Pesci-ent Knowledge: Stephen Kotkin on Xi’s China, Putin’s Russia | GoodFellows | Hoover Institution

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 3. 11. 2022
  • Recorded on November 1st, 2022
    Can China’s current authoritarian model hold without destroying its economy, and what’s the near-term outlook for the war in Ukraine? Stephen Kotkin, the Hoover Institution’s Kleinheinz Senior Fellow and an authority on geopolitics and authoritarian regimes (and a Joe Pesci soundalike) joins Hoover senior fellows Niall Ferguson, H. R. McMaster, and John Cochrane to discuss the latest in Xi Jinping’s China and Vladimir Putin’s Russia.
    ABOUT THE SERIES
    GoodFellows, a weekly Hoover Institution broadcast, features senior fellows John Cochrane, Niall Ferguson, and H.R. McMaster discussing the social, economic, and geostrategic ramifications of this changed world. They can’t banter over lunch these days, but they continue their spirited conversation online about what comes next, as we look forward to an end to the crisis.
    For more in this series visit, www.hoover.org/goodfellows.

Komentáře • 296

  • @fotouhi
    @fotouhi Před rokem +253

    Kotkin never disappoints. He's a true treasure.

    • @ryanward10
      @ryanward10 Před rokem +5

      Unbelievable performance. Brilliant, insightful, poking fun at each other, relevant, high level, yet accessible. 👏

  • @missKfierce
    @missKfierce Před rokem +393

    Stephen Kotkin is a such a joy to listen to.

  • @mart7379
    @mart7379 Před rokem +62

    I nominate Kotkin as the 4th Goodfellow!

    • @--Dani
      @--Dani Před rokem +1

      I second that...would make a great show/podcast into the best👍

    • @penponds
      @penponds Před rokem +1

      Hmmm… was the Three Musketeers improved in the Fourth…?
      LOL!

  • @andrewgrubb9268
    @andrewgrubb9268 Před rokem +125

    In my opinion the GoodFellows + Steve Kotkin at the Hoover Institution is without peer.
    A mesmerising 1 1/4 hour discussion.

  • @zewpustyni1485
    @zewpustyni1485 Před rokem +181

    Great episode, Joe Pesci was a great guest.

  • @ffleischer
    @ffleischer Před rokem +81

    The intro with Nikita Khrushchev claps 👏🏻 for Kotkin is 🤌🏼 What an entertaining and informative episode!!

  • @AsharRM
    @AsharRM Před rokem +146

    What a great world we live in to have all these eminent intellectuals give us this information for free while also keeping us entertained. God bless you all. ❤🎉

  • @illyavogel1660
    @illyavogel1660 Před rokem +296

    Steven Kotkin was a great surprise, this is quickly turning into my favorite weekly show.

  • @coryzane.
    @coryzane. Před rokem +82

    Love the show, Niall has met his match😁 Mr Kotkin is brilliant. Would love to see him back more!

  • @salmanismail5330
    @salmanismail5330 Před rokem +41

    I could listen to stephen kotkin speak all day. 🇬🇧

  • @kibirkshtis
    @kibirkshtis Před rokem +72

    I just love him! Never miss any interview with Stephen. Greetings from Lithuania.

  • @sykes2698
    @sykes2698 Před rokem +37

    Dr Kotkin is such a pleasure to watch and listen to

  • @misterwilliam
    @misterwilliam Před rokem +23

    I see Stephen Kotkin and I just click.

  • @consssf
    @consssf Před rokem +226

    It's a great gift for me to have another opportunity to listen to such a great person as Stephen Kotkin. Thank you guys for that.

  • @mikelis106
    @mikelis106 Před rokem +27

    it is like the sky clearing when he talks, everything becomes clear.

  • @gnazlis
    @gnazlis Před rokem +357

    I can't say what was more the case with this episode, the laughter I had or the knowledge I gained. CONGRATULATIONS!!!
    P.S. I vote for Kotkin to become part of the gang - or at least to come again many times!

  • @peterprocopio2192
    @peterprocopio2192 Před rokem +142

    Great panel and discussion. Please invite Stephen to join on a regular basis.

  • @johnrhodes3350
    @johnrhodes3350 Před rokem +94

    Stephen was almost enjoying himself too much, with those friendly jibes. But everyone else had the benefit and was just enjoying being on the same stage.
    Thank you gentlemen that was as enjoyable as it was informative, not withstanding the most grave and tragic subject. May true wisdom prevail and a lasting peace come quickly.

  • @Theiliteritesbian
    @Theiliteritesbian Před rokem +143

    Yay! My days are always better with a new stephen k drop. I usually listen to it twice bc he chooses his words so well there is a lot of content in each sentence. Thanks for having him back I really appreciate it.

