Who Are the Palestinians Inside Israeli Prisons?
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 01. 2024
- There are over 8,000 Palestinians inside Israeli prisons - including women, children and journalists. Almost 3,000 of them are being held without any charge. But should they be referred to as prisoners? Or is there another word that would better define the specific nature of their incarceration under Israeli occupation? Backspace’s Sana Saeed breaks down how to think about the words we use when discussing the occupation and how to discuss Palestinians incarcerated in Israeli prisons.
Subscribe for more videos: ajplus.co/subscribe
Follow us on Instagram: / ajplus
Like us on Facebook: / ajplusenglish
Follow us on Twitter: / ajplus
“It is said that no one truly knows a nation until one has been inside its jails. A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens, but its lowest ones.”― Nelson Mandela🕋🧕🏼🤲🏼📿
i agree
The real democracy protects the minorities not the majority, because majority does not need it!
Where Is Ahed tamimi...?? Where Is Muna El - kurd???
Sorry, but “detainee” sounds way too neutral. Euphemistic, even. And the term “hostages” for the other side is conversely, way too biased - too. Makes it sound as if they are hapless victims whisked away from gates of Heaven to bowels of Hell.
This series is so important.
Words absolutely DO matter and I share every episode I see.
Thank you for doing this.
They are hostages, for sure...
Thank you for bringing this topic, and creating a thought provoking platform... We should rapidly start demanding changes and action against these targeted practices by the occupators of Palestinian land! ✊🏻✊🏻✊🏻💜🇵🇸🕊
Trading for other hostages. The difference these are innocent hostages the west loves to ignore neglect and forget about. I've been following up on the settlers state of Israel since I was a teenager.
@@MariaReyes-wg5zx thank you for your work!
Love this woman, learned so much from her over the years ❤️
So heartbreaking
Thank you for continuing to cover Palestine Sana so intelligently and eloquently. 🙏 Love from Palestine.
I had a friend in the mid 80's. he and his wife went to Israel. He worked for a Toxic Cleanup Company. they were there for a few months. when they returned, we talked about their trip to The Holy Land. they talked about them visiting many sites.
His wife talked about the way the Israeli's treated the Palestine people. she said the IDF would stop any of them and ask for ID's and shove them around, and even call the police.
Such a pity to call it the Holy Land with all of the abuse on Arabs.
A close friend of mine was a hardcore (gentile) Zionist, until he visited Hebron. He wrote me a long email apologizing for ever thinking I was exaggerating.
That's where the term "holy shit" come from
@@rachaelik he's a humble person to do that.
In effect it's the cursed land, where the greatest evil on Earth goes on. If you want to imagine a god lives there, it's one with horns.
Even to Palestinian jews, asian and african jews, christian palestinian.
You may chain my hands, you may shackle my feet; you may even throw me into a dark prison; but you shall not enslave my thinking, because it is free!
Khalil Gibran😭😞✌👍✊
You may chain my hands, you may shackle my feet; you may even throw me into a dark prison; but you shall not enslave my thinking, because it is free! tell esraelis
Khalil Gibran
Nice! ...The prophet was my favourite.
That is kidnapping
Most of Guantanamo detainees were also kidnapped...
@@husna8031
US/Israeli DemocKKKracy.
False, they commited crimes and were tried in a military court.
@@rafster675 who say that israel after all the lies how can we believe them
Sorry, but “detainee” sounds way too neutral. Euphemistic, even. And the term “hostages” for the other side is conversely, way too biased - too. Makes it sound as if they are hapless victims whisked away from gates of Heaven to bowels of Hell.
A hostage!
Thanks for sharing
اللَّهُمَّ إِنِّي أَسْأَلُكَ مِنَ الْخَيْرِ كُلِّهِ عَاجِلِهِ وَآجِلِهِ مَا عَلِمْتُ مِنْهُ وَمَا لَمْ أَعْلَم،ْ وَأَعُوذُ بِكَ مِنَ الشَّرِّ كُلِّهِ عَاجِلِهِ وَآجِلِهِ مَا عَلِمْتُ مِنْهُ وَمَا لَمْ أَعْلَمْ
When Isreal imprisons a Palestinian child you can call it it their "Palestinian" Bar Mitzvah, just as black Americans refer to their first encounter with the police as their "Black" Bar mitzvah.
