StarTalk Podcast: Celebrating Einstein, with Neil deGrasse Tyson
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 05. 2024
- Join Neil deGrasse Tyson, comic co-host Chuck Nice, and astrophysicist Janna Levin as they celebrate the life and achievements of Albert Einstein and his impact on the scientific world around us including the detection of gravitational waves at LIGO.
Albert Einstein's birthday is on March 14, also known as Pi day.
Host:
Neil deGrasse Tyson
Astrophysicist
Co-Host:
Chuck Nice
Comedian
Guests:
Janna Levin
Astrophysicist & Author, Black Hole Blues and Other Songs from Outer Space, Director of Sciences at Pioneer Works
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
Subscribe to StarTalk: czcams.com/users/startalk...
Follow StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalkradio
About StarTalk:
Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up!
#AlbertEinstein #Einstein #GravitationalWaves - Věda a technologie
It is nice to see Neil DeGrasse Tyson is back. Nice to see you back in action man.
This is awesome! I hope this brings news of the second season of Cosmos. I heard it got delayed until the whole allegations stuff was made clear
@@DiracComb.7585 no, all i knew is that star talk and cosmos are on hiatus until this situation is made clear. I hope that seeing startalk back is a sign that things are looking clearer and well
@@bodbn And you want it to be the truth.
@@bodbn there is 2 allegations of him making a pass at 2 women colleagues. All he said was, "if you give me a hug, I am just going to want more." So they shook hands and nothing happened. Neither is accusing him of rape, and he welcomes the investigation.
He hooked up with some girl while in grad school i believe, sounds like another women claiming sexual misconduct so she can make some money while ruining someone's reputation. If going home with stranger in college is rape, then i was raped more times than i can count.
@@bodbn I can see what you're saying, and yes we shouldn't brush it off. Both sides deserve to be heard. However, it goes "innocent till proven guilty" not "guilty till proven innocent"
Chuck is my favorite guest comedian. He is respectful with the guests and he always have an enthusiastic attitude towards the topic.
Once in awhile Chuck is in way over his head, as when Neil was discussing Neil Armstrong's Moon landing anniversary with a real astronaut, and Chuck was making the DUMBEST remarks, so much so that by halfway through the interview, the astronaut is leaning all the way over towards Neil and his body language is just shunning Chuck.
Chuck is a Moron and not funny...looks like he's never been so close to a woman either
Looks like he is on coke this episode, shaking hands and sweating. Probably a withdrawal.
@Aegsorcisten lmao. "He looks like he's on coke." But also, "he looks like he's withdrawing". Makes sense.
Is Chuck even a "guest". I thought others are guest if he's absent.
Glad Neil is back. He survived the bullshit allegations. Top Man.
And an official A-list celebrity now)))
What happend?
What allegations??
@@wowjack8944 So apparently a long time graduate student with whom Tyson -- according to him -- dated for a short period of time at Harvard, has accused him of rape. She's been saying this since 2010, but now two other women have filed a complaint. Not to choose sides, but the other two complaints are ridiculous to say the least: one complained about him rubbing her shoulders, the other one about him touching her tattoo of the solar system on her arm Lol. And the main girl has accused him of drugging her out to find him giving her oral sex. After which she felt violated and all the typical #metoo slogans and dropped out of university to study "music healing" or something like that. Doesn't sound like a hard case to win I guess.
@@shakespearsplat innocent until proven guilty. and those other two are not even illegal .
Needed some new Neil content in my life. Real shame Cosmos got pushed back, hopefully not too far.
how can you condone a potential rapist. shame on you.
@@bodbn tf?
@@bodbn you fucking npc "potential" is not the same as confirmed
I was searching youtube for new NDT content just a couple of days ago.
@@bodbn why are you even watching the video
I am glad this show is still on. I learn so much. Neil is able to make this interesting and fun. Wish my teachers years ago were all like him.
Fantastic educational and fun
I really feel like Neil is what Einstein would've been in this era. They're both empathetic to the common man who isn't a highly sophisticated science student.
