm" in Meyer vocabulary means "crooked"/"awry" etc. It means that the strike comes at an angle (ideally 45°) and not that is especially powerful or nasty. Things like this make Meyer very, very tricky.
Oh my God the way you just spawn in when Demo-ing the Guards 😆
I honestly wish someone would go through all of Meyer’s book in this format. Wonderful
great content
Good video. Subscribed!
This is so handy x
very cool. just started studying german longsword again so this is very timely for me.
What strike from Ox can be intercepted by Zornhut
the video entitled "Joachim Meyer - Zornhut: 6. Stück" on Björn Rüther's channel shows a counter against an unterhau from ox
i suppose the other thing ox is good for is driving into a thrust and you can parry that with a downward cut (if you get there in time anyway)
Good reference for fighting game)
I loved the movement, Meyers specifically says these are not static positions. You demonstrated this well.
That's not what's meant by "not static stances". Means you should not just stay in the same stance until something happens. Guards are key points in movements/actions
🗿👍
I appreciate that you need to keep moving when sparring, but for the purposes of making a video about the guards, small movements are distracting. Instead, it would be helpful to hold position, at least for a few seconds, ideally while the camera rotates around you to show different angles.
A useful follow up video would show how to transition into or out of these guards when using them to attack/defend. Blood and Iron HEMA channel have made some of these.
Also, what's the difference between Plow an Iron Door as they seem similar?
Is it just the height at which you hold the sword?
you can practice guards still if you want to but his micro movements are actually invaluable because you do not stay still in a sword fight
My man is twitchy
I think its to video-game spin on the stances. Going by how he drops into the stance like a character
I mean, by the manuals, they're not static guards... So, his "idle animation" seems like a good indicator lol.
@@Lftarded bro really invented his own "idle animation" in real life 💀💀💀
Hi. It is really interesting intepretations. Since our traditional aproach based on for instance Meyer´s 1570 treatise differs a lot in many aspects. Why do you stand in a line with your feet? Why do you tend to jump in and out, when it is cleary stated in the text, longsword operates the main strikes in hand and leg synchronization. So stand with left foot forward and right leg goes with the right side strike... Your way seems like a mutation adapted for modern sport tournaments, but it is contradicting the text it self. I suggest to disconnect such intepretation form the original concept. It is apaprently ment for different use. I dont dare to say its bad or wrong. It isnt. But at the same time it has nothing to do with what Meyer writes about and how fencing works as martial art. I hope you understand our perspective. This is not an offensive word or insult, on the contrary. We wish you many victorious events and great fun! If you d like to discover more about traditional aproach without mask and gear, come and join some of our international events in Europe. God speed!
I want to learn hema so bad. I feel like it would be my favorite hobby. But its so hard to get started. i feel like , id love to learn longsword, Messer, rapier, saber and spear. Im already a pretty good archer. But im evan more faszinated with cqc. Its art in my eyes . And every man should have a favorite sport in my opinion .but its so expensive... Thats such a let down since i dont have any spare mony most of the time .. That makes me sad.
There are cheap ways to get started. Host HEMA schools are a bit pricey (like any martial art) but there are organizations like the SCA that don't charge people to come and practice Rapier for example. Most even have loaner gear to get you started. If you're lucky you can find HEMA clubs that are similiar, or only just getting started with low prices for entry and loaner gear while you save up for your own.
@@mindsliver2245 thats some good news, and great advice . I think im gonna take it . Thank you.
Google HEMA Alliance club finder. It might help you find things
I love the video but my constructive criticism would be that all the movement is a bit much and too over exaggerated. Got very distracting and difficult to watch. Imo of course.
This is correct enough form. In very few situations do you want to stand still and rigid. Staying moving allows you to better react to your opponents actions, as it is easier to move off center or intercept if your weight is already in motion.
Meyer are considered exaggerated on the past itself. Even them decided it is too much lol.
God, what a bounce. It makes me dizzy to watch.
Nice. Next time do the toilet run before you do the videos, this jittering about is unbecoming of a seasoned fighter.
Can you just stop the horrendous shuffling? 🤮
Stance too high!
why?
@@user-ge2nk1gt2k Because Meyers stance is lower as seen in the illustrations from each of his manuals.
Most of the stances are unstable and executed poorly.
It's not the fault of Mr. McSweeney but the fact that he took how k ow ledge from the Internet.
Example is the hangetort. Here, the l crossguard needs to be behind the wrist for additional stability.
This could also come from a faulty translation.
Let's take the zornhau as an example. Meyer describes the Zornhau as follows (transcribed) . "Der zornhau ist ein schlimmer hau.". without taking old German and different meanings of words into account, it would translate to, " the wrath strike is a nasty strike." however, "schlimm" in Meyer vocabulary means "crooked"/"awry" etc. It means that the strike comes at an angle (ideally 45°) and not that is especially powerful or nasty.
Things like this make Meyer very, very tricky.