Making a Perpetuum Mobile for april fools day
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 03. 2020
- Want to support The Practical Engineer? Get exclusive BTS and extra content:
/ thepracticalengineer
For more projects, build plans and other stuff:
www.thepracticalengineer.com
Check out the gear I use and recommend here: kit.co/ThePracticalEngineer
Also check out my other social media:
Instagram: / thepracticalengineer
Facebook: / emielthepracticalengineer
Twitter: / prctclengineer
Pinterest: / practicalengineer - Jak na to + styl
Bedankt voor het kijken! Dit was uiteraard een 1 april video. ;)
Thanks for watching! For those watching it later than yesterday (april first..) this was clearly an april fools video. Hope you enjoyed it.
Are you german?
Movie Kenoma.
@@jackplayer7953 No i think this is Dutch.
(im from Germany and thats not German. Im pretty sure that it is Dutch)
Dutch sounds like mixing German with a swiss accent with english.And maybe a little bit of Low German.
@@neutronenstern. ich bin Schweitzer und habe mich grade auch gefragt was er spricht😂 ich glaube es ist schwedisch😅
Oeh tijd voor een nieuw zaagblad op die cirkelzaag...
Quite a degree of workmanship in manufacturing this conversation article. I am jealous of all the neat tools that you possess and you obviously know how to use them. Well done.
There was a bar in San Francisco in early XX century, and there was a giant wheel that kept spinning seemingly forever, until there was a power outage
haha nice
Could have got away with it if they had battery back up.
But it wasn't a perpetuum mobile since it used energy
Here, in Spain, all bars have perpetual mouvements too :
people come and go to get drunk always and always and always ...
And this has been going on for centuries!
@@joesphjoeastar6024 its almost like thats the whole point
This was an extremely nice piece of work, thanks for sharing.
TPE: "No one will notice."
Motor: zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh zzzzzuh
DID YOU SEE THE DATE - -HAHAAA
Exactly Matt 😆. That is was I thought.
@@micharebuz2542 I don't know if I should r/w- you.
@@diaarmy6.9ksoongemsandshit21 yeah definitely
lets do it
Good craftsmanship! People have been trying to make a perpetual motion machine for centuries. Of course they don’t work but it is a mind bender!
I've seen a perpetual motion machine in action. It was a lawyer in a divorce case.
Haha but maybe motion is the wrong word, perpetual bowl movement machine, maybe?
Beautiful build, geat video. Your design has an obvious flaw. The corve of the spokes on the wheel are not quitte right.
The objective is to get the balls being moved up close to the axis before the balls falling to power the wheel begin falling at the circumference (for maximum leverage) The conservation of momentum calculation promises it will be self-powered REALLY. Tweak the curve slightly. Worst case design a segmented spoke that can add the momentum of the balls falling to fall (and be held on the spoke) at a larger radius than the returning balls can go on their ride up to the top. (I've seen ghis work with bottles partially filled using the sloshing liquids power the wheel successfully. The bottles were attached to the wheel with elastics that pulled them to the circumference at the bottom of the wheel, but could not hold them there as they crossed the top. Party on Dude, be good to each other (Think of spinning ice skaters that accelerate just by pulling their arms in... same physics apply here.
$90 to answer one email from mine. And of course, his address was 'hotmail', because it's free.
@@mundymorningreport3137 you need to learn like 1st-grade level physics. you're talking nonsense about something you know nothing about, posing like you are teaching him something 😑😑
@@mundymorningreport3137 Jesus... little bro, there. is. no. such. thing. as. a. perpetual. motion. machine. Never going to work "FOR REAL". That's why it says "April Fool's" & why he put an electric motor in.
I was about ten years old when I saw one at Ripley’s “believe it or not” museum in NYC. I believed it actually worked although my father was not convinced. Dad was right.
I was about the same age, or maybe a bit older and I saw one in a Dutch electronics magazine. I also believed it could work and my physics teacher mr Stuijvenberg had a hard time convincing me otherwise, concerning losses of energy...
Looks fantastic - nice work. I love checking out these so-called perpetual motion videos on CZcams. It also looks like you have the same poorly designed drill as me. The one where the light shines everywhere except on the screw or hole you are attempting to work on. (Milwaukee brand here in the U.S.)
