What if Qui-Gon Was in Revenge of the Sith? - Star Wars Theory

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 07. 2021
  • Thank you for 5 years of Star Wars Theory. Today, let's dive into a fan-fiction from Revenge of the Sith that I think would have changed the fate of Anakin's future, and the events of the galaxy as a whole.
    If Qui-Gon Jinn had showed up to Anakin to speak with him during his more pivotal and dire moment, I believe so many things could have been changed.
    Anakin would see that Jedi can live on beyond the living form. Anakin wouldn't rush to help Palpatine as he fought Mace Windu. He would learn all he could from his true Jedi Master.
    Palpatine would eventually be arrested and Luke and Leia would be born.
    Anakin would train Leia, and Yoda would train Luke, while the marriage and relationship of Anakin and Padme would be kept a secret for as long as they could. The children of Skywalker would just be strong force sensitives to the knowledge of the council, while many would suspect the truth, they would turn a blind eye until they were sure.
    Maul would surface from the far reaches of space, bringing an army with Crimson Dawn to the Jedi and wreaking havoc across the galaxy.
    Write your comments for Part 2 and I'll make it happen.
    Purple hat 5 Year anniversary - teespring.com/orderhatpurple
    Find me on Spotify
    Continue the conversation on the Theory forums!
    starwarstheory.com/THEORY/posts
    Become a Patron to support future content - / starwarstheory
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @starwarstheory
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1,9K

  • @fuzzman02
    @fuzzman02 Před 2 lety +1134

    Theory should be hired by Disney to write a “What If?” show for Star Wars

    • @dylanblanchard6950
      @dylanblanchard6950 Před 2 lety +78

      With clone wars/bad batch animation

    • @Citizenx305
      @Citizenx305 Před 2 lety +28

      Yes !!!!! yes !!!! yeeesss please!!!! Lucas could not be so arrogant for not seeing all the potential and greatness from Theory!!!! (Yes,...at least animated)

    • @Remnant-Star76
      @Remnant-Star76 Před 2 lety +21

      YES! I Agree! While it would make Disney more money, give this to them and have Dave Faloni and John Favreau help write and team to animate, it will also give Fans what they would want to see.

    • @The_WW_Wizard
      @The_WW_Wizard Před 2 lety +3

      ye I agree

    • @lowqualitymemes1289
      @lowqualitymemes1289 Před 2 lety +3

      @@dylanblanchard6950 i’d rather see the animation like the one for marvel

  • @samosman123
    @samosman123 Před 2 lety +1143

    "I'll surely make both videos if you wish" *me after watching all the fan fictions on this channel.. Sceptical..* haha

  • @sorcvelvet6784
    @sorcvelvet6784 Před 2 lety +78

    Qui Gon: Stay in that cockpit
    Anakin: Insert Leonardo Dicaprio laughing while drinking meme

  • @jordanelza8806
    @jordanelza8806 Před 2 lety +88

    Finally someone mentioned that it was indeed lack of sleep that was causing Anakin’s judgement to be clouded. This fact certainly worked in Palpatine’s favor, as it made it even easier to manipulate Anakin. In the normal timeline of course.

  • @DarthAxolotl
    @DarthAxolotl Před 2 lety +352

    He never told anakin what to do.
    "Say here"
    "But"
    "StAy In tHAt COcKpIt"

    • @urmum9999
      @urmum9999 Před 2 lety +7

      I thought the same thing

    • @mesacake
      @mesacake Před 2 lety +43

      Anakin: "But...master you said you would always give me choices!
      Qui-Gon: "Ok."
      Option 1: Stay in that cockpit
      Option 2: StAy In tHAt COcKpIt

    • @albumkosong
      @albumkosong Před 2 lety +13

      @@mesacake stay in that cockpit or don't go out

    • @wheattoast1971
      @wheattoast1971 Před 2 lety +9

      Anakin, drop!

    • @tredavis5392
      @tredavis5392 Před 2 lety +8

      qui gon:”stay here”
      anakin:”but?”
      qui gon:”stay the cockpit u lil sh*t”😂

  • @elijahdoesstuff4600
    @elijahdoesstuff4600 Před 2 lety +374

    If Qui-Gon survived, Anakin simply wouldn’t have turned to the dark side. The only way Palpatine was able to corrupt him was by being fulfilling the role of a father figure, which Qui-Gon would have fulfilled had he not perished at the hands of Darth Maul. Anakin also wouldn’t have become so frustrated with the Jedi, as Qui-Gon would have taught him a less narrow, less dogmatic view of the Force.

    • @PacisJusticia
      @PacisJusticia Před 2 lety +19

      Simple and correct.

    • @DaDunge
      @DaDunge Před 2 lety +48

      Not to mention, Qui-Gon would have gone back for Shimmi. His intention was never to let Watto hold on to her forever. Once the immediate crisis was over he'd have returned exchanged credits for whatever money they use on Tatooine and bought and freed her.

    • @Rgamefreak15
      @Rgamefreak15 Před 2 lety +36

      Also count dooku only left the council when qui gon died. He never would have left, and the clone army would have never been corrupted etc.

