Revenge of the Sith DELETED SCENE Finally Reveals Anakin's Father

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 15. 04. 2022
  • NEW STAR WARS MERCH PAGE: bit.ly/TheStupendousWaveMerch
    For all sponsorship and business inquiries please contact:
    thestupendousscrub@gmail.com
    Business: tmarvelouswave@gmail.com
    Twitter: @StupendousWave
    I believe all content used falls under the remits of Fair Use, but if any content owners would like to dispute this I will not hesitate to immediately remove said content. It is not my intent to in any way infringe on their content ownership. If you happen to find your art or images in the video please let me know and I will be glad to credit you. End Song By WhiteSand "Eternity" • Whitesand - Eternity (...
    Composer: Whitesand (Martynas Lau)
    Year: 2017
    Title: Eternity Additional Music Terminus by: Scott Buckley
    Released under CC-BY 4.0.
    www.scottbuckley.com.au
    Terminus: • 'Terminus' [Epic Cinem...
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1,2K

  • @arbknight12
    @arbknight12 Před 2 lety +1136

    I still say the Plagiues book had the best explanation.
    Sidious and Plagiues meditated on the Dark Side together to throw the Force out of balance.
    The Force didn’t like it, so it retaliated by creating Anakin.

    • @05goode
      @05goode Před 2 lety +31

      No plaguies created him on his own. He even explains to Sidious he went to far

    • @klaudrequester8078
      @klaudrequester8078 Před 2 lety

      That still sounds kinda fucking stupid ngl

    • @the_SolLoser
      @the_SolLoser Před 2 lety +18

      All of that is so dumb. 😂

    • @ap3085
      @ap3085 Před 2 lety +92

      @@05goode arbknight is right. George toyed with the idea of Anakin being palatines or plagious’s Kin through this idea but he scrapped it. The force “retaliating” is the most sound explanation we have in legends.

    • @jackmeds12
      @jackmeds12 Před 2 lety +14

      @@05goode Plageius didn’t create Anakin

  • @lilmike1780
    @lilmike1780 Před 2 lety +1617

    Had Disney not taken over and made everything that was so well crafted and perfect and turned it to legends, then the darth plagueis novel would have explained the whole situation. Well here we are having everything that was amazing being made non-cannon by Disney it breaks my heart. There are sooooo many great series of books that could have been made into great movies, but instead they threw it all away for a story many don’t even care for. Just my 2 cents

    • @polynesianmovtgp7439
      @polynesianmovtgp7439 Před 2 lety

      Yeah that's what Disney does... Molest things.

    • @joelagyeman3146
      @joelagyeman3146 Před 2 lety +89

      @Golgari Assassin can we make an exception for rebels and rogue one

    • @bobagucci502
      @bobagucci502 Před 2 lety +36

      I'm sorry but a lot of those books where trash and episode one stuff killed star wars Disney is just the death rattle.

    • @RevanMartinez
      @RevanMartinez Před 2 lety +63

      Expanded Universe > Disney Canon

    • @ImSamhel
      @ImSamhel Před 2 lety +80

      In my head, only the Disney sequel is non-cannon :) Join me on the fan-side

  • @adamthephotographer
    @adamthephotographer Před 2 lety +62

    In my opinion it's better that he's the prophesied chosen one & leave that air of mystery surrounding him.

  • @StarWarsAnalyst
    @StarWarsAnalyst Před 2 lety +137

    We need an extended cut of every Star Wars movie

  • @TokyoXtreme
    @TokyoXtreme Před 2 lety +41

    I bet it was Sifo-Dyas, who mind-tricked Shmi into forgetting their “entanglement.”

    • @SwampRatt
      @SwampRatt Před 2 lety +2

      Never give this a thought but it makes sense with there abilities to see the future.

    • @metsrus
      @metsrus Před 2 lety

      naah it was clearly Mace Windu who knocked up Shmi

  • @andrewharmer7317
    @andrewharmer7317 Před 2 lety +12

    He's space Jesus and his mother is space Mary! Happy Easter.

  • @nate8604
    @nate8604 Před 2 lety +158

    I believe that Palpatine, and his master Plagueis, tried to control the force itself, and the force answered back, in the form of the chosen one Anakin.

    • @KellyClement
      @KellyClement Před 2 lety

      That sounds like the story of the False God that created the World and then God changed Himself into the Holy Spirit, and Impregnated Sophia, who in her Earthly form called herself Maria or Mary.

    • @robd1329
      @robd1329 Před 2 lety +1

      We need to see a flashback episode of that

    • @matthayes533
      @matthayes533 Před 2 lety +3

      you could say the force... awakened.

    • @Maynardd
      @Maynardd Před 2 lety

      But Anakin was not the chosen one…

    • @nate8604
      @nate8604 Před 2 lety

      @@Maynardd ???

  • @foxtrotekko-kyngkryss1124

    In the actual book where Darths Plagueis and Sidious are manipulating the midichrlorians, Plagueis actually warns that they must be careful in pushing the force too much or it would prompt a response to balance their manipulations.

  • @franksteele2262
    @franksteele2262 Před rokem +10

    Not only did the force object to manipulation, it did so by allowing the chosen one to fall to the dark side only to reverse their plan through a core light side hidden from the sith that Sidious only saw at the end.

  • @troyodell2011
    @troyodell2011 Před 2 lety +207

    People tend to forget that the Sith lie. The whole premise of the conversation about Plaguies with Anakin was to convince him the Sith had answers to his fears, not that any of it was true or not. We know Sidious was the very embodiment of deception so anything he said could be taken with the proverbial 'grain of salt'. The best explanation would be that the Force created Anakin to counter the perversions of the Sith, not that they actually created him.
    We know that he also told Anakin in the same conversation that Plaguies could prevent the ones he loved from dying? That was a lie and Sidious knew it but also knew Anakin would be taken in by it So anything Sidious said can't be trusted. His entire existence was based on deception to gain power for himself.

    • @TarsonTalon
      @TarsonTalon Před 2 lety +15

      I like to think both happened. The Sith did create Anakin, but the Force played an 'UNO Reverse' card. Little did they know, they had created the means of their own destruction.

    • @Fallensounds2010
      @Fallensounds2010 Před 2 lety +2

      I’m taking the opera scene from episode 3 like “Goldstein’s book’ from 1984; the one time they actually told the full, unadulterated truth. It’s designed to make the viewers ponder that odd immaculate conception comment from the first movie and question how much Palpatine actually knew. At bare minimum Plagus/Sidious creating Anakin is definitely cannon, however the methods are officially unknown.

    • @supercap3000
      @supercap3000 Před 2 lety +3

      Sounds like Donald trumps political career

    • @Ryukikon
      @Ryukikon Před 2 lety +2

      I say this pretty much all the time, it goes over people's heads as nothing Palatine said made any sense and so was distorted or lies

    • @williameldridge9382
      @williameldridge9382 Před 2 lety +2

      Any good deceiver knows the value of telling the truth.

