Shankara vs Secularism || Project SHIVOHAM

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 09. 2022
  • ‘India is a Secular Country!’. People who often flaunt these words attribute the Secular character of India to the Constitution of India - which is technically correct. But how come? & why is that Bharat has always been a Pluralistic society accommodative of any religion since thousands of years?
    From a Dharmic standpoint, ISHTA DEVATHA - which means, ‘you worship the God of your choice’ has been part of Bharatiya Civilization. SARVE JANA SUKHINO BHAVANTU - Let us all live together in peace & harmony has been a core societal value in Bharat. Then what additional value Secularism brings to the table? Is Secularism relevant & essential to Bharat?
    Shankara resolved many ideological conflicts & harmonized the society in Bharat. If Shankara deals with Secularism, then how would he respond? In this doc film, we will analyze…
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 579

  • @shivanshdhardubey124
    @shivanshdhardubey124 Před rokem +131

    Adi Shankara single handedly revived Hinduism when it was on the verge of collapse he went all over India and restore back our Sanatan Dharma by his reasoning,teaching and persistence we should forever be grateful to this person that our culture and Dharma is existing today🙏🙏🙏.

    • @amannoobs
      @amannoobs Před rokem +7

      this is a false narrative created by the communists, he restored advaita vedanta with the help of upanishads. Vaidik dharma was never dying

    • @juniordev4190
      @juniordev4190 Před 11 měsíci

      ​@conormakwana6352 who are shudra?

    • @ShankarShankar-hb7bi
      @ShankarShankar-hb7bi Před 11 měsíci

      @@amannoobs so who was the founder of Advaita Vedanta ?

    • @ShankarShankar-hb7bi
      @ShankarShankar-hb7bi Před 11 měsíci

      @conormakwana6352 I Can't find out what chapter or slok are you taking about please explain in detail about the chapter , section , sloka I can't able to find out in Bharmastra shankar bhasya

    • @NoThing-ec9km
      @NoThing-ec9km Před 5 měsíci

      R u joking@@amannoobs

  • @Vedantshikhara
    @Vedantshikhara Před rokem +94

    I'm EX- SECULAR HINDU
    only proud hindu now ❤❤❤🙏🙏🚩🚩🕉🕉🕉

    • @maheshbabu.k44
      @maheshbabu.k44 Před rokem +2

      Great and you are Hindu means you are secular as it is a part of Hindu ❤

    • @user-ri4cr6bn2s
      @user-ri4cr6bn2s Před rokem +2

      @@maheshbabu.k44 not the secularism what society says

    • @Mahadev_BHAKT.....
      @Mahadev_BHAKT..... Před 12 dny

      I am Ex Atheist and Ex Secular..

  • @raghavendrabairy393
    @raghavendrabairy393 Před rokem +102

    Bharat was a pluralistic nation since centuries. But the present generation is not understanding it. Due to the fault of some selfish people who misunderstood our scriptures, we are finding faults in our ancestral knowledge. Our ancestors considered every single being as the manifestation of that Supreme entity, The Parabrahman. We should also strive hard to preserve the pluralistic nature of our Desh Bharat and make it the only nation that exhibits unity in diversity.
    🙏 ॥ सर्वे संतु निरामयः ॥ 🙏
    🙏 ॥ सर्वे जनाः सुखीनो भवन्तु ॥ 🙏

  • @hinata9786
    @hinata9786 Před rokem +160

    This is the level we have to reach, the knowledge that guided us for so many years and yet we don't have an idea about it. Beautiful presentation, the slokas from Vivekchudamani the heart of Advaita vedanta is so powerful. 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

  • @_That_which_is_not_
    @_That_which_is_not_ Před 3 měsíci +4

    Why there's only 75k views...?
    Everyone should share this video

  • @sureshbhale1107
    @sureshbhale1107 Před rokem +9

    Caste based discrimination should end 🙏
    All are equal. This is what our dharma teach