    • @Sukiru218
      @Sukiru218 Před 2 lety +2

      Yup

    • @Zooropa1310
      @Zooropa1310 Před 2 lety +9

      Then Kenobi, no longer needing to train Anakin, would not feel obligated to stay in the Order. He and Duchess Satine would go "Jedi Order Official," and elope. Then upon Maul killing her, with him no longer having the support of his Jedi crew, Kenobi says FUCK IT and goes full dark side. Palpatine does his "I'm here for you when no one else is," and we get Darth Kobe.
      Always 2, but who?

  • @iNabber
    @iNabber Před 2 lety +941

    missed these theory videos so much

  • @thesharpercoder
    @thesharpercoder Před 2 lety +446

    I feel Anakin went over the cliff and fell to the dark side when he disobeyed Windu and left the Council Chambers.
    I like how your story seems to hinge on that one moment, which seems to have gone mostly unnoticed.
    Anakin could not leave the Council Chambers, and still remain a Jedi.

    • @NeilCWCampbell
      @NeilCWCampbell Před 2 lety +8

      Indeed..I was surprised it didn't have a theme that echoed the Duel of fates?

    • @rachelprighel4409
      @rachelprighel4409 Před 2 lety +2

      No he didn't fall off the cliff he just slipped on the cliff

    • @Chosen_Ash
      @Chosen_Ash Před 2 lety +2

      He could but not many

    • @joshua2400
      @joshua2400 Před 2 lety +3

      Jesus Christ loves you my friends :" )

    • @Blues2green
      @Blues2green Před rokem

      or just quit making “what if’s”😅

  • @RipCityBassWorks
    @RipCityBassWorks Před 2 lety +166

    There's a plot hole: if Palpatine was unable to call order 66, Ashoka would have been successful in bringing Maul before the Jedi Council...

    • @syclone008
      @syclone008 Před 2 lety +11

      Smart

    • @frostburn6784
      @frostburn6784 Před 2 lety +1

      Yep this is why this theory is bad smh

    • @syclone008
      @syclone008 Před 2 lety +21

      @@frostburn6784 hes not bad hes actually one of the best star wars yt'bers out there I mean you can have you opinion but does not mean everyone wants to know it

    • @frostburn6784
      @frostburn6784 Před 2 lety +4

      @@syclone008 i didn’t say he was a bad person genius i said this theory is bad not “Theory” is bad read between the lines

    • @alonsozevallos9755
      @alonsozevallos9755 Před 2 lety

      Therefore Crimson Dawn would never exist, or reach a high status s it did in the original timelime. Epic gamer moment

  • @MatCaveGaming
    @MatCaveGaming Před 2 lety +271

    I always felt that Yoda was hearing Qui-Gon reaching out to Anakin in the moment of the Tuskin slaughter, but Anakin ignored the call of Qui-gon. Anakin was so clouded by hate and anger that maybe Anakin didn’t even hear/feel it. Such a powerful scene and one of my favorite moments in the prequels. Great video, dude. I always enjoy these theories and what ifs.

    • @PatrickStewart316
      @PatrickStewart316 Před 2 lety +22

      In the novelization that’s exactly what happens. It is also the first time Yoda ever heard sentient personality reach out from the netherworld of the force. Seriously read attack of the clones some time. That and RoS books are awesome.

  • @Haruckio
    @Haruckio Před 2 lety +123

    I often think about these kind of theories, I just want to see Anakin happy with his family 😭

    • @batlevi2247
      @batlevi2247 Před rokem +1

      Then there would be no Darth Vader or any of the actual original movies so…

    • @user-oi1mb4vu9f
      @user-oi1mb4vu9f Před 11 měsíci +1

      so do I😢

    • @waffles5088
      @waffles5088 Před 10 měsíci +1

      Then there would be no balance in the force, Luke’s new Jedi order wouldn’t exist.
      Being the Chosen One wasn’t a gift, it was a curse.

    • @smiladon12
      @smiladon12 Před 8 měsíci

      ​​@@waffles5088It wasn't a curse but definitely a burden, a double edge sword if you like. He had great and powerful potential for the light and the dark side of the force.

  • @Villicous
    @Villicous Před 2 lety +72

    Whenever anakin gets granted the rank of master is makes me smile

  • @obi-wan-kenobi2393
    @obi-wan-kenobi2393 Před 2 lety +355

    Obi-Wan: "It's over Anakin! I have the high ground!"
    Anakin: "Ok."
    Obi-Wan: "You were right about one thing Master. The negotiations were short."

    • @WoofWoofWhisper
      @WoofWoofWhisper Před 2 lety +1

      General Kenobi!

    • @artdrenaline3293
      @artdrenaline3293 Před 2 lety +10

      @Anakin Skywalker good to see you again General Skywalker, and General Kenobi

    • @obi-wankenobi9209
      @obi-wankenobi9209 Před 2 lety +3

      @@artdrenaline3293 Rex i think im cloned

    • @artdrenaline3293
      @artdrenaline3293 Před 2 lety

      @@obi-wankenobi9209 well that’s certainly odd I can’t be sure which of you is the clone now

    • @obi-wan-kenobi2393
      @obi-wan-kenobi2393 Před 2 lety +9

      @@artdrenaline3293 think Rex, think. I posted the original comment, and the other Obi-Wan has a Lego Star Wars profile picture instead of an actual Obi-Wan image, like me. I am the original Kenobi. Now you should get back to the front lines with General Skywalker

  • @BuhBerger
    @BuhBerger Před 2 lety +379

    Imagine a Star Wars “What if?” series on Disney+
    This type of story could be a series in itself.

