GUESS THE INJURY CHALLENGE - 1
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 11. 2022
- Can you name this injury?
MY MUSIC:
Epidemic Sound - Sign up with this link for a FREE 30 day trial!
www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
Follow Me on Twitter!
/ briansutterermd
I'm a doctor and a sports fan and this channel is dedicated to exploring the unique medical side of the world of sports, including NBA, MLB, NFL, UFC, and many more! Breaking down the biggest what ifs, historical injuries and stories, and making learning about medicine fun and relevant for all sports fans!
Anatomy images: www.biodigital.com
DISCLAIMER: Content not intended to be taken as medical advice. Opinions are my own and do not represent those of my employer. I have not personally treated or evaluated the individual(s) discussed in this video. Content used with educational and transformative intent within Fair Use Guidelines
Content owned and produced by Brian Sutterer LLC 2022 - Sport
Appreciate the support on the new format!! Link videos below that I should do in future episodes
An additional information, patellar tendon is a thick and stretchy ligament. It's easier detach it from tibia then snap it. ACL is a range restriction ligament, made to maintain stability of your knee. So the first to suffer from overload. Pretty fun format, let's see some soccer, skiing and fall mechanisms.
Firstly I was noticed he didn't scream, so very unlikely he has severely injured himself. You can see its as if his muscles give way in a fashion faster than humanly possible so its not faked. The noise you hear is a dislocation followed by an immediate relocation of the joint
Acl tear. The tibia relocates after the tear.
No cheating! Let me know if you like this new style of video :D
I love it! Greetings from MX
Yeah I love it
It was awesome!!
Really like this type of video
As a pre-physio student this is perfect. Thanks!
i thought it was a patellar tendon tear, surprised it was an ACL tear.. as a recovering ACL recipient, this hurt SO MUCH to see 30 times
Same. I was almost 100% sure it was a patellar tendon rupture lol
I didn’t know what it was, but I guess I’m skipping legs today.
Oh my! 👀
Never tore my acl but this hurts me too
@@jonmolina948 The opposite, you should train your ligaments to not be fragile enough to break. But of course not hard enough so the same won't happen to you
ACL. I'm an athletic trainer.. We literally had a class where we watched different injury mechanisms... This is gonna be a fun series of videos!!
That movemen mimickes the terrible leg extension. Very hard on the knees, and replicates no real world movement
@@MikeBarbarossa Old school Physical Therapy myth for sure on the leg extension being terrible. It can be in the rotation. The APTA even wrote up about this exercises a couple years ago. I used to think it was terrible as well but it's not as bad as we once thought. Cheers!
After watching many of these videos, I initially thought ACL because of the tibia shift. Then I talked myself out of it based on the fact that there didn't seem to be a telltale athletic movement associated with the injury. Then I felt silly for second guessing myself seeing as I have no real medical knowledge and should just go with the simple answer. Excellent format and interesting video Dr.
it was clearly acl, the patellar tendon rupture is out because of the patella stays in place afterwards.
It would have been easier if he was upright and attempted to walk. Just watching that joint collapse was enough evidence for me.
As a med student, I LOVE this series. Please keep making them.
Bro that's messed up 😂
As a first semester nursing student, this helps a lot with thinking critically about what was going on, what caused the injury, and why. I really appreciate the videos!
Please keep doing this series!
Also, if you ever see this, please consider going into teaching at some point. You'd make an amazing instructor!
Good luck with school, it’ll fly by and next thing you’ll know you’ll be interviewing for residency 🎉
Why? Stupidity thats why tbh
You should be a professor great way of explaining things.
Thank you!
@@BrianSuttererMD i’d like to second this- i’m a premedical student at a supposedly top 10 ranked premed school and my biology teachers (especially my development and physiology teacher) have absolutely sucked. They dont teach lectures, they just give us videos and they arent engaging or able to explain things clearly either. I’m certain you would be a better teacher than anyone at my school right now based of teaching style alone, and i would encourage you to consider it ag some point
This is awesome man! Do more! I think it’s super knowledgeable to know peoples injuries before they are diagnosed. That way they aren’t killed being brought to the hospital
I guessed the ACL tear. When I saw the injury the first time, I remembered your calling out the video of the wide receiver having that forward pop of the tibia. In this case, I can't tell whether the tibia really moves forward or whether it appears to move forward because everything else has popped backwards. The braces seem to be holding the lower leg in place, so the tibia wouldn't really move at all.
