Corsair Waterblocks... oof
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 05. 2020
- A TON of people asked me to confirm whether or not the Corsair XG7 Waterblocks actually leak since this is something that was recently discussed in some other forums... so we decided to test this ourselves...
**iFixit has over 60,000 tutorials and guides to help you repair your electronics FOR FREE! To see a complete list of guides and tools head to www.ifixit.com/jayztwocents
**And to get your very own iFixit Tools from Amazon head to - amzn.to/2Xu1xE2
○○○○○○ Items featured in this video available at Amazon ○○○○○○
► Amazon US - bit.ly/1meybOF
► Amazon UK - amzn.to/Zx813L
► Amazon Canada - amzn.to/1tl6vc6
Get your JayzTwoCents Merch Here! - crowdmade.com/collections/jay...
••• Follow me on your favorite Social Media! •••
Facebook: / jayztwocents
Twitter: / jayztwocents
Instagram: / jayztwocents
SUBSCRIBE! bit.ly/sub2JayzTwoCents - Věda a technologie
He first discovered the issue with the card installed vertically, and it wasn't squirting like that, it would just drip a little, which is still unacceptable.
A little drip, ok but what about if the PSU shroud is with holes like some cases have. It will drip along side the PSU and when it reaches the bottom the fans could pick up the water and pull it inside the PSU. If you like fireworks I'm sure you won't like them inside your PC, it's unacceptable either way.
@@Teksers Shiba says its still not acceptable.
@@Teksers Did you not read the comment Shiba made? He was commenting on how Major Hardware had it installed when it happened to him.
@@12Burton24 I was adressing the fact that he said a "little drop", I know full well what a little dripplet of water can do in a PC if it falls on the right component.
@@metalmaniac788 Did you not read that I was adressing perforated PSU shoruds, where a little drip can be a lot more hurtfull?
I literally just found Major Hardware in the last couple of weeks and his channel is really good. When he put that video up the first thing I thought was, I hope Jay sees this! This makes me so happy!
His channel is great, one of my favourite up and coming channels right now, very happy to see him get some mainstream attention
I felt the same way! I have watched his video a bit longer though. I remember when he did his first video about it my first thought was "why are Jay&Linus&Kyle&Paul not talking about this?"
Same here, he seems clued up
Lol at this point, it's channels covering channels covering channels covering channels
doing a cover from another channel. 🤣🤣
@@deminybs yo dawg, we heard you like channels! So we referenced some channels within channels just for you.
Based on pictures on Corsair's site, 30-series blocks have added the third screw in the middle
Jay ima be honest with you, i can totally see this happening in a normal use case. maybe not everyone, and certaintly less likely if you're experienced setting up custom loops, but that is not a ton of pressure. that could totally happen to the average person and ruin their components.
I'm guilty of reaching around soft tubing to pull a RAM stick or CMOS battery. GPU wiggled when I did, but not much, but I could see that happening just from that.
@@wasabij Also even one or two unnotticed drips can spell doom if there is even a tiny bit of anything in the water (dye, minerals, addatives, dust) as they can slowely dry up and get stuck under that weakpoint and slowly prop it up with temperature cycling. Then eventually it will leak. So if you build it then test fill it and then make a simple mistake and move the connection just a little bit you can screw yourself in the long run. That shouldn't happen you'd have the break the EK block clean apart before it leaked. The only advice is don't touch the tubing at all ever if you want to keep it in your PC and it hasn't leaked and hope you don't have a power supply right below it (which is typical nowadays)
he's just being gentle with Corsair (bc of sponsor) and, at the same time, not recommending the product by doing this video. I mean, it looks crappy, no one would buy a leaking block
Take it apart like Jay just did and add lightly add some silicone/gasket maker around the o-rings then re-tighten the screws. That should get you by until they come up with a better design.
@@wasabij you're pulling ram or cmos while your system is running?
that major hardware is a great guys, i love how he make frankenstain design and slap in. Also thanks for the loyalty to the viewer jay. I really appreciate it when you say it like that
I liked the water-cooled air cooler he did lol
Linus had a similar issue last year. When I first watched it, I passed it off as Linus being Linus but now it makes more sense.
Link- czcams.com/video/wQMCvQ01e80/video.html&t=704
11:43 in the Linus video.
Linus talks about the screws specifically at 14:01 at his video czcams.com/video/wQMCvQ01e80/video.html
"So I don't know why...so maybe it was just my block wasn't tight enough from the factory...could it be that simple?...that has a good quarter turn left in it....and that has an eighth +"
I was also just watching that video after watching Jayz video about the leak and wanted to post it. So thanks for posting it 👍😃
you right, i passed it too for the same reason. Awesome finding!
@@PikaCantSub Yeah but that risks cracking the arcylic it will keep getting slightly loose as plastics creep a little under temperature cycling and eventually it will just crack if you keep tightning it without tracking how far you have gone. I've seen very expensive custom parts go crack with overtighening or repeated tightening.
