“You’re Not Gonna Create Wealth” | Julia Hartley-Brewer Blasts Labour’s Net Zero Plans
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 06. 2024
- Labour’s GB Energy policy will result in “giant bills”, Penny Mordaunt has claimed.
Speaking at the seven-way BBC debate, the Commons leader said: “It’s not just your taxes that I’m worried about, I’m worried about my constituents being able to afford a Labour government.
Talk’s Julia Hartley-Brewer is joined by former Labour Party official Richard Power Sayeed to discuss this further.
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#talktv #politics #generalelection2024
Labour abandoned the working class, time the working class abandoned Labour!
Vote Reform UK
Seemingly every other Labour spokesman or mouthpiece is a middle-class w00fter like this bloke and Jonathan Lis, a regular on Talk TV. They drone on about subsidies to fossil fuel.
Let's hope enough have seen past the snake-oil pitch, I know many up here have seen past the empty promises and lies.
They abandoned them for the Muslim vote,without that they are nothing
Agreed
This man knows NOTHING about what it’s like to be working class in this country
He knows nothing about anything.
@@thedave7760And you know ? Then why you still in the country if for the last 15 years is such a bad😂
hes clueless
yeah but his daddy was a tool maker
Thankfully neither do I or have the slightest wish to know. Why are the working class so obsessed with class, perhaps it's an inferiority complex ?
The pathetic smile on his face says it all..vote reform
That's smugness
He went to University and gained a degree in History and Politics and knows everything about nothing.
He's got the same experience in all fields. Zero.
Probably a degree in gender studies as well
Bloody right marker.
This Guy is living in cloud cuckoo land
He thinks that buying renewable energy equipment from China is competing with China. How does one get to be so stupid?
Liebour will be a disaster, they do not have a clue. VOTE REFORM UK for real and needed change.
you say Labour will be a disaster, how do you know? yet you advocate Reform who are led by a snake oil salesman and have Lee Anderson, an idiot and others. Reform may get one or two seats if they are lucky.
Labour will be great you might not like him ,but he is calm respectful and truthful, we need respect in Westminster, he is the only one who is thinking about us normal people of the uk, sunac and farage are for themselves and the few,these clowns you cannot trust we remember Johnson and farage in the referendum led us up the garden path, never again just because they shout over everybody and rude,
if reform promised not to continue sending weaponry to ukraine & stopped supporting israell's genocide, they would get much larger support from the british people!! fuck ukraine & fuck israel!!! they ain't got nuffin' to do with britain! just because the first 2 letters of UKraine spells UK, DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE BRITISH!! ALSO, JEWS IN THIS COUNTRY ARE BRITISH, NOT ISRAELIS!!
ENGLAND, BRITAIN COMES FIRST!! CAPICHE?
@@lesleylamy Labour dont even understandt basic energy reality and Kier Starmer is too spineless to even dare say what a woman is, how can you say they'll be great!?!
What good will that do, those idiots Labour will surely get in .
Julia 1 - 0 Strange Man
100% agree
The big horrible smirk on his face- aag
@@stevedickson5853 He was one giant smirk. Liberal-Left to his bone marrow.
Well, 3 - 0 actually 😅
This guy has no clue
He knows so little he thinks he knows everything.
This country is about to make a HUGE mistake 😔.
Well no one is being forced to vote Labour.
@@billybatts8283Maybe not forced, but radicalised and manipulated by the MSM to vote Labour. Keep up son!
It's made them before!, looking forward to the 70's Labour Government again
@@billybatts8283 no they are brainwashed
we are living with a big mistake right now
shes right hes wrong.
Voting age should be raised to 21!
Well said. In Germany before 1914, you had to be 25. Before 25, you were not considered mature. In many ways, it does make sense.
There should be a requirement to have paid a minimum of 12 months' worth of taxes before earning the right to vote.
It should also be just like driving, there is a test you have to pass before being allowed to vote.
Obviously Labour would oppose it as its supporters would have the most difficulty in obtaining the pass mark !
As in the good old days, voting should be regarded as a privilege and be restricted to qualified taxpayers.
25. Also anyone who has an income derived solely from benefits shouldn't be allowed to vote.
This man should not have the right to vote.
