I have used several aer backpacks and this city pack pro is what I have been looking for. The organizer is neither overkilling nor insufficient, the clamshell style with this size works well for versatile occasions, and the aesthetic is so beautiful as aer always offers. Watching this vid when uploaded, I decided to get it, but I forgot to appreciate it. Thank you for uploading interesting vids as always!
This is basically an update to the Lunar Pack collaboration Aer had with Ministry of Supply. It uses the same main body with good updates to the fabric and the addition of some front and side pockets. They also changed the water bottle pocket from a fully-zippered/enclosed design to an exposed one. Only criticism would be the location of that side D ring right above the water bottle pocket. It should’ve been on the opposite side (esp since they got rid of the side handle) b/c as is, if you lash anything to it, it’ll either interfere with getting your water bottle or it’ll be just a little unhygienic if you have an open-lipped bottle.
Thank you for watching and definitely some good points! I agree this is a good alternative to the lunar pack and that’s a good point to have placed the d ring on the other side especially with not having the side handle there
Most reviewers point out that they have the d ring there to allow for an additional carabiner to be clipped to a water bottle for extra security. I do agree I wisht hey had a mirrored one on the other side for additional carry options though.
@@ramonmichaelchavez7667 I'd be curious to see if the bag designers actually meant for that to be the function of that particular D ring, b/c honestly that sounds superfluous. I haven't seen many other bags have a D-ring to support a water bottle pocket, especially one that already seems pretty deep and on a bag that's ostensibly for "city" use (and not like hiking where I could actually see some utility in it). Personally seems like either an oversight in design (to not put it on the opposite side) or an opportunistic design choice without a real function [like maybe there just happened to be a "load bearing" seam there they could slot a D ring there].
I’ve seen other bag designers add that carabiner to support if you have something tall in the water bottle pocket, like a tripod or umbrella. Then you can attach a strap to the D-ring
Excellent presentation of this pack. You just about have me sold. I like that you provide other pack comps. I would’ve liked to see small photos of the comps along with the names and links.
Thanks for your insights! Just a suggestion- When you are talking through alternatives, it would be great if you can show them (at least the pictures). Would make it so much easier for the viewers, as we won’t have to google as u talk about different brands/ bags!
Wow great improvement from Aer here. So glad they moved to clamshell. I still prefer the overall aesthetic of Goruck especially when it comes to zipper noise. But, if this had come out a few years ago when I was comparing the brands I might have gone with this.
I bought the City pack xpac. However find it quite small. Wanted something like travel pack 3 small but find it a tad big. Then this came. Absolutely on my list. Just the price is a bit high.
Another excellent review! The City Pack is more useable now as a work bag. I like that, aside from the internal slip pocket, it's a big open space; you can fit your lunch in there without having to be concerned about the laptop. I don't think I care for that "see-through" mesh half on that zippered pocket, though.
Can you show a comparison with Travel Pack 3 Small? I feel like for only $20 more you would get a much better bag. (Load Lifters, Side Handle, Full Admin Panel…)
It really depends on what you want the backpack for. I have the Travel Pack 3 Small, and I would say that it's too big for an EDC or daily bag for work, but I am a guy with a small build. However, the Travel Pack 3 Small has a 28L capacity and you can compress it down, but it's still quite big, and if you get it in the ballistic nylon it's quite weighty. So this City Pack Pro might be better for EDC.
YES I'm also comparing the two. The City Pack Pro is smaller by 1" in height and width and 4 L but it's a crazy 1.3 lbs lighter with a better water bottle holder IMO. Kind of makes it hard for me to go with the TP3S but I'm still on the fence!
I just got both in the mail today. Both are beautiful and comfortable. I guess it depends on your personal needs. If you want to use the same bag to travel (1-1.5weeks) and edc with, go with the tp3s. If strictly for edc and maybe a weekend trip go with the CPP. Im going with the CPP but can’t go wrong either way
@Traveling Salseros (Danny Barreto) I wanted to ask your opinion on the new Aer City Pack Pro. I am buying this bag in the next few days. My question to you is… If you were purchasing this bag, would you purchase the Xpac or 1680D Codura material? I am liking the orange interior along with the aqua guard zips. However I live in south central Texas and we get very little rainfall. Perhaps Xpac is overkill? Just wanted your expert opinion on these materials and which do you think is best. Thank you again for your time and amazing videos.
