A Penalty Kick Nightmare | VAR, Red Cards, & Re-Takes of Infamous PK Shootout
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 11. 2021
- Penalty kicks are said to be the cruelest way to decide a match...
However on November 21, 2020 - the word ‘cruelty’ doesn’t begin to describe the drama of a shootout between Orlando City SC and New York City FC. Discover the stories behind one of the most infamous playoff matches in MLS History, that included a perfect storm of rule technicalities, combined with the pressure of a knock-out playoff match, and the twists and turns of a sudden death shootout.
The drama of this match also extends to hotly debated topics across the world, including the use of VAR and goalkeeper positioning on penalty kicks, two items that are continuously evolving over time.
Ultimately this type of pressure and drama are what makes the game so entertaining for those watching and yet so difficult to navigate for the players, coaches, and referees involved. Could you handle the pressure?
Playoff Moments is an anthology series that revisits the most memorable moments in MLS Playoff History, told by the players, coaches, and individuals who shaped them into legends.
The Double Post: • The Penalty Kick that ...
The Comeback: • Video
The Bike: • The Bicycle Kick of Yo...
The Instant Classique: • The Unlikely Hero of a...
The Rumble at RFK: • "If We Had VAR, It Wou...
Subscribe to our channel for more soccer content: czcams.com/users/subscription_c...
- Follow us on Twitter: / mls
- Like us on Facebook: / mls
- Follow us on Instagram: / mls
For more information about MLS, go to the league's official website: www.MLSsoccer.com - Sport
It was really interesting getting Chapman’s point of view
Also really nice to see how seriously he takes his officiating. He seems like a very nice guy and very personable
I'm confused though - He explained the laws, and it seems he followed them exactly (based on his explanation of them) but then he says he let everyone down -- why?
@@workphonegmailaccount3051 because we referees take pride in not making moments confusing and esepcially the part where where he accidentally ended the game early when it wasn't over yet
He was my old soccer coach!!!!
Heartbreaking, actually. I ref a lot of youth and small amount of adult rec , and , boy...I'd never cope with being on that big a stage. Noooppe
More deep dives like this in a documentary form with multiple viewpoints from the individuals involved would be dope content from MLS.
They have one for 2013 MLS Cup. and the “Double Post” Game…🙃. I’m sure they have had they for some other MLS Cups as well.
i second this, really quality
Yea, if you could experience world cup final from the point of view of two different teams
Well done MLS, I love that you included Alan Chapman and he had the courage to even do this, way to show that referees are humans as well and we need to consider them too. Alan Chapman I applauded you greatly, well done, well done!!
Absolute Epic game. The ref has nothing to be sorry for. I loved every minute of it.
he does have something to be sorry for following his next game in Orlando though.
Why was Pedro coming off his line a yellow card?
I don't know why Chapman felt he let the league down. Regardless of how long things took to figure out, the right calls were ultimately made according to the rules that were currently in effect.
same im a ref they didnt really give any context either
From some research I did (not much) it seems as though people and the league felt like too many fouls were let go and some other mistakes were made throughout the game by the refs. It’s not about the line call it’s about the overall reffing. Also they were allowed to sub the goalie because they still had a sub slot left(the refs messed up that call). I don’t blame the refs just wanted to add some context
@@Devotion10 ah, I don't remember much about the rest of the game. As for the goalie, they ended up getting that right as any player taking over for a goalie must be on the pitch for the shootout, which Rowe was not. That's why he ultimately came off and Schlegel took over. The number of subs remaining didn't play into it per the rules at the time.
Cause he did let the league down. That was an embarrassment. It all started with a call that really didn't need to be made. Plus they didn't mention how NYFCs goalie went off his line but didn't call it
@@Devotion10 I realize you aren't blaming Chapman and neither am I. This is a genuine question, who is responsible for substitutions? Shouldn't the 4th official have declined the sub from the get go? I assume center officials are not responsible for tracking how many subs have been used and if they are rostered players being subbed etc. I feel like Chapman's crew let him down
Not always a fan of Chapman but hearing the situation firsthand, sounds like he did his job and did it well. I wish him the best and can feel his pain, such an unrewarding profession. Head up Alan!
Found Chapman’s burner.
Well, unfortunately he didn't, as he forgot the rules by allowing the goalkeeper's substitution in the first place and then blew the final whistle after Schlegel's save even though Orlando still had to score their penalty.
