Can A Perpetual Motion Wheel Actually Work?
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 01. 2020
- follow me on instagram: @therealtylertube
you can get merch here : teespring.com/stores/tyler-tube
podcast: / tylerungluedpo. .
Podcast clips / tylerungluedclips
join the discord: / discord
editor, harrison : / harrisando
My equipment
Main camera : amzn.to/2ofDDJF
second camera amzn.to/2TE0KMt
third camera : amzn.to/2Nt9mlC
The mic i use : amzn.to/2BZrAcO
The tripod i use : amzn.to/2LuaGCF - Zábava
This is obviously a joke people. He's not an idiot
Yeah no he really doesn't know any better
BadW01f 2 or when he dumped bleach into aluminum pans. Or drano into aluminum pans
He really is an idiot.
Coma White hasn’t the myth busters almost set things on fire multiple times despite being scientific geniuses
Aye congrats on being a pinned comment! *tyler likes this very much*
Your a little late, they patched this bug when people kept using it for infinite electricity.
Yea, that was the same patch that allowed people to tape cats and buttered toast together for a super engine.
BTW: That was a great energy drink commercial. Look up Flying Horse - Gatorrada (Cat-Toast) if you don't know what I'm talking about.
This comment made me laugh out loud for real
You saved a lot of people a lot of typing with this
I found another way and it still works in the V1.10.1 version and I won't tell anyone because they will patch this again
Lol
I think they patched it in the last update
Yeah probably
@@masondougherty7412 yes
yes the developers said there was a bug so they confirmed a patch
No, it was in the day one patch.
Bruh
Instead of poking fun and saying how it wouldn't work, you built it and actually tried it out, much respect to you sir well done.
Thanks for making this. Just what I was looking for to help debunk!!!! Need more perpetual motion trials for other gizmos.
This channel is like if SmarterEveryDay didnt go to college and instead made moonshine in his garage
dropatrain 😂😂
Exacly i love it
He roughly understands the scientific method
But hey, it's enough for youtube
I’m glad I read a few more comments... I was about to say the exact same thing... 👍🏼
That’s not even an insult lol
The reason it didn't work is, you forgot to fit the hidden electric motor.
And the magnets
Lmao yes
Krakka Jakk711 magnets?
Or the guy in the greenscreen suit spinning the wheel
@@jakkakasunset5485 electric motors work from magnets
I'm glad I looked up perpetual motion today, I found 2 channels I seem to enjoy, you being one of them
Your attitude is as adorable as your beard. There's nothing wrong with laymen science stuff as long as you're honest! Keep on truckin'!
Even if the premise behind the idea made any sense, the friction in the axle of the wheel would mean that energy would continue being lost as the wheel turns until there isn't any energy left in the system.
Also loss of energy due to the turbulence of the water.
What if the axle was somehow suspended a maglif system thus eliminating friction and instead of water the use of something solid
The wheel would encounter air resistance as well so it would also need to be in a vacuum.
@@shaunorafferty5930 there's also resistance in the magnetic fields causing for energy loss. Far less resistance than physical contact, but still there
It's because the water creating the same amount of force when it goes back to the original position so three two forces cancel eachother
“ThEsE hAvE tO bE ExAcT”
The bottles: . . . .. .
😂
The zip ties lol
My chromosones be like
I came to the comments as soon as I noticed two bottles were oddly close together and nobody has really said anything
Take timeout to understand some more about counterweight, laws of the fulcrum, size of the wheel, laws of the moving fluid, and so on and so forth
You've inspired me to make my own perpetual motion machine. Thanks bud!
And, did it work??😅
TRy with 8 bottles
Funny video. You've been one of my favourite CZcamsrs for years and I've recently started messing around and thinking about these concepts too. I know this wasn't meant to be serious but if you pause the vid at 10:25 you can see that 2 250g bottles are trying to lift 5 250g bottles & some weight of the wheel. The only ones pushing the wheel up would be middle and top one on the right. For this to have any chance of working you need to make the angle of bottles more rounded and matching the surface of the wheel so more bottles can push in the direction the wheel wants to move, as u can tell by looking at the bottom/left bottles they just push down and bring the wheel to a stop.