    • @alexmartinez5859
      @alexmartinez5859 Před 2 lety +27

      It could only be made possible through Dave Filoni. No if’s, ands, ors, or buts.

    • @christianbjorck816
      @christianbjorck816 Před 2 lety +7

      Disney? Making good content? Keep dreaming.

    • @Max-zg6ld
      @Max-zg6ld Před 2 lety +8

      @@christianbjorck816 Laughs in Mandalorian, bad Batch, TCW, Rebels, etc

    • @christianbjorck816
      @christianbjorck816 Před 2 lety +4

      @Max TCW wasn’t Disney. And the rest is just shitty watered down EU material. Mandalorian is so laughably bad that it’s only because the sequels were even worse that people cling to it by desperation.

    • @ARG0T
      @ARG0T Před 2 lety +7

      @@christianbjorck816 How is the Mandalorian bad? It isn't almost unanimously loved by the fandom because of "desperation". You sound dumb

  • @djstone9578
    @djstone9578 Před 2 lety +26

    Theory is usually great at voice impressions of SW characters but his Qui-Gon was made me laugh 😂

  • @cameroncope3034
    @cameroncope3034 Před 2 lety +84

    I like that either way Luke’s and yoda’s paths cross and he becomes a important role in Luke’s development

  • @hellothere9536
    @hellothere9536 Před 2 lety +351

    Imagine if he had a talk with Anakin and maybe persuaded him to not go down the dark path...what a different story that would’ve been wow.

    • @jackwenn_9693
      @jackwenn_9693 Před 2 lety +12

      That would be good

    • @hellothere9536
      @hellothere9536 Před 2 lety +5

      @@jackwenn_9693 hello there

    • @mike197714
      @mike197714 Před 2 lety +4

      What Theory said: would be true. Then the whole galactic civil war would have been avoided. But the Councilor controlling the government. That’s plain wrong. Put windo in jail is very disappointing.😔. 😕.

    • @joshuaoglesby1262
      @joshuaoglesby1262 Před 2 lety

      it would be nice to see a what if that includes the prevention of the empire rising

    • @Wingbar
      @Wingbar Před 2 lety +1

      I don’t understand force ghosts. Even in the sequels, anakin’s force ghost could have reached out to kylo/ben to let him know that going down the path of the dark side is wrong. Or are force ghosts not capable of communing with dark side of the force users?

  • @Wingbar
    @Wingbar Před 2 lety +222

    Anakin’s story is so sad. Oh how I wish this was the actual timeline..

    • @samuela2246
      @samuela2246 Před 2 lety +19

      We would never have Darth Vader but I would be okay with that because we would see Anakin at FP (who would basically be a god), and Anakin and Padme raise luke and leia which I've always wanted to see. I have always felt like they would be such good parents and Star Wars fans would finally get a happily after ever.

    • @Wingbar
      @Wingbar Před 2 lety +12

      @@samuela2246 it’s just so sad considering it was so obvious he needed some support, from anyone really. Even just telling him it’s gonna be okay would have probably helped him a lot. The Jedi were so obsessed with the politics and their dogmatic ways that they were not only blinded by the fact that Anakin needed support, but that a Sith Lord was pulling all the strings. I really hate the Jedi for that in the prequels. Anakin was a good kid and didn’t deserve that fate

    • @aminemeskini9192
      @aminemeskini9192 Před 2 lety +3

      anakin and maul stories were very sad

    • @Wolffman109
      @Wolffman109 Před 2 lety +1

      Crucified by the chances of his life, it was like Anakin Skywalker had no chance at all.

  • @Pixel9897
    @Pixel9897 Před 2 lety +58

    Outside of palpatine's ending in this one,
    this is the best fan fiction you've ever done. Truly amazing and I believe it's how George would play it out. The concept of Anakin finally becoming a true jedi and getting powerful, strong with the force and leaning all it's aspects after speaking with Qui Gon is extremely interesting, like his whole life was meaningless to that point, that all his teachings he got were horrible and wrong. Once again, GREAT stuff, almost perfect.

  • @echo013winter3
    @echo013winter3 Před 2 lety +54

    I really liked this. I do believe Anakin would reveal the truth of his relationship with Padme, however. Qui-Gon may not have been overly powerful in life but in death I feel he could rival Palpatine, at least in knowledge of the Force.

  • @MCsAdvice
    @MCsAdvice Před 2 lety +124

    The one thing Anakin desperately needed, was understanding from others.

    • @JohnFourtyTwo
      @JohnFourtyTwo Před 2 lety +15

      Agreed and that is why I always believed the entire Jedi Council failed him, not just Obi-Wan because they all knew how dangerous he could become.

    • @tommytommy7535
      @tommytommy7535 Před 2 lety +9

      the one thing palpatine gave him

    • @aquilazyy1125
      @aquilazyy1125 Před 2 lety +10

      Now come think of it, Obiwan definitely could have understood and comforted Anakin since he too lost his loved one (though this was not known at the time while they were filming RotS I suppose).

