The Titan Submarine Implosion - Blender 3d Simulation
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 06. 2023
- 3d reconstruction made in Blender of how could possibly have been the implosion of the Oceangate Titan submarine.
On 18 June 2023 5 people attempted an exploration aiming to see the rest of the Titanin in the deep Ocean.
Events turned out catastrophic since the submarine was not ready to resist the pressure of 4000 meters under the deep ocean, and it imploded.
This simulation was made for research purpose with extremely serious intentions.
I dont intend in any way to lack respect to anybody involved in the catastrophic event.
Music: Power Music Factory
Channel URL : / @powermusicfactory - Věda a technologie
‘Blender’ is an unfortunate name given the events.
lol
dark humour is best humour
True that !
I laughed way harder at that than I should have.
Oh dude I hate you for making me laugh, I did not come here to laugh, god damn it bro
The submersible has too much plasticity in this simulation. The Titan is made from titanium and carbonfibre held together with rivets and epoxy resin. Titanium is a very hard metal, and carbonfibre tends to splinter rather than bend and deform. The force of the implosion seems to apply equally in all directions in the simulation. In reality, most of the force would take the path of least resistance, such as the middle of the pressure hull, the welds between parts, and/or the front window. Recently, some of the wreckage was recovered, and it was found that the titanium end caps were mostly intact, so they shouldn't be disintegrating as seen here.
That’s because it’s a implosion nerd💀
Made more sense, thanks for the explanation!
@@blizzard7993🤓
@@blizzard7993 tell me you're a fcking idiot without telling me you're a fcking idiot
☝️🤓
Carbon fiber doesn’t bend the way metals do. It shattered. That’s why they found large titanium pieces, but no large carbon fiber pieces. It still crushed them instantly though.
Interesting.
Enough time elapsed for them to still have experienced unimaginable pain though, they likely didn’t have enough time to identify its source or get panicked about it
@@ericfelds6291as far as I understand it at that depth the pressure killed then faster than the human eye can send signals back to the brain. Maybe they heard a creaking type sound but I doubt they even saw the sub implode
@@ericfelds6291no it didn't lmao. They felt absolutely nothing. Instant death faster than their brain could comprehend.
@@realbesnikedits wrong, pain is perceived faster than anyother sensation in the body, it registers twice as fast as we recognize sound, and 1.5X faster than tactile touch. It takes less than 100ms to feel pain, lower estimations are the sub imploded in one second, higher estimations 2 or even 3 seconds elapsed. Sorry this was not a painless death.
What people need to understand watching this, is it was this slow in order to watch the process. In reality it would have been violent and instantaneous. It would have taken roughly one millisecond to implode and it takes roughly 100 milliseconds to register pain. The people on board have been dead before they even felt the water touch their skin.
I wonder what happened to their bodies? Were they like dissolved in a split second? Will anything be ever found back like a piece of a shoe for instance like on Titanic itself? I feel sad for the remaining relatives. 🙏🏻
actually everyone else is wrong you guys are all using this info from youtube and other news reporters that know nothing, now listen if you are descending slowly it would not crush instantly it would slowly start to crush because how slow they are moving down slowly adding up more pressure
@@ihadtochooseaname8532 No there is nothing left of them its like cremation but at instant speed like being on the surface of the sun fast.
And it was made of carbon fiber. It would have shattered rather than crumple
1 millisecond? So you are physist. How do you know, how quick it will take. If 1 milliseconds, or 20 millisecond? Where do you have sources from?
Would like to see a updated version now that we know the titanium end cape survived completely intact.
This simulation was really off, actually. I won't go into detail because I'm too lazy but just do some more research
Exactly
Not gonna lie, catastrophic implosion have recently intrigued me. The titan submersible imploded violently, then followed by an immediate explosion. It Kinda reminded me of the effects of a dying star. A dying star implodes from extreme forces of its own gravity, they violently explodes creating a supernova.
No video simulation can duplicate the actual speed of this catastrophic decompression. There and gone in a blink faster than the human eye and brain can function.
Ain’t go cap I’ve had the same interest in Implosion. All due respect to the family that lost loved ones. But I really want to see what it would look like when a proper submarine goes down with a sub that can’t handle that kind of pressure.
@@badcosine6449 Imagine an M-80 blowing up type of flash. Only you need to realize it imploded before it exploded. The humans vaporized. Perhaps a few teeth made it to the bottom.