Free Palestine prisoners
Free Israeli hostages
@@rafster675 With ALLAH S will and HIS alone will Palestinians prisoners children women and men be freed including Isreali hostages 🇯🇴🇿🇦❤️💯🤲🏼
Free Palestenian Hostages!
So if Hamas was as "advanced" as Russia. Then the words hostages would change to prisoners. How delusional. There's even u.s settlers army in Russia. Or what are they?
@@MariaReyes-wg5zx does Russia kidnap babies?
Keep on aj+ 👏🏻👏🏻
Thank you very much for the explanation
Genocide is a horrouble thing
You are right. Hamas is a genocidal orginization.
Very good report ! Thank you . This information needs to be viral . Is very important EVERYONE Know this. This world needs to change radically and rapidly. La verdad nos hará Libres . Means The Truth makes us Free . I am sorry break my heart all those children and innocent people 😢💔
Excellent point I did not even think of.
Calling incarcerated Palestinians in israeli prisons hostages would be much more meaningful than calling them prisoners because most of them are not legally . Very interesting content, Sanaa 🧐👍
Thanks
I was wondering who would take this and expose this
Please share those to your speaking English friends! There's very important information here!
Bravo on making the points detailing the cause and effect how someone can be defined in foggy yet acceptable terms as so as to numb the listener in a misleading assumption and another way to get public acceptance of atrocities. Does the American collective consciousness need a Clockwork Orange Therapy as our times have revealed deep corruption within the government bodies and politicians that have the same caliber of integrity as say a used car salesman or women. May the true heart of humanity prevail !
🇲🇨🇲🇨🇯🇴🇯🇴💪💪💪
I am crying
Wonderful people! Let's hope that they are successful but I am very worried that the powerful Israeli lobbyists will prevail. Since the ICJ judgement the situation for Palestinians has got worse.
FREE FREE PALESTINE
🤡🤡🤡
My condolences to the millions of *Muslim Uyghurs in Xinjiang* who lost their
- lands, religious practices and dignity,
and now become genocide victims of the Chinese regime with *indisputable evidence* from:
*- hacked Xinjiang Police Files,*
- satelite images,
- eye witnesses,
- survivors,
- Chinese official documents, and
- multiple press investigations since 2008.
and China Mijisters are DRAMA acting like heroes
😂😂😂😂😂😂
You're quite a joker!
The kid with broken arms was a fake one. He was filmed minutes after it with both arms completely fine.
The whole world is blind, where's justice?
each of them trust their own justice.... but because of that reason of justice, they use that for manipulate ppl and do the occupation and genocide...
ask the arab league & all the arab countries why they are silent
@@Kevin-fq3zh I'm talking about them, not the Western world...
but nowadays Arabs r more better than the Western world
Anyhow time will answer, when The Almighty Allah will...
@@Kevin-fq3zhAsk their leaders.Even though they're not fit to be called 'leaders'..
Sorry, but “detainee” sounds way too neutral. Euphemistic, even. And the term “hostages” for the other side is conversely, way too biased - too. Makes it sound as if they are hapless victims whisked away from gates of Heaven to bowels of Hell.
This happens in South Africa
You may chain my hands, you may shackle my feet; you may even throw me into a dark prison; but you shall not enslave my thinking, because it is free!
Khalil Gibran
Unbelievable this is outright injustice to the Palestinians!!!!!
It’s called a war crime
In the name of God, the most gracious, the most merciful
Those to whom the people said, “The people have gathered against you, so fear them,” and it increased their faith, and they said, “Allah is sufficient for us, and He is the best disposer of affairs.”
Great truth of God
May God’s curse be upon the sons of Jewish women who protect the entity’s borders: Sisi and Abdullah II
May God’s curse be upon the negligent leaders of our rulers, the armies and intelligence services of our country, their sheikhs, their muftis, their thugs, and their masters in the West, and first and foremost the normalized rulers, the first of whom are the sons of Jewish women, Sisi and Abdullah II, and their colleagues in treason, Abbas, bin Zayed, bin Salman, Khamenei, and Erdogan.
