Which Culture Is Best in Bannerlord? Complete Bannerlord Culture Guide
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- In this video, we will take a deep look into all 6 Cultures in Bannerlord: Vlandia, Sturgia, Empire, Aserai, Khuzait and Battania. We test each bonus and drawback, look at starting character build options as well as starting spawn locations. By the end of the video, you will know exactly which culture makes sense for you to pick based on your goals and ambitions!
0:00 - Intro
0:16 - Vlandia
3:39 - Sturgia
5:54 - Empire
8:42 - Aserai
10:48 - Khuzait
13:26 - Battania - Hry
The intro is inspired by LockPickingLawyer :D
I had plans to release this video along with the first episode of the Bannerlord Build Guide - but this one took waaaay longer than planned so I will try to get it out before Xmas. My goal is to get Roguery perks done before Friday and WC epiosde 11 shortly after. Wish me luck!!
Click on one, two is binding...
It would be great to get these videos so soon! Your guides are by far the best, most reliable and updated!
I think the reduction to trade penalty is for your caravans, it's worded weirdly but I think it's supposed to 30% cheaper and they have 10% less trade penalty
@@MiguelAbd Lol yeah!! He's so easy to watch. If you ever get a chance, look up his keynote address - he's hilarious to listen to in a longer format!
@@MiguelAbd Thank you! I think the Bannerlord Build Guides will be very helpful for those that don't play thousands of hours like me lol I would have used it when I was just starting out for sure!
You're the most informative and chad Bannerlord channel out there.
Thank you for watching! I know this one is a bit more basic compared to the usual guides, but I think there will be a lot of newer players coming into the game and I wanted to have something for them as well :D Plus, some of the bonuses don't even work, so it's nice to know that at least!
To many words there... What you meant was- You. Are. Chad.
@@BracownReclidobo Lol you makin' me blush...
InfoChad
@@AcornFox Lol thank you :D I may legally change my name soon.
Village production is more then just $$. increased production, also means increased supplies for the castle/town. so, can support higher prosperity, and provides stability. Also, increased supply of a workshop base, means increased workshop income, if the demand is also good.
Yeah great point! I had a lot more info on this, but I cut it during editing because it was turning into a section that was as long as a culture by itself haha :D Thank you for adding this, I appreciate it!
You are the epitome of dunning-kruger effect.
Incredibly thorough as always. Laudable how you actually verified everything (and it was clearly needed). Hope this video finds its way to tale worlds so they can easily pinpoint their mistakes. Hell... they ought to just be subbed to you honestly. You are doing half the job for them and then some :D
Thank you! I was thinking the same thing as most of those are quite trivial, but still need to be tested because I've had countless times where I picked something like a perk or skill, only to find out it's not working later lol. I hope they only fix the bad ones! I would love to keep the Vlandia influence bonus that's supposed to be a negative haha
Agreed.
psssst. that’s what beta testing means
@@AcornFox Yeah I suspect a lot of the things in the game right now are placeholders that they plan on replacing once they get near the end. It wouldn't make sense to spend time balancing things that are going to be overwritten in the end anyways. I'm sure they will get it figured out this year!
@@Strat-Guides sorry for being unclear! my comment was replying to “since youre doing all work for them,” or whatever it says, in the original comment. devs used to pay full time testers, and they somehow tricked us into paying them to do it for them lol.
Also worth pointing out the perks that depend on culture as well, meaning the troop tree can be relevant. The perk that gives you an extra tier when recruiting from notables with your culture is very solid on Empire with their huge swaths cultural territory and their solid unit lines.
That's a great point! I think there are 2 perks that change the trade penalty as well (one for villages and one for towns) that are based on that. Oh, also a perk for converting prisoners of same culture without morale loss and another for morale boost for same culture units.
Oh that would be OP because there are tons of Empire villages.
Ever since you talked about the tactics skill, I made it a point to focus on it. At 289 tactics I can easily destroy any army in the field with minimal losses, and can take any fief with standard losses. It’s a great skill
Oh wow, that's really cool! I'm happy to hear someone tried it out :D It's just nice to at least have the option for those times when you don't feel like fighting.
The thing is...I can destroy pretty much any army with a 1:5 disadvantage with absolutely no losses. Even with 200 Tactics I am loosing these fights in simulated battles. Tactics is one of the most useless skill in the game in my opinion.
@@Bullshitvol2 I see tactics as either all in skill to use, or don't bother with it. Unless you can get up to 300+ it's pretty much useless as you said. I agree with you that you can win these battle if you fought them in person, but with the high skill some of the wins are pretty impressive for autoresolve. It also gives another way to play, which is nice because the more options the better (even if they aren't optimal).
@@Strat-Guides i won a 560 to 2670 siege battle in Talivel castle on auto resolve. Basically won the war for me 😅
@@tobiaswiest Autoresolve siege defense is pretty OP! :D
I love all your content, dude. Your incredible attention to detail and ability to condense expansive and complicated information into easily accessible videos is second to none. Thanks so much for all the hard work!
Thank you! I appreciate the vote of confidence :D
Seeing this it just reinforcing my view that testing is often left to the players while they still have to pay for the game.
Really informative vid which is even appreciated though i am not yet playing the game.( I bought it at the beginning of EA, but couldn't bare to spend more time in it seeing the state of the game back then and wait now for release including full mod support)
I bought at the beginning of EA as well and I can say it's really come a long way since then, but you're definitely right about testing by players. I don't think it's necessarily the devs fault at this point, but more of a norm in the gaming industry as a whole (at least from smaller and indie devs). That being said, I've gotten my money's worth already and imagine full release will be much better! Thank you for watching and hopefully they will finish the project in 2022 so you can get back in!
My first time I picked Aserai, made tons of trades, picked the perk that allows you to gain renown for each caravan you own. Clan Tier 5 in no time!
Another terrific video. Appreciate all the work you put into these. I just hope you don't get burned out before the game gets finalized (and everything gets changed.)
Thank you!