  • @RAM-py6zp
    @RAM-py6zp Před rokem +92

    Stephen Kotkin amazing as always. Thanks for bringing him

  • @joedo3529
    @joedo3529 Před rokem +15

    I see Stephen Kotkin, I could not click any faster.

  • @erikneelsenart
    @erikneelsenart Před rokem +28

    What a powerhouse panel of insight into this generation’s most prescient global issues!

  • @RutwikPandit
    @RutwikPandit Před rokem +96

    How, absolutely love Stephen. One of the best episodes yet !

  • @davidj7201
    @davidj7201 Před rokem +42

    Great to see Kotkin on Goodfellows live.

  • @aurelio-reymilaorcabal9669

    Goodfellow is one of my favorite shows and Stephen Kotkin and HR McMaster the best of analysts.

  • @One_Nation_Conversation
    @One_Nation_Conversation Před rokem +31

    Lol, I love the title to this episode. Goodfellows certainly have a sense of humor -- Joe Pesci would approve. Dr. Kotkin never fails to deliver.

  • @alexanderbristo4599
    @alexanderbristo4599 Před rokem +35

    Steve Kotkin is brilliant

  • @philipford6183
    @philipford6183 Před rokem +148

    An outstanding episode - well done to all involved. A fascinating conversation - Kotkin's a very special guest.

  • @ninabak744
    @ninabak744 Před rokem +41

    Thanks so much. Professor Kotkin , already look forward to your return on the show.

  • @--Dani
    @--Dani Před rokem +23

    Somehow include Dr. Kotkin in the Goodfellows podcast full-time...my God a great podcast would be best ever.
    Big fan either way Fellows 👍

  • @saralwen2622
    @saralwen2622 Před rokem +27

    Kotkin and McMaster are voices of reason as allways. Great content👌

  • @andrewdemchyshyn6599
    @andrewdemchyshyn6599 Před rokem +16

    Me as Ukrainian could not have said it more clearer then Kotkin did. He just knocked out of park. Public need to hear more such accurate takes, it will definitely clear a lot of confusing and will help to drum up support for Ukraine

  • @dancaulfield1008
    @dancaulfield1008 Před rokem +13

    Kotkin is the man!!!!!

  • @IRoch86
    @IRoch86 Před rokem +44

    I'll watch any video with Prof Kotkin, he should have a podcast or his own CZcams channel!!

  • @deankruse2891
    @deankruse2891 Před rokem +23

    so glad Stephen Kotkin was able to be on this episode. Thank you for putting these out, for free, for us to enjoy.

  • @yttlnn45
    @yttlnn45 Před rokem +14

    WooHoo! The Legend Himself! What a treat!🥳
    Thanks a lot Hoover!😊

  • @jonnyjazzz
    @jonnyjazzz Před rokem +11

    Wow, I have never heard a description of this time period of China like this. Really glad I watched this.

  • @mp33blades
    @mp33blades Před rokem +10

    Kotkin is the GOAT

  • @peredavi
    @peredavi Před rokem +32

    Such fantastic discussions and information. Thank you! I’m just a retired airfreight pilot and merchant marine engineer who loves to read history and geopolitics. I went to Nanjing, China as a cadet engineer in 1982, then flew a great deal into Hong Kong, Shanghai,Tsingtao and Guangzhou 1999-2020. Saw a lot of changes. I was greatly disturbed by trade imbalances and I.P. theft for many years.

  • @Bad_spark
    @Bad_spark Před rokem +13

    Kotkin is bloody hilarious and brilliant as usual. He really is extremely entertaining when he's in front of a camera. Yes, Cochrane, Ferguson and McMaster are also great, but Kotkin really shines in this format.

  • @hhmichitsch
    @hhmichitsch Před rokem +31

    Excellent show! Love Kotkin, what a speaker, what a wit. I laughed several times. It is so refeshing to hear such intelligent conversation and comment. I hope to see more from the "Big K" in future at Hoover. As to Mr Kotkin's qestion, I'm one, I don't know who the other guy is.

  • @bpm990d
    @bpm990d Před rokem +14

    Fantastic epispde and very enlightening conversation. Prof. Kotkin is quickly becoming one of my favorite academics.

  • @liamblackshaw3164
    @liamblackshaw3164 Před rokem +11

    The episode we've all been waiting for.

  • @Xandil
    @Xandil Před rokem +10

    It's always great to hear Dr. Kotkin, but especially so with the Good Fellows. It makes my commute back and forth to the office much more enjoyable. Thanks!

