Jana Reacts to Pink Floyd 'Comfortably Numb (Pulse Live Version)'
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 06. 2024
- In this fourth special episode of May 2022 to celebrate our 1 year anniversary of the channel, we react to a highly requested Live performance of one of our top 5 most viewed bands on our Jana Reacts Series:
Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Pulse Live Version) (original video: • Pink Floyd - Comfortab... )
#progrock #pinkfloyd #reactionvideos #comfortablynumb #pulse #davidgilmour #progressiverock #nathanonshuffle #janareacts
Disclaimer: In these reaction videos we will often talk over, pause or edit out sections of the song we are covering. We don’t intend to be annoying or “sacrilegious” to the integrity of the song, we are just giving our pure, unfiltered thoughts and impressions as we listen and edit to make sure we don’t have any copyright issues (and frankly to trim out sections of the video that aren’t as interesting). If you want a pure, uninterrupted listen, we encourage you to please seek out the song on your platform of choice!
Follow me on Social Media:
Twitter: @NathanOnSuffle
Instagram: @NathanOnShuffle
Email: nathanonshuffle@gmail.com
And check out my podcast, where you can listen to audio versions of many of the shows from this CZcams channel: anchor.fm/nathan-on-shuffle
And...Follow my Spotify playlist "Jana Reacts!" featuring music from this series:
open.spotify.com/playlist/1vT...
No copyright infringement intended. We do not own the music we are reacting to. This reaction constitutes Fair Use. - Hudba
This was the summit of Pink Floyd live performances. It's sad to see Richard Wright, knowing that he's 'gone' now. Why should I be frightened of dying? There's no reason for it. You've got to go sometime. RIP RW!
Ah...I miss Rick.
"Do not go gentle into that good night,
Old age should burn and rave at close of day;
Rage, rage against the dying of the light." - Dylan Thomas 1914-1953
You had to be there, no matter how great the video production is, being there and watching the concert unfold before your very eyes and ears was an experience I have never before or since witnessed. I have been to thousands of concerts and this one stood heads above anything else.
They always have had the best lives shows in Rock band history
Pink Floyd are a WORLD 🌐
On the 20th Oct 1994, man first successfully broke through the very fabric of time and space.
At the beginning of the 70s, Pink Floyd made a documentary in the 2,500-year-old amphitheater of Pompeii behind closed doors.Until 2016, no one was allowed to play live in front of an audience in this historic building. To this day, only David has been allowed to perform live there. This concert can be described without exaggeration as historical and magical. Of course, David also shot a live DVD of this concert, which is very successful in sales.Btw; Pink Floyd needed 24 trucks for the light show alone.
I am am old guy and I don't know where I was in 1994, but I sure as hell know where I should have been! this is such a masterpiece.
Pink Floyd puts more production on one song, than most bands put into an entire concert. Every single song in this concert is like this one. I recommend reacting to Sorrow and Keep Talking
pink floyd are british national treasures pure legends
Classed as the Greatest live Guitar solo of
All time
The whole Pulse concert is awesome and David Gilmour is my favorite guitarist. If you want to check out another great live performance from Pulse, I suggest the song 'Sorrow'. I was fortunate enough to see David Gilmour on his solo tour in 2016. If you ever want to check out anything from that, it's under 'David Gilmour, Live from Pompeii, 2016."
I’ll have to check that out, thanks!
kids react to pink floyd watching
It's No.2 on my list then High Hopes. The into for Sorrow was amazing tho...especially when the bass came in.
When the Pulse video came out, it was during the VHS era with the box featuring a blinking LED on the box. I own the DVD and it is worth owning. Lucky me, got to see them during their Animals tour at Wrigley's Field in Chicago. Was good, you always got your moneys worth, the shows were as good as their music.
I saw this live in 94 and it was out of this world! Whole concert was totally unbelievable! Great reaction! Keep them coming!
I like EVERY song from the Pulse Concert, but Comfortably Numb sure ranks high on my list of Pulse favorites.
Followed by Sorrow and High Hopes.When you compare their playing with back then in the 70's they seemed to have gotten better, The same was with Led Zeppelin on Celebration Day with Kashmir. My favourite album from them tho' is "Animals", but it's difficult to pick out one song on this album...it's like a book. Interesting was also the the jam with Gilmour, Brian May, (as bass!), Tony Iommi, Ritchie Blackmore for the Armenian Earthquake Aid concert (You can look it up on CZcams.."Smoke on the Water")
Sorry..Gilmour played bass..
