Where is America? Map Men explain | Thoughts + Commentary
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 11. 2023
- The Map Men explain where is America. We're talking maps, language, accents, Colombia, Latin America... and no one is forgetting Canada.
Original Video: • Where is America?
Jay Foreman channel: / @jayforeman
MORE VIDEOS/ music reactions/ short story readings on Patreon: patreon.com/NoProtocol947?utm...
Literary Recommendation:
4321 by Paul Auster: amzn.to/3GnPH3q
Try Audible for Audiobooks: amzn.to/3QMwv2G
How Many Continents Are There?- conflicting sources
-www.sciencefocus.com/planet-e...
-history.howstuffworks.com/wor...
-www.iflscience.com/how-many-c...
Music Recommendations:
Tren al Sur by Los Prisioneros: • Los Prisioneros - Tren...
Heaven's Only Wishful by MorMor: • MorMor- Heaven's Only...
You can't go wrong with Jay Foreman videos. Plus, everything that makes you smile is a win for me.
Smooth.
Lol @@Lightkie
I can tell you emanate charisma
Flirting ......?
I'm British and dated a girl from Toronto for five years, and not only could I not tell where other North Americans were from, but she couldn't either.
One time in the supermarket in the UK, we could hear an NA accent, and I asked her if they were Canadian or American. She couldn't tell. So we walked to the other end of the supermarket and could still hear them, so we concluded they were from the US.
Europeans do that with every English speaker.
A woman was rude and demanding at a French restaurant. The waiter walks away, cursing stupid dumb Americans. The only problem is she was Norwegian, who knew English.
yeah, even tho i do think americans on average are louder than canadians, that doesn't mean you can tell the difference with just that lol, there is high energy louder type people in canada and there are quiet "keep to yourself" type americans....i know people from both of those personality groups who are from both canada and america
the only real tell there is, is if someone pronounces "about" like "aboot"....like, canadians pronounce everything with an "oo" sound that, in america, sounds like "ow"
@@David_Werbenjagermanjensen There are some other things like filler words that are different as well.
@@johnbattle7518 yeah but i mean like....something that comes up in a lot of words that u can hear the accent to, the canadian people i know almost sound american to me with their word choice, but they always have that "ow" and "oo" thing i was talking about lol
you are probably right with the filler words tho, i just cant recall any of them cuz the only times ive ever heard them were in some form of media i was watching, rather than actual conversations i can relate to
**laughs a little too loud, in American**
Hey! Really enjoying your channel down here in New Zealand. Good variety of subjects covered and clearly intelligent commentary.
Love your reaction and love that you mentioned the question in regards to how many continents there are, since Jay Foreman has a map men video about that too! Looking forward to seeing your reaction and hearing your comments about it!
Always enjoy hearing your take. You're so well spoken and I appreciate that. Also, thanks for the recommendations too! 🙂
It is a nice day when I see a new video notification from this channel, especially when its related to map men.
11:40:
there is a film with a similar premise: "Run Lola Run".
(It's in German but I believe there exists an English version or at least English subtitles).
The title character experiences the same day in 4 different ways.
The only original difference is the exact second on which she leaves her house.
One second earlier or two seconds later and her life takes dramatically different turns...
Great film. Very intriguing.
Hey mate, love your channel, especially for the no intro letsgo! thanks for introducing me to these mad lads.
The point you make about about the number of continents you might think there are is dependant on when / where you were at school reminds me of a recurring question that has been asked on the UK TV show "QI" various times over the last 20 years - "How many moons does the earth have?". There is a compilation of these on the QI CZcams channel, titled "QI Compilation | Alan VS The Moon(s)". Never sure how well known QI is outside the UK, but if you've not come across it before you might find it "Quite Interesting".
Jay Forman is a great dude and his channel is amazing, too! Your videos are great, so far... 😃😃
Enjoy your channel, keep up the great work, thank you for sharing.👍🏻
What you say around 2:40 about translating names is interesting. In English we seem to have largely stopped doing it in the late 19th century. It does make a difference, because, say, the name of King Frederick William of Prussia sounds less sinister and 'other' to us than his descendant Kaiser Wilhelm of Germany, for instance. The King of Spain who launched the Armada against England was Philip II, but we call the current Spanish King Felipe VI. Odd when you think about it. edit: On other points, CGPGrey has a video about the number of continents, and Bill Bryson's book "Made in America" contains some of the other names that the US founding fathers considered adopting.
Really glad you are checking out more of these guys, hope you keep it up, they are really entertaining to me and give some interesting, rather niche information.
