'Hamas is going to survive', warns former US State Department Middle East negotiator • FRANCE 24

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 05. 2024
  • Former US State Department Middle East Negotiator Aaron Miller, who served under six US Secretaries of State on Arab-Israel affairs, told FRANCE 24 on Tuesday that Israel's strategy in Gaza has essentially "broken down" despite its army’s progress in the enclave.
    Read more about this story in our article: f24.my/AKWc.y
    🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
    🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
    🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.com/en/
    Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
    Follow us on X (Twitter): f24.my/Xen
    Browse the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
    Discover our TikTok videos: f24.my/TKen
    Get the latest top stories on Telegram: f24.my/TGen

Komentáře • 135

  • @RogerDosethee-bg8rw
    @RogerDosethee-bg8rw Před 24 dny +19

    War is not about Hamas and hostages, it's about land and political agenda.

    • @ericp1139
      @ericp1139 Před 19 dny

      Trump’s son in law already salivating over beachfront real estate.

  • @pranks1457
    @pranks1457 Před 24 dny +10

    I never thought I would see the West so ridiculous and reactive. Goodbye to your hegemonic past. I don't think the rest of the world will miss you

  • @ulehlud9027
    @ulehlud9027 Před 25 dny +42

    "Shared values" ... it's an insult to the word "values" to apply it to what the U.S. and Israel share. "Interests"... yes.

    • @fatinarnful
      @fatinarnful Před 25 dny

      Their shared values is hatred against Arabs and Muslims which is actual meaning antisemitic! They steal everything !

    • @bikerd12
      @bikerd12 Před 25 dny +2

      Right you’re

    • @sirburst1728
      @sirburst1728 Před 21 dnem

      Well; in a way they both are into the killing business

  • @frankordonez2826
    @frankordonez2826 Před 25 dny +21

    We live on a crazy world

  • @sidakong9467
    @sidakong9467 Před 25 dny +53

    BB don’t need to destroy Hamas, his just need to convince the public his destroying Hamas to stay in power

    • @jeremyharnishfeger6519
      @jeremyharnishfeger6519 Před 25 dny

      AMERICA 🇺🇸 lost the will to win wars after 1945. Woke weak kneed spineless cowardly yellow bellied budlight drinking fools.

    • @oleggold
      @oleggold Před 25 dny +4

      Won't work.
      He is done.
      He had 99 lives in politics, but now it's over.

    • @2Sage-7Poets
      @2Sage-7Poets Před 25 dny

      it could work but his credibility will be questioned why oct7 happened.. and since he already failed protecting the people.. he will be impeached for sure so the result would be the same..

    • @Extreme_sigma
      @Extreme_sigma Před 25 dny

      😂

    • @larrysherk
      @larrysherk Před 25 dny +3

      That doesn't work when every Israeli can see Netanyahu is losing big time.

  • @fathburr
    @fathburr Před 25 dny +17

    USA is talking about increasing Aid flow into Gaza from past 5 months

    • @ggaggagga4
      @ggaggagga4 Před 25 dny +3

      Have you seen all the images of starving children and adults in Gaza? Yeah... me neither...

    • @user-xh8zp6ht2b
      @user-xh8zp6ht2b Před 25 dny

      They are spending a fortune building a floating dock. What is your country doing to help?

  • @beyourselfbrave4115
    @beyourselfbrave4115 Před 25 dny +20

    Someone who knows the actual situation and gives a fair comment . 👍

    • @vlndfee6481
      @vlndfee6481 Před 25 dny

      USA finanz is one step from abyss

  • @ianleslie6971
    @ianleslie6971 Před 25 dny +5

    Excellent coverage and analysis 👏

  • @nevarran
    @nevarran Před 25 dny +15

    News for anyone with half a bran. For everyone else it was pretty clear from the get go. You don't destroy a terrorist organization that relies on desperate and suffering people, by making more desperate and suffering people.

    • @rettro6578
      @rettro6578 Před 25 dny

      💯💯💯

    • @user-gr7kc6hm8k
      @user-gr7kc6hm8k Před 25 dny +2

      ah nice another expert, lucky to meet u here
      so what is the solution?