A good way to do this would be to get a tube or clear hose, fill it with water and create chambers in the tube or hose for water to splash back and forward to create momentum around the wheel. Maybe you could offset the weights too so when a 500g is pushing down it's lifting 250 then another 250g then when the 2 250gs rotate and start pushing down that will lift the 500g up. You'd have to calculate the mass, momentum and include external forces like the mass and momentum of wheel/other bottles to make sure water can keep up. The basic idea of this machine is there's always more pushing and always is overpowering the pulling side.
Pushing and pulling is based on the rotatation.
Anyways, that's my input for your future videos and anyone thinking about having fun with these ideas. It'll be fun seeing you mess around with this stuff and doing experiments just for fun, not to be serious. That's how you end up learning and finding hidden gems, by not being so serious.
The same amount of energy you get from the water moving is lost when the water moves again trying to go up
Yes, but it doesn't work because energy is lost to heat because of friction
@@thatcherbuck yeah but that's one of the reasons
@@johnnyd4827 yea, that's what I'm saying
@@thatcherbuck yeah yeah I just can't see what I'm writing cuz it's like 00:33 where I live and I dont understand a fuck😂
yep
This wasn't a fail at all! It was a success, at providing the expected results of a repeatable experiment. Props to you for being so humble and transparent!
@Just A Dude With A Mustache really
Translation to Red Foreman English ... WAY TO GO DUMB ASS!
@@jasonlangstraat3385 💉💊🥴
1. Not enough bottles.
2. Not enough water in the bottles.
@@TheVirginGaryLovingDemocrats
He needed to
1. balance the wheel, and
2. fill the bottles with a substance with a corn syrup consistency, to help with the momentum.
I got mine to work after doing these steps ;)
everything about this video makes physics majors want to cry
It shouldn't. This is a video of a guy testing, honestly, the validity of videos that he had seen.
He tested it with his initial materials and decided to remove some of the fluid when it didn't work. He tried rotating the wheel in both directions, and he tried manually spinning the wheel at varying speeds. Then he removed the wheel and tested it.
I would say that for a person who has nothing to do with physics as a course study he performed his experiment entirely satisfactorily.
gj tyler, it worked as expected. thank you for the co.edy factor!
Tyler: **Tries to create something that has been proven over 1000s of years to be impossible**
Also Tyler: **is surprised when it doesn't work**
Nothing is impossible but this is near I'm sure friction is the problem with these
Many things are impossible.
Anything's possible if you kludge hard enough.
Im pretty sure with all the gas, chemicals and other brain cell killers he has poured, spilled, blew up, left stuff sitting in has really jacked his IQ up a bit lol still love his channel tho
No no no this is actually very possible he just forgot to put little rockets on the bottoms on the bottles 🤣🤣🤣
Perpetual motion machine: Doesn’t exist
Tyler: Physics mumbo jumbo 😂
I think they do exist... they just don't work :)
Lolol
Fred Smith but that is inside the influence of gravity
Just think about all the forces at play and you will get an idea as to why it cannot do what you want it to. The main issue is you don't think about the friction the wheel has to deal with as it spins, that is wasted energy. Furthermore, whenever water is going down, the wheel is also raising the water on the other side which counters the force you put in. I am sure there is more to this so please correct if I am wrong.
Great job and thank you for the step by step! I need step by step!
“Lisa, in this house we obey the laws of thermodynamics”!
Exactly the scene I was thinking of when I watched this
@@kiwitsu6717 me too
@@kiwitsu6717 same
Can a perpetual motion wheel actually work?
Short answer: NO.
Long answer: This video
Thesnakerox theoretically yes in perfect conditions using a vacuum to negate air resistance and electromagnets to suspend the wheel with ho physical contact negating friction in the system
@@davidp1838 but to do this you need even more energy. Impossible
Let's Cat it’s been done in The Benjamin Franklin museum in Philadelphia they have a pendulum where it moves so little that friction is negligible and also it is affected by the earth rotation and gravity therefore it will never stop unless out current understanding of the laws of physics is wrong then we will learn something from it and adjust out current understanding
Let's Cat you should look into it it’s really interesting
@@davidp1838 i meant that IT isnt possible to generate Energy from nothing. In the Benjamin Franklin Museum they might be using Energy to generate these conditions, for me this isnt much different than using a simple Motor..
