What If Qui Gon Jinn Trained Anakin Skywalker? Star Wars Theory

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 21. 10. 2016
  • Took me all night but here it is! Don't forget to stay until the end, I have a special question for you.
    What if darth maul trained anakin skywalker? - • What If Darth Maul Tra...
    What if Padme survived? - • What If Padme Survived...
    Darth Vader VS Snoke / Plagueis - • DARTH VADER VS SNOKE/P...
    Facebook Page - / starwarstheorytoos
    In alliance with - www.starwarsnewsclub.com

Komentáře • 8K

  • @StarWarsTheory
    @StarWarsTheory  Před 7 lety +8654

    Hey guys, I'm working to get this video in full animation, would you like that?

    • @humanrightsviolation7987
      @humanrightsviolation7987 Před 7 lety +160

      Uh duh! Yes please!

    • @brendanmercer2338
      @brendanmercer2338 Před 7 lety +85

      Star Wars Theory yes that would be cool

    • @cmcbiz07
      @cmcbiz07 Před 7 lety +43

      Star Wars Theory yes please

    • @teamblisk3255
      @teamblisk3255 Před 7 lety +20

      Star Wars Theory I loved it obi wan should kill que Gon in the battle

    • @teamblisk3255
      @teamblisk3255 Před 7 lety +22

      then obi wan and anikan fight obi wan Tris to kill him but mace and Yoda block with sabers then palpitine kills Yoda and mace kills maul then obi wan kills palpitine with redemption and saves mace and ani

  • @ciberkid22
    @ciberkid22 Před 4 lety +4851

    Alternate title: "What if Qui Gon Jinn wasn't Qui Gone"

  • @Yohanan552
    @Yohanan552 Před 4 lety +6984

    "what if Yoda became an alcoholic."

    • @jackofalltrades8412
      @jackofalltrades8412 Před 4 lety +86

      Lol

    • @rejvaik00
      @rejvaik00 Před 4 lety +823

      "Hungover I am, sloshed I was"

    • @Yohanan552
      @Yohanan552 Před 4 lety +399

      @@rejvaik00 feel my face, I can't

    • @StateOfMind63
      @StateOfMind63 Před 4 lety +350

      Much hammered I feel. Vomit.. I must.

    • @Tom-re6zo
      @Tom-re6zo Před 4 lety +239

      Why do you think he talks weird? It's because he's hammered at all times. probably would have stomped palpatine if he sober.

  • @themanbeet8647
    @themanbeet8647 Před 4 lety +1418

    So basically what your saying is that this whole thing would have never happened if it just weren’t for the damn Naboo doors

    • @Andragil717
      @Andragil717 Před 3 lety +145

      Never really understood why they open and close randomly without any interaction other then plot convenience. It's just feels stupid.

    • @aaronalbert5259
      @aaronalbert5259 Před 3 lety +37

      @@Andragil717 motion sensors maybe.

    • @DerHammerSpricht
      @DerHammerSpricht Před 3 lety +68

      That's why it was called Duel of the FATES

    • @mattvolonte9026
      @mattvolonte9026 Před 3 lety +124

      @@DerHammerSpricht The Duel of the GATES

    • @immortalfrieza
      @immortalfrieza Před 2 lety +20

      Or if Qui-Gon had backed away or held back to allow Obi-Wan to catch up.

  • @Josh-lw2uz
    @Josh-lw2uz Před 4 lety +1746

    Council: You must train a padawan before becoming a knight and then a master
    Obi: No worries
    Council: So here is the chosen one
    Obi: WAIT WHA...

    • @vladashlyavas500
      @vladashlyavas500 Před 3 lety +48

      LOL. What really happened when he first met Anakin. :)

    • @patrickwannafightaboutit6338
      @patrickwannafightaboutit6338 Před 3 lety +32

      Chosen One V.S Obi - WON

    • @yunggunz3432
      @yunggunz3432 Před 2 lety +32

      A terrible decision that was

    • @yunggunz3432
      @yunggunz3432 Před 2 lety +28

      trained a murderer he did

    • @crismon0726
      @crismon0726 Před 5 měsíci

      Yoda: train a padawan you must before becomingjedi knight or master you will
      Obi wan: do not worry master yoda
      Yoda: proud of you i am now train the Chosen One you will
      Obi Wan: wait you are joking right?
      Yoda: do not worry you said now train him you will
      Obi Wan: i am ok with training someone while not being a padawan but i cant train the chosen one
      Yoda: troubling this is Qui Gons last wish being fulfilled it will not
      Obi Wan: wha- i can fulfill his dying wish i will show you
      Yoda mind: getting Obi Wan to train the boy i did this will come back to bite me in the future it will not
      The Plot: he was wrong

  • @matthiasmccormack3213
    @matthiasmccormack3213 Před 6 lety +16371

    I disagree, Obi-Wan was ready to train A Padawan, he just wasn't ready to train THAT Padawan

    • @causti9744
      @causti9744 Před 5 lety +2515

      I think Qui Gon was the only who was capable of training Anakin considering how the council took care of him.

    • @causti9744
      @causti9744 Před 5 lety +962

      When i look at the way Yoda advised Anakin when he was afraid about Padmes life, i don't think so. I see why Yoda is seen as wise, well i think many of the stuff he said is bullshit and imo he was a huge part in Anakin turning to the dark side. After the Jedi purge and after his death, he got better though.

    • @deyash4602
      @deyash4602 Před 5 lety +31

      😂

    • @yaldabaoth2507
      @yaldabaoth2507 Před 5 lety +221

      Causti I agree with you, Yoda was bullshit

    • @K.C.-Games
      @K.C.-Games Před 5 lety +309

      Obi wan is like the older brother

  • @akkshaysharrma9991
    @akkshaysharrma9991 Před 4 lety +4187

    Imagine Obi Wan laying down injured and maul just falls next to him in 2 pieces, lmao

    • @Rain-tv7oh
      @Rain-tv7oh Před 4 lety +523

      "Hello there"

    • @godji9396
      @godji9396 Před 4 lety +294

      Through the power of the *gay sex* Obi wan was turned to the dark side

    • @gentleman7407
      @gentleman7407 Před 4 lety +76

      Viktor Angelov Incarnated r/cursedcomments

    • @godji9396
      @godji9396 Před 4 lety +12

      @@gentleman7407

    • @godji9396
      @godji9396 Před 4 lety +6

      @@popeyethegrump1952 shut it

  • @jedipatriot3256
    @jedipatriot3256 Před 3 lety +1056

    Darth Maul: *falls down reactor core and lands text to Obi Wan*
    Obi Wan: “hello there”

    • @darksiderider1233
      @darksiderider1233 Před 3 lety +54

      The real question is... what's at the bottom of these reactor cores? We deserve to know what everyone always safely lands on down there lol

    • @AppGuy
      @AppGuy Před 2 lety +2

      @@darksiderider1233 I wanna know too!!!