@@joefriedman9843 agreed
I can't be any happier with Star Talk coming back. My day started pretty bad but this made it a billion times better
We've been putting out new episodes on the podcast as well! -Ben, Video Producer
Jenna is a superstar in her own right and I never get enough of listening to her. As Albert Einstein is another favorite of mine this video was a real treat. 👏👨🏼🦳
Am I the only only one who appreciated and acknowledged the 'out of the aether' joke by tyson?
with the amount of nerds here, do you really have to ask?
PS Ethereum is back on the rise!
I didn't get it;( help
@@KaterinaTalantliva Prior to Einstein most physicists believed that light had to travel through some "medium" in space the way sound travels using air molecules. This medium was referred to as the aether.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aether_theories
The luminous aether, to be precise
You're not alone bruh..
Yay Neil's back! Thought he was going to get the Vic Mignogna treatment from his allegations. Pleasantly surprised
Ryan Seneczko big mood there dude
Considering how fast Vic's investigation was, there was plenty of evidence. As for Neil, all the story's sound bogus, and there's evidence that suggest nothing happened from at least one of the accusations.
@@Purpletrident Have you seen the "evidence" with Vic? It's the SAME thing with Neil.
Ryan Seneczko Obviously I didn't see the evidence. I'm not an investigator. The investigators saw enough evidence to quickly rule him guilty.
@@Purpletrident And the evidence was anecdotal just like Neil's was. Vic was just bad press and companies created a knee jerk reaction and fired him to avoid backlash.
I had never seen or heard of Janna Levin, but I’m in love now.
too late....I got her.
I couldn’t ever get tired of listening to the beautiful way that Janna passionately explains about science. So inspiring, deep and technical… damn, you’re the best!!
Oh? Wonderful! Thank you to StarTalk, to the enlightening Neil deGrasse Tyson, to the welcomingly funny Chuck Nice, and to the incredible and inspiring Janna Levin for engaging in this way. 🌻
Until someone shows me at least one piece of legitimate evidence, Tyson didn't sexually assault anybody. We should never believe anyone who make claims based without supporting evidence.
I enjoyed the show, and a happy birthday to Albert Einstein.
But until someone does, you shouldn’t call the person who’s saying these things, you shouldn’t believe any side automatically, or dismiss either side until every evidence is released.
@@mountainmangames3613 What you wrote looked fair at first glance. Do you mean that if we accused someone of something a decade ago without evidence, that person would no longer be innocent and must be doubted until they manage to produce something to prove otherwise? Hmm... sounds like someone's life could be ruined without concrete evidence whatsoever as long as they can't prove those random allegations wrong.
Let's start throwing allegations all over the place then... oh wait... isn't that exactly what people have been doing already... oh boy.
@@mountainmangames3613 Yes, the problem is that if allegations come forward and no conclusion can ultimately be drawn, we must treat the accused party as innocent. That's not what the left thinks, with the current trend right now of women accusing men of misconduct decades prior. It wouldn't be a problem if the left accepted innocence until proven guilty, but they don't because it goes against their narrative of men as oppressors.
jmcsquared let me answer both of your guys questions at the same time. It’d be easier.
For you (I’m writing on mobile and can’t see your name, but the first guy who responded) if you do it correctly, it won’t ruin anyone’s life’s, until the final evidence has been brought forth. For example, Bill Cosby. Even with all of the accusations we still have to believe he was innocent and guilty, why they were lying and telling the truth. Preventing any damage in theory, until the court filed their rulings and delivered their decisions. Which as we all know, he is guilty. As for you jmcsquared, the “left” don’t automatically believe either one. Well, let me rephrase. We don’t automatically believe the alleged attacker, mainly because of two reasons.
1. Women who come out and say they were attacked have a LOT to loose. look at Dr. Ford. She gained no money from that, she got death threats to herself and her family and she had to move to a different location because she feared for her life. She gained nothing. If you would like you can DM me via email and we can discuss this further. But saying that just because it happened a long time ago makes you immune to what you did is just...well bullshit. I know I didn’t answer your question fully, but if you want to email me I will gladly do it there.