Most people shouldn't going by the crowds in londonistan each weekend of idiots supporting a terrorist organisation. - If a person cannot adequately explain the basic premise of governance and fiscal responsibility in a "competency to vote" exam, they should NOT BE ALLOWED TO VOTE.
The trouble is, so many people will vote Labour without having any clue about what needs to change and how all this WEF stuff and Net Zero is nonsensical!
Vote Reform UK
Rubbish, where is the money, starmer and the Labour Party, are changing but what is left in the books, is the question. We also need to get rid of the tories we can’t afford them any more. We do not want our taxes cut at the moment till the money is there, Tory’s because they did not lower the personal tax, and that brought pensioners into the tax bracket under stealth tax they are taking quite a lot of money , they did not mention that but lowering Nat ins which is not going to help the poor people of the uk who have been hammered with mortgages rents children going Hungary it should not happen in this day and age I liked to know where all this money has gone ,
And as usual, Julia is correct about everything she says about green energy destroying the UK economy.
If only she'd STFU about Russia and Ukraine and Putin, she'd be almost perfect.
The biosphere is fine, unlike your understanding of it.
@@peterholden3672 So you dont mind that we'll have to mine more metals out of the planet than have ever been mined throughout history to transtition to a net zero world?
How are all these metals going to be mined and transported around the world without using fossil fuels? What happens to the mountains of waste when the solar panels and unrecyclable turbines wear out, oh yeah landfill, ruining the environment, these so called green solutions are anything but! And end up far more expensive.
As usual on the contrary, Julia is complicit in a conspiracy, as usual Julia says nothing illuminating she merely rehearses the crap she imbibed as an infant, Julia is typical of the disgrace of the social media. It is a brothel, like the Supreme Court of the USA it care not a jot for principle , nor apparently do you! Having an opinion requires insight and scepticism and reading and I have no evidence that Julia has read any serious work on the subject on which she feels entitled to mislead you amongst millions of other gullible ignorant and stupid punters
The economy is not the problem. Surviving global warming is the problem.
The climate people always seem to have that condescending grin on their face.
Yeh its caused by all the gas they are full of 🤣
But you won't be able to see there grin when we have 100% renewable energy and they are sitting in the dark . Renewable energy is only 3% of global energy production , more energy is produced by burning wood .
@@martinpowell3855 or the plug they use to stop it from been expelled
He forgotten to take his meds today.
All of it is a scam . These people are brainwashed . This planet will be here in billions of years However the human race wont
Wealth creation and socialism unfortunately are not good bedfellows.
haven't seen a successful one yet , unless you count successful at failing
@@Svetovid_999 difference is i'd rather be poor and free. Then poor and enslaved which is socialism in a tea cup
@@oldshiny3012 Labour are not socialist
@@Svetovid_999 guess you not visited Russia , china or north Korea lately or any other socialist states recently
@InvictusVirtus
Capitalism is very conducive to wealth creation - look at real life examples. People in capitalist societies have a MUCH better standard of living than those in socialist societies. There is a reason why people want to flee socialism for capitalism.
This man has absolutely no cluu. You can't fix stupid that's for sure
This is what you’ll get if you vote Labour, Idiots like him.
These net zero advocates are absolutely nuts, they don't have a clue!
Why? What’s the problem with aiming for net zero?
@@F.O.O well, for starters there's no such thing as climate crisis, plants need CO2 for photosynthesis and the UK is responsible for 1% of emissions, It's madness!
@@stukavonferno8858 Neither of those points disproves climate change
@@F.O.O You asked about net zero, you didn't mention climate change. Climate change has been going on for billions of years and will continue to do so long after the human race has ceased to exist. Please wake up!
What a Pratt
The man doesn't even understand how the grid works.
God help us with the clueless at the helm. And then they wonder why people are voting Reform.
"Subsidise gas and petrol with tax breaks". What planet is that lunatic on ?.
I was about to say the same thing ! This guy is indeed a moron but seems to make a good living spouting this nonsense.
Exactly what I thought, this is the caliber and standard of idiots who intend leading over the cliffs edge. Vote Reform Uk
25 percent of your electric bill is a tax that supports wind and solar.
In what way can you create wealth by taking money from people?
Probably making wind and solar executives rich.
"to create jobs"
Completely devoid of common sense. Dangerous man, in my opinion.
Agree 100%
Nett zero is a complete Conspiracy……!!!
😂
So is carbon tax.