Thank you for watching and good question! Both fabrics are great options overall, the x-pac will have slightly better weather resistance and save a little on weight whereas the ballistic nylon may be a little more abrasion resistant over the long term. If you like the textured look of x-pac and the orange liner I think it will be a very good option
I was wondering if you're planning on reviewing Linus Tech Tips' backpack? I really appreciate your reviews, and I hope to hear your thoughts on it! I wonder how it stacks up vs this bag. Also, wanted to thank you for your reviews. Based on your reviews I bought the Bellroy Transit Plus because I could get free shipping in Canada, which I ended up not liking that much due to a severe lack of tech organization options, so I returned it; but then I bought the Aer Travel Pack 3 (unfortunately expensive with shipping plus duties) which is amazing, it was perfect for my 10 day trip to Europe, alongside their sling bag for walking around cities. No other luggage needed!
Thank you for watching and for the suggestion! Definitely looks like an interesting bag and if I can get my hands on one I will definitely do a video for it :) I’m glad to hear the videos have been helpful as well and that you had a great bag for your trip!
How would this compare to the osprey aoede briefcase backpack? You should do a video showcasing that pack, I'm having a hard time deciding between the city pack pro and the osprey aoede briefcase backpack
Thank you for watching and definitely a tough choice between the two! Although I love the CpL I think I would lean towards this one for some of the additional features it has (water bottle pocket, luggage passthrough, and I like the orientation of the laptop sleeve a bit more)
Great review! I am looking for an edc backpack to take to work etc. I always take a water bottle but rarely take a comp or iPad but still want that option to carry for short travel trips. I am between the goruck gr1 21L and using a molle attachment for a water bottle holder or the city pack pro. I really am looking for a durable pack, good warranty, 20 - 24L, something easy to clean as I work in the hospital setting and sometimes my lunch spills etc. What is your recommendation between those two and any others you would recommend over the two previously mentioned? Second questioned if you recommended the city pack pro would you go cordura vs xpac?
Thank you for watching and I’m glad the video was helpful! This is definitely one of the current best options imo I love the GR1 and have used mine for years, but I would probably lean towards this one for most people due to the additional organization, the laptop pocket, the luggage passthrough and the more breathable harness. I think both fabrics are great just depends if you want some additional weather resistance / bright orange interior (xpac) or a more minimalist / rugged fabric (cordura). Some other options that might be worth considering are the evergoods cpl24, alpha one niner Whitley, the bellroy transit Workpack, Patagonia mini MLC 26
Thank you for watching! On the unit I received to test out the tag said 22l so it might be something aer updated once the official release came out (the tags not necessarily the size of the bag)
For me, the full admin panel is a big deal, they shouldve retain that. And I know, travel pack 3 just looks like that but i dont like the load lifters and the bottle holder style, i like it better here and its smaller make it a perfect edc bag. I just want to carry everything on the bag itself and not carry another small edc bag, cuz if thats the case, i rather have some of their bags which is lighter
Thank you for watching! For me, I don’t think it’s too big but I know some who might feel it’s a little excessive (should be able to hold the items you mentioned pretty well)
Love the bag, just received mine a couple days ago but feel that it’s just a little too “deep” for my preference. Do you have any recommendations for similar bags, with the dedicated laptop compartment, that are maybe a bit wider/taller and less deep? Thanks Danny!
Thank you for watching! If you are looking for something similar from Aer, the city pack and flight pack 3 might be worth checking out. Other than that the goruck GR1 is always a solid option or maybe the bellroy transit Workpack
How do you think it compares to Aer's Tech Pack 2? I know the aesthetic is different, but in terms of layout, organization and usage? I'm having a slightly hard time picking one of the two.
Thank you for watching and great question! I think this is a really compelling alternative to the city pack pro if you like the more sleek aesthetic and you’re looking for a top loading bag (vs the clamshell on the city pack pro). I think the city pack pro can hold a little more and I like the updated harness, but this one includes the side handle, it provides more space in the front admin compartment and it stands up better on its own.
This bag reminds of me the Goruck GR2 but without the militaristic vibes. The GR2 is definitely the more functional bag, but I am considering the gray option of this bag as a more color neutral option of a different style. Not sure if it would be worth it though due to the similarities. I am looking for a companion bag to go with my GR2 26L (I have it in steel, want something gray to better work with my warddrobe and less militaristic). I use my GR2 for weekend trips and ocasional rucking. Ideally as a backpack, I think any bigger would be annoying to carry and I would move to a duffel bag for clothes, but with that being said for longer trips I likely wouldnt mind bringing 2 backacks filled with packing cubes. Unsure if I should go for similar size or smaller for EDC and as a secondary travel bag. Opinions? Currently looking at the TB Synik 22, Aer Travel Pack 3 Small, or City Pack Pro. I'd also look at other suggestions.
