Julia Hartley-Brewer CLASHES with Reform UK’s Ben Habib Over Illegal Immigration
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 04. 2024
- TalkTV's Julia Hartley-Brewer clashes with Reform UK’s Ben Habib over how the party would stop illegal migration.
Rishi Sunak said “nothing will stand in our way” of getting flights to Rwanda off the ground, as the Government braced itself for legal challenges to the scheme to send asylum seekers to the east African country.
The Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration Bill) cleared Parliament shortly after midnight after peers backed down, ending resistance to the scheme.
The Prime Minister hopes the Rwanda scheme will deter migrants from seeking to cross the English Channel, but on Tuesday morning a small boat was seen leaving the Calais shoreline with French police looking on.
Julia: “Are you genuinely saying the policy is ‘we will let people drown to make a point’?”
Ben: “Let’s not infantilise these people!”
#immigration #rwanda #juliahartleybrewer #talktv
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
I'm with Ben 1 million %
As is your right. We live in a democracy
Shut up Julia let him speak.
Hear Hear
she does tend to keep talking too much !!
@@joycegibbs5267 she does this to every guest because she knows her uninformed opinion is of paramount importance.
Gobby Women screaming over Ben.
I’ve stopped listening to Talk Radio during the day because JHB invites guests on and asks a 3 minute question. I’ll just watch the occasional video now. Many other hosts on the channel are the same like Kevin for example.
Spot on ben!!!!! Couldn't agree more,Julia's wrong here!!! 😡
For gods sake listen to the man he is absolutely spot on , just stop bowing to these people Julia
His assessment of most of it was decent but he couldn't answer the most important point. How do you stop the boats? No British Navy ship is going to sit and watch as people drown it goes against their very nature as seamen. The Navy can't legally enter French waters so no way of taking them back to France.
@@mrnumba154
It is the Royal Navy.
This is a result of letting women vote. Feelings before reason.
@@stoater1551 My point still stands.
😅😅😅@@MDM1992
I’m with Ben 💯
Me too, vote reform uk.
@@geoffshaw8053then your get labour well done 😅
@@philfitnesspt6139I'll take that chance.. Vote Reform...
@@philfitnesspt6139 Try defining ANY huge difference between the LibLabCon? Secondly Liebour will win the GE even if Reform UK didn’t exist so your comment is worthless. Anyone who is a genuine Conservative & not a Liberal Democrat party in sheep’s clothing pretending to be the Conservative Party should vote Reform UK to empty the whole swamp in WEFMONSTER! Think on!
@@philfitnesspt6139 So what? They'll be worse the the Tories but the country's still going down the toilet either way. Things will have to get worse before they can get better, hopefully in '29 or before.
Julia is part of the problem.
Julie used to be good but I think she has been got at
@@stephenporter6005:- She is so wrong and undermines the necessary solutions by Reform to the problem. The UK is drowning with this major major problem of migrants. Good for Reform with ways and means to deal with it.
No one else it seems can.
Yes@@stephenporter6005
She only said letting people drown is uncivilised.
@@stephenporter6005 people putting themselves in jepoardy to illegally enter a country is uncivilised.
There is no duty of care to protect people in danger because they are wantonly breaking laws.
Ben is 💯 million % right we cant bow to emotional blackmail
Quite right ! The Australians didn't take all this nonsense with the Vietnamese boat people!!
Is it your lack of numeracy skills or have you got your numbers the wrong way round? So consider 100 being the percent of 100,000,000, you are more likely to be 0.0001% right.