Very well done, would love to have only a quarter of the tools that you have
hammer, screwdriver and sandpaper coming up :) oh not THAT quarter? :)
Am amazed by the plotter drill, what can cut geometric shapes.
Incredible workshop. Must be a pleasure to work (play) in. 👍🏻
Спасибо автору за то, что не стал обманывать доверчивых зрителей, на голубом глазу доказывая, что оно крутится само, без внешнего влияния. За это, конечно же, лайк!
он и так поимел.я не смотрел
Fantastic work !!! Greetings from Brasil !!! 😃👊🏻🇧🇷
Als je met dit techniek stroom kan wekken voor zoveel huishoudens is het fantastisch! Windmolens en met dit systeem geweldig!
Oeh, zonnepanelen er op nog en dan zijn we binnen!
Thanks for the video. You have a nice little shop and you have very good workmanship.
I was about to post an "angry engineer" comment when I realized the date...
GOOD ONE!!!
😂😂😂
Haha, it definitely triggers something with a lot of people
I pity the fool
5:04 you can hear the motor "screaming"
So buy a quiet one!
Classic!! Great prank forcing the perpetual motion machine to turn the wrong way using a hidden motor. Spot on mate.
Nur mit solchen Maschinen kann man ein perpetuum mobile herstellen !
Ich hab es schon immer gewußt.
I like how his intro is like an earape sound
Hi, I noticed the Perpetuum Mobile project and I find it interesting. I wanted to ask if you can make one and how much it could cost including shipping. Thank you.
This is so cool. A great way to put your mind into think mode. Watch and listen to this thing and I bet you’ll figure out what ever you trying to do. How do I get one. Great video mate.
"Leonardo da Vinci worked on it..." Yes, he pointed the perperuum mobile is impossible.
y tenia razon , no toma en cuenta el rozamient que en algun momento detendra el movimiento
Did he point out it was impossible? That is way beyond the physics at that time, when even energy conservation was unknown. I know he designed a few. I infer that he may have had some doubts, but doesn't seem to have been convinced either way.
Some info: www.openculture.com/2019/08/leonardo-da-vincis-elegant-design-for-a-perpetual-motion-machine.html
So do you have a source that he thought it was impossible? I would be interested to learn more about that.
@@landsgevaer You are right, he didn't really point it in scientific way.
But Leonardo didn't believe the perpetuum mobile is possible.
@@JuhaK71 Do you have a source? I looked a bit further and most of what I read suggests either that Da Vinci wasn't sure whether it could be done, or that we aren't sure what Da Vinci thought on the matter. He certainly presented ideas going both ways; i.e. he debunked some perpetuum mobile but designed some other.
E.g. on www.lockhaven.edu/~dsimanek/museum/people/people.htm : "We often can't determine whether a particular device included in his notebooks was of his own design, or of someone else, and we can't always know whether Leonardo considered it workable or practical."
There's no perpetual motion, but there is free energy: the sun and the wind and rivers flowing downhill, to mention just three.
Nadie te pregunto flaco, por que no te callas la boca😆
There actually is perpetual motion because light will travel for ever without diminishing its energy.
@@elliottdiedrich2123
Not quite true: Due to the expansion of the universe and the resulting red shift, the wavelength of a photon increases, and its frequency and energy diminish. It will travel forever but it loses energy as space expands. More significantly, the usual meaning of a perpetual motion machine is one from which you can extract energy forever. This does not exist and cannot exist. But the sun will continue to send us energy for free for few more billion years and so for practical purposes we can consider it as free energy forever.
don't forget flatulence :) an endless supply of greenhouse (and other more noxious) gases
Excellent workmanship and workshop.
Super cool project man - I could watch that thing go for hours!
I think his idea is good but the method is wrong.
czcams.com/video/KBxGdt9ev7M/video.html
Ancient free energy device.
This is the method from 3000Bc.
Our Ancient civilization create amazing structures using this method
damn! Now my suggestions will be filled with Dutch language content!
