What are the geopolitical implications of India's success in space? | DW News
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 09. 2023
- India has launched its first space mission to study the sun. The Aditya L1 spacecraft will travel to the outermost part of the sun's orbit. Its aim is to record data that will help scientists to understand how massive explosions of solar gases happen, and and how they impact the Earth. The mission is due to take around 5 years.
That means India's last two space missions have been successful. Both missions are different, technically difficult missions. Do they proove that India is now among the leaders in space exploration?
Both China and India are rising military and economic powers. They regularly clash on their shared border, and both countries have very ambitious space programs. Will this rivalry in space change their relationship on the ground?
Some discoveries in space affect the way we live on earth, but how much of space exploration is really about politics, bravado and flexing on the world stage?
Subscribe: czcams.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#India #Space #Geopolitics
China doesn't openly share its data with other space agencies, India does. For India, it's not really a race. It's a way to keep improving ourselves and help others with our learnings. So let's not try to push India in this so-called space race.
Agreed
Chinese have their own ground stations & India have to rely on ESA and NASA for ground control and deep space network. India plans to work with and collaborate with while the china focus is self reliance. Two different approaches
@@granand India also has it's own deep space network. They collaborate with ESA and NASA for redundancies....
@@granandindia will complete building space station by 2030.
I think we need to be a bit like CHINA and stop trusting these WESTOID's colonial criminals And I am including Murica in the colonial category too, The native Americans should be given independence now
A win for science either way. Fantastic work India! From the UK
Thanks you so much for your wishes, from India
This is a first.... usually people from UK don't appreciate anything... thanks though
Love the launch
Indian chatting with an indian 😅😅... Me too indian ❤️❤️
You are probably Indian or British Indian. No native brit will ever congratulate India on these missions.
I am an Indian,..And I can assure you that we are not in a race with anyone but just trying to explore space for better opportunity for human beings.
Thanks for assurance mela deepu
Thanks for assurance mela deepu
We Indians are in a race. All are. In 2012 China's 'Yinghuo-1' Mars mission failed and this promoted Manmohan Singh to ask ISRO if we can succeed in the same Mars mission. Once he was given a positive reply from ISRO, he sanctioned money for Mars mission, which happened in 2014.
So, yes, we are in a race and we will do one-upmanship, but not brinkmanship, like Russians did this time and Soviets prior to that.
How do you know what the Indian government is doing?
@@danielandrews5357 He doesn’t Daniel साहब He is just in a state of eternal happiness 🙏
India's space missions truly supported for Humanity
lndia is 10 years ahead of USA in space technology. Jai Hind 💪
@@__daddy__UK*
@@__daddy__Says the Chinese WUMAO. 🎉
@@Traderking1990Chinese Wumaos think they are 10 years ahead of the USA.. total loosers
India is crushing it in the space sector!!! Congratulations India!! From CA!!
Well in reality. It isn't.
@@mayurkanth6987Poor Paxtani spotted 😂
@@JohnWick-uj4gh poor landbhakt spotted.
CA is Canada?
@@SelvaKumar_1992 Yes it is.
Next mission for India should be having our own space station on the lower earth orbit sending our astronauts till 2030.
that costs an insane amount of money and serves no purpose, so how about no?
@@fortytwo244yo ccp bot
@@Ass_of_Amalek use little bit mind,every penny you spend now on space program , give you 100 times more return
@@fortytwo244bhikaristan ma ki chut
I don't know if u know this but isro has already announced that India will be having its own space station before 2030😂😂😂
Kudos to India!
Space programs are highly complex and complicated
...any nation wishing to make it in space, you need to allow time for your own people to work things out first, then launch time happens. Congrats India 🇮🇳
90% 0f Inddians still live in very p0or c0nditi0n but my c0untry spending m0ney 0n space and fancy statues
lndia is 10 years ahead of USA in space technology. Jai Hind 💪
@@__daddy__ woah ! Hold your horse, man. It's not true now, but respect India and the USA in the future. They are our space allies for now, but they aren't stopping us from what we want to do, and nobody can, so who knows, we might become a space superpower, and we will become space superpower and to say. Further, we believe India will rule the world, but for now, put your head down and stay focused.