If a 16 year old can vote, then they must be named in the courts.
Are they going to be classed as responsible adults and subject to the same laws and rules as adults also??
Both brilliant points. We know why Labour are giving 16 year olds the vote. Well my neices are voting for the first time in the GE. But not for Labour or tory.
Remember, the same people saying that 16 years olds are old enough to vote, are also the same people saying that shamima begum was too young at the age of 16 to understand right from wrong.
So which is it.
Old enough, or too young to understand right from wrong.
You can't have both
Yes I remember it well , another labour turn around to make a point
If this man is an advisor to the Labour leadership and they take on board what he is telling them then we are all doomed!
Every single argument put forward by this guy was effortlessly and adeptly dismantled - well done Julia.
Bloke is absolutely clueless
This guy represents the young caffee latte drinking snobs that has no touch with reality all around Europe.
It will create massive wealth - for Labour & China.
Net zero is nonsense.
It's clever for the tax man though.
Except if you want to destroy the economy and create poverty.
The important word is "net" which is a worthwhile goal. However this needs to be on a global scale, with countries like China signing up to it.
@@jjefferyworboys8138 lmao
@jjefferyworboys8138 Co2 is not a problem, it is not a 'greenhouse gas, is is, in fact plant food. We need more not less
Voting should be 21 or over !! Vote Farage labour and tories singing from the same hymn sheet!!
Agree
The idea of 16 year old s voting is madness. 21 should be the minimum ae.
More like 40.
How can something you have to bury in the ground at the end of it's life be renewable?
You make a valid point. But renewables are still far better environmentally and financially then fossil fuels
@@F.O.O Tell that to China, they are burning fossil fuels at a great rate of knots. The world should STOP buying stuff from China.
If 16 year olds are as capable of voting responsibly as 18 year olds, that’s an argument to increase the voting age.
smiley boy in wonderland, we are so fked.
`look what the dog dragged in
His carer has taken the day off.
Strange looking man says we don't decide what kids can do based upon principals... Yes we do.
I have been saying this for years. The UK is no longer the powerhouse of industry it once was. We have lost our shipyards our steel foundries and our motor industry, just to mention a few. Mining is virtually non-existent. Yet they still want us to decrease our use of energy. How are we going to become prosperous once again, if we don’t make anything? I think we have gone as far as we can regarding net zero. Any lower and we will become a wasteland, While countries like China and India prosper. Who thought that was a good idea. 🤬
I think you meant sold without consent rather than lost
Ironically, we’re probably putting just as much co2 in the air as we’re just buying the stuff we need from elsewhere.
@@sywilson73 Yes. But we have no control over private enterprise. It would’ve been nice if the government had stepped in, but they didn’t.
A 16 year old legally can not sign binding contracts, because they don't understand the long term effects,
But can some how understand the long term effects of voting?
Not a chance.
Voting age needs to be raised not lowered
The voting age should be 21 IMO... 5 years of real world life experience rather then fresh out of the classroom..
And even then many young people are still in education or have only just left with the amount of people that go to uni to be indoctrinated with lefty activist propaganda these days!
In that case it needs to be a minimum of 23 as young people have to remain in full time education until they are 18.
Fresh out of indoctrination gets a Labour vote. The most cynical proposition there ever was. Vote Reform Uk
Make it 30! In your twenties you just want to party...
@@rewdwarf123 really? I worked my ar3e off through my 20s to get enough money to put down a deposit on a flat with my now husband… I think it probably depends on what sort of position people are in money-wise and if they have plans for a family etc
More lies
More stupid nonsense, that muppet is delusional.
What I'm really worried about is that Labour will stop the benefit scroungers, who default on their bills, from being cut off. They will then use even more energy, and decent, honest, hard-working people will be forced to pay for them.
They will create wealth for a few, and it will come out of our pockets.
I WOULD RAISE THE VOTING AGE TO 21
We think we've had it bad up to now (which we certainly have) but this country is about to make the biggest mistake in its history by electing a Labour Government.
God help us if we do.
Create wealth 🙄 not only billions in subsidies, but need oil , gas ⛽️ as back up makes it way more expensive, plus trillions for the infrastructure, when we are already broke 🙄
"we need to make the grid national, so we can transfer power from north to south". It already is! That already happens! This statement alone destroys any vague credibility he might have. In fact the reason the grid is natinal (National Grid, gettit?) is because it is supplied by large power stations with power distributed across the whole country.
