Liqui Moly Sludge Remover vs Liqui Moly Engine Flush (Which is Best?)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 04. 2023
  • I tested Liqui Moly Sludge Remover to see how well it removed sludge from an old engine. A phone call to Liqui Moly headquarters in Germany helped clarify which product is stronger. Here's a hint, the said that their sludge remover product (# 5200) is not intended for the US market, but that the Engine Flush (# 2037) is. That doesn't stop 3rd parties from selling it on Amazon though.
    Liqui Moly Pro-Line Engine Flush: amzn.to/3o93BMP
    Liqui Moly Sludge Remover: amzn.to/40w6CIE
    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
  • Auta a dopravní prostředky

Komentáře • 794

  • @OwenLucas
    @OwenLucas  Před rokem +31

    Liqui Moly Pro-Line Engine Flush: amzn.to/3o93BMP
    Liqui Moly Sludge Remover: amzn.to/40w6CIE
    Step by step flush procedure:
    1. Pour 1 can of Liqui Moly Sludge Remover into your engine.
    2. Drive for 124 miles (200km) without wide open throttle operation.
    3. Drain oil and change filter.
    4. If you want to remove any remaining sludge, Refill oil to full capacity and run engine for 10 minutes or go for a short drive.
    5. Drain oil again (to remove any remaining old oil and left over sludge) and change filter.
    6. Add new oil and you are finished.

    • @andy2906
      @andy2906 Před 11 měsíci +8

      Please buy a funnel your giving me OCD

    • @jaywholoveseveryone1721
      @jaywholoveseveryone1721 Před 4 měsíci +1

      @@andy2906 ...and PLEASE catch that drain plug before it falls in that oil! 😂But, I really learned a lot from this video. THANKS OWEN LUCAS for doing this test ❤

    • @andy2906
      @andy2906 Před 4 měsíci

      @@jaywholoveseveryone1721 are YOU Talkin' to ME?

    • @meetsaini990
      @meetsaini990 Před 14 dny

      I want to know can we drive the car for some miles after adding engine flush

  • @Davo_1991
    @Davo_1991 Před 6 měsíci +45

    That risky free pour, this guy has balls

  • @minnesnowtan9970
    @minnesnowtan9970 Před 8 měsíci +41

    "Sludge remover" sounds more powerful to me than "engine flush". Thank you for pointing out the difference.

  • @bdtaylor1979
    @bdtaylor1979 Před rokem +419

    Might be time to switch from a Bluetooth funnel to a real funnel 😂

  • @one7decimal2eight
    @one7decimal2eight Před měsícem +8

    On oil analysis for each one would have been the icing on the cake.

  • @jimizbikowski4112
    @jimizbikowski4112 Před rokem +101

    So I've been a mechanic for 21 years... back in the day there was a machine called a motorvac system for engine flushing... drain oil, take off filter. Attach hoses and adapters to oil filter neck and drain plug... the machine was kept plugged in to an electrical outlet all the time to keep the solvent at 125 degrees or hotter (again this is years ago). Machine used a micron 3 (I believe) filter. Machine pumped this hot fluid through the engine 5 or 6 times, took about 30 min after hook up.. and when I tell you it FLUSHED EVERYTHING I'm not lying.. oil pressure was spot on.. and even weeks later the oil looked as if it was a new car... the stuff in a bottle works sure but gotta do it 5 or 6 consecutive times keeping engine hot and changing filter each time

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +8

      That is quite a machine! I question what shops do nowadays but with equipment like that, you get what you pay for.

    • @uroskostic8570
      @uroskostic8570 Před 8 měsíci +6

      @@OwenLucas Well, you can make scuh a machine, easily. Electric heater for central heating, electric oil pump, and hoses. But, you can also use diesel, and flush it 2-3 times, thats cheaper method.

    • @kingpickle3712
      @kingpickle3712 Před 2 měsíci +1

      I remember watching someone do that while waiting for my vehicle. I was fascinated by it for some reason 😂

    • @wlkthewlkofjc8885
      @wlkthewlkofjc8885 Před 2 měsíci +2

      Company still exists. The machine you mention is discontinued. You can still get the manual off their site.

    • @Ravsawicki1
      @Ravsawicki1 Před 2 měsíci

      Yot engine was really dirty inside, and finały was cleaned after 200km, cause working longer and soecific could make his job.

  • @tssci6774
    @tssci6774 Před rokem +133

    Finally, someone that does full volume oil change before using a flush. 10-20%of old oil will remain. I perform a clean oil flush once a year. Let's the new oil perform better and for a longer time. The darkening of the oil is normal from heat and blowby contaminants. Heat new oil in a stainless steel pan, up to 220F, several times. It will become dark. A better way to measure the performance of these flush products is using oil particle count test. It measures all particulates from 4-30 microns, and is a recognized as an industry ISO standard for oil cleanliness. A full oil analysis costs about $40 USD. Good video, much better than 100s of videos on flushes that don't rinse the engine.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +14

      Interesting that heating the oil alone discolors it, the 126 mile drive was 2 hours almost non stop so the engine definitely got up to temperature.

