The Sigma 16-28mm F2.8// Beautiful Optics, Mediocre Autofocus.
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2022
- GET 10% OFF your next Squarespace website: www.squarespace.com/mannyortiz
MY COLOR GRADING PRESETS: www.manuelortizphoto.com/presets
CHECK OUT HOW I RETOUCH MY PORTRAITS: geni.us/Retouchingcourse
THE MANNY ORTIZ BEAUTY DISH: geni.us/Whitebeautydish
GEAR USED TO SHOOT THIS VIDEO
SIGMA LENS: bhpho.to/3GGMTO0
MY VIDEO CAMERA: bhpho.to/3dw8T17
WIDE ANGLE LENS: bhpho.to/3kmh5Sb
MACRO LENS USED FOR BROLL: amzn.to/34zaeTv
CAMERA SLIDER: bhpho.to/2MVz1Yp
SENNHEISER MIC: bhpho.to/3NCtD6K
MIC ARM: bhpho.to/3a2Z0IY
APUTURE 120D: bhpho.to/3GEXuJH
APUTURE LIGHT DOME: amzn.to/3MTgQwP
WINDOW LIGHT PROJECTOR: amzn.to/3PM1Brm - Zábava
Good, fair, and honest review without any digs at other brands - love it.
No other reviewer compared the Sigma to the Tamron 17-28. This is why I come to Manny’s channel. Appreciate it!
Dustin abbott
@@RemplacementTV They didn't when it first came out... this is 8 months later ;)
Its the most obvious compariso
@@therealdrachi12 There wasn't an comparison when I made this comment this a year ago
For my S5 this is a must have. I have the Tamron for my Sony sonic have all bases covered. Excited to get this one. Love this range for walk around.
That Blowout valve shooting into the atmosphere and that backfire, ufff!! You should do a walk through of your VW (R32..? I think). I know this isn’t a car channel but it would be awesome if you did a video of your car. Great review of the lens!
Thanks for watching and commenting......
Congratulations you have been selected among the lucky winner's
Telegram only to claim your prize...
I came for the video and replayed the crackles like 40 times lol great video like allways 💪🏻
You should compare the 16mm on the sigma vs the 17mm on the Tamron correcting the distorsion in postprocessing. The Sigma has a lot more distorsion at 16mm than Tamron at 17mm and when you apply that correction, the photo is a lot less wide. I saw that before buying the Sigma, and now I have a copy I could see how big is the cut when you correct the photos. I would like to see the comparaison between 2 photos corrected.
Do the Sigma 20mm f/1.4 and the 24mm f/1.4 have the same problems with the focus?
I am considering them or the Panasonic Lumix S 18mm f/1.8 for night club photo AND video work.
Which one would you recommend for such a use case?
Honestly more excited by the crackle of the Golf than the lens itself.lol. Need to do some more pulls in a future video.
I hate to ask this here but: Is there a way to use an off camera speedlight without a tigger/ receiver and without a on camera flash? Thanks
Thank you for the feedback! Great video!
hi Manny, there is an update for this lens, ver.02 released last november 2022, was it able to fix the autofocus problem? thank you!
Many estoy buscando un buen lente para hacer videografia de bodas y e comprado 2 y no me gustan ...me recomiendas este?
The focus issue is present on the 16mm f1.4 for the aps-c. It was the reason why I returned mine. It was maddening. I was trying to focus on a plant close by, I'd touch the screen to focus on a different object far into the distance and it had the exact same behaviour. You can't blame the camera as it does not happen with any other lens but sigmas. Sigma if you read this, please do something about it!
How would you say the Sigma 16-28mm contemporary compares to the Sigma 14-24mm art lens? I have a Sony A7iv and am on the hunt for a wide-angle lens to do some pet studio photography. I have other Sigma art lenses but my biggest concern is weight. Those art lenses are heavy and I am worried that it might be too tiring trying to shoot one handed at times while handling animals with the other :) On the other hand you mentioned the AF in the 16-28mm was not great, which is a huge concern considering I am trying to capture not so still subjects ;) Would love to hear your thoughts! Thanks!!
Finally another wide angle by Sigma for Sony FE mount... Definitely gonna get it
Really debating between the sony 16-35 PZ, Sigma 16-28 2.8 or just stay with the sony 20mm for vlog purposes. Could anyone please help?
Has the autofocus been fixed via firmware update?
Can you tell me a wide angle (fixed or zoom), with wide aperture, no F/4, with very good autofocus for my Panasonic S5II?
Excellent video friend, please does anyone know if they improved the autofocus issue with any update? Or has anyone else had that problem with that lens?
sigma
HI Money. So do you like this lens or not? I can't decide if i should buy it!
is the autofocus problem fixed yet? Thinking of getting this lens
I think the focus breathing isn't bad at all but the hunting killed it for me. Thanks for pointing that out. Going for the Sony 16-35pz since video is my main focus (pun not intended)
I kinda can’t believe he complained about the breathing. Ridiculous.