May God be with you and your enemies, O people of Egypt, Gaza, Palestine, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen.
May God have mercy on your dead and accept them as martyrs along with the prophets and the truthful
A petition isn't the solution but a combination of possibly ensuring the non reverted actions to keep the individuals who disagree from taking advantage of the mistreatment of the imprisoned in isreal whoever their ethnic /or cultural background is
Victims of apartheid 🍉❤️🇵🇸
Victims of a terr*or organization, the IDF.
Free them!
False.
Sorry, but “detainee” sounds way too neutral. Euphemistic, even. And the term “hostages” for the other side is conversely, way too biased - too. Makes it sound as if they are hapless victims whisked away from gates of Heaven to bowels of Hell.
Colonization. DECOLONIZE
It’s saddening and so wrong.
Reasons for Uyghur detention in one of 380 Xinjiang camps in China 🇨🇳 include:
- having a beard,
- wearing a veil,
- applying for a passport,
- possessing a Quran,
- praying,
- downloading WhatsApp and
- having too many children.
#SPAM
Modern day boarding schools. 🤢
Thank you AJ+!
this is horrible
Where is Bisan
I’m asking too . We haven’t heard from her since the hospital. Mansour Shouman has also disappeared #bisan #bringmansourhome
Lives in israel
Sorry, but “detainee” sounds way too neutral. Euphemistic, even. And the term “hostages” for the other side is conversely, way too biased - too. Makes it sound as if they are hapless victims whisked away from gates of Heaven to bowels of Hell.
Now that's a quintessential mouth-breathing claim to make, "@@geanieltarin814".
Kidnapping or illegal detainee
Realese all Palestinian
I'm not a social individual but for someone who isn't anti social maybe a petition to form with a tally, a total tally of individuals in isreal to gather who is in agreement of (plus to keep from mistreatment to returning maybe to resume the total tally again as a possible routine active , like I disagree with the treatment of the imprisoned in isreal if there's aquitted cops here in America who are not rich yet released like the rich of their actions that was raised attention for them to be caught in prison ...... I need to revise casue just the possible goal of the prisoner to prove they have intention to prove why they were aquitted like everyone is should be equally have the equal right to do so .... If majority consent for this
Video series declares it is about misusing semantics (how words are used) and starts with the word "occupiers"... that's doing exactly what it claims to be debunking... let's not forget that 14 million people live in the "Holy" land... and both want to live normal lives... that ain't gonna happen when extremists are protected, outsiders (Khameini and Putin) are exacerbating the situation, and ordinary people don't reject the extremism... there are schools where both Palestinians and Jews children take classes together... if given photos of children from either side, can you tell which is on which "side"? No, they even have the same curly hair... 99.999% identical because they both originate from the same region... brothers killing brothers...
It’s proven by international law that Israel is an occupier. No one is above World law and everyone in history who was arrogant enough to think so have fallen hard and empires have crumbled by the hands of their own people because of their tyranny and arrogance. Read a little. Over 170 countries including the US have agreed that Israel is an occupier and has illegal settlements. 200 lines under the words of fact illegal and occupier my dear Watson.
@staticcouch135 Well said. But you're missing my point... you and I and Palestinians and Jews are brothers and sisters... when do we stop killing each other?
@@staticcouch135Nicely said. But you're missing my point... you and I and Palestinians and Jews are brothers and sisters... when will we stop killing each other? [why do some of comments/responses get deleted by this channel?]
@@staticcouch135[This channel keeps deleting my replies to you... why? ] My original response: Well said. But you are missing my point. You and I and Palestinians and Jews are all brothers and sisters... when are we going to stop killing each other?
@@brianquigley1940 I don’t know why CZcams would want to delete your response but I can conclude that the powers that be hate the fact that I a Palestinian don’t hate Jews and do not condone the killing of either. We just want our rights and freedoms that all humans should have on the land that we have bled and been continuously ethnically cleansed on. Without freedom and self determination no peace can be sustained.
free palestine now
They’re heroes.
You are good.
It is all in the name of mosses who hated them .
