Julia Hartley-Brewer: 'Snotty Attitude Of Many To St George's Cross'
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 04. 2024
- Tom Slater and Julia Hartley-Brewer challenge the negative connotations associated with patriotism in the UK, arguing that these are rooted in misdirected snobbery and stereotypes.
Slater contends that middle-class, left-wing ideology views the country as inherently racist and xenophobic, while Hartley-Brewer highlights the pride that ethnic minority Brits have in the flag and notes that this patriotism is often overlooked in the broader national conversation.
#juliahartleybrewer #stgeorgesday #tomslater
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
Are you celebrating St George's Day today?
Of course.
I have my red t shirt on
Damned right I am. My flags are flying high and my wonderful neighbours are black
Yes. I live in Aragon, Spain, where the day is celebrated unashamedly (also in Catalunya)
Yes and I’m voting Khan out
I’m not ashamed of our flag, I’m proud to be English and the Cross of St George is my flag of which I am very proud 🇬🇧🏴🇬🇧🏴🇬🇧🏴🇬🇧🏴🇬🇧🏴
So many hate our flag and heritage, but love our benefit system.
😂😂
All FOREIGNERS but like our BENEFITS MSM SCUM concentrate to much on
LONDONSTANI CAPITAL of PAKISTAN 😂😂😂😂
Mainly everyones favourite 'peaceful' religion.
Well said 😁👍👏👏👏👏❤️🤍💙
And our Legal Aid
I think it's only the box tickers who are having trouble with the flag..I'm English and proud of our history..
Hate any programs on TV that box tick, adverts worse ,gone from milk tray man to the geek or non existing in any family shown
Happy St George's day from Scotland. Be proud of your flag, its yours. Own it. Cheers 🎉
Thank you.
👍👍🏴🏴🇬🇧
I wish others thought like you. I love Scotland. I love England. I hope both survive and prosper, whatever the future holds.
Thank you!
Thank you 😁👍🏻
I’m Irish ☘️ 🇮🇪 and I’ve always wondered why so many English people are embarrassed by St Georges Day? Why isn’t it a national day off? The English have so much to be proud of, celebrate it.
Many of our own look down on English patriotism and our heritage, especially those from the left.
Well maybe for the Protestant suspect against the catholic saints
Unlike Ireland we have soo much more going on in England unfortunately. if your proud to be English and proud of the flag then you get called a racist or far right..or amongst other things. If England wasn’t full of immigrants, foreigners, we wouldn’t have half of these issues or problems. This country is just a big mess.
Always proud to be English 🏴
Me too.
I am not ashamed of the flag, I am English, proud and my class is immaterial. The Americans respect their flag, so do the French, why am I expected to be ashamed.
Because the Marxists have ear marked England for deletion.
Me too mate. As John Lennon said : "..... I'm not proud to be Working Class, but I'm not ashamed of it either."
No embarrassment or shame here; English, loud and proud. 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
And later Talk tv will report on the St George’s day march and refer to it as far right. That’s the double standards of the media
I'll not bet against that
Julia was already setting that up with the now ceremonial referrences to the "far right", every time "conservative" shows talk about our flag. GB News are the same.
I'm yet to meet a mythical proud ethnic minority where I live
@@Lisafer15 A very rare creature indeed. I've seen more dodos.
No Talk tv won't...bbc & the rest yes
Our Total Apathy... and Frankly our Unbelievable Tolerance ...has RUINED This Country....and the British Tax Payer paid for it ALL too.
Nailed it , apathy will be the downfall of the UK.
Exactly Right.
Spot on...We have to STOP and put our own first..END OF..X
We don't care What anyone thinks ,We are English it's our flag ,so TOUGH ,fly your flags proudly ENGLAND 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
👍👏👏👏
He’s only bloody gone and won it on StGeorge’s day, wahooooo, Tommmmyyyy💪💪💪😛♥️♥️♥️♥️🥳🥳🥳🥳
I am super proud to be English, that will never change. 🏴
Flying mine 🏴🏴🏴 . Don't care who I offend
Me too 🤝
Me too.