  • @vikinieswaranvki
    @vikinieswaranvki Před rokem +23

    No words brother,🥲
    Dharmo Rakshati Rakshitaha.🔱🔥🙏

    • @akhripasta2670
      @akhripasta2670 Před 2 měsíci +1

      Dum Google translate back at it again
      Dharma is not Abrahamic view of Religion

  • @nibnahcnak
    @nibnahcnak Před rokem +31

    When we include these scriptural knowledge base in our everyday schooling we will see Bhavya Bharat 🇮🇳. Jai Hind 🙏
    Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam 🤗

    • @NoThing-ec9km
      @NoThing-ec9km Před 5 měsíci

      It's not allowed, In according to Indian constitution, U can teach any religion in school except Hinduism, If u try to teach Hinduism, U will be taken to jail.

    • @Namish-yv9mz
      @Namish-yv9mz Před měsícem

      As per my knowledge the Constitution of India forbids teaching any religion in schools any religion be it Islam or Christianity or Hinduism or even Jainism and Buddhism. They can do it in their 'religious institutions' if they want to (not Hindus but everyone else). But you see I have seen the ideologies of Jainism and Buddhism being taught in history books. I mean apart from their 'history' which the subject is actually meant for, they also teach their basic ideologies ( talking only about Jainism and Buddhism ... to some extent also Sikhism and Sufism ). But that has never been the case with the Vedic religion despite the fact that it is the most ancient religion of Bharat and the foundation of Bharat in every respect has been laid on the principles of this very religion or at least has an essence of it in itself.@@NoThing-ec9km

  • @jayeshsinghmar677
    @jayeshsinghmar677 Před rokem +29

    Yeeeeeesssss!!!!! I was trying to learn more about guru adi Shankaracharya. What better source to learn from than project shivoham. Har har mahadev.

  • @oss8537
    @oss8537 Před rokem +64

    LITERALLY THE MOST AMAZING DOCUMENTARY I HAVE EVER SEEN.
    THANK YOU PROJECT SHIVOHAM 🙏
    SATYAMEV JAYATE 🙏🙏👍

    • @nativeam25
      @nativeam25 Před rokem

      Most amazing advertisements every fkn 25 seconds.

  • @animeshbhatt3383
    @animeshbhatt3383 Před rokem +16

    Polytheistic religions by nature is secular. West introduced this concept after it became monotheistic. Which means they found a major fault line in what they adopted.

  • @rakeshbai2732
    @rakeshbai2732 Před rokem +16

    I am so glad I found this channel. Cheers from 🇺🇸 I hope that we can all learn more from the dharmic philosophies…❤

  • @krpillaikrpillai6404
    @krpillaikrpillai6404 Před rokem +4

    An absolutely 'Stand out' video...
    A real masterpiece that upholds Sankara's enriched view points on Sanatan Dharma and exposes current absolute misuse of the word secularism

  • @HemanthReddyBharatiya
    @HemanthReddyBharatiya Před rokem +20

    Sri matre namah 🙏🙏
    Am making notes out of your videos అన్న. It helps me for my preparation to write glorifying culture of our Sanatanis 🙏🚩🚩🚩
    Jai Hind 🙏

  • @Anonymous-oq6zf
    @Anonymous-oq6zf Před rokem +30

    Thank you for such good research and knowledge. I am always curious about dharmic philosophy, and you make it so easy and logical to understand. Please continue your work. (From Haryana)

    • @ramchandrasingh6743
      @ramchandrasingh6743 Před rokem +3

      🌸🌸जय श्री कृष्णा🌸🌸
      💐💐राधे कृष्णा💐💐

  • @muralinatarajanyogambal3173

    The problem for today’s Bharath is when we talk about pluralism it means every thing is a manifestation of self and hence all are equal. Some thought the same when they encountered the Abrahamic system as another form of pluralism without understanding that Abrahamic concept itself will kill the very essence of pluralism. However we should also give credit that the same concept of pluralism had given strength to some others not to embrace Abrahamic religion because of its Ill effect.