I wonder if they're able to deploy a submersible that has similar properties to the same depth and film it. Might be costly but sure is interesting to see the implosion on camera
@@riba7069 There one second and gone the next. Nothing to see other than a cloud of crap raining down to the seabed.
Guess they should've hired some "uninspiring" engineers.
agreed
Yup, the boring old white 50 year old guys who actually know what they are doing.
Turns out boring old white guys know a lot about safety and preventing disasters like this.
Eccept, so far they have recovered the tail cone, circular titanium end pieces, and sled.
It was the carbon tube in the centre that failed and imploded.
true, but when I already finished this there was not yet that much detailed informations around the web lol
@@RaffoVFXSo do an update.... The animation is good so you might as well... It is educational after all... This tragedy will hopefully save the lives of any future people that think they can skip steps and take it lightly......
@@RaffoVFX so why you something finishing with uncomplete information?
@warrax111 You do know that he can just make another updated animation? It's not like he lost the blender project
@@bubblezovlove7213 just do it yourself. You’re not his boss
Bro put a beat over this 💀
This simulation is alot more accurate to how it tore apart in the implosion. Well done.
Because other simulations have showed the submersible being squeezed into a chunk of metal, however that wouldnt explain the "debris field" where the parts were all scattered.
However this video is slowed down for understanding purposes. But I think at the end you should've included a real-time version also which would basically be this video but ×10.5 speed to show how it would've actually looked
thanks, next time I will consider putting both slowmo and realspeed veesions:)
@@RaffoVFX 🤜🏻🤛🏻 Awesome!
Just use the playback speed on the video. That little dial looking thing in the upper right corner.
This isnt accurate at all, just look at the images of the recovered debris. Hull completely intact.
@MareShoop ah I actually did that. Thats why I recommended 10.5, cause even with the 2.5x speed, it's not accurate. I downloaded the vid and tried with 10.5 and that's pretty close, that's why I thought of suggesting it to the Channel owner.
ayy yo this a fire trap beat
Keep in mind, these are forces way out of humanity’s control doing this. This implosion would be almost instantaneous at those depths. One moment you’re getting warnings from the craft, and not even a full second later, oblivion.
5ye7y and 65,6ynsrsef
The pressure hull was made of carbon fiber, so the sim should have shown the hull shattering, instead of crumpling and tearing,
remember put the speed x200000
It’s not a bad simulation, but it’s clear the materials do not represent real pressure vessels or are put together in any meaningful way. The aft and forward domes are both titanium and the pressure vessel is carbon fiber, so the CF would fail first. The titanium domes would most likely survive until collision with the body and the tail cone actually did survive for the most part due to being separate from the hull. Again, not a bad animation, just needs work.
They didn`t exactly die in the traditional sense. They basically went from existing to instantaneously non-existing.
My entire argument after someone says "🤓":
Is this done with the finite element method?
I think it would be interesting to see a redo of this based on what actually happened now that we know the parts that stayed intact vs those that broke.
Not at all how it would have happened though, since this shows the nose cone getting obliterated when it was actually recovered fully intact
Quick death... 😢
you for got the blood bro
I’ve got a theory of how the pressure vessel may have actually collapsed.
This goes back to a video I saw of the Ocean Gate team assembling the titanium ring to the Carbon fiber tube. It was fitted in place using an epoxy resin to adhere the titanium ring to the carbon fiber body.
I think with the repeated dives it took, the pressure would have been squeezing on where the titanium ring meets the carbon fiber body, gradually being weakened and getting cracks around the edge of the material.
In addition to the rest of the carbon fiber body likely being pushed beyond its limit as well with each subsequent dive.
But what clues me in the failure was around the titanium rings, they were basically blown clean off, notice the lack of the epoxy resin around where it would’ve met the carbon fiber body.
And that area of the ring and the body is also where the entrance of the Titan sub is, and also notice the lack of a water tight seal where the bell is.
Naaaah pretty innaccurate. The titanium parts didn't deform, as demostrated by the debris found. It is more likely that the carbon fiber imploded with lots of fragments. Carbon fibre residual elongation is near 0% therefore it cannot plasticly deform but implodes in thousands of parts. That's likely how it happened.
Edit: titanium is a pretty strong isotropic material which takes far grater than 380atm to even deform a little. It's bulk modulus is around 1e6 atm to give an idea.