    • @tssci6774
      @tssci6774 Před rokem +6

      @@OwenLucas keep up with methods, bring common sense to the many car myths out there.

    • @wallerwolf6930
      @wallerwolf6930 Před rokem +2

      Yes, this is completely correct, every oil becomes darker again after a short time, after just a "normal" oil change, without such a remedy, it can even look very black again, like after thousands of kilometers. Good to see if you manually measure the oil level on the stick.
      The Liqui Moly still had a cleaning performance here, because particles could be seen again in the filter after only a few kilometers of driving.

    • @trvman1
      @trvman1 Před 2 měsíci

      So basically it close to $150.00 to do this. 4 oil changes (if you do it yourself) and engine flush.

    • @arlokkkk
      @arlokkkk Před měsícem

      how many oil changes before using the flush on a 65k mile car do you think is necessary to do a good flush?

  • @daijonwillock3693
    @daijonwillock3693 Před rokem +212

    If you plan on flushing your oil, it's important to consider that 5-10% (not an exact figure) of the old oil may remain in the oil pump and other parts of the engine, even after draining. While flushing can help break down sludge and make it easier to drain through the oil drain, it's important to note that the contaminated 5-10% of old oil left behind can mix into the new oil, degrading its quality to some extent.
    Keeping up with your recommended oil service intervals and using the recommended oil standards from your car manufacturer can help you change the oil before it degrades and forms carbon deposits. This will allow you to replace the old oil with new oil, keeping the lubricating benefits of the new oil and avoiding the need for engine flushing.
    However, if you want to truly flush your engine, you can use an engine flush product with the old oil and then drain as much contaminated oil as possible. You can then top up the oil twice, once to dilute the remaining old oil with minimum negative deposits and then the second top up you can then add the new oil to complete the oil service and keep up with your oil service intervals to prevent future issues.
    Using oil additives that enhance the engine oil can also be useful in preventing carbon build-up and extending service mileage, but it's still important to change the oil on the manufacturer's recommended mileage basis. Engine flushing may not be necessary or practical for every oil change, and it could be a waste of money if the oil is being changed correctly. However, it can be useful for older cars with high mileage.

    • @ruudhermans8024
      @ruudhermans8024 Před rokem

      Loo

    • @BenState
      @BenState Před rokem +2

      Exponential decrease with oil changes.

    • @flycorvus
      @flycorvus Před rokem +3

      If your car is abused by previous owner, good luck!

    • @oluskloc
      @oluskloc Před rokem +15

      Best flush is add 1liter of kerosine to old oil, run for 10-30 minutes, not on idle but avoid heavy load for engine just light driving or some idle and moderate rev (2-2.5k rpm) on neutral. Drain everything, change oil filter use just cheapest one. Buy cheap synthetic or semi-synthetic oil 1.5 times quantity You need for Your engine. Remove Your spark plugs and add about 100ml of kerosine into every cylinder, leave it overnight. Next day turn engine with statrer still without sparkplugs to avoid hydrolock and remove excess kerosine from cylinders (probably there will be none anyway, all or most drain down to oil pan through piston rings softening carbon deposits but just to be safe check it). Put sparkplugs back. Now add 50:50 mix of oil and kerosine to Your engine top it off. Run it on neutral with moderate revving (or very very light driving) for 30-60 minutes. Drain everything, change oil filter for cheapest one. Top up engine with cheap oil to clean the residue. Drive on it short time like 100-300 hundred km/miles. Drain oil and replace oil filter. Now use quality oil and filter. You're ready to go. Change Your oil and filter often, I do it usually between 10-12kkm or 6-8k miles even my car manufacturer recommends like 20-30kkm/15-20kmiles oil changes which is ridiculous but welcome to europe.
      This will not only clean the engine oil system, also piston rings and combustion chamber, big chance to reduce or even eliminate oil consumption of engine, make it run better. Many times oil consumption is not because of worn piston rings it's because they are stuck with carbon deposits (some natural due to long use of engine but mostly because not changing oil on time before).
      If You willing to spend more money You add some engine flush instead of kerosine like 50% oil 25% of kerosine and 25% of engine flush, it will be even more effecient.
      Don't use like some people 100% kerosine or diesel fuel instead of oil because You will have too low engine oil pressure so one you risk damaging engine second with low oil pressure and flow it doesn't work as well

    • @anirudhaarvind1736
      @anirudhaarvind1736 Před rokem +1

      Is it a myth that flushing an older engine causes it to spring leaks ?

  • @grizzle273463
    @grizzle273463 Před 11 měsíci +11

    That was awesome. Thx for taking the time to make this.

  • @SimTrixSon
    @SimTrixSon Před 10 měsíci +2

    Man I been looking for a really in-dept video about the liqui moly engine flush and this is perfect!