Mountainmangamess@gmail.com (don’t forget the extra S)
Or
It.trolling@gmail.com
Both are business emails I check semi-regularly.
Mountain Man Games just because one popular person doesn’t get hit by a sexual assault claim doesn’t mean it can’t hurt a normal person’s life, which it has hundreds of times.
So happy you're cleared of the allegations! Love you Neil!
It's so satisfying listening to these very intelligent people and chuck talking unpretentiously about deep stuff.
Neil is legit the best person ever. Everything from his voice to his personality and his sense of humor is all great!
this man has been credibly accused by multiple women of being a rapist. you should find better people to hero worship.
Ryan well I’m sorry that I like certain people. If u don’t like him then why are u in his comment section? Why are u on the channel why do u care? Oh bc ur an asshole.
Hollister David then leave the channel dumbass
@@bodbn credibly accused 🤣
Ryan Only 1 allegation is serious which acctually “happend” 30 years ago. The other 2 are “fake” accusations to support the logic one. Inform yourself on the matter before you start judging someone(friendly advise,no harm meant).
Ive missed Chuck and Neil
Great show Neil, and everyone involved! Was very enjoyable to watch, thank you.
Makes me so happy to see you all doing your thing again. Star Talk has been a favorite for years.
HI Dr.Tyson...Chuck...good to see and hear you again!!!😎😎
It's been too long I had Neil DeGrasse Tyson in my life, when will the next season begin? :)
I've heard most things about Einstein, but I don't mind listening to this women tell the story again. Loved the video, keep em coming.
The last part where they talk when everyone collaborated to observe one specific event, is just heartwarming.
Encore, Encore, ENCORE!!! If you don't love Dr. Janna Levin, then you just don't know love! She's awesome and compliments, Dr. DeGrasse's explainer so well. Bring her back for more episodes! Bring her back. Bring her back. Bring her back
Its been a GOOD minute I haven't seen from my favorite human on earth! I've been waiting, so good to see you Neil!
Your favorite human on earth isn't someone like you mom? I really like Neil but he's certainly not my favorite human.
I miss you Doctor Neil DgraceTyson
Could listen to Janna talk all day. Awesome chat, thanks Neil.
I can listen to this man all day.
Who else loves Neil?
Janna Levin is SO adorable! Chuck and Neil, you both are a super team! Thank you. :-)
a hope that things will go back to normal and youtube will be filled with neil's videos that will give you knowledge
and maybe just maybe cosmos will be saved
It has been confirmed!
Janna Levin explained beautifully the sounds of universe and black holes.
And her observation of Einstein's life is superb.
Enjoyed this one thoroughly ❤️❤️
Neil is always fun in betwen
Happy to see Neil back, picking up without missing a beat. Super stoked for Cosmos Season 2!
Professor Levin is just a delight to listen to...
So I could have sworn I heard this before and I went the actual StarTalk website and found that this is just an edited version of a podcast done a year ago! Come back Neil! And quite trying to trick us with re-hashed content!
Dude, all of you rock. Thanks 😊
I was fortunate i had teachers in the late 1970s to mid 1980s for physics and electronics.
What an amazing discussion/lecture guys... inspiring and extremely educational how you added perfect elements of humor to relate to those who (like myself) are not astrophysisits. . or comedians.... Or hell, might know nothing in the least of this subject matter! But as always, you guys made it fun and entertaining... which honestly I hate to say is kind of the only way to educate people these days, myself included! I love this and I love you all for the work and passion you have! Please keep it up! - The Lovelace's from Memphis
3:34 The moment Chuck thinks : "Damn , I need to Google this one" ;-)
Thank you, Dr. Neil, so much for this full video for us! Spreading it out, for sure!
I love the fact that, Neil deGrasse Tyson knows and communicates the difference between further( degree ) and farther( distance ).
:)
You guys look great. I've missed you. Don't ever leave me again!
@24:40 "Get out!" "Move away!"
jeez, that reminds me of the movie Event Horizon....