The end caps and outer fairings were recovered intact, they were not crushed as in this video.
Also, the carbon fiber hull would not crush like this, but rather shatter into tiny pieces and powder in a cloud, in milliseconds
Everything *EXCEPT* the titanium hemisphere part of this implosion is fairly accurate. Good job 👍
You should created two version in this video. Slomo and fast which is real
true that:)
@@RaffoVFXdo it!
Your eyes can't even catch it at the real speed.
@@katanasharp2866 yes it was nanoseconds i know. But some type of quick efect, anything fast
my stomach when i have to present in front of class
If you played this back at 100x speed it would look more accurate
It's exactly like how you crush a water bottle but with so much pressure
From my understanding the tail of Titan actually wags when it detects anomalies in the hull, before it cracks and explodes, it was actually one of the backup safety systems according to Stockton.
Deforms is a better word for it
"Wags" ... ....
@@YudazOwn yes, the design allowed it to wag like a cat tail as an alert mechanism
@@YudazOwn yes, it’s proven to wag when dangerous levels of cracking is felt. The greater the cracking the more violently it wags
@@didamnesia3575 it’s a piss take
You forgot to add the red mist shooting out in all directions 😂
intentionally
@@RaffoVFX puzzy
Nice animation, in my part I made a CFD anaylsis approximating the size of the sub and at depths of 3800m even at 1 or 2 millisecond time the pressure inside the sub is very very enormous, forces acting inside is very enormous..
Also the heat generated inside the sub as air is being compressed is insane, very hot
It wouldn’t pop like a balloon. It probably just cracked as if you squeezed a hard plastic container in your hand. Also titanium is relatively stiff and most likely didn’t even bend at all considering the weak point was the carbon fiber
Also the tail is not pressurized so if wouldn’t deform
Cool👍
I knew that bag of unused screws ment something
Everyone keeps asking why they can't find the bodies. In point two micro seconds not only did the sub imploded but all five passengers were liquidfide into mush before they could even blink, very sad and quick. RIP
Need to redo the animation where the titanium "dome" endcaps and "rings" survive along with a large chunk of the tail section electronics/mechanics.
The titanium end caps and much of the accessory sections are intact. The carbon fiber hull is the part that was missing and is likely the failure point of the submersible.
the carbon fiber hull would shatter an push off the two titanium bells
true, there is actually a lot that could be better. It was just a quick experiment :)
The joint between, in the bottom from tail to belly may had gave up due to glide load which can be, only caused by excessive descending ratio, according to its build dynamic, structure and materials. * The hallow carbon fiber may have broke just like a bamboo wood due to the pressure they were in at that depth..
Lets see what investigation brings up...
The real event took place in less than a millisecond, for reference, it takes our brain 13 milliseconds to process what we see and 100 milliseconds for the brain to register pain. Because of it, I doubt they felt a thing
No pain, except for the terror they felt as they waited for the implosion--likely lots of warning signs that something serious was wrong.😧
Subnautica in real life:
Inaccurate now since recovered debris is quite large and the dome hatch was largely intact minus the viewing porthole
Your simulation is by far the closest representaion in the way the hull would have fragmented during implosion due to the carbon fiber. Speed that up to where it happens in a millisecond and you see how violent and quick it is. The only difference would be some of the pieces that would not have fragmented such as the titanium parts which they did find the titanium caps intact.
Glad to hear that:)
And you are right, would be more precise having different destruction results for some parts.
can you remake it but make the structure accurate based on all the available reference materials? including the rear, non pressurised chassis and the solid, billet nose..
The implosion was probably worse than this.
100 %
Didn't they recover the titanium ind caps basically intact?
Poor people inside😢
for real
Don't cheap out on submersible materials, kids
Rich people inside
@@jimbronx-mb3ct it doesnt matter .
@@ch36799
There lives still matter!
爆縮のイメージがすごく分かりやすかった！
一気に縮まるから、粉々…そういうことなのね。
Boss: do you work well under pressure
Me:
Not a trip for those who break under pressure
But what’s the explanation that led to the implosion? What went wrong beforehand?
The submarine was poorly built
The human body would be turned into dusty organic sea life food in an instant
The end caps have been recovered intact, the white outer shell has been recovered relatively intact.
Wild.
The landing cage and front dome were recovered intact. I think you got a few inputs wrong.