    • @Zach-lv5qs
      @Zach-lv5qs Před 2 lety +4

      A father figure.

    • @tommytommy7535
      @tommytommy7535 Před 2 lety +2

      @@Zach-lv5qs he got palpatine as his father figure

  • @sociallyintrovertedasmr8923
    @sociallyintrovertedasmr8923 Před 2 lety +170

    I always enjoy your alternatives but this is probably one of my favorites and most plausible. Qui-gon wasn''t on the council because he couldn't stomach how rigid they were with their rules. He would have already known about Anakin's and Padme's relationship and that they had children AND he would have been more accepting of it. With that knowledge, Qui-gon would have been instrumental in helping the Jedi understand that "attachments" aren't necessarily a bad thing and would have assisted Anakin with training Luke and Leia. At least until they become teens because we all know that teens refuse to listen to authority figures *facepalm and shakes head*

    • @Wolffman109
      @Wolffman109 Před 2 lety +1

      It's true. They do.

    • @TheBlueBaron
      @TheBlueBaron Před 2 lety +6

      @@Wolffman109 Not all of them do; I didn't. Of course, the only way to raise teenagers that still submit to authority figures is for the parents to still submit to authority figures. One of the advantages of being a monarchist.

    • @persassyjackson1688
      @persassyjackson1688 Před 2 lety +3

      I'm not sure teens are anti-authority lmao. We just tend to want to do our own thing

    • @GeraltofRivia22
      @GeraltofRivia22 Před 2 lety +3

      This is just George Lucas fucking up the Jedi. Nowhere in the OT did it say attachment was forbidden for a Jedi. Obi Wan talks as if it was normal for Anakin to have kids.

    • @jakstorm3180
      @jakstorm3180 Před 2 lety +1

      Qui gon spoke to Anakin on Mortis, It's hard to say, It's the only time he really said anything to him, Palpatine was there and knew.. I think Anakin would have told Qui Gon about everything as a Padawan, when he killed the sand people, all he had was Grampa Palpatine. Had Qui Gon spoke to Anakin more often to yes it would have changed everything.. Palpatine was a step ahead the whole time. The Jedi were spread thin after all there is no time to clear the mind in the middle of the galactic war. Palpatine timed everything too perfectly. He kept Anakin close.

  • @alperenkir3859
    @alperenkir3859 Před 2 lety +22

    Anakin literally talked with Qui-Gon's force ghost in the Mortis Arc; so, I don't think he would be surprised that much when he heard his voice. I think you forgot about that.

    • @chloeleau
      @chloeleau Před 2 lety +11

      Anakin lost his memories of Mortis when he left

  • @yehudisfriedman8459
    @yehudisfriedman8459 Před 2 lety +11

    What I like about this is that it still stays true to Anakin’s character and the story after the change still feels like how events would have realistically unfolded

  • @JackEdgren
    @JackEdgren Před 2 lety +118

    "Qui-Gon never told Anakin what to do" - Theory
    "Anakin! Stay in the cockpit!!!" - Qui-Gon
    Im just joking around, i know your point was adhering to more philosophical decisions presented to Anakin ^_^

    • @pablopaleo4778
      @pablopaleo4778 Před 2 lety +5

      Lol, and Anakin did technically stay in the cockpit 😂. But for real, a great thing they did in Phantom Menace was portray ani’s respect for qui-gon

  • @LeroySinclair69
    @LeroySinclair69 Před 2 lety +67

    Qui gon gin is the most underrated character in SW, would be great to see him in Obi Wan.
    Do you think if he was alive after Ep1, would he have fought in the clone wars or refused?

    • @WildWeavile
      @WildWeavile Před 2 lety +10

      He would have went with Anakin to go see his mother which would have most likely prevented shmi's death.

    • @superbennyboy1
      @superbennyboy1 Před 2 lety

      @@WildWeavile can you explain how it would prevent the death?

    • @mahguvnah7403
      @mahguvnah7403 Před 2 lety +1

      @@superbennyboy1 Most likely he would have reacted sooner to Anakin's visions, thus forestalling her death.

    • @superbennyboy1
      @superbennyboy1 Před 2 lety

      @@mahguvnah7403 I didn't know her death had anything to do with anakin or visions. I thought she was tortured and succumbed to her wounds. Anakin only knew she was sold when he revisited the farm. We would need earlier warnings to prevent her wounds.

    • @superbennyboy1
      @superbennyboy1 Před 2 lety

      @@mahguvnah7403 or would qui gon have other means to find schmi that anakin did not have? Interesting

  • @Goliath691975
    @Goliath691975 Před 2 lety +14

    This is my favorite "what if?". I've liked them all but this one just makes the most sense to me. Keep doing the "what if?" videos. And congratulations on 5 years.

  • @whistlingwolf5259
    @whistlingwolf5259 Před 2 lety +26

    This was amazing. I love how you did this video, and the most realistic ending I have come across, Qui Gon Jinn is my most favorite Jedi closely followed by Obi Wan and Anakin. Just an idea for a future video if you so wish could you do a video about Qui Gon and Obi Wan's Master Padawan relationship and how Qui Gon trained Obi Wan?