No i meant he is 💯 million % right in what he,s saying not just right but way right if they come on a boat and they drown they knew the risk before coming and if we keep saving them they will keep coming and throwing theirselves in the water expecting to be saved and brought here and like idiots we keep saving them because people will think we're mean we're cruel we're inhuman but they know the risk . If I don't want to get stuck climbing a mountain i don't climb it simple why put myself in the situation in the 1st place the more we save them they will keep taking the risk
@@martins24455 letting people drown is cruel and inhumane. But by your logic, no one should help you if you're in danger ever because you put yourself in that position
It is logical if you put yourself in that situation I don't want to get stuck climbing a mountain or falling off then I don't do it and if I did it would be my own fault because I know the risk before I attempted it
I am with Ben ❤🏴
Julia there is no moral highground in succumbing to the invader's blackmail or threats - Ben is correct
There's the problem, these freeloaders know that so it goes on
Ben wins the argument!
He didn't win
@@mrnumba154yes he did
Yes he did
He does good on.ben
You are 100% in the wrong here Julia.
And Ben is 100% right.
Simple as that.
Hartley-Brewer is a motormouth. Why use one word when you can bombard your guest with one hundred words. Ben Habib is 100% correct.
If the people jump into the water in French waters, then it's France's responsibility to rescue them.
Spot on Britain is too soft on the issue we actually go into their waters to pick illegals up, ineffect Britain and France are aiding and abetting, knowing their going to dump passports, but France must know their identity they have to produce it in France
Ho said done, that's been happing since the boat fiasco started it's a outrage 🏴🇬🇧🌹
It's their own responsibility- stupid actions have stupid consequences.
Well if they choose to jump in the water then we turn our boats around and leave them to it. If they drown then they drown. Once the word gets back then perhaps these illegal immigrants will start to think twice.
@@Jen-lg4hpexactly
if someone is threatening to drown themselves as a way to be let in illegally...let them.
Think of those poor hungry sharks for once.
@user-wb-4dq6fi8w People who risk their lives doing daring fetes don't get escorted about by 'do-gooders' like the RNLI or the French border force (i.e. potholers, abseilers hang-gliders etc.) If people deem it essential to set sail and leave a safe place the resulting outcome would soon solve/stop the problem of the traffickers making money out of 'filling' cheap rubber dinghies designed to carry less than half the amount of bodies?
And problem solved
Is Serco supplying the dinghies? God knows they are the biggest earners from illegal immigration.
I am going off you Julia. it must be stopped by any means.
I'm not going to watch her again after this charade. 😮
What is a legacy of Blair?
@@lescarroz1956We are living it now.
Ben is right in what he says....vote reform.... Julia is a lefty deep down.....bring back mike Graham at 10am...
Talk Radio has gone downhill rapidly. The breakfast programme has a gobby woman, the following half hour programme has now been taken over by a lefty, which is why I no longer listen to JHB. They'll have to learn by their mistakes.
Ben is absolutely correct in what he says.
Totally with the Reform UK’s Ben Habib, and would vote for it. Not doing so is a great evil.
Habib is great, Tice is one of them
@@DennisGeorge-cn3zutrue but still voting Reform, it is our last chance
@@sharoncooke1719 I agree, Tice can be replaced
He can be ‘shut up’ by others more aware than he is.
@@triciabaker8992 exactly, as ppl are more aware now & harder to fool
Vote reform, save our nation
WTH is the problem? just get the navy to pick them up and take them straight back! This is an invasion of fighting aged men!
BEEN SAYING THAT FOR MONTHS, SADLY THAT TAKES BALLS, SEVERLY LACKING IN GOVT
They want them. An agreement between France/UK governments.
What navy?
What navy?
The government has been cutting back on the armed services for years
Let him speak Julia. Now you’ve given the illegals an idea.
Believe me, they will already know that
If they choose to jump in to the water, that is their responsibility. They are not the responsibility of Britain.
They are. Because they are attempting to claim asylum in the UK and we have international responsibilities (that Britain co-founded) to uphold their rights as human beings. I think you’re forgetting that these aren’t animals, they’re people.
@@louisdoningtonDon't be stupid.
@@ddanson5831 good one... your argument’s so ironclad that you’ve offered no rebuttal to mine at all. Just insults, as it always is with simple minded people.
