AMC's The Walking Dead VS Telltale' s The Walking Dead
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 05. 2024
- AMC's The Walking Dead VS Telltale' s The Walking Dead
Subscribe: goo.gl/Q2kKrD
CHECK OUT WATCHMOJO'S NEW BOOK, LINKS BELOW!
What has a better stort, AMC's The Walking Dead tv series or Telltale's Walking Dead video game? WatchMojo compares the two fantasstic outings based on The Walking Dead comic book by Robert Kirkman to figure out which one is not only the better adaptation but also which version stands on it's own with the best characters, stories and moments. It was no easy task to put the likes of Daryl Dixon and Carol up against Clementine and Lee Everett, not to mention all the best deaths, zombie kills and shocking moments. Join WatchMojo as we pair these two series against each other to decide which is the best Walking Dead.
The 10-Year Overnight Success: An Entrepreneur's Manifesto: How WatchMojo Built The Most Successful Media Brand On CZcams
PAPERBACK: goo.gl/93prjz
KINDLE: goo.gl/Hs1hKq
If you've never used the Kindle App before, now's your chance to CHECK it out for FREE! CLICK: goo.gl/WmULsn
Special thanks to our user DaveVsTheWorld for suggesting this idea, check out the voting page at watchmojo.com/suggest/AMC's+Th...
WatchMojo's Social Media Pages
/ watchmojo
/ watchmojo
/ watchmojo
Get WatchMojo merchandise at watchmojo.com/store/
WatchMojo’s ten thousand videos on Top 10 lists, Origins, Biographies, Tips, How To’s, Reviews, Commentary and more on Pop Culture, Celebrity, Movies, Music, TV, Film, Video Games, Politics, News, Comics, Superheroes. Your trusted authority on ranking Pop Culture. - Hry
The comics and game would be a better comparison.
Deathpool_04 this game also based on a comics book
Nishan Hoq lee or clementine are not in the comics
Nishan Hoq even tho the game is written by kirkman also tho
Deathpool_04 the game nor the tv show can beat the comics!
lol that would be a shitstorm
Telltale's The Walking Dead is amazing, I will always prefer it over the show.
TheComicBookGuy It's so hard to wait for though
Aaron Keith Believe me, I know, but it's worth it.
Who asked you?
Fake name I was just giving my personal preference.
Fake name Thats what you do in a commentsection; Commenting
Glenn was from Lee's story, when he left to go find his friends in Atlanta he met Rick shortly after.
@@nizhgaming9267 why are you mad?
@@uhejay cause he obviously spoiled him such like me
@@pvpwm5703 oh ok
Pvp wm that was literally no Spoiler
No he was always with his friends don't make up crap
I'm gonna miss telltale and their games :(
Skybound is continuing TWD season 4
Telltale man! No Discussion
I thought you're dead
Wtf
Eemmm GTA SAN ANDREAS YOU BIG SPOCKKKK NO NO NO KOCK AHAHHAHA
Nice car smoke
Telltale's The Walking Dead is the only video game to ever make me cry.
I didn't cry because I was in emotional pain for a few days instead. I don't know which is worse.
Tecosaurus No kidding. Games sticks with you forever. Not very many games do the same
I cri erytim
I didn't cry...thought it was stupid....
Bob Tom cool for you you dumbass
Telltale isn't afraid to kill off an extremely main character (Lee) but Amc is too scared of what the fans will do if they kill off Daryl or Rick.
1K with no videos it's much easier to kill a character in a game that you planned to kill off from the start, from a main character that we've been with since the very first episode and season in the show I prefer the game more btw
1K with no videos even thou they killed off Glenn and Abraham?
1K with no videos and now look what happened to Glenn
1K with no videos I don't see how that's a positive for a game or series.
Daryl was not supposed to be alive pass season 2, the only reason he is still there its because his character sell a lot, but like a lot of derived products. So in other words he gives a lot of money to AMC.
I miss kenny and lee :(
I miss everyone
Same to me😭
Don't we all
X gaming X How about the Wellington option? Kenny never had a death scene in that option.
me too :(
So basically...
A zombie story featuring a man of the law as the main character
Vs
A zombie story featuring a man who broke the law as the main character
if i was president, i would make it legal on my country to kill their wife's affair partner because fuck manipulative hoes. lee dosent deserve this.