Hey emiel I love this it’s so cool looking and I know I’ve said it before but I really miss the English vids 😔
Hey Dave, Sorry again :)
The Practical Engineer it’s ok mate who knows I might start speaking Dutch if I keep watching 😝
I understand and support you switching to Dutch. I just can’t read as fast as you speak Dutch. 🙃
Excellent love it! As a kid I tried and tried... then grew up - learned a lot more about physics...Accepted reality - and its great - we have wind water sun - near perpetual - happy days - and now Im annoyed with all the fake P_M machines on YT... This hits the spot nicely! Thanx!
I read in 11th class in one of the physics chapter about perpetual motion. That was made using water storage. But scientist found something, still energy is being lost through heating up ball-bearing and gear housing
I have done some woodworks in the past but this woodwork plan czcams.com/users/postUgkxZF0EMnrujZvqHhGkxiz559uIABJWR9TG helps me do much in a far lesser time than i used to do i have already built several projects with this plan and i intend to do many more soon. Thank you so much!
With what?
Nobody would notice...if they didn't hear the comically loud motor noise
I too heard it.... Maybe it is some drilling in background
If you do a CZcams search for perpetual motion machines, you will find lots of silent videos!
I thought I was having a stroke, but he just wasn't speaking English 😂
same lol
Obrigada por mostrar como se faz
É muito interessante essa peça,, para quem tem as ferramentas certas e puder faze-la.
Bravo, Bravissimo, complimenti! hai dimostrato il teorema della curvatura dello Spazio e che la curvatura genera movimento nelle Masse, ovvero il Motore immoto. Ti meriteresti Il Nobel per la Fisica classica !
Joseph ,da Torino/Italia
il 2 ottobre 2020.
Even though it's fake, it's still engineer meeting art!!
Thanks!
Отличная мастерская!!!
Lots of fun to watch. What is the model number of the CARBIDE 3D CNC router?
I would have another extension, idea for the perpetual motion machine, and now you only need a copper spiral, and a battery with magnets at both ends to then create magnetic fields running in an inner and an outer rail both left and right, since you have used steel balls I assume that it could then run on its own , even without engine or with a bit of expansion you could charge the engine, unfortunately have not understood everything because I come from Germany! But it's great that someone shows how easy it can be if you have the right machine for it, that's Cool!! Special thanks to you! Please stay healthy, best regards from Hellgate !
Haha! I’ve wanted to build one of those for a long time, just to see if I could make it work. You fooled me!! I thought you actually figured it out. Lol!
Works by Solo bruh
Elon Tusk I guess I need more sleep or more coffee... or both. :-)
Only in first year of engineering you can neglect friction and air resistance..
You solved the worlds energy problem in 5:36 seconds , amazing
Eeeee, what about thermodynamic laws?
Sir hi. I saw your solenoid engine video and was thinking can a liter class engine be created with that mech ? Or at least a 100cc
Awesome Job.
Oddly, even though I don't understand Dutch, I get the gist of what is being done & I'm gonna keep watching Emeil's videos.
Thanks! I'm happy to hear that you'll keep watching :)
Educational and Hilarious! Thanks you for this Funny Video :)
Thank you for this
hilarious and funNy comment 1
LIKED and subsicred
I think your wheel is spinning in the opposite direction of the intended design.
Leo is that you !! :P
Same opinion. First thing I thought of was that the wheel should go the other way.
So it _could_ work!
He only implemented it wrong.
Hey Badmuts, 5 minuten van mn tijd weggegooid. Thanks!
Love your workshop!!!
Looks at date...
Listens to motor whiring 😏
Knows it's gonna be good
If you have read the laws of thermodynamics, you also know that there is no endless energy.
If only solving the world's energy problems were this simple.
@@coltonhaynie6174 You're right, brother, I think we should do with devices that use less energy, not infinite energy.
Ya I agree with you friends..
THE answer is in our Ancient civilization. They know how to create free energy.
czcams.com/video/KBxGdt9ev7M/video.html
Their is a link I given above.
It's about Ancient civilization free energy device. Because of this, they created amazing structures like Kilasa Temple, Ellora caves and the Great Pyramid etc.
Nicholas Tesla once said "No free energy device will not available in market because of Corporate power company's".
It's a nice piece of woodwork.
It would be good hooked up to a solar panel as a decoration.