What you running on your car bro ?. Engine size, air intake , Turbo. BHP? Etc sounds nice 💜
I've been waiting to hear about this lens. Autofocus doesn't bother me, I use a Panasonic S camera 🤌. But the focus breathing is disappointing for video use.
We are together AHAHH. Sony/canon users like "its slower" Dude we are panasonic users that slow or fast as long it focus we are happy. someone should try with panasonic .
Im waiting 2 days than i might buy it and do a review with using focus sensivity
I'm waiting for the stage 3 tune. Cool.
Very difficult to decide between the sigma, the new sony 16-35mm G PZ and my 20mm f1.8... I think I might goo for the combo of sigma and sony 20mm
Sony 20mm is such a beautiful lens. Just about perfect in every aspect I care about.
The new 16-35 has brutal distortion which is a deal breaker for me.
Love the R. I have a mk6 GTI.
Great! I agree with you!
Anyone have thoughts on this Sigma 16-28mm f/2.8 vs. the Sony 16-35mm f/4 PZ?
He said “sus” lol. My kids say this all the time! Nice lens. I have the gm but considering the pz since I typically don’t need fast aperture for outdoors.
The 14-24mm is by far my favorite 😊
Me too, I just bought one recently. Amazing sharpness wide open and great autofocus.
It’s also much bigger, heavier, more expensive, has a bulbous front element, but yeah it’s a nice lens but if you travel it’s perhaps on the bigger heavier side if you need to carry other lenses.
can't put filters on the front is a deal breaker
tamrom looks wider ! nice
Your car sounds so good.
Sweet whip! I have a Mk7.5 GTi 😃
I shoot the Tokina opera 16-28mm f/2.8 FF and the results with my Canon 5DSR are amazing .......
I shot pro beach volleyball olympians for years with the Tamron and never dealt with any dust / sand.
Seems like the only issues really effect video performance. I don't shoot much video so this became very intriguing.
Thanks for watching and commenting......
Congratulations you have been selected among the lucky winner's
Telegram only to claim your prize....
What are you using to hold your camera so steady in the back seat?
Got something for my subscribers
Reach out to me ☝️☝️..
Maybe the autofocus will be fixed in a firmware update. Either way I’m in the market for a wide angle zoom lens and I thought my only affordable option was the Tamron 17-28mm until now.
I have since a half year and it work perfect for architecture and interior also for gimbal work you don't have to re balance.
I don't know if they will fix the AF. I'm sending my lens back. The AF is pulsating, that's unacceptable.
Bro your VW Golf is effing sick !!! you need to put out some car content
Creative way to use and review it. That’s why you’ve blown up so much since I believe 2018/19 when I got my a7iii after finding your review
Ok Manny is a car guy. We need more car content
Hi Manny, I am debating getting this Sigma 16-28 F2.8 or the Sony 20mm F1.8 G.. I mainly shoot video. I already have the Sigma 24-70 F2.8. Which one would you recommend? Thanks
yo pienso que el 20mm iria mejor... la calidad me parece mucho mayor aparte de ser un focal fija!
@@yormaalva I agree, I think the 20mm would be better.
I'm on the same hesitation at this time :) what did you finally choose buddy ? thanks
@@mattpna Hey Matt, I endend up choosing the Sigma 16-28 F2.8, great lens! Have it for one year now, no problems 👌
@@andreasvanhoutte Hey thanks a lot Andreas, really appreciate your reply that much time after your commented the video. Really appreciate. Actually I was on the way to order the sigma lol. Thanks man and have great day !
I own this lens and it’s great in everything except for the heavy distortion at 16mm. Even with correction turned on it makes it almost not usable…
I'd wait to upgrade to 17-28 G2.
Is that actually happening
Disregarding anything else, there's just something I love about Sigma glass and the colors/vibe it produces. I've had both the Tamron 17-28 and 28-75, and honestly while they're perfectly fine lenses, they just look, uh, okay. Idk if the colors are cooler or what, but they just look bland to me. Loving my Sigma 24-70 on my a7S III and I think the Sigma 16-28 might be my next lens!
I LOVE the A7SIII/Sigma Art 24-70 combo. I was gutted to realise the 14-24 Art can't take a Variable ND due to the convex front element. Still, the 16-28 is the next best wide angle for that camera. Image quality is as good as the Art and although the build quality isn't quite as good, it's completed my lens line up.