@@__daddy__Is this sarcastic comment?.
@@Mr-rc4vkilliterate and jealous person who is feeling his butt is burning 🎉
This isn't a zero sum game. It's not as if one country getting to the moon somehow means others can't. For the space race, the more competition, the better for us all. Invite India into more collaborative projects!
From Indians point of view, we are not interested in any race... we are just curious to learn...
Yup, there's enough space for everybody.
@@SuryadevaraRammurthyNaiduYeah, it's just a term, it doesn't have to be if we work together. But since a lot of prestige is involved, if someone has success, everyone else usually pumps more money into their programs, which is good! :)
@brll5733 Yes absolutely, I agree with you. A collective effort for scientific advancement would be amazing, humanity for the win 🧘♂️
You not follow regular news recently Russia space agency failed to soft land in moon lonar 25 crashed in moon surface, Japan JAXA is also doubtful for moon soft landing they delay their moon project, its not easy whatever your country advance in technology but in space program your success rate half of the half
Congratulation, India.🇮🇳🇺🇸
thankyou brother/sister
❤❤❤❤
ISRO is an Open platform for everyone's, ISRO shares everything with Everyone's,
Good Job India
Good job ISRO
Good job Govt of india
While the achievement is remarkable, it is a more than fair question to ask, should India be spending huge resources on this while hundreds of millions of its people suffer from abject poverty. Do the poor, the destitute, the untouchables of India benefit at all from
it doesnt make any difference. we are developing, we should in all the fields. we have every type of people. cant just think about poor 24/7. for you info, the poor who cant return any favour to country gets food at 0.04 cents/kg ration. they dont have to worry about food. and those poor who can work are doinf their bit. and govt have and are already spending billions of dollars for their welfare. so dont you worry.@@Kwippy
@@KwippyIndia has both rich people and poor people. India has very intelligent people and very dumb people too. In India, there is a place for everyone. ISRO makes sure the very intelligent section remain in the country. India doesn't have to wait till it make the dumb people, intelligent or poor people, rich. Everyone grows accordingly.
Also, your comment is quite lame, government already spends too much on public welfare, there re thousands of schemes.
Apart from that, the money on which ISRO does this, is quite low as compared to other agencies.
What's the benefit??
Government provides money to Isro for running it's operations. If in future, mining becomes possible or any other thing, then ISRO might be able to make money and run it's operations on its own. That would definitely save the already tiny amount of money government of India spends on ISRO, which in turn would be used then used to fund more schemes on the poor.
I hope u get this
@@Kwippy Indian Space agency is earning from foreign countries by launching their satellite. It has its own commercial space program. For your kind information ISRO is giving jobs to the thousands of engineers, scientists and other people how can you say that we are wasting money in space program. just shut down your mouth.
@@Kwippyyou must be illiterate
Space missions are very much advantageous for India
India is an ancient civilization that had to eclipse under colonial rule, now overcoming the colonial impact gradually. India is a victim of geopolitics as any other colonized nation, now it started coming up overcoming its past showing its way to other colonized & dominated nations.
yep, and now we are witnessing an awakening in Africa. Tides are turning.
@@MG-iy1ohWe wish you good luck ❤
@@MG-iy1ohGood Luck from India my friend
India is battling hard for African union to be Inducted in G20 Countries Grouping
@@MG-iy1oh bros are ruling hearts of snownunnies🐰 too😈
As an American I'm happy for India to join in exploring space and don't feel threatened by them or even China really. I think we can learn together and make money together on the moon. It's exciting to me and I hope we do more as well. As for Russia they're clearly no threat to us either
Today's Russia can never be a threat the only threat to today's world is china
🇮🇳 🇺🇸 partnerships 👍
To western media one thing we Indians want to say that we are not in a race with anyone , we just want to explore and learn things with whatever limited resource we have . NASA has achieved mind boggling feat and we Indians respect that and we also want to achieve . Space program also helps in uplifting moral of the nation , people think that if ISRO can do that we common people can also do .