I've seen enough of your super informative videos to have guessed this 100% right, and even the reasoning why. But I gotta say, this extra sprinkle of detail you showed on this one actually showing exactly why the quad would cause the patellar tendon to pull the tibia forward...you're taking my armchair quarterback diagnostic skills to a whole nother level! Love this extra level of detail on this style of vid.
keep these coming!! i'm already a big fan of this soon to be (hopefully) new series! I originally guessed Patellar tendon rupture, but your breakdown and explanations made perfect sense. Thank you for always teaching us in exciting, new ways!
Bro that's messed up.
Love your stuff 👌 awesome series! I look forward to more 🙏
I was able to guess the injury correctly based on a few of your other videos I watched, lol. I was initially drawn to your videos for the MMA content, now I find myself watching injury breakdowns for sports I don't even follow! This new style is another great expansion!
This is a great video idea! Please keep it up! I study PT so it helps me think critically. I think the same applies with anyone else studying or just having an interest in the mechanisms that cause orthopedic injuries.
Love this format! As a Sports Chiropractor and high school sports medicine teacher, I use your videos frequently to visually demonstrate the injuries we discuss in class. I appreciate your consistent discussion of anatomy, mechanism of injury, and treatment as it mirrors and reinforces what I teach in class. Keep them coming!! BTW, I called ACL tear:)
I had guessed PCL. Bad habit of associating ACL ruptures with knee hypertension.
This is a great series, would love to see more of these
If it was PCL there would’ve been posterior displacement of the tibia instead.
love this type of content, please make more bro ❤
At first I was thinking platella dislocation but once I realised that the the tibia popped out anterior the way it did, I immediately screamed ACL tear 😅
Great concept Doc, keep it coming!!
Absolutely love this style video, would love to see more!!
I have been dealing with an acl sprain for a couple months and this one was obvious to me after all the doctors have done explaining it to me. This was another good demo!
Super fun! And appreciate you starting off with an easy one. Can’t wait for the difficulty to start ramping up.
Really nice video please do more of these! I am a physiotherapy student and I think this is a great teaching method and your reasoning and explanation as the video continues is a great way to learn, it is much better way of teaching in my opinion (at least from a learning perspective) than just going through the video and explaining what happened. It forces you to think and learn instead of just saying what happened, which is still really good information and useful, but this is nicer to learn from.
For being “just” a massage therapist I was totally pumped when I was right haha. From just watching the clip my first thought was the patellar tendon rupture but after hearing you break it down I knew it had to be an ACL, love it!
Massage therapists are highly trained health professionals. I got mad respect for y'all!!
Thank you for the upload Dr! Poor guy I hope he makes a full recovery! I guessed at the start it would be a: ligament; tendon, muscle injury (above the knee leg muscle) or a combination of the three. I have not studied anatomy for decades & never in detail but hey thank you for making me a detective :::))
Peace & Love!
Love this concept. I hope to see more.
Great series!!! This is so helpful for my studies (medical)!!
First thing I thought was, 'ACL 100%'. Dr. Sutterer has taught me well. (The shift in the tibia, the pop, it looks so similar to other videos of ACLs that have been covered on the channel!)
Watching the first 10 seconds, my guess is patellar tendon rupture.
Edit: In hindsight, the correct answer makes sense. It just seemed like such an extreme translation in the tibia and violent rupture, I thought it was something bigger giving out. Great video.
Exactly what I had thought.
Thought that was the patella for sure, what a horrible exercise yikes
You had the right mindset and Brian said it. Either something broke (bone) or something ruptured (ligament).
I was mainly thinking that since his leg was fully straight and he was bending backwards, that had to be a lot of stress on the ligaments in the knee. Also, with him covering patella ruptures from NBA players, I didn't see a deformity in the knee so I didn't want to guess that.
This is gonna be a fun series.
He was really testing that knee joint. I never heard it snap like that. At least when you’re squatting you can dump the bar to save further damage.
This was great! I’d love to see more of these…
I definitely thought quad or patellar tendon rupture. Hopefully I’ll get the next one.
Big fan of the series! More please!
