Julia Hartley Brewer's furious row on gender reform
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 01. 2023
- The UK Government is not seeking to veto Scottish Parliament legislation “whenever it chooses” by moving against controversial reforms of the gender recognition process passed by Holyrood, Alister Jack has said.
The Scottish Secretary said the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill would have “serious adverse effects” on the operation of UK-wide equalities legislation.
Giving a statement to MPs on the Government’s decision to use Section 35 of the Scotland Act to prevent the Bill from gaining royal assent - the first time such powers have been used since Holyrood was established in 1999 - Mr Jack said “very senior legal opinion” is that using the mechanism is “appropriate”.
Scotland’s First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, has already branded the move a “full-frontal attack on our democratically-elected Scottish Parliament and its ability to make its own decisions on devolved matters”.
She told the BBC the decision will “inevitably end up in court”.
In Westminster, the UK Government was understood to be braced for drawn-out legal wrangling.#talktv
Can humans change their biological sex? And tell us why...
No. You are never born in the wrong body, you are what your meant to be. Yes you can change your shell to fit your your purpose but inside your still the same and always will be.
No, it's a biological and evolutionary impossibility.
Happy to have been able to help.
Why even ask this question? Have we redefined the word "biological" now?
You can't change your Gender it is biologically IMPOSSIBLE to do so.
No, because you came in this world as one ..body and mind ...if your body separate in yr head and think and imagine or get depression or very easy to manipulate ...than you got this, it's not something which should be separate from the body ..so I think it is illness ...and to be treated that way .Why people meditate why monks exsust they all want to rid of "bad thoughts ,bisy mind etc they learn how not to believe mind ..now this all idiots want me to believe what is in there heads and become like them ,no I believe what I see not what you feel ..perace Morgan was good on that one in one show ..but the person didn't like that he indentify as that (..so they are allowed to indentfy how they want , but when someone else as joke says I indentfy as ... they dont like and they say it's not real ,you can not....
On behalf of Scotland, I apologise for that generation.
I'm sure i speak for a lot of England.
1 bad apple can spoil a good bunch.
Not in this case though as i know a hell of a lot of Scott's are against this too.
No apologies needed mate.
We have a fair few divs in England too so your not on your own 👍👍
The youth are lost in most of the west.
Don’t worry pal, it’s happening in England too
@@80PercentScottish ..need WW3 for a good clearout
They are indoctrinated in universitys
It's funny the very people who say she's denying reality,are the very people who have lost touch with it completely
The guys a fruit loop let's put men in women's jails and clamp down on sexual abuse if you don't put a man in a women's jail in first place there's no abuse to clamp down on simple
👌🏾
Well said!!!!
@@CJ-dg6uc and a fruit cake!
Yep!
Biology is “widely discredited” but unsubstantiable personal feelings are fact? We really are in the middle of a mental health epidemic.
I know. It’s fecking insanity.
Need more asylums....
The fact he accuses her of not knowing biological facts is truly flabbergasting.
This is what happens when you normalise insanity!
When they closed all the mental homes
Yep.
Care in the community has failed as the lunatics have taken over the asylum
@@MrOrcshaman I lived in Epsom in the 1970's and 80's, there were at least 8 mental hospitals! By 1990, there were NONE! Today in 2023, lovely residential homes. So, from 1990 to today all THESE patients are on the street! Care in The Community BS.... and that was just in Epsom, Surrey!
This is what happens when you give these adult children too much tolerance!
If this is the youth of my country, We are fucked.
Blame the education system which has indoctrinated them. Scotland, this is your future😢
Blame no discipline for children
Totally f..ked
All of you are spot on.
China putting TikTok out into the west has caused this. An attempt to weaken our youth so we can't form a standing army. In a few decades time, China will make their move and there won't be a damn thing we can do to stop them by that point.
I'm glad you bring these people on to your show. You allow them to display their ideology for all to see.
Don't you mean their idiocy?
It frightens me these are the people looking after us and the country when we get older.
Carl nightmàre
Put the gender reform bill to a public vote in Scotland and watch it be massively voted into nonexistence.