    • @fadumonor868
      @fadumonor868 Před 25 dny +6

      You can’t destroy people who are fighting for basic human rights and self-determination

    • @charlesscott4722
      @charlesscott4722 Před 25 dny

      @@fadumonor868 Actually you can, you can g-word them. It worked for America and Australia

    • @jfern6673
      @jfern6673 Před 25 dny +3

      @@fadumonor868 they are not fighting for basic human rights.. this is how stupid the thinking becomes..

  • @ungerspretoria8280
    @ungerspretoria8280 Před 25 dny +19

    Do the palestinian people have the right to break out of the largest open-air prison? The entire situation could have been different, i for one, would choose freedom and self-determination. That said, i wish war was not an option. The problem: If Israel stop now, they will face endless insurgents committing terror acts in Israel. The same for the Palestinians in Gaza. The only 2 routes in this conflict is either a two-state solution, where they can learn to live together, or the alternative is what we are currently witnessing with the IDF in Gaza. It is clear what route Israel chose to take. If the world want to stop this, the time is now!!! I choose freedom for the people of Palestine. What a sad period in humanity's history..

    • @jfern6673
      @jfern6673 Před 25 dny

      no they dont.. they could have used Eygpts border or left by boat.. the walls stopped them from entering Israel only uninvited.. But people like you dont care about the facts..

    • @tomhenry897
      @tomhenry897 Před 25 dny

      From river to sea
      All you see are
      Israelis
      🇮🇱

    • @josepha.r5839
      @josepha.r5839 Před 25 dny

      "where [Israelis and Palestinians] can learn to live together" I do wish it could be so .. and it might some day but I've been seeing variations of these skirmishes, battles, wars since 1956 and the takeover of Suez Canal. I was 10 and can still remember the scenes on tv. It made sense to me even then that since the canal was in Egypt they should control it and not England/France.

    • @practice4523
      @practice4523 Před 25 dny

      ​@@tomhenry897the creation of israel was and is the worst and biggest blister in the moral history of mankind. That 76 years ago an entire people was cleansed to make way for another is a horrifying nightmare that we all continue to grapple with

    • @roystonmason9125
      @roystonmason9125 Před 24 dny +1

      @@tomhenry897 the most hated country in the world

  • @cryptonighit
    @cryptonighit Před 25 dny +16

    Iranians are the Resistance leader
    Iranians do not abandoned Friends , have you ever seen any Examples ?
    Iranians supported ANC to fight Apartheid long before any other country

    • @frankcrozier1318
      @frankcrozier1318 Před 25 dny

      The world knows who fully supported the vicious apartheid South African regime and even offered them nuclear assistance.

    • @Chisel_Chest
      @Chisel_Chest Před 25 dny

      Iran (the government) sucks balls. They treat their own people terribly and encourage terrorism.

    • @Sonny-ko2zk
      @Sonny-ko2zk Před 24 dny

      That's why SOUTH AFRICA destroyed a banana Republic. The country is collapsing and nothing is working 😂😂😂

    • @cryptonighit
      @cryptonighit Před 24 dny

      @@Sonny-ko2zk you have a convoluted idea in economics ☠️🤣

  • @johndoe-zz1nr
    @johndoe-zz1nr Před 25 dny +16

    Vietnam and Afghanistan wars lasted 10 years. It is a wishful thinking to imagine a day after in Isreal’s Vietnam

    • @limcako41
      @limcako41 Před 25 dny +14

      Also the Israeli occupation of South Lebanon lasted 20 years before the IDF left due to the resistance

    • @sparks1792
      @sparks1792 Před 25 dny +1

      Comparing this with Vietnam lmaoooooo😂

    • @roystonmason9125
      @roystonmason9125 Před 24 dny

      @@sparks1792 also USA BOOM shakka

    • @OloRishaCreole504
      @OloRishaCreole504 Před 23 dny

      Vietnam had lots of artillery though..theres no need forn IDF to be there

  • @jvm-tv
    @jvm-tv Před 25 dny +2

    On point analysis by someone who knows what he's talking about.

  • @DDBb993
    @DDBb993 Před 25 dny

    10:29- How ? How please explain sir? That seems like pie in the sky.

  • @tethergobrrr
    @tethergobrrr Před 25 dny +1

    Saudi mustn’t agree to any deal that doesn’t involve Hms. As a westerner, observing from afar, H is the only player in the mix that has demonstrated trustworthiness and competency to lead.