  • @OverlandOrange
    @OverlandOrange Před měsícem +3

    I used Engine Flush on my 2005 Tacoma w/ 234k, with issues impacting the timing chain. Replacement of the chain was recommended to the tune of $4,500. $18 Engine Flush and 1 extra oil change to flush it all out, and my truck drives like new and no longer needs the repair. NO exaggeration, this stuff is awesome.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před měsícem +1

      Glad to hear it worked out! 💪

  • @ethanmcquaid1
    @ethanmcquaid1 Před 4 měsíci +1

    Incredibly thorough! Love your attention to detail! Definitely subscribing.

  • @tbryan1697
    @tbryan1697 Před 6 měsíci +2

    Really good video quality and close ups. Thorough experiment with inconclusive results. Great effort. Thanks!

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před 6 měsíci

      Thank you very much!

    • @trvman1
      @trvman1 Před 2 měsíci

      Yes, basically all it does show if you change your oil 3 times in a row it comes out clean.

  • @ShikiKaze
    @ShikiKaze Před rokem +7

    I am glad someone on CZcams has the brains the use a proper oil filter cutter. Everyone out here trying to kill themselves with an angle grinder or lose an eye with a sawzall.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem

      Agreed, $25 well spent. Its tough looking at a filter cut with a saw as you cant tell what metal or contaminants are from the saw blade or the engine.

    • @ShikiKaze
      @ShikiKaze Před rokem +2

      @@OwenLucas That's the issue with most of the reviewers just cutting into it with power tools. I can understands tin snips. But when they say try as best they can to not contaminate the filter but then proceed to cut with a power tool it makes their effort moot. Great job on the thought process. Subbing for that.

  • @YazidiOmar
    @YazidiOmar Před 4 měsíci +2

    Best test i ever see in youtube thanks for your time and investement

  • @noob_mechanic
    @noob_mechanic Před rokem +26

    Thank for the time,effort and money spent in the making of this video for other people benefit...salut

  • @derbrandmeister4660
    @derbrandmeister4660 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Very good effort you made for this video! Thank you very much!

  • @isaacjrv
    @isaacjrv Před 6 měsíci +5

    What a video. Amazing, from my experience as I change my own oil, synthetic oil gets darker quicker than conventional oil due temperature, you can see this in other videos as well when they use pots with high heat, gunk in the oil will vary from engine to engine, as I remember my old Toyota pickup truck will get the oil pretty dark within 3000 miles and my Hyundai accent GDI was not as dark after 7000 miles and not as full of gunk as the old truck, but definitely color in newer oils is not actually an indicator as when heated will darker quickly anyways.

  • @georgelynch6139
    @georgelynch6139 Před 11 měsíci +8

    They make a thing called a funnel, they work great

  • @theredscourge
    @theredscourge Před rokem +5

    Nice touch leaving the drain plug to get covered in the oil drain pan to annoy the OCD types X-D

  • @jaywalker6464
    @jaywalker6464 Před 7 měsíci +2

    I love the video, straightforward no bs.

  • @Atilolzz
    @Atilolzz Před rokem +10

    Can we all appreciate the precision at 1:10?

  • @wallerwolf6930
    @wallerwolf6930 Před rokem +1

    Great test, which is obviously very meaningful. The stuff works!

  • @alexanderbarth8320
    @alexanderbarth8320 Před 11 měsíci +2

    Good job. I never thought somebody would go through all this struggle. That was good information.

  • @nas979
    @nas979 Před rokem +23

    To answer your last question you could have done another oil change after driving same km when added the sludge remover and see if the discolouring was due to driving that distance or due to the sludge remover.

    • @sylvainr.399
      @sylvainr.399 Před měsícem

      Totally agree. I was going to write that exact same comment. I would have actually loved to see that, which would have truly completed the test.

    • @MrUsaer
      @MrUsaer Před 24 dny

      Yep. Ended test early. Had no money for gas. Spent it all on oil. Regardless, great video!

  • @kinsmart7294
    @kinsmart7294 Před 11 měsíci +36

    After these intense flushes its always an good idea to drop the oil pan and open the oil pickup filter and clean the pan. Sometimes the interior of the oil pan is painted and the flush can remove the paint and make it clog the oil pickup tube.

  • @Apegabe
    @Apegabe Před rokem +5

    Liqui-Moly products just work! Great video.

  • @CJ-yf5cr
    @CJ-yf5cr Před 11 měsíci +3

    Thank you for taking the time to do this. I'm getting my oil changed soon and this really helped me. 👍

  • @e46imolared
    @e46imolared Před rokem +1

    Video is which i exactly looking for and thanks for effort

  • @dimmacommunication
    @dimmacommunication Před rokem +15

    I prefer the new interchangeable filters :) with top mounting, no oil mess and way easier :)

  • @maliknolan5711
    @maliknolan5711 Před rokem +4

    THANKS FOR THE VIDEO MORE CONTENT ABOUT LIQUI MOLY PRODUCTS ❤

  • @DunOpondo
    @DunOpondo Před rokem +2

    Great comparative video 👍🏿.
    You should also compare that Bizol oil system clean+ o90, does a great job

  • @uranusneptun5239
    @uranusneptun5239 Před rokem +51

    I did two flushes with the sludge stuff in combination with cheap BUT SPECIFIED oil for my engine (a 1.9 JTDm). It worked wonders! I initially planned to do at least 3 flushes because the engine didn't look well maintained but this has been enough. I then filled up with high quality oil, also Liqui Moly and during every oil change and flush I used a new oil filter also a Bosch quality part. I'll repeat this process before the next oil change after 10k km and will probably continue to do so. To get it even more clean and let it stay clean. Engine has almost 200k km on it.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +3

      Is the engine in an Alpha Romeo 159? That is a beautiful car. Glad to see the flush worked out for you! A good oil with a lot of detergents will also help clean your engine between flushes.