I love conversations like this. Why couldn't these videos exist during my time in school? I would've gone face-first into the science field.
The lady there is soooo knowledgeable! Not just on the theory but on the history of science! I need to buy her book!
Albert Einstein’s Theories and equations basically birthed every current cosmological theory.
Inflation
Big Bang
Black holes
Time
Multiverse
And I’m sure I’m forgetting a few. That’s a legacy.
Photoelectric theory. Light basically
He even had a big part in the tiny quantum world
Any news when will Isaac Asimov debate 2019 going to be? Also, how can I try to buy the tickets?
That information about the cubic centimeter of electrons blew my mind
Chuck has the hardest job here. And he does it wonderfully
Yea! Neil is BACK! So glad to see you, don't let the snowflakes keep you down.
Was about to unsub startalk, thinking it was dead. I am so pleased right now
any news about the new Cosmos series?
It's coming out for sure but the network hasn't given out any details on the date.
We are waiting for Cosmos
Welcome back Star Talk!
Thanks to this video I discovered I live less than an hour from LIGO Livingston ! Incredible ! Plan to take a trip to this marvelous site.
Actually Chuck’s question are smart, he is really paying attention
This lady is so smart yet so hipster looking damnn
Wooooo! Love you Neil! Keep doing what you do man! Educate the masses and show everyone how awesome existence is!
March is the monday of the year... but not now with Neil back !!! ♥
18:46 For real, earlier today I was thinking, "Then what is the difference between a neutron star and a black hole, besides the obvious?"
This is the first StarTalk video to have me burst into tears. Not helping is that I had a rough day anyway but I have for *YEARS* not understood what a black hole is, and now I think this video explains it perfectly. The size of the black hole, as explained by NDT in another video, is measured by the event horizon, but the event horizon, as explained here, is the edge of the shadow created by the actual black hole. There is nothing there. In another video, NDT explains that you would actually be conscious as you fell into the event horizon and before you die, you would actually be *aware* of not only your surroundings, but of quite possibly a whole other universe opening up before you, which can exist inside the black hole. (Btw, In his book "Death by Black Hole", NDT explains that spaghettification doesn't occur with every black hole, only smaller ones relative to your size; has to do with the size ratio of the black hole and you as a person.)
Chuck Nice finally asks the question that no one else ever seems to ask, and that is: but when two black holes are colliding, what exactly is colliding. When Janna says, "Spacetime itself", I basically broke down. (On a rewatch, I still teared up - I think this is important stuff lol.)
By the way, all shadows are 3-dimensional, but what we see and call a shadow a "shadow" is the 2-D image that represents the lack of light on, say, the ground or a wall. But the shadow itself is being cast like a beam of dark. So a tree in sunlight will have a 3-D shadow cast shooting perfectly straight from its leeward side (as it were) that you can, as Janna says, step in and out of without feeling anything.
(What you would feel is the sudden lack of radiation emitting from the sun, which is why the shadow of the tree is cooler and more refreshing; has nothing to do with ambient air temperature. Source: startalk again!)
Cool i was looking for a good video!
Shut up, bert
My knowledge on Blackholes just increased by leaps n bounds. I'm amazed. It was a brilliant and open discussion. Thank you all.
One of my modern time heroes discussing one of my all time favorite heroes! Mr. Tyson you are an inspiration!
Me: ringing sounds in my ear
Black hole: omae wa mou shindeiru
Great, now i gotta change all my passwords...
Thank you Chuck for that last question! I was waiting to hear more about the colliding neutron stars and i was afraid they would end without going in to it more but you saved it!
Great show!
Janna, you ROCK!!
5:10
Neil when she says no to putting out on the first date.
YAY!!!!!
Contemplating the leap forward that was General Relativity blows my mind everytime I think about it.
Welcome back Dr Tyson. Your talks and shows are entertaining and inspiring. Eagerly waiting for COSMOS. Love from India...
I did a double take when I heard "Janna Levin" as "Jan 11".
Its my birthday on 14th March!!!
HowTo 101 Happy Birthday!