  • @Revanaught
    @Revanaught Před 2 lety +197

    Y'know, if plagiues had just managed to not be murdered for a bit longer, he could have found out his solution to immortality. Not by studying Anakin, but by studying Maul. Apparently just being angry is all you need to never ever die no matter what happens to you.

    • @DenverStarkey
      @DenverStarkey Před 2 lety +8

      ah but maul was kiled by obi wan on tatooine in the end.

    • @artbasulto7056
      @artbasulto7056 Před 2 lety +26

      @@DenverStarkey yeah, because he wasn’t angry anymore.

    • @KkevrockK
      @KkevrockK Před 2 lety +8

      That lesson was evident long before in the form of Scion

    • @Delicious1922
      @Delicious1922 Před 2 lety +7

      I loved Maul. I hate that he was killed off the movies so quickly.

    • @Missmurder8905
      @Missmurder8905 Před 2 lety +7

      @@Delicious1922 he didn’t “die”… he showed back up in “Solo” at the end.

  • @litlclutch
    @litlclutch Před 2 lety +176

    I think I'd prefer Anikin's origins to be from the Force itself. Everything doesn't have to tie back to existing characters and their machinations. Let their galaxy have it fantastical elements.

    • @respectdawildo_danjones508
      @respectdawildo_danjones508 Před 2 lety

      Typical pos disney ruining everything

    • @e13kid
      @e13kid Před 2 lety +9

      I agree. George Lucas always had a weird Charles Dickens thing going on where he needs crazy coincidences to link all the characters in the story.

    • @AngelCatBaby
      @AngelCatBaby Před 2 lety +1

      I agree

    • @kickballjedi
      @kickballjedi Před rokem

      I think there's too many references of Anakin being a part of Palpatine's overall plan. He uses Maul to kill Qui-Gon so the boy will be trained by the more reckless Obi-Wan, then keeps pulling strings to maneuver his career and his emotions until he's an untrusting, violent, megalomaniac.

    • @terryprentice9657
      @terryprentice9657 Před rokem +2

      @@e13kid YES!!! The Dickensian clichés was the thing I disliked the most in the Prequels.

  • @aldersmoke1
    @aldersmoke1 Před 2 lety +143

    So is it a deleted scene or just an abandoned script idea? "Deleted scene" implies they shot it and didn't use it. If that's the case, where's the scene?

    • @autopium
      @autopium Před 2 lety +44

      Its just click-bait trickery, as always :(

    • @Rivenshield
      @Rivenshield Před 2 lety

      @@autopium Well fuck this shit then.

    • @murphyblogs2984
      @murphyblogs2984 Před 2 lety

      Turtle 🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢

    • @cjmiller6741
      @cjmiller6741 Před 2 lety

      Exactly.

    • @katyesimmons3204
      @katyesimmons3204 Před 2 lety +8

      Lies, lies and more lies… just say you have a theory, not a scene!! Sheesh!!

  • @Nerazmus
    @Nerazmus Před 2 lety +104

    Anakin: "I never had a father."
    Sheev: "No, I am your father."
    Anakin: "No... no... That's not true! It's not possible."

    • @numberonewithcheese
      @numberonewithcheese Před 2 lety +7

      Disney: No I'm your father.

    • @kenb2671
      @kenb2671 Před 2 lety

      Search your feelings you know it to be true.

    • @Delicious1922
      @Delicious1922 Před 2 lety

      "Search your feelings you it to be true,," NOOOOOOO NOOOOO! LOL

    • @Missmurder8905
      @Missmurder8905 Před 2 lety

      Lmao

    • @janinejohnstone468
      @janinejohnstone468 Před 2 lety

      Yes! Thank you... finally, a vaguely realistic and embarrassing reason for Shmi to have gotten pregnant with Anakin. If that was me, I would go to my grave never admitting it...😅

  • @robertmckenna3994
    @robertmckenna3994 Před 2 lety +88

    I doubt that Sidious would ever have mentioned Plagueis as having anything to do with Anakin’s birth. Except to say that Plagueis developed the ability to manipulate the midi-chlorians, but that he, Sidious, used the talent to create Anakin. Further increasing his hold over him, not just as his master, but as his father as well.

    • @hpatss4966
      @hpatss4966 Před 2 lety +11

      I sidious creating him is dumb plot-wise. It works story-wise but The force creating anakin in a fit of rage against Plagueis is more fitting.

    • @Omega1867
      @Omega1867 Před 2 lety +1

      I think the story was told to Anakin as more of an attempt to get him to join the Dark Side against the Jedi rather than “hey, I’m your father! Join me!” It’s bad enough that Disney used this to explain Rey, don’t drag Anakin into it too. They are not siblings.

    • @robertmckenna3994
      @robertmckenna3994 Před 2 lety

      @@Omega1867 that is the point, Sidious would have lied about having a hand in Anakin’s creation just to increase his hold over him.

    • @chocolatecityoutlaw6258
      @chocolatecityoutlaw6258 Před 2 lety

      @@hpatss4966 No, the Force abhors rage, if you say balancing or for equality then maybe, but not rage.

    • @ttintagel
      @ttintagel Před 2 lety

      @@hpatss4966 The plot and the story are the same thing. If it works in the plot, it works in the story, and vice-versa. Unless you meant to use a different word, you’re contradicting yourself.

  • @nzazulak2096
    @nzazulak2096 Před rokem +1

    I really want to say your dive into the Star Wars Lore is awesome. Revealing things that are often really cool and insightful. Thanks for sharing. I do have one comment. My suggestion would be that all the videos the content is repeated or said over. Making the video feel like it you could turn it off half way and not lose anything. May I recommend not doing that but rather I would love you to share your thoughts or do some “what if’s” rather than simply repeating content.

  • @mikemorgan9224
    @mikemorgan9224 Před 2 lety +15

    Great video. Interesting side thought from this scrapped plot idea. If Darth Plagueis indirectly created Anakin due to overreaching effects of his experimentation with the dark side, wouldn't that be even more fodder that the Force created Anakin out of the need for balance, of the Light, to counteract what the dark forces were working towards? That would mean the prophecy of "the one" would be more accurate than Palpatine's suggestion that Anakin was meant to be a prime Sith. I like this idea a lot, and it makes the whole story of his fall and redemption so many years later, all the more tragic.

  • @amandao6686
    @amandao6686 Před 2 lety +73

    I feel like their meddling of the force could have made the force its self put these events into action, so it was still the will of the force, but that it was a reaction to their meddling, not their actions itself being the cause

    • @matrix2245
      @matrix2245 Před 2 lety

      What

    • @thane1499
      @thane1499 Před 2 lety +1

      Wouldn’t that just make them successful

    • @codylucynki1279
      @codylucynki1279 Před 2 lety +6

      @@thane1499 no it's like a monkey's paw
      The hubris of the wish caused it to turn out the way they didn't want

    • @eddiep1008
      @eddiep1008 Před 2 lety +5

      Side effect of meddling with the force,no need for overcomplicating

    • @Poodle_Gun
      @Poodle_Gun Před 2 lety

      That would have been a good enough explanation for me.