Today's date: 12/29/2021: I've tried to duplicate this same issue in my new XG 30 Series Waterblock, I own an Asus ROG Strix RTX 3090. I can tell you this version of the GPU waterblock has been redesigned, and the 3rd screw has been implemented (right in the middle) as it should have been since the beginning, and also the same way the EK waterblock has it. I've tried to use the same amount of force (for what we can tell in this video) and I can rest assure this issue did not appear, at least on my WB for my GPU. It is definitely very solid, honestly made me feel even better about using it. I've been assembling PC's for more than 20 years now, and I feel confident of my own test. If you happen to have the tools, which I have access to, grasp and pinch strength test tools, I was able to test it with a force of about 15 Lbs of force, considering that, if you have 1 gallon of liquid cooling inside your cooling loop, this could weigh between 8 and 10 lbs of force, could be a bit more depending on your fluid, but usually this is the average. So at least on my end I have peace of mind of the new design and feel very good about using it.
You underestimate the amount of force the average joe will put on tubing/fittings in their mini/itx builds to force it to fit.
That's ridiculous.
If it's under that much force after you've got your tubing sorted out you're doing something wrong
**sweats in LinusTechTips**
That would be prior to filling the loop though.
That's what she said "to force it to fit"
igors lab, one of the best german techyoutubers, had the exact same problem with the exact same block witout explicitely torking it, in his review of the block 7 months ago.
corsair literally told him they would fix it and never did.
EDIT: LTT had the same problem with this block too in a normal build, so that product is just crap.
They better revise this or fix it, Hopefully with the RTX 3000 blocks they'll have this issue fixed and I'll buy their GPU block. The block has heft and weight to it but someone how they cheaped out on the plastic terminal housing.. There is a workaround getting an EK block instead and hooking up the RGB to iCue with an adapter cable
Keep in mind research, development, implementation and manufacturing takes A LOT of time. It's not something you can do in a week. Then need to look at what is the main cause (screws not tight enough? parts too thin? too small o-rings? not enough screws? too small contact point? the terminal not wrapping around the block? etc) research new solutions, test them in CAD, manufacture engineering samples, test them IRL in different scenarios and different use cases, test long term durability of the solution based on expected use time (sort of planned obsolescence, but not really), and then make a compromise based on manufacturing difficulty, durability and costs, and then actually switching/tweaking the manufacturing process can be lengthy on a commercial level. Especially since this issue is out there, so doing a good job after a while is better, than making a quick change and have the problem persist/create a new one, giving them more bad publicity.
So yeah, 7 months might be long, but in this case it's not out of the ordinary.
It's Corsair. Did they even opened the service ticket?
@@rubbers3 Or it's just as simple as not using cheap plastic on the most important thing of a block haha but seriously the problem can be easily fixed if they used stronger plastic I reckon with a slightly thicker o-ring. Just replace the cheap plastic and that one o-ring with a thicker version and it's sorted. As a positive I hope they've learned and execute the RTX 3000 blocks better
@@rubbers3 Or just take references from EK...? There's no excuses here, as Jay has mentioned, they should have used another material just like EK doesn't use cheap plastic. They can fix this with a thicker o-ring if they stick with the same plastic design or just outright use a better suited material and design.
Woah, Corsair cheaped out on material and sold for enthusiast pricing? I'm shocked. Absolutely shocked. /s
Their standard operating model - sell cheap shit expensively.
I like their cases,and I have used their aios in the past but this is bad
Even with cheap materials you can make a competent and good design. It's a bad design.
That said if I had one, I would epoxy it, install it and never play about with it.
thereddog223 the only thing I use from them are fans, damn those LL fans look nice
This video kind of highlights the beauty of building your system yourself: each brand has their forte, and when you get to pick all the components yourself, you can end up with a PC that's only made of the best bits.
but ever increasingly they're all made in the same factory
This is why I watch your show Jay. Honest to the audience and a genuine desire to fix the problem for everyone. Good work and good suggestions.
Everyone who owns a Corsair Block had an anxiety spike when they saw the title
I own a cpu Corsair water block and I panicked
Built a Pc recently with the idea of watercooling it with Hydro X stuff, but since I'm moving house soon I figured I'd keep it air cooled because...good lord the hassle of dealing with all the watercooling when transporting this thing would be a headache I didn't need.
Dodged a bullet there, huh.
I have an older Corsair AIO cooler and I'll admit I felt nervous tingles when I read the title.
H100i V2 owner & lowkey panicked for like 3 seconds
I would still panic to be honest it can leak and thats just not acceptable. You dont need too much for to have a little leak....just some drops can be enough to kill something and just saying if you push it instead of pulling the leak will be over your card and not over the plexi.
Major Hardware is doing some really interesting projects, definitely something different in the hardware space. Been following him for about a year now.
Discovered him a few months back, and really like his content. Both quirky and informative, with a healthy amount of silliness and madness sprinkled over it.
His background as an engineer also really shows, as he's often very aware of his experiments limitations.
Yeah, I discovered him when he did a video about watercooling an air cooler. Neat stuff.
He is a crazy guy and put up really interesting content. 3D printing fan blades to match NH-A12*25, 16000rpm fans, water cooling an air cooler, putting 2*200mm fans on 240 radiators, to name a few.
Man I'm glad I found your channel. I'm building my first gaming PC since like 2007 so your tips and reviews are amazing lol
This will be my first ever custom loop as well.