@@theshycryo not the lover
Shawn slept with Lori and Rick killed him But let's not talk about that 😂
I SAVED MY WHOLE GROUP WHAT DO YOU MEAN.
@Megagirlgamer *Shane and plus he only did that because he thought that Rick had died.. + Rick forgave him and gave him chance after chance
I'm not the only one who teared up when they showed the final Lee and Clementine scene, right?
I didnt feel a thing
Zodiac spear no I cried from old memories :'-(
Beastly Form same
Zodiac spear I think only about .00001% of the ppl who played season 1 didn't cry
Zodiac spear No I was crying xD i was so sad for the whole day thinking about it
the thing that sucks about the show is if you see Rick and Daryl surrounded by a huge horde you know they'll most likely make it out okay where in the game you don't know that
Adrian Castro rick is likely to die at the end especially in the comic book series
Bill Cipher ya but he'll probably die of old age or something in the comics cause the comics are peaceful now after A New Beginning
manboy manboy of course it isn't but things aren't just chaos like all out war. Alexandria is pretty peaceful if you ask me.
A.K.D Not in the show. He will die before the end. The writer said so.
A.K.D *NEW WORLD ORDER*
Telltale hands down
No media has made me feel actual deep emotions and I actually cared about everyone
When that first season ended...I was depressed for 3 days
Silent Mochi it’s back ;)
SAME
@@Its_Myles539 You're a dumbass if you think that
The amc tv show is better compear the comics & telltale game!
@@Ianfriends-gs1wj no it definitely is not
Lee and Clem have the best relationship. Man I cried like a baby when Clem had that dream about Lee in Season 2.
You mean season 4?
Glad to know I'm not alone
The game is more emotional and sad...I'll tell you that.
Saquib Bhuiyan you got that right I'm still getting over kenny and lee's death
Pet Lover64 they fucked up Kenny's death in S3
Saquib Bhuiyan yeah they did i guess Kenny doesn't think it's safe to wear a seatbelt while teaching a child to drive
Common sense Kenny common sense
Pet Lover64 Telltale was lazy and drunk when making that scene...
Pet Lover64 kenny took it off to look at AJ, because he wasn't speaking.
Round 6: Characters.
Clementine.
Need I say more?
Telltale claims this round.
Kenny.. bitch Pls
Lee is the best
Shadow Spector agreed
Sarah
Darly machoine negan The govener Carl is like Clem One chacter can't beat a hole cast
As much as i love both the Game & TV show, playing the 1st Season of the Game years ago is what got me into the walking dead as a whole .
The game is my favorite, Then the comics And I've never seen the tv show cuz I dont own netflix and its not on my cable.
Michael Gualtieri same
Honestly same
I became obsessed with the entire twd universe after playing the first season
@@hashtheduck the tv show is on Disney + now which owned AMC.
They should make the telltale version of TWD into a movie
No
It already was a movie lol but facts. Id be down to see a live action movie
Or make the show into game
They better not fucked it up if they plan it
A show would better, because movies have limited time, and wouldn't be enough to fulfill the entire story
I enjoyed the first season of telltale alone even more than the entire amc series
Yeah, it's not even a competition. Far, far better
theCatastrophe yep
Same
lmao true
The problem is that amc is so focused on pumping out episodes, they forgot the quality as a whole
lee's death beats the whole season of amc's. that's all you need.
Carl dying was more tragic.
Pfft... Don't even try to compare Carl's death to Lee's
Lee dying was most tragic Especially when says He will miss her. 😢😢😢😢
Jason Bodine Carl was basically a meat log with an eye and Lee was a roasted steak compared to Carl’s raw turkey gizzard with flies buzzing around it.
I agree with you on that
My mom hates video games... And she says that telltale is better than AMC.
Well shes right about the telltale is better😏
@@sweetpop_1314 no
Thomarhork it’s not but I do prefer telltale
Sincerely, Fuego oh cool, does she play Telltale?
Kimmy -Splat Queen AMC has a really good story and its also very emotional unlike telltale. If it wasn’t for TWD comics/show there wouldn’t be a game.
Glenn comes from Lee's story, Telltale for ever.
The game takes place in the comic universe, not the TV show.
@@lacobus779 that doesn't change anything about that statement said lol.
no lol fucking idiots havent even watched the show ?
Clementine THE GAME IS BETTER !
Zhygop and Hershel but only for like two 5-10 minute scenes.