  • @DontrelleRoosevelt
    @DontrelleRoosevelt Před 2 lety +1

    As always, you nailed it right on the head!

  • @allancallander449
    @allancallander449 Před 2 lety +15

    You didn't show us any deleted scene, just told us in your own words that it was a thing.

    • @DrownInLysergic
      @DrownInLysergic Před rokem

      Although I do indulge in his videos, he's the weakest Star Wars channel I've found so far. There's been a few videos where he spews incorrect information, made up information, and then stuff like this where he tells us something the proof being "just trust me bro" but doesn't actually show the deleted scene or anything else.

  • @Raul_Menendez
    @Raul_Menendez Před 2 lety +9

    Anakin and Palpatine on the Space Maury show when?

  • @logiticalresponse9574
    @logiticalresponse9574 Před 2 lety +20

    Unintelligent reports suggest that plageus(spelled?) and Palpatine did influence the force to create anakin but the force didnt directly insert its will(y) into schmee(spelled? ) . Through a small hole in the 4th wall the force influenced George Lucas to create anakin in the years following episode 6 . That is a testament to how powerful the force actually is. Not only influencing a higher reality but influenc the 4th dimension in that higher reality. However those reports cannot be confirmed

    • @EmeraldBat67
      @EmeraldBat67 Před 2 lety

      Plageuis, Shmi

    • @logiticalresponse9574
      @logiticalresponse9574 Před 2 lety

      🙏

    • @DenverStarkey
      @DenverStarkey Před 2 lety

      actually lucas wrote vaders/anakins back story (at least the larger beats of it) before finishing empire strikes back., once he decided that vader was going to be anakin skywalker he knew he had to come up with a back story to fill in the character's motivations better as well as explain how he became a cyborg .

    • @logiticalresponse9574
      @logiticalresponse9574 Před 2 lety

      @@DenverStarkey wow the force is crazy 🤪. It influenced lucas before it even knew it influenced lucas to create anakin . Thats like some 6th wall ish😅

  • @tylerpowell3051
    @tylerpowell3051 Před 2 lety +2

    Seems like the same explanation I've heard for the last 7 years since watching these videos lol.

  • @RachelOfTheLostMoon
    @RachelOfTheLostMoon Před 2 lety +19

    I just go with what was on screen. The Force did it. Anakin did bring balance, he brought the decadent Jedi who had become stagnant and brittle to an end and he then usurped the Sith who had become too bloated with power. In the end there was balance, both light and dark were no longer concentrated in two warring organizations.

    • @gmoffat70
      @gmoffat70 Před rokem +2

      Damn. I didn't think anyone got it. Anakin did bring balance to the force. Balance does not mean that the sith die and the jedi flourish. The sith always only have 2. Master and apprentice. After what anakin did, everything was brought into balance. Only 2 prominent jedi remained. Yoda and Obi-wan. Thus balance. These wannabe star wars professors are missing it all together. Obi-wan was the only jedi to ever say anakin was supposed to destroy the sith. All others just said "chosen one" and bring balance to the force. Everyone misses the fact that Obi-wan got it wrong. And that's the harsh truth. These guys need to stop trying to manifest some grand plan by George Lucas. This was his plan. There is no alternative outcome. Anakin fulfilled his destiny

    • @ryandowning2855
      @ryandowning2855 Před rokem

      Unfortanetly that is not true. Because Vader didn't actually kill the emperor, as we know now.

  • @LordSesshomaru86
    @LordSesshomaru86 Před rokem +4

    Even without extended scenes, deleted scenes, books, etc, it's already implied by Palpatine that Plagueis is responsible for creating Anakin. That's all I need

  • @shaydowsith348
    @shaydowsith348 Před 2 lety +5

    Makes sense, although Palpatines plan to transfer himself into Anakin failed when Vader became more machine than man - and his plans for Vader had to change. Essence transfer did not originate with Plagueius however, Tenebrae and Vitiate had used it, and Andandu before him - although they did it thru Sith alchemy. This knowledge was lost to the "rule of two" Sith due to the 1 sith of the line who deviated from the grand plan and followed the light. What Was new to Plagueius was his use of midichroians rather than Sith Alchemy to achieve life.

  • @petehannon7685
    @petehannon7685 Před rokem +1

    Hello, question please : )
    The animated footage around 4:20 - 4:22 - what's that from?
    Thanks!!

  • @kcspain9195
    @kcspain9195 Před 2 lety

    I want to know what is the music played at the end of this video? That is amazing!!

  • @MagnarTheSwole
    @MagnarTheSwole Před 2 lety +7

    I always thought Watto was Anakin’s dad…

  • @agentjackstone3543
    @agentjackstone3543 Před 2 lety +19

    It's so funny how everyone gets so into this and tries to make sense out of it. Just go back and read Lucas' original treatments or listen to his interviews. That's why all of this is so convoluted and people have to search for "true explanations." There isn't one, George was making it up as he went along hahahahahaha. As long as I have the original trilogy I'm happy. Prequels are cool too, but I can't live without episodes 4 through 6.

    • @haroldsy6804
      @haroldsy6804 Před rokem +1

      LOL, yeah that is how I remember it too, that George was making things up as he went but still fun to try and link them together.

    • @fclefjefff4041
      @fclefjefff4041 Před rokem

      Seriously, all the comics, novels, and games (and this point, the entire franchise) is glorified fan fiction. Literally hundreds of different writers blurting out goofy, convoluted nonsense just because people will pay for anything Star Wars related.

  • @davepowder4020
    @davepowder4020 Před 2 lety +1

    Luke, Leia, I've got something awkward to tell you about your grandpa...

  • @AnonymousUchiha
    @AnonymousUchiha Před 2 lety +4

    Love this would make so much sense his literally Anakins Father in the shadows he was always by his side 😭😂 even when Padmee was with Anakin as chancellor he was like that's my boy lol

  • @deansheets
    @deansheets Před 2 lety +6

    I just realized that Anakin never got the title master, not even as a sith cause he was darth sidious apprentice until he died.

    • @SephirohsReunion
      @SephirohsReunion Před 2 lety +2

      Well, he was ahsokas master while he was still a jedi...if you consider the clone wars show to be canon. She even referred to him as master several times

    • @mr.helmetgobrr3482
      @mr.helmetgobrr3482 Před 2 lety

      @@SephirohsReunion i think she used that word for "teacher"

    • @dantebryant6788
      @dantebryant6788 Před 2 lety

      @@SephirohsReunion I mean clone wars is canon

  • @kingshadow8782
    @kingshadow8782 Před 2 lety +5

    Amazing

  • @zerog5109
    @zerog5109 Před 2 lety +15

    Once more the Sith will rule the galaxy... and we shall have peace.

