2016 Porsche 718 Boxster S first drive - ruined by the turbo?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 3. 04. 2016
  • Cassius Clay, The Rock, Arnie. They all successfully re-invented themselves after cult status, and now Porsche is trying to do the same with the 718 'Boxster'. Question is though, now the straight six is defunct, does the new four-pot have what it takes? Subscribe to Autocar now: smarturl.it/autocar
    Autocar, the world's leading motoring magazine and website, delivers industry-leading news, the most in-depth car reviews and opinion from our team of experts. Our presenters include some of the world's top motoring journalists who have unrivalled access to the world's fastest, rarest, most exotic and most exciting cars on some of the world's best roads and race tracks.
    Visit www.autocar.co.uk for the latest news, reviews and analysis
    New videos are uploaded to Autocar's CZcams channel each week. Don't miss a single one. Subscribe to the channel now: smarturl.it/autocar
    / autocar
    LIKE Autocar on Facebook: www.autocar.co.uk/facebook
    FOLLOW Autocar on Twitter: / autocar
    +1 Autocar on Google+: plus.google.com/+autocar
    Subscribe to Autocar now: smarturl.it/autocar
  • Auta a dopravní prostředky

Komentáře • 595

  • @rtsmith3921
    @rtsmith3921 Před 6 lety +4

    Just bought the 718 Cayman and was an owner of a previous 981 Generation-and other then the sound, the new 718 is dynamically better, in virtually every way. Excellent review by the way.

  • @johannes914
    @johannes914 Před 8 lety +17

    I like it, but I might be a little biased... Flat four has been in the Porsche genes from the beginning ... don't forget it

    • @jbelden916
      @jbelden916 Před 8 lety

      +johannes914 yeah but nobody heard a 914 and thought the sound was awesome, this kinda sounds like that

  • @timobac1
    @timobac1 Před 8 lety +73

    Great review. If it was my money i'd buy a second hand last gen Boxster. That engine-noise defines the car if you ask me.

    • @Kaipeternicolas
      @Kaipeternicolas Před 8 lety +1

      +Timo B. Absolutely! Get the old GTS!

    • @1seipai
      @1seipai Před 8 lety

      Too right, get the previous version. Turbo engines are killing off performance cars. No way is a turbo charged engine involving. Basically it's just s**t!

    • @denniskwok7613
      @denniskwok7613 Před 8 lety

      +1seipai Have you driven a 675LT? I'm guessing not.

    • @Kaipeternicolas
      @Kaipeternicolas Před 8 lety

      Dennis Kwok I haven't driven the 675LT but the 650s. So?

    • @denniskwok7613
      @denniskwok7613 Před 8 lety +1

      Kaipeternicolas I wasn't talking to you dude.

  • @nikb6528
    @nikb6528 Před 8 lety +9

    Great video, Autocar! I like the 718, but hate the fact it's a 4 cylinder..

  • @newmotoring
    @newmotoring Před 8 lety

    Well done guys. First really decent bit of CZcams content for a while, the kind of content that's been a staple of the Autocar channel for years until more recently. Please keep it up!

  • @aaronming8466
    @aaronming8466 Před 8 lety +36

    Ruined by the 4 pot turbo, Indeed.

    • @marcnobel3938
      @marcnobel3938 Před 8 lety +1

      +Dung Bag Happily the GT Models stay with a NA flat 6.

    • @aaronming8466
      @aaronming8466 Před 8 lety

      Marc Nobel Might not be the case for the 718 GTS in time to come, as the trademark of the 718 is its flat 4

    • @marcnobel3938
      @marcnobel3938 Před 8 lety +1

      Dung Bag
      Not sure about the GTS, but Models like the GT4 will still go with NA flat 6. Same to GT3 and GT3 RS and R Model of the 911.

    • @ashleyjames308
      @ashleyjames308 Před 5 lety +1

      The four cylinder engine is a hugely better engine than the old six. I’ve just upgraded and it’s a hell of an upgrade.

  • @Doupik
    @Doupik Před 8 lety +6

    3:28 "I'm enjoying the steering, I'm enjoying the handling, I'm enjoying the sweet gear shift"
    - yeah, you sound ecstatic AF :-)

    • @Sandouras
      @Sandouras Před 8 lety +1

      +Doupik Hahaha, indeed!

  • @enaicee
    @enaicee Před 8 lety +1

    Having driven the old 987 Boxster S, part of the fun was hearing Porsche's signature flat 6 wail every time i put my foot down...why on earth would someone pay this much money to LOSE that magnificent aural experience.

  • @tim2468
    @tim2468 Před 8 lety +4

    One of the most honest and bottom line reviews I have ever seen. As a long time Porsche owner and a current Spyder owner I think this guy's opinion is quite valuable to anyone considering a new Boxter.

    • @victorross2809
      @victorross2809 Před 8 lety

      +Tim Archer Very much agreed. Intelligent talk, simple and no fuss review with ample and deserved credit to the 718. But yeah, ultimately a car like this is about emotion and involvement. If that suffers, the purists will be disappointed.

  • @MattMaranMotoring
    @MattMaranMotoring Před 8 lety +6

    I think it sounds great, but then again I may be a bit biased lol. I agree it doesn't sound like a traditional Porsche but neither does the Cayenne or Macan.