    • @darksiderider1233
      @darksiderider1233 Před 2 lety +2

      @@AppGuy I had a feeling I wasn't the only one wanting to know

    • @lawenda2099
      @lawenda2099 Před 2 lety +9

      @@darksiderider1233 I'm pretty sure we saw where Maul landed in one of the comics or something, basically just an empty room from what I remember. I think he survived because it was like the chutes in Empire, curved n' shit.

    • @knavecapricorn1537
      @knavecapricorn1537 Před 2 lety +13

      *Puts Maul back together like a lego figure*

  • @uscman
    @uscman Před 3 lety +702

    Anakin was rebellious under the training of Obi-Wan, but Anakin would be respectful as heck under Qui-Gon and they’d have a father-son like relationship. Unlike Anakin and Obi-Wan’s brotherly relationship.

    • @williamwest9204
      @williamwest9204 Před rokem +36

      Hed still have some of his tendencies as he got older but yeah hed be respectful.
      Hed also have more control and a better ability to harness his emotions and feelings with quigons non typical and more old school force beliefs.

    • @TheUnseenPath
      @TheUnseenPath Před rokem +5

      He was a rebellious student regardless the Jedi tried but he just fought them for everything.

    • @rai4119
      @rai4119 Před rokem +5

      didnt anakin say he saw obi-wan as a father before, though? i think the main difference is that under qui-gon, that wouldnt have been rebuffed

    • @Blue_Eyed_Chippewa
      @Blue_Eyed_Chippewa Před rokem +1

      @Rai I think you are right. Obi-Wan was what 14 years older than Anakin? I feel like Anakin saw Obi-Wan as a father but they had a relationship more akin to a brother. Brothers compete. They try to outdo one another. And one thing a younger brother hates is for his brother to be his boss. Especially as they get older. I feel like they had the classic "I can do what I want to my brother but no one else can" relationship. Owing to that Had Palpatine killed Obi-Wan I feel like Anakin kills Palpatine in vengeance. But that's just my fan theory. Obviously Anakin didn't accept Obi-Wans as a father. You are right there.

    • @roronoalaw7772
      @roronoalaw7772 Před rokem

      He still respected Obi-Wan but was rebellious by nature

  • @bryanegelhoffsanimationtec257
    @bryanegelhoffsanimationtec257 Před 5 lety +5617

    I still love Obi Wan, but to think we can all agree that Qui Gon would have been a better teacher for Anakin.

    • @qtap7181
      @qtap7181 Před 5 lety +125

      Mabye. I dont think Anakin would be as good at lightsaber combat though. I could be wrong though.

    • @ajl9772
      @ajl9772 Před 5 lety +229

      Obi Wan never gets enough credit. He balanced Anakin out. Despite their conflicts the two ended up being very close and being best friends. While I think Anakin may have told Qui Gon about Padme, I doubt it changes anything. Qui Gon's philosophy seemed to be that the ends justify the means. I think this would only give Anakin the idea that his desire to save Padme was completely justified despite using the dark side to do it. After all once he saw Mace Windu basically say this about killing Palpatine, it pretty much made Anakin flip. I think Qui Gon teaching Anakin this philosophy would only have given Anakin the idea to look to the darkside even sooner.

    • @antasmathebatking2386
      @antasmathebatking2386 Před 5 lety +8

      Agreed, but I think my lightsaber color vould be purple, perfect for me, now an anti-hero.

    • @JayGenez
      @JayGenez Před 5 lety +12

      Tough pill to swallow. I love Obi too, but you're right lol.

    • @demonlordomegaacepilot7090
      @demonlordomegaacepilot7090 Před 5 lety +59

      No qui gon was the teacher to train anakin because qui gon was as wise as Yoda. And i would say quigon was close to a true jedi in the force more than anything.

  • @voidvacancy6948
    @voidvacancy6948 Před 4 lety +5375

    I can just imagine Darth Maul and Obi wan lying at the bottom of the shaft and being like
    Darth Maul: Hey
    Obi wan: wasup
    Darth maul: wanna join the dark side
    Obi wan: sure I got nothing else to do on Fridays

    • @KangarooFam
      @KangarooFam Před 4 lety +420

      Maul: but first, lemme get some robot legs

    • @fionnmullally926
      @fionnmullally926 Před 4 lety +339

      Darth maul hey
      Obi wan hello there

    • @voidvacancy6948
      @voidvacancy6948 Před 4 lety +73

      Filthy Casual
      Yes until Anakin ruins it

    • @FilthyCasualty
      @FilthyCasualty Před 4 lety +45

      Riley Richards
      Anakin joins.

    • @fionnmullally926
      @fionnmullally926 Před 4 lety +32

      U where the choosen wan anakin it's siad u would destroy the sith not join in

  • @FunkyYoyo420
    @FunkyYoyo420 Před 4 lety +277

    i bet sith obi-wan would still be going like: hello there.

  • @ShadowSearcher31
    @ShadowSearcher31 Před 3 lety +305

    Obi-wan: even though my master is gravely injured I must use Witt and smarts to overcome this foe
    Qui-gon: I’m gonna clock him in the jaw

  • @generalkenobi3620
    @generalkenobi3620 Před 4 lety +1972

    I was ready. He still destroyed the emperor in the end.

    • @generalkenobi3620
      @generalkenobi3620 Před 4 lety +74

      Obi-Wan Kenobi Ok, not gonna argue.

    • @dylan__nayld8595
      @dylan__nayld8595 Před 4 lety +73

      Obi-Wan Kenobi My nigga next time you go on calling someone a fatass try putting it in one sentence.