  • @mattmc4life
    @mattmc4life Před 2 lety

    brilliant idea

  • @DGTubbs
    @DGTubbs Před 2 lety +5

    Remember, the question relating to Anakin's father at the beginning of the video is, "Where did Anakin come from?" The idea that Plagiues inadvertently created Anakin using sith alchemy seems conclusive regardless the sith lord's intentions. That Palpatine presented himself as a father figure fits into the overarching theme of the Star Wars franchise: Quigon was a father figure to Anakin and Obi-Wan; Palpatine became a father figure to Anakin; Obi-Wan was a father figure to Luke; Yoda was a father figure to many; Anakin was a father figure to Ashoka and Luke; etc. But such a theme about father figures does not answer where Anakin came from.

  • @janetbaker7725
    @janetbaker7725 Před 2 lety +19

    I think the reason Luke said that the Jedi must end is because in order to have great light side power the opposite must exist. To remove the powerful darkness the powerful light had to be extinguished. I don't like it, but I can see that point of view.

    • @moribundxix
      @moribundxix Před 2 lety +5

      And though it was long ago in a different galaxy, that idea succeeded thus removing force sensitive sentient beings from the universe. at least for us... :) May the force be with you.

    • @Grenaden86
      @Grenaden86 Před 2 lety +2

      I see it completely differently tbh. I think Luke saying something like that actually was subservient to an idea or ethos actually completely outside of the Star Wars story in any capacity. And its allegiance to that rather than the story or its development is one of main reasons why so many decades-long fans of the SWU despise its current iteration.

    • @moribundxix
      @moribundxix Před 2 lety +1

      @@Grenaden86 I can see that point of view and I respect it...

    • @janetbaker7725
      @janetbaker7725 Před 2 lety

      @@Grenaden86 The current SWU isn't worth following. Challenge creates betterment. The current mythos doesn't promote betterment. You're right, it promotes subservience.

  • @ccseries
    @ccseries Před rokem +1

    Made more sense than what I was thinking.

  • @Delicious1922
    @Delicious1922 Před rokem +1

    May the Force be with you, always

  • @collettk
    @collettk Před 2 lety +4

    I would be fine with Disney’s direction with cannon id they would just do 3 things:
    • Make Darth Plagueis Novel cannon
    • Make the Darth Bane trilogy cannon
    • Find a way to undo the Sequel trilogy as cannon (it wasn’t even a real story…they just crammed bits and pieces from past SW movies to create nostalgia)

  • @nickolasoliveira6526
    @nickolasoliveira6526 Před 2 lety +12

    I dunno man, Anakin had pretty fatherless behavior

  • @sswitchhzz7774
    @sswitchhzz7774 Před 2 lety +1

    Let’s GOOOOO BABY, LOVE YALL

  • @americanpaisareturns9051
    @americanpaisareturns9051 Před 2 lety +5

    You turned her against me!

  • @ion_force
    @ion_force Před 2 lety +6

    I think the original, vague explanation works best. Anakin is an anomaly, sent by the force to fulfil the prophecy.
    Simple, easy. Works fine.

    • @SwiftJustice
      @SwiftJustice Před 2 lety +1

      They clearly intended to explain it tho, and they started to in that theater scene. Cat's out of the bag.

  • @davids9520
    @davids9520 Před 2 lety +3

    It was Jar Jar all along! 😀

  • @ChibaMitsurugi19792
    @ChibaMitsurugi19792 Před rokem +1

    I thought, by way of the Plagueis novel, that Plagueis was afraid that the force or midichlorians or whatever created Anakin as a form of backlash to punish him for his experimentation in the creation of life.

  • @corbinpowell128
    @corbinpowell128 Před 2 lety

    Happy Easter to anyone reading this!

  • @Lastson005
    @Lastson005 Před 2 lety +13

    I literally said this same thing a little while back in another one of your videos and got so many people telling me I was wrong and correcting me. I hope they all watch this video.

    • @venmer4266
      @venmer4266 Před 2 lety

      The idea of revealing the Sith to be responsible for Anakin's conception was a scrapped plot point that Lucas believed tarnished the validity of Anakin's status as chosen one, so it was ultimately removed. It was never considered canon. In the Plagueis novel of legends, the Cosmic Force retaliated against the Sith for their meddling with the midi-chlorians. In current canon, the official explanation is the Force conceived Anakin to destroy the Sith.

    • @markosmun8896
      @markosmun8896 Před rokem

      The official novation spelled it out outright that Palpatine created him.
      By the time the movie was released, it was left to ambiguity.

  • @jeffreyweaver9854
    @jeffreyweaver9854 Před 2 lety +5

    I had figured that, near the end of "Return Of The Jedi" , when Palpatine, Darth Vader, and Luke Skywalker were in Palpatine's throne room, that there were three generations of one family in that scene! I believe that a young Senator Palpatine had an affair with MS. Skywalker, then used a Sith mind wipe to erase the memory of the affair from her mind before selling her into slavery!

    • @keirfarnum6811
      @keirfarnum6811 Před 2 lety

      “MS?” Do you mean “Shmee Skywalker?”

    • @ttintagel
      @ttintagel Před 2 lety

      This sounds perfectly plausible to me.

    • @tephyrula
      @tephyrula Před rokem

      also why Siths don't go in proper jedi training and are always found later by other siths makes sense why ani wouldn't be noticed by the Jedi order as a child

    • @jeffreyweaver9854
      @jeffreyweaver9854 Před rokem

      @@tephyrula I think you missed something that had appeared in Episode 1. When Anakin Skywalker first met Qui-Gon, he was approximately 8 years old and had very little idea of any special significance or direction as to his future!

  • @silvernexoknight
    @silvernexoknight Před 2 lety

    Cool vid

  • @dprice1187
    @dprice1187 Před rokem +1

    Plagueis created Anakin, Palpatine found out and killed Plagueis, so that he could eventually gain Anakin as a apprentice. He knew how powerful Anakin could become.

  • @larryblomstedt1515
    @larryblomstedt1515 Před 2 lety +27

    It would explain why Anakin had such loyalty to Palpatine in his fall to the dark side if he thought that Palpatine was his father. It would also add a layer of emotion and explanation to why he approached Luke the same way. Might explain Vader's hesitation dispatching the emperor later.

    • @Omega1867
      @Omega1867 Před 2 lety

      Anakin has loyalty to Palpatine because he was pretty much screwing with Anakin’s head and tainting him toward the dark side since they met. He tricked Anakin into think thinking they were friends and that Palps was the ONLY one who could save Padme. I very much doubt it’s because of “familial ties”. Palpatine is not Anakin’s father.

    • @mattjones5987
      @mattjones5987 Před 2 lety +1

      The movies really should have spent more time on the mentorship and father figure aspects of Anakin's relationship with Palpatine and less time on the boring political intrigue. Yes, given what the movies presented, it's hard to believe Anakin would just toss Obi-Wan under the bus for Palpatine.

