What Happens If You Save The Serial Killer Prostitute From Hanging In Red Dead Redemption 2? (RDR2)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 09. 2024
  • What Happens If You Save The Serial Killer Prostitute From Hanging In Red Dead Redemption 2? (RDR2)
    ►Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: www.g2a.com/r/...
    In today's Red Dead Redemption 2 video - We are going to figure out what happens if you save the Valentine Saloon Lady from getting Hanging in a SECRET outcome encounter in Red Dead Redemption 2!
    ►My Facebook:
    / mrbossftw
    ►My Snapchat:
    / mrbosssnaps
    ►My Twitter:
    #!...
    ►My Instagram:
    / jamesrosshudgins
    Hope you enjoyed this video! See you guys in the next one! ✌🏻

Komentáře • 3,3K

  • @TheEddieStilson
    @TheEddieStilson Před 3 lety +2530

    She took six closed fist punches from Arthur before she went down. That’s pretty impressive.

  • @S4ns
    @S4ns Před 5 lety +6004

    Eh, I saved her from hanging.
    I figured if she keeps killing she'll need to keep paying someone to clean up the mess.
    Job security, man.

    • @svetlanasokolov6582
      @svetlanasokolov6582 Před 5 lety +28

      BAHAHAHA

    • @jackgarcia4950
      @jackgarcia4950 Před 5 lety +41

      Smart man

    • @lucase2850
      @lucase2850 Před 5 lety +70

      I shoot the lag men and just cheat to lower my wanted level and then i puld the lever myshelf

    • @Mr99watup
      @Mr99watup Před 5 lety +21

      U help the 1st time n then she keeps doing it if U keep helping so u can keep hiding bodies

    • @High-Pie_Chop
      @High-Pie_Chop Před 5 lety +52

      For some reason I find her beautiful

  • @theohall9873
    @theohall9873 Před 3 lety +3246

    tbh I thought he was beating on her and she defended herself, didn't even cross my mind she was a serial killer

    • @butwhy.5498
      @butwhy.5498 Před 3 lety +126

      Well someone in reality would report a self defense to the sheriff that's what i thought when I seen this on a livestream.

    • @jamesgannon4514
      @jamesgannon4514 Před 3 lety +113

      No savoir faire. Unfortunately you'll learn the world is every bit as sick and twisted as anything imagined for a video game.

    • @jamesgannon4514
      @jamesgannon4514 Před 3 lety +24

      Oh and even worse

    • @crystalstar4001
      @crystalstar4001 Před 3 lety +90

      i helped her and then went back to valentine at a different time and she flagged me down for my help again with different dialogue. except i got caught the second time and couldnt stop the witness

    • @new-yj4pm
      @new-yj4pm Před 3 lety +92

      It was kinda suspicious. She didn't have any bruises.. Just blood, that was definitely not hers.

  • @malinehunter8785
    @malinehunter8785 Před 4 lety +6867

    So nobody is going to talk about how the sheriffs are sitting on each other’s laps?? No okay...I lost my shit as I saw that lol

    • @rozi1005
      @rozi1005 Před 4 lety +99

      Maline Hunter me toooooooo😂😂😂

    • @MAML_
      @MAML_ Před 4 lety +269

      Gayness 100

    • @cristynohara
      @cristynohara Před 4 lety +36

      😂😂😂😂

    • @1FLAYKO
      @1FLAYKO Před 4 lety +274

      Rockstar throwing it back to Broke back mountain🤦🏽‍♂️

    • @vsevolodpoddyh8191
      @vsevolodpoddyh8191 Před 4 lety +179

      2:55 don't thank me.

  • @Santouryu3
    @Santouryu3 Před 4 lety +2856

    Arthur Morgan: Ah, Micah. I found you a noice lady in Valentine.
    Micah: You don't say, cowpoke.
    Arthur Morgan: Here's the key, so... have fun!

  • @BetweenTheLyons
    @BetweenTheLyons Před 2 lety +115

    "All she had on her was Oleander-"
    Literally a poison.

  • @brian3379
    @brian3379 Před 4 lety +2092

    I literally did this mission, accepted the offer and thought nothing of it until now.

    • @rockyshields9122
      @rockyshields9122 Před 4 lety +129

      same this is the first I knew you could turn someone into the sheriff.

    • @jackbullandothers3322
      @jackbullandothers3322 Před 4 lety +60

      Same... man now I feel like a dumbass...

    • @Beach-bn2nj
      @Beach-bn2nj Před 4 lety +120

      @@jackbullandothers3322 I did this and didn't even think that's what happened. I thought she was telling the truth lol. I guess I'm a fucking idiot for believing her, because it was really sketchy that she immediately said to bring him to the pig pen to be eaten.

    • @smokedowa2632
      @smokedowa2632 Před 4 lety +96

      L4zorWolf the game world is generally portrayed as one where dudes are rapey asf so I assumed she was telling the truth also

    • @eaglesridge7896
      @eaglesridge7896 Před 4 lety +17

      I'll admit I did the same.
      Almost feel like instant believes are simping a bit, but eh.
      All the guys you meet in those saloons are rapey, you even have 2 women in your gang nearly get assaulted, so you feel a bit bad for the girl just wanting to not hang.
      Edit: Got the event to return and this time I just said yes then before the room i hogtied her. Whole town got angry at me.