Congratulations team ISRO for Aditya -L-1 Mission success 💐💐
While the achievement is remarkable, it is a more than fair question to ask, should India be spending huge resources on this while hundreds of millions of its people suffer from abject poverty. Do the poor, the destitute, the untouchables of India benefit at all from
@@Kwippy USA home less person - 5.5 lakh
UK-3.3lakh
France- 2.7 lakh
India - only 1.8 million in the massive 1.4 billion population.
Still we are poor but you not????? Such a f**** hypocrisy of West.
@@Kwippyhuge resources?
The govt spent just 75 million dollars for Chandrayaan2 moon spacecraft and 107 Billion dollars for social sector expenditure...
Respectfully, Have some sense and information before commenting....
India's space exploration is of great importance in the context of the geopolitics of this century.
India was denied access to GPS during the Kargil war by the west. Later we developed satellites capable of doing that. West always allied with countries supporting terrorism.
ISRO returned roughly 5 times returns to the amount spend on the organization.
Around 500 television channels broadcast through our satellites,
Indias defense capability of monitoring the rogue neighbors and missile guidance depends on the satellites
Satellites helps in education reaching rural population through satellites, weather forecasting, disaster management etc
Our ATM transactions happen though the satellites
Our stock trading happens through the satellites
Fisherman get information about the availability of fish in the sea
We launch foreign satellites through our rockets and earn money out of it.
do you have burnol there
Where's Charu? He's India's premier DW space expert xD
Good to know DW is reaching out to more Indians to learn about the country instead os stayinf in it's own bubble
Limit of bvgrahmin quota
ISRO❤ The most efficient space organisation on Earth 🌏
While the achievement is remarkable, it is a more than fair question to ask, should India be spending huge resources on this while hundreds of millions of its people suffer from abject poverty. Do the poor, the destitute, the untouchables of India benefit at all from
@@Kwippydo you know how much was spent on it? Approx. 40-50 million Dollars. Is that a huge amount? Even 50 times that amount can't rid India of poverty. And as far as rocket launching expenses are concerned, USA spends in hundreds of millions of dollars maybe billion or more too. Has it ridden itself completely of poverty? You just need a couple of burnols. Get yourself a few and keep continuing to watch India progress further. 😂😂😂😂😂
@@Kwippythe cost chandrayaan 3 is like 4.3 Rs per person for indian it's like nothing
What image u have of India is completely different than reality, so better come in india have some fun and good tourism experience and see the reality too 😊
@@KwippyIndian genius mind which get attracted to west bcoz of lack of opportunities in India, will stay in india and will contribute us to achieve more so you just saw a western colonial perspective on topic indirectly saying that FORMER COLONEY OF UK SHOULD NOT HAVE WHAT UK DONT HAVE , poverty in india is decreasing fast , IMF said india has erdicated extreme proverty (government policy are very nice of poor very chep even free food and LPG gas ) poverty percentage in UK and INDIA is almost same and In uk poverty is bit constant but in india it's decreasing
@@Kwippyu keep saying this... But when there is a threat to earth, India will settle its people in another planet which is favorable for life.. Dont beg for a seat please🤪
ISRO s' funding is much lesser than most space agencies. So imagine the extent they would have gone with a heavy budget
They would get lazy
@@24jithu24 how ?
more money not always gives better results, there is limit to what they already know and can implement.
agreed. Budget of ISRO needs to increase.
*Charu didn't study Aero-Space?* ☹️☹️🙁🙁
🤣🤣
😀
Where is charu 🥺🥺🥺 why isnt THE EXPERT on India not giving any comments on indian space exploration..
Where's our all rounder CHARU, did he skipped aero space science? Or giving the chances to others huh! ? How generous😂😂😅
look charu could not keep up to the pace of ISRO missions (one after another missions in so quick succesions and he begged he required lot of time for preparation aka mouthfeeding )and pleaaded DW to leave him alone 🤭
@@seshasaivenkatHey could you provide the context ?
