Maruti Suzuki Alto vs Renault Kwid: Don't Invest In These!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 04. 2024
  • In this clip from MotorInc Balance, Kartikeya says you should actually save your money, wait longer and move to the next higher segment of cars if you can - they're are a lot better.
    ~
    MotorInc Balance is our segment where we present perspective on two or more vehicles so that the differences between the two become clear and it becomes easier for you to decide which of them would fit better into your life.
    ~
    #MotorInc #MotorIncBalance #MarutiSuzuki #Renault #MarutiSuzukiAlto #RenaultKwid #LordAlto #Comparison #KartikeyaSinghee
  • Auta a dopravní prostředky

Komentáře • 45

  • @tanujsoni3057
    @tanujsoni3057 Před 3 měsíci +23

    Got tiago nrg 2024 for 8 lakh rupees on Road! TOP end model, kwid top end cost 7 lakhs.. for just 1 or 1.5 lakh more... you are getting a wayyyyy better car.

    • @RaxitD31
      @RaxitD31 Před 3 měsíci +27

      Got XUV 300 for 9.5 lakhs. For just 1.5 lakh more got a much bigger and better car than tiago NRG.
      This thing goes on and on sir.

    • @yashmaheshwari1727
      @yashmaheshwari1727 Před 3 měsíci +5

      ​@@RaxitD31 so basically bump from Alto to XUV 300

    • @nikhilPUD01
      @nikhilPUD01 Před 3 měsíci

      I am looking for 2bd hand car Maharashtra
      Which one should I buy

    • @Anonymous-tz3gw
      @Anonymous-tz3gw Před 3 měsíci

      बाजार में इतना आप्शन है कि हरेक 20-25 हजार के अंतर पर कार उपलब्ध है😮😮😮😮

  • @vyshakreghukumar995
    @vyshakreghukumar995 Před 3 měsíci +4

    Couple of reasons why I think such small cars are absolutely required.
    1. In very tight bylanes I've encountered bigass buses and trucks coming from the opposite direction, and with sedans and large hatchbacks it is just a headache to pass such tricky situations. But with a small cars, it becomes really stress-free.
    2. Parking is getting tougher with each passing day and the smaller the car, the easier things become.
    3. Finally there are some people (don't call me sexist for saying this, but mostly women) who I've seen struggle for years and unable to master the skill of driving. I've seen some struggling for almost 20 years and yet unable to drive in manual cars. For such people, getting a small automatic car would've saved many years.

    • @motorinc
      @motorinc  Před 3 měsíci +1

      Hullo V! Completely get that! Tha nos for sharing!
      We aren’t denying the importance or usefulness of these cars. We are questioning if there’s better value to be found. And today there most definitely is.

  • @rajoosolanky780
    @rajoosolanky780 Před 3 měsíci +20

    You are right. But only the bigger boot, suspensions, etc. are not ENOUGH.
    Your Small Cars needs Easily Available-Affordable Spares, good Quality After-Sales Services & Service Stns Network.
    And that's where the KWID does not match the Maruti Alto's Engine Refinements, Reliability & Service Stns Network.
    After investing buyers hard earned money, everyone expects good ownership experience. Is it not.
    Since Renaults Cars Sales nos. are very low their Services Stns Spares Stocking is poor & at the same time to Service Stn to cover minimum cost of operations they unethically charge extra.

  • @iamfinallypaying-nr5xw
    @iamfinallypaying-nr5xw Před 2 měsíci +2

    6800 km , 4 months , Alto K10 VXI+ AMT works like charm , great machine very nimble in Indian city traffic and occasional highways usage , getting 21 kmpl solid . No maintainance exp spent. Could have bought a car at 10 lakhs price range but the size has saved me so much time searching for parking and cruising down narrow streets .

    • @motorinc
      @motorinc  Před 2 měsíci

      Thanks for sharing @iamfinallypaying-nr5xw.

  • @HunterVlog350cc
    @HunterVlog350cc Před 3 měsíci +5

    for tier 2 cities and congested places these 2 are just fine. agree??? for everything else there is Tiago❤❤

  • @sufiyansheikh131
    @sufiyansheikh131 Před 3 měsíci +2

    Why not simply get a reliable and decently well maintained used car? It'll be old but i guess it'll give u better value if u get the right car at the right price

  • @arciful
    @arciful Před 3 měsíci

    You guys are awesome auto journalist!!

  • @nomustacheguy5249
    @nomustacheguy5249 Před 2 měsíci

    Probably one of the best advice I've seen Karthikeyan give oj this channel. No weird hyperboles.

  • @garbhitkumawat2172
    @garbhitkumawat2172 Před 3 měsíci +3

    Where is 1.5X option....

  • @sierralimaa
    @sierralimaa Před 3 měsíci

    So what’s the right small hatchback which ticks most checkbox but is not heavy on the pocket as well ?

    • @motorinc
      @motorinc  Před 3 měsíci +1

      Depending on your preferences and budget - Celerio, Exter, Ignis, WagonR, Kiger/Magnite. Many choices! Do let us know what you are looking for, we’ll try to help out here. Thanks!

  • @yuvisyuniverse
    @yuvisyuniverse Před 3 měsíci +1

    I heard rock solid then I heard reputation not build quality.

  • @abirpramanik
    @abirpramanik Před 3 měsíci

    hi shumi sir, Very confused Between two bike ns200 and n250 ... want a bike Which feel less vibration at 110- 120 , what you prefer.. ns or n250???