    • @averagedev7768
      @averagedev7768 Před rokem

      I must ask where you found a 1.9 JTDm with less then 200 000km. The dash bight be showing that but trust me not a single one has that milage. None the less that is a very reliable engine. I suppose you got it in the Alfa 147 or 159 or in Fiat Stilo

    • @Druze_Tito
      @Druze_Tito Před rokem

      10k is a pretty long interval

    • @eponymous7910
      @eponymous7910 Před rokem +2

      ​@@Druze_Tito not really. 6000 Miles. It's about average I would've thought

    • @Druze_Tito
      @Druze_Tito Před rokem +6

      @@eponymous7910 average doesnt mean anything. It is too high. I dont recommend going more than 6000 km no matter the oil. If you love your car.

  • @fastst1
    @fastst1 Před rokem +36

    Also beware, sometimes if the sludge is really heavy, it can end up clogging the oil pump pickup screen. Used to add a quart or half a quart of ATF to an oil change, the atf has amazing amounts of detergents in it to keep the transmission squeaky clean. Keep going forward with regular oil changes.

    • @CrazyChiefXxX
      @CrazyChiefXxX Před rokem +2

      wouldnt that be hard on turbo bearings? if you drive a OEm turbo 4?

    • @Chris-nm1jr
      @Chris-nm1jr Před rokem +2

      No it wont. So much detergents and emulgator in it.

    • @slimsherman5818
      @slimsherman5818 Před 10 měsíci +1

      Did you mean add to old oil to help flush and then drain, or to top off after fresh oil change. Thanks

    • @fastst1
      @fastst1 Před 10 měsíci +11

      @@slimsherman5818 That's correct, 500-1000 miles before the next oil change a shot of ATF into the engine oil. The biggest generator of nasty sludge is cold thermostats, short trips and crazy intervals between changes.

    • @makgstefan
      @makgstefan Před 5 měsíci +5

      i hear this answer all the time everywhere. Be aware that using engine flush can clog the oil pump or the pickup screen. Have you ever seen how big is the pickup screen and how big are the gaps? If you can clog this pickup screen it means your engine is tearing apart not just sludge. To clog this screen you need pieces of the bearings or the pistons. It is not so simple to clog the pickup screen. And if the engine can clog because of this it means you need a change of engine not just sludge removers.

  • @pitik
    @pitik Před 7 měsíci +1

    Very good test... . Thank you so much.

  • @TheSupergunman3000
    @TheSupergunman3000 Před rokem +6

    Keep up with this content and you will reach 100k in no time, accurate testing, direct to the point, helpful information, can be better with better editing and camera work, also possible improvements in lubricity testing but this will happen naturally with time
    Keep up this good content testing different products for cars (but not necessarily)

  • @ambrogiogatti3429
    @ambrogiogatti3429 Před rokem +1

    Questo è l'esperimento più completo che abbia mai visto.
    Complimenti!!
    Io tuttavia non uso i tuoi prodotti, uso il Liqui Moly Clean 1019
    Non ho mai fatto le tue prove, ma sono convinto che un po' di pulizia all'interno del motore la faccia.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +1

      Grazie per i complimenti signore. Non ho sentito parlare di Motor Clean 1019. Non è disponibile negli Stati Uniti, ma vedrò se riesco a procurarmene uno. Liqui Moly produce così tanti prodotti che la loro gamma è davvero impressionante. Grazie ancora.

  • @noahlapuz3853
    @noahlapuz3853 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Beautiful demonstration!

  • @roshansanju341
    @roshansanju341 Před 8 měsíci +2

    What a detailed explanation...
    Wonderful.. wonderful 👍

  • @Ram14250
    @Ram14250 Před rokem +9

    I think that 3.6 L GM V6's are very shootie engines when they combust fuel. I think the oil will get darker just by driving. Those little particles you found in the oil filters are just from driving and the oil collecting shoot. It was a fun video to watch though!

  • @dillonostrum9264
    @dillonostrum9264 Před rokem +6

    It definitely was a good cleaner as ive seen lighter oil on diesels after 200 miles since an oil change

  • @cbidwell91
    @cbidwell91 Před 6 měsíci +9

    Good chance the color changed due to temperature from your drive. Oil turns black simply by getting hot, but the little chunks you got out are a good indication that the product was helping. Cool video, and at the end of the day it can't hurt to try and flush an engine. AMSOIL has a similar product as well.

    • @datsuntoyy
      @datsuntoyy Před 5 měsíci +1

      No it doesn’t. If your oil discolors from getting hot, you have some seriously bad oil.