I think Charu is someone who hates India ? Am i right ?
@@ViPUL22 so what?? Indians usually hate India and Hindus... Charu ain't any diff neither this Abhishek guy ...
But it still fun 🤣😂😀
@@pikachue602 Indians usually hate India and Hindus ?? Since when ?
It's Westerners who hates India
You did typo mistake i think
@@ViPUL22 no I'm not mistaken. when westerners do it is understandable but not when it is done by Indian nris themselves
Congratulations to 🇮🇳👍
Space race more majestic then Arms race. Hat down to Indian space program
UK 🇬🇧 : give our aid money back😡
India🇮🇳 : liftoff narmaal
What about India's money then 45trillion😡
😂😂
Lift off normal (लिफ्ट ऑफ नॉर्मल) not liftoff narmaal (लिफ्टाफ नार्मल) a Botta o wata 😅😅😅😅
West: india u have poverty problem
India : lift off naarmal 😂
Its a way of making fun of others using our bad english accent , you do not understand sarcasm it seems @@chandrakamal1826
Where is Charu? He is astrophysicist no?
😂
He's on board, he will be softlanding on sun and report later
@@kkkkjjjj4517🤣🤣🤣🤣
Wow India is on a role, great leap for humanity! Great job guys..❤
One thing i can vouch for my country that its each success will and never have been a threat to any nation , neither India do things to race with someone
You see, India doing missions not only for India, they shares data with other countries, hence everyone can use it and work on it, It is truly commendable. Kudos to the ISRO Team and India 👏
Space is for everyone & space exploration is benificial for everyone ,,,we represent humanity over there ,,,& we are clear on that 😊
We thank England for providing imaginary loan for all these space missions Even it's own Economy is dying.
😂
Space has no limit. There is no need for India china to fight over small piece of land on earth when there is limitless in space
Well China is the one who wants others territory
Space is always a vantage point to monitor planet earth and adversary countries in it.
the ultimate high ground
@@jorenbaplu5100 this is where the fun begins.
The US remains the only country to have detonated a nuclear device in space. “Starfish Prime” 7/9/62
for india its not a race they know they are the best in the game for them its curiousity and they want to inspire millions of indians to reach the pinnacle of science and tech
Events like this really shine a light on the absolutely stunning achievement of the Apollo Program and the Moon landings from 1969-1972. Watched a documentary on Apollo 8 recently, which was the first manned spaceflight to leave Earth's gravitational pull to orbit the Moon. Just fascinating, more so when you learn how they did it, how each component was developed and tested. The single greatest engineering accomplishment in history.
Please share name of the documentary & OTT platform where it is available to watch...
Thanks
Jai Hind, from an an admirer from Peru.
As an Indian i always dreamt about visiting Machu Picchu 😅
Thank you
India might share major scientific findings and they are very vocal about what the findings are. What they won't share is lander details, orbital coordinates
What astonishing is India us able do it Very cheap 😮and successful ❤
Am surprised my India shared the scientific research data asap on social media when the rover did work
Where did they share data in Social Media? Saying bunch of elements present in an analysis is not sharing data. ISRO will share with their counter parts in a private channel. I never seen any space mission sharing data publicly. Even NASA/JPL doesn't share data publicly.
It's normal for science community, except China
@@gopalray9553 If you had read scientific journals on this topic，you would not say that. If you are not expert or researchers, ok it’s not your fault to not aquare those data.
Just few pictures
Every one is missing charu? He is like johny Sinc 😂
All rounder Charu is missing 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Isro is working on India's first crewed space mission called gaganyan. Its technology demonstrating launch will be carried out by the end of this September
We are not racing with anyone its our ambition to explore our universe for human kind thats it. And we will do it without asking anyone.😎👍
Indian mission for whole humanity...
China Russia not shares their date with world
Science with low cost with high goal will benefit the entire World.
Time to end nbbragmin quota .
Indians always work for mankind for thousands of years!!