Thank you for watching and that’s great to what you’ve been enjoying the gr2! I do think this could be a good companion for the use case you mentioned, as well as the synik 22 (that one feels slightly smaller and has a really good pocket layout), to me the travel pack 3 small might actually feel a little big for what you are describing, the bellroy transit Workpack might be another option worth checking out
Thank you for watching! Both are really great options overall, I would lean a bit more towards the aer as it has a dedicated laptop compartment and slightly more space
What do you prefer between this and the Bellroy Workpack? I’ve ordered both and torn between them. I wish the bellroy had a better water bottle holder…
Thank you for watching and definitely a tough choice! Both are awesome bags but I would lean towards this one as I like that it has an external water bottle pocket, a luggage passthrough and the harness system is a little more comfortable imo
@@dannypacks Thank you for your response, and videos (I’ve watched plenty! but just not commented before). I’m starting to lean towards the Aer too, for the same reasons. I got it in XPAC so the bellroy is quite a bit cheaper, and lighter/small/flexible but I reached out to this because of the lacking water bottle/D rings. Thank you! Enjoy the rest of your day
Great review and this look like a perfect bag for me! Does it feel heavy on your back compared to packs like Evergoods or Mystery Ranch? And would you recommend it for college use?
Thank you for watching and I’m glad the video was helpful! I think this would definitely be a solid bag for college, and it can feel a little heavier compared to some of those bags especially in the 1680d ballistic fabric, but not by a lot and it’s a fair trade off for the additional padding / features you get imo
The City Pack Pro is in no way packable. It's using the same rigid Cordura fabric like other Aer packs while the Go Pack 2 is more pliable and intended to be stuffed inside another bag.
Great video. Thank you. I'm trying to find a personal item on airplanes type backpack for professional travel. I like this one a lot as well as the Troubadour Ridge (preferred aesthetics). Any thoughts between the two, or other professional looking bags?
Larger size and move to full clamshell are great improvements but the removal of the side handle is a major L. Quickly putting the bag on and removing from luggage pass through becomes more difficult.
Thank you for watching and I agree on the removal of the side handle, keeping that would have made this pretty much perfect for me especially for the luggage passthrough like you said
Thank you for watching! I haven’t had a chance to check out the jet pack just yet, but compared to the whitely there are definitely some similarities (clamshell opening, plenty of pocketing), the biggest differences will be in the size as this one feels bigger than the Whitley and it also has a separate laptop compartment compared to the Whitley which has the laptop in the main compartment
Thank you for watching and good call out! On the unit I received the tag said 22 but I see aer has updated their site to 24l and it does feel like it can hold a similar amount to other 24l bags
@@dannypacks Sweet! I was debating between this and the MoS Lunar Pack but I think this one might win out. I was digging the Lunar Pack's simplicity but it's a bit too simple -needs just a tad more organization for a work bag.
Thank you for watching and yes I think this would be a nice alternative as it has good space and durability and it’s comfortable to wear for walking around
Thank you for watching! The one I have in the video is from Wandrd, but the brand of the bottle is miir if you want to see some of the different options they have :)
Thank you for watching! The volume should be 24l, when I first received the bag the tag said 22l but this has been updated to better reflect the size of the bag :)
Thank you for watching and definitely a tough choice! I really like the simplified layout of the lunar pack as well as the water bottle pocket and the fact that it has a side handle. With that being said, If i had to pick one I might still lean towards the CPP for the additional space and the option to get ballistic nylon or x pack for additional weather resistance
@@dannypacks thanks Danny. so to summarize, you prefer the organization/layout of the lunar pack, but the extra space and fabrics of the CPP? Do you find the harness on both of them to be equally comfortable? I’m also debating the Fjällräven Raven 28 for another choice so wasn’t sure on your thoughts vs these as well.