Except for allowing the goalie to substitute and then calling the game with a penalty to go lol
@@LafayetTheAwesomeOne the only thing he ACTUALLY messed up was the three whistle blasts one penalty early. He ALMOST messed up allowing the new goalie to substitute during the kicks from the mark, but since there's no provision in the laws for substitutions during that phase of the game, and he didn't restart play with the new keeper in goal, technically there wasn't a substitution and no laws were violated. He absolutely failed to project the confidence and authority a referee needs to in that situation, and was directly responsible for a hell of a lot of confusion, but up until he signaled the match was over one penalty early he didn't actually violate any laws of the game.
@@KCMaynes the keeper substitution + blowing the whistle early = his 2 major mistakes, just not 1.
Legendary game, was screaming at my TV for 10 minutes. Let's go Lions!!!
Ehhhm wrong football I guess bro
Lol fax
2 big things they glanced over:
• The ref initially allowed Rowe, the backup substitute GK for Orlando, to come on and get in goal to face the next penalty. He was then told to get off the pitch as they could not make a sub. The ref then again allowed him briefly to return on the field, only for him to finally say that Orlando were definitely not allowed to make a sub, and a field player who was already on the field would have to take the gloves and play GK
• The only reason Orlando celebrated after the Schlegel save was because the ref had blown the whistle, indicating the game was over and they had won! It was not a mistaken celebration from Orlando thinking the game was over, it was a mistaken final whistle from the ref who thought the game was over.
Really wished they explained that better in this video, because that is what truly happened. I watched the whole thing happen live at the stadium
We won 3 times that day.. It was unreal
Did he blow the whistle after the save, or did he blow the whistle three times? Because if we're going to nitpick whistle blows, that's relevant.
@@michaeldunn1754 13:24 if you listen you can hear the whistle 3 times and he points to the center circle. I’d say that is proof that the ref messed up
Thank you. Was completely baffled by the ref crying at the end. So confused what he was blaming himself for.
@@tjallday95 it makes no sense.
Why does he count 5-5 when in fact they have moved on into sudden death?
Once you go into sudden death it doesn't matter the score on the first 10 pks since they r tied.
Confusing to say the least....
As a neutral watching, this was the craziest thing I've ever witnessed
The context definitely helps. And I’m glad they got ride of that rule. In the moment, when it happened I was flabbergasted and blown away with the drama lol
Can't believe I witnessed this in person.. This was the craziest game I have seen in my life. Schlegel killed it and it a moment I won't ever forget. OCSC VAMOS ORLANDO
I remember watching this live, couldn't believe the insanity I was watching!
If this doesn’t make you fall in love with this sport and league idk what will
More of this content. Amazing
I don't know why the rules would even say you give a yellow for that in the first place. Absolutely ridiculous, retaking the penalty is enough of a punishment. It's like being given a yellow for being offside more than twice in a match.
I don’t blame the ref, it’s just sad that the rules had a problem. Glad Orlando had the result they deserved however
The ref wasn’t in the wrong whatsoever! He did his job perfectly! Being hard on oneself. I hate refs but this man did his job 👌🏽
So blessed to have been there to celebrate with my hometown non the less to have been working that day it was definitely intense 🙌🏻 but supper proud of my city fingers crossed for tmrws game
Definitely the craziest game I’ve ever been to the atmosphere was crazy even tho it wasn’t full. VAMOS ORLANDO 💜🦁
I was at the game. Glad OCSC got the win. I couldn’t believe what was happening when it was happening.
He just summoned his inner Scott Sterling!
Legendary!!
Top shelf!
Chapman was 100% correct according to the laws with the keeper off the line and the red card. He clearly didn't want to do that, but he didn't have a choice.
I wish he'd have explained his thought process around allowing the keeper replacement. That's pretty basic to know it's not allowed in this situation. My guess is that there was some sort of confusion because of the additional subs/windows allowed due to Covid.
As for the celebration, that really was just a brain fart. Quite frankly, given everything up to then losing count seems likely especially with a different keeper in the net which may have thrown his mental count off, but he looked at his book and then blew it. I'm guessing he messed up back when the keeper was off the line. That would have been a miss for NY which then turned into a make. Not acceptable, but likely what happened.
Schlegel is a Legend!
Thank god Orlando won that match. The aftermath if we'd lost would not have been good
Greatest finish in MLS history. I can't wait for it to be beaten!