LOL ....Millions if not billions of years
You mean trillions of years 🤣😂🤣😂 turd
I'm hooked to that "Liftoff naarmal". That's become like a lucky charm for isro
Yeah Mee too 😂 'liftoff naarmal'
The father of Indian space research envisioned Indian space project for betterment of humanity and progress of downtrodden. Now our ambitions are rising but our principals are still the same. We were never part of any race and we never will be. We are doing it for science and good that we can do with it.
Very well explained. ❤
Founder of ISRO, Dr. Vikram Sarabhai emphasized the importance of a space program in his quote:
"There are some who question the relevance of space activities in a developing nation. To us, there is no ambiguity of purpose. We do not have the fantasy of competing with the economically advanced nations in the exploration of the moon or the planets or manned space-flight.
But we are convinced that if we are to play a meaningful role nationally, and in the community of nations, we must be second to none in the application of advanced technologies to the real problems of man and society."
How visionary he was when India was a young struggling nation.
Yet he was so sure about the possibilities of space programme.
Lift off Normalll...🎉
No it's Naarmal
@@nishpakshagupta8331
Need to hear this more and more.
Congratulations ISRO
India for Mars Orbiter Mission, Mangalyaan on november 2013,
Chandrayaan3 soft landing on South pole of the moon mission on July 2023 & Sun observation mission Aditya L1 on September 2023..👍👍
India only country who always says after its successful Space missions, This is world's and humanity's mission 😅😅😅
You are wrong, NASA has open data policy, space agencies across the world, and humanity in general has benefited from NASA. ISRO is doing commendable job, but you cannot negate NASA’s contribution.
While the achievement is remarkable, it is a more than fair question to ask, should India be spending huge resources on this while hundreds of millions of its people suffer from abject poverty. Do the poor, the destitute, the untouchables of India benefit at all from
@@Kwippyi mean the u.s does the same, plenty of poor ppl without a home and kids that goes hungry.
@@Kwippyalthough the u.s dont get aid from other countries..
Those who smuggled 400 trillion dollars in 200 years ask how you, a poor country, got to the moon? Like you, our forefathers never went out to rob anyone, that was not our culture. It is that goodness that India stands tall in front of the world today.
GB News & BBC If your people have shame and dignity tell them to set an example by returning that Kohinoor gem!
India believes in Basudhaiva Kutumbakam, in Sanskrit it means World is one family so whatever India finds during these expeditions, will be shared with other countries and this will ultimately help entire humanity 😊
You kept bombarding space in name of exploration and now when it is India's turn, it's called space race. Good job👍
We want All-rounder Charu 👊🗿✊
Why does the west think we are in competition with anyone? We are doing it for us but also for humanity. What we will learn will benefit everyone. The successful Chandrayaan-3 mission and now Aditya L1 instilled a sense of pride in me but that’s all. Not even once I thought that we one upped anyone.
Waiting to see, "this space program funded by British tax payers".😂
India believe in co-operational success for betterment of entire mankind !
Because we know there is no borders in space, & we humans know negligible amount of knowledge about universe.
1 Correction = India did not indulge in any race.
They launched their moon mission around the same time as Russia launched theirs. Nobody really thinks they had a serious race going but just the timing had people calling it an informal "race".
@@raggedcriticalrussia launched after India so it's not India's fault
@@PriyanshuRaj6 I think they launched before India - they just couldn't stick the landing.
@@raggedcritical they launched way too late..you need to upgrade your general knowledge
@@raggedcriticalRussia launched after India.
India's space exploration is of great importance in the context of the geopolitics of this century.
India was denied access to GPS during the Kargil war by the west. Later we developed satellites capable of doing that. West always allied with countries supporting terrorism.
ISRO returned roughly 5 times returns to the amount spend on the organization.
Around 500 television channels broadcast through our satellites,
Indias defense capability of monitoring the rogue neighbors and missile guidance depends on the satellites
Satellites helps in education reaching rural population through satellites, weather forecasting, disaster management etc
Our ATM transactions happen though the satellites
Our stock trading happens through the satellites
Fisherman get information about the availability of fish in the sea
We launch foreign satellites through our rockets and earn money out of it.