    • @franklinkuehny1894
      @franklinkuehny1894 Před 2 lety

      @matt jones- as much as Anakins relationship with his father figure palpatine mattered, that's not the reason he chose palpatine over obi wan. The reason he chose palpatine was because of his love for his wife Padme. He has the gift of seeing the future and everything he saw up until that point came true. Most notably, his mother dying and him not being able to do anything about it because of obi wan nor listening to him in episode 2. He blamed obi wan for the loss of his mother and because of that lost a lot of trust in his brother. So combine his fear of losing padme, with his trust in palpatine to save her and his resentment and lack of trust in obi wan and you have the perfect recipe of ingredients for him to do what he did.

  • @aerofool66
    @aerofool66 Před 2 lety +13

    When Shmi gives her explanation, I always get the impression that she just did not want Anakin’s father in her life so she has pretty much cut off any reference to him. I feel it was a real person, and she knew who he was. She just did not want to have anything to do with him nor does she want her son to have any connection to him.

    • @ttintagel
      @ttintagel Před 2 lety +3

      Yeah, I imagine she wasn’t the only slave woman whose child had no father she was willing to acknowledge.

    • @andreagriffiths3512
      @andreagriffiths3512 Před rokem +1

      I always got the impression that she might have been pimped out. It explains why she did not want to remember the father and, given her status as a slave, it also covers the fact that she wouldn’t have been free to have a romantic relationship.

    • @aerofool66
      @aerofool66 Před rokem +1

      @@andreagriffiths3512 you may be onto something there!

  • @FabioRodrigues-jy9se
    @FabioRodrigues-jy9se Před 2 lety

    Hello, what is the name of the music at 08:02 ? Thank´s

  • @briandaleske5139
    @briandaleske5139 Před 2 lety +2

    If this theory might be correct; Than I think it could be used as a set of events that had happened in a parallel dimension, and the alternate version of (Anakin Skywalker) came into existence this way.

  • @Darth_Vader66.
    @Darth_Vader66. Před 2 lety +7

    Disney just screws everything up,it was perfect the way it was

  • @adamsleeman6737
    @adamsleeman6737 Před 2 lety +3

    If you think about it Anakin was the chosen one he truly brought balance by destroying the Jedi he brought light and dark closer together 2 main Jedi and 2 main sith

  • @Blitzwingz
    @Blitzwingz Před rokem +2

    The Force used Plagiues's experiment and created Anakin, the one to bring balance to the force.

  • @katpoohtoo
    @katpoohtoo Před 2 lety

    What is the name of that music at the end of the video?

  • @kevinwiltshire2217
    @kevinwiltshire2217 Před 2 lety +4

    I don't think plagueis had any influence on Anakin Skywalker turning to the dark side I think the screwed up methods of the Jedi persuaded him to join the dark side

  • @PaulLoh
    @PaulLoh Před 2 lety +10

    The makers of the Mandalorian probably know this about Plagueis and are building upon it. I don't think it's a coincidence that Anakin and Grogu were born in the same year. Maybe they're a dyad like Rey and Kylo.

    • @aaaaaaaaa3515
      @aaaaaaaaa3515 Před 2 lety +1

      But anakin was dead by that time

    • @VideoBastard5150
      @VideoBastard5150 Před 2 lety +1

      @@aaaaaaaaa3515 I was thinking the same thing but isn't Grogu like 50 years old in The Mandalorian? Could put his birth year around the time Anakin was born.

  • @hideinplainsight1048
    @hideinplainsight1048 Před 2 lety

    It would make sense with the newer movies and Ray and Ben having such a strong connection, and the light saber calling to her. So in a way kinda like how Luke and Leah kissed each other Ray and Ben repeated that.

  • @haroldsy6804
    @haroldsy6804 Před rokem +1

    Darth Vader's story, many people thought was George's story and they felt that his marriage would have some bearing on it. (I am not a Lukas expert and don't know anything about his life). There was speculation by fans that Lukas' marriage was broken up by a third party and he was going to play that story out with Darth Vader. The theory was that Obi Wan would break up Anikin and Padme and I did sense some tension in the movie along those lines but instead, Vader's anger came about from Padme's death and the betrayal he felt that came from Obiwan. Honestly if Luke became Obi wan's son that could have explained a lot of Vader's anger and Obi Wan's actions. As to Anikin's origin story I feel that being created by Sidius or his master seems very weird and twins too? Yeah it seems really out there. Maybe since Lukas brought in the midi cloreans who were the creators of life itself. Maybe as a sentient group of microscopic life they could have created Anikin but as a potential for evil and his son and daughter as the potential for good similar to the way when a virus is created then an antivirus is also created such as with a phage. So in that story Anikin was not the chosen one, it was Luke or Lea. This may balance out with Lukas' view of how children will vindicate their parents or something along those lines. So in this theory Sidius and his master may have caused a great amount of dark force from their experimentation that the midi cloriens decided to expend and make Anikin out of, but true to the rules of the force Anikin's children will be his undoing, or more like Vader's undoing.

  • @DrErickLopez
    @DrErickLopez Před 2 lety +6

    I think that the way the story plays out on screen is the best explication.
    It’s not a mystery as to who his father is. He is merely the creation of the force. That’s enough. There’s no need to take that wonderful mystical explanation and try to make it analytically dull by giving him a concrete explanation.
    Somethings are better off left alone.
    In actuality, keeping it mystical that the force created him, makes it more intriguing in that natural universal forces tried to intervene so much that in creating this chosen one, he was still left to the actual living beings to raise and instill values. Which ultimately failed big time!

    • @DavidRLentz
      @DavidRLentz Před rokem +1

      Do the actual medical sciences have anything remotely akin to midi-chlorians? The closest I have been able to guess is "mitochondria", which I under- stand to be an intracellular structure serving as a mecha- nism to create energy (I infer chemically). I arrive at this through enjoying an excellent vocabulary; however, my scientific knowledge is rather haphazard.

    • @DrErickLopez
      @DrErickLopez Před rokem +1

      @@DavidRLentz yes sir! One of the jobs of the Mitochondria is to produce ATP which is one of the byproducts of breaking down glucose. ATP is then utilized by cells in your body for them to work & function properly.
      However, restructuring the power of the mitochondria to access the will of the force is something that cannot be taught by a Jedi. 😉

  • @Declankrenic
    @Declankrenic Před 2 lety +7

    Isn't there a Darth Vader comic from a few years ago that explains this?

    • @P4Tri0t420
      @P4Tri0t420 Před 2 lety +3

      Yes idk why He didnt mentioned that

    • @mylife-23
      @mylife-23 Před 2 lety +1

      @@P4Tri0t420 cuz it was de-canonized

    • @RevanMartinez
      @RevanMartinez Před 2 lety +1

      @@mylife-23 it was never decanonized, it just implied that kylo ren and reys kiss later on was kind of incest if Palpatine fathers both of them lol. Only the writer tried to explain it away by basically saying "it was part of vaders vision and not reality"

    • @mylife-23
      @mylife-23 Před 2 lety

      @@RevanMartinez I heard they said the comic wasn't canon

  • @lisalorezo1145
    @lisalorezo1145 Před rokem +1

    Yes

  • @lilymack4028
    @lilymack4028 Před 2 lety

    yes, i like this explanation.