@@RVASProductions yup that summary sounds about right, as far as the harnesses they are both pretty comfortable but I slightly prefer the CPP as it contours to my shoulders a bit more. The raven 28 is another really great option, pretty different aesthetically but I love the more classic vibe and it has one of my favorite layouts and its great that it can give you a good amount of volume without feeling overwhelming
@@dannypacks Thanks very much! Very last question for you... on the CPP, does it ever feel "top heavy"? I've heard some folks say that visually the bag looks like it bulges out at the top especially if you overload the top front admin pocket. Wondering on your thoughts there
@@RVASProductions Glad to help! i think its a fair concern and the bag can look a little uneven if you don't pack as much into the bottom of the bag and use mostly the top pockets
Thank you for watching! Overall I prefer the aer city pack pro, as it has a dedicated Laptop area and I like some of the additional organization but both are great
I really want to like these packs because they look super cool, but who needs to carry all of these items around. The typical person has a laptop, a charger, a wallet, sunglasses, etc. Why do you need a 3-pound backpack unless of course you work in tech or are a CZcamsr and have 2 computers, cameras, stands and lots of gear. Anyway, great review as always :)
Thank you for watching and definitely a fair point! There’s many days where I don’t really carry that much and could probably get away with a much smaller bag, my thought when I review many of these bags is “could this be my bag for multiple use cases: gym, school, longer work day, weekend trips, etc” and imagine if I could use it emptier on days when I’m carrying less stuff while keeping the flexibility for the days I need a little more space
Well seems we don’t know the same « typical persons . » I carry everyday with me a laptop, gym clothes and lunch. If you add all the extras (wallet, glasses, small tech stuff) 20-25ish liters, like this bag, is the sweet spot for many commuters.
Really does seem like a worse version of the Travel Pack 3 Small. Both expensive and bulky, but this lacks load lifters, side handles, compression straps, detachable optional hip belt, full admin panel, etc. I suppose they target the people who think that the TP3 Small is too bulky, but this one still is. You just lose a lot of the features. Sure get the "worst-of-both worlds" impression here.
the city pack pro is 1.3 lbs lighter than the tp3s and is 1 inch smaller in L & W (depth is the same). while I think the tp3s could be used under the seat, i think you'll have an easier time with this one. for a bag of this size i don't think i'll be needing those features as well. it is expensive but so are the rest of aer's bags in general.
Thank you for watching and definitely some really good points there! As someone who is a big fan of the tp3 small, the way I look at it is that the tp3 small works as an edc bag but it feels like I’m using a travel pack as an edc whereas this one feels more like a daily backpack (a good alternative to something like the tech pack 2 imo). The lack of the side handle I agree is a big miss on this one, but I don’t mind not having the compression straps and the load lifters might not make as much sense with the contoured strap design this has. Overall, if people are looking for the most versatile bag particularly for minimal travel use I agree the TP3 might be the better value, but for anyone who wants more of a daily bag this is probably the one I would go with
Is the 4L less in this pack over the TP3S even noticeable (capacity wise)? As I know litters are very subjective. For example my Timbuk2 Authority, which on paper is 6L bigger than my Herschel backpack fits significantly less than the Herschel, likely because the inside of the Timbuk2 is filled with interior fabric/pockets/organization which all work to eat up the internal capacity of the bag.
I can't decide between Travel Pack 3 vs this City Pack Pro!
I have used several aer backpacks and this city pack pro is what I have been looking for. The organizer is neither overkilling nor insufficient, the clamshell style with this size works well for versatile occasions, and the aesthetic is so beautiful as aer always offers. Watching this vid when uploaded, I decided to get it, but I forgot to appreciate it. Thank you for uploading interesting vids as always!
Thank you for watching and for the support! I’m glad the video was helpful and that the bag has been working out well!:)
I bought this a few weeks ago. I love it. It’s well built and comfy. The only change is line to see is a pen slot in the admin section.
Thank you for watching and I’m glad to hear the bag has been working well so far!:)
This is basically an update to the Lunar Pack collaboration Aer had with Ministry of Supply. It uses the same main body with good updates to the fabric and the addition of some front and side pockets. They also changed the water bottle pocket from a fully-zippered/enclosed design to an exposed one. Only criticism would be the location of that side D ring right above the water bottle pocket. It should’ve been on the opposite side (esp since they got rid of the side handle) b/c as is, if you lash anything to it, it’ll either interfere with getting your water bottle or it’ll be just a little unhygienic if you have an open-lipped bottle.
Thank you for watching and definitely some good points! I agree this is a good alternative to the lunar pack and that’s a good point to have placed the d ring on the other side especially with not having the side handle there
Most reviewers point out that they have the d ring there to allow for an additional carabiner to be clipped to a water bottle for extra security. I do agree I wisht hey had a mirrored one on the other side for additional carry options though.
@@ramonmichaelchavez7667 I'd be curious to see if the bag designers actually meant for that to be the function of that particular D ring, b/c honestly that sounds superfluous. I haven't seen many other bags have a D-ring to support a water bottle pocket, especially one that already seems pretty deep and on a bag that's ostensibly for "city" use (and not like hiking where I could actually see some utility in it). Personally seems like either an oversight in design (to not put it on the opposite side) or an opportunistic design choice without a real function [like maybe there just happened to be a "load bearing" seam there they could slot a D ring there].