Went for my daily walk earlier and noticed only my neighbour and I are flying the flag.
When Iwas a young lad and I'm 87 now every flagpole on buildings had a St. George's flag flying, and I'm talking about when there were no bloody lefties.
Bet you benefit from the NHS and Pensions the 'bloody lefties' gifted you. Try not to be ungrateful.
You mean in the Good days ❤..x
Happy St. George's Day 🏴
Im english and proud. And i always fly my flag 🏴
If any body in the UK doesn't like our flags then don't let the door hit you on the way out.
Im English and proud, I've flown the flag out side my house on St George's day for as long as i can remember!
This "snotty attitude" exists primarily in the elitist middle class intellectuals, every one else is fine.
So proud to see these people and towns flying the flag and celebrating.
Definitely NOT ASHAMED of our flag nor if being English!
I am proud of my heritage and all our achievements.
St Georges flag was flown when I was in the Brownies 75 years ago, why do some idiots want to change things to suit themselves.
Happy St. Georges day from Australia. In my small town, we regularly fly the English along the scottish welsh irish along our Aussie and aboriginal flag, all of which make up our heritage and roots. Anyway, be proud England stand up!!!
Happy St George's day from Wales be proud🏴🏴
millions of foreigners hate the flag, and our country, but they all want to live here
Not ashamed, English , patriot and proud.
For everything free, parasites.
What’s wrong with being far right it’s the far left why we are in this state
Absolutely 💯
I wear my George Cross Lapel badge every day, never been ashamed to do so either.
Happy Saint George's day one and all ;)
Love being Anglo Saxon English.
My St Georges flag is up and waving.
As a Welsh man, I think England should be proud of their flag. I work in England and find it strange there are no flags around on St George's Day.
I have Irish, Lebanese and Black people in my family, strangely they all love our country, why… because of the freedoms they enjoy here! they like me, are proud to be British!
Today we celebrate England , other parts of U.K. Have their own special days
I've always said my nationality is English but my citizenship is British.
I am proud to be English/British. Not proud of Gov or people who run us down. We need to show how proud we are.
If the police stopped taking the flags from people they might get a chance to wave it.
Yeah at least today they get to wave their flag without being arrested( hopefully)
I'm not ashamed of my flag. No amount of gaslighting will change that.
The Anglo needs to become revolutionary.
Nothing less.
It's what Sunake wants..
And when it all eventually all boils over it will.
St George and the dragon is even on some of British army regiments cap badges . They celebrate St George day with the real pride of being English.
One of my neighbours flys the flag either Union flag or English flag every day and it always makes me feel happy when i see it flying
I live in Middle class England and we can have pride in our homeland
Only in London Julia
Happy St George’s day from Ireland
Proud to be English born.🏴 family been around since 1500s😊
long live england
Going to Whitehall at 3 with my St George's flag
🏴have an awesome St George’s Day 🏴
I’m very proud of today, I have my flags outside to celebrate 🏴
I’m proud of you, Flying from my balcony
Not far right just patriots and proud of our country and I am not far right.
Its only the middle class left and the Establishment classes who are embarrassed. Us working class are very proud...
Talk TV please understand the difference....
U are working class, and a patriot? But your employers are embarrassed to be patriotic? Ever wondered why they are embarrassed? Maybe if you thought like them u wouldn't have to break your back working for a living
@@minkshultz Another moronic comment from a Guardian reading prick. Yes I am from a working class background by do a middle management job and live in a wealthy suburb of West London....Notice I said middle class LEFT! The middle class right and the upper classes are generally patriotic. You are a patronising condescending idiot.
The English identity is suppressed because they are the majority. The Union Jack was normally used by the BNP not the SGC. Often socialist regimes feel the need to suppress majority groups.
'Majority groups' don't make me laugh, you can't get enough votes to elect MP's.