  • @judge4all
    @judge4all Před rokem +10

    I highly recommend that the Good Fellows extend further invitation to the fine Professor to the show.

  • @user-oi9iz9jr8y
    @user-oi9iz9jr8y Před rokem +17

    Fantastic show. Steven is very interesting

  • @MrEnjoyBeats
    @MrEnjoyBeats Před rokem +11

    Kotkin is always a pleasure!

  • @WhizzingFish12
    @WhizzingFish12 Před rokem +15

    1st Comment - woo hoo! Kotkin is brilliant in both knowledge and explanatory ability. Always love listening to him.

  • @mel3004
    @mel3004 Před rokem +16

    What a great show! Thanks so much.

  • @robertdobosz9681
    @robertdobosz9681 Před rokem +12

    Wow Kotkin is a superstar!

  • @SidekickSam24
    @SidekickSam24 Před rokem +18

    It's nice to have people who can talk about these serious topics but can keep it light-hearted. It can be easy to get frustrated or despairing when looking at the problems in the world. We need to remember to not take everything too seriously and allow room for humor. Humor can solve some of the problems on its own.

  • @ChrisHam01
    @ChrisHam01 Před rokem +22

    What a fantastic episode. A new high watermark. Thanks!

  • @Saggizone
    @Saggizone Před rokem +9

    Hurrah for the Steve!!!! I asked! 🙏👌

  • @thanksfernuthin
    @thanksfernuthin Před rokem +11

    So nice to see face to face discourse. I never realized how important that was until the COVID Zoom era. If this conversation was held on Zoom it would have had half the information and twice the talk over/awkward pauses. We humans definitely need to see each other's facial and body cues real time to efficiently converse.

  • @MrCarlGW
    @MrCarlGW Před rokem +13

    Stephen, you were remarkable. Thank-you. I'm finishing up Paradox of Power. Take your time on Vol III. I still have II to read. 😃

  • @mattben
    @mattben Před rokem +10

    Knowledge and humor, i love it

  • @pilarramos3305
    @pilarramos3305 Před 9 měsíci +1

    My favorite historian. Thank you for featuring him, fascinating and fun, great combination.

  • @lawrencemartin24
    @lawrencemartin24 Před rokem +10

    Kotkin is fascinating.

  • @hikerJohn
    @hikerJohn Před rokem +9

    Kotkin is great to listen to. He needs to get out more often . . . :o)

  • @michaelgrisafi821
    @michaelgrisafi821 Před rokem +8

    Fantastic conversation. Stevephen K's. ability to negotiate the many tributaries that serve a great river of knowledge
    Is to us amateurs, truly, a gift of insights, that illuminate past and present observations very few can parralle. He's at the top of his game and we're grateful for such contributions to contemporary parlance.

  • @idriwzrd
    @idriwzrd Před rokem +3

    What an excellent discussion. Kotkin was an invaluable addition.

  • @strelnikoff1632
    @strelnikoff1632 Před rokem +9

    Great show. Full marks.

  • @charlesmackey8179
    @charlesmackey8179 Před rokem +5

    Outstanding from All !

  • @mikelis106
    @mikelis106 Před rokem +10

    finally you got him here, sure enough he played hard to get!

  • @designwithintent8270
    @designwithintent8270 Před rokem +7

    Gentlemen, another insightful analysis of the war and beyond!

  • @messinround4810
    @messinround4810 Před rokem +8

    Yay professor Kotkin!

  • @mart7379
    @mart7379 Před rokem +8

    Outstanding. I look forward to every Goodfellows episode.

  • @allen143
    @allen143 Před rokem +2

    Live and in person, what a refreshing change.

  • @omacburma
    @omacburma Před rokem +3

    Great show, thanks for bringing Dr. Kotkin on. The show is at it's best when it deals with issues like these.

  • @oliverliddell613
    @oliverliddell613 Před rokem +1

    I love this guy. He is so disarming in appearance and accent but so fluent in his knowledge and delivery.

  • @dmeyer0
    @dmeyer0 Před rokem +6

    Thank you, Stephen Kotkin. Thank you so much - this was a fascinating show. I'm a huge fan and am eagerly awaiting the 3rd book in your Stalin biography.

  • @markc5025
    @markc5025 Před rokem +27

    Excellent show. Stephen was great as always. Very hard to make a prediction about the war. It will come down to which society can endure more pain. We have poor visibility into how badly the sanctions are hitting Russia. The effect of mobilization on the Russian economy has to be massive along with the cutoff of European purchases of gas and oil. My money is on the Ukrainians.

  • @ericwillis777
    @ericwillis777 Před rokem +2

    Thankyou for this podcast, and well done Stephen Kotkin, excellent comments and responses, much appreciated.