The end of TWD telltale season 1 is so sad I cried during that
Mario the Plumber yeah only heartless kids didn't cry
Pet Lover64 ikr
Mario the Plumber idk why but I cried over Kenny asking you to stay at Wellington more than Lee's death
desantis101 I cried at both but more at lee's death
Urban Clementine holy shit, you grew a beard!
Telltale's, I have always been a fan. ♥
U Are clementine . U were a fan of u from The beggining XD 😂😂 . Better than "CORAL!!!!"
Russian George But of course, haha
Russian George no
Well of course you're a fan, you're the main character.
Clementine
I'd think that judging by your... yourself
the LEE-gend
ok i’ll show myself out
NO STAY PLEASE
Mandy Rose u suck
...
It's clemenTIME for you to LEEve
Stay we all need the Leegend
AJ WIN THE SHOCKING MOMENTS
HAHAHAHA
He literally blew Marlon's brains out
Thanks!
@@idonotcare1871 he kill tenn also cause he knew tenn will be a problem to others again. Moreover he didn't let clem died. Probably the smartest kid character in a game .
I like season 3 AJ but not season 4 AJ
Why do I have a feeling that haters of TWD show are going to be all over the comments
apparently its already happenning.
Tony Koslowski ARE YOU FROM THE FUTURE??!!
because people like to say a show sucks even though they watch every week lol
Tony Koslowski haha telltale beats the show u lose
Prince Ashitaka how?
Lee 4 ever
Javier Ibarra IKR
Kek
Javier Ibarra yep
Lee is in a better place now.
Truee
if this was updated now, Telltale would win round 4 after the finale lol
Because they knew when to stop.
I'm late but have you even watched the show
@@victorleanos9405 late reply but the show knows when to end, read the comics and stop spewing BS weeb
@@mikeamber2528 you’re a bit late my g
@@Chrollo23 that's why I said 'late reply' buddy
WHYY LEE?! WHY U HAVE TO DIE?!
1like = 1 happy ending for Lee and Clementine
Damn only 9
;-;
O O F
lee and luke deserved better
TellTale's The Walking Dead is the only game in history to have made me cry... I am so glad you chose that.
Dr. Virus 129 same lol
Dr. Virus 129 The Last of Us?
Volkan Polat yea that fucking game is sad as fuck
you never played FFVII?
No. The show is better.
Fear the walking dead should have followed the telltale series
The game is far better than fear the walking dead
Uhohhotdog Gaming ikr
Uhohhotdog Gaming i only watch fear the walking dead just because they go to México
no shit sherlock
Uhohhotdog Gaming But the telltale games arent done yet
Telltale's emphasized more on the characters' relationships while AMC's is more action packed and story based. The proof is at the ending of WD season 4 by telltale, most players cry. I never cried on a game before and I cried too, it's great watching how much Clem had grown. While AMC's WD always keep me wondering what will happen next. Both of them are good and I wish them the best luck in the future
I think show is better cause maincharacters do not die so soon but im talking about the show before season 7 when it got downhill. If lee or kenny would survived in season 4 the game would be much better than show
@@pena380 The show is great in seasons 9-10 as well
The show also has character relationships
Maggie and carol
Daryl and carol
Daryl and Maggie
Maggie and Judith
Daryl and Judith
@@mattycraig1544 yeah but unfortunatelly, without Rick and Carl Grimmes since season 8 and the middle of season 9, it is not the same anymore , at least for my point of view.
@@rafaelarcas942 facts
did you know that amc chracters twd glenn,hershel and jesus where appeared in twd game
that was comic book characters
@@Azrael777_ but Glenn was in the game thought
@@ZzombieGurl yeah they look more like their comic book versions not tv show. It even says the game is based off the comic book.
Gddjdud
Based off comics
no matter what you AMC Walking Dead Fanboys say Telltale Walking Dead was more Emotional in Every Way😢😢😢
the show tosses plot and good writing out the window for the cheap thrill of seeing a side character die in a "gruesome" way
Aron TheDarkNight Better deaths and villains I agree, but survivors? Hell no, the game has better survivors
The show tosses the plot around. What part of the plot is tossed around if you care to elaborate. If anything the game had no real plot especially in season 1 by moving around looking for clems parents with a lot of choices being meaninless
Telltales Walking Dead had better survivors than AMC's Walking Dead.