Thank you!
I finished binge watching House and went through a withdrawal for a few days and then found this channel, all is well now.
Shhhhhhhh....it's house under another ID .......don't busy his secret dude.....
Welcome brother :)
Wasn't withdrawal most likely just Lupus.
@@L8ugh1ngm8n1 It's never Lupus.
A man of taste I see. Welcome to the shitshow.
I was concerned about the cheap materials Corsair was using and decided to pay a bit more for EK products. Glad I did.
Corsair cut too many corners with their water cooling products.
Their cpu blocks are pretty great tbh. The block and pump/reservoir combo leave a lot to be desired. From far away you can tell that its plastic.
im going to do the same, but honestly atleast in my country, corsair is really closed priced to ek, so it wouldnt do much of a difference
Same here, just did a water loop build and their products are cheap for a reason. Like the pump/res looks cheaper until you factor in the RGB controller and one inlet/outlet so I would need a splitter to do a drain. At that point the EK was a cheaper option anyway and probably better quality.
I have a Phanteks and an EK GPU waterblock in two machines. (SKU: Phanteks PH-GB2080TiFE & EK-FC2080-RTX-TI-CLASSIC-RGB-NP) They both have been running fine. I even swapped the terminal on the EK block with an EK-FC 90° Rotary Terminal because it's crammed into a small case. Subjectively, the Phanteks block looks as little better IMO. Mine has a nice reflective silver cover.
My only complaint is that in the design of the EK-FC classic RGB waterblock they glued a decorative piece of metal over the screws you would need to access to service the block. Very dumb design. I pried it off and removed the glue with goo gone which means the ARGB strip had to come off too. No big deal since that computer case has no window to see the block so the ARGB was irrelevant. EK shouldn't be gluing things over top of the screws though as that's something Apple does.
Never bought any Corsair GPU blocks even though I use iCUE for their ram, fans and keyboard. It's useful to have all that stuff consolidated into one piece of bloatware rather than multiple pieces of bloatware. I didn't like the aesthetics of their GPU block design personally.
Not only that In one of Linus' videos about Rad stacking they said it wasn't a good idea and then Linus removed of of his rads and his temps went up by 5C. So it seems like it to me that Corsair has alot to learn about Water/Liquid cooling. I would have asked EK about Rad stacking to see what they say about it.
But Jay, I am a wife and watching :'(
Funnily enough, my husband did buy me an iFixit kit eventually :D
Oh
Welcome to the crazy geek space, Anne! Glad to have you here!
iFixxiiiiiiittttttttttttttttttttttttttttt! {flames}
You and your husband have a great life then! You both hit the jackpot :D
Whoa, it even fixes marriages!
everything fun and games until the neighbors kid pulls up to the water gun party with a pump and a corsair waterblock
Sent you a tweet with a pic, but can confirm they DID change the 30xx series blocks. I have personally installed a 3090 FE Corsair block and they not only added center screw position, but also changed it to TWO screws in each of the three positions. Thanks for providing this feedback, as they seem to have listened!
Major Hardware does some really awesome engineering projects. Great channel.
Yep, strange how he did his "this Corsair GPU block leaks" yesterday,
and jay did it today 🤣🤣
static noises made me think my head set was dying.
i thought my pc is goin bye bye .
@@zalievac it was a grate prank.
I thought my phone gave up
@F a High pitch audio noise, not from AC
Thought my note 9 took a dump lol
I always love jays impromptu ifixit adds and his frustration over the years about originally not having them as a sponsor. haha
I’ve been watching Major Hardware for quite some time and he has a lot of cool ideas etc, It’s nice to see him featured in a bigger channel so he can hopefully grow faster
Always remember "Never be part of a problem, be part of the solution"
This is how you do a vid. Don't just say there's a problem, help find a solution
Great work Jay, keep it up, I really think Corsair will keep your fix in mind and that they will continue to sponsor you
If they get mad and say NO, screw them, you point out the problem and how to fix it, they should thank you
@@post-leftluddite Didn't know that, I just saw Jays video
"I don't feel, under any normal use case, this would happen to you."
That's literally how the issue was discovered.
Did you even watch his video?
He definitely didn't watch the first video and I'm guessing he watched about 30 seconds of this newest video. This was super low effort. Dissapointed.
Disrespected Major Hardware by not watching/understanding whole story. Just going off quickly because Corsair.
Second disrespect by referring to source/story as B stream.
All the people complaining about this, like have you ever seen how EK even puts warnings on their blocks saying you need to check the tightness and seal of everything? (Hell they used to actually recommend taking apart and rebuilding some of the blocks). His video is pretty demonstrative with his particular components, and illustrates the issue pretty well. QC being shit is separate than the design flaw itself, which the design flaw itself is bad, but not normal use case bad.
well its true bud. DO YOU JUST YANK ON YOUR WATER COOLING PORTS?
Daniel Inman Major hardware discovered this issue before trying to pull on the ports... maybe look some shit up before making stupid remarks?
This was a very good video, really good information.
You KEEP at it! Good work thank you !!
I like your show Jay they are really informative and funny too. Thanks for the heads-up for some information that I will use in the future.