  • @Scirollo
    @Scirollo Před 2 lety +25

    I love this happy ending, super well done. As George once said, you don't need to kill off a character to make people feel. George would be proud of this man, well done!

  • @madisonruffles226
    @madisonruffles226 Před 2 lety +68

    If sidious has “unlimited” power and Vader can only be 80% of that doesn’t that still make Vader’s power unlimited 🤔

    • @IndianaJoe0321
      @IndianaJoe0321 Před 2 lety +7

      Fuzzy math makes my brain hurt! 🤣

    • @donkbox7317
      @donkbox7317 Před 2 lety +9

      Yes anything multiplied by infinity is infinity. However since everyone can be a multiple of sidious' power so their all infinite mathematically. So sidious has finite power but it is massssive

    • @Historicutuber
      @Historicutuber Před 2 lety

      Lol

    • @PacisJusticia
      @PacisJusticia Před 2 lety +3

      @@donkbox7317 I don't mean to be pedantic but you're not correct. He says quite clearly 'UNLIMITED POWER' which points to a power that isn't just massive, but unlimited. :V _/

    • @donkbox7317
      @donkbox7317 Před 2 lety +4

      @@PacisJusticia by that logic everyone has infinite power because everyone can be modelled as a multiple of sidious’ power

  • @stevenwilkerson7037
    @stevenwilkerson7037 Před 2 lety +25

    I can't believe that it has been five years already, crazy how fast time can fly by! Congrats on this milestone, and thank you for all of the wonderful Star Wars content you have produced so far! :)

  • @Makise3
    @Makise3 Před 2 lety +2

    I’m so so happy you’re doing fan fictions again! It was always my favorite thing about your channel and I really hope you keep making them again.

  • @jackbagley8498
    @jackbagley8498 Před 2 lety +34

    Happy 5 years theory I’ve been here for 3 years and I love this content!

    • @noahsg7631
      @noahsg7631 Před 2 lety +1

      Its a shame your a yankees fan though

    • @jackbagley8498
      @jackbagley8498 Před 2 lety +1

      @@noahsg7631 lol it’s for the empire

    • @noahsg7631
      @noahsg7631 Před 2 lety +1

      @@jackbagley8498 That makes sense then lmao

  • @ladymandoreviews
    @ladymandoreviews Před 2 lety +24

    I can't describe how much I loved this fan fiction! I want this to exist in a parallel universe so much!

  • @TheAquaAuthor
    @TheAquaAuthor Před 2 lety +4

    I miss these. I want more, I've rewatched your fan fic videos over and over again, and I love them so much. I would love to see more of them!

  • @DominickRuocco
    @DominickRuocco Před 2 lety +6

    This was my first fan fiction that I have watched on this channel and it was fantastic. I would love to see a part 2. Congratulations on 5 years and thank you for all of the amazing work that you do for the Star Wars community.

  • @TitanusGojiraIsSigma
    @TitanusGojiraIsSigma Před 2 lety +35

    "I've waited 4- No, 5,000 years for this."
    -Kars

    • @ultimatekars4416
      @ultimatekars4416 Před 2 lety

      Yes 😏

    • @TitanusGojiraIsSigma
      @TitanusGojiraIsSigma Před 2 lety

      @@ultimatekars4416 Someone's able to think again I see.

    • @ultimatekars4416
      @ultimatekars4416 Před 2 lety

      @@TitanusGojiraIsSigma Indeed! I'm chilling, sipping tea in Morioh Town. I'm with a kid with stupid hair 😂😂

    • @devinb3878
      @devinb3878 Před 2 lety

      @@ultimatekars4416 what have you done

  • @Ellevie_Olivia
    @Ellevie_Olivia Před 2 lety +13

    If Qui-Gon was in Revenge of the Sith, he could help Anakin see how the dark side is taking advantage of his fear and say no to its offer.
    Dave Filoni said that Qui-Gon was the father figure Anakin never had so I think he would be able to help Anakin face his fear and overcome it. Instead of telling Anakin to deny his fear by saying ‘Let go of your attachments!’ as the Jedi Council did.
    Anakin’s biggest fear is fear of abandonment. He went down the rabbit hole of trying his best to not be abandoned so much so that he ended up abandoning his wife and children himself! That’s sad!

  • @BleachBtch
    @BleachBtch Před 2 lety +2

    What a GREAT fanfic, Fantastic job as usual and Congrats on 5 yrs!!

  • @GameBlock_
    @GameBlock_ Před 2 lety +3

    PLEASE make a part two of this. This was so good!

  • @zkwarrior3112
    @zkwarrior3112 Před 2 lety +16

    Glad to see Fan-Fictions come back!

  • @kjydlonge2896
    @kjydlonge2896 Před 2 lety +16

    I hope to see Gui-Gon in the new obi wan series because obi-wan was suppose to learn how to communicate with him in his exile

  • @hplpresents1215
    @hplpresents1215 Před 2 lety +1

    You one of my fav you tubers and I love watching ur fan fictions. Please bring them back

  • @johnnysir7114
    @johnnysir7114 Před 2 lety +2

    He doesn't do sequel fanfics
    Thats why I love this channel

  • @sensei2248
    @sensei2248 Před 2 lety +18

    I love how at the end you led it into George’s Sequel Trilogy! This video is much better than expected 🤍

  • @noahsibahi-jackson8757
    @noahsibahi-jackson8757 Před 2 lety +37

    This fan fiction was so well done it honestly made me emotional as it brought me back to 5 years ago back when the channel started in which would confide in your videos to help with my depression

  • @jonwoods1892
    @jonwoods1892 Před 2 lety +2

    That was amazing thank you for everything you have done for us over the last five years.