@@louisdoningtonwell they seem to be commiting a lot of crime when they get to the uk including rape murder and terrorist attacks
Julia has lost her mind
Probably dreaming of her next holiday.
Would she have been so worried about German soldiers drowning during their invasion in 1940 ?What is the difference,a uniform??!!
her brain's turned to porridge due to the stress of her thinning hair...
She’s just trying to signal empathy, it’s what women do
I'm with Ben.
Ben Habib is a Great Man!! 🙏
Talk TV going down the drain 😂👍
Well yes it's closing on free to air T V , over time I have become disenchanted with Talk T V TOO London centric
Let's face it Julia Hartley brewer Brewer though the May deal WAS BREXIT
Gone down the drain with that mouth. Too self opinionated
Gone!
I prefer it to other stations, because, there is more input from the public. I would rather hear a voice of an individual male or female than a presenter reading out an Email.
Going down the drain, I nevercrated it from the start. Just another independent 'mainstream' channel
Ukraine is defending its border with force and the UN/EU is not only OK with it, but is supporting Ukraine! Britain is being invaded by Islam, so Britain needs to use force just like Ukraine is.
There is no conflict in Ukraine it's all part of the plan so is gaza .
How can you be invaded by a religion?
it's basically conflict of Interest all religions all have different beliefs . And nobody likes too much difference @@sbor2020
@@craigwebb4012 The question was how a can religion invade a country. Anyway, as for your comment, the three Abrahamic religions all believe in the existence of one God, the creator and sustainer of the universe. They share many of the same prophets, such as Moses and Elijah in Judaism, and Jesus in both Christianity and Islam. You far-right people even talk of “Judeo-Christian” tradition rather than “Abrahamic” ignoring the similarities and creating conflict. Abraham, the original prophet even sacrificed his own son Isaac, so that sacrifice is central to your religions. But I am sure theological discussion is not what you meant, but more on Islamophobia, which is mainly driven by ignorance, and political ideologies. Isn’t freedom important to you? Don’t you think it's important to promote understanding, tolerance, and respect for all individuals, regardless of their religious beliefs?
Sbor Yes you can,islam as invaded many nations and never left. Maybe you should buy some books on history because it seems you know nothing of history. As a first book get something covering caliphates.
Does that woman ever shut up!
Nope!
A whole interview and she never mentioned being vaxxed
Of course not she BLEEDS once a month 😅
@@briancarr4607 I doubt it now.
heard her say that Tommy Robinson is all about himself, well that comment applies to her far more then TR.
Ben is 100% right. Just turn them around. Government and France have an agreement for safe passage to UK. No safe passage back to France or we stop giving our tax money to France. Sorted
They'd just jump in. I don't think that our agreement with France allows us to enter French waters or for them to enter ours. Border force or the Royal Navy are never just going to let people drown. What kind of person would just sit and watch that? It's easy for reform to criticise everything Sunak does but they've never been in office and likely never will. A Labour government is going to be so much worse.
Yes, stop the bleeding heart BS. Your country is being destroyed in front of you. Wake up.
And threaten to take away fishing lisences
Stop the housing, the money etc, then there"'ll be nothing to leave France for.
@@carolewynn9407I've said that
I am with Ben, rent a gob keeps interrupting him!
The UK is more unsafe them being here!
100% with Ben if you stick a knife in your boat in the middle of the ocean that’s literally isn’t anyone else’s fault but your own
So if they have a knife they are carrying an offensive weapon . That must compound their illegality.
Exactly
They knew the risk and they paid the price I have zero sympathy tbh
cheaper to buy a ferry ticket.......but then again they're already in France illegally ........France want's to to be part of the "open border" EU so let France deal with them ........they're nothing to do with us guv'
Well I hope you’re consistent with this line of thought. I’m sure you’re also against government bailouts for companies, benefits for the poor and doctors saving the lives of patients with self-inflicted injuries? I mean they got in the car, don’t they know those things are death traps? There’s nothing we can do for them, they’ll just have to live with the consequences. And I’m sure you’re all for Donald Trump seeing real jail time, not just a slap on the wrist, but decades. He knew the consequences of his fraud, corruption, solicitation, intimidation and negligence after all.