Changing your mind in any theory is a given. Albert Einstein would still change his mind today.
I've been so waiting for him to return.
Oh hi, Mr Tyson. -Pluto is a planet- What a lovely day, eh?
..........
@@StarTalk lol
Pluto is a planet, it's just a dwarf planet. And we still consider Dwarfs humans unless we're on middle earth.
Celebrate Albert Einstein’s birthday, pi-day, and Stephen Hawking’s deathday?
Now that is a decent conspiracy theory
cellularticulate do u have he resources to create 50,000,000 Intel Core i9’s, 20,000,000 GPU, and 100,000,000 one-petabyte hard drives
wow. The year Galalao died was the same year Isiac Newton was born.
Einstein was a fraud, wife beater, communist and a racist Jew-supremacist. He stole the works of Heinrich Hertz, Philipp Lenard, James Maxwell, Josiah Gibbs, Ludwig Boltzmann, Friedrich Hasenöhrl and others.
Probably, somebody also might've born the year Hawking died, who's going to be the next big gun.
One theory about behavioral “tells” involves watching a person’s hands (rather than their face)... watching Chuck’s hands they move, fiddle, clasp, scratch his hair, etc. in the beginning while he’s listening. Then he seems to calm down, which as a viewer is more relaxing.
Good to have you back
They mentioned early in the show that Eisnstein was alone in formulating the General Theory of Relativity, however there was at least one other scientist, the English Physicist David Hilbert that was working on a similar approach to Einstein's take. In fact they exchanged correspondence just before and after Einstein’s publication of General Relativity. There was some discussion in later years as to the degree that Einstein coud have stolen Hilbert’s idea but that has been discredited lately. Below an excerpt from Wikipedia on the main points of the dispute:
"Before 1997, "the commonly accepted view was that David Hilbert completed the general theory of relativity at least 5 days before Albert Einstein submitted his conclusive paper on this theory on 25 November 1915. Hilbert's article, bearing the date of submission 20 November 1915 but published only on 31 March 1916, presents a generally covariant theory of gravitation, including field equations essentially equivalent to those in Einstein's paper" (Corry, Renn and Stachel, 1997). Since the discovery of printer's proofs of Hilbert's paper of Nov 20, dated 6 Dec 1915, which show a number of differences from the finally published paper, this 'commonly accepted view' has been challenged.[10]
Whether Einstein got the correct mathematical formulation for general relativity from Hilbert, or formulated it independently. Points at issue:
* The content of Hilbert's November 16 letter/postcard to Einstein is not known. It is however, clear[according to whom?] from Einstein's response that it was an account of Hilbert's work.
* It is not known what was on the missing part of Hilbert's printer proofs. The missing portion is large enough to have contained the field equations in an explicit form. There are several competing speculations about the content of the missing piece.
* Based on the above, it is not known whether Hilbert had formulated the field equations in an explicit form before December 6 (the date of the printer's proofs) or not.
It is known from the proofs that Hilbert introduced four non-covariant equations in order to specify the gravitational potentials g g^{{}} and that this approach was dropped from his revised paper.
Whether Hilbert ever tried to claim priority for the field equations - it seems clear that he regarded the theory of general relativity as Einstein's theory.
What Hilbert thought he was referring to when he used the term "equations of my theory" about Einstein's research. Hilbert made a similar remark in a letter to Karl Schwarzschild.[B 1]"
Please expand on ur comment. Too brief
Yes, you are right.
Moreover, I think, Poincaré also came pretty close.
??@@classickettlebell2035
Yes. The difference I think is that David Hilbert was actually figuring out the math of the field equations right around the same time Einstein was struggling with the math. In Walter Isaacson’s biography of Einstein I recall he comments on Einstein's desire to publish as soon as possible as if he felt he was in some sort of race to publish. The fact that Poncaré insisted on the use of the Ether and did not address the issues of time dilation put him a bit behind into moving from ideas to an actual probable theory that could be proved and poked around. That’s my take. I know there is a lot of controversy , in some circles, around that.