Best part was you spinning the wheel with your fingers on the spokes. That resistance you were feeling was friction and the reason it will never work. Great job on the vid!!
This is very real.Plus if you use larger bottles, it increases distance of the liquid from the center.
"Bearded dude overcomes laws of physics, gets likes on CZcams"
And you get them in comments haha
well for one its not overcoming laws of physics, its literally a law of physics. secondly he didnt overcome it because he doesnt realize how precise you actually need to be to make this happen, itll never work with an old bicycle wheel and zipties. thirdly he didnt get a like
Kable you, my friend, just so happened to earn my like. But that’s about it on the likes from me.
@@KableTac it'll never work in the first place.(watch ted-ed)
Perpetual motion isn't impossible. My girl hasn't stopped talking since I met her.
That's perpetual commotion
She will one day though ;)
DrJustinable Yea, you’re right we need to silence her immediately 🔫 a
She’ll shut up when she has no brain function.
She is also probably still eating, right? 😂
Dude you are hilarious. Perpetual motion is something humans have been trying to figure out for probably thousands of years and here you are in your garage getting annoyed after an hour or so. Man this is great stuff. Love your channel dude, you are a very cool guy
Humans have not had current technology for thousands of years, bound to happen one-day
The moving water is accelerated and decelerated depending on position on the wheel. The deceleration is caused by the bottle and that force is applied to the bottle and wheel
11:04 the sounds that echo in my room late at night.
Definitely not a NASA agent i laughed way harder than I should’ve at tbis
OMG 😂
Lmao I laughed so hard
Gotta slow down and enjoy it... Otherwise you might hurt yourself
😂 so dead 😂
11:25 me after curry night
Tyr0 aw jeeze
Me after chipotle
After taco bell
Bahahaha
You violated 2 of the laws of thermodynamics 😂
It is great to see him have an idea, try it out and realise it did/wouldn’t work!
Top 10 Most Satisfying Sounds
Number 8: A zip tie being closed
Whats the yop
Number 1: m1 garand clip being ejected
Elijah Cohen *pInG*
And the water at 11:05
Says the 👮 cop
That Bag about to knock him out! Thanks for showing us the truth. Very Happy you did this even if it is depressing!
"That extra gram won't matter."
That is what my brother said to the cartel right before they used his blood in a perpetual motion experiment.
I admire your application of the scientific method to see for yourself if this worked. I totally understand why you thought it would! It /sounds/ very reasonable. Experimentation is what leads to finding things that we know now to be laws, and a hands on approach is often the best way to really understand something. Also, its good to take stuff like this as a warning, as reasonable as it sounded and people made it look, the people who experimented and the people who know the science were able to disprove it, so keep that in mind when you (referring to literally everyone right now) want to believe in conspiracy theories. You know, the earth is a sphere, climate change is a real issue, etc.
Gabi King had us in the first half ngl
Gabi King I can't tell how much of this is sarcasm
@@ayekantspeylgud Ah I realize now my wording was a little off. I mean that, we shouldn't believe conspiracies about the Earth being flat, or climate change not being real, not the other way around lol. I did think it was clear because the science only points in one direction, but I see the confusion
Lol this dude thinks the earth is a sphere and climate change is real, good one bud
Gabi King climate change isn’t a real issue why did you even sneak that in this paragraph, it’s a natural occurrence that humans have little to no effect on
i was waiting for that heavy bag to randomly disconnect from the wall and knock him across the room.
Same
Nice
I noticed that to and was wishing the same thung
lmao i didnt even notice the punchin bag til u said sumtin lmao
🤣🤣🤣
if you adjust the angle of the water bottles it will work need to capture toemovment of wate and they key of cycles and walla
I didn't even come to see if it works, I came to watch Tyler entertain me! 😂
Netflix: Are you still watching?
Somebody's daughter : 11:29
I was completely unprepared for what i just heard.