100% Ben is correct were too soft, we need to act tougher, sorry Julia, otherwise this illegal crossing crap will never ever end
Bens right and the majority of people agree 100%.
Julia doesn't have a point here - she wants them stopped but doesn't have the bottle to stop them when it gets difficult.
I agree with Ben, Reform get my vote.
I think the country will have a big surprise when we have the next general election. I think reform could win a lot of support.
@@Andrew-qg1owmaybe they’ll win “support” but I doubt they’ll win seats, thank god.
If only Ben was the leader, and not Richard Tice, and no involvement with HNH.
"Women and children first...oh there aren't any - just you lads is it?"
-RG
😂 yep , Ricky sums it up in a sentence...
Ben for prime minister
You lost this one, Julia.
I think the majority of people would back Ben.
You sure?
I’m sorry, you think that the MAJORITY of the British public would back drowning immigrants in the English Channel? Thankfully, I think you’ve lost your marbles mate.
Yes they would I would
@@louisdoningtonno hes right I would 😊
Whats wrong with bloody Julia,well said Ben
Julia let Ben explain 😊 your a defeatist
If they are in French waters it is not our duty of care because they are not in our jurisdiction
So let people drown is what you’re saying.smh.🙄 Have the French government clamp down on this with their own boarder force. Some agreement between Britain and France, that might be a start. I mean, throw another dingy in the water….perleeeze. 🙄 😎🇬🇧🇬🇧
The French coast guard are towing these boats into English waters just that that they can wash their hands of the situation.
@@michaelillingworth6433And the RNLI going in to French waters to pick them up.
Even in British waters, they are not our responsibility!
Let them share your house with your children Julia 😊
VOTE REFORM. Happy St George's Day
Disappointed in JHB today.
Me to I'm not watching talk tv anymore gb news for me now
@@BertramG-oz4nu GB News is just as bad. Online Independent news is the only way to get news that doesn't lie to you.
@@BertramG-oz4nu GBNews just as bad, how disgusting Eamon Holmes spoke to Suella yesterday.
@@scoobiedoo8922GB news says it as it is. That's what we need.
i am most days
You're obviously okay with losing our country Julia.
If the migrants jump into the water that is their choice, they have free will. We don't have duty of care to these people. We have duty of care to our own people. Ben is right
The whole country is wide open. Flights, cars, lorries, fishing vessels arriving every where. No one has a clue how many people are living in this country.
80 million plus is a modest guess!
@@nemosays6337 12/14 years ago 4 supermarkets and 1 water company reckoned on 80m. Nearer 100m now.
Your exactly right, all the cuts the tories have made in their time in government has left all services without the people and resources to do a proper job.
@@markcarlon8558 - That's not actually true, we have the people and the resources yet they keep importing more and more to an unsustainable level, so why are they doing this and it's almost the entire so called Western world?
Well simply put they don't see people they see numbers, they don't want freedom at least not for us they want control and they are restocking the pond!
It does seem to be getting rather crowded.
Civilized Julia??? Give it time another10 million, and see how civilised we are then!
Totally agree with Ben - they are choosing to put themselves in danger because they want to come to freebie Britain
Julia... the time for half measures and talk is over! Ben is right... Julia needs to make her mind up... complaining about illegal immigrants then balking at tough measures is pathetic!
If they voluntarily jump into the sea give them a choice, be taken back to France or get left on your own in the water 11 miles from the UK coast.
We can't take them back to France, we can't enter French waters and they can't enter ours.
The Anglo needs to become revolutionary.
Nothing less!
if we dont leave the ECHR it will never happen
Many people feel the sentiments that Ben Habib has expressed.
She's a Hypocrite... 100% I'm not going to watch her again....