  • @AyeLowkeyLoki
    @AyeLowkeyLoki Před 5 lety +1392

    This is pretty crazy how many options the game offers you and how different everyone can play out this random little scenario

    • @CallmeDaddy21
      @CallmeDaddy21 Před 3 lety +17

      @M Ihsan Nugraha best. game. ever.

    • @lacroixmusik9770
      @lacroixmusik9770 Před 3 lety +14

      @@CallmeDaddy21 its good, but the openworld is shit.

    • @gizmothehusky7676
      @gizmothehusky7676 Před 2 lety +2

      You know why?! Because real men don't care where other men turd! -jon

    • @betraid
      @betraid Před rokem +2

      ​@Ihsan lul what scenarios Witcher 3 gives you to choose from? it has 3 basic endings +2 for dlc, your choices has no impact on game world, the only difference is game ending "video". But still their games are decent, spent my self 230+ hours in witcher 3 and about 150 in Cyberpunk.

    • @betraid
      @betraid Před rokem

      @Ihsan I mean, between all endings there is 0 changes whole game is about deciding Ciri fate. cmon. and it don't even reflect on game world. if choose another answers in 3-4 quest is next level and masterpiece openworld rpg for u, than i feel sorry for ya pal.

  • @braedenh6858
    @braedenh6858 Před 3 lety +113

    I helped her, but I never thought about turning her in afterwards! I didn't even know reporting things to the sheriff was an option

    • @DavitChaladze123
      @DavitChaladze123 Před 2 měsíci

      Wait what? How can you report?

    • @kochengputeh3605
      @kochengputeh3605 Před měsícem +1

      Bruh i brought her to sheriff and they thought i kidnapped her

    • @lastfirst5863
      @lastfirst5863 Před měsícem

      Only scripted things can be reported, so it’s very rare to get a crime the sheriff will care about… that isn’t committed by you.
      There’s a guy in valentine who tries to drown his wife you can hogtie and take to the sheriff and he’ll accept the prisoner.

  • @Bob.Roberts
    @Bob.Roberts Před 4 lety +306

    In my game, there was another thing I tried: After declining to help her, she pulls a knife on Arthur; I then run him down through the saloon with her in pursuit. Most of the patrons back away in terror, but a couple of dudes at the bar take swings at her if she gets close to them; she takes down all of them if they don't pull their guns, then comes after you again, and if you run into the street, she gets gunned down from a couple of people near the entrance. The sheriff shows up and gives one of the default lines about how her killing finally caught up with her, etc. etc. The funny thing was, after shooting her, everyone just goes back to what they were doing, bodies in the bar just laying there and everything, lol. The important thing is, you can't allow Arthur to be struck immediately after he declines to help, otherwise she just stays in the room, knife drawn, until you leave town.

    • @Bonko78
      @Bonko78 Před 2 lety +24

      Interesting. The fact that bodies tend to be left unattended is unfortunately something we get to see a lot of (aftermath of gunfights in towns, people getting run over by the railcars in Saint Denis, etc). Strangely enough, it seems the game already has A.I mechanisms in place to fix that. After some gunfights, when Arthur is wanted by the law, you can hide in the vicinity and wait for the lawmen ot come. If they don't find you, they will instead carry dead bodies away on their horses. So it's unfortunate that Rockstar didn't have time to make that behavior more generally applicable because it's a bit of an immersion breaker to have corpses on the streets just lying around.

    • @shtembyduelsson
      @shtembyduelsson Před 2 lety +1

      That's some Oblivion stuff.

    • @carlthomaswilliamsjr.2995
      @carlthomaswilliamsjr.2995 Před 2 lety +5

      Westworld man....Westworld.

    • @josejh-eb8st
      @josejh-eb8st Před rokem +1

      I tried this and she stabbed me right as I got in the hallway then I punched her and she ran away idk where she is now

  • @ronrandquist7762
    @ronrandquist7762 Před 4 lety +700

    Just started playing RDR2 after christmas. I ran into her the 1st time and helped her, and took the money, then left. Came back into town a few nights later and she hailed me again, so I took the body to the pig pen, took the money and left again. Went up north and got the Arabian horse. then happened to be passing through Valentine again and saw a public hanging going on. I sat and listened to the speech, and thought wow, I helped her twice. I wondered about trying to save her, but they pulled the lever and that was it. So many decision points, It never pass my mind to turn her in. I didn't even know that you could report stuff to the law.

    • @StruttinStrayCat
      @StruttinStrayCat Před 4 lety +42

      Ron Randquist - Uncanny. I did the EXACT same series of events with exactly the same feelings you just described (horse included)!
      I was just about to post that you can help her twice, not turn her in, see her in the jail cell (but not get to talk to her, unfortunately) and finally see her hang, but decided to look through the comments first to see if someone else already posted it. Yours was the first I found.

    • @wes4522
      @wes4522 Před 4 lety +9

      Finally someone else!

    • @loretta2539
      @loretta2539 Před 4 lety +7

      I helped her once and she never asked again or gotten hanged for me

    • @TheEddieStilson
      @TheEddieStilson Před 3 lety +3

      So even if you help her out she still gets caught and hanged? That’s crazy.