@@nega9000 please does anyone know if they improved the autofocus issue with any update? Or has anyone else had that problem with that lens? sigma
@@mijhaelvi5921 I didn’t know there was an autofocus issue with that lens! I do know it plays very nicely with my A7SIII. No issues at all so far.
So car photoshoot?
Here for the cute 🐕 ❤
Hi Manny, Bussiness inquires, pls reply, thank you
Been trying to upgrade my equipment 😭
Man I came for the lens and stayed for the car YIKES. NICE!
That VW sounds good baaaaby!
MK7 guy here 🤚🏾. Came for the review stayed for the R footage.
Man forget the lenses, it’s the blow off valve for me! I love that sound!
He was just trying to show off his exhaust and blow off valve, LOL
😂 ruthless!
Only needed one reason. My S1R needs this. But then I'm only shooting boring interiors LOL
just copped the Sigma 50mm 1.4 for Sony E mount and it's money I've ever spent 🙌🏾💯
That’s a shame to hear about the AF. The 24-70 is nuts on AF
Nikon preset
The R looks amazing. Very clean. Have you considered doing a night shoot around the city and filming the experience ?
Seems like the AF issues really only happen at 16mm going from minimum focus to far away. That's not something that bothers me too much, especially if Sigma releases firmware updates. This looks like a really beautiful lens to pair with my Sigma 28-70mm, which I'm honestly very happy with. Thanks for the review!
I had the 16mm f1.4 (aps-c lens), it had the exact same behaviour. I guess they're using the exact same software for the 16mm focusing bit and it has some issues. The lens I had is a prime, which makes it infuriating as there is no other focal length to choose from, so you're stuck with that.
3 years ago i bought the 16-35 2.8 GM. Still the best, for me.
Great review. Autofocus performance information is very important. Single autofocus beep beep tests are irrelevant, most lenses could do that.
Thanks for watching and commenting......
Congratulations you have been selected among the lucky winner's
Telegram only to claim your prize..
Some lens (sigma) still have more yellow color. If you have tamron 28-75 then take tamron 17-28 the same colors is better option. Some of 24-70 and 85 art have yellow tint and this is not for all copy wtf ;/
Got something for my subscribers
Reach out to me ☝️☝️...
Focus breathing isn't an issue at all.. recently I watched a 2022 movie on Netflix and in some scenes there was a tremendous amount of focus breathing and guess what, it didn't matter at all and I wonder why non-professional videographers and photographers who use cameras like A7 would really care that much about it.
Exactly. For any non cine lens (ESP a wide angle zoom), a small amount of focus breathing is perfectly acceptable. Esp when racking from close to far. In most general situations the focus pull will not be that extreme and therefore barely noticeable. One thing that a lot of these comparisons fail to mention is the Tamron's focus by wire system which is brutal for any kind of manual focus situations as it's totally non linear.
I just ordered the 35mm f/1.4 GM Lens can’t wait to use it !!
I’m glad I purchased the Batis 25mm instead. Both of these are pookie
Manny never really touches Nikon products
Congratulations you won and thanks for watching..
Congratulations you won and thanks for watching..
Sony still on top.
17 looks so compressed compared 16
17 looks almost the same as 16, you wouldn't ever guess which is which in blind test.
The focus breathing doesn't look bad at all.
For ultrawide, AF isn't that important for Photographers.
I believe you got a bad copy. All reviews that I watched don't have any focusing issues.
a portrait shooter who will read the specs and spew words for content and will never ever use the lens in his lifetime. the plebs are engrossed as usual
Bro, the PERFECTION does not exist, we all know that. However, Sigma produce high quality glass, I love my Sigma lenses, even though my Canon lenses was way more expensive, for instance...
Sigma is definitely warmer than Tamron and I don't like it.
I thought Sony cameras don’t have AF issue? Hmmmmmmmmmm
Hola Manny, el 40 mm 1.4 Art de Sigma es el que me ha aportado ésa alta definición natural que andaba buscando.saludos desdé España
The car footage was cool 😎
Alr so this means sony >>> canon
i wait your upload ahaha and i want to report the same name and he said i won
what is up with the irresponsable driving???? wanna kill some dogs??
The video was nice, maybe I miss it, but is this only for the Sony system?
Thanks for the video
Despite the fall on crypto, Expert Angela Cole Carr remains the best and I recommend her to all investors out there.
Same here, I started with $3,000 now earning $28,300 bi-weekly profits with her trading program.
HOW! I would really appreciate if you show me how to go about it. Please can you list the platforms ?
I Totally agree! Investment has also changed my life financially and I have heard a lot about investments with Expert Angela Cole Carr and how good she is, please how safe are the profits?
She's really amazing i still cannot believe someone can be this exceptional when it comes to Bitcoin activities.
I've really heard lot about Mrs Angela Cole Carr , please can I have her info
Sigma is better.