Omid, Lee, Jane & Kenny > Rick, Daryl, Michonne & Abraham
Zeno-Sama who gives a fuck about emotional. The show is 100% better
Telltale's the walking dead is defiantly better. I used to love the TV series, but then everything started to feel very boring and bland, and with the series being too chicken to kill off main characters like Rick and Daryl. But telltale, it doesn't shy away from that, and we grow genuine bonds with many of the characters. And we feel the struggles they go through more and feel happy with them when they accomplish something. And we especially cry when they have to die.(I was bawling when Lee died.) and even if we get choices in the Telltale game, we still can't stop the deaths of characters we grow to truely love. And they know how to make things tense and threatening. And the telltale game isn't filled with filler like the show is.
***** And yet they didn't kill Daryl. And they never will. Because they know that if they do, the show will lose many fans. Their just pandering to the fans now.
Brianna Chiavetta also rick can't die. if rick was to die, then the show would end.
McKenna DeBiase Lee, the main character of the telltale Walking dead series died and it's still going. So your argument is invalid.
Yet these "chickens" killed off fucking glenn.
They already killed so many major characters, they don't need to kill any more off.
I swear if Telltale don’t win all of the rounds then this is rigged..
*This is rigged*
It would just be an opinion.
Telltale is crap.
@@bo0stard571 no it not it way better than the show
@@boyanpetrov1683 no. People that like a video game that looks like a childs drawing better than a real show with more characters and more complex stories don t know what they talking about. I don t think they even watched the show if they say it is bad.
@@bo0stard571 cuz it really is bad everybody stopped watching cause it's so repetitive.
They both had good first seasons. I can tell you that.
That is true. The first season of AMC’s was certainly suspenseful, with the disappearance of Merle on the roof, to the attack on the camp, to the explosion of the lab, it was all a great way to start the series off. Telltale mastered the emotion of the series. They make you love and hate the characters, and then kill them in sad ways. Carley or Doug gets taken by the horde. The one that you saved gets shot by Lilly, Duck’s death scene, that all was heartbreaking to see. They both had amazing first seasons.
A Complete and Utter Failure yet telltales never messed a season up lmao
@@3120dd season 3
@@TrickbotGaming season three's purpose was to show clem that there are still families out there who is still together. clem was so lost at that time, losing AJ and all. not just because clem isnt the playable character, it's horrible.
@@jhem7557 season 3 was by far worst
oh my god they killed Kenny!!!
SSJ Ragnarok YOU KILL KENNY
Only a douche would kill Kenny. Jane had it coming. Ignoring the fact that she gives shitty advice and would never sacrifice her life for Clemintine like Lee or Kenny would, she also clearly cannot be trusted since she lies in the finale. And this was a huge lie that cost somebody their life.
I chose to "Look Away", not knowing that Kenny was going to *kill* Jane. I got angry, so I killed Kenny. I was the one dude out of my friend group that killed Jane and Kenny......
Super Saiyan Goddess Truer words were never spoken.
SSJ Ragnarok why tf would you kill Kenny
Lee and clementine are so cute :/ I miss them
Garrett Sampson I miss the old her tbh.
yeah I miss their sergeant father and daughter- like relationship and now after season 2 I miss her other one too dam it telltale stop breaking my heart over these characters : (
danielle Patrick hmm
Hello ?
I think. . . Clementine is alive, I think, I *TOTALLY* do not know if she is but *I THINK*
RIP Scott Wilson who played Hershel
Yea that's sad but hershel was a useless character tho
@@JackMarstonIsCool .
The reason why telltales the walking dead is my favorite game OF ALL TIME, and beats the TV show by far. Is because of the connection the players have with the characters, most companies would do anything to have that.
I hate how this was made right before TWDG season 3 came out -_-
Clementine I KNOW RIGHT I CHECKED THE DATE OF THE VID and im like god damn exactly a month away if only they included s3 TOO
Omg yes!
Clementine yeah the death of Mariana would have made us win by even further in the shocking round
Faggot Sings I don't know, S3 was not great honestly, the only memorable events were Mariana's death and Javier saying "I love you" to David, those were the only moments where I felt what the characters were feeling, when in the first two season I was always at 100% with Lee and Clem.
Florent3571 To be honest, hearing Javier say "I love you" again and again after taking so many hits actually made me chuckle. But I can understand why that scene would be emotional. It shows that Javier loves his brother so much, that he's willing to get hurt for him -- nay, get hurt BY him -- if that's the only way to make David see it.