5:00 I respect you a lot for that. We need more people like you with integrity in this world.
Tegridy Farms
you forgot to link major hardware channel for actually finding this flaw
Major Hardware, found the issue, researched it, compared an alternative supplier and made specific recommendations - definitely deserves the credit for this... I expect his Subs will skyrocket after this as they should...
So you can't just type his name, in the little box, at the top of the page, that never goes away? He gave him credit for it.
Outstanding video! I'm glad I saw this as I was eyeballing this exact cooler at microcenter.
I'm glad to see this video. I literally just got two of these waterblocks for my dual PC build in a Phanteks 719. Not installed so easy to return. The hard part is finding a waterblock that fits my EVGA 2070 Black.
corsair has the logo of a sinking ship, of course it's to expected that is might be leaking someday
Is there a ship?
Are you sure it is a SHIP?
@@kbhushan12 It is, a sailing ship
The name Corsair is itself a boat..
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corsair
The name has nothing to do with the logo.
Glad to see Major Hardware getting some recognition, its a cool little channel
he should 3d-print a solution
@@TheUmbrex his channel made me bute the bullet and get a 3d printer, just so I could try doing some of the same random ideas.
It's funny only found major hardware a month ago or so. Solid dude. Nice to shout him out.
This was great video Jay, i enjoyed!
I wouldn't want that in my rig Jay, I agree with Major.
He did say if you're concerned, don't buy it until Corsair fixes it.
@@mjc0961 He also said that he doesn't think its a problem for people who own them.
@@hardcorehardware361 But Linus, Major, and others have had this issue during normal operation. These leak, Major wasn't "testing" it as much as showing where the issue is. Jay not suggesting that everybody that owns one of these blocks get in line with Corsair for a refund is a disservice to his viewers.
Watch his first video on it too. He found it leaking in his system without yanking on it. Major Hardware is a good channel.
It's a bit like the problems ASUS had with their TUF RX 5700 XT where the cooler would sag causing bad contact with the GPU and resulting in high temperatures. In that case it was a combination of the card and cooler design and using conservative force torquing the screws holding the cooler. Corsair has a similar problem with the design of the cooler, the materials used and the torque used on the screws to hold it all together. The design was probably made with a rigid ports bloc in mind, while the ports block was scaled down in dimension and material to meet a price point. The screws are torqued to a safe value that almost guarantees that they won't strip the threads or crack the acrylic, and I wouldn't be surprised if it would have worked fine if the ports block was just slightly sturdier.
Now keep in mind that the original video from General Hardware showed that the first water block did leak under relatively normal circumstances. It's been a while since a watched the video myself but as I remember it the loop was built using normal soft tubing, but using a 3D printed tube guide to give it more of a hard loop look. This might have added some slight stress to the port block on the GPU cooler, but if so it wasn't really some crazy amount of force applied, yet it was enough to make it leak.
Now the water block he received as a replacement was not tested in a system so it's impossible to say if that too would have leaked under identical circumstances, but what was demonstrated in the second video was that Corsair hadn't made any changes to the design and it could still be susceptible to start leaking if used in the same way. Without further data there is no way to know how loose the manufacturing tolerances are. In this case I'm tempted to throw my hat in with Jay in saying that it probably is a very small risk that these will leak in normal use, at least when new. If it was a common occurrence then there would be a lot more noise made by people having it happen to them. After all if it's one thing Corsair is good at it's selling large volumes.
Finally I think it's *not* a non issue. The design is weak, and when there's that small a margin between a working computer and a wet computer it's not to be trivialized.
Funny how Jay didn't mention that bit & also felt a little bit covering his arse & Corsairs maybe 5%. Not outright denying the issue but firstly suggesting it was run out of spec due to no rad & then saying he was reefing on it too hard which Major Hardware clearly wasn't.
Jay does seem to defend the Corsair stuff.
AV Techy did a video about the A500 air cooler that Jay reviewed czcams.com/video/5bpx8fosDWY/video.html
Yes, I know, answering my own post. Naughty...
I just took a look at the Corsair range of GPU coolers and what I can see they've got at least five models of GPU water blocks, and all of them use the same ports block for the inlet and outlet. Changing the design to use three screws instead of only two would require all of these to be redesigned and retooled, which would be very expensive. If redesigning the ports block to be more rigid, perhaps using a better material, can improve the seal enough it would be much cheaper than a full redesign.
It might seem crass, but when you talk about these things every dollar counts. Yes it's a problem that shouldn't have existed. The design should have been corrected before it went into production, but it wasn't and now it's time for damage control. Besides if it can be addressed without a redesign of the water block then it's possible to retrofit any of the water blocks that's already been sold, and at a relatively low cost.
There has been some quite vicious comments made about Corsair over this weak design. I'd argue that companies doesn't go out of their way to create bad products as that would cost them in a loss of perceived brand value. But they are new to water cooling so they are likely to make some mistakes. With the generally high prices the water cooling market probably looked very tempting, promising high margins if they could achieve large enough manufacturing volume. I suspect the current situation is a result of over enthusiastic money pinching causing the ports block to be made weaker than it was originally planed, and that it might bite them in the ass.