Jakob Wit 😂😂😂😂
My god lol
OMG 😂😂😂😂😂☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️
My god 😂😂😂
Me: it looks like he's gonna drill into the table.
Tyler: and I've drilled into the table.
Every perpetual motion machine that I have seen has weights all around the wheel. They are evenly spaced and placed in a manner to where the ones on the bottom of the wheel are close to outer edges and the ones on top are close the axis. Try bringing the water bottles closer to the axis,see if that works.
Yet another teaching point, this is called Pascal's law/pascal's principal, in fluid/gas/liquid mechanics, it states as followed; fluid at rest in a closed container, a pressure change in one part is transmitted without loss to every portion of the fluid and to the walls of the container.
"Water seeks it's own level"
everyone that likes engineering has at least once in his life thought about making a perpetual motion machine in his mind.
Yea. It's almost impossible to perfect tho. The same amount of energy goes into moving the bottles up as when they came down, and then there's also the added problem of energy being lost to heat. You'd need to make a levitating wheel and then figure out a way to make it so there's more energy going down than up, which is the hard part.
@@Sp00kq is say it IS impossible to perfect. You'd need to have a situation with literally zero friction or other energy loss, which is impossible.
Even if it was possible, there'd be no way to harness the energy anyway, so it's pretty much useless
I've always had a theory. What if you could have a wheel connected to a turbine, you manually spin the wheel once and the electricity created then branched off with one branch going to a device the requiring just enough power to keep the wheel turning. Assuming the necessary amount of power needed to power the wheel is less than the amount of energy the turbine creates, you theoretically would have infinite power
@@cb3rdDegreeBurns
the turbine would create less energy than needed to spin the wheel unfortunately. people try those things for centuries and it never worked simply because of how energy works - they have a word for this: entropy. you will always get less energy than you put into.
It’s impossible.
Insert electroboom yelling “YOU CANNOT MAKE FREE ENERGY!”
Austin GX yes. You’ve got the idea
God dang... best comment on her
It's not making free anger it's just finding a really efficient way of reusing energy. F##k auto correct
Unless if you have a FULL BRIDGE RECTIFIER! Powering it
I literally heard it in his exact voice
Thank you man! Perfect! Science is made when you experiment! You experimented, you're a scientist, a real one. No one told that the experience had to work! Science is not made with only success!
If your interested in the physics aspect, there's a simple explanation.
The law Law of Conservation of Energy
Since energy can't be created, we have to put some of our own energy (chemical energy) into the system, and it will be converted mainly to mechanical energy in the system. Even here some energy is lost due to sound energy and friction (thermal energy).
Then in the system you constantly lose energy to more friction and sound.
11:06 me in the toilet in 3am
This killed me
Haha for real
That little giggle is also very true
"we know this doesn't work"
*doesn't work *
Tyler: 😮
Tyler, "this is how it's supposed to work".
Also Tyler, "I have no idea how this works but here we go"
I knew how this is gonna end, and yet I thoroughly enjoyed the video
The wheel hanging from the celing experiment at the begining is actually not centrifugal force
Its gyroscopic force
Thanks no one asked
Shut up nerd
Paralyzed John Cena lol
GAME FOR FAME xD
I'm glad it annoyed someone else as well.
The movement of the water going down on one side counteracts the leverage of the water going out on the other. The water going to the neck of the bottle is flowing in the opposite direction of wheel rotation, creating a counterproductive force.
This actually has nothing to do with it. Pay close attention to how much water is on one side of the wheel.
@@collynlovell9982
Actually it does. Why do you think it stops and goes the opposite direction? Watch it at .25x
He basically made a severely unbalanced wheel
So actually the reason that perpetual motion machines don't and will never work is because friction exists. If there was no friction then the wheel wouldn't slow down
No friction would do nothing for perpetual motion because of the water imbalance. The water on the left of the wheel is in fact moving in a direction opposite the wheel which is counterproductive. It will cause the wheel to slow no matter what. If the wheel begins to slow at all it will continue to slow and eventually stop. You could create this setup with a magnetic bearing to get rid of the friction in the center of the wheel and the backward force of the water on the left would still slow the wheel to an eventual stop.