So far things are going okay. I'm used to working 10 - 12 hour days for over 10 years at this point (sales, management and now self employed - all have long hours) so this type of work doesn't scare me at all :D I actually enjoy it. The editing gets a little tedious because of how much editing I put into them, but that's something that can be outsourced at some point in the future, so I don't mind it for now. I need to learn everything I can so when I do hire someone, I won't be an idiot about it and get swindled haha
Wow, this is great stuff. This is the type of content I've been seeking to educate myself about the games I play ever since I came across Spirit of the Law and his AOE2 content. Keep it up!
Thank you! Spirit of the Law is the goat and I can only hope to match his quality someday :D I don't even play AoE2 (It's been 15+ years or so) but I still watch all of his videos lol
I love these videos. They really help me optimize my builds. Thanks strat!
Thank you for watching! I'm glad the info is helpful :)
had to give a like and sub for all the time and testing to prove your information thanks heaps for that time investment and making my bannerlords experience better !
What a glorious audio cut at 0:22 x)
The best benefit i find in a culture is to have same-culture subjects not bitching about your rule, Empire has the edge on that one due to sheer size but good cornercamps like Aserai work great too. Vlandia's my personal favourite due to the only malus being a minor issue.
I said Vassal in the original on accident and I didn't feel like doing the lazy text edit to correct it, but I couldn't get the voice to match haha I should have just redone the whole sentence. Lesson learned :)
Yeah I think Empire is one of my favorite to use just for that reason. Lol corner campers, that's a great line!
i would love to see a video on the hearths and other game mechanics that run deep in the background that impact the larger gameplay. Also something i got out of this video was that Vlandia is good candidate for a whole map taker because of the enhancements to the villages which may improve the larger economy and foster a more stable empire. I would presume in the longer context of the game that empire villages would have a smaller population over time if left unattacked vs any other culture.
I do have plans for a couple guides covering towns, castles and villages and one of the bigger topics will be hearths (and prosperity which is basically the same thing). So I can tell you the most important part of hearths for villages - they are in 3 categories: 1 - 199 hearths is poor, 200 - 599 is average, 600+ is wealthy. Villages output based on their hearths level, so the goal is to get everything above 600 ASAP. Food provided to the town or castle is 6, 12 and 18 respectively, so it's a big deal to get to wealthy status. It also produces more goods. I don't have the exact numbers yet because I need to finish testing, but it seems to be a big increase each level, like 50% more. So poor vs wealth is more than 100% difference in product output! I think once you get to 600 or above, then hearth growth isn't a big deal. You will get more militia to defend, but other than that it's not as important so I think empire debuff isn't as bad as it seems (assuming you can keep the idiots from raiding you into the ground LOL). The more important number is prosperity since it's a continuous scale instead of stair-step like the villages. I'm really excited for the guide though, I love the economy stuff so I get excited talking about it (as you can tell by this wall of text lol)!
You have the best guides for bannerlord. Keep it up man. Great work.
Thank you so much! :D I've got a few more planned before Xmas so hopefully I can get them all done in time
Perfect timing! I was about to start a SP campaign and I was wondering about this very question!
Nice! I was planning on doing this a long time ago and it kept getting pushed to the bottom of the list :(
@@Strat-Guides which resulted in a very karmic moment for me so that’s a tiny bonus I think! Edit: aside from your very expansive character creation guide, do you have a guide in the works for a beginner character based on the family system by any chance? 😄
Best Bannerlord yt channel out there - if I get a recommendation for a Bannerlord vid and it isn’t Strat Gaming then I’m not watching !
Great video as always, looking forward to the next one
Thank you!! I really appreciate that :) I'm working on Roguery right now and I'm about halfway through the testing and I have to admit, some of the perks are a little better than I thought they were! I'll have this wrapped up for Friday!
top quality content 👍 thanks for the guide man!!
No problem, hopefully it's helpful! :D
Absolutely the best modern culture guide, thank you.
Thank you for watching!
I am working on the Roguery perks guide right now and will have it ready by Friday and I have to say, I'm very impressed with the testing results! I used to hate the perk for Roguery because they were pretty bad, but they made some changes and I think it's a skill worth looking at finally :D
Early game Battania and Aserai perks can be great, especially with the movement speed bonuses to their respective terrains. However, endgame, it is tough to beat the perks of the Empire culture. Why? 3/8ths of the world is Empire culture, so once you're running a kingdom you're only going to get owner culture mismatch loyalty debuffs for 5/8th of all settlements instead of 7/8ths of all settlements if you picked any other culture. The aligned culture also helps recruit 3/8ths of all the possible clans. There is also a maximum to village hearths I believe, so the slower hearth growth rate doesn't have a long-term detrimental effect if you keep raiders from burning your villages all the time, as you'll hit the max hearths anyway even with the slower growth rate, and you can slot in governors with +village heart growth perks to boost new settlements until they get up to the max anyway. Lastly, while the extra militia the Battania perk offers does have defensive benefits the same as a garrison would, militia doesn't help with protecting against a settlement revolt (in fact it can work against you, as your militia is what overthrows your garrison to successfully revolt), nor does it help with settlement security, not to mention a garrison troop can be tier 6 quality while a militia troop is tier 2 quality. I'd rather have a 250 strong tier 4 garrison + 150 militia defending a settlement versus a 200 strong tier 4 garrison + 225 militia defending the same settlement for the same wages, and the extra garrison will help keep settlement security high which means prosperity gains are stronger too, snowballing your ability to afford an even stronger garrison to defend the settlement. Movement speed bonus in woods or desert is great, but once you've got an end-game cohort of 5 clan members leading 250+ man parties to march around in a 1250-man+ army, you're going to be slow no matter what.
Good point, I completed my most recent WC using empire for that exact reason :)
I find creating a kingdom is the best way to avoid rebellions because passing lots of loyalty policies is quite easy to do before you load up on other clans.
Love the content, thank you and happy holidays!
Thank you for watching! Happy Holidays to you and family :D
thanks for another amazing bannerlord guide!