Also, even though Mariana's death was kinda shocking, it wasn't too difficult to bear because I felt like we didn't really get to know her. Surprisingly enough, I thought the saddest part in the game was when Gabe died (I say it's surprising because Gabe wasn't exactly one of my favorite characters). But even then, I didn't think his death was THAT sad.
In addition, killing off Kenny/Jane the way they did made it feel lazy and rushed, like they just needed an excuse to get rid of them. Furthermore, only Kenny was given the courtesy of having his unstable personality COMPLETELY reversed as if it was never there, whereas Jane didn't change AT ALL despite having shown positive character development throughout Season 2, which I thought was rather unfair. I felt like the writers were just being biased because they knew most people chose Kenny, and so they were just trying to appease them. But either way, neither the deaths of Kenny nor Jane was well-thought out.
Also, not enough Clementine.
Overall, Season 3 just wasn't as good as the first two seasons. Now to be fair, Season 3's story is actually pretty solid compared to most video games, and the voice acting is great as usual. But the problem with Season 3 is that the writing felt rushed, while also lacking that heavy, emotional substance the Walking Dead series is known for. Season 3 felt less like a survival story, and more like a family drama.
Lee:Rick
Clem:Carl
Kenny:Darald
Michonne:Michonne
Rick is more like Kenny
Clem is her own uniqueness which makes her special
Daryl is like Luke
Rick went insane and so did Kenny. Appropriate Fitting Instant.Michael
Glenn:Glenn
Negan:Glenn
oh wait..
he's dead
Kelly Jelly kenny is nothing like Daryl lmao.
I prefer Telltale's by far.
nah
You're both wrong the comics are better
Darrion Lee, I like the comics as much as I like the Telltales Walking Dead video game series, but I hate the AMC Walking Dead the most.
Telltale is best
Amc Show is better
Telltales
Lee Everett TELLTALES WINS THIS WAR CASE CLOSED
HURRAY!!!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
john paul songayab yep remember s1 of twdg got over 90 awards😚
👏
No kidding. You are lee
Amc
TELLTALE! IT'S THE ONLY GAME THAT HAS EVER MADE ME CRY! GOOD ANIMATIONS, STORY AND SO UGHH LEEEEEEE!!
shocking moments should have gone to telltale because the tv series all the shocking moments were basically all just deaths..
I would disagree i like telltale but amc had the most shocking.
list some
How do i list them, you do not watch amc. Unexpected shooting, Characters are unpredictable,and plot twists. Helicopter men crashed one of them gets picked up to a town of people, then that one injured guy tells them where they are (His other friends), then they go to the group, acting friendly then, they shoot all of them. That was shocking. I could name more but i have not watched that much. But i am a unbiased person. I think amc has more shocking moments, Its a big long unending movie, so more room for shocking moments.
Of course AMC's has more shocking moments, it has 7 seasons while TellTale's has 2, and still in terms of quality the Videogame shocking moments are better
Clementine... nough said
aDm yes
Hell Yes
aDm and lee
No, the series has also his memorable characters
NO.
Lee's death😣
Lee❤❤❤:I'll miss you
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Eva Hernandez 6 words. Stop with emojis.
@@ploobus194 NO WAY!!!!!:(((((
Eva Hernandez I agree I loved lee
R.i.p Lee you will be missed :_(
@@shun07 just sayin, you have an amazing name 10/10 xD
Telltale any day of the week.
Twice on Sundays.
Both versions are great in their own way.
Sylviia 24
Yes, that's a given.
Sylviia 24 ikr Glenn was featured in the telltale game
THANK YOU!
Wolly Wolf123 So was Hershel.
Sylviia 24 yep
Teltale's walking dead is best... Its so much good story and even sad...
I totally disagree but I'll still like your comment because of your profile picture and your username.
Especially their ost
@@ethanrobert342 i never knew normal pokemon can talk
@ and sadness doesn't make something better
@@Trollgaming1987 was that a roast?
Rip Lee
Rip Kenny
Rip Mariana
Rip telltale
unRIP Telltale
Well I've never watched the show, but I'm obsessed with the game, even though they killed most of my favourite characters off.
Really, the show vs the game?