    • @rachmatzulfiqar
      @rachmatzulfiqar Před 3 lety +7

      @@TheEddieStilson well, she's sick (she's a psychopath) she will keep killing man after man, she'll get caught eventually

  • @Jay-Niner
    @Jay-Niner Před 2 lety +377

    There's more. If you just help her, then there is at least one follow up encounter that can happen.
    She kills another guy and asks for help again but this time, the victim has a knife sticking in the middle of his back which makes the self defence excuse more unlikely. You can again choose to help her or report her.

    • @lunix3259
      @lunix3259 Před rokem +5

      I'm trying to trigger this encounter

    • @ORTyOW
      @ORTyOW Před rokem +57

      Yep, that's what happened to me. I didn't believe her this time and rejected her request to help. Then she tried to kill me and I killed her! Now, after few weeks after that, I came back to Valentine and see her beeing hanged... But I killed her before... Rockstar?... I guess it is a bug/defect

    • @condorX2
      @condorX2 Před rokem +16

      @@ORTyOW I believe her.
      Ibjust playing this game, but I really like to play her character just to see what she had to go through everyday in the prostitution business.
      Arthur can go kill a bunch of people and the serial killer never comes to mind xD
      Here is my take, if she is really a serial killer, why would she need you? She could have someone else like a homeless person for hired to take care of the corpse. There are are so many options like a loyal sidekick etc.
      😋

    • @Guilherme.A.Pereira
      @Guilherme.A.Pereira Před rokem +1

      @@ORTyOW did you shoot or just knocked down?

    • @comradeeverclear4063
      @comradeeverclear4063 Před rokem +3

      ​@@ORTyOWIf you punch her you actually just knocked her out, you didn't kill her

  • @therealmaxspeedster
    @therealmaxspeedster Před 5 lety +2061

    You could also: 1. Help her out and take her money then: 2. Turn her in and take Sherriff's money then: 3. Save her from hanging...."Win-Win" right??

    • @ihavenothingtodoinmylife5865
      @ihavenothingtodoinmylife5865 Před 5 lety +60

      Too bad that's all the reward

    • @tommyblade8093
      @tommyblade8093 Před 5 lety +36

      @@ihavenothingtodoinmylife5865 wait...

    • @tuberculosis8127
      @tuberculosis8127 Před 5 lety +16

      4 agreed and Just leave. I guess thats not good becouse she takes and attack you with knife

    • @GLJ94
      @GLJ94 Před 5 lety +88

      Actually you can run into her at least 3 times if you don't turn her in. In my game I helped her get rid of 3 bodies and got paid each time. Then while I was riding through town I saw her at the gallows. I waited and got watched her swing.

    • @statusquorules
      @statusquorules Před 5 lety +11

      @@GLJ94 I saved her twice now she's being hung... hmm never even got to turn her in

  • @pixelwanderer1962
    @pixelwanderer1962 Před 5 lety +249

    Arthur: "Thought you should know one of the working girls just put a knife in a feller upstairs at the saloon."
    Sheriff: "Not again!"
    This poor sheriff must have seen some shit

  • @bryanstrange3176
    @bryanstrange3176 Před 3 lety +74

    1:35
    "My God, you practically gutted the man."
    I don't know why but I started dying laughing when Arthur said that. Lmao

    • @iiTzLurks
      @iiTzLurks Před 2 lety

      we got you this time you bit@#

  • @angelodiberardino9498
    @angelodiberardino9498 Před 4 lety +233

    "... the sheriffs, who were sitting on eachothers laps..." lmao

  • @user-nd3ew1kp4w
    @user-nd3ew1kp4w Před 5 lety +181

    2:25 she actually has Olander Sage (which is poisonous) it helps making poison knives and arrows

  • @R.J.G469
    @R.J.G469 Před 2 lety +54

    The Sheriff's sitting in each other's lap caught me off guard. It looks too perfect 😆 🤣 like they were hanging out having a good time when you came in. I laughed so hard 🤣 😂 😭

    • @LaymanGamin
      @LaymanGamin Před 2 lety +3

      Bru!! I died when I was playin it 😂

    • @charlesfurnari7777
      @charlesfurnari7777 Před 2 lety +1

      That was funny. I guess the Sheriff got tired of Moira.

    • @sirlee8470
      @sirlee8470 Před 2 lety +1

      Nothing about that was perfect. The NPC's were literally clipping into one another. Y'all over think this shit.

    • @shakespeareangentleman
      @shakespeareangentleman Před rokem +1

      We know we just think it's funny. Take a joke 💀

    • @anti-ethniccleansing465
      @anti-ethniccleansing465 Před rokem

      @@sirlee8470
      Holy crap. I’d rather be dead than have no sense of humor like you.

  • @jroberts7387
    @jroberts7387 Před 5 lety +735

    1:59 Arthur Morgan supports equal rights...and lefts

  • @International72521
    @International72521 Před 5 lety +2614

    2:58 You caught us in a bad moment...

  • @Food24112
    @Food24112 Před 3 lety +220

    I thought that her payment was going to be sleeping with you lmao

    • @christianjohnson5379
      @christianjohnson5379 Před 3 lety +34

      And where did you get that idea? You know the creators for Red Dead are more driven to have red dead be more sexually chaste compared to Grand theft Auto where you have the option to sleep with hookers, etc. Unlike GTA, the protagonists of Red Dead seem to have a moral compass, even as wanted criminals. 😂

    • @davemarco7014
      @davemarco7014 Před 3 lety +9

      @Merch moneh

    • @nathanielgarza9198
      @nathanielgarza9198 Před 2 lety +5

      Arthur is a gentleman, he would never ask for sexual favors. He is also tough, and manly so he is not desperate

    • @RyansFine
      @RyansFine Před rokem +2

      ​​@@christianjohnson5379 tbf it makes sense for John since he's married and RD1 in particular is about him reuniting with his family. It'd be undercut if he could bang prostitutes the entire game lol. As for Arthur, I feel like it's mostly a holdover from the first game

  • @subscribetopewdiepie1258
    @subscribetopewdiepie1258 Před 5 lety +315

    “Yeah, she put a knife in the feller upstairs.”
    “Ah, Not again.”