I’ve seen other bag designers add that carabiner to support if you have something tall in the water bottle pocket, like a tripod or umbrella. Then you can attach a strap to the D-ring
Excellent presentation of this pack. You just about have me sold. I like that you provide other pack comps. I would’ve liked to see small photos of the comps along with the names and links.
Thank you for watching and I’m glad the video was helpful! Appreciate the feedback on the comparisons as well!:)
Thanks for your insights! Just a suggestion- When you are talking through alternatives, it would be great if you can show them (at least the pictures). Would make it so much easier for the viewers, as we won’t have to google as u talk about different brands/ bags!
Thank you for watching and for the suggestion! I will definitely keep that in mind for future reviews!
Wow great improvement from Aer here. So glad they moved to clamshell. I still prefer the overall aesthetic of Goruck especially when it comes to zipper noise. But, if this had come out a few years ago when I was comparing the brands I might have gone with this.
Thank you for watching and I agree i really like the change to a clamshell, definitely a solid goruck alternative
I bought the City pack xpac. However find it quite small. Wanted something like travel pack 3 small but find it a tad big. Then this came. Absolutely on my list. Just the price is a bit high.
Thank you for watching! The sizing on this is definitely a nice in between the city pack and the travel pack 3 small, really nice for edc
Another excellent review! The City Pack is more useable now as a work bag. I like that, aside from the internal slip pocket, it's a big open space; you can fit your lunch in there without having to be concerned about the laptop. I don't think I care for that "see-through" mesh half on that zippered pocket, though.
Thank you for watching and I definitely agree on it being a great work bag!:)
Can you show a comparison with Travel Pack 3 Small? I feel like for only $20 more you would get a much better bag. (Load Lifters, Side Handle, Full Admin Panel…)
Yeah, maybe a side-by-side comparison with the TP3 Small and the Flight Pack 3!
Thinking the same thing. I bought both to compare them.
It really depends on what you want the backpack for. I have the Travel Pack 3 Small, and I would say that it's too big for an EDC or daily bag for work, but I am a guy with a small build. However, the Travel Pack 3 Small has a 28L capacity and you can compress it down, but it's still quite big, and if you get it in the ballistic nylon it's quite weighty. So this City Pack Pro might be better for EDC.
YES I'm also comparing the two. The City Pack Pro is smaller by 1" in height and width and 4 L but it's a crazy 1.3 lbs lighter with a better water bottle holder IMO. Kind of makes it hard for me to go with the TP3S but I'm still on the fence!
I just got both in the mail today. Both are beautiful and comfortable. I guess it depends on your personal needs. If you want to use the same bag to travel (1-1.5weeks) and edc with, go with the tp3s. If strictly for edc and maybe a weekend trip go with the CPP. Im going with the CPP but can’t go wrong either way
I wish this came in a small version like a 20-22L
Thank you for watching and I agree that would be a pretty interesting alternative to have!
I do wish they make city pack in 18 or 20lt version. This 24lt is a bit too big and chunky. And the 14lt is too small for travel.
Thanks. You forgot to show the AirTag pocket.
Thank you for watching and that’s a good call out, so many features to cover that one definitely slipped by :)
@Traveling Salseros (Danny Barreto) I wanted to ask your opinion on the new Aer City Pack Pro. I am buying this bag in the next few days. My question to you is… If you were purchasing this bag, would you purchase the Xpac or 1680D Codura material? I am liking the orange interior along with the aqua guard zips. However I live in south central Texas and we get very little rainfall. Perhaps Xpac is overkill? Just wanted your expert opinion on these materials and which do you think is best. Thank you again for your time and amazing videos.
Thank you for watching and good question! Both fabrics are great options overall, the x-pac will have slightly better weather resistance and save a little on weight whereas the ballistic nylon may be a little more abrasion resistant over the long term. If you like the textured look of x-pac and the orange liner I think it will be a very good option
I was wondering if you're planning on reviewing Linus Tech Tips' backpack? I really appreciate your reviews, and I hope to hear your thoughts on it! I wonder how it stacks up vs this bag.
Also, wanted to thank you for your reviews. Based on your reviews I bought the Bellroy Transit Plus because I could get free shipping in Canada, which I ended up not liking that much due to a severe lack of tech organization options, so I returned it; but then I bought the Aer Travel Pack 3 (unfortunately expensive with shipping plus duties) which is amazing, it was perfect for my 10 day trip to Europe, alongside their sling bag for walking around cities. No other luggage needed!