    • @generalkenobi3620
      @generalkenobi3620 Před 4 lety +54

      Kylo Ren Well, I’m a force ghost now, but I am jealous of how Anakin gets to go back to his prequel form.

    • @AshleyBurgoyne
      @AshleyBurgoyne Před 4 lety +3

      @@lepau2702 no your not

    • @AshleyBurgoyne
      @AshleyBurgoyne Před 4 lety +3

      @@lepau2702 no you weren't

  • @Chriscraft-ug3sz
    @Chriscraft-ug3sz Před 5 lety +1512

    Obi-Wan was the master of trolling, he wouldn’t die, he would just force push himself back up and calmly say ‘Hello there..’ 👌🏻

  • @kindnessark8064
    @kindnessark8064 Před 3 lety +293

    You know loosing Qui Gon Jinn was the biggest loss in this story. I think the legend of bringing balance to the force was certainly true, but I think the prophesy of the Jedi could only have been made complete with Qui Gon. I think having the wrong Master flipped the prophesy towards the dark side before the balance was brought.

    • @mikeexits
      @mikeexits Před rokem +25

      Sometimes things need to get worse before they get better. And sometimes that makes for a better story. Ultimately Anakin did bring balance thanks to Luke being the light he needed to resolve his inner conflict.
      I often wonder what would have been of the sequel trilogy had Disney, JJ, and Rian Johnson not made their anti-trilogy and de-canonized the entire expanded universe.

    • @zachryder3150
      @zachryder3150 Před rokem +9

      If Plo Koon had trained Anakin he would've also brought balance to the Force.

    • @randomnamefr
      @randomnamefr Před rokem +2

      He did bring balance to the force.What you’re saying is completely one sided for the lightside.He brought balance to the force when he fell to the darkside when the lightside were too powerful and he came back to lightside when darkside were too powerful.All these quigons death ,mothers death,fear of losing padme,they were all destined to be.He was always destined to fall into the darkside

    • @e7delusional992
      @e7delusional992 Před rokem

      the prohecy was never abt him it was abt rey

    • @FruitCoupes
      @FruitCoupes Před rokem +2

      @@e7delusional992 hahahahahahahahaha…….hahahahahahahahahahahaha

  • @WorldPeace21
    @WorldPeace21 Před rokem +60

    I can't believe that Qui Gon wouldn't have searched for Obi-Wan's body.

  • @thehighground9514
    @thehighground9514 Před 4 lety +2055

    Qui-gon: how are you still alive?
    Maul:I was saved....by a bunch of fans

  • @Reavix1
    @Reavix1 Před 5 lety +2886

    Obi-Wan would never fall to the dark side.

    • @lizziemccoy6403
      @lizziemccoy6403 Před 4 lety +78

      I was thinking that haha

    • @kelvinbremont1341
      @kelvinbremont1341 Před 4 lety +344

      I know this was very interesting. Until the moment they made obi wan a sith.

    • @NationalEligraphic
      @NationalEligraphic Před 4 lety +31

      He could very easily turn

    • @grifballa
      @grifballa Před 4 lety +178

      Under the right circumstances. He was still young and could have easily felt abandoned by Qui Gon. There's also the possibility of major head trauma that could give him issues with his memory.

    • @ImpossibleMusic69
      @ImpossibleMusic69 Před 4 lety +63

      Reavx I hated the spin on the end with no explanation but if obi Wan wasn't even fully knighted and indoctrinated without a doubt of the jedi ways he most certainly could've fallen to the dark side. Even masters have turned to the dark but it would be easier to turn young obi over to seeking power, instead of being with the jedi, who only got him unimaginable pain of losing the battle and being damaged.

  • @Truly_Sithari
    @Truly_Sithari Před 4 lety +244

    Instead of the quote:
    “Kenobi!!!”
    It would be
    “JINN!!!”

  • @randomcamm4519
    @randomcamm4519 Před 3 lety +27

    The mental image of qui gon throwing a left hook at maul has Made me infinitely happier

  • @Golemoid
    @Golemoid Před 4 lety +2073

    Wait. Without Qui Gon's death, Dooku wouldn't leave the order, would there even be a clone wars?

    • @wolves600
      @wolves600 Před 4 lety +352

      probably since palpatine was setting it up he would have found out about the clones another way

    • @jeova0sanctus0unus
      @jeova0sanctus0unus Před 4 lety +167

      palpatine would find someone else.

    • @captainworldwide3106
      @captainworldwide3106 Před 4 lety +62

      Dooku was already on the dark side when Qui Gon died. I think...

    • @wolves600
      @wolves600 Před 4 lety +144

      @@captainworldwide3106 no he wasnt he didnt go to the dark side till after his death

    • @wolves600
      @wolves600 Před 4 lety +122

      @@captainworldwide3106 he was on the edge before that but his death pushed him over it

  • @sebanunez3723
    @sebanunez3723 Před 4 lety +1409

    Anakin: i want to become a jedi master
    Mace Windu: say sike right now

  • @Papashaft
    @Papashaft Před 3 lety +89

    The answer to the title is simple, Anakin wouldn’t turn to the dark side

    • @VOAN
      @VOAN Před 3 lety +10

      Yeap that also means that Darth Vader wouldn't exist either and Leia and Luke will grow up to be padawan as well.

    • @zacg8975
      @zacg8975 Před 2 lety +3

      Yes I agree And Qui Gon is the father figure Anakin Skywalker needed That's one of the reasons why I love Qui Gon Jinn

    • @zelgadisgreywolf8313
      @zelgadisgreywolf8313 Před 2 lety +2

      I doubt that. Just look at Dooku - him and Qui Gon are exactly the same. Free thinkers in Jedi Order and look where this led Dooku. To dark side. As it was pointed - for Qui Gon outcomes of actions was more important than actions itself, so Anakin would probably learn even earlier that using Dark Side to "save Padme" is good if Padme is saved, as the outcome is good. Heck - that is kind of why he kind of flipped when Windu did the same fighting with Palpatine. Not to mention Qui Qon was decived by Darth Plagueis, he believe that jedi should follow the force, not the jedi order, and he believed that the force led him to Anakin, and that Anakin is the choose one, where in books it was kind of revealed Anakin was most likely made by Plagueis and his midichlorian experiments, which led him to believe - he is close to become immortal.