  • @xminusone1
    @xminusone1 Před 2 lety +7

    Did you know that darth plaeguis manipulated the midichorians to impregnate shmi and give birth to Anakin and that's what palpatine explained in telling the Legend of darth plaeguis the wise and that's why shmi got impregnated with midichorians and so she give birth to Anakin who, later, listen to Palpatine tell him the Legend of darth plaeguis the wise and...... You got the idea..

    • @Lemuel928
      @Lemuel928 Před 2 lety

      Plagius is your real grandfather,Luke.

  • @JacobGen
    @JacobGen Před 2 lety +6

    Jar Jar to Shmi: Weesa havin a babee? Weesa havin a boy! Yippieee!!!!

  • @ChildePC
    @ChildePC Před 2 lety +1

    Hey #Stupendouswave when did they start construction of the second death star? Was there a sith reason to create it? Do you think the base on endor was realistic to shield such a big construction effort?

  • @DarkLordofTheSith69
    @DarkLordofTheSith69 Před rokem +1

    Darth Plaguies created Anakin its all in the Plaguies book which is set before phantom but also runs alongside phantom towards the end amd plagueis even goes to meet anakin and feel his power for himself on coruscant but anakin has gone to the jedi temple and in phantom when sidious is talking to maul on the balcony Plaguies is off camera in the next room and thats the night sidious kills plaguies in his sleep after getting plaguies drunk and force lighting his breathing regulators while he slept

  • @BarbaraA.MertzRN-CCRN
    @BarbaraA.MertzRN-CCRN Před 2 lety +5

    Had Anakin's birth been carefully arranged, then too would his childhood have been overseen and guided. The fact that it was NOT (guarded, overseen or guided) means that it just didn't happen that way. These are all AFTER THE FACT considerations and arrangements - (like saying Rick Deckard was a replicant, for example). That is not how the original script was written. Any attempt to make it BETTER written is simply an attempt to make a failed situation look better after-the-fact. I don't buy it.

    • @NiallHosking
      @NiallHosking Před 2 lety

      It is entirely possible that Plagueis and Sidious mucked about but didn't find out, so they thought they failed but had (somewhat) succeeded, but through that quirk of fate failed to have full control over Anakin.

  • @bridgerhibbert2993
    @bridgerhibbert2993 Před 2 lety +4

    With what we have now, I don't like the idea that Palpatine or Plagueis could have been Anakin's father. Otherwise, it means that Anakin never was a Chosen One (since the prophecy was more like a lie or untrue, as implied in Matt Stover 's revenge of the Sith), and because it means Anakin was destined to fall to the dark side (since his birth was unnatural to begin with).
    Another way to look at it is the Force Sensitive Skywalkers are a fluke in the Force, throwing off the balance because of how powerful they are, so they needed to die in order for there to be true natural balance.

    • @FilmDoctor42
      @FilmDoctor42 Před 2 lety

      Anakin eventually "kills" the Empire. Also, his daughter, Leia, gives birth to Ben, who eventually joins with Rey to finally destroy the Emperor's clone.

  • @AlbionofRunescape
    @AlbionofRunescape Před rokem +1

    My fan theory is his mom was wildin’ out at the Cantina and got knocked up.

  • @smogonthetees1
    @smogonthetees1 Před 2 lety

    Whats the background music?

  • @DorianXLII
    @DorianXLII Před 2 lety +12

    I prefer the explanation that Anakin was a mistake made by Plaguis. The channel itself established that The Force itself hates the Sith, because they use The Force, rather than work with it. Darth Plaguis, and Sideous likewise, were doing a lot of messing around with trying to bend the Midichlorians to their will, and The Force itself kept resisting their experiments with failures. But what was revealed somewhere in the Canon, that escapes me at the moment, the most common result of their failures was some being extremely saturated in Midichlorians, above 20 thousand stands out. With all those failures by the Sith, and their experiments being done so close to Naboo, it makes a lot of sense that this sentient Force would have an equal reflex to literally ballance itself out within the general area of space. I know a lot of people hated the first Prequel movie, but we do find out that even a damaged ship can make it from Naboo (where the experiments were attempted) to Tatooine quite easily with a damaged Hyperdrive. As Naboo and Tatooine are so opposite in climate and diversity of life, it does make sense that The Force itself balanced out the failures by, itself, collecting a high density of Midichlorians into Shmi Skywalker, a person who is so far detached from a Sith, that she becomes the most logical vessel for a Force-Induced Conception. The reason Anakin survived, and the attempts to create vessels for the Sith to never die did not, would be because The Force doesn't have to manipulate anything, it already permiates life itself, and is involved in the creation of new life anyways. It would have been as normal a creation as any other birth, with only the dense Midichlorian count being any influence on how The Force ITSELF Created this particular child.
    Is Anakin the "Ancient" Chosen One prophesied by both the Sith and the Jedi? Is he "the Chosen One" that the Force Wielders of Morbis were waiting for? In all honesty, we can't be sure. What isn't in Canon anywhere, is the exact detailed writing of what THE PROPHESY of The Chosen One actually was. We have nothing to differentiate between the Jedi, Sith, and Morbian interpretations of it. We don't even know when the Chosen One was actually entered into the culture of those who interacted with The Force. Even Darth Bane somewhat fits The Chosen One from The Sith point of view. So, until there's an In-Canon release of the text of The Chosen One/The One we really can't know for sure.

    • @mortisnoctu
      @mortisnoctu Před 2 lety

      Nicely written

    • @TooYoungToDie_TooOldToLive
      @TooYoungToDie_TooOldToLive Před 2 lety +4

      I prefer the explanation that the FORCE created Anakin. This makes it so that, in the end, of what I consider Canon(1-6) Anakin did in fact bring balance to the force like the prophecy told, by KILLING Palpatine.

    • @michaelwelk8124
      @michaelwelk8124 Před 2 lety +5

      Seems interesting that thousands of Jedi and a few Sith means that the Sith is the heavier side. Balance to me seems exactly as it played out, Order 66.

    • @mortisnoctu
      @mortisnoctu Před 2 lety

      @@michaelwelk8124 Brutal!!!

    • @whiteranger8396
      @whiteranger8396 Před 2 lety

      @@mortisnoctu agreed

  • @josephgaribaysr4970
    @josephgaribaysr4970 Před 2 lety +17

    I like this theory. I always thought that if the force itself was the father of Anikin then he was the one to bring balance to the force, but the jedi distorted it and thought it meant destroying the sith. But if you look to the yin/yang symbol where they are elements that are conflicting yet harmonious then you will realize Anikin was also going to be a sith. The sith were almost gone and it distorted the balance. The jedi, the sith is also said the light side, the dark side or good and evil. Whichever you use you will not know one without knowing the other. I think this is proven when you look at the most powerful jedi and sith, they use abilities from both sides of the force. But by confusing Anikins emotions, it made him more reckless, so a balance was not met and the dark side gained the upper hand. So in short, the aragance of the jedi made the situation worse

    • @baddriversofmoosejaw8681
      @baddriversofmoosejaw8681 Před 2 lety +1

      According to Wookieepedia The Star Wars Wiki Darth Plagueis after learning how to manipulate the midi-chlorians to resurrect the dead, create life and attempt to discover immortality The Force fought back and conceived Anakin to combat the threat of the new power The Sith were discovering but also The Father was losing his power and Anakin was to be his successor as revealed in The Clone Wars episode: Overlords.