No problem, hopefully it's helpful!
It would be amazing if they would let you create your own unique culture. The possibilities are endless
That's a really good idea! Especially for sandbox - they could have a list of things to pick from, it would really be cool to build a character based on the extra choices at the start!
@@Strat-Guides that's like all over ever wanted honestly....
@@BracownReclidobo Let's start a petition!
@@Strat-Guides legit would sign
It would be interesting, a seventh culture, "traveler from distant lands". Perhaps with the option of having up to 3 benefits, at the cost of having 2 disadvantages. Or the option of having only one advantage but no disadvantages.
For those who wish to embody empires that are not in the game.
You're slowly becoming the SpiritoftheLaw for Bannerlord
He puts out some great videos, so that's a huge compliment! Thank you :D
Great video! I generally default to either Empire or Battania but am more inclined towards Empire in my recent games due to the Forest Kin perk issue for Battania (not sure if it's fixed for 1.7.0) along with the number of Empire cities on the campaign map to deal with loyalty issues.
There's also a few other impacts of starting culture throughout the game.
- Early game the Leadership 25 perk Combat Tips is useful to boost recruitment level from same culture NPCs to recruit more troops of your own culture and negate opinion penalties from opposing traits. Good for quickly massing up Fians and Khan Guards for Battania and Khuzait respectively.
- As ruler, the kingdom policy Citizenship is extremely powerful especially for Empire culture since it gives +0.5 loyalty to settlement of the same culture as the owner clan but -0.5 loyalty of different culture. I use it when I'm uniting the entire Calradic Empire before I focus on conquering the other factions. Not so good though if you grants settlements to vassals of another culture.
- Charm 150 perks in 1.7.0 depend on whether the lords are of the same or different culture as yours.
Thank you! We are in the same boat - I used to exclusively play Battania, but I tire of dealing with rebellions in my kingdom member's fiefs so empire is the smart play now, then just promote companions of the same culture once outside the empire lands. It seems to work pretty well if you have the influence to burn!
These other suggestions are great by the way! Particularly citizenship, I really like that policy.
perks are 99% working with the newest patch. the only perk that doesn't work is a medic one i think.
@@feyenoord1821 If you're going off of Bannerlordperks.com then there is some discrepancy there. The code may seem to be correct and functioning, but something is going on with it's implementation because I've found several instances where some perks either don't work at all or don't function as described.
That being said, TW has fixed A LOT of them since release lol I remember the days when literally none of them were working :)
@@Strat-Guides yeah i havent played the game in a while so i looked it up on that website. can you give me some examples where in the website and game have discrepancies? i thought they fixed all the perks so i was planning another playthrough with now perks being %100 fixed.
@@feyenoord1821 Sure, the big one that comes to mind is the charm perk that gives a boost to relations with "same sex" or opposite. I've tested it about 20 different times: nobles, notables, companions, prison breaks, voting, donating troops, donating nobles, barter giving donations, etc. etc. and not once did it give any extra relations increase. The code states that the perk work, but clearly in the testing it's not functioning properly.
So Glad i've been vindicated as i've been saying for Ages that Batannia has had the best bonuses for ages, as their forest bonus is so overwhelmingly good
Lol you just never know with TaleWorlds, so I understand the relief :D It's hard to get away from Battania, although empire and vlandia have some pretty big selling points too... the other 3, not so much!
Another excellent guide!
Thank you for watching!!
Great and detailed video. Thank you.
Thank you for watching!!
Good content as always!
Thank you! :D
once more, great video!
Thank you! I appreciate :)
Hey strat, have you/would you be willing to look into making a troop tactics guide? I notice in your playthroughs you seem to be really good at actively commanding troops and I was wondering if you could make a guide on how to manage your troops like that on the field, and tips on what tactics/formations to use in general. I could look into other videos but I find that your guides are always thorough and very informative. Thank you for the content as always 💖
Yes I do have a whole series of videos planned for this topic! I'm going to look at different unit type combinations, formations and when to use each, how to combat different army compositions, etc. I'm not sure how many videos it will take, but probably at least 5 or 6 based on how much info there is :D Once I finish off the perks, that series will be starting up right after.
Thanks for the video!
No problem, hopefully it's helpful!
Awesome content, you've got a new sub!
Thank you and welcome to the channel!!!
This was great, thanks 👍👍
Thanks for watching!
Awesome channel, we need more math, graphs and tests. )
Lol you got it. One can never have too much math and graphs :)
Congrats on the 10k subs!
Thank you! It was such a quick thing, I thought it would take years to get there but it's been less than 5 months :D
Wow what a breakdown man. Whew ! U put a lot of work into these. Thank you! How long did it take to research and make this ?
Thanks!! Most of my guides take about 40 hours from start to finish. Some of the longer ones take about double that but this one wasn't too bad
good job mate. definitely living up to your name strat gaming. I sub to you.
Thank you for the support!!
Battanian start also seems to be great for agressive combat and fian spamming. Having the speed reduction tempered in forest, you can literally catch anyone you chase maybe except for kuzait war boys and battanians themselves but with speed bonuses battanians can be catchable.
As of fian spamming, you could join vlanida or empire as a vessal and when war with battania, you can visit the villages, do the "harass for recruits" instead of raid and you get free units including the arrow boys. With cooldown of few days, you can put your troops on a castle or town and do the same thing all over again. If you get battanian fief, that's even better since you get no loyalty debuff.
I really like the tip on forced recruiting - I think that's hands down the best way to farm specific unit types since you get access to 3 or 4 recruiting slots, which would take a long time to farm the relations with notables to match it. It's a really good mechanic, although I'm confused as to why it doesn't cause a relations hit? If my people were force recruited into the enemy army (like so many though history) I would be a little upset :P
@@Strat-Guides I would guess it's the case the relation hit is ommited in the code, as harassing for recruit and materials falls in the same action as raiding. Or they're just contempt they solved it with a few men and not the whole village burning down
love your video dude 🙏🏻💯 thanks for information, I wish you success with this channel
sorry for bad english 🙏🏻
Thank you for the kind words! Your English is flawless so far, no need to apologize :) What's your native language? It's really cool to see all the people from around the world enjoying the game together!
my native language is "bahasa indonesia" sir 😁🙏🏻
@@EsTehHaanget Ah cool! I've never met anyone from Indonesia before so it's a pleasure :) I know a little bit about that part of the world from playing EU4, so I at least know where it is on the map haha
Good work!