Wow great video. As a physics student I definitely appreciate the explanation of the forces and torque in play. IMO its definitely a great tool to have to understand anatomy and movements better.
I like this type of video testing us on all you been teaching us
I had a PCL injury few months ago, so I read and watch a lot about knee tendons, I guessed the injury right away :)
Keep it up with the great content.
Love the new format!! I'd love to see more of these
Nailed it! I like this new guessing game! Do more of these please!
I’ve decided to comment just looking at the full speed video to make it a bit harder on myself. I feel like I can see the tibia shift forward during the ‘snap’ which implies an ACL tear to me, as his leg seems to have lost the ability to keep his tibia from swinging forward. Either way, love the new video idea. I’m a med student so I usually try to guess what’s going on first anyway, and I feel like this channel has helped give me a better handle on a lot of MSK injuries that I would sometimes struggle to identify in the past. Keep up the good work doc!
@Lagdarr As not a med student who could only watch the first 5 seconds of the video before “nope”-ing out I just gotta say thank you for your intellectual and emotional sacrifice. Just finish med school, I believe in you
@@dawson289 lol
Poor guy. I wish him a swift recovery. I guessed right! Great explanation doc!!
I teach sports medicine at a high school. Please make more of these challenge videos, they are awesome!
Loved this!! Please do more!!
I should seriously be a knee surgeon.. I was saying the correct injury out loud! So stoked!
Yes mate you’re a genius! I’d let you give me a reconstruction right now 🎉
@@jburger590 I mean, I don’t have one minute of official study or practice.. but we can give it a try😅 I aspire to be a knee surgeon one day though!
As an athletic training student, I got the notification and the title honestly made me click right away, seems like a great video idea 👍
love this idea for a series!
Absolutely keep this series going💯
My guess is ACL from the tibia shift!
Edit: also thought could be the tendon as well with the eccentric firing but didn’t see much movement from the quad muscle
Loved this video!
Easy one... brain fracture 😂😂😂
Looks, to me, like both his pride and his ego were bruised, too
Cool video aspect!!
Got it right because of your most awesome educational videos!!!
Thanks!!!
.....and yes, it's cool to confirm that we're learning from your videos by diagnosing the injury!!!!
Amazing idea Doc. “The best way of learning is practice”… you just made use practice medicine❤…thanks for this series😊.
Really love this idea and concept for a video. Being in PT school it definitely challenges me and teaches me a lot.
I tore my acl in 2020 and was told to never do quad extensions again, you kinda have that same motion here, instead of your torso being stationary while doing a sitting quad sets, your legs are stationary. Either way you do it, it puts enormous tension on that acl as you said.
I initially said patella tendon rupture but after explanation and remembering my past from the injury it makes a lot of sense!
ACL tear 100%
And he is doing sissy squats abysmally
I wouldn’t even classify it as a sissy squat, I believe he thinks he’s doing a core/back extension or something of that nature. The weight is just fuel to the fire.
Thanks doc. I enjoyed watching this. Brings back memories
I'll subscribe for videos like this! This is an educational format which invites us to not just listen to a presentation of information but to use the video to evaluate using the knowledge we have and see why we might have been correct or missed something you caught. I personally did see the shift of the relation of the tibia and femer. I didn't notice the forward travel as much as the downward shift of the femer till pointed out. I thought it had something to do with a supporting ligament rupture but wasn't sure which. Great video!
Thank you!! I really enjoyed it too and will definitely do more of them !
Maybe I should’ve been taking notes 😅
Update: I guessed ACL tear at 2:15😁never heard it sound like that though… hope he’s okay!
I love this format. Just subscribed. Great learning
I knew ACL tear instantly just by looking at that position, waaay too much weight leveraged over the fulcrum point(his knees) as he over extends backwards his quads buckle under the weight so his ACL tears because it's around the fulcrum point
Great video as always love this new type of video and most likely gonna be a complete tear of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament
I like these videos. Keep it coming doc
Awesome video! Definitely keep these coming! I’m striving to be a PA specializing in orthopedics!
I watch all your videos but especially liked this one. As someone who watches a lot of sports and has no medical background, this is a great channel!
This is a great format, subbed
I thought it was a patellar tendon rupture. I figured it wasn’t a quad tear - the injury looked like it clearly took place at the knee, but I made sure to watch to see if you would say an ACL tear. Sure enough I got my answer 👍 Love the idea for guessing the injury as you explain it first. Great work again, Doc!