    • @TheRatTravels
      @TheRatTravels Před 5 měsíci +1

      Blow-by occurs when combustion gases and possibly some unburned fuel pass by the piston rings and enter the crankcase. These gases can contain carbon from the combustion process, which then mixes with the engine oil, causing it to darken. If the piston rings are worn out or not sealing properly, blow-by can increase, leading to more rapid oil discoloration.

    • @cbidwell91
      @cbidwell91 Před 5 měsíci +2

      @@datsuntoyy Yes it does. It is a well-known characteristic in the oil industry around thermal/fluid dynamics. Simply heating oil in a beaker will turn the oil black. Now, there a many other factors which can contribute, but oxidation and heat will turn the oil from its gold color to black quite quickly. Project Farm has some great oil testing videos (much of which can be subjective) but he will heat up oil on hot plates and after 30 minutes of heat the oil is black.

    • @datsuntoyy
      @datsuntoyy Před 5 měsíci

      @@cbidwell91 Burning oil will turn it black, ordinary use doesn't get that hot. I've seen plenty of oil samples in my 50 years of working on cars with a few hundred miles that have no color at all other than the light amber it comes with. Likewise, MANY years ago I've seen brand new oil that's nearly black.
      Hot plates get a lot hotter than a car engine does. My car's maxes out at 220 (hottest I've ever seen it) yet my hot plate can get over twice that.
      In his test he's heating it to 400 degrees and flashpoint of Mobil 1 5w-30 is 440 so he's heating it to nearly catching on fire. He also talks about the oil smoking, in cooking it's called the smoke point and oil burns when it his the smoke point.

  • @scoremxcom
    @scoremxcom Před 10 měsíci +31

    get a funnel.

  • @bluesideup7891
    @bluesideup7891 Před rokem +1

    Very interesting thank you for the test!

  • @arthurmroyce
    @arthurmroyce Před rokem +14

    Back in the day, we threw in a quart of kerosene and let the engine idle for 20 to 30 minutes. Then we changed the oil and filter.

    • @jimizbikowski4112
      @jimizbikowski4112 Před rokem

      Kerosene or diesel!!! Or... Trans fluid! Old school fix right there!

    • @_TheBreaker_
      @_TheBreaker_ Před rokem

      A bit of Trans fluid is a cheap lifter tick fix

    • @hayabusettofficial4469
      @hayabusettofficial4469 Před rokem

      @@jimizbikowski4112wont kerosene and diesel will make oil seals bcome bad ?

  • @michaelmyers3892
    @michaelmyers3892 Před rokem +6

    I have a 2002 Subaru AWD outback over 250,000 + miles on the original four-cylinder engine smoking none of that stuff but 95% of those miles or all highway so I burned up most of your carbon and sludge because of that but now I'm doing a deep dive and going to give her a thorough cleaning and that includes dropping the oil pan cleaning out the pick up screen and oil pan you in a double flush and clean she's worth it she's been a super reliable car all over the United States including the Rocky mountains

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem

      Interesting, give it a flew flushes first, might be able to avoid pulling the pan off. Congrats on taking care of the car to 250k! 💪

    • @michaelmyers3892
      @michaelmyers3892 Před rokem

      @@OwenLucas she's been a remarkable car how many people underestimate the Subaru and how reliable they are just normal maintenance and these things will go forever

    • @gregs7519
      @gregs7519 Před rokem

      @@michaelmyers3892 make sure you replace the head gasket with the new MLS style if you haven't already done so

  • @free2chasehappy
    @free2chasehappy Před rokem +7

    I wonder how much the Engine Flush could clean out after running the Sludge Remover… Great vid!

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +2

      Interesting question, you would hope it got everything.

  • @ugniusskeivys972
    @ugniusskeivys972 Před měsícem

    I used fluch on my old ford transit mk6, I couldn't believe the result, there was no more smoke and the engine started with half a turn of the key. I recommend!!!

  • @joehardy7984
    @joehardy7984 Před měsícem +1

    To help answer your question about the darkness after the moly flush. Molybdenum disulfide is a dry lubricant somewhat similar to graphite. It’s a fine black powder mixed with whatever else is in the engine flush. The results can seem a little misleading. It gives the appearance of more contaminants being removed when really it just turns things dark. It’s used as a thickener in complex lithium moly grease. Great for ball joints and cv shaft bearings (not the tripod gears in the shaft). The thickening effect is why they recommend keeping away from full throttle circulation. The idea with the moly isn’t to clean anything but to coat the engine components allowing them to have the additional lubricating affect from the moly. Not sure there’s enough moly in the flush to have any real impact.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před měsícem

      Very interesting points. I’ll have to check the MSDS to see if there is moly in the flush, if they even disclose that.
      Would be interesting to see if LiquiMoly turns new oil on a new engine dark!
      The part about thickening is interesting as I thought the solvents in the flush thinned the oil.
      Thank you for your insights!

  • @NoHandleAT
    @NoHandleAT Před rokem +272

    The color of the Oil is not related its cleanness, If you boil Engine oil it turns dark/black. Do the test, put some engine oil on a pan and cook it for a couple hours you will see it turn black without absolutely no "contaminants".