    • @detaart
      @detaart Před 8 lety +1

      +subaruwrxfan Hi Matt,
      The problem is that porsches are pretty much defined by their flat six engine.
      The cayenne or macan aren't exactly sports cars. People don't tend to care.
      Besides, a v8 cayenne sounds pretty sweet.

    • @pranavmukesh
      @pranavmukesh Před 8 lety +1

      but they're not traditional Porsches. they're just holes in the market for the sake of selling. real Porsche's are the CAYMAN, boxster and the 911. I think the panamera is a proper Porsche as well because it is kind of a modern day 928. but Cayenne and Macan aren't "real" Porsche's

    • @joobaggs6886
      @joobaggs6886 Před 8 lety

      yeah i bet it would sound like a sti if it had exhaust and down pipe fitted! i bet tuners get this engine to 500hp soon!

  • @lewisharley4752
    @lewisharley4752 Před 8 lety +71

    looks like a mid 2000's toyota MR2

    • @johanssonb
      @johanssonb Před 8 lety +11

      +Lewis Harley Wtf? An MR2 would give up three of its four wheels to look like this.

    • @lewisharley4752
      @lewisharley4752 Před 8 lety

      lol

    • @carcrazyafrica
      @carcrazyafrica Před 8 lety +1

      +Lewis Harley i do see a bit of Toyota MRS and Jag F type rear in this...lol

    • @NutellaCrepe
      @NutellaCrepe Před 8 lety

      +Tatenda Jinya (EthosVeritas) I see LaFerrari and Lada; they all have 4 wheels!

    • @alianisz
      @alianisz Před 8 lety

      +Lewis Harley Whats wrong with you?

  • @Guy_de_Loimbard
    @Guy_de_Loimbard Před 8 lety +8

    Honestly, I prefer the sound of the 718. Ever since Porsche started putting roughly equal-length exhaust headers on their sixes, the sound has been a bit... clinical. Now the engine note has some personality again. whether or not it "sounds like a Porsche" may well depend on whether you're old enough to remember when some Porsches had flat-4 motors, or even when the flat 6's still had that nice boxer rumble. IMO this is a return to form. Count me as a fan of the 718.

    • @Baerchenization
      @Baerchenization Před 7 lety

      You haven't even seen a 718, let alone heard one! What are you talking about?! And if you are like 99.9% of the people, you didn't have the chance to listen to a flat 6 for 5 minutes either, that is you probably never had the chance to drive one. Jesus... you posted that 3 months ago, where there weren't any 718s around, and still there are like 6 people to like this nonsense... that is CZcams for you.

    • @Guy_de_Loimbard
      @Guy_de_Loimbard Před 7 lety +3

      Baerchenization Perhaps you weren't aware that this and most other car review videos have, like, an audio track n' stuff to go along with the video?
      Look son, the number of cars I've owned over the decades probably comes close to the number of years you've been alive. I've owned one or more Chevy, Ford, Buick, Porsche, Volkswagen, Nissan, Mazda, Dodge, Saab, Audi, Subaru, Mazda, Mitsubishi, and probably a couple others I don't feel like scouring from my memory banks right now, equipped with a whole variety of power plants -- I4s, I5s, flat-4s, flat-6s, conventional V6s, narrow-angle V6s, V8s, and even a rotary.
      I've heard enough exhaust notes over the years to know what I like and what I don't, even if I'm only hearing it in car review videos for the first time. And yes, I'm aware that the in-cabin exhaust note is often electronically enhanced/synthesized these days which is why I listen and judge the exhaust note from exterior shots only.

    • @aitorjara100
      @aitorjara100 Před 7 lety

      Says someone who doesn't even have a Porsche to actually know what he's talking about. You can't tell it until you drive it. The flat 4 is fucking bullshit, feels the same as driving the new audi S3 or the golf R, but paying 40k more.

    • @Guy_de_Loimbard
      @Guy_de_Loimbard Před 7 lety +1

      Aitor Jara I've owned Porsches before and I don't have to own one now to know I prefer the sound of one over the sound of another. If you think driving one of the most well-balanced sports cars ever built feels the same as driving a nose-heavy, understeering hog like the S3 or Golf R, you have no business telling anyone they don't know what they're talking about.

  • @bludika
    @bludika Před 8 lety +10

    the tail lights i think looks too ordinary now, i always thought the boxster/cayman tail lights were really unique but this one, looks too plain and small, i think it took a step backwards

  • @PianoandCarcrack94
    @PianoandCarcrack94 Před 8 lety +23

    putting the beetle back in porsches

  • @gta8770
    @gta8770 Před 8 lety +9

    Ruined by the turbo? Not exactly...
    Ruined by the FOUR F****ING CYLINDER!!!!

    • @HenryDavidFloyd
      @HenryDavidFloyd Před 8 lety

      +gas taber They've got plenty of famous cars with 4 cylinders. Having 4 cylinders never hurt them.

  • @stonewalled9696
    @stonewalled9696 Před 8 lety +11

    This should be a $40k range car. I'd buy it used and drive the hell out of it!

    • @SgtSeth
      @SgtSeth Před 8 lety +1

      +IIproductionsII That is exactly what Mercedes Benz has done with their brand name. In the Southern US, every person wanting to look "high-end" is driving a bargain Merc and they look like crap. Mostly because these people cant afford the up keep on them.