  • @IkariaDark
    @IkariaDark Před 3 lety +38

    Something that always killed me was even though anakin had so much doubt against the jedi at this point he still tries to see there point of view and turn over palpatine and told mace, he did everything right and mace was going to kill palapatine the exact thing anakin felt and wanted to do but was wrong he lost all faith in that moment

  • @MrHunterWiseman
    @MrHunterWiseman Před 4 lety +1101

    What if Anakin refused to leave Tatooine because he wanted to pod race forever?

    • @carrie637
      @carrie637 Před 4 lety +91

      Sam Lim, what if Anakin liked sand?

    • @maya-4733
      @maya-4733 Před 4 lety +8

      Hunter Wiseman I was the 66th like😳😬

    • @crazy-7623
      @crazy-7623 Před 4 lety +10

      sand is very helthy1!1!1!1!1!11! it give many vitmins and minreals so it helthy
      (This is a joke lmao.)

    • @moldyaGencyontwitter
      @moldyaGencyontwitter Před 3 lety +3

      *Lego Grunt*

    • @Shineci
      @Shineci Před 3 lety +1

      @@moldyaGencyontwitter I have a lego grunt. And multiple spartans, along with a few Elites armed with energy swords and gravity hammers

  • @ryanandrews321
    @ryanandrews321 Před 4 lety +936

    Palpatine “Are you going to kill me?”
    Anakin “Yes lol”
    Palpatine “Noo...Noooooo!”

  • @andthusitis3178
    @andthusitis3178 Před 3 lety +42

    Imagine dialogue between Anakin, Qui Gon, and Ashoka

  • @ZTisHim
    @ZTisHim Před 3 lety +23

    "You must learn patience boi"
    -Mace Windu 2016

  • @iancrawford9658
    @iancrawford9658 Před 4 lety +786

    If obi wan died would qui gon be the guy who says “hello there”

    • @vasilisgreen
      @vasilisgreen Před 4 lety +75

      No, he would say, "You are the general I'm looking for" and grievous would just be bamboozled and his brain would melt from the confusion...

    • @oakleyhasafoot7878
      @oakleyhasafoot7878 Před 4 lety +1

      Ian Crawford he’d probably be silent

    • @ShortSight32
      @ShortSight32 Před 4 lety +5

      "Hello there, im tekking these citizenz to Gcorizunt

    • @iancrawford9658
      @iancrawford9658 Před 4 lety +1

      Gcorizunt?

    • @The12thDoctor
      @The12thDoctor Před 4 lety +1

      Nah

  • @danperry5375
    @danperry5375 Před 4 lety +1471

    I want to see a version of this where both Qui-Gon jinn and Obi-Wan survive.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +61

      Yeah HISHE really needs to do that and make another alternate outcome of THE PHANTOM MENACE when Qui-Gon actually survives that battle with Maul and becomes Anakin's master

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +3

      @Lesi PlaysHacks Glad you agree

    • @hassan_0160
      @hassan_0160 Před 4 lety +13

      There is video by stupendous wave about what if Qui Gon Jinn survived which him and Obi Wan Kenobi both survived

    • @sharky6184
      @sharky6184 Před 4 lety +12

      Why didn’t Obi-Wan just force heal him?

    • @jackattackanims8387
      @jackattackanims8387 Před 4 lety +2

      He didn’t know force heal yet

  • @oscarkageson-loe
    @oscarkageson-loe Před 3 lety +42

    In this universe I imagine Anakin looking like Luke from the Mandalorian along with a green lightsaber

  • @readingbetweentheframes
    @readingbetweentheframes Před 3 lety +65

    This was fun! There’s something you overlooked though. Palpating would have never allowed qui gon and anakins relationship to grow. He would have used Dooku who was qui gons master to in some way betray qui gon or get him out of the picture.

  • @KingTChalla69
    @KingTChalla69 Před 4 lety +1198

    If the council thought Anakin was such a risk why would they make him be the Padawan of Obi Wan? why not Yoda ,Windu or any other Jedi Master?

    • @isaacthompson3600
      @isaacthompson3600 Před 4 lety +7

      czcams.com/video/4cJMjDCPSSg/video.html

    • @zacharydimauro2706
      @zacharydimauro2706 Před 4 lety +314

      Because no one wanted anakin to get trained in the first place. Obi wan was literally the only person who was willing to train him.

    • @gabrieltejada1697
      @gabrieltejada1697 Před 4 lety +211

      Mark Pozsar there was no plot hole in that part if you actually watched the movie, it was Qui Gon's dying wish and that’s why Obi-wan trained Anakin.

    • @dougiec.8219
      @dougiec.8219 Před 4 lety +65

      No one else would take him as his padawan. Reason why obi did was because he made a promise to qui Gon Jinn

    • @Antonio-ru9kv
      @Antonio-ru9kv Před 4 lety +52

      Cause Obi-Wan promised to Qui Gon that he will train Anakin. Only problem was that Obi-Wan was not experienced for big challenge like that, so he failed.

  • @GibsonPrime
    @GibsonPrime Před 4 lety +137

    Hahahaha "Qui-Gon got pissed, punched Darth Maul in the face and cut him in half". I know I'm going to enjoy the rest of this!

  • @alexaanimations1237
    @alexaanimations1237 Před 2 lety +41

    I wonder what would happen if qui-gon actually checked the shaft to find obi wan. Saved him and they both trained anakin.

  • @TheFacelessStoryMaker
    @TheFacelessStoryMaker Před 2 lety +46

    Okay. Obi-Wan being a sith in Anakin's place was unexpected and an awesome story point as well.

  • @zacharyrodriguez6027
    @zacharyrodriguez6027 Před 4 lety +504

    Sidious: Don’t continue to be a pawn on the Jedi Counsel!!
    *in the exact same breath*
    Sidious: Be MY pawn though!

    • @seaBBB
      @seaBBB Před 4 lety +5

      I disagree, Anakin was a Jedi Knight, not a Jedi Paw- oh that's what you meant

    • @RoCreate
      @RoCreate Před 4 lety

      Jedi Council*

    • @jackgooge9049
      @jackgooge9049 Před 4 lety +1

      Sean Fakelastname Goddamit I laughed at that.