  • @elmarwolters2751
    @elmarwolters2751 Před rokem +5

    Thank you guys, I'm learning .....

  • @ma7rix13
    @ma7rix13 Před rokem +2

    I propose Professor K as a permanent member of the Goodfellas. His intelligence and comedic input really makes this enjoyable to listen to.

  • @harrybarber4391
    @harrybarber4391 Před rokem +6

    Great discussion. Thank you all!

  • @freda7436
    @freda7436 Před rokem +5

    I would pay good money to hear Kotkin do the " I'm funny? Funny how?..." line Joe Pesci does in Goodfellas!

  • @annejames2442
    @annejames2442 Před rokem +6

    Stephen Kotkin my absolute favorite. Thank you for a great show.

  • @slavemonkey5063
    @slavemonkey5063 Před rokem +1

    Great show, great guest! Bring Steven Kotkin back anytime to talk about anything, not just Russia!

  • @DennisDithmar
    @DennisDithmar Před rokem +3

    Brilliant show. Kotkin is always worth the while - and then some.

  • @dickjivas5996
    @dickjivas5996 Před rokem +1

    PLEASE bring this man back, you're my favorite 5.

  • @matthewhartt5887
    @matthewhartt5887 Před rokem +3

    Thank you Prof. Kotkin for teaching me so much. Thank you sir.

  • @henkbielderman4243
    @henkbielderman4243 Před rokem +6

    What a pleasure!

  • @JieSuCabc
    @JieSuCabc Před rokem +2

    I learned a lot from Stephen Kotkin. Thank you.

  • @Brommear
    @Brommear Před rokem +5

    This was the best 1 hour and a bit I have had in years - if not ever!

  • @SeattlePioneer
    @SeattlePioneer Před rokem +2

    Yes, but STEPHEN! WHEN can we expect Volume III of Stalin?
    When that has been delivered, I will be glad to hear you on these talk shows!
    I don't want to see graven on Stephen's tombstone:
    "Volumes I & II of Stalin were GREAT!"

  • @cool_guy
    @cool_guy Před rokem +4

    GoodFellows 3D
    Love u guys!

  • @Drewski005
    @Drewski005 Před rokem +2

    Captivating and informative, looking forward to the sequel. 😀

  • @redsix5165
    @redsix5165 Před rokem +4

    I was anticipating the cheers and laughed when I heard them!

  • @overlex
    @overlex Před 11 měsíci +2

    I wish Kotkin would quote Pesci more often 😂 He’s a very funny guy!

  • @Rader-iv9fk
    @Rader-iv9fk Před rokem +3

    Guys, you MUST add Kotkin to the Goodfellas podcast, I am telling you this guy is awesome, and I love the accent. Your Podcast will explode in a GREAT way! Kotkin is a commen sense guy but he is brilianT!

  • @richardt.buryan832
    @richardt.buryan832 Před rokem +4

    OUTSTANDING.

  • @veeas11
    @veeas11 Před rokem +1

    its like 4 kids in a treehouse, and simultaneously the deepest conversation in the world

  • @BKLevi
    @BKLevi Před rokem +2

    I seriously enjoyed this show. One to save.

  • @michaelodonovan6989
    @michaelodonovan6989 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Serious guy with a great sense of humour. Love the whole panel as well. Well done people, subscribed.

  • @roxannekeomaka4754
    @roxannekeomaka4754 Před rokem +1

    Mr. Kotkin is so interesting. I can listen and learn fro him all day, everyday!

  • @guillermomira2122
    @guillermomira2122 Před rokem +1

    Thanks for bringing Stephen on!!

  • @davidhawkins7138
    @davidhawkins7138 Před rokem +6

    Steven Kotkin has a deep understanding of so many issues. Thank you for this and the excellent comments and questions.
    I have 1 quibble with his analysis. There is no way that Russia can "disable" the SpaceX Starlink satellites. This isn't a single giant geostationary satellite, it's a network of over 2,300 satellites. SpaceX is launching them at a rate of over 50 satellites per week. Losing 1, 10, or a few hundred wouldn't stop the system from working. Russia can't do anything about this.

  • @Paochinblog
    @Paochinblog Před 10 měsíci +1

    Kudos to Ukraine. It is crucial to establish a universal nation that incorporates smaller countries capable of contributing unique strategies against communism. Dr. Kotkin's insights are highly valued.

  • @TheHighlanderprime
    @TheHighlanderprime Před rokem +1

    Steven’s Pesci accent and orator style and his profound knowledge makes for a very unique and original presentation. Just imagine Joe Pesci making these presentations. It’s both funny and captivating.