Aron TheDarkNight I've really been enjoying the comic, and I do like the game, but to compare a game to a tv show is kind of odd for me, personally though I found the comic a lot more shocking than either, like that Thomas guy from the prison he was a lot more horrific in the comic than he was in the show same for governor, clearly the show changed a hell lot from the comic, Judith isn't even alive anymore in the comic
AMC's has more fans then the game. The game sucked dick when my choice doesn't affect shit. Fuck the piece of shit game.
game is a lot better I still like the show to though
shame butt hurt fans look at how one of their choices didn't matter and call the game a piece of shit then again everyone has opinions
the game will always be better
the game is way bette rthan that wack ass show...
Here's the summary of AMC's version: "CARL!!!!!!"
Sir Timothy I think you mean "CORAL" 😂😂😂😂
+matthew giammatteo I never knew AMC was so interrested in underwater life.
Quickman 26 I see what you did there I shall give you a round of applause 👏 you deserve it
+Jake Nimroy Thanks man. I appreciate it.
Sir Timothy Coral
This isn’t even a contest, the game is way better than the show
how?
The show is longer than all the seasons of the game
Which means more character development
The game basically just killed everyone besides clem
I watched the game before the show and some how the show is still better to me
takeover 世界 because the game is more interesting and even if it isn’t as long you feel more emotionally attached to the characters in the game then in the show
Its your opinion so i cant really argue back
😂. But what im saying is, since a game is a game and a show is a show. The game is focus more on gameplay while the show is focus more chararcter development because it is wayyy longer. Thats why up to s4 of twd game, every main og characters died besides clem and aj. The game is made because of the show too
King Tyrone ur wrong
Lee’s story is better at emotionally reeling in the audience, in just about 10 hours you have felt like you have known these characters forever and in the end, Lee’s death is extremely heartbreaking
clem would beat carl any day of the week dude he is nothing compared he has people while clem is left with no one in season three
SloppyPiggy123 carl has better aim cause he has 1 eye
SloppyPiggy123 how carl massacres negans men he
Also gets shot in the eye and in the chest and survives
Carl is dead now fellas dat pussy got himself killed doing hippie shit with walkers in the woods
Trump of Rivia As a great fan of the games, Clem could still die in season 4. Of course, I hope not, but the main character of a season dying is nothing new to Telltale's TWD games...
Telltale. They can do whatever they want and they do. They took advantage of the story and made it cooler.
John Mendoza I agree
J's Doodles agree but they did some forced character death that piss me off by that I mean season 2 version of Lee and both of the option resulted in him dying.(not saying it because of spoilers but I'm just going to say death by drowning im ice cold water)
i mean... the show sorta took advantage of the comics
Gr1m Reaper008 yeah but they needed permission from the creator Robert Kirkman. That gave us the comics
*Pfft, Rick cannot beat the almightly Lee-gend.*
@@nizhgaming9267 the fuck? lee is better lol.
Lord Felix 😭😭damn i just laughed out loud. you can’t compare them.
@@theshycryo Actually even if they didn't choose to end Lee I think he would never have a character development such as Rick's.
Lee is far better than Rick
@@tomoca1246 comic's Rick is a fuckin' legend, but in this video we're talking about the TV one. He's nothing compared to Lee
I cried at clementines lee flashback at the train😭😭😭😫
I really prefer Telltales TWD tbh.
Jayem Same
AmandaR.55 me too
That's what they chose
Jayem yes me too
IK!
The spinoff show of the walking dead should have been based off the game , not fear the walking dead .
Captain Malcolm Reynolds that would be awesome someone needs to make that happen
keep in mind amc came first
Captain Malcolm Reynolds Yea, I agree 100% they really should've done that based off the game. I would watch it a lot more than the AMC TWD version
The purpose of the game is to give you a chance to choose your story. If the spinoff was based of the game, it would have to canonize choices and outcomes.
Twd game is set in the comic universe not tv show universe
Lee > Rick
I said it.
I mean it.
You can't change my mind.
And who said you are wrong
There are only 2 video games that I've played in my entire life that made me cry: Walking Dead game season 1, and Red Dead Redemption 2.
Walking Dead TV show has never made me cry, but I have felt shock and sadness.
So for me, the game wins.
I wish telltale would realease their episodes faster
Fresh Chadaugi yeah I can't wait for the next episode in season 3
Lick Im still tryna get with David's wife lowkey tho
Lick yeah when i see david as a boss of the new frontier i scream like crazy can't wait for ep 3
I bet David's face when they tell him his own people killed his daughter is gonna be the next new meme
10:10 am I like it how episode 5 came out a few days ago
The game! It has so much more emotion and I’m attached to the characters more! Telltale is so much better💖
Alyssa Dawn facts
IKR@Thor Foræder
We should do a rematch after the finish of the fourth season
•The game •Season 1: AMAZING FUCKING MASTERPIECE
Season 2: ALSO AMAZING
Season 3: JAVI!!!!