Thank you!
You do a video on what it takes to become a mercenary the benefits, how the mechanics work also when you decide to join the faction what gear you get for it. Having a hard time finding a video with the faction loot for joining the kingdom. Also don't fully understand the mercenary mechanic. Really been enjoying your content a lot of times I'll replay a couple of the videos over and over while I play my playthrough
Yeah I do have plans for a video like that! It will probably be another month though as this month my schedule is pretty much maxed out - finished the world conquest series, companion guide and starting the battlefield tactics series.
I can give a few points that might help in the mean time - You can become a mercenary at clan tier 1, which means you have 50 renown total. You can check the renown on your clan tab in the top right of the screen. There are a few benefits to becoming a mercenary:
- And influence you have will be converted into Denars. When you first sign up as a mercenary, they will give you the "contract amount" and is usually around 100 - 200 denars per 1 influence. So if you destroy a group of looters for 2 influence, it will give you and extra payment of 200 - 400 depending on your contract amount. You won't get the full payment right away, it will subtract a few influence per day until you reach 0.
- You can fight with a kingdom in larger battles against strong enemies, helping you get valuable XP, good loot drops, etc.
- You can hop from kingdom to kingdom as a mercenary, so you can join and leave at will following the wars around the map.
- You can get into defensive sieges and earn massive XP for bow, athletics and throwing using siege engines and rocks.
- If you capture nobles in battle, you can donate them to a friendly town/castle to gain relations and XP, then leave the mercenary contract and break them out of prison the same day to gain more relations, charm and roguery XP. It's pretty funny actually :)
I'm not sure exactly what equipment is given for each faction as I usually start my own kingdom. I know Battania gives a 2H sword that is decent and Khuzait give a mid tier bow.
I hope this helps until I can get a full video up on the topic! Feel free to reach out with more questions.
Big respect for the battanian bias, loving my playthrough with it rn
Battania FTW! :D
i feel pathetic i'll read a random perk in the game and i'll think "okay you say that... but now i gotta check strat's channel to see how it actually works"
Haha that's a good one! That's just how it is with Betas I guess. You never know what is working or not without actually doing the tests. I'm happy to do my part!
There are no other channels informative as this and it’s not even close.
Thank you! I see the same thing with other games too - people put out "guides" but it's literally them talking to the loading screen for 15 minutes lol Hopefully we can put an end to the low-effort stuff on CZcams :D
man i love all your knowledge based content
Thank you! It's like watching a lecture, but on something more interesting? :)
@@Strat-Guides hmm, a bit maybe. it feels more like meetings where people actually did their research, and therefore I can approach the next steps and decisions with peace of mind.
@@AdaLollA Yeah that's a good way of looking at it. I see the same thing happening all over the place - the worst offenders are the "investor tic toks" lol giving advice with literally 0 substance behind it other than "HURR DURR LOOK AT MUH EXPENSIVE WATCH & CAR" :P
strat gaming at year 2030: "oK gUyS I DiD aLl ThE 7776 cOmBiNaTiOnS oF tHe StArTiNg OpTiOnS AnD FiNiShEd 7776 CaMpAinS tO sEe WhIcH WaS BeSt.
btw merry christmas
Lol that sounds like something Mr Beast would have done a few years ago!
Merry Christmas to you as well :D
@@Strat-Guides lol
Awesome. I should have watched this before starting gaming Bannerlord. I would had saved myself some time of my life.
Lol I know what you mean!
Aserai bonus doesn't apply to armor and weapons,only to food and trade goods.
I believe the only bonus that changes price for weapons and armor(only sell)is the 25 Trade Bottom,Whole Appraiser.
Where you get 25% more denars from selling gear.
This is a good thing to have for every character,as in large battles you can easily get 5-10K denars which will net you like 2.5K more denars.
Thanks for watching! Yeah I really like that perk - especially since we can get it at level 25.
Been thinking to do a campaign of either Vlandia or Battania, because i’m from the region those people used to live (not at the same time ofc.) but i’ve got this rlly good empire campaign that i don’t want to really give up, it’s confusing and pretty hard to decide on
Nice, what would your plans be for each of those? I'm always curious to see how other people run their campaigns :)
The break of the Attribute and Focus points was nice. Will you share your Notion link for that?
I just added it to the list, thank you for reminding me! I'm getting old :(
Commenting during the first ad answer is it depends on what you want.
That's exactly right (in my opinion)! I think there are some cultures that are objectively bad, but most do have valid strategies behind picking them. Thank you for watching!
great video amazing amount of info ... thank you .. i only wish you can pack more info in a video but will have to wait for the next video.. Do not forget to do the other videos on Hearths and Game Mechanics..// how about video on each Culture game play initial setup and any bets use of that Culture beyond initial set up...
I know what you mean, I had a ton of info that I had to cut because it was turning into "rambling" lol I get caught up in the data and how stuff works so it's easy for me to get side-tracked. I will try to do the hearths and town stuff soon, I may just do a video specifically with that and keep it short. Or I may try to fit it in with the town management guide, but then I feel like it's going to run for an hour haha We will see!
Someone had suggested doing the culture guide based on how to play with each one and I think it's a great idea! I did add it to my list :) I'm not sure when I'll be able to get to it, but hopefully soon. Once the perks are all done, that frees up enough time to probably do 1.5 - 2 videos worth of work per week (they take a lot longer than normal guides).
@@Strat-Guides no worries take all the time you need... i do prefer videos to the point per topic , easier to find and time wise when i need to refresh what i forgot lol ...