    • @aidanhughes1484
      @aidanhughes1484 Před 8 lety

      it is but you have no add ons 😂

  • @jdmancinimd
    @jdmancinimd Před 8 lety +3

    I have a 2014 Boxster S with a 6 cylinder and I plan on keeping it. I think it will actually increase in value now that Porsche has gone to Turbo-4s.

  • @TheVickersDoorter
    @TheVickersDoorter Před 8 lety +4

    I take delivery of my 718 Saturday. I will refrain through from wearing the Primark sweater...

  • @al8161
    @al8161 Před 8 lety +1

    This is actually one of the first reviews I have enjoyed, not boring like the ones before
    Keep it on

  • @18T220
    @18T220 Před 8 lety +18

    My old 2000 Boxster S 3.2 sounds much better.

    • @VirusTornado
      @VirusTornado Před 8 lety

      +18T220 Sounds like a race car with a straight pipe.

  • @detective3728
    @detective3728 Před 8 lety +20

    There is not much soul left in that guy, huh?

    • @Kaipeternicolas
      @Kaipeternicolas Před 8 lety +1

      +Chrstian “Driver” mrclep Might be because of the car?

    • @detective3728
      @detective3728 Před 8 lety +1

      Kaipeternicolas really dude, really...

    • @nikb6528
      @nikb6528 Před 8 lety +1

      Kaipeternicolas No, he's actually always a bit cold and stoical.

    • @detective3728
      @detective3728 Před 8 lety +1

      ***** no one said it was bad, beside you who haven´t drivin it...

    • @riemjann1
      @riemjann1 Před 8 lety

      I actually did like his presentation this time. He's certainly doing a better job than he did half a year ago.

  • @JimBob_1975
    @JimBob_1975 Před 7 lety +1

    My 986 sounds beautifully refined when cruising at low revs/speed and puts a smile on your face when you open it up. The new one doesn't IMO.

  • @AJBCooper
    @AJBCooper Před 8 lety

    Much better production quality on this video nicely done!

  • @brittbrown5191
    @brittbrown5191 Před 8 lety +1

    Looking forward to the 718 introduction.

  • @a.f.s.3004
    @a.f.s.3004 Před 8 lety +2

    Hang on to the flat 6's......instant keeper now!

  • @xxBoilerMakerxx
    @xxBoilerMakerxx Před 8 lety +2

    I don't understand it when reviewers are switched between similar cars. As for example was done here. It makes it impossible to compare - one of the primary points of reviews. Steve Sutcliffe reviewed Cayman S, GTS, Boxster Spyder and other Porsches. Why didn't he review this car? I'd love his opinion on the new engine.

  • @marcuskuip
    @marcuskuip Před 8 lety +10

    I think you're still to kind too kind to that awful sounding 4 cilinder in it. It's a damn shame the flat 6 is gone. And not just because of the sound, or the throttle response, but because of the emotion a NA engine brings in it's power delivery. And I'm not saying that as a Porsche purist, but as a sports car purist.

    • @TassieLorenzo
      @TassieLorenzo Před 8 lety

      +marcuskuip Agreed. The power delivery of a wrx or other 4 cyl turbo isn't bad, it's just a bit bland. Same deal here - the engine is effective but not too interesting.

  • @mrla6240
    @mrla6240 Před 8 lety

    nice review! guess i could get use to the sound and turbo lag lol

  • @uhugvjkbkjh
    @uhugvjkbkjh Před 8 lety +2

    Good review. Tricky times when a writer knows that by ripping into a manufacturer they won't ask him to review their cars. Thus carefully constructed sentences...

  • @profhamel
    @profhamel Před 8 lety +2

    I owned one of the last air-cooled 911s, so I do appreciate the Porsche flat-6. Having said that, I wonder if the sound of the 718 will be a disappointment to anyone who hasn't owned a 911 or "classic" Boxster. In other words, is the engine disappointing outright, or only in comparison to the traditional flat-6 benchmark?

  • @TheAegisClaw
    @TheAegisClaw Před 8 lety +2

    So many people going on about the sound of cars recently. A nice sound is... Nice. Not really of massive importance compared to how it drives though.

  • @bosse641
    @bosse641 Před 8 lety

    Very good review. ....enjoyed that. ....thanks.

  • @johnferebee
    @johnferebee Před 4 měsíci

    Have a new 718 Boxster and it’s my first Porsche so apparently I don’t know any better. This is the most fun I’ve ever had in a car with the possible exception of the back seat of an old Ford at the drive in movie.

  • @Dgannt
    @Dgannt Před 8 lety +4

    It's like F1. The drama is gone. They might get faster lap times with these new Power Unites (PU) but that rumbling that gave you goosebumps is gone. The same with this new Porsche. I've got to say Ferrari did a great job with 488 GTB. Specially as the torque increases with every gear and you don't get full torque like in most sports cars. A lot of torque is good in a race car, not in a sports cars.

  • @all-flat-engines
    @all-flat-engines Před 8 lety +3

    First time I've seen this channel struggle to say anything nice about a Porsche, and he's right it does sound like a WRX

  • @nicoroehr
    @nicoroehr Před 8 lety

    Thumbs up for the honest review.