Thanks for showing an exercise to avoid like the plague. Already had 2 ACL tears. Nor getting a 3rd
i’m in my first year of my DPT and i liked the format a lot. it was good fun and can see it being a good learning tool
Please more of these man!
Love this break down. Thanks!
This was really cool and educational. Thanks, doc!
Loved this and going to share it with some bright high school students! Hope to see more videos like this and thank you 😁
Good evening Doctor Sutterer.
Presently I'm a university faculty member teaching course work in our Health and Exercise Science Department. Prior to this, I was an head athletic training at the university level for 30 years dealing with all aspects of sports performance and injuries. I wanted to thank you for your content and the educational opportunities you provide to myself and my students on a daily basis. Your work is much appreciated and I encourage all of my students each quarter to subscribe to your channel.
I feel like I've watched enough of these videos to be confident in calling that an ACL tear. The shin seemingly popping forward is a dead giveaway for me.
Edit: Whew, really happy my confidence paid off! Great video as always doc
Oh man. This one, the double quad tear during squat, the pec tear on incline bench. Burned into my brain.
Love this! Do more of these videos please 🤗
I think this is an awesome series. Please continue
Great video format! Greatly enjoyed it from a MS perspective
Current DPT student and immediately identified anterior translation of the tibia and thought ACL. So many different mechanisms to create anterior translation!
I literally screamed when I saw that injury happen.
Yup, had this injury with a bucket handle tear in the meniscus... worst injury and recovery I've ever had
I thought ACL tear when Insaw the knee move that way but wasn't quite certain. I love this new style of video. It makes us think critically.
Loved the video, even though I missed it by judging this a pattelar tendon rupture. Looking for more in the future!
Great video! Please keep them coming!
Yeah I really think this is a cool series. Cool idea Doc!
Love this style of video. Everyone likes to play a doctor.
Thanks
I LOVED THIS GUESSING TYPE VIDEO!!!! And I did thought it was the ACL before I saw the answer😎😎 I took extra pleasure during this video because my options were acl and qudricepts and patellar tendon rupture which then those were the possible diagnoses you mentioned during the video. We love your videos at the university of Monterrey in Mexico
Love this, keep it up!!
Got it watching the preview before even clicking. I watch too many of your videos man 🤣
Love this doc 👍👍
Awesome idea. Very educational!
I love this keep them coming
I am really liking it
Would love to watch more
Going waaaaasy back to my nursing school days, i was thinking a knee CL injury of sorts due to the immense strain this "exercise" puts on the knee and it's components but wasn't sure. I was also wondering if it could've been a muscle tear or something too. But ACL makes sense, thanks doctor for the brain exercise
This is my jam! Before watching, my first I pression is patellar tendon rupture.
Edit:
This actually makes so much sense. I trian youth athletes and we do lots of Nordics to help take stress off the ACL to prevent knee injuries.
If you keep making these guess the Injury videos I'll keep watching for sure.
Knew it from the first few full speed replays. Great video starting out easy I like it.
I guessed ACL. Keep up the great work, I enjoyed this new style of video in addition to your current content. Thanks.
Doc you gotta do it again. I did guess acl tear based on that shift in the tibia but I wanna see another one of these
Quad /patellar rupture vs acl tear
As always, great video!
Addendum LOL:
In addition to the quadricep contraction, when his body is parallel to the floor, that would create the longest lever arm, for max tension on the ACL, opposed to the other ranges of motion
Love this style of video!
Initially I thought patellar tendon rupture or acl at full speed. In slow motion that immediate anterior shift of the lower leg made me believe it was the acl. I love the explanation about how the quadriceps concentric contraction added to the anterior force causing the tear. My questions are: Is it more or less common to tear the acl with an added rotational force? Would the menisci possibly be compromised as well given the sudden shift under load?
This is great, it’s like a final exam for school!!
so far i like this challenge idea. I'd like to see more please!
This is a cool game! Do this more often.
That's the coolest video idea ever. I love it 👍. Btw I guessed ACL. The doctor's always did the lachmann test on me, when I injured my knee on the soccer field. (luckily I never had a torn ACL)
I'm starting med school in February and your videos are great to hype me up for my future 😅.