    • @tyler8253
      @tyler8253 Před 4 lety +2

      I remember seeing a YTP that changed it to be:
      "Don't be a pawn of the jedi council, be a pawn of the dark side"
      And that more or less sums up Episode 3 lol

    • @uvindukulathunga3860
      @uvindukulathunga3860 Před 2 lety

      @@tyler8253 even sidious is a pawn of darkside which is his greed and powerlust

  • @vylocs6547
    @vylocs6547 Před 4 lety +165

    I laughed so hard when he did the young anakin voice

  • @roaringthunder115
    @roaringthunder115 Před 3 lety +10

    Obi wan-*falls down the shaft* Hello there
    Maul-Hah. That’s funny. Wanna get robot legs and try to do our own thing?
    Obi wan-Well they are broken, so sure.

  • @ssgogeta29
    @ssgogeta29 Před 4 lety +16

    Dude, you’re fan fictions are so amazing and well thought out!
    I hope that there will be more in the future.
    Anakin from the Clone Wars is my favorite character and I always wondered what Star Wars would be like if he had Qui-Gon around to help him through his struggles.
    I feel like if he had both Qui-Gon and Obi-wan, he wouldn’t have fallen to the dark side.

  • @HobGungan
    @HobGungan Před 7 lety +596

    You had me right up until the "Evil One-Wan" bit.

    • @geekygamergirl7259
      @geekygamergirl7259 Před 7 lety +31

      Seriously. Can we please have it explained in this version how those two even survived?

    • @Jenilbee
      @Jenilbee Před 7 lety +25

      watch the clone wars were darth maul survived it is the same principal

    • @thereallowz7193
      @thereallowz7193 Před 5 lety +38

      Adam Bram yeah that's just stupid, why would he suddenly join de darkside and why would he join the guy who pretty much killed him

    • @TheAmericanCrusader
      @TheAmericanCrusader Před 5 lety +16

      I actually would've had Maul finish off Obi-Wan by consuming his Force energy to survive and draw more power like how Darth Nihilus survived the Malachor IV cataclysm

    • @thetruebleu014
      @thetruebleu014 Před 5 lety +2

      Carlos David he was brainwashed

  • @tntkff9901
    @tntkff9901 Před 4 lety +405

    "...punches him in the face..."
    Maul: "Wait, that's illegal..."

    • @Wretchrot
      @Wretchrot Před 3 lety +17

      "I will make it legal"

    • @jackwenn_9693
      @jackwenn_9693 Před 3 lety +7

      Hmmm

    • @pumkin610
      @pumkin610 Před 2 lety +2

      "Doesn't seem very jedi of- 2:25 " Darth maul

    • @mikeexits
      @mikeexits Před rokem +2

      @@Wretchrot Just imagining those being the last words Maul hears as he dies makes me chuckle.

  • @ScorpioKing50
    @ScorpioKing50 Před 2 lety +15

    Well that escalated quickly wasn't expecting that lol. Imagine if they did a What If version for the Star Wars universe lol

    • @mikeexits
      @mikeexits Před rokem +3

      I still find "sith Obi Wan" jarring and not believable at all lol. Definitely on the less likely end of possibility.

  • @brickabang
    @brickabang Před 3 lety +8

    3:39 Wow, plo koon has a huge lightsaber.

  • @romandumych1623
    @romandumych1623 Před 4 lety +578

    "A *Duel* between 3 people..."
    Yeah, this is big brain time

  • @monke12354
    @monke12354 Před 5 lety +1235

    Obiwan didnt need to die for qui-gon to teach him lol

    • @briansouthparkstudio1357
      @briansouthparkstudio1357 Před 5 lety +125

      correct obiwan was about to take his trials anyway and would have likely passed. he was ready qui-gon was being truthful

    • @Ritz38
      @Ritz38 Před 4 lety +11

      Wdym If someone didn't die then who will train Anakin??

    • @Dre-yd2xh
      @Dre-yd2xh Před 4 lety +23

      yeah, obiwan could have survived and took someone else as his apprentice at least

    • @kaivin88
      @kaivin88 Před 4 lety +16

      Although, in an alternate timeline in a galaxy far far away, if both jedi survive in that battle with maul, obi wan is still be teaching anakin but with the eyes of jinn of course. In this timeline, obi-wan becomes a more capable master and having a disciple that is so OP. An anakin with the qualities of an aggressive jedi and still not able to resist the dark side like another windu.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +11

      No, he would've survived too and moved on to become a Jedi knight while Qui-Gon takes on Anakin as he next padawan council's approval or not

  • @real-potatogamer
    @real-potatogamer Před 4 lety +16

    I understand that through his rage, Maul was able to keep himself alive. But how would Obiwan? And then if he survived, why join the dark side?
    Other than that I think this is brilliant!

  • @FinleyPowell-gg8sq
    @FinleyPowell-gg8sq Před 3 lety +11

    This is a bigger plot twist than episode 5 xD

  • @NurseAkali
    @NurseAkali Před 6 lety +761

    "I want to become a Jedi Master!"
    *13 years later*
    Mace Windu: That was a nice joke.

  • @NoNo-fi3tc
    @NoNo-fi3tc Před 4 lety +405

    “The four Jedi masters and Anakin, the Jedi KNIGHT.” You really had to do him like that huh

  • @danieldefibaugh9607
    @danieldefibaugh9607 Před 2 lety +1

    Love checking out your work so far. Trying my best to ensure I like and share the best ones for now on to keep em coming. Off to part 2!

  • @hero_of_legend7071
    @hero_of_legend7071 Před 3 lety +3

    Obi wan at the end just walks in like "hello there"

  • @zachreyes6484
    @zachreyes6484 Před 6 lety +180

    Meanwhile at the reactor
    Obi-Wan= Soooooo What do we do now?
    Maul= IDK
    Obiwan- Wanna get pizza?
    Maul= Ok

  • @IsaacWolfOfficial
    @IsaacWolfOfficial Před 5 lety +408

    Man, why does kit fisto always have to die in all these theories 🤣

  • @louisehayes4981
    @louisehayes4981 Před 3 lety +3

    Conclusion: there would be almost no memes in Star Wars

  • @ronchilled
    @ronchilled Před rokem

    Dude your alternate star wars plots are so awesome and well thought!