  • @draculus4318
    @draculus4318 Před rokem +28

    Absolute respect for you. Your project has added huge knowledge about Bhartiya knowledge system in my life. Thank you.

  • @muddukrishnaiahk536
    @muddukrishnaiahk536 Před rokem +2

    People of Bharat and the world at large are woe much to shivoham for this noble and glittering enlightenment between Bharats pluralism and British secularism, thanks to shivoham alot in these dark burning days of ignorance.

  • @adishankarabrahmavidyapeet8719

    Wonderful analysis! Jaya Shankara!!

  • @MKSundaram
    @MKSundaram Před rokem +6

    Truly appreciate your efforts to keep the Sanatana Dharma intact by educating people of Bharat. May God Keep Showering Blessings On You. 🙂

  • @mylord8105
    @mylord8105 Před rokem +7

    धर्मो रक्षति रक्षित:

  • @rosanilebron1566
    @rosanilebron1566 Před rokem +12

    Thanks for another very interesting and educational documentary. As I was watching the video, my thought went to this question: Why institutionalized religions where created in the first place? By answering this question, one can come to the conclusion of why secularism has been adopted in democratic republics. Because, secularism is exclusive ONLY in a democracy. And this is why it has been instrumental in the West. But, Bharat stems from a whole diffetent background in which spiritual and cultural pluralism is the basis of its society. I think that due to the past agressions of other religions in India, in the present it presents secularism as "freedom to choose religious beliefs". Because, in the past Bharat has been very vulnerable to foreign invaders who tried to convert and force people into their religious belliefs. And Bharat wasn't a republic, it was a nation divided in different states, but no central government. When Bharat became a republic, which was very recent considering its antiquity, the central government adopted a model of democracy based on other democracies as well. These are my thoughts, maybe I'm wrong, but is the way I can understand this topic.

  • @veda.conciousness
    @veda.conciousness Před rokem +7

    Really great work sir, yes really great sentences are their in scriptures unfortunately they are not in minds and attitudes of many people in bharath. Our core point of dharma is ONENESS. MY DEEP PRAYERS TO ESWARA TO MAKE UNDERSTAND THIS BY EVERY HUMAN BEING IN THIS WORLD.
    . AFTER ALL WE ARE LIVING ON A SMALL SOIL BALL. WE ARE MOST TINY MATTERS WITH GREAT POTENTIAL........ సర్వేజనా సుఖినోభవంతు.

  • @SantoshKumar-oc5gk
    @SantoshKumar-oc5gk Před rokem +9

    Such a informative video.proud to belonging to Santana Dharma.⭕

  • @kapbhat
    @kapbhat Před rokem +8

    This is an excellent video from Shivoham. Thanks for your hard work for taking Santana Sanskruti’s values to every corner. ❤

  • @HemanthReddyBharatiya
    @HemanthReddyBharatiya Před rokem +4

    This kind of research scholar & intellectuals for this mother land BHARATA MATA 🇮🇳 wants to put the facts straight 🙏🙏🙏..
    jai Hind 🇮🇳
    Jai Bhavani 🕉️🚩🙏

  • @abhinavbadoni7032
    @abhinavbadoni7032 Před rokem +37

    Amazing sir. You're doing an awesome work to teach bhartiyas about their own dharmic culture.

  • @sriprakashhr9578
    @sriprakashhr9578 Před rokem +13

    Thanks as always for Ann educative doc film. Many a times I feel we need to blame ourselves. We forgot to recognise our dharma and aged those aggressors and became subservient. We have lost the courage to stand up for truth.

  • @VenkataSreedharNalam
    @VenkataSreedharNalam Před rokem +4

    So clearly explained. Must watch and to be understood by Sanathana Dharma followers🙏🙏🙏

  • @aryanyadav3690
    @aryanyadav3690 Před rokem +7

    हमेशा की तरह जानकारीपूर्ण वीडियो । धन्यवाद 🕉️🙏🏻

  • @qwertyqwerty2090
    @qwertyqwerty2090 Před rokem +9

    Really great work u are doing man🚩🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩

  • @Tathastu_srivastava
    @Tathastu_srivastava Před rokem +9

    what a lovely documentary you have created sir ☺☺

  • @suchitha1425
    @suchitha1425 Před rokem +13

    One of my favorite channels💖 Project Shivoham💖.
    Appreciate the deep research that goes into each topic and the straight forward presentation that makes it all the more intense.