Thank you for watching and for the suggestion! Definitely looks like an interesting bag and if I can get my hands on one I will definitely do a video for it :) I’m glad to hear the videos have been helpful as well and that you had a great bag for your trip!
How would this compare to the osprey aoede briefcase backpack? You should do a video showcasing that pack, I'm having a hard time deciding between the city pack pro and the osprey aoede briefcase backpack
Great bag, definitely the missing link on their assortment. If you could own only one bag between this one and the CPL24 which one would you keep ?
Thank you for watching and definitely a tough choice between the two! Although I love the CpL I think I would lean towards this one for some of the additional features it has (water bottle pocket, luggage passthrough, and I like the orientation of the laptop sleeve a bit more)
@@dannypacks Thanks for taking time answering and your great work !
Great review! I am looking for an edc backpack to take to work etc. I always take a water bottle but rarely take a comp or iPad but still want that option to carry for short travel trips. I am between the goruck gr1 21L and using a molle attachment for a water bottle holder or the city pack pro. I really am looking for a durable pack, good warranty, 20 - 24L, something easy to clean as I work in the hospital setting and sometimes my lunch spills etc. What is your recommendation between those two and any others you would recommend over the two previously mentioned? Second questioned if you recommended the city pack pro would you go cordura vs xpac?
Thank you for watching and I’m glad the video was helpful! This is definitely one of the current best options imo I love the GR1 and have used mine for years, but I would probably lean towards this one for most people due to the additional organization, the laptop pocket, the luggage passthrough and the more breathable harness. I think both fabrics are great just depends if you want some additional weather resistance / bright orange interior (xpac) or a more minimalist / rugged fabric (cordura). Some other options that might be worth considering are the evergoods cpl24, alpha one niner Whitley, the bellroy transit Workpack, Patagonia mini MLC 26
In their website it says 24L, but every video I´ve seen mentions 22L. Do you know why or if Aer changed the size?
Thank you for watching! On the unit I received to test out the tag said 22l so it might be something aer updated once the official release came out (the tags not necessarily the size of the bag)
For me, the full admin panel is a big deal, they shouldve retain that. And I know, travel pack 3 just looks like that but i dont like the load lifters and the bottle holder style, i like it better here and its smaller make it a perfect edc bag. I just want to carry everything on the bag itself and not carry another small edc bag, cuz if thats the case, i rather have some of their bags which is lighter
Thank you for watching and fair points! I agree I still prefer the admin panel on the travel pack 3 small
Is this bag too big for a EDC? I usually just carry my lunch bag for work and a water bottle would that fit?
Thank you for watching! For me, I don’t think it’s too big but I know some who might feel it’s a little excessive (should be able to hold the items you mentioned pretty well)
Can you fit the goruck pouches that you’ve reviewed fit in the lower front pocket?
Thank You!
Thank you for watching!:)
Love the bag, just received mine a couple days ago but feel that it’s just a little too “deep” for my preference. Do you have any recommendations for similar bags, with the dedicated laptop compartment, that are maybe a bit wider/taller and less deep? Thanks Danny!
Thank you for watching! If you are looking for something similar from Aer, the city pack and flight pack 3 might be worth checking out. Other than that the goruck GR1 is always a solid option or maybe the bellroy transit Workpack
Does a 17 inch laptop fit in the bag?
How do you think it compares to Aer's Tech Pack 2? I know the aesthetic is different, but in terms of layout, organization and usage? I'm having a slightly hard time picking one of the two.
Thank you for watching and great question! I think this is a really compelling alternative to the city pack pro if you like the more sleek aesthetic and you’re looking for a top loading bag (vs the clamshell on the city pack pro). I think the city pack pro can hold a little more and I like the updated harness, but this one includes the side handle, it provides more space in the front admin compartment and it stands up better on its own.
This bag reminds of me the Goruck GR2 but without the militaristic vibes. The GR2 is definitely the more functional bag, but I am considering the gray option of this bag as a more color neutral option of a different style. Not sure if it would be worth it though due to the similarities. I am looking for a companion bag to go with my GR2 26L (I have it in steel, want something gray to better work with my warddrobe and less militaristic). I use my GR2 for weekend trips and ocasional rucking. Ideally as a backpack, I think any bigger would be annoying to carry and I would move to a duffel bag for clothes, but with that being said for longer trips I likely wouldnt mind bringing 2 backacks filled with packing cubes. Unsure if I should go for similar size or smaller for EDC and as a secondary travel bag. Opinions? Currently looking at the TB Synik 22, Aer Travel Pack 3 Small, or City Pack Pro. I'd also look at other suggestions.