    • @robpolaris5002
      @robpolaris5002 Před 2 lety

      Actually Anakin did destroy the Sith, he killed Palpatine and in doing so himself. No more Sith!

    • @baddriversofmoosejaw8681
      @baddriversofmoosejaw8681 Před 2 lety +1

      @@robpolaris5002 Palpatine/Sidious survived the fall down the reactor shaft and the destruction of the Death Star 2 because through Plagueis' teachings he had learned how to transfer into a new cloned body and basically resurrected himself. Anakin had fulfilled the prophecy of The Chosen One and brought balance to The Force as Qui-gon had predicted. It was not the end of The Sith though as after Palpatine transferred his living essence to a new body and hid out on Exegol for the next 35 years before finally revealing himself during the final battle on The Rise of Skywalker. He had hoped to achieve immortality and rule the galaxy for 10,000 years like Plagueis before him but because Kylo Ren/Ben Solo transferred his life force into Palpatine's granddaughter: Rey she was able to call on the powers of all the past Jedi, including Anakin and finally destroy Palpatine, his Sith eternal cultists and The Sith once and for all. Technically because Rey called on Anakin and the other past Jedi, Anakin was still there to fulfill the prophecy and destroy The Sith forever.

    • @deluxgamer999
      @deluxgamer999 Před 2 lety +3

      @@baddriversofmoosejaw8681 I personally don't count the sequels in my head canon, lazy writing destroyed those films, the fact that they had to explain Sidious' return in companion books rather than actually doing it in the films was shit.

    • @baddriversofmoosejaw8681
      @baddriversofmoosejaw8681 Před 2 lety

      @@deluxgamer999 That's fine. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

  • @KP-rh5qz
    @KP-rh5qz Před rokem +1

    I need to read these books. Where should I start?

  • @YouTubeMrP
    @YouTubeMrP Před 2 lety +11

    If Palapatine is Anakin’s father then Rey really does have a legitimate claim to the Skywalker lineage, doesn’t she?

    • @happymike420
      @happymike420 Před 2 lety

      That's the only explanation for it

    • @hsafootballworld1321
      @hsafootballworld1321 Před 2 lety

      Forget about Rey.
      She does not exist. The last 3 movies should not be considered as part of Star Wars

    • @charlieclark9552
      @charlieclark9552 Před 2 lety

      ​@@hsafootballworld1321 she does exist the sequels happened deal with it or rage against the universe forever

    • @hsafootballworld1321
      @hsafootballworld1321 Před 2 lety

      @@charlieclark9552 dont care what you say. It does not exist for me.
      The last 3 movies were a big joke

  • @QuadZillaGodZillasbrother

    Here’s the thing I always thought that Aniken‘s father was literally the FORCE think of it Palpatine basically use the force to make smei Skywalker become pregnant with Anakin so I always thought that the Force was literally Anakin‘s father

    • @ayalovesgaming599
      @ayalovesgaming599 Před 2 lety

      Yes the literal force created anakin

    • @QuadZillaGodZillasbrother
      @QuadZillaGodZillasbrother Před 2 lety

      @@ayalovesgaming599 It’s kind of ironic when you think about it because palpatine basically just fulfilled the prophecy for the Jedi lol

  • @svenmartin840
    @svenmartin840 Před 2 lety +1

    Here is my thoughts. Palpatine learn from The sisterhood of Karn. During his time on Karn where he met the Time Lord morbius. 20 years before Anakin was born. That's how he learned to manipulate the force. Through morbius and his third generation

  • @bookemdano1317
    @bookemdano1317 Před 2 lety

    OOOrrr, it really was an immaculate conception done by the force itself in order to bring balance., just as Qui Gon had said.

  • @anthonyyoutubefan7567
    @anthonyyoutubefan7567 Před 2 lety +16

    I was SO DISAPPOINTED, the second after I heard Shmi Skywalker state, in Episode I: "There was no Father..." It ruined a large part of the (potential for the) character of Anakin Skywalker, and The Skywalker Family, for me. I always wondered who the Father of Anakin Skywalker would be, and what his exploits were in life, before marrying, and having a firstborn Son...I wondered if he was Force-sensitive, as well, and may have even become a Jedi himself, but, left it, due to a personal spiritual crisis, which would explain why The Jedi Order was so wary of allowing another Skywalker in to the fold. To this day, I would like to see a one-off movie depicting the life history or The Skywalker Twins' Grandfather, even if he weren't a Force-user.

    • @redred1952
      @redred1952 Před 2 lety +1

      Plagueis

    • @questworldiangreenknight7455
      @questworldiangreenknight7455 Před 2 lety +3

      Agreed

    • @Grimerpr2016
      @Grimerpr2016 Před 2 lety +10

      essentially he's like Jesus of the star wars universe and shmi is the virgin Mary, the father is the force or god..

    • @alondite215
      @alondite215 Před 2 lety +9

      Strong disagree. Anakin's conception being immaculate, as if he was conceived by the force itself, makes so much more sense for him as the Chosen One and is a much more interesting origin that makes him as unique and special as he is supposed to be, rather than just being some guy with a normal father who happens to be highly force sensitive.

    • @jaynavarre6498
      @jaynavarre6498 Před 2 lety

      Lines up with Uncle Owen’s dialogue

  • @gonhunter3994
    @gonhunter3994 Před 2 lety +5

    Is it a Plagueis/Darth Jar Jar scene? Hi btw

  • @MsFliKix
    @MsFliKix Před rokem +1

    Always thought Qui-Gon Jim could’ve been another alternative for Anakins father

  • @tappearson2372
    @tappearson2372 Před rokem +1

    This was answered in the comics years ago ."Anakin's father is The Emperor. Palpatine manipulated the Midi-chlorians inside of Shmi's womb to create Anakin."

    • @markosmun8896
      @markosmun8896 Před rokem

      The official novelization for The Return of the Sith also explained it outright by stating the same ......it just never made it to the movie and was left up to ambiguity.

  • @ericlindberg705
    @ericlindberg705 Před 2 lety +20

    I'm confused. How is Palpatine the father if Plagueis' experiments brought Anakin into existence? Earlier in the video you said Plagueis created him but then claimed there was no ambiguity that Palpatine was his father. Did they conduct the Force experiments together and Anakin has two dads? Personally I've always loved the idea that Palpatine created Anakin but your video seems to offer two contradictory answers about that.