Hi, cool video & perpetual build! Have you considered using magnetism instead of a motor? I believe there would be a way to construct alternating magnet currents to push/pull the wheel - the metal balls could even come in to play to help with this effort. I have not thought about it long enough to conceptualize a final design though have some ideas from watching your video.
@Maxx Kroes Unless the magnet(s) is/are used to power a mini generator that could then power the motor(or use this idea in conjunction to come up with a design).
Here's a link to one that I found here on YT:
czcams.com/video/TYhJwF-H3sY/video.html
Let me know your thoughts?
Best prank ever! Thanks Emil! :D
Glad you like it :)
I was watching this at 4 am in my store room , just not make any sound.
Well done, but please I'm very interested in finding ideas to generate electricity or to have perpetual rotation
In love with your tools 🛠
Someone needs to figure out a way to make one of these turn a generator lol.
It's easy, all you need is a gas engine and a belt.
I'll get right on it... give me about 20 years.
@Tim haha!
Tim Hallas lol or a steam turbine.
And THAT would be the concept of the perpetuum! And to pull it off it does not need any actual force to be used and it needs to go endlessly, at a very faste amount of rotations per minute. And that is the problem. There is no everlasting friction that keeps the machine moving.
thanks for the recommendation CZcams, I have no idea what he's saying.
i thought (I) was tripping. *beeep you youtube
I speak 3 fuckin' languages and I can't understand hum. So... Thanks yt
@@roxelhearts3916 its Dutch lol
He's speaking the ugliest language in the world.
hey ,are there ads of rise of kingdoms in other countries?
(I'm in turkey)
Hello !! The work you do is wonderful
The things you can create when you have the right tools.
The right mindset
The right mindset and tools. :-)
No, not free energy. It's a open system.
It's clearly receiving external power for your enthusiasm. 😁
haha that must be it 😂
Wow.. I will try to make one. if we add gear between motor and wheel. Will it help.. 😄👍🏼
What an idea! But how long it useful?
What's German for "In this house we obey the laws of thermodynamics"?
That's universal language 😉
„In diesem Haus halten wir uns an die Gesetze der Thermodynamik.“
But in this case you need dutch:
„In dit huis houden we ons aan de wetten van de thermodynamica.“
He's not German he's dutch
april fools
haha, april fools indeed. I'm still honest ;)
Nicely done Emiel! 😃👍🏻👊🏻
Inteligente hábil y atractivo... Todo lo que se quiere en esta vida. ❤️
April fool!
:)
Not gonna lie it’s not super convincing because you could hear the motor and the balls don’t really look like they’re actually powering the wheel
I know, I could have spend a week trying to make it look more natural, but I think it would have added very little to the project. After the video I took the motor out anyway because i like it better if you can turn it by hand.
Hope you stil enjoyed the video.
The Practical Engineer I think that maybe speeding the motor up a bit would have helped, but yeah great video I did enjoy it =)
Don't you know? it's NOT a motor, it's a generator. You have to be able to turn the free energy into electricity, so you can solve the world's energy problem! 😆🤣😁
The main reason why it’s not convincing is because it is spinning in the opposite way. If you reverse the direction it will look a lot more natural.
mooi gedaan. leuk voor op een school!
Maar kun je de opgaande kan waar de kogel weer naar de as moet rollen ook recht maken? dan rolt de knikker beter naar het midden. en lijkt het nog beter.
En wat betreft het frezen. beperk de uitsteeklengte van de frees. dan kun je er iets meer voor zetten. en anders wordt het resultaat nog mooier.
Thanks voor de freestips! Ik heb er inmiddels een hoop over bijgeleerd. Volgende keer pak ik ook acrylaat ipv PC dat is ook wat fijner frezen
Tools that everybody has in house 😂 . Good job, Very nice video. Thanks!
With basic tools ;)
Не хилый фрезер у парнишки! Вот было бы здорово, если бы он ещё и русский выучил.
Краще український
@@user-bb7vx9ww9u пусть оба учит.
😃😁😁
На голландском что ли говорит?
No one will notice, if they’re deaf 😂
I can't lipread Dutch. Spanish, English and French yes, but not Dutch or German.