David Gilmour played a solo of Comfortably Numb in Brazil in front of a crowd of young kids, some not older than yours, and they knew all the text. It was very moving seeing this reaction towards an old man up there playing his soul out.
czcams.com/video/WJtH7Uw2e2A/video.html
I was in that concert , it was most amazing concert i have ever seen .Was one in life time experience
One of the most mesmerizing and awe inspiring live performances ever.
I was there... Earls Court London 1994.....it was incredible 👏 😍
The first time I saw Pink Floyd, was at Earls Court 1973 and last time Earls Court again 2006.
Well done for not interrupting, check out Run Like Hell from the same concert, it's visually stunning and will blow you away !
I do believe that it's in the Guinness book of records.
Great reaction! Thank you
The song High Hopes also on the Pulse live was the last song by Pink Floyd with lyrics. The lyrics were written by Molly, Davids future wife.
Her name is Polly Samson. ❤
Bravo to you both, you know how to share your happiness with your listeners.
I quite agree with your final verdict, quite simply (Amazing).
What an incredible performance. Appreciated your reaction. It is indeed amazing.
Thank you!
Also, yes-- David Gilmour is considered the defacto "leader" of "Pink Floyd", but as others have said Waters is still regularly touring PF music, and even Nick Mason has recently been touring his Saucerful of Secrets shows that focus on early Pink Floyd (also not to be missed!)
Those S of S shows were fantastic.
Pink Floyd has officially broke up after the band released their album *The Endless River* in 2014. An album of unfinished tracks (mostly from Richard Wright - keyboardist who died in 2008) that was recorded during Pink Floyd's *"LAST OFFICIAL ALBUM"* 1994's *The Division Bell.*
Roger Waters still releases new albums & tours with his band.
David Gilmour will put an album out now & then & tour. Basically, he has mostly retired.
Nick Mason currently put a band together & tours that plays Pink Floyd early material before *The Dark Side of the Moon* album.
Saw Pink Floyd at Arrowhead Stadium in 1988. Probably the most elaborate stage show I've ever seen at a rock concert.
Sounds awesome!
Saw them in 78 Kemper Arena. Different tour, same city!
Loved the fact you played it all the way through without pausing. Great review.
Thank you, glad you liked it!
Hey guys! Excellent reaction. PULSE! Such a great show. For those who haven't seen this gem I highly recommend to watch it in its entirety. Many say this version of Comfortably Numb has the best guitar solo ever. The best? Not sure about that, but it is pretty damn good. This show is awesome! PINK FLOYD 🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈❗❗❗❗❗❗❗❗
Thank you!! We might have to check out more of this show! 😀
@@NathanOnShuffle You'll be glad you did.😎
It's hard to argue. I've watched many, many versions of. Dave has said he always likes to change it up a little bit. The version from Night at Pompeii is also excellent, and was an excellent show, it just didn't have Nick and Richard. Also, the version for Live Aid 8, the last time the 4 member played together, was also good.
@@Rikalonius I agree. I have all the dvds you mentioned. Anything played live will always be a little different. All great versions!🎸🔥😎
@@jeffschielka7845 Then I have no doubt the remastered Delicate Sound of Thunder is also among your DVD collection? If not, it should be, but I'm guessing it is.
Love Your Reaction ..... I think you two did really great explaining the song and group .....Thank You
Someone once said that David Gilmour's guitar solos are basically the equivalent of drinking fine French champagne. But Pink Floyd basically set the bar for the "Big Stadium Rock Show" back then. It may feel a bit anachronistic now, but I guess today's younger generation enjoy it as much as us old farts did back in the day. Rock is dead they say, Long Live Rock! 😄
Saw hem live 4 times, including twice in the 1970s with Roger Waters still in the band. Also saw David Gilmour twice in the same week in the mid 1980s and Roger Waters 4 times solo, the first time with Eric Clapton taking a stab at Pink Floyd classics. I am beyond lucky enough to have seen Dark Side of the Moon 3 times in its entirety, also have seen classic Floyd do all of Echoes, Wish You Were Here and Animals, lastly saw Roger do the entire Wall. I am beyond lucky, this music will be listened to for centuries and I saw it right in front of me. I guess my generation hit the musical lottery, the first 2 times I saw them in the 1970s it was $8.50 a ticket. Do Echoes, live at Pompeii, it is a 2 part video from the ruins they set up at in 1972, it will blow your minds! Enjoy. 🎵🎹🎸🎷
Guys, if you get the chance to catch a Roger Waters solo tour, definitely go. I've seen him twice, once on the tour for The Wall in 2011, which was an amazing production, and his tour in 2017, which was just as much a production, although not affiliated with any one album.