    • @greedmachine666
      @greedmachine666 Před 2 lety +1

      (To all of you) It was BOTH Darth Plagues and Darth Sidious (Sheev Palpatine) being responsible for ''Anakin's existence'' using Sith Alchemy, But more to do with Plagues power who did the actual impregnation of Shmi Skywalker by ''influencing the Midichlorians to create life'' as Palpatine said as he turns directly to Anakin, The result was the exact opposite of what they wanted, But metaphorically Palpatine (still alive unlike Plagues) is Anakin's father due to being the one who continued to encourage him with praise, and saying how ''the Jedi feared his potential power'' That's what (I think) He means when he says Darth Sidious is Anakin's father, as he is also responsible for influencing and seducing Anakin to the dark side (with the hope of saving Padme with this knowledge Palpatine did in fact learn with Plagues during their experiments) They are both Anakin's father ''metaphorically speaking'' But it was the Midichlorians that chose to create Anakin as being of light, instead of the dark being they hoped to create, Ironically Anakin became what Plagues would have wanted due to Palpatine befriending and mentoring Anakin (Something mentioned more than once and often forgotten by some fans) They were close friends and the Jedi didn't like that at all, as they began to suspect Palpatine of being the corrupt villain he truly was.

    • @FokusEnzo
      @FokusEnzo Před 2 lety

      @@greedmachine666 stop talking crap

    • @greedmachine666
      @greedmachine666 Před 2 lety +1

      @@FokusEnzo I know what I'm talking about, and I'm correct on every part of my comment, Read the novel ''Darth Plagues'' it's Not Crap !!!

    • @FokusEnzo
      @FokusEnzo Před 2 lety

      @@greedmachine666 na its deffo crap damn you really are a nerd

    • @dadtimejamtime
      @dadtimejamtime Před 2 lety +1

      I agree - these videos are too verbose and end up confusing. I guess the answer is that plagues made the medichlorians make anakin - so he was the actual creator/nature father. But palpatine/sidious groomed him and turned him to the dark side as a nurture father.
      With Rey being a palpatine though by blood, it’d be more interesting if palpatine’s blood was used in a alchemical experiment to drive the force to create anakin.
      The idea that all beings created by manipulating the force actually grow to destroy the same manipulators who made them to begin with is a cool closed loop. Imagine Rey was another attempt at an anakin style coercion of the force.
      Also what is shmi doing just hanging out with such a bad ass last name?!

  • @michaelarrington988
    @michaelarrington988 Před 2 lety +5

    we need a series about Revan it would be way more interesting than what they doing lately .

  • @coryryder9070
    @coryryder9070 Před 2 lety

    its ether hes tied to palpatine or a jedi knight that would explain the stuff thoe if it is palpatine with ray too

  • @heaven3546
    @heaven3546 Před rokem +1

    The theory that makes the most sense to me is, that the force created Anakin as an answer to Plagueis experiments. I believe that the Jedis and the Siths prophecys of the chosen one where originally the same. It prophesied one great chosen one of the force. But over hundreds of years they interpreted it to their own advantage and the prophecys we know were formed. So when Plagueis tried to manipulate the midi-chlorians to create the Sith version of the chosen one the force answered and created the real chosen one.

  • @brianhallman6594
    @brianhallman6594 Před 2 lety +7

    I personally like the reasoning for Anakin's birth, being because the force answered the Sith Lords trying to bully it!!!!

    • @jimmyskwid9002
      @jimmyskwid9002 Před 2 lety

      I like to believe that anakin was the force itself manifesting itself as a human, however that manifestation had no knowledge of being the force itself, but could still tap into the power (I know it’s far fetched)

    • @robd1329
      @robd1329 Před 2 lety

      I buy it!

  • @ethos2822
    @ethos2822 Před 2 lety +4

    Force Child Support!!

  • @markosmun8896
    @markosmun8896 Před rokem +1

    It is Plagueis who is The Phantom Menace .,...you never see him but he is the one who started the menace .....and by Palpatine killing him ( his master as in the Rule of Two ) , Pslpatine was possessed by Plagueis and all the former Sith before him.

  • @brandondetroitfanmichaels4325

    Palpatine: "I need your help son"

  • @michellecrocker2485
    @michellecrocker2485 Před 2 lety +5

    Anyone feel that Anakin wasn’t the only one who resulted in plagues’s experiment?

  • @aaaaaeiou
    @aaaaaeiou Před 2 lety +7

    I would have believed that Shmee created Anikin through the will to be free, and he would bring peace to the galaxy. Could her strong will have been touched by the sithe, therefore creating an anomily? After all, Anikin was not the saviour, but his children were. The creation of life needs male and female attributes.

    • @shadowbanned1999
      @shadowbanned1999 Před 2 lety +1

      That's stupid. And your wrong anikan was the chosen one.

  • @D35p3r4d0
    @D35p3r4d0 Před rokem +1

    You know, I've always felt that (even with the original Trilogy) half of Star Wars existed in Head-Canon. George Lucas was a talented idea-man, and one could make an argument for "writer," but I think even in those first days he simply didn't know what he wanted to do. As the films were made and established Canon, they created a slew of unanswered questions and mysteries that were simply never explained. Ironically, because the characters and concepts were so well established and portrayed, the answers were fairly obvious "between the lines." If you watch Phantom Menace with the idea that Palpatine and/or Pleagus created Anikan (or at least sought out to) several things that were clearly "abandoned" make sense. And, yes, the "Chosen One" arch in the films was more-or-less abandoned. Lucas simply wrote himself into a hole and in the end pulled an answer out none of us really bought.
    However, Canon is what Canon is. Especially now that the franchise is in... Questionable hands... The fans themselves write most of the Lore. What is ultimately accepted by the fans is what makes the most logical sense. I feel this is why Rey hasn't really stuck in the hearts of fans. I mean, we didn't originally like what George did with Anakin, but we all accepted it. Rey was just... Well... Enough has been said on that matter. My point is that we had already had an entire "afterseries" (that Disney now calls Legends) that worked for us. The Solo kids, the New Empire, the New Jedi Order, all the way up to those non-Force-Affected Aliens (which was kinda silly). Heck, even Palpatine's clone who discovers his true nature at the end of his book, I mean... Damn! There was some quality stuff there! But it isn't there.
    In conclusion, I would argue that Star Wars is more a product of its fandom than most other Intellectual Properties. I say, just give it to the fans. It has become a true Modern Mythology at this point.

  • @mattrobbins1237
    @mattrobbins1237 Před rokem +1

    What's everyones opinions on the Timothy Zahn 3 book series starting with *Heir To The Empire*?

  • @monstermilly5050
    @monstermilly5050 Před 2 lety +3

    Man look I'm sick of all this. At the end of the whole saga im pretty sure we're gonna find out that Darth bane has been behind it all #LongLiveTheSith

    • @nomad_syndrome1490
      @nomad_syndrome1490 Před 2 lety +1

      This makes total sense as Zannah flexed the hand that Bane was having trouble with at the end of the 3rd book of its series.

    • @monstermilly5050
      @monstermilly5050 Před 2 lety

      @@nomad_syndrome1490 exactly