Season 4: I STILL CANT STOP CRYING
then watches the show
.....holy shit this is awesome
Norris Nastac read the comics.
This is me
the show or game?
for me show
S2 DISAPPOINTED
S3 MAJOR FLOP SUCKED
S4 GOOD
@@alexprime5015 game or show? cuz in the show all sesons are good ( well 7 and 8 not really but yeah)
One thing in the game that I've always loved over the TV series is the constant remembrance of how much of a problem lack of food is, especially when you have to give 4 things to 10 people. It really sheds lots of light on more realistic issues that would plague someone in an apocalypse.
YEAH!!! Telltale games will remember this!
Telltale's the walking dead has better structure in storytelling and I don't cringe everytime they do a serious dialogue.
Video game is actually wayyy wayyyy better than the original series
I don't know why people are saying how can you compare the two, we'll both of them are based off the comic
Theodore Williams except the game isn't though
Yonatan Bash technically the concept is still the same even with different characters. It's about people interacting with other people in a zombie apocalypse
The Telltale games take place in the same universe as the comics. Even has cameo appearances of comic book characters like Glenn.
Yonatan Bash It also still takes place in the comic universe. They still exist in the same time as the comic book events
technically it is though
In a gunfight, rick would win. In melee, lee's got it hands down.
+Rick Dixon no way lee will kill rick in a hand hand fight
Phamquest are you stupid Rick is the boi
Rick is 4 years into the ZA and Lee is 3 months so Rick would win, but seasons 1 or 2 Rick would be crushed by Lee
Lee will win in close combat. In S1 E4, he can take down Molly who is a very good scavenger.
Phamquest
Lee was a beast and Rick got beat up by that governer punk... So i agree.
I am surprised the game won! Its said that it was just a game. I miss Clem, sweet-pea.
To be honest, if it wasn’t for the game I wouldn’t even know the show existed.
Sorry Rick but Lee's the best
Rick and Lee are very different. Kenny and Rick are way more alike
Instant.Michael true
Lee took care of a random fucking child, cut his arm off, witnessed the death of many, started a train, saw a woman literally suicide in front of him, and asked for a little girl he loved to shoot him.
correct
with Clem and Kenny: YEAH!
Obviously the game is better....its probably the best story in gaming
assasinsjeff ikr
assasinsjeff nope
assasinsjeff It did win game of the year! 😊
last of us is better than the game
ConnorThePug Um were not talking about last of us
Telltale: No Debate.
Amc never gave me heartfelt moments consecutively, but the TallTell version make my heart ach thinking about the characters death and character development. They also have better ost that really help out those teary moments.
Then it sounds like to me you didn't care much for the show because Glenn's death and Carl's plus the pike scene in season 9 were all emotional moments
@@TheRealRickGrimes Uh I said consecutively. Those moment didn't happen right after the other like the Talltale version so you don't know what you're talking about. Course I like the show too
@@antoinebutler9828 I do know what I'm talking about you just need to read my comment again since you need extra time to understand what your reading. AMC did penalty of heartful moments you just can't admit show is better than the game. Clementine is the only character that keeps that game going. While the show you got more badass characters keeping it alive.
@@TheRealRickGrimes Those moment weren't continuous as that was my point. Now you wanna argue cause I'm not agreeing with you? Just read the comment and keep it pushing.
@@antoinebutler9828 No it's just you sound stupid saying "AMC never gave me heartful moments" even though there's plenty
Rick's crying is more funny than sad
Don’t forget Maggie
No
AWWWWWWWW NAAWWWWWWWWW
powernova911 I agree... the first time I watched the series, it was more effective, but now I can’t watch his crying in earlier seasons without laughing
Maggie crying season eight:
*NO RIIAACCCKKKK HHEEEE'S THEE EANNNIME*
Rick crying season three:
Ohhhh no no nooo Hooo no no no
RIP The Walking Dead Game Season 3 :'(
+Ishaan kaushal Teaser*
As far as I know, it is still going to be released. Just maybe delayed.
I read on a the TellTale message board a few days ago that it was scheduled for a November 15th release, but, there had been delays. It may be February before it comes out, but I think we will get it eventually.