  • @zacpoirrier3569
    @zacpoirrier3569 Před rokem

    This is my FAVORITE “what if” you’ve done man. Qui Gon and Plo Koon are far and away my favorite Jedi. So I I love your videos involving QGJ.

  • @highground8601
    @highground8601 Před 2 lety +23

    It would be cool if they made a what happened if series on Disney plus but for star wars

  • @aaronconnolly3072
    @aaronconnolly3072 Před 2 lety +35

    I still believe that Obi-Wan was pre-maturely made a Jedi master. Even though I love him, he was not like his master, where he just stuck to the book.(AKA the council) I believe Anakin would've trusted Qui-Gon because he simply ain't no snitch.

    • @bmorbus
      @bmorbus Před 2 lety

      That exactly the point, if Quigon would have survive Anakin would be properly trained, with Obi-one Anakin acted like brothers, he was spoiled, but with a fatherly role around things would change

    • @JohnFourtyTwo
      @JohnFourtyTwo Před 2 lety +1

      Agreed plus I thought of Obi-Wan training Anakin just after he became a Jedi Knight was not right either. I believe only Jedi Masters should train Padawans since the word "master" comes from the Latin word "magister" which means teacher. Also the Padawans should be trained by various masters and not just one to get a well-rounded eduation on various techniques and not just one. Only after years of experience as a knight should Obi-Wan be made a master and by then he would've been Anakin's last master.

    • @kyberkreeper
      @kyberkreeper Před 2 lety +1

      Not even the Council stuck to the book. They had a choice: serve the will of the Force, or the Republic. They made that choice when they sent troops to Geonosis in AOTC. That book went partially out the window then.

  • @patriotforlife6592
    @patriotforlife6592 Před 2 lety

    As always, a pleasure to listen to your content friend. Happy 5 years

  • @Kryptarch
    @Kryptarch Před 2 lety +4

    LOVE this!! Can't wait for part 2! It would be amazing if Luke gradually brought Talon to the Light and maybe they started a relationship of sorts,

  • @obi-wankenobi592
    @obi-wankenobi592 Před 2 lety +16

    Qui-Gon was always one of my favorite characters, I hope he’s a character in the next battlefront (if there will be a third)

    • @kubix426
      @kubix426 Před 2 lety

      Nah no way 💀💀

    • @fanofmetal1
      @fanofmetal1 Před 2 lety

      No one would play the rest of the characters.

  • @darkace5959
    @darkace5959 Před 2 lety +17

    This was an excellent fan fiction from the Jedi’s point of view. I want to know what happens with other “Legends” Jedi like Kyle Katarn, Mara Jade, Corran Horn, Sil Gal, etc. Also what would become of the lovable scoundrels Han, Chewy and Lando?

  • @davidcox12317
    @davidcox12317 Před 2 lety +1

    I would love to see a part two and three. Watching your videos are like watching star wars shorts so entertaining and full of quality content.

  • @nickw4368
    @nickw4368 Před 2 lety +3

    Let's get it theory!! 5 years strong and I loved being with you all the way. Can't wait for PART TWO

  • @tyranusarchive6984
    @tyranusarchive6984 Před 2 lety +8

    What if Leia, Lando, and Chewe caught up to Boba and Han in the Empire Strikes Back? That would have been an awesome fight.

  • @hunterkiller1440
    @hunterkiller1440 Před 2 lety +498

    Pity Liam Neeson was in a car accident, otherwise he would've been in ROTS.

    • @antexexe4081
      @antexexe4081 Před 2 lety +16

      What do you mean car accident?

    • @jorgex2000
      @jorgex2000 Před 2 lety +86

      @@antexexe4081 I'm guessing that during the filming he was in an accident which lead to his scene being removed from the movie.

    • @realmicahmillard
      @realmicahmillard Před 2 lety +91

      @hunterkiller1440 Liam Neeson was filming BATMAN BEGINS, he had a schedule conflict to begin with which is why he turned it down intially.

    • @realmicahmillard
      @realmicahmillard Před 2 lety +60

      @hunterkiller1440 the motor cycle accident happened in 2000 so by the time they were filming Revenge of the Sith in 2003 and 2004 he would've been healed enough to film the scene.

    • @cuumbanana3521
      @cuumbanana3521 Před 2 lety +7

      @@realmicahmillard revenge of the sith came out in 2003, filming was before then

  • @nikolaia_kiev_guy8735
    @nikolaia_kiev_guy8735 Před 2 lety +2

    That is one amazing piece of fan fiction, man! Part 2, please!

  • @josephmurray6187
    @josephmurray6187 Před 2 lety

    dude! i think this is your best theory what if video yet! I love this idea that you came up with!