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +93

      I will take your word for it, no need for me to bring motor oil into the kitchen, my wife would be very mad! Very good point though, as a previous commenter mentioned, particle count would be the definitive test.

    • @Hernsama
      @Hernsama Před rokem +13

      I second that. When I bought my new car I did an oil change at 500 miles and 1k miles and it was brown both times. It had little hint of gold but that’s about it.

    • @Athiril
      @Athiril Před rokem +19

      Fresh oil also doesn’t come out that dark after 125 miles

    • @jackylsmith8138
      @jackylsmith8138 Před rokem +27

      @@Athiril if it is a diesel it will come out black. It is designed to.

    • @shckltnebay
      @shckltnebay Před rokem +6

      @@Athiril Disagree

  • @johndangelo9630
    @johndangelo9630 Před rokem +7

    I would have sent the oil samples to get tested. You may discover that the sludge, and engine flush products may have also introduced contamination to the engine bearings... to begin that slow wear...especially if the additives also had an opportunity to bypass the oil filter.

  • @slozanov5330
    @slozanov5330 Před rokem +1

    very good test

  • @lawrencecavens5760
    @lawrencecavens5760 Před 4 měsíci +1

    You have to remember that the Sump will have sludge that builds up over time and will get washed out with solvents.
    To help prevent this condition use WD40 in with your oil. 1 cup will work fine and clean all internal parts and you will also find that oil changes will be abit fewer that you'll need as the engine is getting a gentle clean out. I did this with a 2008 Ford F250 Super Duty and great results happend as I let the WD40 work with my oil my engine has returned to near factory condition. One of my lash adjuster was starting to stick when the engine was at operating temp and light ticking was heard - on cold start up it was all quiet - So i tried this in adding WD40 and It sure worked and freed up what ever the stickiness was at the lash adjuster and no more tick .

  • @drumvannelle69
    @drumvannelle69 Před rokem +1

    Great video 👍

  • @ForkInTheButt
    @ForkInTheButt Před 11 měsíci +7

    As one of hondas engine engineers said, never do this to a high mileage engine as it could cause more problems by clogging holes with debris. Leave the engine as it is

    • @eviltwo7950
      @eviltwo7950 Před 9 měsíci

      Is this true

    • @jayw900
      @jayw900 Před 7 měsíci

      @@eviltwo7950
      No idea about what a Honda engineer said. However, it's for the same reason it is not recommended to do a tranny flush in a high mileage car that has never had one done before.

  • @factsnotfeelingssendit5961

    Quart of diesel idle 10 minutes drop oil. Repeat if necessary. Seafoam in the crank works well too.

  • @thomaslam6821
    @thomaslam6821 Před rokem +1

    Great video! 👍👍👍

  • @abdo2010wwe
    @abdo2010wwe Před rokem +1

    Good job test 🎉

  • @steven4894
    @steven4894 Před rokem +1

    Thanks for your research and due diligence on this important 🚗 engine topic.

  • @IvanToman
    @IvanToman Před 11 měsíci +2

    You forgot last part of experiment. Drive another 200 km now without any cleaning aditive and drain again. If you see significant difference between that and previous sample than it works; if it is again similarly dirty then it does not.

  • @shanetseng6040
    @shanetseng6040 Před rokem +5

    The test was almost perfect!! Only part thaz missing is to keep the constant of 160miles drive between every single fill and drains (and you said it too). But good test tho overall!

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +1

      Thank you! Yes, that's basically 2 hours of driving, would have been a lot of filming time lol.

    • @shanetseng6040
      @shanetseng6040 Před rokem

      @@OwenLucas yea, right! lol

  • @monkehbitch
    @monkehbitch Před 5 měsíci +4

    The base line would be to see if you actually had any sludge build up in the first place by taking off the valve cover. I guess the only thing you did really was super clean your engine. (Never a bad thing)

  • @ClarVad
    @ClarVad Před 2 měsíci +3

    I was taught that your oil turns black no matter how clean the engine is. There is always some stuff that gets past the rings on the piston and gets into the oil. Great video.

  • @n0isiv
    @n0isiv Před 4 měsíci +1

    great video. did wish that you did 1 more oil change after the flush and see if 140 miles was dark again and if there were any particles.

  • @felixlafuente9714
    @felixlafuente9714 Před rokem +1

    Great Video!!

  • @RickYt001
    @RickYt001 Před 2 měsíci +1

    nice test. appreciate

  • @rocker19061
    @rocker19061 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Hey, noce video. But whats the name of the tool you ised to open the oil filter?

  • @NorthlanderMN
    @NorthlanderMN Před rokem +2

    Gonna do a BG epr flush on a Camry with 165000 miles. I’m gonna change it twice but changing the oil filter one time because it’s a real pain dealing with. Should be fine.

  • @chongshenchang9367
    @chongshenchang9367 Před 3 měsíci +1

    The blackness of the oil depends on whether your vehicle is Diesel or Petrol engine. In Diesel engine, the oil becomes black within few miles of driving which is very much normal. And the blackness of the oil is not due to flushing, but that's how it should be naturally. No need to flush.