Thank you for watching and that’s great to what you’ve been enjoying the gr2! I do think this could be a good companion for the use case you mentioned, as well as the synik 22 (that one feels slightly smaller and has a really good pocket layout), to me the travel pack 3 small might actually feel a little big for what you are describing, the bellroy transit Workpack might be another option worth checking out
Hey Dannny, which would you recommend for edc this or alpha Whitney
Thank you for watching! Both are really great options overall, I would lean a bit more towards the aer as it has a dedicated laptop compartment and slightly more space
I want to see Aer City Pack Pro vs Alpha One Niner Whitley video
Thank you for watching and that’s a great idea for a comparison video!:)
is it self standing?
Thank you for watching! Although it can depend how the bag is loaded out it does stand up pretty well on its own for the most part
What do you prefer between this and the Bellroy Workpack? I’ve ordered both and torn between them. I wish the bellroy had a better water bottle holder…
Thank you for watching and definitely a tough choice! Both are awesome bags but I would lean towards this one as I like that it has an external water bottle pocket, a luggage passthrough and the harness system is a little more comfortable imo
@@dannypacks Thank you for your response, and videos (I’ve watched plenty! but just not commented before). I’m starting to lean towards the Aer too, for the same reasons. I got it in XPAC so the bellroy is quite a bit cheaper, and lighter/small/flexible but I reached out to this because of the lacking water bottle/D rings.
Thank you! Enjoy the rest of your day
Great review and this look like a perfect bag for me! Does it feel heavy on your back compared to packs like Evergoods or Mystery Ranch? And would you recommend it for college use?
Thank you for watching and I’m glad the video was helpful! I think this would definitely be a solid bag for college, and it can feel a little heavier compared to some of those bags especially in the 1680d ballistic fabric, but not by a lot and it’s a fair trade off for the additional padding / features you get imo
It’s it the same packing cube you used in your original City Pack video?
Thank you for watching and yes same day packing cube in both videos :)
What I am curious is how this would compare to the Go Pack 2, particularly as far as use as a packable Daypack.
The City Pack Pro is in no way packable. It's using the same rigid Cordura fabric like other Aer packs while the Go Pack 2 is more pliable and intended to be stuffed inside another bag.
Thank you for watching and +1 to Jack’s comment, the city pack pro just really isn’t made to be packable
Great video. Thank you. I'm trying to find a personal item on airplanes type backpack for professional travel. I like this one a lot as well as the Troubadour Ridge (preferred aesthetics). Any thoughts between the two, or other professional looking bags?
Larger size and move to full clamshell are great improvements but the removal of the side handle is a major L. Quickly putting the bag on and removing from luggage pass through becomes more difficult.
Thank you for watching and I agree on the removal of the side handle, keeping that would have made this pretty much perfect for me especially for the luggage passthrough like you said
How would you compare this to the A19 Whitley and the Arktype Jetpack?
Thank you for watching! I haven’t had a chance to check out the jet pack just yet, but compared to the whitely there are definitely some similarities (clamshell opening, plenty of pocketing), the biggest differences will be in the size as this one feels bigger than the Whitley and it also has a separate laptop compartment compared to the Whitley which has the laptop in the main compartment
It has a 24L capacity and not 22L.
Thank you for watching and good call out! On the unit I received the tag said 22 but I see aer has updated their site to 24l and it does feel like it can hold a similar amount to other 24l bags
For scaling purposes, how tall are you?
Thank you for watching! I am 5’11”
Can this pack stand on its own?
Thank you for watching! It can depend on how the weight is distributed but for the most part it stands up pretty well on its own
Would the water bottle pocket hold a 26oz Rambler?
Thank you for watching and yes it can hold the 26 oz rambler!
@@dannypacks Sweet! I was debating between this and the MoS Lunar Pack but I think this one might win out. I was digging the Lunar Pack's simplicity but it's a bit too simple -needs just a tad more organization for a work bag.
Hi. Is this good as a university backpack?
Thank you for watching and yes I think this would be a nice alternative as it has good space and durability and it’s comfortable to wear for walking around
😎 Where can I buy the 20oz water bottle you have? ✌️
Thank you for watching! The one I have in the video is from Wandrd, but the brand of the bottle is miir if you want to see some of the different options they have :)
is it 24 L or 22L ?
Aer sites i did not find 22l . anyone paste link of 22L pls
Thank you for watching! The volume should be 24l, when I first received the bag the tag said 22l but this has been updated to better reflect the size of the bag :)
no bottle holder?