😂🤣
@@Q_QQ_Q OLA HUUBER 😂😂
@@Q_QQ_QUSE ITCH GUARD PAXSTANI😂
Long way to go...
Congratulation team ISRO and government of India for successfully launched Aditya L1 mission 🇮🇳
Jai Hind ❤ Bande Mataram.
OMG India is super power , Occupation of the Space and in no time India will be the Space Domination now ............
India means। great history and grand thinking for earth
Always like to hear Namrata Goswami's analysis!
they are very smart people..
India & It's technology advancement is very crucial for world peace
She represents very well india's strength & capabilities . Thank you mam. We are looking forward to do good works with isro . ❤
why this deluge of such videos after india's recent missions...no-one was bothered when us, china etc launched missions...is it FOMO or what....a country, poor it may be by western standarss and it actually is, with human capital of 1.5bn is ought to have decent scientific progress here and there, even if some may complain abt its poverty etc...do you expect such a big country to only work on its poverty and just stop working on other aspects of progress...this is not how things work...
So, did you now get your validation from a german news channel? Are you happy now, that some country praised your country?
@@vb9950 did you even read my post?
You are so absolutely right. I’m surprised that some very well educated people cannot grasp the concept. Look at the silly comment from vb9950 for an example of absolute stupidity.
@@cccc2740 First they'll grudgingly recognize our capabilities and propagate them to their masses. Then, they'll shift the Overton window towards a point where they'll start equating India with China (they're already doing that through their nonsense electoral autocracy terminology and on the topic of "Cashmere". Its obvious why they are drumming it up now. Its a shift from their usual stance of "poor India" to "threat India".
It's not really about India. It's more about Russia and China. I'm pretty sure there wouldn't have been any such focus on India, had there not been a war with Russia where India stayed neutral and where Russia's lander crashed. They are highlighting India's achievement as an insult to slap Russia and to show that 'even India can now do things better than Russia'. It's honestly a very backhanded 'compliment' to India and I'm glad that Indians pushed back on the narrative in the comments of every segment that tried to paint as if 'Russia and India was in a race'. Its an attempt to drive a wedge between India and Russia as well as trying to prop up India as their relation with China has soured.
They know very well that India is militarily and geographically very important to check China. There is no other country in Asia with the same space capability as India and they are partnering with India on space sector to develop our capabilities as well as get into contracts to use each other facilities, because all of it, along without navigation satellites, anti spy satellites are all imperative to monitor and restrict Chinese movement, especially naval movement in India ocean.
And it's standard practice in West to create 'manufactured consent' with media before they involve with any major geopolitical move.
Most of the western countries have a very contradictory relationship with India as their defense see India as a partner (because China) but most of their government apparatus is very often in conflict with Indian government because of our protectiveness to local economy as well as the because of having a very unrelatable culture, however the same governments, until recently were pretty much a brethren to China because of their cheap manufacturing and shipping. In such a scenario, they need this media prepping for furthering ties and partnerships with India.
PS. I'm obviously not talking about the scientific community in any countries, but about the government and media apparatus
I hope in the future ISRO can replace the hole that roscosmos left in the alliance of NASA, esa, JAXA and the canadian space agency. Preferably around 2030 when the ISS gets decomissioned
Well, India did sign the Artemis Accords and a few years before that India also formally launched its Human Spaceflight Development program. So its entirely possible to see that happening.
No charu detected, opinion rejected 😂
Who is charu bro? 😅
@@ShubhamKumar-fh5hdIt's a secret 😂😂
@@ShubhamKumar-fh5hdummm.....Briefly
He is Jhonny Sins for DW.
HE IS EVERYTHING THAT YOU CAN IMAGINE
@@ShubhamKumar-fh5hd bro u don't know charu?? Th myth the legend 😑. You should be tried for crimes against humanity. 😂
JK=He is India correspondence for dw, he used to give his opinion on everything. He was jhonny sins of India matter from economy to politics, only expert dw could afford. ❤️
@@Freethinker-vj4utI think.....after criticism Nowadays DW hire more people.....but there will one & only Lord Charu 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
The inner meaning of India's success to other countries-
1. UK - we colonized and looted India for 200 years, still give them aid worth millions as a symbol of superiority... how come these ppl beat us..