Julie you have got that so wrong. Let’s hear your idea to solve this problem
She's the journalist, interviewer and is doing what she is meant to do. I like Ben Habib, but don't understand his argument.
@@simonnicklin1313 yes I agree but a lot of her interviews she does not let the person answer the questions in full
Yeah. Rubbishes Rwanda and then rubbishes this alternative. Her idea would probably to take them back to France. As if they or the French would agree to that.
@@reigninblood123 👍Absolutely, mythought exactly.
I think the thing that she is trying to point out is that just saying 'stop the boats' isn't a plan. We all know that the Royal Navy/Border Force are never going to leave people to drowned. We can't force people to turn around. His plan of giving them a boat that they can't damage is laughable, you'd have just given them something even more sea worthy. Reform do not have a plan for what they'd actually do at the border, that isn't their fault, it is just the nature of the problem. It's easy for them to criticise when they aren't in office.
Simple solution,,drag the boats back to France and leave them on the beaches ,,is that too hard to comprehend !!!
The secret to solving any problem is to start with the biggest threat and work your way down.
The biggest threats to the public are ALWAYS allowed to stay. As recent events have proven time and time again.
The dangers to women and children are always allowed to stay and Rwanda WILL NOT take them
I’m sure the French would have something to say about that…..and you lost the last war with them !
We can't legally enter French waters
@@mrnumba154 So is the RNLI taxi service illegal?
@@trevaudio Helping to liberate France in 1944 spending lives and money was losing?
JHB has lost her marbles.
I support Ben 100%
Fine France for letting them leave their shores, that's a start 👍
Fine France?😂 You can't demand a fine from a foreign country.
Not France's fault, because we lure them over with free hotels and money
Yeah you can. America still fines Cuba today for something they did half a century ago.
I'm with Ben on this, and frankly Julia stretches the argument to bizarre lengths. Stop paying France, and tell them any boats leaving their shores will be returned. Yes, save people mid-channel, but having saved them, return them to France not England. And never forget, these boats are just a distraction for the 750,000 last year that came 'legally' via airports. My town centre is now unrecognisable from just 5 years ago and I really fear what this country will look like when my children are my age.
There is a big push to overwhelm us before the ppl finally wake up
Another legacy of Tony Bliar!! 🤬
No sheff, a legacy of brexit. We had the Dublin 111 agreement which allowed us to return migrants who shouldn't be here. Not a brexit benefit.....
Tony Blair the ghost then never gives up giving to UK politics
@@59patrickw legacy of brexit pat. No Dublin111 agreement, still, that's what you voted for!
@@juliegregory3900ah good ole brexit to blame again, never a missed opportunity blame that.
@@ddanson5831 but that's a fact Dan.....
Go BEn 🇬🇧
Welll said Ben.
The French navy knew the boat was overloaded, why did they not stop it as they are paid millions to do?
Don't understand why JHB was deliberately obstructive on this issue, we cannot continue to operate with a gun to our heads with these outrageous laws
Yep, Blair again. No government elected by us had or has any right to sign us up to be ruled by foreign/international bodies. As Hartley-Brewer says other nations ignore ECHR when it interferes with their national interests.
See noone realises the damage blair did to theUK when he was in power making echr higher than uk law open borders illegal wars devolution terrible pm
Julia is proving just how left-wing she really is
Sorry Julia, I’m with Ben. This country needs to ‘man up’. If anyone deliberately chooses to make a wrong decision in life then there should always be consequences. Anything from jumping into the sea to shoplifting. Rules are rules and we would be a far better country if the government and the police had the balls to enforce them.
Right, if you don't give me a million pounds, I'm gonna jump in front of a moving train??????
I agree with him not Julia
Ben speaks the truth if she shuts up😂 doesn't this tripe also allow the same amount of Rwandans to come here??
I've heard this but it seems to have been swept under the carpet. Also how much are we paying Rwanda ? How much are we paying the French? Either way we're sunk.
