The BRUTAL and UNFORGIVABLE Crimes of the JEDI
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 02. 2024
- The Jedi, keepers of the peace, bastions of light and warriors of morality: or at least thats what they want you to believe. A look at the Jedi’s history reveals a startling truth, one that is not so noble or pure, bordering upon the very dark side they sought to destory. Join us as we explore some of the worst atrocities of the Jedi Order, from the war crimes of the Clone Wars, to the destruction of entire planets in the name of peace and the greater good.
But before we start, I’d like to thank Joel McMahon for suggesting this video. Your name will be entered into the VF Saber Giveaway draw. Be sure to comment your lore questions, what ifs etc down for a chance to have your idea made into a video and to have your name entered into the giveaway draw. Anyway, on with the video.
Perhaps the most notable and well known reason why the Jedi were not so honourable as it is often believed is because of the many war crimes their members commited. In fact there are so many, an entire video dedicated to this topic is likely needed. Perhaps of greatest note are the Jedi’s methods of “enhcanced Interogation” raising significant moral questions.
A particularly harrowing example of this contradiction is evidenced by Anakin Skywalker's treatment of the Geonosian leader, Poggle the Lesser. Held captive, Poggle becomes the target of Anakin's aggression during physical assault that escalates to a Force choke. The treatment of priosonewrs in this way is highly morally questionable, even if it was for the seeming greater good.
This kind of violent interogation could be excused as it was done by Ankakin Skywalker, a renegade Jedi who ultimately fell to the dark side, thus absolving the Jedi of responsibility. However, it is not solely under Anakin's hand that such actions unfold. This story is further complicated by the involvement of esteemed Jedi council members such as Obi-Wan Kenobi and Mace Windu. In their quest to uncover the whereabouts of a hidden holocron, these Jedi leaders unite their formidable powers to exert an overwhelming Jedi Mind power on the bounty hunter Cad Bane. This coercive strategy teeters on the edge of violating Bane's mental integrity, exerting such force that it threatens to shatter his mind unless he capitulates to their demands. The fact that the Jedi Orders second in command, not only knew about such violent actions, but partook in them, shows just how far the Jedi had fallen.
Another controversial tactic recurrently employed by the Jedi throughout the Clone Wars has sparked considerable debate regarding its ethical implications-specifically, the practice of feigning surrender during combat. This strategy, known in the realms of international law and warfare ethics as "perfidy," directly contravenes the principles laid out in the Geneva Convention.
In one notable instance during the Battle of Christophsis, the series introduces viewers to a cunning ploy orchestrated by Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi. In an effort to halt the progression of hostilities and buy time, Kenobi orchestrates a ruse of surrender. This deliberate act of deception serves a dual purpose: it momentarily halts the enemy's advance and provides a crucial window for Anakin Skywalker, alongside his newly appointed apprentice, Ahsoka Tano, to undertake a daring mission to disable the Separatists' ray shield.
Another instance of perfidy is executed by Anakin Skywalker in a strategic maneuver above the planet Ryloth. In a bold and desperate gambit, Anakin presents the illusion of surrendering a crippled Venator-class cruiser. This feint deceives the Separatist blockade into allowing the Republic vessel to approach perilously close. In a dramatic culmination, Anakin's ship rams through the enemy lines, annihilating the Trade Federation's command ship in a spectacular explosion and paving the way for Republic forces to deploy ground troops onto the beleaguered planet.
The ethical boundaries of the Jedi Order, often regarded as guardians of peace and justice in the galaxy,
The ethical quandaries surrounding the Jedi's conduct during the Clone Wars extend beyond their interrogation methods and strategic deceptions to encompass the very manner in which their adversaries are combated on the battlefield. A striking example of the moral complexities faced by the Jedi is illustrated in the actions of Ki-Adi-Mundi, a revered member of the Jedi Council. His directive for the clone troopers under his command to deploy flamethrowers against sentient beings starkly highlights the erosion of the Jedi's moral compass amidst the fog of war. - Zábava
Now we need a video about the Sith‘s atrocities. Or the worst atrocities in Star Wars history in general.
"The hate is swelling in you now.."
😂
How about a video that’s like “Jedi that were actually just awful people”
I'd love a video on the yuuzhan vong war
Well for Grievous's family, not all of them died but certainly a few of them
The crucial window made me laugh harder than it should’ve
I would love to see a video, or series of videos covering the Star Wars Infinities alternate universes.
Yes…but I think that’s the point of the Jedi in prequels and I think in legends Luke actually realizes the flaws of the old Jedi and tried to correct, he did in canon too…but he fell back into the same old habits as the Jedi of the past 23:37
Lol,you forget that the jedi fell because one of their own didn’t follow their rules ????
@@user-kx3tw1gh8j no…I just think that aside from Anakin turning to the dark side…their were a bunch of other factors that contributed to the Jedi’s downfall outside of Anakin betraying them…the sith had been planning for the destruction of the Jedi and republic for years even before Anakin was born…palpatine just added him in them because he wanted him to be his new apprentice, he was going to do everything he did in the movies even if Anakin wasn’t around.
Disney star wars movies isn't canon legends is canon now been for a while
@@yokaivegaurd8707 really?