  • @iXpress
    @iXpress Před rokem +3

    Great topic, and you have done best!!! However discussion of Christian roots of Secularism is very important. Needs another video.

  • @shaktiprasadmishra9456
    @shaktiprasadmishra9456 Před rokem +14

    Brilliant presentation. Intellectually so stimulating and factually so convincing.

  • @uttamkumarroy7337
    @uttamkumarroy7337 Před rokem +2

    Bharatya Pluralism is much better than secularism. Now the time has reached that point we have to comprehend and realize the matter consciously. 🙏

  • @Medha_03
    @Medha_03 Před rokem +3

    Excuse me, you are seriously underrated with the kind of content you have.
    Praying you reach greater heights. 🙏🙏

  • @user-om2jr5ut9s
    @user-om2jr5ut9s Před rokem +3

    One of the greatest video that i have ever watched. Love your content 💗 .no words to explain

  • @srroyalrevolt7566
    @srroyalrevolt7566 Před rokem +2

    What a Video! Thanks for the team PROJECT SHIVOHAM.
    TIME TO REWRITE THE CONSTITUTION

  • @roshanmahale5688
    @roshanmahale5688 Před rokem +1

    I don't understand why such videos does not get views. this should reach as many people as possible

  • @pavansai2683
    @pavansai2683 Před rokem +1

    Your content is simply indisputable and no more words for your analysis🤐🤐🤐🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

  • @arpandey7043
    @arpandey7043 Před 4 měsíci +3

    The problem is indian central or state govts are not secular... It separates people in the name of minority by differentiating religion... Minority law is corrupted by religious racism...govt/court needs to reevaluate whom to put in minority basket

  • @vineethsingh3126
    @vineethsingh3126 Před rokem +4

    Incredable words by acharya Shankaracharya 🙏😌😱

  • @viveknalla6554
    @viveknalla6554 Před rokem +8

    Thanks as always for this masterpiece 🙏 Always proud of Bhaarat! Bhaarat maata ki jai🙏

  • @actl7301
    @actl7301 Před rokem +1

    This is the first experience in my life when someone helped me understand about my roots, culture, history and what I am, in such a beautiful and easy way through this series of Project Shivoham.
    Sadhuwad to all the members of this Project. 🙏💐

  • @delphi247
    @delphi247 Před rokem +2

    Fantastic work, I appreciate the summary and comparison of the two philosophies. Very interesting!

  • @laxmipathich
    @laxmipathich Před rokem +3

    Thank you for such a wonderful work…Really it’s an eye opener 🙏

  • @krnprasad4804
    @krnprasad4804 Před rokem +2

    Thanks a ton for this thought provoking, food for thought episode. Bow down to you 🙏

  • @ravichandra8146
    @ravichandra8146 Před rokem +2

    Thanks a lot for sharing this documentary and help us understand the basic meaning of secularism. Else, I was of the opinion that it is something we as individuals need to manage to keep the harmony of the society. Great to know that it is completely different from pluralism which we have been following for unknown period of time.

  • @themartian7121
    @themartian7121 Před 20 dny +1

    Thank you, brother! ...... Martin from South Africa 🙏

  • @aayushpaliwal3450
    @aayushpaliwal3450 Před rokem +2

    As always, a very good doc film.

  • @ChhayaChandrasekhar
    @ChhayaChandrasekhar Před rokem +4

    Hi
    Thank you for bringing forth the principles of Guru Shankaracharya 🙏

  • @vinadoctor1646
    @vinadoctor1646 Před rokem +3

    Brilliantly explained.. thank you for sharing your wisdom.. truly appreciate your work. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @shreyaslahoti7542
    @shreyaslahoti7542 Před rokem +2

    What a beautiful explanation. Loved it.