Thank you for watching! This has an external water bottle pocket on one side
Have brought travel pack 3 small x pac, maybe waist money on the city pro
Thank you for watching! I agree that if you have the travel pack 3 small already then buying this one as well may not be worth it
Flight Pack 3 X-pac is the best everyday backpack from AER.
Thank you for watching and I agree the flight pack is a really solid edc option especially with the updates on the 3!
Do you prefer this or the Lunar Pack?
Thank you for watching and definitely a tough choice! I really like the simplified layout of the lunar pack as well as the water bottle pocket and the fact that it has a side handle. With that being said, If i had to pick one I might still lean towards the CPP for the additional space and the option to get ballistic nylon or x pack for additional weather resistance
@@dannypacks thanks Danny. so to summarize, you prefer the organization/layout of the lunar pack, but the extra space and fabrics of the CPP? Do you find the harness on both of them to be equally comfortable?
I’m also debating the Fjällräven Raven 28 for another choice so wasn’t sure on your thoughts vs these as well.
@@RVASProductions yup that summary sounds about right, as far as the harnesses they are both pretty comfortable but I slightly prefer the CPP as it contours to my shoulders a bit more. The raven 28 is another really great option, pretty different aesthetically but I love the more classic vibe and it has one of my favorite layouts and its great that it can give you a good amount of volume without feeling overwhelming
@@dannypacks Thanks very much! Very last question for you... on the CPP, does it ever feel "top heavy"? I've heard some folks say that visually the bag looks like it bulges out at the top especially if you overload the top front admin pocket. Wondering on your thoughts there
@@RVASProductions Glad to help! i think its a fair concern and the bag can look a little uneven if you don't pack as much into the bottom of the bag and use mostly the top pockets
This or the EG CHZ22?
Thank you for watching! Overall I prefer the aer city pack pro, as it has a dedicated Laptop area and I like some of the additional organization but both are great
@@dannypacks awesome thanks for responding! Build quality is comparable between the 2?
@@michaellaughlinii6866 yup both are really well built!
I really want to like these packs because they look super cool, but who needs to carry all of these items around. The typical person has a laptop, a charger, a wallet, sunglasses, etc. Why do you need a 3-pound backpack unless of course you work in tech or are a CZcamsr and have 2 computers, cameras, stands and lots of gear. Anyway, great review as always :)
Thank you for watching and definitely a fair point! There’s many days where I don’t really carry that much and could probably get away with a much smaller bag, my thought when I review many of these bags is “could this be my bag for multiple use cases: gym, school, longer work day, weekend trips, etc” and imagine if I could use it emptier on days when I’m carrying less stuff while keeping the flexibility for the days I need a little more space
Well seems we don’t know the same « typical persons . »
I carry everyday with me a laptop, gym clothes and lunch. If you add all the extras (wallet, glasses, small tech stuff) 20-25ish liters, like this bag, is the sweet spot for many commuters.
it's 24 not 22 litres fyi
Thank you for watching and for the additional information! I’ll add a note to the description to clarify!
Really does seem like a worse version of the Travel Pack 3 Small. Both expensive and bulky, but this lacks load lifters, side handles, compression straps, detachable optional hip belt, full admin panel, etc.
I suppose they target the people who think that the TP3 Small is too bulky, but this one still is. You just lose a lot of the features. Sure get the "worst-of-both worlds" impression here.
the city pack pro is 1.3 lbs lighter than the tp3s and is 1 inch smaller in L & W (depth is the same). while I think the tp3s could be used under the seat, i think you'll have an easier time with this one. for a bag of this size i don't think i'll be needing those features as well. it is expensive but so are the rest of aer's bags in general.
Thank you for watching and definitely some really good points there! As someone who is a big fan of the tp3 small, the way I look at it is that the tp3 small works as an edc bag but it feels like I’m using a travel pack as an edc whereas this one feels more like a daily backpack (a good alternative to something like the tech pack 2 imo). The lack of the side handle I agree is a big miss on this one, but I don’t mind not having the compression straps and the load lifters might not make as much sense with the contoured strap design this has. Overall, if people are looking for the most versatile bag particularly for minimal travel use I agree the TP3 might be the better value, but for anyone who wants more of a daily bag this is probably the one I would go with
Is the 4L less in this pack over the TP3S even noticeable (capacity wise)? As I know litters are very subjective. For example my Timbuk2 Authority, which on paper is 6L bigger than my Herschel backpack fits significantly less than the Herschel, likely because the inside of the Timbuk2 is filled with interior fabric/pockets/organization which all work to eat up the internal capacity of the bag.