  • @Gaia_Gaistar
    @Gaia_Gaistar Před 5 lety +2520

    9:01 is where he actually tries out saving methods.

  • @Eliteshade
    @Eliteshade Před 3 lety +39

    serial killer lady: *you gotta get me down*
    Arthur: *Pulls the lever* :)

    • @Vectellious
      @Vectellious Před 3 lety +5

      Lady: *Pull the trigger arthur!!*
      Arthur: *pulls the lever instead*
      Lady: "*Wrong levahhhhhh!*"

  • @killerb6792
    @killerb6792 Před 5 lety +96

    1:56 "what do you mean? It's too late to back out now" proceeds to be turned into a punching bag

  • @euphoriaav5308
    @euphoriaav5308 Před 5 lety +42

    Serial killer lady is crazy because she killed one dude but main character kills hundreds out of boredom and she's the crazy one 😂

  • @teddieblue6723
    @teddieblue6723 Před 3 lety +24

    The idea that she pinpointed the blame in him while having no physical evidence on her made me lol so hard. She fr tried

  • @eSKAone-
    @eSKAone- Před 4 lety +591

    This game has probably the deepest roleplaying mechanics of them all, with all the different interaction trees.

    • @nokachi3339
      @nokachi3339 Před 3 lety +11

      Yeah no, not even close😂

    • @addictedtoRS
      @addictedtoRS Před 3 lety +1

      @@nokachi3339 What does it better?

    • @nokachi3339
      @nokachi3339 Před 3 lety +5

      @@addictedtoRS New Vegas comes to mind

    • @addictedtoRS
      @addictedtoRS Před 3 lety +24

      @@nokachi3339 Uhhh, no, not really. NV doesn't have the random encounters with like 4 different outcomes to each one, but it does give you more than one option to beat most quests. NV was indeed phenomenal for it's day, but doesn't even come anywhere close to RDR2 in terms of roleplay. I've beaten NV like 15 times if not more, one of my favourites of all time. But you're wrong. You have significantly more freedom to do what you like in RDR2, and you play as a character you really feel emotional for, doing what you think is best to fit the narrative of his personality and traits, AKA roleplay. NV you're kinda just a blank canvas, no personality, you do what you do cause there's really nothing stopping you from just killing everything that you can see. There are a few quests with a few different outcomes, and you can kill just about anything at any time. That's where the roleplay ends for NV.

    • @nokachi3339
      @nokachi3339 Před 3 lety +11

      @@addictedtoRS yeah... you role play the character in NV where in RDR2 you get a personality given to you. In NV you make the personality, the character
      Ya know... you role play

  • @_sarcasticat_2126
    @_sarcasticat_2126 Před 3 lety +90

    Sheriffs: in an incredibly compromising position
    ya boi: just busts through the door
    Sheriffs: *Well hey there*

  • @yeppe9855
    @yeppe9855 Před 2 lety +7

    i dont understand how you see robbing and turning in a serial killer as "the most dishonorable thing you can do"

  • @imfineijustneedspaceimnoth3178

    2:02 WhOs tAlKiN nOw HuH

  • @darth_dan8886
    @darth_dan8886 Před 5 lety +1386

    So you basically triple-crossed the lady...

    • @dwhite8005
      @dwhite8005 Před 5 lety +1

      @Christopher Villanueva What do you mean?

    • @dylanpaul1212
      @dylanpaul1212 Před 4 lety +3

      Christopher Villanueva 🤣🤣😭😭

    • @evexec07
      @evexec07 Před 4 lety +14

      Quadruple-crossing if you kill her as she runs.

    • @Poet482
      @Poet482 Před 4 lety +4

      The Revolver Ocelot of Red Dead.

    • @Dz_Izu
      @Dz_Izu Před 4 lety +1

      Yep

  • @thisisanerror
    @thisisanerror Před 2 lety +7

    im glad at least the sheriff was able to find true love

  • @gavinsfriend5272
    @gavinsfriend5272 Před 5 lety +589

    Listen, have you seen...I'm looking for my friend Gavin?

    • @dingogotyababy8879
      @dingogotyababy8879 Před 4 lety +12

      Uh yep mate. Last seen around Rhodes

    • @geico47
      @geico47 Před 4 lety +10

      You again I don’t know go find him your self

    • @finnley905
      @finnley905 Před 4 lety +3

      You have a name

    • @finnley905
      @finnley905 Před 4 lety +13

      Kill the guy loot him and you get a letter but he respawns anyway

    • @finnley905
      @finnley905 Před 4 lety +1

      The letter tells you his name

  • @jroberts7387
    @jroberts7387 Před 5 lety +153

    4:56 "give me another drink before I shit right here in the bar" hahaha

    • @Tiger_Trades21
      @Tiger_Trades21 Před 5 lety +3

      LoL... some funny shit right there.