  • @priman268
    @priman268 Před rokem

    This deserves of million views how many of you are sharing this let's share this video to all the ppl

  • @rashmiupadhyay1825
    @rashmiupadhyay1825 Před rokem +3

    Such a masterpiece ✨🙏🏼❤️

  • @babishak.b3001
    @babishak.b3001 Před rokem +1

    I just thought about project shivoham, here comes my favourite ,thank you man for your videos from kerala.

  • @noArguments
    @noArguments Před rokem +1

    जातिनीतिकुलगोत्रदूरगं
    नामरूपगुणदोषवर्जितम।
    देशकालविषयातिवर्ति यद
    ब्रह्म तत्त्वमसि भावयात्मनि।।
    Namaskaram 🔱🙏🙏

  • @sha5381
    @sha5381 Před 5 měsíci

    By far one of your best, thoughtful, though provoking & simple message doc film🙏🏻

  • @jitendrabharthi1039
    @jitendrabharthi1039 Před rokem +1

    Just one word for you explanation and details - AWESOME

  • @dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569

    Waah kya kahu iss video ka masterpiece

  • @astikmondal9690
    @astikmondal9690 Před rokem

    Thanks a lot for this wonderful logical explanation with clarity. Usually people don't want to fall in this conflict due to lack of knowledge.

  • @vamsiakula9860
    @vamsiakula9860 Před rokem +2

    waiting waiting waiting everytime refreshing and opening your channel for this video finally got it

  • @saraswathisunku3401
    @saraswathisunku3401 Před rokem

    Beautifully made ..... giving the stark difference between Sanatana Dharma and the Abrahamic religions.....
    When the caste system disappears, Sanatana Dharma will flower again into a large tree!!!!

  • @prithviraj3157
    @prithviraj3157 Před rokem +1

    Everyone watching these videos must forward to at least 5 relatives and 5 friends.

  • @aalayamanimahalingam423
    @aalayamanimahalingam423 Před rokem +3

    It's the best words from GOD through you brother I really appreciate your work for mankind unity The Best of the best

  • @sunstarmoon3958
    @sunstarmoon3958 Před rokem

    You have done sharing work n superb presentation balanced with love ,light and compassion! Thanks from soul...

  • @shrutibhardwaj950
    @shrutibhardwaj950 Před rokem

    That's so so amazing. I am simply amazed to see your intellect. You are such an intelligent and sensible person. Glad that I found your channel.

  • @manishankar9349
    @manishankar9349 Před rokem +1

    Great Great Work brother higly inspired by your work,thanks for teaching the greatness of india and vedas

  • @SureSh-ve8fo
    @SureSh-ve8fo Před rokem

    Please please🙏🙏🙏🙏 continue your work in this path.... May shiva bless you..... You are superb...... Love you so much for your work on this explanation on the real who we are..... We will support you always... Hara maha dev... 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @indunair4426
    @indunair4426 Před 14 dny

    This happened several years ago during a college excursion with a stopover to an ancient Hindu temple. At the threshold one of our Muslim student was prohibited from entering. This has happened many times in Big n Famous Hindu temple.
    Popular is when Yesudas was prevented from Guruvayor temple.
    It is now 2024 but such laws continue…

  • @tatasth8559
    @tatasth8559 Před rokem +6

    Jai Bharat 🕉
    Vandemataram 🙏🏻
    Edited: I call them adharmic(abrahmic) political/militant cult ideologies

  • @adityavenkatav5872
    @adityavenkatav5872 Před 10 měsíci

    Thanks for these efforts in making people enlightened with truth🙏

  • @ritukiran
    @ritukiran Před rokem

    As ever, great job - and yes the questions set me thinking... :)

  • @TommyJefferson1801
    @TommyJefferson1801 Před rokem +1

    Man was waiting for this video

  • @vishvajitkumar9497
    @vishvajitkumar9497 Před rokem +5

    i learn lot of things from ur videos. thanks

  • @actl7301
    @actl7301 Před rokem

    No words for you 🙏
    I follow you as my GURU.
    Thanks a lot🙏🙏

  • @grsumathi
    @grsumathi Před rokem

    Very apt👌 good job!👍👍
    More people have to watch and know this.