  • @agentbb007
    @agentbb007 Před 8 lety +16

    Most people can't tell the sound difference between a 4 and 6 unless you tell them then suddenly everyone says they can hear the difference and the 4 sounds so bad lol people are such liars.

    • @bighands69
      @bighands69 Před 8 lety +3

      That is just pure nonsense.
      Porsche V6 engines have a unique sound. Even a V6 with a turbo will sound different.
      We are clearly talking about engine noise not exhaust.

    • @neogenzim1995
      @neogenzim1995 Před 7 lety +6

      V6? you fucking daft mate?

    • @setman8081
      @setman8081 Před 7 lety

      maybe he jumped the track and was talking about their panamera V6? :-/ haha

    • @aitorjara100
      @aitorjara100 Před 7 lety +1

      You are such a stupid guy... I have the flat 6 and I can tell this one here is fucking disgusting, it sounds like a really small engine just like the one in the audi S3 or golf R. There is nothing as the flat 6 you can't feel the same while driving. Personally I would never spend money on a porsche with a turbo unless the engine is 3.4L at mínimum. Besides that they are charging more money for this new versión than ever, which makes me even more sick.

    • @maestrovso
      @maestrovso Před 7 lety

      Didn't you notice his screen name? He sure can tell 6 apart from 9.

  • @marlondaniels7023
    @marlondaniels7023 Před 8 lety +1

    i promise you this guy was taught this job by a librarian

  • @adamhammond6250
    @adamhammond6250 Před 8 lety +1

    I doubt the boxer 4 will affect standard Boxster or Boxster S sales at all. Here's hoping that they maintain 6 cylinders and natural aspiration for any special models though.

  • @uhugvjkbkjh
    @uhugvjkbkjh Před 8 lety +1

    The thing about some of these supposed more efficient new turbo 4's - on top of not getting the claimed mpg figures, the mpg read outs are actually fibbing by literally miles ie Golf R

  • @jacquenoir7876
    @jacquenoir7876 Před 8 lety +1

    So wield watching a car drive on the correct side of the road!

  • @LeJohnz
    @LeJohnz Před 8 lety +1

    I think another thing that hurts is the fact that they're even charging us thousands more over the outgoing model's base price..

  • @Russellhawker
    @Russellhawker Před 8 lety +2

    Shame Porsche didn't checkout the original 718 to see how to make a flat four exciting and soulful. Nothing wrong with a flat four when done right. The 550 Spyder and 718 sounded awesome. They screamed and howled like a Porsche should.

  • @detaart
    @detaart Před 8 lety +14

    slightly ... a little bit ... ever so minute ... might ... not sure ... slightly less ... not as much ...
    Just say it! It's a four pot, and it's not slightly less involving, not a little bit worse, not just a bit less. It's a real loss, and a real shame.

    • @ashleyjames308
      @ashleyjames308 Před 5 lety

      john m I’ve just bought one and it’s fantastic, the new four is a huge improvement, considerably faster everywhere and noticeably better handling. The old six was noisy, hard work and slow in comparison. Mine has the PDK too, which is much better than manual.

    • @Peter-Oxley-Modelling-Lab
      @Peter-Oxley-Modelling-Lab Před 5 lety

      Ashley James You need to book an appointment with your Doctor to get your ears checked out.
      You might have persuaded yourself, but you are not kidding anyone else.
      The new car's engine sounds worse that a Subaru. Faster. True, slight improvement in steering feel, but otherwise everywhere else seems worse. Turbo lag, (poor throttle response) weird droning sounds, rear lights look like Halfords aftermarket, cheap looking plasticky steering wheel, bland front bumper, no soul, no charisma, a major step backwards compared to wonderful looking and sounding 981. And yes, in case you hadn't guessed, I have driven both a lot. Driven 4x 718's (different models) Had a week with 718 Cayman and was glad to hand it back. A shame. On paper it sounds great but the reality is shocking.

    • @ashleyjames308
      @ashleyjames308 Před 5 lety +2

      Peter Oxley The 718 has GT4 rear suspension arms, a wider track and much better handling. The previous models never felt quite right IMO, whereas the 718 is beautifully balanced. There isn’t any obvious turbo lag just more power everywhere. The old six was a bit gutless unless you kept it above 4,500 when it was noisy and tiring on a journey. The new car is much quieter.
      Im sure you’re very upset because Porsche have rendered whatever you own out of date, but they had no alternative if they were going to make a faster car than hot hatches.

    • @ashleyjames308
      @ashleyjames308 Před 5 lety

      Peter Oxley I think you made a mistake because I did the same as you, I had a 987, i agonised over a 981 and tried a 718 extensively. There are so many areas where the 981 falls short. But if you prefer the induction roar of a six and that’s what matters to you, I’m happy for you.
      TBH I think Porsche have customers like me who want a long distance touring car that’s fun to drive fast with the roof down etc and they have track day types who spend a fortune on exhausts and wheels and like brake callipers painted horrible colours that clash with the car. On the road in real world conditions, the 718 is a much faster, quieter, better handling, better riding car with a much better navigation system that operates with my iPhone. Even the headlights are a massive improvement. I thought it was a no brainer. 😉

    • @Peter-Oxley-Modelling-Lab
      @Peter-Oxley-Modelling-Lab Před 5 lety

      Ashley James No mistake, I can assure you. Porsche have lost their USP and made their car more like it's competitors from Audi, and in engine terms, inferior to Nissan, and BMW. They have made the mistake. As Chris Harris said: The 718 is still a great sports car...just not quite as great as the one before. In isolation it is ok. But not a keeper.😉

  • @jeffk464
    @jeffk464 Před 8 lety +1

    I personally would absolutely love to have the cayman version of this.