  • @stefanloncar6868
    @stefanloncar6868 Před 2 lety +18

    What if Dooku and Grievous betrayed and killed Chancelor Palpatine at beggining of Revenge of The Sith ?

    • @floriantinschert5542
      @floriantinschert5542 Před 2 lety

      Not a chance, Sidious would have slaughtered them. Just look at how he dealt with Savage & Maul. Sure, Dooku is more powerful but not THAT powerful.

    • @Desjarlais07
      @Desjarlais07 Před 2 lety

      @@floriantinschert5542 yeah but palpatine trained maul mostly in lightsaber combat and less on the force...more or less just how to tap into the dark side with anger.

    • @floriantinschert5542
      @floriantinschert5542 Před 2 lety

      I know. But what I’m referring to here is the ease with which he slaughtered them. There’s a reason Dooku never challenged Sidious directly and kept looking for a really powerful apprentice - he knew he would have been toast. And Grievous, come on, he wasn’t a match for Obi-Wan or any of the really skilled Jedi. And they had no chance against Palpatine, except for Windu and even that’s debatable.

    • @stefanloncar6868
      @stefanloncar6868 Před 2 lety

      @@floriantinschert5542 Mace was trained by Yoda and reason he managed to take down Sidious was cause he used V-Pod from
      Dooku was also trained by Yoda

  • @bankerduck4925
    @bankerduck4925 Před 2 lety +8

    Back to his roots. This was simply AMAZING.
    Truly a wonderful and actually a very good, absolutely awesome fanfiction! Thank you!

  • @MrE23rising
    @MrE23rising Před 2 lety

    Great video ! Your fan fictions are the reason why I subscribed in 2017 ! Keep up the great work !

  • @derangedband
    @derangedband Před 2 lety

    How have I known about this channel so long but only just properly checked it out and subbed! I absolutely love these videos. There's so many characters you like enough to want a happy ending for. I've read it in the comments before but a star wars 'what if' would be fantastic with you at the helm 😊

  • @lucifermorningstar2505
    @lucifermorningstar2505 Před 2 lety +12

    Tbh if the Jedi wasn’t so cheap they could have came back for his mom and bought her freedom

  • @DarthAxolotl
    @DarthAxolotl Před 2 lety +3

    I've missed these fan fics so much, it's how I found this channel. The nostalgia is real

  • @darkhollow6487
    @darkhollow6487 Před 2 lety

    Please do more fan fiction/theory videos, this video was so good, it feels like your reading a book the way you script the video and voice the characters (your Anakin impression is superb), the music the back ground just adds so much with out you even noticing, and I'm having a hard time saying what else I great because the whole video is great, please make more theory videos, and thank-you.

  • @carlosgalvan9496
    @carlosgalvan9496 Před 2 lety +1

    Fan fictions were always my favorite videos of Star Wars theory

  • @ZacharyShadowkillThe1st
    @ZacharyShadowkillThe1st Před 2 lety +10

    You're an amazing guy, SWT. We love you! And your Fanfictions. My personal favorites are "What if Obi-Wan didn't leave Anakin" and "What if Mace Windu went to Utapau." I love a good redemption arc. Emphasis on the word GOOD. Because there are many redemption arcs that just feels rushed & forced, because of how poorly written some of them are! (I'm looking at you, Kylo Ren).

  • @Atomic-Bomberr
    @Atomic-Bomberr Před 2 lety +6

    Happy Five Years man! Can’t believe I was 16 when I found your CZcams Channel, keep up the good work which has bring enjoyment to so many! too many more years 🥂
    Just watched the video and all I have to say - PART 2 WITH MUAL

  • @starwarstairique
    @starwarstairique Před 2 lety +2

    This videos good af 🔥🔥🔥 Wholesome ending we’d love to see on the big screen

  • @youtubeman2001
    @youtubeman2001 Před 2 lety +1

    One of your best videos yet

  • @CloaxHere
    @CloaxHere Před 2 lety +57

    Hold on, if all this hypothetically happened, wouldn't Maul still be in custody? And where is Ashoka in all of this?

    • @frostburn6784
      @frostburn6784 Před 2 lety

      This is why its a bad theory smh

    • @CloaxHere
      @CloaxHere Před 2 lety +22

      @@frostburn6784 I wouldn't say it's a bad theory, it's just there are lots of things that SWT either forgot or didn't include for the sake of trying to make the theory work.

    • @NotAn_NPC
      @NotAn_NPC Před 2 lety +17

      @@CloaxHere Star Wars has so much lore and so many characters that it's almost impossible to not miss Out on some characters or events etc.

    • @FreezeFun
      @FreezeFun Před 2 lety +3

      Maybe Maul got away instead of captured. Ahsoka still left the Order.

    • @theimprovedbore550
      @theimprovedbore550 Před 2 lety

      its possible that ahsoka was simply assigned to someone else

  • @stephenkyburz6529
    @stephenkyburz6529 Před 2 lety +4

    06:21 "He never told Anakin what to do"
    *Shows the only moment when Qui-Gon tells Anakin what to do*

  • @ethanblickenstaff3812
    @ethanblickenstaff3812 Před 2 lety

    So glad you're doing fan fictions again. These are my favorite videos on CZcams.