@@Titus9508 Thats because they have no confidence in the corrupt system
I am and have 2 St. George flags in the front garden and boy they look magnificent
Question?:? Could this be because of what is being taught in their schools
Happy Saint Georges Day To All.🌹🇬🇧
Not a single article on the BBC front page about St George's Day, but there is one about a transgender muslim and one on dominican gay rights.
And they wonder why they're losing licence payers.
Stop the benefits then you will see them leave in thousands
Yeah all the ones waving English flags are on benefits 😂
If we love our county, we are not far right.
🏴🏴🏴🏴
I remember a chant, Give me hope in my heart keep me English,give me hope in my heart i pray, Give me hope in my heart keep me English, keep me ENGLISH till my dieing day.
Cant even buy one in shops got mine on line
I'm exceptionally proud to be indigenous of this country. I'm exceptionally proud and humbled by those who fought hard & gave their lives for us.
I'm disgusted by those in government, councils & mayorships who don't hold the same values or religion as we do, trying to stop us from celebrating our own history and way of life.
HAPPY ST GEORGES DAY, TO ALL FELLOW PATRIOTS PROUD TO BRITISH BORN & BRED 🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑🏴🇬🇧👑
Crazy that some people think we shouldn’t be proud of our flag
Its also anti Christian. You have to ask the question why an English parliament is not allowed.
My St George flag is flying proudly . Meanwhile in Manningham, Bradford, an islamist is standing for election.
I have not been to look, but I bet my Lefty town hall is not flying it, but is still flying the Ukraine flag.
God bless British history and culture
Maybe it’s because we have so many Foreigners here who dislike us???
Fly it be proud.
It's absolutely shocking that this is even up for debate.
I'm not personally but love that other people are it lifts my spirits
I find it ridiculous that the Scottish, Welsh, and Irish are proud to fly their flags, but many English feel the flag is a symbol of colonialism and empire. If you read the history of the British Empire, you will find that a huge number of the key figures were Scottish, Irish, or Welsh. Hell, Arthur Wellesley, the Duke of Wellington, was Irish!! The English need to develop a backbone and be proud of their history!!!
Americans celebrate St Patrick in a big way even Joe " go brandon" is proud to be Irish although he claims he's not stupid.
Happy St Georges Day
I've lived away from England for over 30 years but am still proud to be British and have the St George's and Union Jack flags on my Spanish car. It is not a class thing and I am no racist. It's just how I proudly identify being a foreigner abroad.
I don't know anyone whose ashamed of our flag.
White Christian Britain Stand Up!! 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Save the NHS, the Jewel in Britain's Crown.
England is a wonderful, beautiful country with an extraordinary history and accomplishments not just for the country but for the whole of humankind. I DO CELEBRATE AND HONOUR IT.. a shame and dishonour to those who constantly attack the flag, they should move and leave this beautiful land to us, the ones who want to make it better, the ones who love it and celebrate it. England deserves to be celebrated, respected and honoured.. Happy St Georges's day to all
Only Pali flag is allowed
I love your flag.
@@edda682 I’m a big fan of the UK. please don’t let them ruin it.
@@themossad dont worry, no one is ruining it. Everyone has freedoms here....
@@Sal19732 sure, I can see...
@@Sal19732 Not everyone.
We are called racist or far right for wanting to celebrate our country with its beautiful culture 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
I couldn't even buy a Flag around my area, Lewes, Brighton. I think they think we are far right and racists if we wave a flag. Asylum seekers are risking their lives to get here, we were a nation of carers and saviours to peoples in need. We now feel ashamed that we can't even look after ourselves. Do people feel ashamed of being English ??
NEVER..IM PROUD OF MY COUNTRY ❤..