  • @videomaniac108
    @videomaniac108 Před 2 měsíci

    I have a Nissan 370z and would monitor the color change of my oil over the 3K oil change interval I used. I found that even after 1K miles the oil would only be very slightly darker than when new. I would say that there would probably be no discernable change in color, unless you're running a diesel engine.

  • @marcasswellbmd6922
    @marcasswellbmd6922 Před 11 měsíci +1

    You should have just used it and then did drain and fills to see if it continues to break off carbon after the oil is changed.. Thanks great vid..

  • @tj-hero
    @tj-hero Před 11 měsíci +1

    i really thank you for sharing your video with us 🙏🌹🌹🌹

  • @shahreeyman
    @shahreeyman Před 5 měsíci +1

    After seeing this video, I need full engine opening video, to confirm my doub

  • @twanahawrami7691
    @twanahawrami7691 Před měsícem +1

    Good job thanks 👍👍👍👍

  • @PetrolHeadBrasil
    @PetrolHeadBrasil Před rokem +2

    Nothing like having enough money to do 3 oil changes for a CZcams video...one day I'll make it!

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem

      I haven’t made it yet! I actually got those oil jugs at Amazon on clearance for about $5 each lol.

    • @PetrolHeadBrasil
      @PetrolHeadBrasil Před rokem +2

      @@OwenLucas WOW!!!! 5 bucks?! That was cheap indeed....

  • @triodak
    @triodak Před 11 měsíci +2

    I use Engine Flush Pro (# 2037) every time I change oil (Once a year at 8-12k km). Engine is 1.8T from Audi. I idle the engine filed with Flush for 90-120 min (not the recommended 10 min). After 10 years of this treatment even 50 min idle does not dark oil much. There still is "dirt" in engine but to work with it Flush need 90 min minimum. Good quality 0W-30 oil is a little darker after year of use. In the past it was dark straight after oil change. Oil filter always have few small black pieces of sludge (I cut open them). Oil consumption is on the same level for years. It did decrease a little after first 2 years. I do recommend to use engine flush every oil change. Six times for 90 min then once a year.

    • @javieroargubi
      @javieroargubi Před 9 měsíci +1

      wow 90-120 mins? 2 hours of idling?? that cant be good?

    • @knallaff
      @knallaff Před 6 měsíci

      😂Not for your wallet and not for the environment

    • @Romo.85
      @Romo.85 Před 4 měsíci

      You are crazy 😅

  • @jtbrown5801
    @jtbrown5801 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Good test

  • @MrOnlymoin1
    @MrOnlymoin1 Před rokem +1

    wonderful video

  • @sanjeevbhaskar5472
    @sanjeevbhaskar5472 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Change oil every 4 months and oil filter every alternate oil change, you won't need any sludge remover or flush for 300,000 kms.

  • @Coyote27981
    @Coyote27981 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Whenever i buy a used car, specially if it looks dirty inside the engine.
    I buy 3 oil filters, 1 fill of cheap oil, 1 liqui moly engine flush and 1 fill of good oil.
    Swap the oil filter and warm it up. put the engine flush, run it as instructed. Drain old oil and remove filter. Put cheap oil plus 2nd filter. Drive it 2000km. Drain oil and remove filter. Put good oil plus 3rd filter.
    That usually makes the trick.

  • @neiliewheeliebin
    @neiliewheeliebin Před 3 měsíci +1

    There's already solvents in synthetic oil from what I've seen, i left oil on a red funnel & wiped it with a white cloth to see red come off it

  • @_jurist
    @_jurist Před rokem +21

    Dude, get a funnel

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +2

      😂

    • @joelnrs
      @joelnrs Před 7 měsíci +2

      Living life on the edge without a funnel 😂

    • @adjes2010
      @adjes2010 Před 2 měsíci

      😂😂😂😂

  • @bma1970
    @bma1970 Před měsícem +1

    Thank you👍

  • @kebruya
    @kebruya Před 3 měsíci +1

    In my opinion the sludge remover would be the safest way to flush engine, since its less concentrated, it will slowly dissolve the sludge, trying to flush it in 10 minutes would possibly break away a big chunk of sludge possibly clog your oil gally.

  • @Ardiansyah-zp1pk
    @Ardiansyah-zp1pk Před 2 měsíci +1

    I once tried using cooking oil to clean the oil sludge in my car, with a ratio of 50:50, after 4000 kilometers, the LO sludge all collapsed.

  • @ronaldq1653
    @ronaldq1653 Před 6 měsíci

    Good morning, Blessings, Greetings from San Carlos, Costa Rica, Pura Vida, question, I am new to this, which of the 2 liquids is first added to the engine, the engine cleaner or the mud remover, which is added first.

  • @laxavierpierre4481
    @laxavierpierre4481 Před rokem +1

    The potting on that super tech filter….