I hear the Chinese EV market is going well for them. Thousands of EVs left to rot in large fields 🤣
You can build as many wind turbines as you like but that will never provide reliable power so there has to be nuclear or gas turbine backup for every one … so we’re building two parallel generation sources and having to pay the capital maintenance and operating costs of both!
Net Zero is economically destructive delusional insanity.
The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels are largely beneficial. Benefits include greening of the planet with increased agricultural yields (main effect), reduced winter heating costs, fewer deaths from hypothermia and postponement of the next glacial maximum.
Renewable sources like wind and solar with a base load of nuclear has been the consensus for a while now. This is easily doable it just requires investment. And energy would get cheaper as renewables tend to produce cheaper energy
Any wealth they create will end up in their own pockets
Come on - deep breath, leap of faith - vote Reform - your country needs you!
If he considers 16 year olds adults then I would like to hear him commit to changing the law so they can also be tried and sentenced as adults - it's both or neither...
In Scotland 16 year olds can vote in their national assembly, but there was a case recently where a man got away with a rape he committed when he was 17 against a girl of 13. He was given community service, and the judge said if he'd committed the rape when he was over 25 he'd have been jailed. If they want 16 year olds to be treated as adults and allowed to vote then they should be treated as adults when they do wrong.
@@catwoman7462 agree 💯❣👏. Same in Wales!!
The woke graduate class speaks to us unworthy working classes.
The worst i can wish this guy is to live in the world he wants.
Yeah the Trueman reality
With people like this running our country what could possibly go wrong?
Net zero is a costly dream. Decades away. Meanwhile we go broke.
Subsidies petrol with tax breaks??!!!! Ffs!!
Going to wind power has cost us an extra £18 billion. The more wind farms, the more we pay even if they are turned off, we pay for what they could of supplied .
Go and live in China please
fossil fuel tax breaks what about the big tax breaks to buy a useless EV to appease these fools
"You’re Not Gonna Create Wealth” . Yes they are, for their political cohorts and corporate masters.
I can see a wind turbine from our kitchen window. It hasn't turned for days.
Big difference between the one wind turbine you can see out of your window and multiple large aggregated wind farms mate
How can anyone vote for labour, astonishing
16 year old doesn't know what time of day it is!
Simple question - if “renewable” energy is really cheaper, then why has the cost of electricity been going up all over the western world as they struggle to bring in this form of energy to create the net zero economy ?
How can we rely on solar farms when we dont see the sun for most of the year? We live in a very northern European country. They are creating an energy shortage and pushing up prices.
This man is a complete nob😂
Who says oil will run out utter utter bs
There are enough fossil fuel reserves to last for several centuries.
@@johngeier8692not only that but the oil fields they capped off for been depleted, have refilled themselves. Is oil really fossil fuel.
More than we've taken out of the North Sea was discovered in British Antarctica, tap the resources be energy independent maybe even export some.
16 year olds don't pay taxes as they're still at school. Most 18 year olds don't pay taxes as they're still at school, and even up to the age of 21 roughly half don't pay taxes as they're at university.
NZ as just stopped the closing down of oil and fossil fuels because the fear of blackouts in winter
Oil and gas are NOT subsidised…. They are taxed to excess already… what a total muppet….
At 16 I was not mature enough .I was a rebel..and kids are less disciplined today..
And addicted to social media and whatever else smart phones can do.
Clean cheap energy? Why are my bills going up? Where is all this mythical cheap energy?
Always a pleasure to have him on this show!! I’ve just crashed the car listening to this convo.
Electricity in the UK is now more than 5.5 times higher than Russia. Gas is similar.
The UK steel industry has ceased not least due to the massively un-competitive price of electricity.
Would you want to live in Russia though ?
Yes - why not?
Net Zero is economically destructive delusional insanity.
The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels are largely beneficial. Benefits include greening of the planet with increased agricultural yields (main effect), reduced winter heating costs, fewer deaths from hypothermia and postponement of the next glacial maximum. This is especially so in cold areas such as the UK.
The fraudulent Paris Accord needs to be abandoned and the most economical energy resources available need to be utilised.
if he had his way it would be Richard "no Power" Sayeed!