White working class? Snotty? What utter tosh!! I am proud of my flag and I love my country. Why is it that we are not allowed to be patriotic? People who hate this country have the view that it's colonialism, or that it excludes others. That's missing the point completely. Am I proud of everything we have done in our history? No of course not. Show me a country that has never done anything bad or wrong in some way, all have. But I am proud of the good things we have done, and that's why I'm proud of my country and my flag. I am not proud of the way the country is being run but who we are as a people, not politicians, but the ordinary people and the good that people have done for this country and it's people, yes I am proud. So Happy St George's Day everyone!
If you don't like it, move out and that goes for politicians to and to the police.
It must be a generational thing- I’m the only person in my road flying the flag - and am proud of our country and history with all its faults and attributes- it makes me wonder about our large population- WHY WHEN EVERYONE HATES THIS COUNTRY aren’t they leaving ???????
No shame here regarding my country's flag, it flew high in my front garden on St Georges day and will continue every year 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
I'm not ashamed of our England flag I'm English and this is my flag and I'm not racist just proud
I'm glad to say that you're wrong, Julie. It's not an awful lot of people who dislike the national flag of England.
It's only a very small minority probably only about 8% of the British people.
The problem is that we live in a minority rule clown world, and the minority has the way, and the means to shout the loudest to make themselves heard, making themselves seem like the majority, or the many.
The fact is the silent majority have been allowing them to get away with it for so long now that they actually believe that they are the majority and that most of the British people are on the same page as them.
Pretty in pink, Good in green, Racy in red, Bonny in blue, whatever the colour, it just suits you.
Those ashamed of their own flag should be visited by two police and a mental health professional 👍🇬🇧🤔
🎉🎉🎉🎉 be proud to be British and English im Welsh god bless the st George day
Proud to be English, proud of our flag! Possibly because I was brought up with a sense of pride! Those who attack are flag and live in England can leave anytime they like and reside under a national flag that supports their culture ! 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
🏴✝️⚔️🏴. Angelcynn Modignes
We are the people 🏴
I live in the Philippines and fly the English flag Happy St George's Day
I'm English first British second. I'm ex Scots guards so love all my Scottish, Welsh and Irish brothers. But the flag is my flag. 😊
England has the best music conservatoires in the world, such as the Royal College of Music and Royal Academy of Music, where students from all over the World come to study! As a musician, I'm very proud to be English! 🏴
If you were unfortunate enough to be on a Transatlantic slave ship in the 1800s shackled in chains below decks could you imagine the excitement when a Royal Navy Ensign Flag (featuring the Cross of St George) was spotted on a ship in the distance..... Yes, middle class lefties it was the Royal Navy who single handily STOPPED the slave trade.....
After the Atlantic trade was abolished they switched to the Indian Ocean and put an end to the very cruel slave trade where the Arabs would castrate all the Africans they captured.
We should be proud of what this flag represents! ......(not how the BBC/Guardian left wing alliance portray it)
Born by birth
English by the grace of God
Julia, I'm currently in France and you need to see the lengths they go to to celebrate St Georges Day here. It puts the UK to shame. Of course it may be our "National " flag but St George is also the Patron Saint of: Albania, Bulgaria, England, Ethiopia, Greece, Georgia, Portugal, Romania, Syria, Lebanon, Catalonia, Alcoi, Aragon and Rio de Janeiro. I'm absolutely thrilled that we all feel the brotherhood of St, George and welcome the unity of all those patrons from all those countroes with open arms. Hooray for some common sense at last.
I am Welsh and proud of our ST DAVIDS DAY, hope all you guys in England have a great day, happy ST GEORGE'S DAY
And yet England hasn’t got its own official national anthem unlike wales and Scotland. Why can’t the English have it?
God save the king is the British national anthem!
It's been discussed in parliament on many occasions, usually in private members bills, the latest in 2016 by a Labour MP! I don't think any of them reached the voting stage.
Because the powers that be want us to think British not English..it's brainwashing
We're experiencing the same issue in the US where our OWN flag is being mocked, and the Betsy Ross flag in particular seems to draw a lot of ire towards it (for some unknown reason) Be proud of who you are. I'm not even British, and I hate what Britain has become as of late.