2. Europe - our forefathers colonized so many continents.. we are white and superior.. we are pioneers in science.. we should control the hitech induatries, create brain drain from poor countries and we should control the hitech echo system.. inspite of these how India can be successful.. this is a failure of our policy and we should revisit..
3. US - lets collaborate with India, create a conception that India is an ally, use India against China to our favour.. similar to what we did with Pakistan and used against India and Soviets..
But unfortunately Western countries dont undetstand that India has the edge and poeple with real knowledge and expertise who can think ahead of Western strategists.. 😂😂😂😂
Finally, India has a clear headed leader abd stable government voted in by the majority. India is doing what it needs to do. Space exploration will result in promoting science, space and defense sector, job creation and human life . At the same time, it helps build defense technologies. All in all, it enhances India’s clout in the community of nations. Given the trajectory of its economy and evolution of a strategic culture, it will emerge as a solid pole in world power politics. That may take a decade or two. A powerful country, it is going to be.
FYI ISRO chairman said they are happy when China does successful space missions and its not political in space research and its for humanity
Keep Calm and Continue Your Great Work ISRO
Many West are becoming envy of India's growth and success..... They forgot everything is in cyclical form.... India was विश्वगुरु in past and will again become in Future 🙏
Thanks for kicking out Charu. He was very bias.
Gaganyan and Indian space station are the main event.
These all, shukrayan, mangalyan 2, LUPEX, SPADEX, NGLV etc etc are side quest.
But the boss fight, will be indians on moon, which has been hinted to happen around 2035. It is garuntee that a manned moon mission will happen in the future, but the dates are tentitive, probably cost boundings.
Can tell you that it won't happen by 2035. For Moon landing, we need a superheavy lift rocket. None of the rockets ISRO has ever considered seriously have belonged to this category. And now, the bar has moved higher. Now, India must first finish its current target of NGLV by 2030 and then immediately start working on a new much more powerful methalox engine than the LM-100. This engine when developed (maybe by around 2039) should then be used to develop a new superheavy lift rocket that is equivalent to the Starship, not the Saturn V or SLS. If we manage to achieve that by mid-2040s, we might see Indian gagannauts landing on the Moon on India's 100th Independence Day.
That is the most realistic timeline. Unless there arises a political/military need to hasten the development of a Starship-class rocket.
@@death_parade dont think so.
The NGLV will be developed by 2028-29, cause if it won't, it would take a serious amount of missions to build a space station without a heavy lift rocket. So we can count that NGLV will be completed by 2030.
And it will be enough for the starter moon landing. Yes not like building a base there, that will have to wait another 5-10 years, till ISRO made another reusable super heavy launch rocket. But the thing is, ISRO is already working on prototypes of these all kind of rockets. Even a reusable one.
So by 2035 india will have all the means for a manned moon landing. Since NGLV is enough to carrying them to the moon.
@@rickgolder6818 Bruh, NGLV is what, 20 tons to LEO (if we are being optimistic)? Not enough to even launch a single part of a Lunar ship.
We can't cheap out on delta V of the rocket in a Moon Mission. The payloads will be humans this time. Can't really take the slow route like Chandrayaan-2 and 3 did. We need TLI direct. And TLI payload capacity of NGLV won't even be enough for a human lander, forget a crew and service module.
We need at least 75 tons to LEO rocket and ideally 150 tons to LEO rocket.
@@death_parade bruh, NGLV will be able to send payload from 4tons to 16 tons to GTO, and above 23-24 tons to LEO. Yes the Saturn V, which took the Apollo, was a more powerful rocket (could carry above 40tons to GTO). But that was because the systems and computers were much more bigger and heavier than what we have today. So a big amount of space was taken due to those.