We used to have an industrial power base making things for other countries and getting the profits. Then the EU legislated that we had to buy the cheapest materials from the cheapest supplier and our industries went down the toilet so we buy these “renewables “ from other countries, have to pay them subsidies when these wind farms don’t make enough money (!) and have to pay again to replace them when they stop working after ten years. Where’s the wealth creation in that? The only way this country can create wealth is to start making things again.
If the majority of people in this country following the last time they were in power and what happened in the EU vote for Labour then the country 100% deserves to fall....
If this guy is the face of labour we are fecked
100%
A Excuse for a Human Being talking Complete Bollock's 😷
You have to admit, though, he has a big smile. Just nothing going on behind it.
We headed to the abyss with Labour
your forgetting labour uses that world famous fantasy fiction Abacus, its the same one Venezuela used
what did the tories use- beans
Well to be fair, was it not that intellectual titan & mathematical labour genius Diane Abbott that created the world renowned Abacus of crash economics 😂
Compete against China 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 man we don't even have decent roads 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You’re going to transmit power for +500 miles, do you realise the cost and losses associated with that, and don’t forget the NIMBYS.
Which is why we invest in storage
What storage
@@keithlevoir608 Energy storage such as lithium ion and lead acid batteries. There’s pumped hydro storage as-well and several different options. We charge up these storage facilities during low demand and high energy production times and discharge the energy during high demand and low energy production times
@@F.O.O Electrical energy storage is one of the most unproductive use of resources there is. Pumped hydro fares better but you need the vast area for the reservoir.
Energy storage does not generate any more energy for use, it simply stores existing energy for later use. A 100W solar panel with energy storage still only captures up to 100W in solar power.
There is a reason why historically electrical batteries used in mobile devices are kept as small as possible. Energy storage is never a good solution; people only pay the cost of energy storage if there is no other choice.
Why do you think nobody’s done it the technology isn’t good enough yet
If it actually created wealth and prosperity, you wouldn't need a government mandate to get people to do it, they'd just switch over to generate higher profits.
The thought of Labour or the Tories getting elected literally terrifies me. The UK will be finished under either party. Blair will be in the wings too. Got to give Reform a chance , if not the country is done. 😞
Richard Power, oh dear, oh dear, oh dear, what a joke 😂😂😂😂😂
We are going to be cold and in the dark with people with attitudes like this !!!!!!!
Yeah so what BS is he going to spout when thousands go into fuel poverty in wimter. And suffer from chronic health problems. Talk about a whoops party. Very frightening.
The idea that we can compete by making everything more expensive is beyond stupid.
Why is no one talking about the electricity required to power AI? Huge amounts of reliable electricity required.
It’s negligible compared to ultimate load of heat pumps and electric cars!
@@andyxox4168 1000 terrawatts an hour by 2026? Also described as 'roughly equal to the electricity usage of Japan'. But it is never mentioned in these discussions. They talk about EVs all the time, and that's bad enough - just look at the devastation in South America, caused by China, in mining the lithium (how is that any better for the environment?).
@@andyxox4168 I suggest you do some research.
GOD HELP US ALL WHEN LABOUR GET INTO POWER A VOTE FOR LABOUR IS A VOTE FOR ISLAM
The smug condescending look on his face and his take on the voting age says it all
Yes A total bell.
I thought the term "talking 💭out of his💭 arse" was just a saying. This bloke proves that as a myth‼️
Lol
Thank you. That's given me my daily chuckle!!!
got the central heating on ,
no global warming in uk this summer ,
but Labour Green TAX on the way ,
gonna be extremely cold winter ❄❄🌨🌨🥶🥶⛄⛄
Net Zero is all very well, but hardly any of it is manufactured in this country so we are just sending lots of money to China (who aren't reducing emissions) and creating CO2 during the manufacturing process. If the UK became net zero tomorrow, the increase in emissions by India, Africa and China would negate it within weeks.
Days.
Well said Julia this man is talking rubbish vote Reform 👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️🇬🇧
My sixteen year daughter hasn't got a clue politically.
What a bell!😂😂
Its a wonder he didn't say. 'People can buy an eco blanket to keep warm. They have lots of big holes in them. You couldn't write this tripe.
THE GREAT CLIMATE 🐂💩
Sitting there with a big smirk on his gob and utterly "clueless" - the next government in waiting.
Frightening