The whole video I was screaming "spin it the other way"
I think the reason it's stopping so quickly is because the positions of the bottles aren't perfectly balanced - while obviously this can't actually work as a perpetual motion machine, I think normally you'd expect it to take a few minutes to run down, and it wouldn't necessarily reverse like that.
That same rabbit hole got me to your channel 🤣
You’re trying to get energy for free ?
Universe : no
Lol yess!!
He's actually not. He's trying to leverage an initially applied kinetic energy, which is entirely possible
If you want free energy use wind or sun or river
@@techazepro6105 still not free, it's cheap energy but not "free"
3:00 “503, 505”
RIP Davie504 😂
only true ones know
Bennett Cole BASS
SLAPP LIKE NOW
Lmao
S a c r i l e g i o u s
Thank you my boy! You saved my time .
Quando comecei a assistir o vídeo já pensei : Lá vem mais um "gênio"para tentar provar o "moto conntínuo" com vários truques e tc . Até pensei : quantas lâmpadas esse "gênio" vai "acender" com a engenhoca? . Fiquei surpreso !!! Um dos poucos que assumem que NÃO FUNCIONA . Parabéns .Gostei muito
“Alright maybe you just gotta go real fast”
This is the quality content that keeps me coming back.
I friggin love this guy. Do all of his experiments work? No. Am I always entertained? Yes! I applaud you Tyler
I've never seen that before...the hanging spinning wheel thing. Damn cool. Thanks.
Tyler have you thought about changing the viscosity of the liquid from water to something heavier and slower shifting?
Dude, I love your channel and everything you try but you aren't about to break the second law of thermodynamics in your garage. Perpetual motion does not exist. You can't get more energy out than what you put in, and everything wears down and eventually needs repaired or replaced. If humanity perfected a perpetual motion machine, we'd jump to a tier 3 civilization immediately.
The concept on it’s own is entertaining enough. Imagine if this video had been the breakthrough discovery... just some guy in his garage.
Eh, it's all in fun. At least he seems to have gotten away from glue videos.
@@wungomungo6177 lol what if he proved it
Bruh
Dude he does it only four entertainmant chill
I love this guy. Never stop making videos!
Have you tried an eye dropper for adding tiny amounts
Have you tried heros fountian on the wheel? Or coke and mentos for a buster to change balance and keep it moving...
Loved the clipity-clopity sound!
11:49 sounds like me in the bathroom in my teens
I knew I would see this comment
can you connect bicycle dynamo to it and see how long it will work and how much power produce?
Maybe try supporting the wheel from both sides and mount the bottles from the center instead of the caps.
I just want to you know what anytime my husband and I see a man with a big beard we'll say "I bet he couldn't put 2,000 toothpicks in it tho"
what?
Yall weird af then 😂
It was the extra gram
It was... THE GRAMMM!
All for the gram. B***** love a gram
Think about it this way: you've equally spaced a bunch of weight on a wheel, all you did is balance it. In order to spin the wheel, you had to put force on one side and then let it go to push it forward. By adding those bottles all you've done is add weight to the the entire wheel, like adding a tire, its changed nothing and gives no driving force to the wheel
It's almost like the added weight increases friction which is a constant force acting against the initial momentary force applied to make it spin. Thus friction will win every time.
Not exactly. Although the torque on the left side is higher than the right, the torque at the bottom is higher than the top. Both of these higher forces are in opposition. So right there you have a zero net turning force. Even so, there's still the various frictions that also resist the wheel from turning.
It is the weight what creates the energy in this tool, so increase the amount of water in each bottle upto tow third of the volume then try again, it should work, also tie the bottles in a way that keep the body of the bottle strait (sticking) on the wheel not forming an angle and keep the caps in the front of the rotation.
It was like watching Dora the Explorer.
Me: The bottle, the bottle!
Tyler: Does it look like the bottle needs to go back?
Me: YES!!!!!
SAME!