    • @TWtribbles
      @TWtribbles Před 5 lety +3

      I fucking love this game

    • @thestwinner680
      @thestwinner680 Před 5 lety

      @@Tiger_Trades21 Funny Shit is when you're sitting on the john and it just starts going _SIDEWAYS_ - That's some *Funny Shit* right there!...

    • @diverdcwn
      @diverdcwn Před 5 lety

      'Cause that's how it was back in the day, you know?

    • @snake.3416
      @snake.3416 Před 5 lety +1

      5:20 "Because real men don't care where other men turd"😂

  • @MattII33
    @MattII33 Před 2 lety +56

    Yet another scenario in this game I had no idea about. I always just assumed she was telling the truth. It's funny because I've actually had 2 encounters with her in Valentine where she killed a man both times and I never thought about her actually being a serial killer.

  • @T0MT0M77
    @T0MT0M77 Před 5 lety +726

    She will run away. Just normal things 🤦🏻‍♂️
    Saved you 10min :)

  • @doughtysibs9538
    @doughtysibs9538 Před 5 lety +159

    When I tried to turn this girl into the law she started screaming help and I got wanted for kidnapping

    • @tordropzz2828
      @tordropzz2828 Před 3 lety +61

      Just like real life!!

    • @lukeallen7304
      @lukeallen7304 Před 3 lety +9

      That happened to me and I just ran into the sheriffs office

    • @thelonesurvivor3955
      @thelonesurvivor3955 Před 3 lety +5

      Yep,just like a woman lol.

    • @obanos9835
      @obanos9835 Před 3 lety

      İ watched this mission before my youtuber didnt become wanted Imao

  • @alexandriadusek7807
    @alexandriadusek7807 Před 3 lety +14

    Lol i never even thought about her being a serial killer and helped her hide the body, then went on about my bad self lmaooo

  • @WeDontHaveCookies
    @WeDontHaveCookies Před 4 lety +22

    She kills a second guy also and asks you to dispose of the body. When you come back to get the money from her Arthur tells her that she should probably find a new line of work and she says that this life is all that she knows.

  • @SourPatchPuss
    @SourPatchPuss Před 4 lety +37

    I literally laughed out loud at the guy sitting on the sheriffs lap 😂

  • @blizzardfun5765
    @blizzardfun5765 Před 2 lety +5

    The voice actor did a magnificent job 😆
    You could here the strain and anger in her voice.
    When she tries manipulate you her voice tone greatly changed as well

  • @daniyel
    @daniyel Před 5 lety +473

    James Franco: "First Time?"

  • @GeneralG1810
    @GeneralG1810 Před 4 lety +218

    Seriously the amount of detail they put into this game is phenomenal

    • @ayumuchan3541
      @ayumuchan3541 Před rokem +4

      like how the two lawmen were being gay and proud with each other

    • @KowalDWR
      @KowalDWR Před rokem +7

      @@ayumuchan3541 that's most realistic part. Cops are gay

    • @comradeeverclear4063
      @comradeeverclear4063 Před rokem +3

      ​@@KowalDWRSounds like self projection bud

    • @justMrAxe
      @justMrAxe Před 8 měsíci

      @@comradeeverclear4063problem?

    • @vatocat4953
      @vatocat4953 Před 7 měsíci

      @@justMrAxe yeah the problem is he's a cop, or gay. both?

  • @drdapplesnappler8016
    @drdapplesnappler8016 Před 3 lety +7

    2:00 Arthur hit that girl with the 1 2 3 wombo combo then hit that FALCON PUNCH

  • @havok5021
    @havok5021 Před 5 lety +283

    9:23 a bunch of lawmen (2 lawmen)

  • @plain_simple_garak
    @plain_simple_garak Před 4 lety +105

    4:56 has me rolling because of the drunk in the background pontificating about how they just shit inside in the good old days.
    "Real men don't care where other men turd!" I beg to differ, sir

    • @claudiamiller5895
      @claudiamiller5895 Před 3 lety +4

      I don’t know if you ever played Charles’ missions but he’s hilarious because you go near a bar and he goes “oh I can’t go in there I shit on his bar!!!” And Arthur goes “you shit ON the bar?” And Charles says something like “yes! I had to go and I was drunk!”

    • @jrsixowfour8674
      @jrsixowfour8674 Před 3 lety +1

      @@claudiamiller5895 Charles Chatenay pronounced shat-ah-nay

  • @1398go
    @1398go Před rokem +4

    The two sheriffs were sitting on each other's laps. 😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @creeperlordmotions5337
    @creeperlordmotions5337 Před 4 lety +183

    "real men don't care where other men turd!"

    • @egpmh2891
      @egpmh2891 Před 4 lety +16

      “And if you do you aren’t a man at all”

    • @Noahjames27
      @Noahjames27 Před 3 lety +2

      whats with that guy I got beef with him i fight him any time I can

    • @robtz759
      @robtz759 Před 3 lety

      @@Noahjames27 "Back in the day, we eat turd"

    • @travisbaker7547
      @travisbaker7547 Před 3 lety +1

      I knowww I literally laughed out loud like people started staring 😆 ...I read it scrolling down as it was happening damn lol that happens a lot

  • @OptimusGnarkill
    @OptimusGnarkill Před 5 lety +60

    “Real men don’t care where other men turd.” 😂😂

  • @chasepalagi7675
    @chasepalagi7675 Před 2 lety +12

    3:04 looks like the Valentine sherriff has more than one secret!