Edit: Funnily enough, I just picked up (a translated version of) Columbus' Ship Diarie of the first voyage yesterday! Kinda exited to read it now.
W vid choice gangsta, always down for some geography.
Kinda random, but: in addition to commenting and liking these videos, I encourage everyone here to click “share” and then click “copy link” - even if you don’t plan on sending it to anyone. This action alone constitutes a share to the algorithm. It takes two seconds and is an often overlooked but significant factor in boosting visibility of CZcams videos that you find worthy and enjoyable. This goes for any content that you would like to see better represented on the platform, of course.
I worry that I may be running out of adequate ways to thank you! I truly do appreciate your support, but please know that just your view is enough as well (: I wonder if you’ve already read todays literary recommendation?
Also, I had no clue that the algorithm works that way lol
@@NoProtocol You can always create a template and copy/paste to save time =D
And hey, I have everything I need in life, so giving away the excess to make the people/causes/whatever I care about happy means a million times more to me than letting it sit there collecting dust in a brokerage account or something. (The opportunity cost of choosing to give has never been the loss of another zero in the balance, so what difference does it REALLY make, anyway?) To me, it's a fair exchange of value; I'm going to try to keep the doting to a minimum, but you have a knack beyond what I think you realize for being behind a camera and making literally anything interesting. More so than the incessant, overly flattering comments would have you believe, even. I have a busy life. I otherwise couldn't care less about sepak takraw. I still clicked the notification as soon as I received it. This must be the first channel I have been part of the "notification squad" for since like, my early HS days when Kurzgesagt was first on the come up.
Side note, while we're on the topic: the only reason I don't slide the Super Thanks bar to $500 every time is because of the parenthesis THEN colon smileys. That is NOT normal behavior.
Thanks for the heads-up on the link copy - Done.
I also want to thank you for the share link info, and for supporting NP's channel.
Just found your channel, loved this video!
OK, so I've just discovered you and I'm on a bit of a binge, but you're bloody wonderful you are.
More jay foreman! Love his stuff
Old American here, I subscribed because this is the first video of yours I have encountered and found it very entertaining.
My sincerest suggestion to check any Jay Foreman video of these series:
- MapMen
- Unfinished London
- any of his music videos that always have comedic or satirical lyrics
I'm hoping you see this message. I've noticed that you're not uploading much stand up reactions. These are my personal favorites. One of the many reasons for this is that your smile and laughter brighten even the darkest days! Would you consider incorporating more in the future? I'm happy to offer suggestions if you wish. Thank you for the original, thought-provoking and entertaining content and commentary! ✌️ ☮️ 🇺🇸❤
Those pictures of the architecture in Bogotá were awesome, I appreciate you sharing them. As a person in the UK, to me they looked like some typical country pub down the road from me haha would have never guessed it was in Colombia if I hadn't been told! The amazing organic patchwork of ideas and happenstance that makes up human history is often delightful :)
Oh you gem! Your videos haven't been hitting my feed.
Congrats on 100k subscribers!
I like how we are slowly getting a 360 panorama of this room.
Idk why but I always hear matpat screaming in my head “THE LORRREEEE” every time more is revealed lol
Atlas Pro gas a phenomenal video on defining continents. I think it would fit in well with your content.
Damn your hair is just glistening, really nice. another fun vid, always love your uploads
Jay Foreman has a video on the number of continents that might be interesting to look at
It always annoys me when people complain about someone saying Columbus "discovered" America. You don't have to be the first person to ever see or do something to be able to discover it for yourself or others.
It's like if you're driving home from work and you take a different street that's 5 minutes quicker, you just "discovered" a new route for yourself. It doesn't mean other people didn't already know about that route. Children are constantly making "discoveries as they grow. The first time they see a Bumble Bee, that's a new discovery for them. A few weeks ago I discovered a new recipe for a delicious chicken and broccoli dish, I didn't create the recipe though and others knew about it, but I discovered it for myself.
It's the same with Columbus, no he wasn't the first person to know about the continent. But the people of Europe didn't know about it, so he "discovered" it for the people of Europe.
It depends which people of Europe you're talking about. The Icelanders knew about Vinland, which was North America.
I liked your video. I liked the map video. I reccomend the song Ghostwriter by RJD2
If you’re ever watching Map Men and a note, or news headline, or document flashes up for just a second, be sure to pause and read it. Chances are it’s been written by the lads and will probably be hilarious. Their attention to detail is mind blowing.