  • @vardaspavarde6423
    @vardaspavarde6423 Před 4 lety +439

    They need to make ,,What if"" animated series on Disney+

    • @dingkong5034
      @dingkong5034 Před 4 lety +44

      They're doing that for Marvel lmao. But yeah, Star Wars needs a What If series.

    • @garrettquikstop2812
      @garrettquikstop2812 Před 4 lety +4

      Yesssssss!!!!!!!!!

    • @sameyeams
      @sameyeams Před 4 lety +3

      That's what I've been saying!!!
      We need a What If? series for Star Wars.

    • @anakinskinwalker1724
      @anakinskinwalker1724 Před 3 lety

      Yeah, and it'd have theories/facts like the Who Was/Is show on Netflix

    • @supernova2351
      @supernova2351 Před 3 lety +1

      Well know there is a what if coming out, but it is Marvel

  • @belainegibsson.2082
    @belainegibsson.2082 Před 7 lety +305

    Interesting... but I laughed out loud when the photoshopped Yoda, Anakin and Plo were walking in.

  • @zerus9630
    @zerus9630 Před 2 lety +6

    This was awesome and felt organic to the story and characters. This feels more canon than anything that Disney puts on the big screen.

  • @retrovergil6930
    @retrovergil6930 Před 4 lety +6

    It took me minutes to understand that this is a what if

  • @drac3650
    @drac3650 Před 7 lety +935

    Ummm huge plot hole: Count Dooku wouldn't have turned if Qui-Gon was alive

    • @mamatorinq5678
      @mamatorinq5678 Před 7 lety +113

      Pedro Gomes yah... he could have just said that sidious brought back maul in order to complete his training. Maul would then take dooku's place in the storyline.

    • @ODER66MIKE
      @ODER66MIKE Před 7 lety +17

      Pedro Gomes yeah but count dooku probably would have said something about obi wan being killed

    • @Luna-xr3dk
      @Luna-xr3dk Před 6 lety +16

      Pedro Gomes yeah but Obi wan died. In which case Dooku would betray the jedi order

    • @devthakur2689
      @devthakur2689 Před 6 lety +28

      It was not Qui-Gon Jinn that made him turn it was what the Jedi saw in the force when he turn the Jedi didn't know about Order 66 or the chancellor was a Sith Lord but Count Dooku saw that in the force

    • @Valatmir
      @Valatmir Před 6 lety +1

      I think it would be the other side around

  • @outloat9184
    @outloat9184 Před 4 lety +165

    Anakin needed a father, not a brother. He had grown with only his mother, and had finally found not the father he wanted, but the father he needed

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +20

      I agree, Qui-Gon would've done so much better with Anakin than Obi-Wan EVER did!

    • @rikudoubapeck
      @rikudoubapeck Před 4 lety +8

      EXACTLY!!!!!! I said this exact thing on another video. Whenever people cry about Anakin being whiny or how Anakin and Obi Wan aren't simply good mates like described in episode 4 they always ignore that from the beginning their relationship was rocky because they both saw Qui Gon as a father so Obi Wan was more comfortable viewing Anakin as his step-brother but Anakin needed a father figure. Unfortunately Obi Wan being unable to fill that role left it open for Palpatine.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +14

      @@rikudoubapeck Yeah Obi-Wan definitely was more like a strict older bro than a fatherly figure of a master as Qui-Gon could've been to Anakin had he lived

    • @rikudoubapeck
      @rikudoubapeck Před 4 lety +3

      @@gibbs615 Agreed.

    • @TheLatiosnlatias02
      @TheLatiosnlatias02 Před 3 lety +1

      @@gibbs615
      That's why I've always favoured Qui Gon.

  • @johnlinton7148
    @johnlinton7148 Před 2 lety +1

    Love it, man. Great videos, and enjoyed watching your lives of the Lego Skywalker Saga.

  • @Xehanort10
    @Xehanort10 Před 3 lety +10

    Things would definitely have gone better since Qui-Gon was more experienced whereas Obi-Wan was only a Padawan himself when he trained Anakin.

  • @MisterTutor2010
    @MisterTutor2010 Před 7 lety +1232

    Maul is not half the Sith he used to be :)

    • @bruhwtf2282
      @bruhwtf2282 Před 7 lety +7

      MisterTutor2010 👍

    • @Themartialartsmusician
      @Themartialartsmusician Před 7 lety +5

      MisterTutor2010 badumtss

    • @falloutboisumbish9409
      @falloutboisumbish9409 Před 6 lety +3

      MisterTutor2010 😂

    • @AJkoubek
      @AJkoubek Před 6 lety +13

      IN THIS TIME LINE DOOKU WOULD NOT HAVE JOINED THE SITH SINCE IT WAS THE LOSS OF HIS FRIEND QUI GON THAT CAUSED HIM TO JOIN THE SITH HE WOULD HAVE AIDED IN TRAINING SKY WALKER U SHOULD PUT THIS IN YOUR STORY THANKS

    • @Devilsnightforlife
      @Devilsnightforlife Před 6 lety +7

      Now he's just a sith that we used to know ;)

  • @penguinroad5197
    @penguinroad5197 Před 4 lety +158

    9:05 I cant stop laughing at these guys being pasted into the video

  • @mr.l4461
    @mr.l4461 Před 7 měsíci +3

    I think the fact Obi-WAN’s first padawan to be the Chosen One made it difficult for him as he was a padawan who lost his master and was about to face the trials

  • @ajftwg5827
    @ajftwg5827 Před 2 lety

    Man this channel is so creative, I love every one of these videos

  • @scr3aming3agle83
    @scr3aming3agle83 Před 7 lety +532

    you had me m8, until evil obi-won.
    now maul made sense though, but not obi won

    • @XL1813
      @XL1813 Před 7 lety +24

      I agree. That was just weird.

    • @Tedphoenician
      @Tedphoenician Před 7 lety +2

      Also saying Maul was a Zabrak.