That's why the Scottish public weren't asked their opinion, and the ones who dared voice concern were either ignored or shouted down by mobs of trans 'allies'
DIVERSITY IS WHAT NEEDS ACCEPTANCE MASCULINE WOMAN AND FEMININE MEN NOT DANGEROUS SURGERIES SIGNED TRANS
@@sarahdickson1724 my god i know nothing about this? Wot u saying? It wasnt even put to a vote?
give us a break one life if someone wants to change trough surgery then that is their choice what it got to do with you will it stop you going to work will it stop anything you do if another person changes sex and then they can be happy
@@dianecameron137 You're not understanding our problem. No one wants to stop people who have genuinely medical conditions. That however is not what the snp bill is going to do. Please go read it then you'll understand.
he seems very concerned about the hurt feelings of trans people but when julia asked him about women being raped in prison by men he didn't show an ounce of sympathy for their trauma. the feelings of trans are far more important than the feelings and safety of women and children in his book. disgusting attitude imo.
SHE THATS MASCULINISED WOMAN
what about the women in jail that sexually assault will we move them to a mans prison dont throw all trans into the same pot
Agreed.
Do you have any idea what happens to trans women in men's prisons? Take a guess
@@NaaahBruv got evidence to back those claims?
Imagine telling someone 30 years ago what 2023 would look like.
We wouldn't believe it.
I would advice people .to stop the boats even then
I'm a 90s kid and I wish I was born in a different time cause some of the utter nonsense that the world has to deal with today is absolutely bonkers and I've honestly had enough
People like him is what society can do without
Well.said .
Hear hear
I am Scottish, and thank God this bill should never have been passed. I don't know who this boy is, but biology is biology. He needs to educate his self
As Julia stated you are what you're born has regardless of what you add on or take off bottom line is at then end of the day it's what's on your Passport that tells you what you started life as you can be this person or them /it or they but you will never get away from your Passport...
you need to get educated go and get a count on how many kill themselves because of people like you or maybe you dont mind maybe you dont care that other parents lose their children because are so unhappy we give birth to people and they have the right like you to be who they are in their life they
Sadly woke snowflakes are all of this type of mentality! Should not have even got to this level. Its rediculous. If someone wants to cut bits off or add etc thats fine upto him,her or it. But dont expect to be able to put "yourself" in a natural born gender space. Eg sports, changing rooms, toilets prisons etc. Have your own section as optional.
Himself.
@@grasshoppertime Herself.
I'm becoming more convinced every day that we are going to have to use force to stop the insanity.
We all suffer from some sort mental stress and mine comes from listening to people saying theirs is more important than mine
This needs to be outlawed everywhere around the world
There is no way the vast majority of the Scots believe in the trans BS
Just ask them is it acceptable for someone to hate gays, if they say no then ask why? Tell them that people are born how they are, if someone is born in the wrong body and that's ok then surely someone who is prone to hatred is also allowed to be who he /she is? We are all born with certain predispositions, it's basically DNA and while some people will reject their natural body or sex then some people will reject love, most adults don't care what anybody thinks, feels or does in private but it's a problem if you want to make other people feel, think or act exactly like you! We only want to keep trans issues away from kids to protect them while the other side would lock up half the country because of they act, think, feel or speak, kind of ironic those people talk about tolerance 😂 their actions prove they're dictator fascists, plus they don't care about people like they pretend because they're poisoning young vulnerable impressionable kids to please the trans community, think about the amount of money spent pushing this trans narrative and it affects only 0.001% of the population, there's a bigger % of the population homeless yet you never see any money spent on propaganda for those people! It's all fake concern to use people as puppets to create divide and to force through laws which will keep them maintain power without any accountability, their loyal group of idiotic fans(voters) never question them and twist everything to make the politicians look good, these people are the people used to hold everyone else down in misery without a voice, again very ironic that these people cheer on censorship yet they act like they care about human rights, pure evil and exactly the type of people who allowed Hitler, Stalin, Mao to thrive, it's human nature and history, there's enough gullible self righteous people who think they're morally superior to everyone around them, we get to truly understand now what it was like under these types
It's hard to de-programme someone initiated into a cult.