  • @jamdc2000
    @jamdc2000 Před 8 lety

    now that was a proper review

  • @ashleyjames308
    @ashleyjames308 Před 5 lety

    Turbos are all about torque and power. You can only get more power by getting more fuel into an engine. There are two ways to do it; more revs or forced induction.
    The six was hard work and noisy, the 718 is fast everywhere and a vast improvement, it flies from any speed anywhere. Everything is easier, faster and more relaxing. The GT4 rear suspension is also a lot better and enables faster cornering.
    The 718 completely outclassed the 981.
    I’ve just got mine and I’m sold.

  • @joecribben2975
    @joecribben2975 Před 8 lety

    Recently sold the last gen boxster, even though I'm moving on to bigger toys I have to say I'm going to miss it.

  • @TassieLorenzo
    @TassieLorenzo Před 8 lety +6

    Riding a wave of midrange torque (because there isn't anything extra to be found at the top-end, no point revving it out), shouldn't be what a sportscar is about.

    • @chaoticdog85
      @chaoticdog85 Před 8 lety

      agree, gt yes...not a sports car though

    • @chaoticdog85
      @chaoticdog85 Před 8 lety

      agree, gt yes...not a sports car though

    • @chaoticdog85
      @chaoticdog85 Před 8 lety

      agree, gt yes...not a sports car though

    • @SgtSeth
      @SgtSeth Před 8 lety

      +chaoticdog85 Merriam Webster would like to disagree with you
      " a low small usually 2-passenger automobile designed for quick response, easy maneuverability, and high-speed driving"
      That seems to fit the 718 build quite nicely.

  • @metalmikebot
    @metalmikebot Před 8 lety +1

    I think it sounds awesome. It doesn't sound like a naturally aspirated flat six, but so what? I still want one.

  • @macarows4014
    @macarows4014 Před 8 lety +3

    After hearing this lovely gentleman, and concluding that nowadays engineers are UNABLE to make NA engines more powerful & cleaner without damn turbos I am not surprised we have over 200k orders for new Tesla Model 3.

    • @101ktm
      @101ktm Před 4 lety

      Mac Arows haha seriously? His only complaint was it lost 2 cylinders and everyone is complaining about the sound being horrible and you think the Tesla Model 3 with no cylinders and no sound is what Porsche buyers want? Tesla’s are cool but i’d buy a turbo 4 banger Porsche with the best handling chassis ever produced and more power and torque than the previous Caymans NA 6 over the Tesla any day. The auto industry is seeing a progression from large displacement naturally aspirated to small displacement turbo charged and ultimately and unfortunately electric. Someday electric will rule the world and any of us who are still alive will lament the sound of a combustion engine at start up and roaring down the road.

  • @FOR8YESHUA
    @FOR8YESHUA Před 8 lety +1

    It would be nice with a floppy paddle twin clutch, twin turbo, supercharger and all wheel drive. That would be fun stuff. I like the quiet of the cabin. It seems as though it is livable as it is but may be missing some of the soul that Porsche is known for even in the Camen.

  • @oldschoolracinggames5729
    @oldschoolracinggames5729 Před 8 lety +5

    MCLAREN P1- ruined by the turbo?
    eat this, british

  • @Skooby59
    @Skooby59 Před 8 lety

    nice new set up

  • @MayTheZenBeWithYou
    @MayTheZenBeWithYou Před 8 lety +2

    least involving review I've ever seen, i had to force myself to see it till the end. Man it's a porsche, you're driving a car that the majority of us is dreaming of, please put some emotion in it. It's a car not a woman it will not leave you if you show her some love XD

  • @mukangtae3
    @mukangtae3 Před 8 lety +4

    fuck turbo i hope they make hybrid NA engines asap to compete against shitty turbo engines

  • @kristy77a
    @kristy77a Před 8 lety

    Great video and epic countryside (I grew up in norther California and live in NYC-am always pining for bigger skies). Engine sound does seem like it's gone from nightingale to pigeon. I'd still surrender my left nut to own one.

  • @ChiroVideosTVlondon
    @ChiroVideosTVlondon Před 8 lety +4

    Doesn't sound too bad for a four, definitely fruitier than my mark3 TTS but obviously more expensive as well. It looks beautiful, but sports cars need to crackle and pop.

  • @KNIGHTRACEDOTCOM
    @KNIGHTRACEDOTCOM Před 8 lety

    would be great with the 3.8 and maybe 2 turbos. I drove a cayman with an x51 3.8 and a twin turbo kit the other day, very nice.

  • @MagicAyrtonforever
    @MagicAyrtonforever Před 8 lety +14

    Everything that made me want a Porsche has gone.

    • @HenryDavidFloyd
      @HenryDavidFloyd Před 8 lety +2

      +MagicAyrtonforever They've had plenty of amazing 4-cylinder cars in their history. 356, 718 (the original), 912, 914, 924, 944, 968... not to mention their current Le Mans car. This one should be just as great.