For now I'd suggest anyone looking at buying a water block for their graphics card to look at the other established manufacturers first. If you've already got one from Corsair then keep a close eye at it for now and see if Corsair comes out with some kind of fix. You can of course test putting some force on the ports block on your card and see if it seems likely to develop a leak, but make sure you catch any water that might escape.
I feel Corsair has over valued their brand name this time. Currently these GPU water blocks cost just as much as the corresponding blocks from EK where I shop. But the EK blocks seems to be of a higher quality.
i'm very glad i saw hardware unboxed and your video about this as i was on the fence about buying this block for my 5700 xt which the way i have the soft tubing run on my test bench would provide the exact same torque as is applied in that video. i still might buy that block once they make a v2 or address the issue as all the black/nickel heatkiller blocks are sold out everywhere and i dont see them coming back in stock anytime soon.
Great video and I appareciate your unbiased approach.
You should have watched his first video too, to understand the whole case Jay!
He had some drops on his motherboard and didnt know where they came from!
He didn't even know why major hardware put a map in the video and showed full disrespect to him, i know that most of us won't make our competitor looks good on any possible way but i think there was no need to do such a thing like calling him a "B stream". Also major hardware said that he is a huge fan of corsair.
@@ezequieltamez9318 Pretty good text and I agree with everything you said :)
agree
@@timno9804 I think jay was trying to defend corsair saying something like "if you already got this product/want to buy there is no need to panic just because mr. nobody somehow managed to find a flaw in the design that in a real case scenario would never happend to you" and his 2+ m subscribers wont panic and never buy something from corsair, but the thing is that major hardware as i mentioned is a corsair fan and he isn't even mad because he got a bad product and i think there is no need to shit on him just to make happy your sponsor!
Hey Jay - you mention (at 15:54) that POM and Acetal are "two different types of material". They're NOT. "Acetal" and "POM" are just two different names for the same thing - (polyoxymethylene). Just thought you'd like to know.
As someone who works in the plastics industry, I appreciate this comment! Im glad im not the only one who was thinking this lol
I don't think Jay really knows anything about plastics or manufacturing plastics, from the way he talks.
@@deathnightANIMATED God forbid.
@@River_Miles You would think he knows this having a boosted Chevy, how much reinforcing material matters under pressure.
But he's not got the time for research anymore...
Ha! I love the "done" expression as Jay is already turning away from the camera while saying, "...link is in the description below."
Take it apart like Jay just did and lightly add some silicone/gasket maker around the o-rings then re-tighten the screws. That should get you by until they come up with a better design.
In Major Hardware's initial video (not the one you have pulled up) shows it leaking inside of his case while running under a normal use case.
Yup saw that 2 months back, Jayz just trying to give Corsair a passing saying that "one needs to pull very very hard" ! It freaking doesn't matter!
It leaks and it'a bad design, Period.
Corsair should replace or refund all users.
@@kiranm25x Linus ended up showcasing the leak too without him knowing.
@@kiranm25x i think jay know that and he already said that to corsair and corsair just be like "okay we know that but we won't do anything about it :)"
cause jay just said "that's what happen when you cheap out some component"
@@kiranm25x how is he giving them a pass? He very clearly said that even though they sponsor him you should not buy this product
@@TheMedievalNerd yeah but they fix it tho
Jay I love you, but if you're going to reference someone's video please watch it first. Not only did he propose solutions, but he explains that he originally caught the issue with a card which was installed vertically within a system that dripped. I'm glad to see you giving the issue some more clout though
why does it matter if the other dude gave solutions? are you sour that jay thought of the same things or? not understanding that. and he literally showed him putting the block and a weird angle and it leaking in the video. I truly dont understand why it matters if he watched the entire video or not.
@@izaiahbartley3377 cause Jay says he wants credit for proposing solutions, which major hardware already offered
@@izaiahbartley3377 Because it explains context, as well as Jay, I am assuming sarcastically, claiming he wants credit for the proposed fix, which the other video already mentioned making a more rigid mount or at least adding a third screw. He would also know exactly how it was mounted to cause this, and it wasn't just him twisting the crap out of the fitting, as well he would know this other guy did the same to his EK block already and showed what was going on. He would also know that Corsair was aware of this issue even before this other video and that other viewers directed him to contact Corsair, because they had the same issue. He would also know that Corsair told him that his block would have a fix applied and not that he would just be shipped a like replacement that clearly fixed nothing. It's a 10 minute video Jay could have watched it while on hold with Corsair.
@@izaiahbartley3377 some are "sour" because Jay acted like he solved the whole issue on his own. Plus he referred to Major Hardware or the story as B stream (whatever that is) plus Jay suggested it was run out of spec due to no rad & lastly by saying it wouldn't leak in normal use when video said first fault was in normal use & lastly suggested it was a non story because it required reefing on the card which it clearly didn't.
@@norfolkngood8960 except Jay doesn't act like he solved it on his own. He literally says the problem is pretty obvious (not some genius thing), and on his units you can clearly see it requires reefing on it. Calm down people. Ffs. If tightness of bolts is an issue as well as the lack of a 3rd one, it stands to reason that some bolts might be even less tight than others.