His tours are absolutely amazing, both musically and production wise.
We’ll definitely have to keep that in mind!
@@NathanOnShuffle
For an example...
I've known the words to In The Flesh since The Wall's release. But, as an observant Jew, when I saw the theatricality for that song when Roger Waters The Wall's show started up after the intermission in front of the wall that was built across the stage in front of the audience's eyes in the first half of the show, I honestly felt my first real visceral reaction to antisemitism in my life. I know it was a portrayal, and not real sentiment, but it was very, very well done. I literally felt sick to my stomach.
His other productions for other numbers are just about as good, especially for Pigs (Three Different Ones).
I saw Pink Floyd in '89 without Roger Waters, 29 yrs later I saw Roger Waters in Prague, one thing missing on my Pink Floyd list is to see The Wall live
@Nathan On Shuffle
Fabulous isn’t it. You clearly enjoyed this version of ‘Comfortably Numb’, so
I highly recommend you try this one too. Even if it’s just for your own personal viewing.
I was lucky enough to see the ‘One Night Only’ Cinema showing of David Gilmour’s return to the Pompeii Amphitheater, in 2016, with his Band.
(Pink Floyd’s previous visit being in 1971, when they were filmed playing ‘Echoes’, in the Centre of the Amphitheater, with no audience).
And this version of ‘Comfortably Numb’, from that 2016 Show, is sensational. This time to an audience.
And what a light Show this has too. All in the stunning setting of this Roman Amphitheater.
The whole Show is stunning. Incredible. David Gilmour is 70 years of age here and his performance is mind blowing.
Just my own feelings.
Hope you’re able to sample this, if you haven’t already, the setting is sensational. You won’t regret it.
czcams.com/video/eHKG7EMxWW8/video.html
🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
Sound vidéo is Epic
This was none to nothing only followed by Sorrow and High Hopes.When you compare their playing with back then in the 70's they seemed to have gotten better, (altho it was 1993). David Gilmour, no tattoos, just an ordinary guy you would probably walk past in the street (Maybe a pub landlord with a Cambridge accent) The same was with Led Zeppelin on Celebration Day with Kashmir. (older guys again). My favourite album from them tho' is "Animals", but it's difficult to pick out one song on this album...it's like a book. Interesting was also the the jam with Gilmour, Brian May, (as bass!), Tony Iommi, Ritchie Blackmore for the Armenian Earthquake Aid concert (You can look it up on CZcams.."Smoke on the Water")
Great reaction 👍👍😊😊Try 'Run like Hell', the song that came after this and closed the show. Stunning.
I just have to say thanks for that beautiful reaction, you didn't cut anything, so respectful... I saw that concert in France because I'm a real fan of Pink Floyd. Now I follow you because I saw you made another reaction to a song I love, Firth of Fith, I'm gonna watch it right now, but thanks a lot for all your respect, now I'm with you for a while, wonderful couple, you're beautiful. Love from France 🇫🇷😘
In fact, I remember I saw this reaction, and I loved it, Firth of Fifth... I know I'm French and and it's not easy to listen to French music for most of people. I just wanted to suggest you to listen to the concert "Collision Tour", a concert with 2 French groups, it's very interesting to listen to, I suggest you "Volfony's Revenge" and " Versus" from the concert with Hint and 3zekiel... I don't ask you to make reactions, just to listen to them, I'm sure you'll love it, progressive rock, just for you... No French lyrics, don't worry, just music, English and enjoy it, it's crazy and special ! Love you. ❤️
Thank you so much!
Nice comment! I saw the concert in Strasbourg, and it will always be the best live music experience I ever saw. Have a great summer!
@@isabelledrevet5913 When I lived in France (1983-1995) I really got to love a lot of French music. Now maybe it sounds "old", but Jean-Jacques Goldman, Telephone, France Gall, Noir Desire, NTM, even Nougaro (also Vanessa).... loved it all!