    • @MagicAyrtonforever
      @MagicAyrtonforever Před 8 lety

      Henry Floyd Just sounds wrong. Sorry. 914-4 was pants so was 924

    • @HenryDavidFloyd
      @HenryDavidFloyd Před 8 lety

      MagicAyrtonforever Yeah I'm not a fan of those two either. But come on, can you really hate the original 718? Or the 356, or the 944 Turbo or the 919?

    • @MagicAyrtonforever
      @MagicAyrtonforever Před 8 lety

      Henry Floyd It's not hatred, it's a total lack of interest.

    • @HenryDavidFloyd
      @HenryDavidFloyd Před 8 lety

      MagicAyrtonforever You have a total lack of interest in those cars I mentioned? I guess there's no accounting for taste.

  • @rosso_cali7110
    @rosso_cali7110 Před 8 lety +10

    For my, car sound is everything. I really like the 6 cilinder from Porsche.
    I don''t care about how fast it is, it sounds like nothing and has no emotion. Porsche i'm really really disappointed in you

    • @bedlambikes
      @bedlambikes Před 8 lety

      +FullHDsupercars _ I've been saving for my Cayman S for over two years now, and I'm devastated. Time to just pull the trigger and get an on the lot 2016 instead? So much for building it to my specs and choices.....ugh.

  • @goons123flofy
    @goons123flofy Před 8 lety

    Paul Giamatti of the car world. Don't get me wrong, I value his opinion and he is a heck of a driver.

  • @Malteser3535
    @Malteser3535 Před 8 lety +3

    Aircooled to watercooled was feasible. But moving from a flat 6 to a flat 4 is unbearable.

    • @rasvial
      @rasvial Před 8 lety

      +Malteser3535 because?

    • @Malteser3535
      @Malteser3535 Před 8 lety

      Because of the sound, the free inertial force and the free mass moment, therefore you need a balance shaft. The flat six doesn't need that. This is why they are so torquey but still like to rev.
      If you have the chance, drive a manual 911 Carrera S with the 3.8 flat six. You'll know what I mean.
      Sorry for my bad engllish.

  • @GirishKumarBhat
    @GirishKumarBhat Před 8 lety

    0:42 With that DUG DUG DUG DUG DUG DUG, I was like "Is that Royal Enfield Bullet?"

  • @Ducatista189
    @Ducatista189 Před 8 lety +1

    It would be rather funny if we ever reached a production car with a v24 cylinder engine, and then the following replacement would have to make due with a turbocharged v16. People would still complain. Its all relative. At least we still have the beautiful sounds of internal combustion available to us. There'll be a day when it won't. Enjoy the explosions. Enjoy the turbo whistle. Enjoy the breakdowns that are that flaw in cars, that exists in anything beautiful. Live in the now, appreciate the past and accept the future. Your life will be better off for it.

  • @GrotrianSeiler
    @GrotrianSeiler Před 8 lety +1

    I like the progress, but I don't think the engineers did a very good job with the exhaust. That's not a very exciting sound.

  • @mariodiniz21
    @mariodiniz21 Před 8 lety +4

    if it sounds like that with a sports exhaust, it's better to make it a diesel.

  • @FreestylerAlbert
    @FreestylerAlbert Před 8 lety

    sound from the speakers , rigth?

  • @Michael_Michaels
    @Michael_Michaels Před 8 lety +5

    I actualy rather hear the turbo whistle than a 6 cylinder...

    • @vivalaphill
      @vivalaphill Před 8 lety +51

      blasphemy.

    • @jeffk464
      @jeffk464 Před 8 lety +2

      +MikeVonDoom
      I love turbos

    • @jimtaylor431
      @jimtaylor431 Před 8 lety +5

      +MikeVonDoom Owning both a 6 cylinder car and a 4 cyl turbo car, they do both have their own appeal no doubt about it... but I think I prefer the 6 cylinder sound more. It's always going to be an individual choice / preference though I guess.

    • @SenszR
      @SenszR Před 8 lety +1

      +MikeVonDoom ew

    • @marcnobel3938
      @marcnobel3938 Před 8 lety

      +MikeVonDoom Depends on the engine. Exchanging a raw high rev flat 6 in this case is sad, but when you NA Lovers can still go with the GT Models.

  • @bbpleg
    @bbpleg Před 8 lety

    Please tell us whether or not it actually is more fuel efficient than the previous model. From my personal experience, these new smaller displacement engines, don't provide better consumption figures, except on a test dyno.

  • @AkaAndyKnuckles
    @AkaAndyKnuckles Před 8 lety

    Nice video, though the sound was so and so. Really nice car.

  • @neiltaylor5332
    @neiltaylor5332 Před 8 lety +1

    I guess the 6 cylinder Boxter Spyder/ Cayman GT4 will now increase in value even more.

    • @3232schmitty
      @3232schmitty Před 8 lety +1

      +Neil Taylor They were already collectors' cars too. Damn, there go me dreams of having one in ten years

  • @vivalaphill
    @vivalaphill Před 8 lety +16

    faster,cleaner, more effective.....I don't care I want a raw beast. not a shiny perfect Hoover.