@@malepagamer7281 Yeah that's the tricky part. I try to make videos with topics that are self-contained so that you don't have to watch 2 - 3 other videos to understand the context, making it easy to come back and just click time stamps to get what you need and go.
Well with Bannerlord coming to Xbox Series X/S and PS5 in two days time to start brushing up on what faction I want to play as
Love it! Thanks!!
No problem, Thank you for watching :)
@@Strat-Guides If it's not too much trouble, would you share the database with the starting races and their choices for APs and FPs?
@@fightcancer Yeah it's on the discord with all the other guide info :D
discord.gg/kJqAfqapxN
I wouldn't be so quick to say that the Vlandian modifier is bugged. Army size is definitely not the only factor in determining an army's influence cost. I know this from looking at my faction and seeing armies of like, 120 cost less influence than armies of like 70. And I think wow, great deal, but the army arrives and it's a bunch of recruits. I assume unit tier affects it as well. So we can't really know without more advanced testing. I'm not sure what that testing would need to be, I can only think of difficult methods.
Yeah I actually spend 2 - 3 hours working on that exact problem today actually. I felt really good about it when I published the video, but then today I start to think about a few things that weren't quite 100%. So relations to the noble is a factor in influence cost. Distance they have to travel to you as well. Number of troops, troop quality and some random factor (someone looked at the code for me) are in there. I looked back at all of my testing and I held nearly everything constant EXCEPT troop quality. I thought they spawned in with a template (40% tier 3, 30% tier 2, 30% tier 1, 10% archers, etc. etc.) But I tested it again and it was not the case! I was still not able to show a 20% increase in influence cost for Vlandia, but I also don't feel 100% about the conclusion I came to in the video. I did the best I could with the data I collected (I did 4 or 5 tests and they mostly matched), but it seems TaleWorlds mathematics might have gotten the better of me once more haha :D Great discussion you're brining up by the way, I appreciate the insight!
Stratgaming is my fav youtuber loves
Haha thank you!
Fleson19 put out a pretty interesting video today about the culture of the caravan leader impacting daily income - interestingly in the tests he ran the result was that Aserai led caravans earned ~50 denars more per day! Seeming to indicate that the trade buff does apply, but as another viewer suggested below it might only apply to trade goods.
This leads me to my second thought, given that culture is inherited based on the mother it would be a bit fun to see you pick up a carefully curated selection of children. Here's what I imagine - your main heir is the culture you prefer to play as (e.g. Battanian). You then create three or so focuses for children and tailor them from birth towards those lifepaths - generals, governors and traders. Generals you may want to make them Sturgians (25% reduction in inf cost means you get larger and better armies faster as an AI, especially true given most armies are largely infantry). Trader children - have your caravans run by Aserai kids for the buff to trade income (although arguably Battanian is better as it better allows them to evade threats through movespeed). Governors is a tricky one - Battanian might be good because of the militia buff and empire is interesting because of the garrison reduction cost but both have their downsides, might be interesting to look into further.
Either way I'd love to see you sending out armies led by your kids in the speedrun as if you're Temujin himself letting your vicious generals loose on the world haha. Although I suspect that you'll have almost all the world conquered by the point they start to grow up...
Yeah I saw that this morning, pretty interesting stuff! When I was running my tests for this video, it's possible that that the trade penalty reduction was working, but that the items and quantity being tested were too small to notice the difference. I'll have to look into it further, but I do recall from doing my trade video that trade goods penalty was pretty small (like 10% for going from level 1 to 300 which is 60% trade penalty reduction).
Haha sounds like a Eugenics experiment :D It sounds like a ton of work, but if it does work out, you would have some "uber-kinder" lol I really like the idea of the governor kid that can really stabilize a town quickly.
I play as Battanian, I like celtic theme, but their bonuses and elite troops fit my strategy and tactics. But I don't rely on battanians only, for instance late game my infantry are legionnaires, cavaly is mostly vlandian and skirmish cavalry is aserai and sturgian, cavalry archers ofc khuzait with some bucelarii too. Most of my ranged troops are fian champs but there is a significant number of vlandian sharps. Sturgian infantry is also very durable.
Wow that's a good mix from all over! Do you usually get them from prisoners, recruit them or convert bandits?
@@Strat-Guides as for legionnaires, I had a campaign deep in Aserai territory, no way of getting troops in that region when villages don't belong to you or they are depleted, but lots of looters want to join. With sufficient equipment and loot, after few battles you can have 50+ top infantry, not bad :D
@@Lobo1888 Oh that's right, looters promote to the Empire line. That's a great idea given how many there are at all parts of the map!
@@Strat-Guides tbh it's a bit grindy to get to leadership level 150 and have veteran's respect perk, but totally worthy, especially late game. And it's also good when you catch mountain bandits or forrest bandits far from Battania and Vlandia, you can get Fians and Banner Knights.
@@Lobo1888 I'll add to that, because I agree with everything you said: There is a new perk roguery level 150 that let's you capture bandits 100% of the time making it even better to get 150 leadership! I'm releasing the Roguery perks guide tonight so it will be in there :D
Bro I re-checked the video time when he said we gonna review the 7k plus combos
I've always run Battanian, never looked at the rest because of the movement bonus and because.. well I'm Scottish and it's nice to pretend we're merged with our Celtic cousins into a united force of sorts :)
The movement bonus has saved my skin so many times in forests though.
Haha nice! A lot of my heritage comes from Scotland (Mackintosh clan from what my Grandpa had told me). Maybe that's why I always play Battania... :P
My heritage are Thai and Han Chinese, we’ll never be add to the game and the closest to my Chinese side is the Khuzait who’s pretty much Mongols 😔
@@taejo4975 Yeah I don't really see them adding any more cultures to the game, but it would be pretty cool if they did! Siam culture would be amazing for melee combat (muay thai is so dominant so they should be extra bonuses). Also, didn't the Mongols eventually adopt Chinese culture and customs and become more Chinese than Mongol? At least the ones that were further to the south. I could be wrong, but I remember watching something on that, so we can RP as Khuzait and just build foot troops :D
@@Strat-Guides The Mongol that adopted were those in Yuan, there are more Mongol tribes and Khanagate after the spilt. Khuzait here are mostly Mongol based, I do want Tang Dynasty inspired faction though.