The only word he said that I agreed with was the word "mental".
@@MarcoNegrisEyeshe a masculine woman still female
@@hospitalsgivingpatientsdan8894 huh? Who we speaking about here??
And it's a cult,growing by the day.gathering power.
Should have asked him “discredited by who?”
Spot on Julia,I’m ashamed I am Scottish after listening to this young man,what’s happening to our youngsters nowadays 🏴🏴🇬🇧🇬🇧🤨
Should you be labelling him a man? You may be mis-gendering him!😅😅😅
I just find it astonishing how such a tiny demographic of the public think they can turn science, social norms and reality on its head just to suit their own fantasies and expect to do it without any resistance?
And yet this tiny demographic has half the world's governments passing legislation that gives them the legitimacy and destroys the legitimacy of scientists, medical doctors, university lecturers and, mostly, of half of the world's population -- women.
This is the only comment we should all be talking about…how are they doing this?
Those who shout the loudest are often the most stupid
Brilliant response and true.
They won't win. Keep fighting against these lunatics. One day they will be ALL in a mental institution, in straight jackets sucking soup from a straw. Forever.
As a Scot I can confirm his pocast is shite 🤣
🤣
Guarantee he is getting some sort of state funding to help him keep going too.
@@Ligerpride impartiality is not his strongest attribute 🤣
😂😂
poocast
Wow, Scotland is in real trouble 😞
He's arguing his twisted fairytale because he's making a living from it.
We use to laugh at people like Ennis today they are no longer a laughing matter there views are dangerous to our children grandchildren wife's sisters mothers daughters
It's name is "Enis"? Really? That's hilarious. First name is actually "P" isn't it?
The problem is people are still laughing at him in the ignorance of not knowing this is being taught in schools, laws are being passed ect.
This guy is not a laughing matter, hes dangerous!
@@EskiLdn Very, very , very dangerous!
The children are our future? R.I.P. humanity.
@@Buster_Piles I think it innes
I find these young zealots truly terrifying: they will sit on their stools and calmly deny manifest observable truths and empirical medical facts - and they do so filled to the brim with pompous self-righteousness and _absolutely certain_ belief in their gibberish. Fascinating to observe, in a way, but also very chilling.
How true...
Thank you for such an intelligent and absolutely to the point response.
Being terrified gives them power. Laugh at them.
.. ah, but they've done a 2 hour seminar at uni, so they know stuff that we don't!.
Yup and indoctrination starts early in education and is brought to maturity in our universities
The fact he kept going on about mental health. Tells you all you need to know.
How can anyone believe that they were born on the wrong body when they have no objective experience to compare it to.
When treating mental health means lopping off healthy body parts, we’ve truly lost our way.
if its your body it up to you what you want stop hating if you dont want to do that then that up to you if others want to how is it affecting your life probably not
@@dianecameron137the argument is letting adolescents do things to their body before they are truly mature. When they reach a sensible age then yes, it’s up to them. But pushing the age back even earlier as the SNP has done is madness
@@dianecameron137 Today i identify as a woman, tomorrow, a man, on wednesdays im an aardvark.
@@dianecameron137
1. Children shouldn't be taking action or making decisions that will impact on their entire future health and well being such as the basic biological ability to procreate. If you're an adult Diane more power to you.
2. The NHS cannot treat critical illness care nor is it hitting targets for cancer - I hate to say this but whilst this is the case tax payers money should not be spent on this kind of field.
@@dianecameron137 if I want to amputate my arms and legs because I identify as paraplegic, does the your body your choice argument still stand?
And to say that it doesn’t harm anybody else… humans have a propensity to be influenced by members of their group. Self harm (of which “reassignment surgery” certainly falls under) isn’t something we should be encouraging in society.
Love Julia for talking straight!
Shocking levels of insanity.
Why are we entertaining an illness!!!!!
It's a power play.
sick people are the ones that cant accept people are different
I agree.can anyone slse out there entertain that we are dealing with a virus,that's spreading and affecting the brain?I cannot explain it any other way.