I don't think it collapsed in on itself with equal pressure from every angle, because the pressure would have been greater where the sub's hull was weaker, at the center of the cylinder - which if true would have sent either end of the sub flying in opposite directions (they were found intact, and far apart, suggesting that's true). It could have happened in so many ways, though, like by coming into contact with the sea floor too quickly; or the viewing window that was supposedly only rated for 1300m being compacted like a plunger toward the tail of the sub, pushing everything out the backend, and shredding the carbon fiber hull from front to back.
The titanium cap was retrieved in a good shape. I guess simulation should be repeated according to the new findings.
The scary thing is that it happened in 0.0000000000000000000000000000000000000000001 MILISECONDS!
This simulation was way overkill. Debris found was more intact.
Coffee and tea = confío en ti ( lo último que le dijeron los millonarios a Stockton Rush antes de subirse al submarino
The only thing is that it happend faster than you can process light, the people on board didn’t know what hit them
Bro good work! Thx
We now know that the titanium pieces were found, in tact.
It makes it seem like it was the boy made of one type of material.
well. I guess you'll need to remake this seeing as the pieces they brought up were in larger pieces than this shows.
me crushing the soda can after finishing my drink:
If you're saying this is what happen accurately you WRONG ,but if this is just for fun and it's just your opinion does not State it's 100% accurate then you are okay because they found a lot of chunks but not the titanium shell obviously but front part and tail and part Electronics plus the titanium front corner with its portal glass gone is entirely somewhat intact but the middle part based on their evidence completely disintegrated but that can change on further investigation but whatever the cause rest in peace those five passengers 🙏 0:28 0:28
I was always curious about implosion.
Can we get a version without slowmo? How does it look in 'real' time o.o
So it melted too?
I appreciate your work with blender and your purpose but according to the new footage of the wrack, there were much bigger parts from the ubot left than everybody thinks. I guess that only the cylinder could have been damaged like in the simulation.
Damn Ocean you scarry !
not accurate because the titanium hemispheres were each pulled from the bottom in one piece and this shows them being ripped apart.
monday (dia del mono)
But the titanium cap with the viewing window remained intact. I think it was only the hill that was severely damaged
This tracks hard i hope they bumpin rip
I just can't get my head around the fact, that it would have happened faster than they would have known what was happening! Faster than a second! Mind blowing (excuse the choice of phrase) The only saving grace is, that they wouldn't have felt it, or known what was about to happen! I feel bad for their families...it's horrific!
Reminds me of that old guy build a home made rocket and launch off trying to proof the earth was flat. But he got flat instead.
What a painful deep death
good effort although its slightly false, the front end of the titan was found and many other parts were also found, which looked very different then this animation
So where did they get the sub wreckage from? and now human remains? Something is not adding up
you're here, theres nothing I fear
Pro tip
Do Not trust your life to wealthy "innovators" with names like "Stockton Rush"
That is all
Don't trust a man with an english accent, got it.
Nice, but not correct. As described on other places, CF materials under the high pressure are very brittle, so the CF cylinder (mid part of Titan's hull) shold be shattered, not deformed.
Wow
Thank you for doing this rendering test! If it hasn't already been stated, there could be benefit to rebuilding the rig so that only the carbon fibre tube at the center of the vehicle implodes, with tail cone and titanium rings end capping the pressure vessel staying intact. Great Rig regardless!
true! I actually wanted to do it, but since I was in a rush I just accepted this as a quick simbolyc simulation :)
Visualization lime this will help the public stay informed. And make the future of pressure vehicles safer!
@@CalvinFalk Agreed, the best thing that people can do is to spread the voice and making informative videos, so that hopefully is not gonna happen again.
(And actually do it not only when something like this happens to some millionaires)
Not correct, because recovery of the components show the connector rings intact. Also the landing sled was intact
Sir, if you could send me this model in STEP file
You forgot to add the bodies in this simulation
Well this was incorrect because the just found the front hull and it was in one piece
Sick beat 😂
Everyone who made this simulations do not understand that there are different materials that react differently. Basically, the carbon fiber shell shattered, and everything else broke away
crispy
Can you recreate it with people inside ?
cruel
How in the world i have this search term 💀
Cool thing btw
Innacurate, the door in the front was completely scratchless
how i wish some body parts were included in the simulation
Those would have disappeared too