They are kidnapped.
They're hostages.
if you do crimes you gonna be convicted, what do you expect?
@@khaliilbinammar4700 everyone that sits in jail knows why they are there, there is not a single person that doesn't. AJ+ just trying to make palestinian seem miserable to feed their own narrative
Palestine will be free.
Watchimg ur recent vdos Found out this is one sided biased muslim channel. Keep it up. But noy a worthy channel to follow. Showing one sided news is not good journalism
The answer is simple. These are Palestinians that actually commited crimes in Israel, be it murder, assualt, or anything else. Unlike the Hamas tunnels where the hostages are being held, the Israeli jails provide their prisoners with reasonable living conditions.
except they haven't committed any crimes. Are you being stupid unpurpose?
Except they haven't committed crimes, are you a bot?
@@4T3hM4kr0n im not a bot. Im a jew defending my people. There is a video of why one woman went to jail. She pulled a machete out of her purse and tried to stab the cop she was talking to. You call that an innocent?
most of them are children that some of them got imprisoned at the age of 4. Are you going to tell me that they're criminals too?
@@waves2378are you stupid like genuinely. You gonna bash off 8000 people who got imprisoned with no real charge over an assumption that they y'all act like that lady? Are you like a dumbass saying things with no real reason?
😂😂😂
free palestine
💚🍉☝🏼
Omm cough hhuii flu iij olmec ugffgh reefyy jjjii xswwry hhjin jjbbhj fry uuu ijjndryy
🤲🇵🇸💗🇧🇬🙏🏻
Брилиантно!
Hostages 😢
Free palistine
Israel, Hamas, and End Times | Ezekiel 38 | Gary Hamrick - Cornerstone Chapel
Israel, Hamas, and End Times | Ezekiel 38 | Gary Hamrick - Cornerstone Chapel
**UNRWA's message to the Palestinians? You can choose war over peace and still expect to get everything you want.**
Some humanitarian groups seem to be backing global terrorism because they're too keen on showing the world how tolerant they are. They've got this long list of people to blame, all because they want to look good. This leads them to value the wrong things, like how much aid they can give out, instead of aiming for true fairness and helping people become self-sufficient
They should be all about fairness and neutrality, helping people to a point where they can stand on their own, and then moving on to help others in need elsewhere.
Take the situation with the Palestinians and UNRWA after the 1948 War of Independence.
The real issue started when the choice was made to go to war instead of living in peace with Israel. That war led to Palestinian defeat and the creation of UNRWA to help the resulting 750,000 refugees. Fast forward to today, three generations later, and UNRWA says there are 5.9 million Palestinian refugees eligible for their services. (Remember that these humanitarian groups measure themselves by the size of aid provided.)
UNRWA has a unique definition for Palestinian refugees that includes not only the original refugees from the 1948 and 1967 conflicts but also their descendants. This definition is broader than the one that the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) typically uses, which does not include descendants in refugee status. Effectively, the agency increased its responsibilities by a factor of 8 with its new definition.
The fact that Palestinians are still considered refugees is due to their bad reputation.
Everyone in the Middle East knows how they have earned this reputation by starting conflict in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Kuwait and Tunisia. Many of these countries still have not recovered. No one wants Palestinians to integrate into their societies. But this also reflects a failure by UNRWA to get the people self-sufficient and prioritize civic responsibilities over the priority of conflict and the destruction of Israel.
Over 74 years, UNRWA's become huge, with 13,000 people working there, still handling all basic services for Palestinians.
UNRWA keeps focusing on Palestinian victimhood and doing jobs that a government should be doing.
This overlooks the big picture: the refusal to accept Israel and the decision to wage war. Choices were made and priorities were set-not to work towards coexistence or economic partnership but to risk everything for war. Decisions have consequences.
But if you ask UNRWA, there shouldn't be a fallout from these decisions. Seventy-five years on, and we still have Palestinians in camps, hoping to reverse their defeat.
UNRWA's stance that Palestinians are merely victims without pushing for real societal and behavioral change has led to a cycle of dependency. They turn a blind eye to military efforts and validate historical grievances, ignoring the lack of accountability. While Hamas builds tunnels and missiles and the PA rewards violence, UNRWA remains silent.