@@SimonJones49 i think he meant was the noise from the motor. It was whirring.
THE DATE - -HAHAA
Nice workshop!
Great april fools video!
Keep it up man.
Greetings from Friesland
Hey, goed om te horen. Groeten terug!
This makes me so uncomfortable. I feel like I should understand what you're saying but I don't
Use captions
Парень рукастый, но мы физику знаем хорошо, и нас не нае.ёшь.
Ну, дык он честно показывает, что этот сувенир с моторчиком внутри)))
hello good evening , geat job ,i will like to know ,how can i get the design plans
or how much do you charge me let me know
thanks
That's a great little shop you have
Блин, какие у него ахуенные станки, респект! ! !
You'll never get back the same amount of energy you put in, something's are just impossible. I know it's a prank..
Some countries, like The Netherlands where this video sprang from, have a national prank day on April 1st. Newspapers, 8pm news, everybody tries to prank on that day. And when naive people have demonstrated to believe the prank, we comment on that saying "1 April".
In the US, this is called April Fool's (Day) and as you could read, is part of the title - there, it's paired with similar "celebration".
Thanks for the detailed explanation on april fools day. Judging by the comments most people don't even read the whole title to realise it is a joke.. :)
maar op de hoogte van de as moot je een grote maneet zetten zo gaan die stalen ballen naar die magneet toe en da valle ze naar beneden ,je moet alleen de afstand zoeken , zo goed dat hij goed draait tot kijk
Nice piece with a twist at the end 👍
So weird/funny to hear german and english at some parts when he speaked.
It's not German, it's Dutch.
@@PaulJosephdeWerk but after all Dutch is pretty similar to German, especially the Plattdütsch dialect from northern germany.
Yeah, as a Dutch person it's fairly easy to understand German (but don't tell them ;) )
@@Thepracticalengineer das wissen wir eh.
Amazing work, although I understood none of you spoken word, your engineering came through just fine.!!
Here is a question what if you made 5 wheel's or 6 and offset them. Would that give it a longer run time if it was not ran by a motor
Well, he seems to do it putting a pinch of fun on it, but in the end his skills end up stoling the show here.. 👏🏻
Gracias desde Colombia , podría incluir traducción al español así sea subtitulos??
Porque no entendí , porque le pone cables o para que esas entradas eléctricas. Bendiciones.
Mooi dingetje.
En de denkfout bij dit ontwerp is dat er aan de dalende (rechterzijde) minder kogels zijn dan bij de omhooggaande (links) kogels. De afstand (arm) is wel groter, maar het gewicht (massa) is kleiner.
Ik denk dat je op 0 uitkom als je van alle kogels het koppel gaat uitrekenen.
En dan is het gewicht van de kogels niet precies gelijk en het kogellager kost energie. Dus inderdaad onmogelijk.
als je het uitrekent kom je inderdaad exact op 0 uit als je de wrijving niet meeneemt, alles wat naar beneden gaat moet ook weer omhoog. Maar het was zeker een leuke voor 1 april 😅
Would you please send me where I can obtain the plans for this? Thanks.
I love drillpresses. Yeah, sanding is. The trick and ball bearings, nice
I love that computer controlled router.
As a second generation engineer, I’ll repeat my father’s quote...Nothing is Free!
Nice project!! 🤠
Oh, if it's not a perpetual motion machine, it's wonderful, great work.
Wie Schönheit ist es dir zuzuhören und sogar zu verstehen!
Excellent! well done.
¡¡Con esas herramientas, claro que se hacen maravillas!!
Hi, a really nice video. Just found you on CZcams and you are the first dutch woodworker. So I directly subscribed to your channel. Best wishes. Peter
Nice! Thanks Peter! Are you Dutch too?
Not directly, but indirectly. My father was born and living in Rotterdam. As a child I was very often in Rotterdam with my grandparents. And I still have contact to few persons of my family there. But more of that I love to stay on vacation there, mainly near the sea. When we all are safe (about Corona) I will be in Alkmaar first week of August. Let’s hope... Anyway I will follow your channel now as I am really impressed what you are showing and about your 100 k subscribers. Really really good. All the best. Peter
Tim Taylor would love your shop!!!