    • @MrKeyboardCommando
      @MrKeyboardCommando Před 8 lety +3

      +vivalaphill Yeah, you'd have to be a real sucker to want one of those.

    • @madfiat8932
      @madfiat8932 Před 8 lety +1

      +vivalaphill If you want a raw beast, you don't buy a Porsche. You buy something like a 4C or a Lamborghini.

    • @genericallyaccepted
      @genericallyaccepted Před 8 lety +1

      +Alvin Brinson you can't even get a clutch pedal in a 4C, which also happens to have a turbocharged 4 banger.
      Can you get a stick in the new Lamborghinis or have they, too, moved to solely offering paddle shift?

    • @LukeEvans55
      @LukeEvans55 Před 5 lety

      Sounds like you want a Lotus

  • @paulandrebeccak5680
    @paulandrebeccak5680 Před 8 lety

    I think this review is fantastic. Is the car a faster, marginally better driving car? Yes. Does it have the soul or involvement of the flat 6? No. You can see it on his face during the whole review, the car is just not as thrilling w/o the flat 6. I've got a 2.7 981 Boxster 6 speed which I will certainly not be trading in for a 718 anytime soon. Great review Autocar!!

  • @alexserrano2850
    @alexserrano2850 Před 8 lety

    Take it to your favourite mountain road, drop the top, feel the balance and torque and enjoy the forest autumnal breeze. Then get back home through the highway comfortably listening to your favourite music and sleep happily.
    Mid engined, usable power, not crazy expensive, reasonable mileage and gorgeous design. This car is all about experience and not performance.
    Perfect road car in my opinion :)

  • @evanescent0311
    @evanescent0311 Před 7 lety

    no doubt, the GTS sounds better, but when I drove a new (leftover) GTS back to back with the 718S, I found the 718S to feel much more powerful and better in every way...also the GTS looked great, but immediately old as "last year's model" ... same price, I went for the 718S.... don't regret it.

  • @trdartz
    @trdartz Před 8 lety +1

    oh dear, what have Porsche done..... drove a Turbo S Cab recently.... I did not like it .. it's very capable... but it's so quiet and too refined.. I felt so detached.... I much preferred the 991.1 S and GT3 NA motors.... how I wish Porsche stick with NA at least with ALL GT cars for the foreseeable future

  • @jimmymcgoo8641
    @jimmymcgoo8641 Před 5 měsíci

    Remapped one of these would be fun!

  • @khoaphan8490
    @khoaphan8490 Před 7 lety

    I'm probably the only one who's not paying attention to the sound but to how they made a freaking 4 cylinder accelerate 0-60 in 4.5s

  • @ponygt6629
    @ponygt6629 Před 8 lety

    Ford Focus RS vs 2017 Porsche Boxter will be a great video to watch out for

  • @pughy79
    @pughy79 Před 5 lety +1

    Great car. True it doesn’t sound quite as good as the old ones but the improved performance more than makes up for it imo. Enjoy as we’ll all be driving electric cars before we know it!

    • @gregalanbell
      @gregalanbell Před rokem

      New all electric on its way, glad I got my 718 ice!

  • @aDaWaN
    @aDaWaN Před 8 lety +1

    Porsche just returned to their roots: this thing sounds exactly like an old beetle..

    • @detaart
      @detaart Před 8 lety +1

      +aDaWaN ummm ... no ... have you ever been in an old beetle? The only way that can rev to 7.5k is when you shift it from fourth into first ... and you can do it only once.
      Beetles are puttery laid back little cars. They are not sports cars. Try driving a beetle like a sports car, and you will quite quickly and suddenly face the way you came from, possibly upside down.

    • @JohnnyWrong
      @JohnnyWrong Před 8 lety

      +detaart He's just parroting what he heard that buffoon Clarkson say. ;)

    • @detaart
      @detaart Před 8 lety

      disgraceland uk possibly

  • @ianharley7709
    @ianharley7709 Před 8 lety +2

    Honest review 👀

  • @Fizzbomb123
    @Fizzbomb123 Před 8 lety

    I'm enjoying my CGTS

  • @AlexRogersTV
    @AlexRogersTV Před 8 lety

    Imagine a world where Porsche make a change to a car and people don't complain...

  • @ScottZ370
    @ScottZ370 Před 8 lety +9

    I don't see it selling that well to be honest, it's basically just the final straw to push a potential buyer to buy an F Type V6S

    • @metalmikebot
      @metalmikebot Před 8 lety +4

      +S Miller If the sound preference is the deciding factor, maybe. But this is faster than an F-Type V6 S and will out handle it for days.

    • @ScottZ370
      @ScottZ370 Před 8 lety +3

      Mike Doolittle Buyers of these cars rarely go flat out though or take them to the track, for them it's all about how it makes you feel

    • @metalmikebot
      @metalmikebot Před 8 lety +1

      I definitely agree. But everything about this car says it feels amazing. I can't see an advantage for the F-Type outside of the sound, which is obviously very subjective. I like both, for different reasons. But I'd still take the superior acceleration and handling of the 718.

    • @TheHesK9
      @TheHesK9 Před 8 lety

      I think it will still do pretty well. If you want handling then you can get a Elise 220 or a Exige 350 roadster, the F type is good but the 718 is a good compromise for a sports car

    • @SenszR
      @SenszR Před 8 lety +1

      +S Miller Well these cars drive better than the F-Type so the only advantage the F-Type has is the sound.