My impression is that Einstein, being the more intuitive thinker, found the field equations in a long long trial and error process.
Meanwhile Hilbert, being the mathematician, thought that it was necessary to derive them from first principles (SRT limit, Newtonian limit, general covariance).
So Einstein had A solution, Hilbert knew it was the only one possible.
Yes! Inject this into my subconscious as I drift into a Sunbeam......wait.
Wowww.... "as I drift into a Sunbeam".... that's nice.
I can do this all day long. all I need is me my coffee, these guys and a comfortable chair.
yeah! the man is back. good to see you again.
Nerd out time
Great, finally where a Nerd like me belongs
So Happy to have you back Neil!
Just for people's information. This is technically a re-run, as it was in their podcast quite a while ago. It's nice to see them in person though!! and hear it all again.
When I'm around conservative theists, well, that must be how Einstein felt around the general public.
charlidog2 are you comparing yourself with Einstein? You’re lucky to live in a world where million of people ara atheists, we have access to the truth, you’re not that special or outsider. Einstein was alone with his brilliant mind in a world where he didn’t has power and he had to prove his theory perfectly and even after that we was misunderstood, that must be frustrating.
19:40 True that the image of a hole is a total misrepresentation about what is a "black hole"... The French were right on this.
I agree, but I think the french doesn't like 'black hole' because it can be racist and offensive. Everytime we talk about a black thing, or any subject like that, specially if it came from a non black person, it's a delicate task. And yes i'm french. Today it's idiot to think 'Black hole' can be offensive, but I can understand the people at that time who just want to avoid a possible problem with that... But hey, is it really inappropriate to say something black, that it's black...?
I could listen to her speak for hours
After this I think Janna become one of my favourite lady scientists, I could listen to her for much longer :) I'll need to watch some other vids of hers
Albert Einstein also predicted today's economy. He said the 1% will control the news, media and educational system to intentionally make children Dumber so that they worship Authority.
"Private capital tends to become concentrated in few hands, partly because of competition among the capitalists, and partly because technological development and the increasing division of labor encourage the formation of larger units of production at the expense of smaller ones. The result of these developments is an oligarchy of private capital the enormous power of which cannot be effectively checked even by a democratically organized political society. This is true since the members of legislative bodies are selected by political parties, largely financed or otherwise influenced by private capitalists who, for all practical purposes, separate the electorate from the legislature. The consequence is that the representatives of the people do not in fact sufficiently protect the interests of the underprivileged sections of the population. Moreover, under existing conditions, private capitalists inevitably control, directly or indirectly, the main sources of information (press, radio, education). It is thus extremely difficult, and indeed in most cases quite impossible, for the individual citizen to come to objective conclusions and to make intelligent use of his political rights." - Albert Einstein
"Albert Einstein also predicted today's economy" Well, it was hardly a "grand" prediction was it. Einstein simply took the Pareto principle to its inevitable conclusion. Don't get me wrong, I love Einstein, I just think most of the credit should be given to Vilfredo Pareto.
One thing he didn’t take into account - the internet. Not only corporations & politicians control the news.
Janet is quite attractive :)
love to see full episodes!
I'm empressed!
His accuser should've detached herself from the #metoo movement. Was a bad idea to not take that important step.
Also helps if she doesn't make false accusations
She also shouldn't be batshit crazy. That website she created where she obsessed over him didn't help.
neil has a lot to answer for. Personally he and Bill Cosby should be sharing a cell together.
@@bodbn keep commenting on every comment like you should. Foh
@@bodbn Bring evidence to prove it or fuck off
Sooooooooooooooooo are they going to talk about Einstein or blabber on about random shjt?
Sooooo.... So long time Mr Tyson. Where have you been? Glad to have a new episode tonight. Best regards from France .
It didn't constrain him
It liberates him ❤
As a fan of Einstein, I feel so validated by Neil's recognition that I exist!
Happy to see you back Dr Neil DeGrasse Tyson.
Idk how I haven’t seen this before now. This is like my dream conversation!!!
Woooow man how smart they are.
Respect 🙏🙏🙏.