  • @backupschmliff1156
    @backupschmliff1156 Před 5 lety +91

    I didn’t know she was a serial killer, I just thought that he was actually beating her just like in “Polite Society, Valentine Style” when the drunk beats Karen.

  • @M00ly
    @M00ly Před 5 lety +171

    She asked me for help 2 times and I covered up her crimes. Then suddenly I found her in jail

    • @phildpain
      @phildpain Před 4 lety +9

      Same here. I then saw her about to be hanged and saved her. Followed her for awhile then tied her up and put her on the railroad track.

    • @rafabuda0
      @rafabuda0 Před 4 lety +2

      third time's the charm I guess

  • @wildoutlawz6898
    @wildoutlawz6898 Před 3 lety +5

    When You decide to dispose the body and bring the lady to the sherrif office
    "I'm playing both sides, so that I always come out on top"

  • @XxShadowGTxX
    @XxShadowGTxX Před 4 lety +14

    "It's too late to back out now!!"
    *Soulfully beats that ass*

  • @Deryan-tv2tt
    @Deryan-tv2tt Před 4 lety +14

    The way the sherif threw home girl on the floor to hog tie her, is the same movement from the teachers and stuff in Bully when they take you to the Principals office. Haha

  • @philoopnorth4901
    @philoopnorth4901 Před 3 lety +8

    In my current playthrough, I helped her out twice, didn't involve the sheriff at all, and still came across her execution later.
    I shot the rope then ran like buggery to get out of a town full of pissed off lawmen, while she buggered off in another direction with the noose around her neck.

    • @crimsonmask3819
      @crimsonmask3819 Před 10 měsíci

      That's my default run. Was hoping there would be more of her, but no...

  • @Pawtism
    @Pawtism Před 5 lety +411

    I double crossed her (took her money to get rid of the body, turned her into the law, although i waited in the office until they brought her back, and got the reward). BTW, I'd argue it's the most honorable solution, not the least. I did the job she paid me for, and I reported a crime I witnessed (what happened between her and the sheriff is her problem).

    • @dr.bright6272
      @dr.bright6272 Před 5 lety +2

      I want to know what happens if you refuse to help her, hog tie her and bring her to the sheriff

    • @kadielarson5708
      @kadielarson5708 Před 5 lety +4

      Jack of Knives the sheriff gives you money for turning her in

    • @ewwpoorpeople5684
      @ewwpoorpeople5684 Před 5 lety +2

      Doubt

    • @Pawtism
      @Pawtism Před 5 lety +21

      @Steven Yi I swore no loyalty to either the murderous hooker, nor the sheriff. I didn't tell her I wouldn't turn her in, just that I would help get rid of the body (which I did, and was paid for).

    • @Pawtism
      @Pawtism Před 5 lety +24

      @Steven Yi She should have paid me to keep quiet instead of to move the body. :p

  • @Taipan108
    @Taipan108 Před 5 lety +332

    I’ve helped her out twice and I didn’t even realise she’s a serial killer until now that I’ve watched your video. I’m so naïve!

    • @just4games985
      @just4games985 Před 5 lety +28

      Viracocha Maybe you're just too trusting.
      I am too. Didn't think about till Arthur muttered as he left. Going to turn her in next time.

    • @challah_1919
      @challah_1919 Před 5 lety +59

      i am the same as you, i legit thought she was just being attacked by people and on the second time I got bad honor and i got confused

    • @MelonBoy17
      @MelonBoy17 Před 5 lety +6

      She framed me

    • @jongriffin6004
      @jongriffin6004 Před 5 lety +7

      I helped her, then someone saw me dumping the body and before I could get back to her, I became “wanted” and the option of returning to her was gone. Will the opportunity come again for me to replay this or am I screwed?

    • @pooseesucker9895
      @pooseesucker9895 Před 5 lety +2

      You're 12

  • @prakharmishra3997
    @prakharmishra3997 Před 2 lety +5

    The way he beat her up after she drew the knife was absolutely hilarious

  • @ofearghailthefearless6481
    @ofearghailthefearless6481 Před 5 lety +13

    Least honorable?! Dishonorable my ass! If I was put in this situation, I would’ve done the same thing

  • @rlharveson
    @rlharveson Před 5 lety +15

    I just discovered one more!
    Turns out if you let her go twice, then go to the deputy, you'll see her in jail
    I guess either way, she'll always be caught in the end

  • @joeking5917
    @joeking5917 Před 3 lety +45

    I’m pretty sure there’s also an option to bring the body directly to the sheriff and he’ll say something like “I hope you’ve got a good excuse for having that body”

  • @Dekorume
    @Dekorume Před 4 lety +34

    Encountered her, dumped the dude's body, got paid and went on my merry way.

  • @strongocho
    @strongocho Před 5 lety +13

    2:58 Gets pretty lonely without Moira around...

  • @Bobz_McGee
    @Bobz_McGee Před 2 lety +12

    I also helped her out both times. I believed her since I didn’t really get any indication that she was lying. Couldn’t take the money the second time because I got caught disposing of the body. I still think it’s pretty vague even after the Sheriff’s dialogue whether she was just a crazy murderer. I think it’s at the very least too ambiguous to call her a “serial killer”. By the way, you don’t need cheats to save her. I managed to do it by shooting the rope from far away, and then I had to book it on foot and steal one of the lawmens’ horses because mine got spooked and ran away once they started shooting at me. It was INTENSE!