UNRWA's message to the Palestinians? You can choose war over peace and still expect to get everything you want.
That's a dangerous mindset.
Bad propaganda. 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♀️
No one believes or trusts your propaganda anymore so find another planet to play that crappy tune to.
**For those who do not know;' the Al-Aqsa Mosque was built over the most important holy site for Jews in the world, The Temple of Solomon. IN the 7th century, Islam appropriated this holy site for Muslim's following the conquest and colonization of Israel from the Arabs who originated in Saudi Arabia. ** Yes, Islam is NOT native to Israel. Since, then Muslim's and now the Palestinians have denied Jews access and now HAMAS wants to make sure Jews will NEVER visit it. This is the #1 holy site for Jews!
Islam is the colonizer and Islam is the one who has set up an apartheid system at the Al-Aqsa mosque. This was never about a state for Palestinians. This is a holy war for Hamas and they will never accept sharing Al-Aqsa or any part of Israel with Jews.
For 3,000 years, The Temple of Solomon, a site of profound significance in Jewish history and religion, has been a focal point in the prayers and spiritual lives of Jewish people worldwide. All Jews pray facing the Temple of Solomon located in Jerusalem, due to its origins in the ancestral homeland, Israel.
In the 7th century, a pivotal era in religious history, Islam emerged in the Arabian Peninsula. It was the beginning of the Islamic Conquests.
Over the following centuries, Islamic empires expanded their territories significantly. They encountered regions rich in cultural and religious history. This expansion included regions of the former Christian-Roman Empire. [2] The lands conquered by Islamic empires included territories that were integral to Jewish and Christian life in parts of West Asia, Northern Africa, and the Middle East. Among the territories that came under Islamic rule was Israel
In this process, several sites that were previously held sacred by these religions were APPROPRIATED into the Islamic cultural and religious framework. [1]
One of the critical events in this period was the construction of the Al-Aqsa Mosque over the ruins of the Temple of Solomon in Jerusalem. This mosque, a site now revered in Islam, is situated over the most holy Jewish site. This process often involved transforming existing religious sites to reflect the beliefs and practices of the new ruling power. This was part of a broader pattern of forced cultural transformation that occurred as Islamic rule was established in these regions. [4]
Following the Islamic conquest, the status of Jewish communities in these regions shifted. Under Islamic rule, Jewish people, like Christians, were often classified as "dhimmis," non-Muslim citizens of an Islamic state. This status came with certain protections but also imposed restrictions and special taxes not required of Muslims. [3] The Pact of ‘Umar lays out a variety of sumptuary laws, meaning laws whose ostensible purpose was to distinguish non-Muslims from Muslims in social interactions, place limits on non-Muslim behavior, and emphasize the social superiority of Muslims.
As a result, Jews were no longer allowed access to the Temple of Solomon, and it was reserved only for Muslims. The issue of access for Jews to this site for prayer and worship is still denied today.
You don’t give up do you with the vomit of lies. 😆☝️
If the Palestinians stopped hating Israel then they wouldn’t be arrested and just accept their situation there wouldn’t be so many issues 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇺🇸🇺🇸
is that a joke ?
@Stevencole-ln7cb i dont see any jokes with this statement. Hes right.
@@waves2378 except he's wrong and so are you.
@4T3hM4kr0n no he isn't. I have something to ask: Israel is known as the Jewish homeland, yet a fair amount of non-jewish people live there. Do they "deserve" whats happening to them as well? Is this a matter of location or religion?
@@waves2378 you don't even know what you're saying do you? You agree with aynrandfan7454 that the palestinians should just "learn to like israel" despite being the continued victims of an ethnic cleansing campaign. You then flip flop and phrase your response in favor of the palestinians resisting genocide by directly implying that they don't deserve it.
Molim vas recite gdje j novinarka Bisan iz Gaze?? Dugo je nismo čuli i brinemo se.
A petition isn't the solution but a combination of possibly ensuring the non reverted actions to keep the individuals who disagree from taking advantage of the mistreatment of the imprisoned in isreal whoever their ethnic /or cultural background is