@@taejo4975 Ah got it, Yuan sounds very familiar! Thanks for clearing that up. I've seen some pretty ghastly looking 2H swords from the Chinese armory (I think it was forged in fire, the ZhanMaDao was one of them). I would love to get my hands on it :D What type of unit would the Tang dynasty specialize in? I think other games like AoE has them focusing on crossbows if I recall. Zhugenu?
On this channel I found all the answers to the questions about the Bannerlord game
I found even more questions after making these videos haha TW maths is stronk :)
@@Strat-Guides The fact is that modern programmers do not know mathematics well, which is why such problems appear in games
Great job, buddy, as always. Only the Khuzaites are not Mongols, before their invasion there are still two and a half centuries according to the game chronology and about a century according to the setting: armor, weapons and so on. Although here, of course, collected from the 10th to the 13th century, but not later!
Thank you! Would it be more accurate to call them a "manchurian steppe tribe" then? I don't know the history of that area quite as well as Europe so I'm happy to learn more about it.
For some reason, I keep forgetting this game is set quite a bit earlier than it is :P Would you say it's 600 - 900ish??
@@Strat-Guides I really want to do a detailed analysis of all the cultures in the game someday. Although, of course, these are largely collective images, nevertheless, all have more or less real prototypes in history... I will not reveal all the cards, brother, all the knowledge of the world is at your fingertips.)
P.S. My English is not very good, I could not translate correctly: "Would you say it's 600 - 900ish??"
@@RemGaffer That would be really cool to watch a video on the real people that inspired the cultures of Bannerlord! I would definitely watch every episode :D
Sorry for my poor explanation - I meant to ask: "Is Bannerlord set between the years 600AD and 900AD roughly?"
@@Strat-Guides Oh, well, then my English is not so bad - that's about what I understood, but I wanted to clarify.)
I hesitated, because I immediately said that the 10th- the beginning of the 13th century is the most suitable, despite the fact that there is a lot of material culture both from the Bronze Age and up to the 16th.)
I always change my fiefs to irrigation when i realized that militia might be tied to hearts. It seems like they might be related so i just do that and hope. I really hate it when these mercenaries attack my villages so hopefully it actually makes a difference. Even when you have all your parties in defense and your kingdom strat in defense it's not enough to not get raided.
Yeah the only way to not get raided is to capture/behead enemy nobles :P Otherwise, there will always be that one or two parties that slips by and starts to raid. It's very annoying!
Another great video as usual. For me the fact that Empire are the largest culture is quite a big factor, and in my opinion makes them a great choice alone. Shame, as I am a Sturgian fanboy, and their bonuses are a little lame.
I agree, my current WC play through series is Empire for that exact reason! It makes it so much easier to avoid rebellions if you don't have all the policies ready yet.
I think Sturgia needs some kind of movement speed boost or they need their home redrawn because they always get into 2 wars at once and going back and forth takes way too long, making defense nearly impossible :(
I think with the Khuzait comparison the higher influence may be caused by you being a different culture. I'm not sure though no way to test that but just a theory as to why the math may be skewed
Make a video ranking the top 10 races and cultures in real life next please.
Haha that sounds like a really bad idea for a CZcams channel :P
Another question is it possible to level up a perk without actually putting any points into it can you power through it eventually? For example if I don't put any points into spear throwing, and I just go ham on it can I eventually power through it with no multipliers
What ends up happening is you reach the "hard cap". So if you have 0 focus points and 2 attribute points (default amount) then you will level up to 18 and then stop, no matter how much you use the skill. You will still gain XP for your main character level, but the skill XP stops.
9:50 I think the trade penalty has to be when you sell like 300 same items, their selling price decreases.
What I think is that this price decrease gets less steep with the aserai trade penalty trait.
thank you for this bruh i just started playing bannerlord 2
Hey cloud! Thanks for watching :) I hope you're having a good time! It's a tough game so feel free to reach out if you have any questions. We also have a discord with +5k people on it that can help as well, feel free to stop by!
Might it be worth reexaming the issue with khuzait @11:11? the day this vid was posted i was having issues in beta patch with horse archers not getting recognized as such in the pre-battle formations, which today was solved in a hotfix. since both issues were about horse archers not being properly recognized, maybe its possible that they were caused by the same problem?
Good idea, but unfortunately the problem is deeper than that is seems :( It's still giving the same pricing. It would be odd because the upgrade price was accurate but hiring price was not, so it makes me think the code for hiring is where the issue is. Thanks for the heads up and hopefully they do fix it once word gets back to them from the video (and maybe they can make it more than 10%... that's pretty weak lol)
Rising channel for bannerlord content yessir
Let's hope! I'm really looking forward to 2022. I really hope they finish Bannerlord and take it to it's fullest potential. Even if they don't, there are always amazing mods!
@@Strat-Guides Yep n also about your list, I like how it compiles the benefits of the perks, not only is battania op with the fian champions, but the militia is op, battanian fiefs are always the biggest when it comes to troop count. Do you have a link or download to your list cuz it really helps with perk selections.
@@restitutororbis675 So I have all of the Perks in a single database that I call the "hero builder" and I also have all of the policies in a separate database. I posted the hero builder on the discord server, you're welcome to copy it! You need a notion account to copy it, but notion is 100% free as well. discord.gg/48Tpe9dKH9 I'll try to get the policies database on there tonight when I get a chance. There are only 30 policies in the game so that one's not as big of a deal, but the perks are like 700+, I highly recommend using the database to find the right ones :)
For Aserai, did the trade price penalty reduction also not work on trade goods? It looks like you only tried it with armor in the video.