Also when the French navy offered help to an overloaded dinghy, the occupants refused saying they wanted to go to England.
Just turn the boats around or put the occupants on the next ferry under armed guard. Maybe they'll try to sink the ferry. Whatever happens it'll cost the UK.
Happy St Georges day everyone, fly your flags (or should we just remove the red cross and fly a white one? 🤔
Seems as if we are already flying the white flag.
Over my dead body, we will never surrender !
That was an L for Julia. She's out of touch if she thinks the majority care for the welfare of the illegals.
she wants a job with Sly News or BBC
BEN FOR PM
Julia Hartley-Brewer, yes we are civilized human beings, but are they?
Time to scrap the house of lords,and get get MPs to support the UK not the EU
£1.8 million per person give me that money any immigrant can have my job my house my life i will leave this country tomorrow
JHB is turning woke, I think she is after Angela Rayners job
And that Julia Fartley Spewer is why you are losing viewers hand over fist 🙄🙄 listen to TNT news radio much better
Stop all the benifits and handouts the boats would stop coming within an hour!!!
Billions on defense but conquered by a dingy invasion.
Parliament hasn't been running this Country for over 30 years.
It is struggling now because the lazy politicians have relied on the EU and The UN to do their job for them.and are now incapable of making up ANY sensible legislation that is workable and doesn't have to be referred to an outside body .(thanks Blair).
At least,with Reform you won't get career politicians just coasting along waiting for their pensions,and we might see some positive changes.
Ben Habib should really be leading Reform.
Dave just wait till the millionaire/billionaires hedgefund managers and property magnates etc ie Reform get in ( hopefully not!) they would only ever look after their own ie wealthy people like them.
If they're picked up by the Royal Navy and trasported back to France which we're allowed to do how will they drown?
Also if they try to jump overboard without a dinghy/life vest it's on the illegal what happens next
The Royal Navy can't legally enter Frenxh waters.
@@mrnumba154 They can escort/pass them back over like the French do to us
@@draper360ify Once they are in our waters France has zero obligation to do that.
@@mrnumba154 Then France is complicit in the human trafficing of illegal immigrants into the uk by escorting them out of their waters to ours and legal action towards the French navy/coastguard needs to be opened
@@mrnumba154spoiler alert..they do. Rnli the Royal Navy for Lethal Illegals do this all the time. They pick em up in France and bring them here...they lost my money donations many years ago now.
💥
100% with Ben.
Please vote Reform , we need Ben or we re finished
How did Ben not win that by-election? The people living there must be halfwits.
You are spot on Ben. We cannot be responsible for these people if they make their own choice to do this.
It sounds horrible but it's not our problem if people are dying on the way here. Don't want to die don’t take the risk. They are perfectly safe in France.
Julia's mask slips quite badly sometimes.
Sunak should be on the first flight - if it ever takes off of course
Starmer too!
Sorry People DIED but 1 it was THEIR FAULT for crossing ..& 2 it was the French's Fault for Allowing them to Cross after ALL the Millions of ££££££££££ we have payed them to stop the Boats yet THEY have done NOTHING
@@SteveGreenwood-gb7dc But they only have to Go Half way Then WE Pick the up ?
I fail to see how a flight to Rwanda will stop the boats coming across the channel. Free holiday what's not to like?
Love you Ben - we need to lead Reform, PLEASE
Phone rings -brrrr brrrr
"Hello, Border Force, how can we help ?"
"If you don't give come and get me, take me to your country, give me a warm bed and food every day, some pocket money, and leave me alone to work in the black economy, I am going to kill myself".
"Ooh Er. Crikey . . . . we'll be right over".
In the name of all that's Holy, it is simply pathetic
Julia Hartley is acting like a traitor to British people
Blair’s name again , he is the problem
Why can’t the French rescued them then?
Ben for uk prime minister ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
When the boats land, they are here for good.
At least we know Julia is now on the 'wrong side'...