The Philadelphia vs Nashville game on November 28 went to penalty kicks. Nashville didn’t even net one kick; the first two kicks were two saves and then two kicks completely missed the net, fifth shot not needed.
I was at this game and omg it was so insane I cried like 3 times of happiness, sadness, and happiness again. Nothing like this should ever happen again, GO CITY
Manchester City!
@@joejamros Orlando city
this was soooo oepic
Happy to say I was at the game! 🦁
I remember this it was crazy
I laugh so hard when I saw the highlight
the retake was fair, thats just how it works.
rules are rules, even if its just a couple inches.
but a yellow for coming off his line? I've never heard that anywhere
It looks a bit ridiculous that the referee speaks as if he is a criminal offender or something. Did they interview him 2 hours after the game?
Only reason I don’t feel bad for Chapman is because he screwed us again against Nashville with that last minute call against Dike
Is he still refereeing or no?
@@isaiaparicio he is, Orlando scored a goal on Halloween against Nashville in extra time that would’ve put us in 4th place and given us home advantage. He called a foul on Dike and took the goal away. Pro came out recently and said it was the wrong call.
@@luisvillar3571 and then Nashville destroyed you in the playoffs a few weeks later. The universe has a balance.
Now do one on Chapman’s revenge against Orlando by calling off the second goal against Nashville at the end of the 2021 regular season lol
Schlegel should never, ever, pay for a drink in Central Florida for as long as he lives. Go City!
Could someone explain why the ref said he let the league down? It sounds like he made the right call after all. Did I miss something?
I think it's the confusion. It took him several minutes to sort out whether they were allowed to sub a new keeper on. He also seemed to think the game was over himself on the next-to-last penalty before realizing and backtracking.
The ref didn't know the rules
@@davipereira7754 No one gets to that level without “knowing the rules”. It was an incredibly unlikely and obscure situation that wasn’t actually addressed with perfect clarity in the rules.
The early game call was a brain fart, that happens no matter how many rules you know.
Never celebrate too early
I was watching this game, and that penalty shootout took like half an hour instead of 13 minutes
9:13 Yes you can change your laws mid season. But your league chooses not to. In Sweden they update to the new laws in the summer in the middle of the season.
Coming off your line was a yellow? What a stupid rule. Just a re kick is fine
Not sure what Chapman was remorseful about unless it was something that happened before the shootout.
The only thing I can think of is that subbing confusion after the red, but in the end he handled it properly so I don't think he did anything wrong
@@TheY0shi08 I agree.
At 9:47 he said 4 or 5 minutes but it was actually half an hour.
Round one was built on PKs, between Orlando and RSL...
I can attest to that - it is exactly how referees feel when difficult decisions need to be made. You call it as you see it, and you feel it when it is painful for a team
Damn, ref really kicking himself but he technically did nothing wrong.
If it wasn't for that first red card we wouldn't have witnessed these scenes 😳 The hero wasn't even supposed to be playing that game wow 😳 fate
Props to Alan Chapman for being in this, he still fucked up, but it wasn’t 100% his fault
Soccer is like a movie always happy ending I love it
It’s football
It’s your mom
@@mariodiaz1582 wow ur literally like 8 with ur “ur mom” jokes
@@ollieianssen5811 its both
Already knew what it was going to be before they even took the last kick... correct decision
Man the only crime in this video is the omission of Favela Chegou
They didn’t have to post this a day after NYCFC’s best playoff game in history
Came here to post the exact same thing, MLS just doesn’t like us. They probably gnash their teeth on the social medias this week every time they have to post about Taty being the golden boot or NYC making progress in the playoffs 🤣
@@MSosa1195 facts
You’re comment ages well for you😂
Gr8 game
Why didn’t they show footage of the keeper to see if he was also in line
now your yellows are erased into the shootout so he wouldnt have been sent off
Every Lion remember that night the Pride was confused but we never hunt alone. 💜💜💜
I F,,,Cry the day I was so happy for the team and for the hero the day historic game
Was at the stadium, it was pure pandemonium
I'm still at the stadium. I will never leave that stadium.
Why was the ref crying? Did he take a bribe or make errors?
I'm still at the stadium. I will never leave that stadium.
Lmao i remember the second hand embarrassment I felt
Good thinking ref
good
Lol, nice crowd, Orlando.
Yeah it was
@@Aig6 4000 strong?
I don't think the goalie came off his line. His heel was on the white.