So I tried to test it a few times with trade goods, but the problem is the economy isn't exactly the same with each play through you load up. I was able to match the inventory levels by using console command and restocking the town, and it seemed like the prices were exactly the same at that point. I'm pretty confident the bonus isn't working for anything :( You bring up an excellent point though, I probably should have shown examples of the other trade items but I edited them out because of the time constraint. Thank you for watching!
@@Strat-Guides I know this is necro but, is that trade penalty reduction for your caravans specifically? Would their upkeep be lower/profit be higher as aseri just for being aseri, because they're getting a behind the scenes better trade price? Not that you have to test this or anything, just throwing the idea out there. It occurred to me just now as I was starting a new game.
I liked the old Sturgian bonus better then the new one cause when you get rich money is kind of nothing. Though it's not always winter.
Yeah I think the snow movement speed was a good one. It wasn't back then because snow move penalty didn't even work haha but it would be good now since it's finally working. Go figure :P
@@Strat-Guides Never realize always picked battanians.
the problem most people i have seen playing this game when it comes to Garrisons is they will fill it with their highest tier troops and thus lose so much money to keeping them in said Garrison that they will end up broke the best option to counter this is only place 25 elite units of foot and the same number of archers and rely on the militia units to fill the rest as they cost nothing to keep in the towns and castles but with the right build of your char and those of your faction that are in charge of said places you can end up making money from only using militia and a few elite troops for example in one of my playthroughs in sandbox i spent about 25 in game yrs building up members of my own clan and only my own clan and a select number of other followers to be good at the things needed to manage towns and the like as well as ensuring they were good traders and had at least half the perks in the other trees that could make money or help to keep places and people on good terms and doing this i took all of the Empire, Aserai, Khuzait lands and was only losing $8000 per week but making around $70k in the same time so by the time i was taking on the other factions i was the richest faction in the game and had no issues holding towns and castles for shorter spans of time with massive armies of elite troops but once i had control of the main areas around those towns i would remove those Garrison units and replace them with the militia units and my small group of elite and the enemy would never be able to take back any of their former towns or castles as due to having a corp of elite people i could move to where they were needed to boost the city or castle and then at least 3 armies always within the area they could protect those places i could force the enemy to where i could have all their nobles within one city and take them all in one battle it also pays to fight in a smart way like always ensuring your archers are on a raised area of land to ensure line of sight and give them better range on enemies and use your foot men in a smart way as in never just charge an enemy as this leads them to split into smaller groups and get pinned down by enemy troops as for cav (non ranged) have them act as one of your flanks and only commit them once the enemy have started to flee this ensures they wont take losses to the enemy foot men
Hi Strat, is the +1 Battania militia bonus really worth it?
Any video showing the difference it makes for a new player?
Thanks.
It's not a huge difference, but it can definitely help! I don't think I have a video dedicated to testing just that, but I can say from experience that more militia is good for auto resolve battles. They get the fortification bonus, so they fight as if they were higher tier units.
Depends on your play style
For sure. It's probably more important to pick one that's fun to play!
could you do a video that explains morale on the battlefield?
I do have that topic on my list to tackle soon. They changed it up recently, so I'm curious myself to see how it works now!
Pretty sure that the distance a party is from you affect invite to army so might wana test the valandian influence cost again
Yeah it is a factor, although I'm still not positive if the culture bonus was working properly or not. I wish there was an easier way to test it :(
I think the reduction in cost of influence for armies in the vlandian part comes from relations with the lord/clan. I have seen something similar in my plays, but not sure yet
And in the sturgian relations hit, I think the first voting wasn't affected because you proposed it, so it counts as a proposal, rather than a vote (my guess)
So I just double checked the save files, both were at 0 relations with those nobles. I also retested and teleported to the same spot before calling them in, same results. I checked their troops, mostly the same mix of units in both saves. I can't really think of anything else that would cause a 20% difference when everything else that changes the influence cost are equal?
For the Sturgian vote, I think you're right. It might only be relations hit from that actual vote screen and not proposing things. Although I'm not sure how I would test it otherwise as proposing policies doesn't cause relations hit, only voting against. Great point you brought up, thank you!
@@Strat-Guides yeah, that influence thing must be a typo indeed then, weird. Thanks for the testing man
Edit:maybe something else affects influence cost, but this might be hard to pinpoint
LOL did you switch to comic sans font for the Khuzait on purpose? At least it looks like comic sans, I'm no typeographer but I *am* a memer
Not them specifically lol I was having a hard time reading the text with blurry background and not having a black background specifically for the text so I started to experiment with other text. I think that one is easier to read, but takes up a ton of space so I like it for end-of-section recaps that have a lot of words. I need the normal one I use when doing the actual data though since I need it to be slim :) I'm less than 5 months into this whole youtube and editing thing so I still have lots to learn and experiment with.
I have a question. Whenever I start a game I always start in training fields. Is there a setting or something I have to disable to spawn in the cultures respective start?
So when you start a campaign, it will put you there always. You should try the sandbox mode, it will avoid the main quests and let you do whatever you want AND you spawn in your own culture :)
I just dont get how to get the startingposition right. I just choose Battania as Culture but got spawned in the training field of the Empire. Please Help! D:
Awesome videos. Gets me starting Bannerlord over and over again.
Sorry I should have mentioned that - if you start a campaign, you will default to the training fields but if you go sandbox, you will start with your culture's location!
Thank you for watching! I'm glad you're enjoying the game :D
13:04 - If I remember the lore, Monchug decided to settle the Khuzaits into permanent towns/cities instead of continuing the nomadic traditions of his ancestors. This culture clash might have been reflected in the "Horse archers go brr" Khuzait mentality and "only 3 riding options in character creation"
Interesting! That would make sense then if that's the case. That's one area of Bannerlord I'm quite lacking in - the lore :(
I pick Battania for movement bonus but play like a Khuzait with horse archers.