Because its sexually exciting to a critical mass of men
@@steph6109 It's interesting just how small that critical mass is though. So small in fact that it requires assistance from others (men and women) to give it any power.
I love how Julia just goes for it. She’s totally fabulous
He looks so shocked when she tells the truth and states facts. How dare she!
Thank you for standing firm with common sense Julia.
“Never argue with an fool. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.”
“Never wrestle with a pig, you will both get dirty and the pig will like it…”
“Never wrestle with a pig, you will both get dirty and the pig will like it..”
You cannot have a conversation with madness.
Correct. You can't argue with stupid.
Touché!
Well done Julia
I would have had his mike cut off in the first 2 minutes, you cannot get anywhere in any discussion when two people talk continuously AT each other- a couple of years in the Army would sort him out.
@@goosegog47 Also, like most of these mindless left wing activists, they're mostly rude and obnoxious. He talks like a person who thinks he has years of life experience. You are what you are. It's like changing an oak tree into a willow.
His argument doesn't even make any internal sense..he is saying why should people have to wait longer and endure the discomfort of being in the wrong body but the Bill takes away the need for any medical processes before changing gender, so how would that make anyone feel more comfortable in their body; you basically pop a wig on and Bob's your uncle (or maybe your Aunt!) People have lost their minds. I just don't understand how we ended up in this madness.
like talking at a nursery, he has no idea of life, embarrassing himself
There are over 6,000 physiologial differences between men and women. Despite how much Enis has been indoctrinated, his absolute disregard for women and girls, and how many surgeries a person gets and drugs he takes, that fact does not change.
Hes worried about trans women feeling and not feel alienated
Prison for him
@@catcoffee7958 He's worried about men.
Apparently, according to this boy, the facts have been 'discredited' ! lol lol
@@catcoffee7958 notice these leftists are never concerned about trans men (women) all that much. It’s always about trans woman (ie men)
God he's irritating, I'm Scottish & hate what the SNP are doing to my country 🏴 🤝 🏴 🇬🇧
I feel her pain.
'Are you talking about SMPs or trans people?' Love it Julia! No way this bill should ever be treated seriously. It's wrong. Women will be in danger from sex pests. The SNP are astoundingly short-sighted.
This guy never got the joke 😂😂😂
Maybe they aren't short-sighted at all. Attacks on women and girls seems to be exaclty what they want.
Absolutely. Women are precious and should be protected at all costs. Blokes in drag need to accept the world and reality does not bend around them.
Well tried Julia but you were arguing with the wall, such is the state of the poor lad’s neurosis. 😂😂😂
@@patrickwalker-nolan7617
Actually admits he has a mental illness that was once known as yuppie flu.
I have only one thing to say “You can’t argue with stupid” 🤦🏻🤦🏻
Yes you can! 😀🤡
Idiots, we are surrounded by them
JHB does seem to be exceptionally stupid and incapable of less anything more than basic concepts, even that she is wrong about. Trans folk don’t go on these disgusting gutter shows, they are there to lynch mob you not listen or understand.
@@richardshortall5987 . . . Thanks, bud ! 👍 😀
Win- Win 🏆
You have to be careful because casual onlookers might not notice the difference 👍😂😂
Thanks Alister for standing up for the community against ignorant people.
Julia is a firecracker 🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨
I'm now at the point that when I hear a young person automatically list off their discomforts in life I usually think that they probably have rich parents.
feelings over facts is their motto
What a state we are in!!!!!!!
If he has a degree it should be revoked immediately
People like this guy love using the "discredited research" line while clearly ignoring obvious facts.
Using science they have literally made up.
Like the millions and millions of cells in the human body, everyone of which is xx or xy. Your mental state has nothing to do with this and your mind can not alter a single one of these chromosomes. Sorry, Jock, but you need to buy a simple biology textbook.
I have an invisible disability too. I live with epilepsy. So what? What kudos does that give me to dismiss everyone else’s concerns? NONE. You poor little man….you’re more important, yes, yes! Ridiculous.