  • @mpanayi1
    @mpanayi1 Před 8 lety +4

    Porsche already has a modern, efficient flat 6 motor... in the new 911s. Using a 4-pot for "emissions" is a bullish*t excuse. From where i stand, its Porsche's way of demoting the cayman/boxster to much below the 911 as the 981 cayman/boxster actually got better reviews that their bigger brother. Porsche felt they were losing sales of 911s to cayman/boxsters. Hence the 4-pot.

    • @TheCa007
      @TheCa007 Před 8 lety

      100% correct.

    • @howardlittell
      @howardlittell Před 8 lety

      Yup. It's why I purchased a new Cayman S 981 when it first came out in 2014 over a 991. Looks better than a 911 too

    • @alexserrano2850
      @alexserrano2850 Před 8 lety

      +Michael Panayi I don't really know what is so demeaning about a 4 cylinder engine other than the sound, personally I find the concept of a middle placed turbo 2.5 flat four very attractive. You could make the argument of the torque at the top end, but I don't go 8/10 or 10/10 every time I drive. This is a road car so the torque is better suited for its purpose, it weights less and it's certainly less thirsty.
      I don't know about you but to me this seems like a much more competent road car than the last generation. I'm willing to sacrifice the sound for all this.

    • @TheCa007
      @TheCa007 Před 8 lety

      +Alex Serranoit
      It 718 4 cylinder weights more than the 981 flat 6, because of the turbos and uses just as much fuel if not more when you punch it there is no advantage. Other than a cheaper product for more money.

    • @mpanayi1
      @mpanayi1 Před 8 lety

      +Alex Serrano unfortunately, the 718 actually weighs more than the previous generation, and under real driving conditions, the turbo motor is not more efficient that the old motor. Also, regarding the concept of a 4 cylinder, you have to remember this is a 60k car. For 60k, you expect the motor to be special, not just capable. No one is denying that the 718 performance is better, but its not a special motor, just capable A VW golf (much cheaper) has a 4-pot motor, and is also capable, but no one would call the engine special. Also, haven driven the 981 cayman, cayman s and gts, none of them are lacking in torque especially when combined with the PDK gearbox. regardless, the 718 is still a great car, i just can't standing the marketing crap in justifying a repositioning of the boxster/cayman to be clearly a poor man's 911.

  • @tadficuscactus
    @tadficuscactus Před 8 lety +1

    At least they kept it as a boxer engine.

  • @happydappyman
    @happydappyman Před 8 lety

    turbo was fast.
    Now most people think it's a decent way to make a small efficient engine as powerful as a bigger one albeit with more lag, and worse sound.
    I guess people know its more complicated than that now

  • @geekf1
    @geekf1 Před 8 lety +1

    More or less the same verdict Harry Metcalfe gave about the new 911 Carrera S (turbo). In acouple of years Porsche would've sorted these small turbo engines out.

  • @Nickmetallcreator
    @Nickmetallcreator Před 8 lety +1

    Back to the beetle roots, with the 4cyl engine...

  • @racecrashrepeat
    @racecrashrepeat Před 8 lety +2

    couldn't pick a road with more bumps and tyre noise?

  • @nickamarit
    @nickamarit Před 8 lety

    Love the steering wheel. :)

  • @Xbox360Player350
    @Xbox360Player350 Před 8 lety +1

    They could have at least used unequal length headers to give it a more characterful STi type sound

    • @dumkopf
      @dumkopf Před 8 lety

      +Xbox360Player350 Why the hell would they want to sound like a subaru?

    • @Xbox360Player350
      @Xbox360Player350 Před 8 lety +1

      +dumkopf Why would they want it to sound like an FR-S, as it does now?

    • @dumkopf
      @dumkopf Před 8 lety

      Xbox360Player350 Well there are only so many ways it can sound. Why would they want to make it sound like a Subaru?

    • @Xbox360Player350
      @Xbox360Player350 Před 8 lety +1

      +dumkopf Most people prefer the boxer rumble over a generic 4 cyl vacuum cleaner type sound

  • @utubecomment21
    @utubecomment21 Před 8 lety +1

    And seemingly Porsche came 37th out of 38 for the Whatcar reliability survey, so make sure you have those breakdown recovery premiums up-to-date.
    www.whatcar.com/news/honda-named-uks-reliable-used-car-manufacturer-2015/

  • @theresonly1truth138
    @theresonly1truth138 Před 8 lety +4

    i want this with the 2015 boxster gts bumper!!!!!

  • @neoblackcyptron
    @neoblackcyptron Před 2 lety

    I don’t like noisy loud engines ironically this suits my needs.

  • @nikitalatman444
    @nikitalatman444 Před 8 lety +1

    you meant DECREASING fuel consumption right?

  • @phoenix6064
    @phoenix6064 Před 8 lety

    Test it vs the old one on track and twisty roads, I bet it's no more fuel efficent than the old 6.

  • @boymoontube
    @boymoontube Před 8 lety

    So hard to extinguish from the older versions.

    • @NeonLuvBar
      @NeonLuvBar Před 8 lety +1

      +boyScotland They are more inflammable ?

    • @boymoontube
      @boymoontube Před 8 lety +1

      hehe, another bad typo...............