Linus actually covered this by accident 7 months ago in his “I went AMD - Personal Rig Update 2019” video. He tightened it up and leak went away. Not a permanent solution but fixed it for the moment.
Watching you and other channels make so many systems with custom water loops never told me how expensive it would be. I went on EKWB's site and did the math, and it would cost me about 900 Euro to do water-cool my system.
Anything water cooling related I’d go with EK every time. They know what they’re doing.
I watched the original video where his original gpu block was in his system with soft tubing and it was leaking then. Wasnt a stream but it was dripping. This is why he changed to ek water block for his gpu. So they sent him a new one and which isbthe reason for the updated video that you are covering
He was led to believe the new block was a repaired/fixed one.
Corsair generally makes quality products, and they have a great warranty replacement. That being said, after my last Corsair AIO went bad, I went back to air cooling, and haven't really looked back since.
My thoughts on water-cooling: custom or air. No aio I've ever seen maintains thermals and volume as well as an air cooler... I'm no pro but the risk isn't worth it.
Edit *big beefy air cooler*
Corsair AIOs are just Asetek AIOs, which are the worst ones on the market.
it's actually refreshing seeing someone be non toxic on youtube and instead try to help solve the problem bless
Random youtuber- I found this product leaks, even squirts a little
Jayztwocents- let's see how far we can make it squirt
New joint venture - jayztwocents and corsair present- waterblock super soaker, coming this summer
Jay: "Don't look at those numbers!!"
Me: ENHANCE!
kowalski ANALYSIS
FOCUS THERE!
CZcams Compression: No
WE NEED THE EXTRA RESOLUTION!!
I used to work in an industry that uses high pressure high tech hydraulics. There is a o-ring grease under the brand Molykote which is designed to plump out an o-ring by a few microns allowing a better squeeze hence better seal.
This video demonstrates your professionalism. Compliments!!!
Given there will likely be some strain from the tubing when installed in many desktops, especially by people who aren't very careful, I'd say there is still some risk.
Combine the not so tight factory screws with some tension in the system and then add some time and heat cycling and I can def see it weeping eventually.
Overall, like you said they should really improve the design just to be safe. Reducing the O-ring channel depth a bit and adding a third screw would definitely solve.
Also, I realize it's not going to be taken in and out a lot, but adding metal threaded inserts for the screws going into the plastic would really add some strength.
Honestly, if you already have one, then simply do not stretch your tubes so tight, allow a little extra on the tube length and this will be a non-issue
Joshua Bell - It isn’t a non issue. Watch Majors first video on it.
"...add some time and heat cycling..." This, exactly. The "well don't pull so hard on it" is just such a lazy answer. If you are extremely careful to not put *any* load on the tubes, you *might* not have an issue over time. But there's gonna be *some* load on the tubes unless you use some kind of custom setup where that is explicitly taken into account. At that point, it is no longer at the level of robustness you would expect. Especially considering all it takes is one drop of water to fall into the PSU or an electrical connection to cause far more damage than the cost of just using a better EK block.
@@Ughmahedhurtz sure, it needs to be addressed, but for now, just allow extra tubing, like whatever you think it needs, add 2mm. Also, tighten those 2 screws and you should be fine til Corsair comes up with a fix
Hard tubing also can add a lot of strain in tight areas, so I think there is quite a risk with this. Kind of lucky i held off.
That flashback to the exploding pump literally made me spit out my water I laughed so hard.
What vid is that from?
@@Williwillwixxen An absolute classic czcams.com/video/xAMmQy8bdXk/video.html
I noticed a similar issue with my Alphacool acrylic block. During leak testing, when i moved the videocard to mess around with the PCIe riser and put strain on the terminals, it started to leak. As long as i keep the videocard seated, no problem, it has been running for months without a single drop.
The alphacool block is basically 2 acrylic plates pushing an O-ring together by screws. If you put lateral force on it, displacing the O-ring a bit, it might start to drip. Tightening the screws (careful to not crack the acrylic plates) did help somewhat. It doesn't mean anything is defective, but it is something to note if you need to do maintenance on your computer.
Good news, Jay will continue to have huge stacks of free Corsair products next to him for all his future PC builds.
Same thing happened to Linus on his personal rig update 2019 when he was putting in his new x570 aqua
Linus said on Wan show 2020-05-22 that he had no probllems with his block but he was aware that it was built lightly.
I saw that! It leaked a bit right at the same spot, he concluded that it wasn't tightened enough.
He should have watched MajorHardwares 2 videos on the subject, still glad this is getting noticed
Why?
For reference, EK's FC bridge is acetal, and yes it has 3 screws on each block. Never had any problem with that on 10+ machines.
Sir yur videos are really helpful keep it up
Major Hardware is a great little channel, highly recommend.
Absolutely.
Everytime he pulls out the iFixit Kit, Im coming out yelling "IFIX IT" like in his video for it
FYI, I just received an Alphacool GPX-A block for the Powercolor Red Devil and it has three screws through the top as well.
I will say in preparing for my build I found a major issue with an EK radiator. I took it apart to paint the housing and in doing so found the in/out fittings that it comes with were torqued down so tight the O-rings were shredded, and one of the fittings had split the metal in the threads. So yeah, take stuff apart, inspect all the O-rings, ports, fittings, etc. And of course leak test.