I love this guy he makes quality content
I think what's happening is that the momentum is on the outside and when it's on the outside the object slows down. Like a figure skater and when it's in the inside the object speeds up
I appreciate the effort. It is a learning process. Understanding comes from experimentation. Coming up with a constant imbalance is what is needed. Just as with petroleum, sunlight, and other sources of energy, they can run out. Even the thought of the earth being a sphere and spinning. How did it start spinning, if it is? Lots of questions. As long as your source of energy lasts for your lifetime, then it is perpetual to you. All is relative.
One thing that might be affecting it from spinning for a least a little while is since you only have the wheel bolted on one side it’s probably causing friction on the axle and or the bearings and stoping them from spinning.
I feel bad for him “humm it doesn’t work I did all this for nothing 😟”😂😂
Dude, this guys awesome
If you treet the axle and balance the water in the bottles you can get it to spin the longest one was about 18hr but you would never be able to pull any energy out of it.
Until you can get rid of friction all together you can’t have a perpetual motion machine
And wind resistance and break physics
Even without friction it's fundamentally impossible.
Energy can neither be created nor destroyed, and in any closed system entropy will tend to increase.
John Petersen yeah but isn’t there a whole theory about like how energy is constantly created and destroyed? Idk I’m not that into science
@@dennisbooth7731 no it's just transferred in ways that look like it's created and destroyed.
I get pretty excited whenever I see these videos. I could only imagine what living next to him would be like. 😂
It seemed to almost work, I was curious is making sure your base is solid that it doesn’t move and level. Then you would have to find the exact weight or even half the maximum volume the bottle can hold?
I’m just a little stoned and was thinking... 🤔 💭
Fill the water to at least half way. Turn the wheel toward the direction of the bottle’s extension i.e. the bottom.
I love this channel and I'm a chemistry major and physics as a minor. I know his videos are not the most scientific but they're extremely entertaining. Perpetual motion machine or not love the channel. (He could have been like a lot perpetual motion machine videos and fake it)
Gee thanks I'll watch this video whenever I need to figure out how to hold a tire to my ceiling
1:53
Was still fun to try though. Thanks man
When I’m in class and the teacher is teaching too fast 9:55
Tyler: .. imma teach kids about perpetual motion...
Also Tyler with a D.A.R.E. shirt on tell kids to smoke Diesel...
😂😂🤣.. savage
I came to the comments section to see how many physics professors were watching CZcams. Apparently a fair amount.
A mere layman's understanding of physics is enough to realise that this could never work. It really does not take any formal education in physics to understand this. It's physics 101 at best.
I wonder if you zip tied them to the spokes instead of the outside if it would work. Because the bottles are catching air resistant, but if they were parallel to the spokes and zip tied they wouldn’t catch as much resistance.
Respect to you for being honest and not joining in with the rest of the fake video's on CZcams 💯👍😉
Crazy man believes he has created the ultimate renewable energy source
Captain SNES someone tell Electroboom 😄
Bro he never mentioned it being an energy source. He said a perpetual wheel that would run for a long time.do you guys feel smart when pointing out something a child knows? Literally everyone knows you cant just create a constant energy source or a machine that runs by itself. He just wants something that will spin for a while
@@EpilepsyWarning you mean like a wheel without bottles attached?
@a guy if i test for alien dna in my drinking water i feel like that might indicate my insanity
EpilepsyWarning There are lots of constant energy sources. Perhaps the best example would be the sun,the sun is constantly giving off radiant energy. An example of “a Device that runs by itself” would be a S O L A R P A N E L, a solar panel uses photovoltaic cells to convert radiant energy into electricity . Also a solar panel does not need any power to run so you could say it “runs by its self”. It is uneducated people like you who who have to pick on others to make your self feel smarter. Why don’t you finish middle school before you act like you know what you’re talking about. PUT THAT IN YOU J U U L AND SMOKE IT.
Tyler: For every 10 videos on perpetual motion, there are 10 videos explaining the physics of why it won't work.
Also Tyler : Why can't I get this to work?
Best Channel Ever!
The centrifugal force deal was worth the price of admission.
The bottles are adding kinetic energy (the energy of motion) on one side, and removing it on the other thus they neutralize each other thereby allowing friction and other forces to stop the wheel.