No he is pecial very special, like a snow flake 🤣
Hyper narcissistic.
No wonder we are in the state we are in with people like him , god help us .
We live in the age of the freak !
Thanks Julia. Please keep standing up to the deranged.
You are brilliant
This man needs a lot of learning
The lunatics have taken over the asylum ffs
This guy has lost his marbles.
Do you think wearing lipstick, a miniskirt and high heels? That’s what make you a woman, freak? Do you have a UTERUS/ WOMB? Can you get PREGNANT? I experience back pain, tender, nippers, bloating and stomach cramps every month, because I have monthly ministration,period. Also when I was pregnant I had awful morning sickness.
There’s no such thing as tryout being a woman for six months!!! you have to be born a woman because God made you one
👏😂
I think that those conducting these interviews like Julia really miss the opportunity to speak with the same volume as you have to shut these idiots up. If Julia had said just the fact that he'll NEVER experience pregnancy because he's not a woman it ends right there!
Well said 👍👍👍
You cannot reason with ideologues like Ennis. It's essentially like trying to tell a member of a cult that they are a member of a cult; they will literally deny objective reality because to admit to it is so psychologically damaging to them.
Wokeness is a cult, a mass indoctrination that has to bend reality to fit its agenda
Literally deny? Do you just mean deny?
@@markfox1545 No, I mean literally, as in Ennis literally denied objective reality in this video; he didn't suggest, or hypothesize, or simply disagree, he literally, with specific words, denied proven objective biological and evolutionary reality.
Happy to have cleared that up for you, because I appreciate some intellectually challenged individuals struggle to understand what words mean.
I’m trans feminine man not woman we need acceptance not dangerous surgeries
@@hospitalsgivingpatientsdan8894 "Acceptance"? What, exactly, does that mean?
If it means people have to deny objective reality and lie, all to affirm the delusions of a statistically tiny number of people, it's not going to happen.
The argument immediately turns to "Look how much of a victim I also am."
What has happened to this country?
He makes me embarrased to be Scottish
Jesus christ these people are very troubled individuals 🙄
We have never in the past ever debated stupidly but today madness is the norm, my dog wants to be human but it doesn't understand that he's a dog and he's barking up the wrong tree.
😂😂😂
And the tree wants to be a daffodil.
we talking about humans dont be stupid people have the right to be who they are if you happy being you great I bet you wouldnt say it to their faces just think if it was a member of your family or a work mate or would you rather the kill themselves this is not new it has always been thereit 2023 not the dark ages we dont burn witches anymore
Perhaps it's a trans-tree!
Smart that had me in 🪡🤣🤣🤣🤣
The absolute cheek of this guy to use his ME/CFS to say that if we care about ME we should let people legally self-ID. As a woman (an actual woman) with ME, that is absurdly dishonest.
This person is out of his mind or her mind or whatever the hell it identifies as
He is obviously a man. We need to quit denying reality right now. There are no discredited studies. They say an obvious truth, there are men and there are women, period.
he is a boy and that is all there is to it
@@cleopatra1633 how do you know today ?
@@johnadams1856 Because we have eyes.
@@christopher_ecclestone oh really .
Shame, these kids are lost. This guy was so quick to talk about his “disability” he wears his victimhood as a badge of honour…
this is insane
The guy is on another planet
I wish i could use "discredited" the way this young chap uses it. I would be unstoppable
'You're not letting me speak'.... I think that's for the best son!