  • @dabatramzy7027
    @dabatramzy7027 Před rokem

    I love this homie. You constantly out-doing yourself and improving and is blessed to watch. MTFBWY ❤️

  • @aliriogarciaflamenco3048
    @aliriogarciaflamenco3048 Před 2 lety +4

    This would be an awesome "What If". For some reason I will like to see this in the big screen. Thanks for this 5 years and congrats man. Let's make it 5 more!

  • @Mindstormer
    @Mindstormer Před 2 lety +4

    Love the depth you gave in this one it’s so good! One plot hole though. Maul wouldn’t have escaped if order 66 didn’t happen, at least not right away. Someone would have to rescue him. I think that should be another fan fiction and maybe continue this story too! I would love that!

  • @darthgambit5567
    @darthgambit5567 Před 2 lety

    I've waited for this since you brought it up in a stream, so hype

  • @panosyiotis3686
    @panosyiotis3686 Před 2 lety

    One of your best videos yet, my friend, keep it up.

  • @MerkFreeks
    @MerkFreeks Před 2 lety +6

    Really wish we got this in some form in the movies.
    Also technically Anakin spoke to Qui Gon on Mortis during the CW.

    • @Jahomey505
      @Jahomey505 Před 2 lety

      We probably would’ve if the prequels were made first

    • @Jahomey505
      @Jahomey505 Před 2 lety

      @@HO-zy2bv no I mean if the prequels were made before the originals, we probably could’ve gotten a story like that. But the prequels could only do so much because it was always gonna have to turn out to what we got in the originals

  • @JBaker17
    @JBaker17 Před 2 lety +2

    This fan-fiction is by far my favorite. It kept me invested the entire episode. Thank you, and happy 5-years!

  • @Adassity
    @Adassity Před 2 lety

    I subscribed for the ”What if” videos. Good to see them return

  • @jw6489
    @jw6489 Před 2 lety +1

    This videos was AMAZING
    Pls do part 2.

  • @Palps_Was_Taken
    @Palps_Was_Taken Před 2 lety +10

    Can you make a theory about the multiple realities, with Ahsoka being alive or dead depending on rebels season 4? There are several good videos on it. But I love the video feels like I’m going back to the roots of Star Wars Theory.

  • @hellraiderpl559
    @hellraiderpl559 Před 2 lety +7

    A fanfiction! What a nice surprise. Maybe do some sequel fanfics if you want? My ideas:
    - What if Chewbacca killed Kylo Ren in TFA?
    - What if Finn didn't survive?
    - What if Han Solo didn't die?
    - What if Kylo Ren came back home with Han?
    - What if Luke agreed to return from exile?

  • @lilstribss1010
    @lilstribss1010 Před 2 lety +4

    Can’t wait for part 2 Theory good to see fan fictions again. Loved it.

  • @empvms
    @empvms Před 2 lety +2

    Congratulations! You Have Always Been A Part Of My Childhood. And Thank You For The Fanfics. They Are My Favorite. Always So Entertaining And Makes Me Wonder More. Again, Thank You For Entertaining Me And My Family And Friends. :)

  • @joeymuscarella6358
    @joeymuscarella6358 Před 2 lety +5

    Congrats on 5 years been watching for a while and will continue to for a long time

  • @My2cents.
    @My2cents. Před 2 lety +47

    One doesn’t experience self-transcendence, the illusion of self only dissipates🎈

    • @bludragonproject9677
      @bludragonproject9677 Před 2 lety +1

      You are right from a certain point of view. You must expand your awareness and observe from a different, a higher perspective to truly understand what has transpired.

    • @omerginawi9768
      @omerginawi9768 Před 2 lety

      I have you seen many times

    • @failure4452
      @failure4452 Před 2 lety +1

      Balloon

  • @projenstar2159
    @projenstar2159 Před 2 lety

    Need a part two for this 🤙🏻 love the Theory videos and would love to see a "what if" series for Star Wars.

  • @dfo627
    @dfo627 Před 2 lety

    Any of your videos seem accurate to the stories! Tremendous job! Please make a part two of this, I’m very interested! God bless you!

  • @DerpedGamer
    @DerpedGamer Před 2 lety +4

    This is a fantastic fan-fic. I'm genuinely excited to see a part 2!

  • @starwarsfiction
    @starwarsfiction Před 2 lety +17

    There’s a chance Anakin wouldn’t turn 🤭

  • @florisdw1499
    @florisdw1499 Před 2 lety

    I missed these so much. Please do this more often👏🏻

  • @itsnot1
    @itsnot1 Před 2 lety

    I love these videos I would love love love a part 2 I've missed these a lot keep up the great work

  • @Arcflo
    @Arcflo Před 2 lety +2

    I got chills man! Thank you Theory you’ve truly been a huge inspiration to me!

  • @DingleDangle66
    @DingleDangle66 Před 2 lety +5

    If Qui Gon appeared, he could probably try and make me a Jedi Master....

  • @willbrett5203
    @willbrett5203 Před 2 lety +1

    Congrats on 5 years I remember finding your channel in 2016 after watching The force awakens for the first time

  • @cadestpeter7550
    @cadestpeter7550 Před 2 lety

    please do a part two, I love these what if's please continue making these.