Major hardware is a great channel that experiments with lots of stuff, you should link his channel.
Major hardware is amazing. His projects a great for any one who likes fun PC stuff.
+1 yes he is great :)
Good to know he isn't a grifter just looking for cheap views.
I also watch him.
linus had that issue when he first put that block on his RTX titan i think! in one of his recent personal rig videos, i think it's the one titled "I Went AMD" or something along those lines.
lets be honest though Linus messes everything up lol
thereddog223 Which probably makes him more representative of real world users.
I agree this is probably extremely unlikely to be an issue for a buyer in the real world. But, that small chance risks thousands of dollars of hardware (and potentially far more in opportunity costs) and should be a actioned immediately.
Also, to comments that it would be less dramatic in a practical scenario, that is often a greater threat as it just takes a few drops to threaten your system and if there is a leak you want to know about it.
It's even worse that it would drip onto the PSU
@@88porpoise I would not buy this product,but I would buy their aios and cases
Thank you JAY for addressing that. A lot of people where probably on the fence about buying that water block, but like you said you don't really it will be a problem in less people are flexing on the piece. God Bless and stay safe!
The focus from Jay's face to the monitor and Jay again and monitor again was smooth~
What camera did you use? Sony alpha?
No way to sugercoat it, this is a design flaw and they should issue a recall
I think they should go with a different plastic and thicker o-rings for existing owners. They could send out repair kits to them with those new parts, and that should mitigate the issue. I don't think they need a full recall. This waterblock has been out for more than a year and the issue was just now discovered, so it's clearly not physically impacting a huge number of users.
I love Major Hardware, I think his most famous video is where he water cools an air cooler.
I have one of these in my system right now. I have not had a leak, but I hope they do a recall to all the current owners of this waterblock as this is clearly a design flaw. Thanks for the video!
So glad I saw this before purchasing. Will now wait until this is resolved.
I'm glad you guys are aware of this guy. He's really good.
The German channel igors lab talked about that issue already in his review a year ago. Unfortunately the video is in german. czcams.com/video/mpoP6-LfwyQ/video.html Maybe automatic translation works on that.
In his video he says, that he talked to corsair and that they were planning to change the manufacturing procedure to make it stronger.
Thanks for this
Well they didn't change anything, did they? Why do manufacturers need to be forced and shamed like this for any action to be taken?
@@parthgajjar1607 Design and manufacturing takes time it's not something they can just do in a day if they need to redisign it then they'll have to test it and make sure it's fine then make them and get them shipped shipping from china can take 6months alone lol
@@ry22
dawg it doesn't take a year to screw in another screw in the middle or use bigger o-rings
@@ry22 It wouldn´t take 6 Month to ship stuff from China to Europe or USA. They send me a case out of China directly within 2 Days. Yes it would be expensive, but a Container on a Ship with THOUSANDS of these Blocks would be here in like 3 Weeks, at most. Tooling and co would take some time, but tbh, the fix is simple and easy to accomplish, even in Massproduction. Around 8 Month are gone by now and they did nothing at all. Now they get a f*cking shitstorm and in my Opinion they deserve it right in their face. Only Had Problems with Corsair the Last year, with multiple AIOs and Stuff. RAM is good tho, but they dont Produce that themselve, just the Design. Even Keyboards are somewhat shit. That Text is written on my MK2 Strafe, with its wobbly Spacebar. For around 150 Bucks thats really bad. But i like it enough to keep it.
I respect the discretion at the start and honest review
At my company one of the QA tasks for our power modules is to just start grabbing wires near connectors and pulling on them. If they come out they are replaced. If they stay in they are good.
If you assume that if you can break it with no special, tools the customer can. You either place a warning or redesign it.
That was the *second* video Major Hardware did about this issue
Jay, you made it seem like Major Hardware only happened to find this huge flaw by applying force manually; when his videos clearly state that he noticed it dripping under *normal use;* that's an important distinction that makes it a non-viable product. It needs to be taken off the shelves, not just avoided by people who managed to catch this story online.
Well, Jay also stated that he doesn’t know who he is, and didn’t watch any of his other videos.
@@mikeycrackson he is a review channel not I'm gonna test everything to it's maximum potential till I find a flaws kinds of channel
@@NoName-st2jl don't be silly this is an important news for a customer and he should be testing for leaks as it could DESTROY your system.
@@mikeycrackson He is not really a review channel he is a promotional channel, it is his job to say the product is fine.
@@dest1037 so you're saying that he needs to spend months testing that think so that he could say there's a leak yeah no
IFixit ordered. Glad to support the channel
Thanks for the heads up. Cool video 👍
Major hardware is a legend
I've never heard about him/the channel. 🤫
Never heard either but someone should open a channel called major software and do a collab
I thought you had to be dead before achieving legend status?
@@DanielFrost79 same here
@@MajorHardware hahahah, you really are amazing. I actually found you when you water-cooled the air-cooler, I remember downloading your video and watching it on the bus home, I was very impressed it :)
I wish they would’ve watched both videos of his to see what’s going on.