Innes is not a Scottish woman. I am. Scottish women are cheering a United Kingdom Conservative Party (Never thought I'd ever write those words)... BECAUSE people like Innes are in some parallel universe. Right Innes, explain this... If SNP get their Gender SELF Identification bill through, I (a biological XX woman, could walk into a public Ladies Toilet. A 6 foot man in a suit, with a beard, could be standing in a cubicle, with the door open, urinating in the toilet. I could say. "I don't think you should be here". HE could then phone the Police. A PoliceMAN, could come into the Ladies Toilets to address the phone call. We could have a MAN saying he is self identifying as a woman, and a MALE Police Officer, and I, THE ONLY WOMAN, in.... a LADIES Toilet, could be arrested, for a Hate Crime. Women are being made a 3rd Gender behind MEN, and MEN identifying as women. Men mansplaining what "woman" is, is a Hate Crime, but Trans get to do it EVERY time they assert they are women. XY Chromosomes make you men, and XX Chromosomes make me a woman. Using Innes' Nursery School level, "I'll hold my breath until you agree with me" mindset, every bit of "learning" we have made in multiple millenia, should be thrown in the bin. Because people just out of their teens think THEY are the font of all wisdom. Innes actually proves that children shouldn't be allowed to make life changing decisions, when they barely know how to tie their shoe laces.
@Gogglebox 2.......😁👍
Well done Julia for telling it how it is ! 👍
The man is delusional
Keep pulling it, lad. Don't deny its existence.
I noticed that before he answered any question he had to put forward his own victim status, why is that?
They all play the pathetic victim card nowadays it ensures they never have to get a job
It's the foundation of everything that follows, the crux.
I am living in ireland this young man needs to take a better look into his claim.
It's about POWER not RIGHTS.
I absolutely adore Julia. Often disagree, but it is so good the hear someone actually saying what they mean.
Activism is a way for useless people to feel important, even if the consequences of their activism are counterproductive for those they claim to be helping and damaging to the fabric of society as a whole.
Thomas Sowell
There's no hope anymore is there !!! I'm not religious, but God help us !!! PLEASE !!!
We are all absolutely doomed with young folk like this coming up.
This young person is nuts
The only way to put an end to this madness is if we all push to have man and women recognised as legally protected identities and anyone who says otherwise can be convicted of a hate crime! Enough is enough!!
yeah like in the dark ages think we should move on as all different people on this earth just live your own life people can be whoever they want to be why is it affecting you is it stopping you getting up and living your life no probably not
@@dianecameron137 people never like there own tactics used against them and that's exactly the point!
@@dianecameron137 Correct. People should be able to live their lives as they see fit, within reason of course. However, when a class of activists demand that society at large must acknowledge someone else's delusions, then we have a real problem. Especially when the law is involved. You are now infringing on my right to be able to think and express my own opinions.
Sorry. Ain't happening. I'd rather go to jail than affirm things I know are false.
You can think you have changed into a woman but you will never experience being pregnant morning sickness the hot flushes sore nipple's etc etc , you will never be a true woman so just zip it,
@@dianecameron137 The trouble is it is affecting everyone else. Biological men identifying as women in women’s toilets, changing rooms, refuges and prisons. Plus children being indoctrinated in schools.
Apparently as much as 80 % of the Scottish people do not approve of this legislation . Sturgeon’ s banks of lawyers knew this would cause constitutional problems but she went ahead anyway in order to create another grievance ….but she backed the wrong horse . Time to get rid of devolution. ….it hasn’t worked .
A well educated FOOL
He's been well and truly brainwashed
Scottish education.
She a masculinised woman female
This man is nuts. End of.
Why is she taking a 16 years old seriously
because they'll be the ones in charge soon😱😱😱😱
Who told that young man the rubbish he's spouting? Schools? Universities?
I identify as Nicola's mum. She's now grounded.
He is in a parallel reality.
The removal of the classroom bully has created a generation of weak and incompetent people.
I am beginning to think that JAB we all took has driven us NUTS
That’s what happened when you teach kids « they can be whatever they want to be » 😂
Very true, they take it literally, ridiculous concept.
they"are what they believe themselves to be without real evidence" would be closer to what is happening in the schools , colleges and unversities. the opposite of education is occuring, they are taught to believe the dream is real and the real is nothing but a dream. time to stop the funding of these bodies if they continue to preach such rubbish to the students.
That guy is delusional...
And where is the study showing biology has been disproven?
Keep men out of women's intimate spaces. Keep pushing back! Keep fighting! We're with you. Thank you.
It's about time we started to treat these absurdities with the contempt they deserve.
Poor little boy wants some more attention 😭😭
How she managed not to rip her hair out trying to explain her self is beyond me