  • @vlaythsh7880
    @vlaythsh7880 Před 22 dny +1

    Till oppresion is their resistance will be their , its not hard to cmprehend.

  • @SeeLasSee
    @SeeLasSee Před 25 dny +5

    Well the head of Hamas lives in comfort in Doha. He had 11 sons until recently…

  • @leeoswald9799
    @leeoswald9799 Před 25 dny +4

    WORLD'S WORST COMB OVER.

  • @elaineread15
    @elaineread15 Před 25 dny +3

    He states that Israel has a "proximity problem with Islamic resistance."
    Palestine 🇵🇸 , who suffer illegal occupation, are the ones with the proximity problems.

    • @tomhenry897
      @tomhenry897 Před 25 dny

      From river to sea
      All you see are
      Israelis
      🇮🇱

    • @elaineread15
      @elaineread15 Před 25 dny

      @tomhenry897 Precisely. You illustrate the point that Israel are the neighbours from hell.

  • @ggaggagga4
    @ggaggagga4 Před 25 dny

    I'd like to see this guy discuss the issue with Dr Dan Schueftan. Miller needs to be schooled in the difference between solutions and responses.

  • @ThamiNdlalane
    @ThamiNdlalane Před 25 dny

    Seriously, did they expect to Hamas??

  • @KiritoAkira
    @KiritoAkira Před 25 dny +3

    Is impossible to destroy a resistance

  • @Tamar-sz8ox
    @Tamar-sz8ox Před 25 dny

    We do not know what will happen. I do think peace will come one day 100%

  • @geraldgillman1642
    @geraldgillman1642 Před 25 dny +1

    in turkey and eggpyt for sure

  • @Just_Johnnie
    @Just_Johnnie Před 25 dny

    I don’t think wars can completely destroy Hama. It’s not possible as long as money flowing freely to Hamas.

    • @SinaZarin
      @SinaZarin Před 25 dny

      You are so ignorant and naive. It's not about the money. How many mercenaries have you seen to fight like this? They would never stop fighting until self-determination.

  • @master1941
    @master1941 Před 25 dny

    Yeah, outside of the middle east

  • @wilg9400
    @wilg9400 Před 25 dny

    This has been proved to be true over and over in the guerrilla wars in history. Even if you eliminate it the vacuumed room will create another group rapidly when the whole environment not changed as well.

  • @tomhenry897
    @tomhenry897 Před 25 dny

    In quarter
    None will be left in Gaza

  • @thomasnicodemou5160
    @thomasnicodemou5160 Před 25 dny +1

    He is missing the point by a mile.
    Whatever you may think of Hamas, at the end of the day is an armed group within the occupation, further still Gaza has been under siege for the last 17 years.
    There is no military solution to the problem.
    The Palestinian people deserve freedom, independence and self determination.
    The rest of talk is irrelevant rubbish.

  • @johnnymisbegotten
    @johnnymisbegotten Před 25 dny

    What happened to the 2 state solution ?

  • @nooralimanjee9102
    @nooralimanjee9102 Před 24 dny

    Sure, on the surface , but
    back door and still open.
    VETO IN UNITED NATION
    SPEAK ITSELF.

  • @foreveryoung999
    @foreveryoung999 Před 25 dny +1

    You can't kill a dark spirit.

  • @charlessmyth
    @charlessmyth Před 25 dny +9

    With so much "success" in Afghanistan and Iraq, to draw upon, the US has a seriously brass neck to be lecturing the Israelis :-)

    • @alexpkeaton4471
      @alexpkeaton4471 Před 25 dny

      Well, when was the last time you saw the US get owned by a native reservation?
      IDF = Incompetent Defense Failures

  • @KChung-dt5gs
    @KChung-dt5gs Před 25 dny

    Appreciate this guys analysis...but what's up with that hair style?

  • @Ken-cg2wr
    @Ken-cg2wr Před 24 dny

    Correct. The prophecy says there will always be a group of people fighting evil in the Holy Land until the return of Jesus.

  • @rananjaysingh8010
    @rananjaysingh8010 Před 25 dny

    In a democratic country staying in power is dependent on the,people's votes.

  • @Thedudness1980
    @Thedudness1980 Před 25 dny +1

    In order to change hamas, hamas should be weaker, and that goal isn't achieved yet.