@@Bwillis2099 yes because of the temple of time in rebels. Plus the 7,8 and 9 does not make any sense at all
I would love to see you do a deep dive into the history of the Sith Triumvirate👍🏻
If you haven’t already you should make a video about the Charon Death Cult
Me after watching this video: "You know... At 1st I wanted to cry seeing Order 66 but yet I somehow didn't 1st seeing it but after watching this video I now see why I didn't cry, it was well deserved."
Do a video on the horrors of Haruun Kal
What about the full history of clones. Not just Jango clones, buy even the ones we are seeing in bad batch and other possible cline types. Also when they fell and how much Kaminos had to do with it. Full history of Camino as well
Do a video explaining why Padme and Leia didn't take the last name Skywalker in both canon and legends and why in legends why Mara Jade was the only wife in the Skywalker family to take the name Skywalker and why Leia and Padme did not
Vader in episode 4: "Your name is Skywalker?"
Because *Leia* was raised by different family from the beginning so they were her real family (not the biological one). In secret, the Empire has been looking for those kids ever since their birthday. If Organa's, who's always been in opposition to the emperor, suddenly adopted kid was parading around with Skywalker as a last name, Empire's agents would've realized it's her and kidnapped or killed her. She didn't want to change it because she probably wanted to honor the name of her family, especially after what happened to Aldeeran, ESPECIALLY that she was a politician like her father - Leia was the youngest senator in the Imperial senate.
*Padme.* She couldn't have taken on Anakin's name because they were illegal couple. Not just by Order's standards but also she was a head of state. A noble, who surely, couldn't just marry anyone she wanted and things had to be arranged. It would have been a huge diplomatic blunder if it came out. Only small number of people knew about them. Even if she wanted to take the name, she's died right after the childbirth so "there was no time"
I'd add one more to the list: Jedi Master Sifo Dyas colluded with the Kaminoans to create a slave army. While this was done without the knowledge of the Jedi Council, the Jedi would use that army and commission the cloning of more slaves to win the war against the CIS.
Unpopular opinion;
The Jedi order under Yoda’s leadership really are the villains of the Star Wars universe.
If you know then you know 🤷🏾♂️✅.
Revan's actions and commands are also in the same bucket as Anakin since he also fell to the dark side.
Could you do a video on Lukes improved version of the jedi order?
I don't think Star wars has a Geneva convention
also another reason why the jedi were likely so intense in their collecting of young force sensitives was to keep them not only out of the hands of the sith but all other force orders they knew of so that way they could starve them of new members to continue their force traditions and thus cause them to die out
This is what the sith do, if you don't know about Palpatine.
Say I have one: why the Jedi Council (at the time of the Mandalorian Wars, Jedi Civil War, and Dark Wars) were so arrogant and refused to act? When you stand back you can see their choices brought about the First Jedi Purge
should also have mentioned the local jedi council where zayne carrick's master was part of that slaughtered all younglings and padawans because they had a vision that one of them would fallto the dark side and the destruction of the true mandalorians .
Now do one on how the Sith were beneficial
How Jedi trained with a lightsaber
The jedi stealing children was NOT only confined to the old Sith wars , Yoda stole Luke and Leia.
He decided the fate of the twins instead of delivering them to Padme's family .
He took it upon himself to give Luke to a couple of strangers , and gave Leia to his friends.
Padme's family SHOULD have been given custody of them .
Yoda was trash.
Exar kun was right to go against the republic, and he was an atrocity walking
fourth (i was actually first but i said fourth to be different)🤓
*différent*
The first 18 seconds basically describes our current politics. 😂
How about a video about all the war crimes committed during the clone wars. Or just the war crimes committed by Anakin Skywalker 😂
Both the Jedi and Sith were pretty terrible
And that is why Anakin was born. To get rid of them both
Good points, but the Sith portion is literally some certified Darth Vitiate propaganda.
Palpatine was right...the Jedi had grown arrogant and foolish. Had they kept strictly to the light, Palpatine's plan could never have succeeded.
Undoubtedly the jedi committed some war crimes etc during their time as "peacekeepers" however their crimes pale next to the countless atrocities of the sith, in no way can the jedi be seen as the bad guys in all this
True
The good sith
The Jedi and the Sith are 2 sides of the same coin that should be tossed in a well, and forgotten. Both philosophies have good points, but still practically miss the mark.
Possible video idea? "What if after the jedi were killed during order 66, the lightsabers weren't destroyed but the kybers within them were used and retrofitted into specialised lightblasters"
The jedi should have been destroyed thousands of years earlier , and banned from ever returning.
All hail the Dark!
Yeah! The sith and mandalorians were better!
Takes look into history: ah sh**, no.
Tell the hundreds if not thousands of soldiers in WW2 who were saved from fortified pill boxes flame throwers were unethical.
Tell that to the people they were used on. It’s all about point of view.
False surrender just is good combat strategy.
That's illegal
Too many SW fans think they're being edgy by regarding the sith as the good guys in this galaxy😅
When I was in my teen years during ROTS I went through my edge phase with the Sith. Almost 2 decades later I’m more self aligned as a Gray Jedi.
@jibril2473 I kinda did too lol, I mean the empire is clearly representing fascism, or at the very least extreme nationalism
Gotta get those Mace hating edgelord views up
Gotta say fake surrender makes sense as a war crime in the real world, but against droids? Eh