I'd rather them take the time to release a complete game, instead of putting out a broken piece of crap that we have to patch 100 times.
I've pre-ordered for a Feb 28th release date !! I was so sad on Nov 15th when I tried to pick it up!
It's not a telltale game until the release date gets pushed back
Had you waited another 2-3 more years for the Final season of Telltales TWD to come out to make this video, Telltale would’ve swept AMC 0-5 in this battle.
Yeah you're right
Season 9 and ten of the walking dead would like to say Hello
Telltale easily crushes amc the walking dead
wrong, show is better
3 years ago, watch the new seasons PAINLESS
Do this video again! With season 3 and 4
I personally like Telltale's The Walking Dead a lot more than AMC'S version but to bad Glenn isn't in it.
Bryce Sabol Glenn and Hersel were on TWD's Telltale on season one episode one.
margareth michelina I know I mean to bad that Glenn isn't in Telltales version of the Walking Dead
Bryce Sabol Glenn is in the telltale game
Bryce Sabol That's literally what Margareth said
+Aidan Henriksen,Glenn isn't in the game I even beat the entire game.
did anyone know that glenn was in the walking dead game of episode 1 season 1.
So was hershel
No he wasent
CJ yes he was. Remember where you meet Kenny
CJ he was. after Lee and clem got away from clem's house, hershels son drove them to hershels farm, where hershel himself took care of Lee's leg.
Rocraft 259 then where were his daughters
If there would be a TWD series based on the telltale story (maybe on netflix or something), it would be so awesome! The telltale's story is so creative, emotional and good from season 1 to season 4. It would be my favorite series ever (If they wouldn't change important things that the game has).
Seeing lee and clem again hit me in the feels again
Will there ever be a day when Clementine makes it on the Tv show?!
Mikey Kruz no! If you know anything about the walking dead show vs the game they are two different stories
Mikey Kruz lets pray
No actually, telltale base it on the comics, so she could appear in the comics but not the tv show. Besides the tv show would just kill her off anyway for "shock value" or do something stupid.
Cutu Puss That's what the walking dead game do with Lee,u fucking idiot
Immortal Gamer u fucking idiot clementine is in the game and telltale dont want her to be in the show because telltale have it set in the world of comics not the show
i love both, but show didn't made me cry.. but game did.. so game 2
show 1
Telltale that moment when Clem had t kill Lee made me lose it
Same when I shot Kenny in season 2
How dare u shoot Kenny! But... Its the best choice, that's an good death instead being crippled and get eaten by walker.
I bauled my eyes man it wasn't easy
@@paapakermy3845 I know
@@paapakermy3845 did you go with jane seriously? I went to wellington and had go left kenny that was only way to kenny survive
7:48 wtf why would you shoot Kenny
THE GAME, NO QUESTION ABOUT IT.
THE SHOW,NO QUESTION ABOUT IT.
Kyle Crane NO THE GAME
Let's be honest Kenny is everyone's favorite.
Kenny is love, Kenny is life.
no its not
StormSurge Not at all.
Hell no. Fuck that bastard.
I hate him
I like the game more, the characters are more lovable. And its more emotional, plus very enjoyable.My opinion
you are telling me, penny. As a matter of fact, in the tv show some main or secondary protagonists are lying or hidding things even when they think that this is for the better which making them despicable to the eyes of the public. Not to mention that the tv show even more bad characters who taking stupid decisions that make the situation worse.
Telltale easily
I swear if Telltale doesn't win...
good, it won, nothing against the show, but i think the games are 10 times better than it in every aspect.
Quick Gaming spoilers!
Quick Gaming There both good in there own way. If we were just going off the first 2 seasons of the TV show, then the show would win but overall, the game is more emotional
MoneybucksMovies Lol, wasn't the second season like all on the farm or something?
MoneybucksMovies uhh, i thought the later seasons were considered better. I've only watched up to the mid-season finale of Season 4
Jesus is a badass character in both though hands down
Yea
With all my respect to rick, but lee is a GOAT
Telltale season 1 and 2 were amazing season 3 was boring
And season 4 was funny
Kinda true... Because they where just talking, talking and talking.. xD
Telltale season 1: meh
Telltale season 2: shit
Telltale season 3: sHit
:)
Season 4 was better than 1 in my opinion
Season 4 had so much action in it that nobody could ever argue about it, since aj shooting clementine was harsh man.