  • @kasturipillay6626
    @kasturipillay6626 Před rokem +1

    Thanks for your educated opinion. 🙏

  • @davedutt4602
    @davedutt4602 Před rokem +1

    Thank you so much brother for giving us the true knowledge of our history.
    Har Har Mahadev🙏

  • @suprasupra4942
    @suprasupra4942 Před 11 měsíci

    This speech should be delivered in United Nations

  • @shankarshastry8006
    @shankarshastry8006 Před 27 dny

    I am still searching a superior word to appreciate you. My small brain couldn't find above the word EXCELLENT.

  • @VijayKumar-tj5hx
    @VijayKumar-tj5hx Před rokem +1

    This video broadened my way of thinking 💯

  • @darshanjadhav6038
    @darshanjadhav6038 Před rokem +3

    pure gold knowledge 😍

  • @lakshminarasimhanabeshake7490

    Hi Namaskaram 🙏, your videos are really informative, thought provoking and bringing us into the fold of questioning everything to bring clarity. Can you also please touch on topics like 'Karma' and 'Dharma' as it's misunderstood by lot of us. Thanks 🙏

  • @manisaraswatula8999
    @manisaraswatula8999 Před rokem +8

    Amazing content 👌🏻 👏🏻

  • @clauaome25
    @clauaome25 Před rokem

    Always love hearing your voice and wonderful content.

  • @vandanareddy3647
    @vandanareddy3647 Před 11 měsíci

    Excellent logical reasoning and keep spreading awareness

  • @surenn8242
    @surenn8242 Před rokem +1

    Excellent and great information..

  • @tanumishra407
    @tanumishra407 Před rokem +1

    Only channel which videos I like before watching. 🕉

  • @teachereducation5425
    @teachereducation5425 Před rokem

    Great masterpiece of comparative analysis. Hope PM Modi takes note of this and replace the word secularism with Dharmic pluralusm in Indian constitution. Liberate India from western colonial ideology.

  • @spycat3223
    @spycat3223 Před rokem

    Bro I love ur work and ur team it's my wish that ur Chanel grow . And u may blessed with long age .🙏 thank you keep it up 👍💯

  • @rajag.s.2550
    @rajag.s.2550 Před rokem

    A copy of this video should be sent to the judges of all the courts in India.

  • @Agnosticc
    @Agnosticc Před rokem +4

    Indian right wingers are also making mistake, instead of developing it as Indic Wing, people are portraying Indian right wing similar to western Right wing which is conservative & infamous for extreme views.
    We've to brand hindutva as true secular liberal and inclusive or we can say it's Indian version of secularism... That's how we have to counter the false narrative of the left eco system.

    • @adash7841
      @adash7841 Před rokem +1

      Indian right wing doesn't agree with America right wing in every aspect. They're different. Indian rw main aim is to create hindu brotherhood.

  • @santutech6060
    @santutech6060 Před rokem

    I hope and wish this documentary reach each and every human being.

  • @dominicayyanikkatt7463
    @dominicayyanikkatt7463 Před rokem +8

    Thank you for this clear discourse on secularism. Most Indians have a preference for what is imported. Those who talk of secularism without understanding its history and meaning are enamoured of it because it is an imported ideology.

  • @rekhav4757
    @rekhav4757 Před rokem

    👌 . 🙏 Thanks for sharing this important knowledge .

  • @mrameshmrg1573
    @mrameshmrg1573 Před rokem

    Thanks a lot for your documentary.🙏🙏🙏

  • @bkdevil5278
    @bkdevil5278 Před rokem +4

    Very Informative video

  • @nidhisharma6940
    @nidhisharma6940 Před rokem +1

    Hey man, that music in the background gives me goosebumps