  • @masautomx2131
    @masautomx2131 Před rokem +2

    The best way after flushing the engine, is to remove the engine carter and clean all the sludge acumulated on it

  • @cuvame
    @cuvame Před rokem +6

    When dealing with diesel engines. Color doesnt matter because it gets dirty as fast as 1 2 3..... so usually I check for the consistency. Yes it is black but then consistency should be watery and not thick like honey.

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +1

      Great point!

    • @jacekkangaroo4402
      @jacekkangaroo4402 Před 8 měsíci

      in my 3.2 liter turbo diesel engine oil changes color after 1500-2000km

    • @cuvame
      @cuvame Před 8 měsíci

      @@jacekkangaroo4402 you use synthetic or mineral?

    • @jacekkangaroo4402
      @jacekkangaroo4402 Před 8 měsíci

      @@cuvame always full synthetic

    • @cuvame
      @cuvame Před 8 měsíci

      @@jacekkangaroo4402 imagine.... your even using fully synthetic and is goe sblack after 2k hahaha but I bet the consistency is still watery which is what every owner should look for.

  • @brantfrans8595
    @brantfrans8595 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Interesting product.👍

  • @Alvon_PR
    @Alvon_PR Před 11 měsíci +1

    I would recommen using diesel oil because it had high TBN which cleaning engine, it will clean your engine from sludge slowly without cloging your oil pump pick up screen.

  • @sbrader97
    @sbrader97 Před rokem +19

    But since the sludge remover is weaker to be able to be used while driving 124 miles i think it could still overall clean out a engine better than normal engine flush thats run at idle as it gets longer to work and the revs might get it into other parts of the engine like vvt which might not happen at idle though ive heard that can also cause issues if you flush sludge and block the vvt filter screen with sludge

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před rokem +7

      That is a very good point, especially about the vvt screen.

    • @CL9k24a3
      @CL9k24a3 Před rokem +2

      Always replace vvt screen after flush. When you are at idle than no harm can be done

  • @user-nr3hr9lu1v
    @user-nr3hr9lu1v Před 5 měsíci +1

    The color is very important!!
    One more time - very important.
    Thats why by sports cars they change the oil in every couple of thousands kilometer... evel less - depending on the lot's of things - speed, RPM's , long high -speed drive and so long.
    An example - when you look in the french fries pan with a new oil - even at 180C - the oil is still light brown - gold.
    The most important thing here is that a person who wants a very good and useful car should change the oil not in 25 - 30 000 km , but in a 10 - 12 000km. And he must do it with min 2 times engine flush.
    In the end of the day - it depends of the personal needs and money!
    Wish you all a very nice day ✌️💫

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před 5 měsíci +1

      You too Sir, thank you for your insight!

  • @reinhardwolters7180
    @reinhardwolters7180 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Old deposits will not be removed by simply rinsing with oil. And I was told that there are funnels for transferring liquids.

  • @binagarten4667
    @binagarten4667 Před 4 měsíci +1

    I did a BG oil flush, and then a further 4 oil and filter changes. I do have to stress at this point the moter was a diesel. The final oil at a cost of after £200 was light. Within 20 miles of driving it was black as the Ace of Spades. The car was a VW Golf TDi 1.9 BXE engine. My uncle a mechanic of many years standing came and gave me a kick up the jacksie, he said you have just wasted £200, and worse still so many hours, days and time. People buy carsfor the sum I spent in oil changes and flushes!

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před 4 měsíci

      Yeah 1 drain is enough, but at least your engine is super clean!

  • @torentmonkey
    @torentmonkey Před 7 měsíci +1

    My advice, run the cheapest oil for very short intervals like 1 2 weeks and under 1000 miles. Drain, repeat a few times. I buy oil in bulk like 20 liter jugs and do this to any car I buy then switch to a higher quality oil and 6 month or 5k miles intervals ( this applies to me only and will vary with usage track or grocery getting ).

  • @CHEVI789
    @CHEVI789 Před měsícem

    I change my oil every 7500-10,000 km (4700-6250 Mi)which is every 6 months in my case, and every time I look at the oil dipstick it's so clean, I learned this from my old 70's car where I was forced to change it due to oil loss, and that car had done over 380,000km (237,500 Mi)and still flew like a rocket, new oil and filter keeps your engine clean and the most important thing, your seals nice and soft.

  • @Rns555
    @Rns555 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Helpful video, could you say which one is the best to clean up sludge on pistons and valves?

    • @OwenLucas
      @OwenLucas  Před 7 měsíci +1

      According to the LiquiMoly engineer that I spoke with. The pro-Line Engine Flush is the most powerful of their engine flushes. Regarding the valves, you will need a specific valve cleaner. Techron is works great along with LiquiMoly 2001 Valve Clean.

    • @Rns555
      @Rns555 Před 7 měsíci +1

      @@OwenLucas thanks! 👍🏼

  • @kris856
    @kris856 Před rokem +3

    Please try some Archoil or Oilsyn Powercleaner... I used to use LM, but after I came across the AR stuff, which I consider to be the best ones on the market, I will never try anything else

  • @madeulook5872
    @madeulook5872 Před rokem +1

    Having 2k on my current oil change. It's still not this dark so I'm gonna say it's the additives