    • @manoja538
      @manoja538 Před 3 měsíci

      Hey buddy, my advice is to test ride both the bikes. If you want to cruise at 3 digit speeds then i would suggest you to go for n250, it's more modern than the vintage 200ns.

    • @abirpramanik
      @abirpramanik Před 3 měsíci

      @@manoja538 thanks for advice i m also bit leaning towards n250

  • @factyou22
    @factyou22 Před 3 měsíci +5

    Nice but can I ask you why you're speaking in 0.25x speed?

    • @daninwheels1006
      @daninwheels1006 Před 3 měsíci +11

      Simply to grab attention, when we slow down our speech we tend to listen carefully

  • @Hikefly-05
    @Hikefly-05 Před 3 měsíci

    Which one above segment plz do reply?

    • @manoja538
      @manoja538 Před 3 měsíci

      Tiago, i10 nios , wagon r

  • @abhishekjha346
    @abhishekjha346 Před 3 měsíci +1

    why you talk like this ????
    Well, primarily putting your money into buying any car is not an investment in any economic sense. Its depreciating asset. Nobody buys car as an investment, like buying a house or a plot. Its a necessity and one needs it, like buying a refrigerator. its a necessity not an investment

    • @Anonymous-tz3gw
      @Anonymous-tz3gw Před 3 měsíci

      इस हिसाब से तो हरेक इलेक्ट्रॉनिक और इलेक्ट्रिक सामान डेपरिशिएटिंग एसेट है 😆😆😆😆😆😆

    • @abhishekjha346
      @abhishekjha346 Před 3 měsíci

      @@Anonymous-tz3gw bilkul., car khareedna nivesh kaise ho sakta hai. Aaj BMW khareedo., ek mahine baad bechne jao toh uska value kam ho jaata hai.,
      Aaj iphone kareedo, ek maheene baad bechne jao., toh kya cost price se zyada milega ?? Then how is it investment.

  • @swkulkar
    @swkulkar Před 3 měsíci

    Alto's Engine feels superior to drive. Kwid in comparison needs improvement.
    If you like driving then between these two Alto should be your choice.

  • @CuriousSteveOfficial
    @CuriousSteveOfficial Před 2 měsíci

    If i can go beyond what are the other cars sir, i have watched a couple of videos but you haven't revealed those. Currently i'm considereing these two if i can move my budget a little bit whats the best choice @motorinc please tell me

  • @user-ex7ex1qt4t
    @user-ex7ex1qt4t Před 3 měsíci

    "Investing" in either of these cars is a stupid "investment".

  • @Hikefly-05
    @Hikefly-05 Před 3 měsíci

    I'm looking for compact car with 4 on board traveling around city with wk end or long wk trip with friends in western ghats trekking, going in hills for paraglding and family friendly car my wife should be able drive confidently in small tr 2 and 3 city etc
    U should compare both car with segment above for better clarity. As it is going to be my first and last car for nxt 10 yr for sure. Bcz I don't want to invest my money in car I want to buy an bike with small 250cc to 400cc off road capabilities bike with light weight agile, vting as shumi told alredy told that ktm is working on new frame for adventure. Hope you got what I want? 😂😂😂

    • @vyshakreghukumar995
      @vyshakreghukumar995 Před 3 měsíci +1

      For driving in ghats, I'd recommend the S-presso. The crash rating is really poor, so do not attempt any dangerous maneuvers. 😅
      For the rest, it's a really awesome workhorse. Decent interiors, compact dimensions, city driving manners, good ground clearance for handling bad roads, decent engine with ample power, well calibrated AMT.
      For biking, I'd recommend the Xpulse 200 4V. Very light weight and capable off-roader, but unsure of its city driving manners. You could also check out Suzuki V-Strom SX, Yezdi Adventure, RE Scram, RE Himalayan. Or you could wait for the upcoming RE Scram 440, KTM Adventure/Enduro 390/250. (The Xpulse 400/440 might not launch soon, hence waiting might be futile).

  • @RiturajDixit-dv9qe
    @RiturajDixit-dv9qe Před 3 měsíci

    What should we upgrade too?

    • @motorinc
      @motorinc  Před 3 měsíci +3

      Celerio, Ignis, Kiger/Magnite, Exter. More options too… let us know what you are looking for. Will try to help out!

    • @Hikefly-05
      @Hikefly-05 Před 3 měsíci +2

      I'm looking for compact car with 4 on board traveling around city with wk end or long wk trip with friends in western ghats trekking, going in hills for paraglding and family friendly car my wife should be able drive confidently in small tr 2 and 3 city etc
      U should compare both car with segment above for better clarity. As it is going to be my first and last car for nxt 10 yr for sure. Bcz I don't want to invest my money in car I want to buy an bike with small 250cc to 400cc off road capabilities bike with light weight agile, vting as shumi told alredy told that ktm is working on new frame for adventure. Hope you got what I want? 😂😂😂

    • @vnk0518
      @vnk0518 Před 3 měsíci

      ​@@motorinc i want a car i move rarely a week. With good petrol mileage

    • @Hikefly-05
      @Hikefly-05 Před měsícem

      @@motorinc what about upcoming C3

    • @Hikefly-05
      @Hikefly-05 Před měsícem

      @ what about face-lift of updated C3