    • @yannmc2290
      @yannmc2290 Před 7 lety +13

      I think Obi-wan could possibly have fallen under different circumstances, however it is unfathomable to me that he would ever join with Sidious or even Maul, especially this late in his training. Dooku would probably have been the only one capable of leading him to the dark side if he had confided in him during his own fall after Qui-Gons death, but since Qui-Gon is alive in this timeline that also wouldn't have happened. Of the Jedis shown in the prequel movies until that point, I believe that none are really prone to turning to the dark side with the possible exception of Kit Fisto under very very unlikely circumstances.

    • @Erinnn379
      @Erinnn379 Před 7 lety +1

      Maul was a Zabrak?

    • @scr3aming3agle83
      @scr3aming3agle83 Před 7 lety

      Aaron Akins yes he is, along with his brother savage opress.

  • @michaelh4227
    @michaelh4227 Před 4 lety +70

    Obi-Wan may have failed as a teacher, but at least he had the high ground.

  • @DonTheTruth91
    @DonTheTruth91 Před rokem

    I love this actually ❤️❤️. This was AMAZING! I love it!

  • @TheW1sest
    @TheW1sest Před rokem

    I think this is probably my favourite what if you’ve made

  • @derekjohn185
    @derekjohn185 Před 4 lety +504

    We need a 'what-if' timeline where qui-gon left the order to train Anakin; leaving obi-wan to complete trials in the order. Then qui-gon could train him in the True ways of the force. Not merely within the constraints of the council who had become rupublic/Palpatine puppets. WHOLE DIFFERENT STORY!!!

  • @georgek3686
    @georgek3686 Před 6 lety +355

    The one plot hole I find in this scenario, is this; Would Anakin really engage in a romantic relationship with Padme, having received the disciplinary training from Gin, and even if he did, wouldn't Gin be aware?

    • @pjmurray91
      @pjmurray91 Před 6 lety +54

      George K Qui Gon was in love with someone once too. I don't remember her name though

    • @randysyes4446
      @randysyes4446 Před 5 lety +54

      I think you have a point though, Jin would be much more of a cockblock. unless he was hookin up too, cuz he's that guy.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 5 lety +89

      George K I believe like a father he would've been supportive about Anakin's feelings towards Padme since he was in love himself once

    • @Shurtugl
      @Shurtugl Před 5 lety

      Exactly!

    • @jacobsummers3441
      @jacobsummers3441 Před 5 lety +62

      I think he would support it and guide it. Qui Gon did not only studied the light side of the force.
      He studied the dark side to brimg back someone he loved. So he would understand Anakin and woyld probably be able to give better guidance to him than the whole jedi council combined.

  • @Karmai9
    @Karmai9 Před 4 lety +4

    9:41 have a seat

  • @1138keshav
    @1138keshav Před 3 lety +4

    I just can't fathom Quigon not going to check if obiwan is dead or give him a proper burial

  • @NinjaSushi2
    @NinjaSushi2 Před 4 lety +122

    *Obi Won comes back as a sith*
    "SHUT THE FRONT DOOR!"

    • @ua7521
      @ua7521 Před 4 lety +8

      *Maul comes out as well*
      “SHUT THE OTHER FRONT DOOR!”
      Yes, this is a hishe reference.

  • @Sparty-pi3jq
    @Sparty-pi3jq Před 3 měsíci

    Sooo well done! Thanks for this one!

  • @justsomeguywithoutashirt4310

    Qui gon jinn:We grant you the rank of master,young skywalker.
    Mace windu:I obj-
    Qui gon jinn:Take a seat Mace Windu

  • @annazhang75
    @annazhang75 Před 6 lety +68

    “Obi was with orange eyes!” *spits out water* WHAT THE F--

  • @zachestrada6467
    @zachestrada6467 Před 4 lety +75

    You guys have to remember that the Obi Wan in this movie is still young and a learning padawan. He isn’t the old and wise Jedi Master we see in the 3rd movie. Therefore, it isn’t completely unrealistic that he makes the turn to the Dark Side, especially after spending time with Darth Maul where ever they ended up.

  • @jennmcfarland8016
    @jennmcfarland8016 Před 2 lety

    Love the vid man. You are so great at what you do😃 keep up the good work

  • @jamiet2602
    @jamiet2602 Před 3 lety +3

    HOLLYYYY SHITT HOW HAVE I ONLY JUST WATCHED THIS

  • @swmerchant6474
    @swmerchant6474 Před 4 lety +577

    Hey have you guys been to the maul?
    I hear everything is half off :)

  • @SHARDK2
    @SHARDK2 Před 4 lety +230

    9:10
    Top class editing, right there. Can hardly tell that it's altered.

  • @lachiemcmahon9308
    @lachiemcmahon9308 Před 2 lety

    That vid was so good keep up the good work

  • @markboyle1939
    @markboyle1939 Před 2 lety +1

    Sweet ending! Qui Gon has always been my favourite character and that was a cool twist. Nicely done! ;)

  • @masterdarklink1
    @masterdarklink1 Před 6 lety +281

    I feel like this could have been expanded upon further.
    For example, Count Dooku had originally left the Jedi after the death of Qui Gon because he was dissatisfied with how the order was dealing with it, but with Qui Gon not dead, would Dooku have left to become Darth Tyrannus?
    How would Qui Gon have reacted to Anakin's visions of his mother? Obi Wan told him to let go of them but would Qui Gon? Or would he have let Anakin return to Tatooine early? If so, he would have saved her sooner and prevented her death and Anakin's destruction of the Sand people.
    Would Qui Gon have discovered Anakin's and Padmè's relationship sooner than Obi Wan did? He was older and had been in his own relationship beforehand, maybe Anakin would have revealed it to him, so when the visions of Padmè's death in childbirth started Qui Gon could have been far more supportive in helping Anakin stay calm.
    Would Anakin and Palpatine have been as close friends? Qui Gon was always weary of the Senate, and with Qui Gon acting as a father figure for Anakin would Palpatine have been as effective with his manipulation?
    I can't help but feel you've only scratched the surface here, there is so much more to be explored with an idea like this~

    • @Archon3960
      @Archon3960 Před 5 lety +18

      Or even Qui Gon trying to reform the Jedi Order to make it less dogmatic.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 5 lety +2

      masterdarklink1 I think Qui-Gon would've letted Anakin go to Tatooine to save his mother and like a father he also would've supported Anakin's feelings for Padme.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 5 lety +9

      The Archangel Exactly! Qui-Gon would've been the one to prevent Anakin's turn to the dark side had he survived

    • @dragoninthewest1
      @dragoninthewest1 Před 5 lety +1

      In the current Canon, Dooku had left the Jedi Order by the time of Qui-Gon is training Obi-Wan. He went back to his home world to take over governing following the death of his father. Apparently he always felt a certain pull to the dark side.