Here's what happened... his ignorance got in the way.
Yeah, I enjoy Jay's content but sometimes he can act like a big man baby and a know-it-all which is off putting. And I got a bit of a condescending tone when he was referring to the other channel. His ego can really go to his head sometimes. Love the content, just wish he would work on these things.
@@post-leftluddite Not to mention he tells people not to worry if the have one installed and to leave it in. Wow. Put it this way, let's say you were going to buy this exact cooler and then before you pay for it someone tells you it might leak if the tubing is bent the wrong way but it probably won't happen. Would you still buy it? Hell no you wouldn't. You'd be thinking "I don't want any amount of water anywhere inside my PC I don't care WHAT the probability." Right?
But yeah, Jay says it's probably nothing, leave it in. Ok, I'll pass on the coolaid, thanks.
Jay: "This hard squirt... *long pause*"
Me: Pbbbbbt bwahahaaahaa... I'm a terrible person.
The EK uses a big chunky black monolith of a manifold that is next to impossible to bend, the Corsair had a nice cost-saving injection molded part, and the part itself is warping because the flange is thin compared to the leverage the tall part gives you. Given how loose those screws appeared to be, a dribble forming after a bit of thermal cycling, and a bit of deformation in the plastic from a static load by tubing being overly tight, wouldn't be surprising.
i remember linus had a small problem with it to.
Yeah, he tightened it really tight...
Did he drop it?
David Poole
Most likely.
watch major hardwware frist vid his was leaking in his system
thats how he found out
I have a Bykski block. The IO on it is one solid chunk of acrylic and a fairly beef ridden O-ring. It's a good boi.
Just remember, when you really tighten into acrylic, it will form stress fractures over time. Really crank down on those screws like you did, and it *will* crack eventually.
I've seen at least 4 videos in which these blocks leak, including Linus's, in which he puts one in his personal build. I hope he swaps this out
Like Jay said, it IS an issue that needs to be fixed, BUT it shouldnt rly concern people that use this block in a completely normal way.
@@LuxLikeGaming I can't agree more, you're using it wrong is never an excuse. With that mentality, you should get an Apple computer.
LuxLikeGaming - Watch Majors first video on it. It was used normally in a system and was leaking on its own.
@@tacticalcenter8658 Why? I said it right there: It needs to be fixed asap and you if you're concerned about it dont buy it, BUT if you already have one in your system you dont need to worry to much if you're using it properly.
there is a chance that jay got a bit better unit(qc) or it needs serious normal usage to get worse?
I feel like Jay did not watch both Major Hardware's videos, or at least he just saw the squirting and called it a day.
all we wanna see is the squirting
I think it's pretty clear that Jay was trying to mitigate damage to his sponsor, and was willing to discredit Major Hardware and trivialize the issue to do so. He should have listened to his own statements about integrity.
@@post-leftluddite I mean its already a solution done by another company, so in reality, it was neither of their ideas. Also why does it matter in either case, just drama for drama...
I am the wife... I am watching... and I want the iFixIt kit for me, not my husband XD
same lol, it always bugs me when techtubers say that
OmiKnight ditto
Same! I need an ifixit for mothers day...
Jay, If they go to a thicker oring, they will need wider groves and it may mean it doesn't seal in the center as the wings on the fitting block don't look very stiff. There are tables for this stuff and it's pretty normal industry stuff. Not something i do every day though. A potential fix would be to add gussets to the "wings" so that they can load the center better.
PLS rename the video in "Is this a major hardware design flaw... or a non issue? Testing Corsair Block Leaks" xD
Why..? The title is perfectly accurate. This is a total non-issue, it will never leak in normal or even severe use... You have to intentionally abuse the cooler to cause a leak. If you are applying pressure to the block in the way that causes the parts to separate that's a user issue..
@@StrengthFromGiving Psst... Major Hardware is the guy who made the leakage video
PinHookEast you didn’t get the joke. And no, this is definitely not a non-issue.
Yeah, this is totally NOT a non-issue. Corsair fucked this up good. See how weak that tube block is constructed! Even though in normal use you might never bend it so hard, the design is still bullshit. It can not really even be accounted to trying to save on costs, no, it is just fucked up design, I would fire the one responsible.
PinHookEast if you would’ve seen the first video you would know that it did leak without apply pressure like this in the guys actual system.
I'm glad Major Hardware's channel is going to get some exposure from this, he does some whacky and fun stuff with a 3D printer. I've been subbed since he watercooled a CPU heat spreader.
Jay should have given him a hyperlink for his Journalistic findings kinda like sources sited page
@@fredmortensen5107 Jay came across rather snobbish about the whole thing imho which might be wrong but just my personal view.
@@norfolkngood8960 Agreed, Jay did seem exactly like that
@@norfolkngood8960 Yeah Jay obviously didn't actually watch his video otherwise he would've given Major Hardware the respect he deserved. This is what happens when you're more invested in your own ego than addressing your "loyal" audience's concerns.
That clip it it blowing up then ahhh!!! Priceless!!
I love how few research you do.... major hardware showed how it was when it was installed in a system.
Jay showing how little he looks into things when it comes to the ones giving him free toys.