  • @Dan-yf2df
    @Dan-yf2df Před 25 dny +12

    Employees of the US State Department are known for their incompetence so any prediction this person makes is bound to be wrong.

    • @juanrodriguez5404
      @juanrodriguez5404 Před 25 dny +7

      What's your background in thinking this person is wrong?? 🤔

    • @Alopen-xb1rb
      @Alopen-xb1rb Před 25 dny +2

      Sure thing bro. You must have all the answers. Care to actually articulate anything other than “Wrong”.

    • @SquillyNelson
      @SquillyNelson Před 25 dny +2

      Close. Lower-level diplomats generally do great work, but are usually undermined by the higher-level 'planners.'

  • @MrBeard-ig5zc
    @MrBeard-ig5zc Před 23 dny

    Every US state department “negotiator” for this conflict has been Jewish. Every single one.

  • @Truspio
    @Truspio Před 25 dny +2

    Turkey announced it treats 1000 Hms soldiers.
    How can it not survive?

    • @slightlyamusedyoutuber3517
      @slightlyamusedyoutuber3517 Před 25 dny +4

      Hummus Freedom Fighter? Also Isreel treated IS1S fighters at their medical facilities, how did they survive that?

    • @giorgismaximos8662
      @giorgismaximos8662 Před 25 dny

      @@slightlyamusedyoutuber3517 Turkey a NATO member supporting treating and
      probably training ter rists

    • @SinaZarin
      @SinaZarin Před 25 dny +1

      ​@giorgismaximos8662 nato needs them way more than they need nato. They are chummy with iran and have 2nd best, the biggest army of nato. No one is threatening them.

    • @slightlyamusedyoutuber3517
      @slightlyamusedyoutuber3517 Před 25 dny

      @@giorgismaximos8662 Isreel a close ally to the western world, has treated IS1S members, who've fought and killed western nationals.

    • @ruqiasalah5744
      @ruqiasalah5744 Před 25 dny

      How much you can lied

  • @k9k9k9er6
    @k9k9k9er6 Před 25 dny +2

    What a great negotiator…I bet terr orists love him…is this kind of negotiation and attitude that let Taliban back in power I guess…

    • @arjenrobbed1294
      @arjenrobbed1294 Před 22 dny

      IDF are the terrorists here in every aspect for decades

  • @user-tx2mj6uz6v
    @user-tx2mj6uz6v Před 25 dny +2

    Miller’s inference that Netanyahu is doing everything solely to stay in power is unsupported and slanderous. He makes preference to the ongoing trial against Netanyahu, but the Court in that case has already said that “bribery” cannot be proved, and that statement is essentially the end of the trial, though it may continue for a few months.
    As for “risk aversion” or “risk tolerance,” more than 90% of Israel’s Jews demand the end of Hamas. It’s not coming from Netanyahu, it’s from the people. Netanyahu has promised repeatedly that Hamas will be destroyed, the most recent promise last night (5/13), that is what the people want, and that is what will happen. Larry M. Goldstein

    • @rettro6578
      @rettro6578 Před 25 dny

      What nonsense, Netanyahu will be put on trial for 10/7 failures.

  • @jrkr7357
    @jrkr7357 Před 25 dny +1

    The size of the mentioned Hamas is very subjective. Does it mean a group of 2 or 10 or 100 or 1000 Hamas members ?
    I think the size of Hamas needs to be specified because Hamas can be represented by 2 members or 10 or 100 members .....

    • @oleggold
      @oleggold Před 25 dny +1

      Hamas is around 100k members in total. It's crazy, but that's the size +/-.

    • @patriciasamson7096
      @patriciasamson7096 Před 25 dny +2

      @@oleggold evidence ????

    • @jamludentertainment
      @jamludentertainment Před 25 dny

      Good question, we dont even have the numbers of those that were eliminated.

    • @jaegybomb
      @jaegybomb Před 25 dny

      I've heard 40k but I'm sure they are recruiting. The only thing that is going to get a democracy to stick in Gaza is getting peace talks going in the West Bank and slowly handing over 50% of the settlements (over like 10 years) while they remain peaceful.

    • @josepha.r5839
      @josepha.r5839 Před 25 dny

      @@patriciasamson7096 If it wasn't before it probably is now .. even some/many couch 'warriors' here in the US.