Also, the chinese are planing to send Humans to moon by 2030. And the interesting point is that they are going to use there Long Mach 5 rocket (current most powerful rocket of china), which can carry around 14 tons to GTO and around 20tons to LEO. Even there improved Long Mach 5B can carry only around 25 ton to LEO and around 16 tons to GTO. Significantly less than the american ones. And the Long Mach 10, which was initially thought of using in the manned moon mission is not going to be used, since it will take much more time for china to develope a super heavy lift rocket.
So how are they gonna do it ? Well they are gonna use two rockets, one will be carrying the humans, and other one will carry the lander. They are gonna use one rocket to go to the moon, and one for the return trip. Atleast thats what they are currently saying, and thats also seems likely, since long Mach 10 will take some time.
India could do a similar approach, and use two NGLV mk2s to go and come back. Its tricky but not impossible. And I believe thats what they are gonna do .
@@rickgolder6818 China's long march 10 manned reusable rocket will ready by 2027. It will able to lift 70+ tons payload in LEO and 27 tons payload in moon. China will use two long march 10 rocket for moon mission.
Long march 9 reusable rocket will be developed by 2030 . It will able to lift 150 tons payload in LEO. This rocket will use to deliver construction materials for lunar base.
China is not using long march 5 rocket for lunar manned mission. It can deliver only 25 tons payload in LEO. it is not sufficient for lunar mission. Weight of spaceship is 22+ tons.
India can't develop 20+ tons LEO rocket by 2030. India couldn't develop a rocket engine.Chinese space start ups are beating india. Next year Space pioneer is going to launch 17 tons LEO rocket.
I heard spice mission and spice craft in the beginning. Please correct me if i am wrong.
thanks to DW for its unbiased and informative reporting as always. bbc should learn from them
Looks like a paid news . Not talking about trib@l gen0c1d3 in m@nipur 😢
What she said... Stays in its magnetic field??? 3:08
I think she wanted to say the gravitational force equilibrium as L1 point has equal pull from both sun and the earth, but it is an unstable equilibrium point. hence a slight movement can cause you to get into sun's field of influence or the earth's. so you need to be very careful to stay on that point.
India don't want to be in competition to do something sake of it..every mission has a scientific purpose. Once we have the capability n learnings..it's easy to launch bigger mission or partner with nasa esa jaxa..we don't want a space station as already there are two..look to land n observe all possible outerspace with many smaller missions..
East or west., bharat (INDIA) is the best
Congratulations India my country and isro
Brah! Space is so vast, it isn't a zero sum game as someone said. Infact I suspect as the space exploration gets more and more intense with more players around the world, the lesser the differences between us on this planet gets.
charu ?
Than to Dw for the positive reporting❤
ISRO POWER-
The definitive discovery of Moon water came in 2008, when India's space agency ISRO launched the Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft to lunar orbit.
In the realm of space exploration, ISRO has accomplished an extraordinary feat by engineering intricate solutions to make space endeavors cost-effective. Notably, ISRO stands as the pioneering space agency to achieve a successful moon landing at the southern pole and a remarkable first-time voyage to Mars.
That is the power of India. Many so-called developed nations that running on Indian blood and Indian money can’t even launch a single rocket from their surface. Jai Hind,Jai Bharati
Dw now stop calling charu 😂😂😂😂and
India's next mission is Gaganyan. And in this mission we are sending our Astronaut into space. Jai Hind
Knowledge increases by sharing.
My grandmother
Bravo india you impressed us ❤
While Germany is drastically reducing its space programme.
Many Space illeterate caught here in chat.. 😂😂
India's space missions has got no element of competition. It's more to advance the interest of common Indians.
Jai ho India ❤ Proud of ISRO
Future space mission of isro
Shukrayaan( Venus mission )
Gagayaan to send India to space
Mangalyaan ( Mars orbitor and lander)
Lupex moon mission
Nisar satellite
Indian Space station by 2030
May be a manned mission to moon by 2035
All countries should come together fir humanity
A win in since is win for humanity not only for a nation
when will German land on moon's south pole? or can't they??