This referee should never touch a field again
Godrigo!!!!!!
It all started because he allowed an extra sub after a red
This ref been paid in football he left his line soon as the penalty was hit america you have decade's and eon's before you understand football not soccer , what a shame
bruh 2:08. illegall penalty?
Chapman get a bend on his head lol.
KAKA must be very happy nani congratulations and to all of you Orlando you are top level players and for the younger ones only to become better my dream is an American player winning the fifa player award and the French prize ballon dor since the real Madrid great in 56 Alfredo de stafano
Then lost the next week with a missed PK 🤣😂
damn lol
Nah we just lost 0-2 again NER
I'm sure that was the referee's fault.
💜💜💜
First one to watch and comment 💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾
Justice has been done. NYCFC have won the Cup while Orlando lost in the first round!
This video ignored two mistakes made by the ref. The whole thing was a cluster. This PK shootout perfectly summed up the way the world views MLS
Well you have the Great Leonel Messi here now so get out your books and pencils you are in for Glory and a lesson
Imagine making a video about a ref that couldn’t manage a playoff game for the exact same team he almost screwed out of this year’s playoffs… oh wait….
Hahaha America 🤦🏾♂️
The father of cr7 is also of african origin
IN the SANE
if you get an yellow card during the normal time, it does not add to a red card if getting another one in the penalty shootout.
Changed the law??? Cool so we give people 2 yellows and they're headed to jail. +1
What
Lmaoo mls a mess
That day I almost cry when I saw the injustice against Orlando City but God is great and a star was born that night 💜💜💜💜
Alan Chapman should stop reffing and take up gardening like Thanos.
💛💚🌲💚💛
That was probably one of the WORST referee calls I’ve ever seen. That sideline ref needs to be booted from the MLS immediately
Arguing the correct call of the keeper being off the line is pointless. He was off the line. There was a big emphasis on this (still is). There is a line to make it very clear. Complain about the rule but not how it was correctly applied.
The MLS needs to do a better job of “letting the players play”. They’re currently taking a very black or white approach to many rules.
Which brings me to my next point, A referee will ALWAYS have discretion on making a call or not if he believes said action affected the outcome. That’s why the first thing that was asked to the ref was “what was the on field call?” before even going to VAR.
In this case the goalie made an amazing play which is coming off the books because of a technicality, in no way did those .5 inches that Gallese was off the line were the reason why he stopped that PK. He made an amazing play that should’ve sealed the deal.
Just my opinion, love the debate on the comment section
@@joseaste259 This has been hashed out already. What is acceptable? 1 inch? 4 inches? There is a line drawn on the pitch. This is an international standard and enforced the same elsewhere. It's not an MLS black and white interpretation.
That said, MLS has certainly been known to tie the referees' hands with their points of emphasis. The biggest example is the hands to the face automatic red from 5ish years back. That became a joke on how strict it was. The referees, wanting to keep their jobs and get assigned more games, gave reds which they absolutely knew were not in the spirit of the law.
I don't believe the keeper being off the line is one of those. I don't want a judgment of how much being off the line mattered in the save. The keeper will always push the line. It's like not calling a sprinter for a false start because it was so close.
If this were UCL QF that would have not been given as anything.
Allen Chapman is by far the worst Refreee in the MLS. & that says a lot .
Alan Chapman needs to retire. Worst REFEREE. 2 times in a row against Orlando. He only took 12 seconds to determine that Dike’s was fouled. Alan Chapman WORST OF THR WORST. Go Orlando City❤️
Not true, I think he is one of the best, I mean that bar is pretty low but still, even if his calls are wrong, he always gives his explanation and reasoning behind every single call. And he keeps the game flowing, exactly what the ref should do
@@1999guatemala cry
They ruin the soccer , to much stupid new rules . This is no more the real soccer …..$$$😡
As a European I can only smile about the hype in all the comments. We in the old world have problems with the rules of your football, but you in the new world have problems with our football. Every referee on a professional level in Europe would have done better than this one, and every spectator in Europe would have understood immediately what was happening and what went wrong (IF it happened, the referee wouldn't have let it happen).
you don't get a yellow for coming off your line in a pen shootout 🤡absolute farmers league
did you even listen to the video at all as to why this is? You Eurosnob.
It's amazing how MLS promotes this when all it is is just the official being incompetent.
REPENT JESUS IS COMING SOON ESCAPE THE WRATH THAT IS COMING!!