  • @mr.potatoesgamesandrandomn5534

    The most dishonorable thing I have ever done was subscribing to you

  • @OmniEarthChild
    @OmniEarthChild Před 5 lety +71

    I helped her and dumped the body... Got money.
    After I dumped the body I lingered. The hog farm couple will be doing some dominatrix stuff and if you look you'll get a bad cowboy lol. It pretty funny

  • @blackmahon9232
    @blackmahon9232 Před 2 lety +1

    Them sheriff doing some broke back mountain stuff 😂

  • @freeguy2418
    @freeguy2418 Před rokem +4

    If you help and leave for first time, she will ask for the 2nd time and this time you can directly hogtie her and you can hand her over to the sheriff which is honorable in my case.

  • @christopherserrano1520
    @christopherserrano1520 Před 2 lety +4

    I helped her out and then came back later and she’d done it again and asked for my help a second time 🤣

  • @Kiera579
    @Kiera579 Před 2 lety +4

    I helped her out because i had no idea she was a serial killer and genuinely believed her story

  • @udrubudrub
    @udrubudrub Před 2 lety +4

    Fun fact: When your at the saloon with lenny entering the same room you can see some action

  • @siddharth846
    @siddharth846 Před 3 lety +9

    Man, rdr2 is a masterpiece, can't state it enough! On the other hand look at cyberpunk 2077.

    • @anoshs
      @anoshs Před 3 lety +2

      They’re both superb games. The bugs for both were horrible. Completely unplayable on PC. I’m hoping the release more content for Cyberpunk but I honestly can’t get enough of RDR2.

    • @siddharth846
      @siddharth846 Před 3 lety +1

      @@anoshs played rdr2 on ps4 no issues except few frame drops and minor bugs, meanwhile they are still trying to fix cyberpunk 2077, and from the looks of its state i think it'll never be playable (stable 30fps) on base last gen consoles. I heard the game has good story but they scammed so many people. I'll play it but wait atleast 1 year, anyways ps5 doesn't seem to be available here

  • @stinw.9226
    @stinw.9226 Před 2 lety +35

    I helped her twice (might have actually been three times??), was pretty suspicious by the second one already but knowing that time and how women were treated it seemed like a fair case. HOWEVER, even after helping a few times I rode by valentine once and she was being hanged for murder sooo..

  • @Animations_Master
    @Animations_Master Před 5 lety +370

    11:45 best part of the video

    • @grzk
      @grzk Před 5 lety +5

      Yup.

    • @noobmaster-wg7bm
      @noobmaster-wg7bm Před 5 lety +1

      Yup

    • @ballndie9688
      @ballndie9688 Před 5 lety +1

      Hands down

    • @lonewolf-4lfe399
      @lonewolf-4lfe399 Před 5 lety +19

      Actually the best part is you haters leaving this channel

    • @slavpepe142
      @slavpepe142 Před 5 lety +9

      LONEWOLF -4LFE holy lenin, people like you make me cringe, even saying “haters” make me want to die.

  • @foto19881
    @foto19881 Před 4 lety +10

    I helped her once, and the second time she begged me for help, I said no and she tried to stab me. Then I hogtied her and brought her to the sheriff and got arrested for kidnapping -.-"

    • @mcmax571
      @mcmax571 Před 4 lety

      I helped her both times and if I knew that you could turn her in for an award I would've. I did see her hang and did nothing because I was worried that she would name me as an accomplice.

  • @consume_vegetables
    @consume_vegetables Před 3 lety +4

    When she suggests dumping the body in the pigpen, I knew that was red flag. "This is not her first rodeo".

    • @oldwaterranch
      @oldwaterranch Před 3 lety

      Actually it’s pretty well known that hogs/pigs eat anything and everything. At least amongst people familiar with livestock. (Given the time period, it didn’t strike me as odd when I encountered her. Mainly because it was probably more common knowledge then. Then again I only encountered her once. Would’ve been suspicious had it happened twice and she asked for help again. Would’ve been like “... hold up.” 👀)

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93 Před 3 lety

      It's a Deadwood reference

  • @baggszilla
    @baggszilla Před 5 lety +289

    Why do you get bad honor if you report her to the sheriffs?

    • @sm0keyMcP0t420
      @sm0keyMcP0t420 Před 5 lety +43

      @@jonroth123 ahh nice. my game was bugged i guess (its normal for RDR2) because the second time she gave me the same excuse i tried to turn her in and the entire town started trying to murder me, lol. so many of these side missions are broken.

    • @obuttslamyomama8438
      @obuttslamyomama8438 Před 5 lety +38

      Robert Baggs cause you a snitch

    • @NXS1FY
      @NXS1FY Před 5 lety +45

      If you help her then double cross her you get dishonor. If you refuse and carry her to the sheriff you get honor. It's the double cross which is dishonorable. The right course of action is to turn her in and let her hang as she according to the Sheriff has killed multiple people making her a serial killer praying on male patrons at the saloon. People don't believe everything you hear. Just because she tells you it was self defence doesn't mean the story is true. She admits her guilt when you take her in and threatens.