    • @puttputt524
      @puttputt524 Před 5 lety

      masterdarklink1 aside from all this, I think they would have lost the clone wars really early without obi wan and anakin. That pairing really carried the war.

  • @themandalorian6999
    @themandalorian6999 Před 4 lety +109

    No Matter what universe Palpatine is Always *The* *SENATE*

    • @VerdeMorte
      @VerdeMorte Před 3 lety +5

      What if the ENTIRE rest of the Senate walked in and started protesting about his statement and then Paparazzi showed up camera flashing him in the face through the window?

    • @nicholasplese292
      @nicholasplese292 Před 3 lety +1

      What if palpatine wasn’t the senate

  • @crazybanana4239
    @crazybanana4239 Před 3 lety +1

    Qui Gonn: "throws punch"
    Darth Maul: ayo hold up dafuq

  • @maddnessalert9996
    @maddnessalert9996 Před 4 lety +2

    That’s how you subvert expectations.

  • @ConorCarlisle
    @ConorCarlisle Před 7 lety +177

    Here's an interesting idea for you to do: What if The Skywalker Twins were Swapped?

    • @ActuallyJozu
      @ActuallyJozu Před 7 lety +13

      Carlisle the Cinephile You mean like Luke is a prince and Leia is a Jedi?

    • @ConorCarlisle
      @ConorCarlisle Před 7 lety +10

      Samuel Yes. I'd like to hear about an alternate timeline where Luke was adopted by the Organas and Leia was raised on Tattooine by Owen and Beru/watched over by Obi-Wan.

    • @ActuallyJozu
      @ActuallyJozu Před 7 lety +8

      That sounds like a good what if scenario, I wanna see a video about that too now!

    • @michellehuss2545
      @michellehuss2545 Před 6 lety +11

      In an interview, George Lucas said he was going to make Leia the hero of the story, but changed his mind because in 1977 the world was not ready for a female hero yet.

    • @Dennis_Fueru
      @Dennis_Fueru Před 6 lety +2

      I don't think there will be much different, honestly

  • @rxw_productions4114
    @rxw_productions4114 Před 6 lety +397

    If Darth maul survived the fall without legs. Obi-wan can

    • @markfirland9577
      @markfirland9577 Před 6 lety +11

      maul did what other sith did in history and reject death one lord went as far as to have "died" dozens of times only to come back submersed in yet another layer of darkness tho i forget the name he was never defeated but became one with the force

    • @christianriddler5063
      @christianriddler5063 Před 5 lety +13

      Darth Sion was the sith that died several times and at the end his body was rotten and falling apart and the only thing that kept him alive was his hatred and pain which the exile saved him from in the end.

    • @getgoing581
      @getgoing581 Před 5 lety

      Mark Firland They were all undead pawns of the darkside that would see you as weak for your foolish admiration and kill you where you where you stand.

    • @tapwater9435
      @tapwater9435 Před 5 lety

      exaxtly

    • @ravonbox6050
      @ravonbox6050 Před 5 lety +1

      See, there's another plot hole witht this theory: Palpatine follows the Rule of Two, therefore he would have more than likely disposed of either maul or Kenobi.

  • @LegoGuyProductions117

    OH SNAP THAT REVEAL AT THE END WAS AMAZING I NEED A PART 2

  • @sifuazula9089
    @sifuazula9089 Před 3 lety +3

    Who says anakin will even fall in love with padame if qui gon has taught him in the true jedi ways

  • @jddiggy2343
    @jddiggy2343 Před 4 lety +163

    So obi wan harnesses force speed just to slip and fall to his death.

    • @MrTaylorAries
      @MrTaylorAries Před 3 lety +2

      Ikr like damn so he fell and died but maul survived being cut in half? Doesn't make sense. Leaving both bodies down there makes no sense... I'd want to prove maul was dead just as much as obi wan so I could tell the council so they didn't think I just dropped sued off somewhere never to be seen again lol

    • @D00DM00D
      @D00DM00D Před 3 lety +11

      He forgot to use Force Brake

    • @uvindukulathunga3860
      @uvindukulathunga3860 Před 2 lety +2

      why the hell those cores are even deep like that

    • @Complete_Stranger7050
      @Complete_Stranger7050 Před 2 lety

      Force Suicide

    • @whyshouldishowmyname848
      @whyshouldishowmyname848 Před 2 lety

      @@uvindukulathunga3860 Probably for cooling effect

  • @neilmankodi1159
    @neilmankodi1159 Před 5 lety +217

    There is a plot hole in this
    If Jinn had really taught Anakin the true Jedi way then he would never have married Padme (as a Jedi cannot have any attachments)
    That would have made him immune to Palatine's brainwashing.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +82

      Actually Jinn was a GREY JEDI meaning he didn't always follow all those cold rules of the Jedi order, meaning he wouldn't have minded about Anakin falling in love with Padme

    • @SycosenMerihem
      @SycosenMerihem Před 4 lety +13

      @@gibbs615 Qui-Qon Jinn would see that he would pursue and train new powers to protect the woman he loved, and see her as a conduit for his success.

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety +14

      @@SycosenMerihem Perhaps that's true, what I'm saying though is Qui-Gon would've supported Anakin's feelings for Padme like a father would

    • @DocTime56
      @DocTime56 Před 4 lety +35

      @@gibbs615 I love the Gray Jedi code, it doesn't sound as powerful as the sith code, but sounds so in balance, contrary to the Jedi code were they just don't acknowledge emotions

    • @gibbs615
      @gibbs615 Před 4 lety

      @@DocTime56 You got that right

  • @phantom9062
    @phantom9062 Před 2 lety

    You are truly the Grand Master of Star Wars fans and we are humble Jedi fans to serve along side you and support you. May the force be with you, always.

  • @obi-wankenobi7399
    @obi-wankenobi7399 Před 3 lety +3

    10:21 Hello there!