Pink floyd, es un ícono en la música del rock, únicos en el mundo, grupo inglés qué ha hecho conciertos en Venezia, quéridos en todo el mundo incluyendo México y latinoamerica. Con una visión a futuro increíble.
Mí hijo y mi nieta escuchan a Pink floyd y les encanta de tan solo 10 años.
Luego les comento en forma de broma por qué se roban mi música y me contestan qué es mejor qué la actual. Pink floyd es lo ( MÁXIMO) saludos cordiales desde México.
It can be found on Facebook Music Videos
Was at the Philly show in 94,brought my 12 year old daughter and she was scared because she read that there was going to be gold lasers and they could blind us, bwahahaha. Anyways she was hooked on the Floyd from them on...Thanks for doing this one! And have a great day.
Ha, interesting! Thanks!
You gotta do (echoes) live in Pompey.
I was just -rewatching some of your Rush reactions and noticed in the post discussion on "Subdivisions" the two of you were observing a consistent theme of individuality over conformity between "Subdivisions" and "2112". If you want another song of theirs that explores that very theme you should play "Free Will" for your wife.
"Faithless" is a pretty good (more recent) Rush song that addresses some of these bigger issues, too.
Watch the Movie The Wall it will explain so many things...
Daniel ISRAEL
Un coucou de France, excellente réaction et merci, vous qui êtes comme moi des fans de PINK FLOYD je vous invite à écouter la reprise de HIGH HOPES en live de NIGHTWISH, vous allez avoir une très très grande surprise. Je suis extrêmement impatiente de voir votre réaction et de connaitre votre analyse. Merci de me croire sur parole et surtout pour ce groupe que j'adore et qui pour moi, est le plus grand groupe du monde.
saw this tour when i was 18 or 19 years old in Toronto and they did 3 shows in 3 nights i saw the first and second show and on the second show i met up with some friends before the show and they were all on LSD so i asked if they had more Lol So about halfway through the show i was feeling so good Lol Will never forget both shows
Hey kids! DON'T DO DRUGS!!!!
I'm serious
David straight up wrote this song. Just not all of the lyrics. I’ve listened to all of the early demos and I will always stay true to believing this song is at least 80% Gilmour
It was based on an experience of Roger Waters.
@@heliotropezzz333 the lyrics yes. David recorded the demo prior to Roger adding lyrics, for a solo album, and it’s basically the complete song in melody. And of course the guitar is all David. So I will stand by what I said that David is responsible for most of this song
In all the decades of listening to music since the early 70's, Pink Floyd is still my favorite band. Thanks for the memories.
Please have a listen to our young Aussie legend Taj Farrant, keeping this music alive. So good. czcams.com/video/l7eN89R4--E/video.html
I'll have to check that out, thank you!
@@NathanOnShuffle You won't be disappointed.
He has so many improv/jam sessions, and cover tracks on his channel.
Sorrow same pulse show
Richard Wright died since this was recorded so there's only David Gilmour and drummer Nick Mason of the early Pink Floyd members. Roger Waters is alive but no longer in the band.
I watched until the 12 second mark. If you are going to react then REACT !!! We don't need all the shit about dots and start . Won't be back.
Ok! Hope you find what you are looking for elsewhere! We have a style that’s definitely not for everybody, I get it.
I've never understood the fascination with this song. It's good, but I'd take 'Us and Them' over 'Comfortably Numb' any day.
Sometimes you say not smart things!😎
Get your ears checked.
@@Rings-of-Saturn2 I also think Close to the Edge is the greatest piece of music there is, so my ears are just fine, thank you.
@@jeffschielka7845 what does intelligence have to do with liking or not liking a song, ya goof : )
@@Lightmane Maybe try thinking before typing? ❓⌨😎
Everyone gotta stop doing the comfortable numb track of pulse reaction ,its gonna get worn out. 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗
People need to stop requesting it then... 😂
@@NathanOnShuffle aye, oh well go the floyd 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
I can listen to this masterpiece everyday!!! I love it too much!!!! I
@@333perfection okay, I cant argue with that. especially with a cracking st of headphones. 👍👍👍👍🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🎸🎸🎸🎸
@@waynedome5469 🙂
La voce di David e la sua chitarra...