    • @easproductions1305
      @easproductions1305 Před 5 lety +18

      Jonathon Roth, I reported her to the police and got good honor, but if you help her then report her you get bad honor. It’s because double crossing people is considered dishonorable in the game. And the man she killed didn’t harm her...
      She killed a lot of men and is known as the *Lady of the Night* that has been reported killing men.

    • @dr.bright6272
      @dr.bright6272 Před 5 lety +2

      Because you killed her

  • @banginurmomsince94
    @banginurmomsince94 Před 4 lety +6

    If you help her once, you can help her at least one more time after. Idk if there are more than two chances, but i’ve helped her twice for sure. My thinking was the men of this time were animals so it wasn’t unlikely that more than one of em got too rough with her and she had to defend herself. I had no idea you could even turn her in.

  • @teskio
    @teskio Před 3 lety +2

    Sherrifs can never have no assplay without someone interruptin’

  • @jackgarcia4950
    @jackgarcia4950 Před 5 lety +5

    The conversation the drunk guy was having while the girl was cleaning the bed 😂😂

  • @cmobluz7142
    @cmobluz7142 Před 5 lety +5

    I didn't know about this encounter but when I was just playing yesterday I was in Valentine by a window that two guys are watching the lady and dude smoking something and tripping out. And you get bad karma for looking

  • @MOBSSTA
    @MOBSSTA Před 3 lety +4

    That's first time I see Arthur become one of the reporters of crime and not otherwise lol

  • @TrevorT6
    @TrevorT6 Před 5 lety +65

    I’m surprised you didn’t talk about the other encounters you can have with her if you help her

    • @FiiSKiiS
      @FiiSKiiS Před 5 lety +12

      My bet is he doesn't know about them.

    • @DeezCheez69
      @DeezCheez69 Před 5 lety +2

      What are they

    • @almaz4858
      @almaz4858 Před 5 lety +1

      Yknow like the hehe boiii encounter

    • @debunkingstupidity1335
      @debunkingstupidity1335 Před 5 lety +13

      Yeah you also don’t need to turn her in to see her hang, I never turned her in and still had the option to save her at the gallows

    • @mattkoozman3882
      @mattkoozman3882 Před 5 lety +3

      What other encounters seriously I must have missed them as well? Wanted to see if we could come to and “arrangement” to not report her. lmao.

  • @Machthacken
    @Machthacken Před 5 lety +40

    Did you know when you do the first mission in chapter three with Dutch and you decide to go fishing Dutch talks about his mother and that she was buried in blackwater

    • @doubledroptinehunter
      @doubledroptinehunter Před 5 lety +12

      Her gravestone is actually there in the Blackwater cemetary.

    • @IRAZELAST
      @IRAZELAST Před 5 lety +1

      Machthacken2004 near the church. Am I right?

  • @jordanowen9079
    @jordanowen9079 Před 2 lety +4

    I love how Arthur's attitude is he walked up the stairs so he might as well be an accomplice to murder.
    You know because he walked up the stairs already 🤣😅.
    Arthur just decided way too quickly

  • @master4gameplays
    @master4gameplays Před 4 lety +19

    1:59 When you come home back from work and your wife hasn't made dinner

  • @airfishboy5386
    @airfishboy5386 Před 4 lety +10

    In my play through I helped her 3 different times. Spoiler she ends up getting caught with or without your intervention. Saw a random event at the gallows... I’m like oh shit, crazy stabby lady, is that you! Had to help her escape! Haha

  • @demonslfia7597
    @demonslfia7597 Před 3 lety +1

    1:59 she folded!🤣🤣

  • @davidsuarez1285
    @davidsuarez1285 Před 4 lety +4

    Holy shit that final punch was brutal 😲

  • @123bigred
    @123bigred Před 5 lety +8

    One of my favorite side mission chance encounters. I was not expecting her to pull a knife if you declined. Great find

  • @FALL3NW0RLD
    @FALL3NW0RLD Před 2 lety +1

    Your “most dishonourable route” is what I found to be the best outcome

  • @iamsnique
    @iamsnique Před 5 lety +8

    1:58 I literally thought I was watching world star fights! 🤣

  • @dandiamaldan
    @dandiamaldan Před 4 lety +28

    That background discussion about man's turd lmfao

  • @Moetastic
    @Moetastic Před 8 měsíci +1

    Moral of the story, anyone asking you to dispose of a body is highly suspicious and shouldn't be automatically regardless of whats between their legs.

  • @alejandrobernal6180
    @alejandrobernal6180 Před 5 lety +8

    I helped her out twice, left Valentine for a day or so, came back and she was getting hanged...

  • @PEPEMUNOZ2003
    @PEPEMUNOZ2003 Před 5 lety +4

    The most dishonorable thing to do
    Bringing a black widow to the sheriff's office

  • @UitdenOosterhout
    @UitdenOosterhout Před 3 lety +2

    If you help her dispose of the body and you don’t report it to the sheriff, she will still be hanged after a few days when you helped her. So I guess she kept killing people after you helped her dispose of the body.

  • @joelington7376
    @joelington7376 Před 5 lety +9

    damnnnn homie gave her the 6 peiece chicken combo extra crispy😂👊🏼👊🏼

    • @rat229
      @rat229 Před 2 lety

      Gave her a 6 peice with 2 estra biscuits and then Chris Brown pulls up in his car with Rihanna with a black eye in the passenger seat