Ooh that's dirty! LOL The best of both worlds :D
Been a long time since I've really sat down with Bannerlord, did they remove one of the cultures having faster troop XP gain? I remember that always being my go to pick
Yeah they reworked it last year - I think that used to be Vlandia if I recall? Now Battania seems to be the best in terms of cultural bonuses.
Battania is my favourite as well. Those Fian Champions, they got it all, looks and skills. I also really like all the cool lore Battanians have when you look at theri town/village descriptions. A shame Caladog is such a terrible leader.
if you know how to build your char the only real thing that matters in your culture choice is the one you want to play as even with the ones with the worst bonuses can be leveled to be better than the other ones in their flat bonuses and also the only real thing the culture pick does is slightly change the starting gear and your starting area in sandbox in the Campaign it makes little to no real diff between them at all
the extra production from castle villages is deceptive. castles will grow until they eat as much as they produce, and that is based on the income you get from the villages and castle taxes. over time this means that a castle in the long run is more of a burden than a help. they will siege it with a force scaled for the size of the garrison, so the garrison doesn't mean much in the long run (bigger garrison means a bigger hit to the AI when they lose, but will take more troops for you to defeat the AI). the money you spend feeding the castle will easily outstrip any denars it generates before long, and the cost of defending it usually is even higher still. now that being said the villages go to the nearest town and sell their produce, which will boost the prosperity of the town and feed it. this makes the town more profitable, and so if you can get the town that the castles go to then it is a good deal, otherwise it is easily overlooked.
Agreed! I usually cut the garrison loose from my castles and make as much money as I can before the enemy takes it back lol Or I'll donate it back to someone else. Great insight, thanks for sharing this!!
Ok good im not the only one who found the sennon hardwood cheese
At first glance, I thought the opening footage was from escaping the prison in Oblivion.
Haha the famous intro! That would be a fun video idea, trying to recreate that.
for khuzaits special units - (khan guard tree) the bonus is not working. but for usual cavalry and cavalry archers works.
Ah crap, I forgot to test that :( Okay so the recruitment and upgrade cost both not working for noble line?
Also for the regular troops, upgrade cost works for both melee and ranged cav but recruitment only for melee cav, ranged cav are full price :(
The Aserai trading perks is working. But the Weapons, and Armors (and the horses and foods too) is not a trading stuff. Only the other products count "trading things". As like wood, iron, velvet, jewelry, silver ect.
So they did patch it in 1.7.2 and it's now working for all items :) unless I read the patch notes wrong?
@@Strat-Guides Sorry, I don't know. The 1.7.2 is just a beta patch currently. I wasn't check it...
Why does your voice change when you say mercenary at the beginning? Was that from a different game? It sounded familiar. Did you just edit your own voice?
Haha the truth is much more simple and funny - So I originally said Vassal on accident, so I wanted to record mercenary to replace it, but both of my kids were napping so i had to be quit and the sound came out all funky... I was going to replace it again, but now they are going crazy and it's hard to get any recording done once they are up! The joys of running a channel while working from home with kids. :D
@@Strat-Guides it threw me off haha! I was racking my brain trying to remember a game that sounded like that, but I was confused cause it also sounded like you. It does kinda sound like you were talking through a com link helmet or something. Like the npc voice in call of duty or something. Lol
when starting a new characther i focus on the atribute, not on the skill. Usually i go for all social pick, but then youth i choose what is best for my characther
Yeah that's what I do too :) It's much easier to get focus points, but very hard to get more attribute points.
Did the aserai trade reduction have any difference with trade goods or weapons?
I tested everything and saw no difference :( Sorry I should have mentioned it. The video was already starting to get a little long so I cut quite a bit out for the final edit.
My boi the Bannerlord GOAT how is the world quest run going?
Baaaaaaa :P It's going pretty well, we are at the beginning of the snowball stage and with the 1.7.0 sieges working I think it will go even faster than expected!
You forgot a few points about culture.
If Vlandia, must have knight stacks.
If Battania, must shoot every Vlandian.
If Empire, must subdue barbarians and build aqueducts for your LEGION stacks.
If Khuzait must execute all neighbours.
If Aserai must have camels and big axes.
If Sturgia, must have a great infantry army *and leave* Sturgia.
Lol I like it! Sounds like a nice set of rules to play by :)
"leave Sturgia" vlandian action.
Stugia is a good culture to start as but not a good culture to serve under. The movement through their land like you said takes very long. Sturgians don't like settling for peace either. They will hold 3 way wars with Battania, Khuzait, and the nothern empire. Which ends up making their land very hard to defend, losing much of their fiefs early game. My play through trying to serve their kingdom went rather terrible. I spent a lot of time in prison and not enough on the battlefield. I think a great video would be the perks of serving starting kingdoms
If you are Sturgian yourself and wnat to fight for Sturgia it's a good thing if they lose fiefs early, then you can retake those fiefs when you become a vassal and have your first fiefs be of the right culture and on the frontline which both makes them easy to build up and gives a lot of siege defense opportunities to level up skills fast.
That's a great point about multiple wars. They tried to address Sturgia getting stomped in patches several times now, but they always seem to end up in the same place each patch lol That's a great idea for another video, I will add it to the list!
Good point about Sturgia losing fiefs and being able to take the back later as a vassal. I think the only issue there is once they lose a couple fiefs, they can sometimes spiral down and not recover for the rest of the game :(
@@Strat-Guides I think it depends a bit on how much you are powergaming and how hard battles you can handle. I really feel that the way the game is designed now it's usually a bad idea to be a vassal for your own culture because of how culture and fiefs work. The best strategy to prepare for your own kingdom is really to be fighting against your own culture so you can get those fiefs and farm relationships of your cultures clans by never taking lords as prisoners (same broken mechanic as warband...), but the alternative is to make sure your faction is doing really badly, retake the lost fiefs and then start your own kingdom keeping those fiefs once the rest of your faction is too weak to threaten you. I personally like taking Sturgia as my kingdom a lot since you basically only have to defend around Omor and Tyal and no other faction attacks both of those at once.