I usually don't commit on anything , but thank you for all your good shows.
Awesome! Thanks ❤️ Much Love! #Hangovergang
There are many reaction video channels but you stand out because your refer to other sources and you promote reading books. I like that a lot.
Jay Foreman did a comedy musical support act for Dave Gorman in the UK several years back. I missed the show but I have his CD from it kicking around somewhere.
You from Nicaragua? Well done, country!
Not only is the best rum I've ever drunk from there, but a favorite CZcamsr too. Great!
Map men do a video on continents. Worth a watch
4321 is a fabulous book. I read Moon Palace earlier in the year, which is similar, but one storyline. The New York Trilogy is great too: three short novellas.
Love the “how many continents are there?” conversation: I recently got into a debate with a friend from Colombia about it. I was raised saying North America/South America whereas she says it’s just America. But you’ve got to think that if you say it’s just the one continent of America, that logic should push you to the conclusion there are only four continents: America, Eurasica (Europe, Asia, Africa), Australia, and Antarctica.
According to the Ingoldsby Legends (google it),all the best geographers say that there are five continents; Europe, Asia, Africa, America and Romney Marsh.
I like that. I guess a good question would be , how much water qualifies as a divide? Oceans obviously count, but do canals?
@@punky1534great question. If you do it that way I think we end up with 6. NA, SA (Panama canal), Eurasia, Africa (Suez canal), Australia and Antarctica. Just like it was said in the video - it’s odd there isn’t a consensus about this. 🤔
Continents do have a consensus, it's a study of the science of Geology. There are many more continents than you think, there are 7 major ones, but there also many sub-continents and micro-continents
Continents in this sense meaning geographic, not geologic. Yes, there are continental plates and subcontinents, but we’re talking about the lack of globally defined geographical areas.
You are not wrong on the accents between Canada and the USA.. Even the distinct ones have a lot of similarities. When I hear a rural canadian accent it reminds me of a Wisconsin accent.
In English, CURRENT and recent monarch names are NOT translated. So, for example, the King of Spain is Felipe VI not Philip VI, even though all previous Felipe's are almost always referred to as Philip in English. Same with Carl XVI Gustaf of Sweden (all previous Carl's are called Charles in English). I didn't know that Elizabeth II was called Isabel in Spanish. Queens named Isabella in Spain or Portugal are not called Elizabeth in English.
Map Men made a video about how many continent there are. That should interest you. ^^
I live in Brazil, Rio de Janeiro, and I learned at school that there are 6 continents, America, Africa, Europe, Asia, Oceania and Antarctica, but for some time at school I learned that America was divided into 3 Americas, North, South and Central America, that changed over time, so it would be 8 if it didn't changed.
So if Central America is its own continent, what is Middle East? Is it Asia, Europe, or Africa? Or would it be by itself just like Central America. Most maps have Central America with North America as the continent.
Even a moderate Toronto accent will sometimes sneak a longer o in some words whereas someone from my area right next door (Michigan) will not. Aboot is not about.
Yes, I do like the humor of these guys. First video from them I've seen.
That would be like having four books for the price of one.
Love that your accent is coming out here and there. :)
Yea I live in the u.p we have a different accent from downstate and Canadiens, but Canadiens will always have longer o’s as well as always saying eh with a high h sound
4:12 I have this map downstairs. It's great :D
Map men did a video about how many continents there are. That might be what you're referring to anyway but it's good, if you haven't seen it i would recommend
Loved this. For an alternative view of the world (not just "America") try Al Murray's "Take on the Nations of the World". Very, clever, very funny (contains some profanity, of course it would its Al Murray!). Makes reference to most of the Americas including Colombia, Canada, "treacherous" Argentina, Peru, Panama etc. Quite long but will suit your sense of humour (I think),
British defeated every country in the world. Pub land lord series
Greetings from Minneapolis, South Canadia!
About the number of continents thing Map Men made another video talking about that!
4:25 Cooperworld-Jonesania
Btw the link to the channel is broken
Also funny you should mention the different conceptions of how many continents there are, because our lovely map men have a video entirely on this topic, could be a fun reaction for next time!
I thought it was interesting that you mentioned the Newfie (Newfoundland) Accent, I'm no expert and base my obeservations purely on watching the TV drama The Republic of Doyle set in Newfoundland, that because it was seperated from mainland Canada it retained most of it British Isles origins and the Irish influence on the region's culture and language is still present today, which has likely contributed to the development of a distinct accent in the area. The accent spoken in Newfoundland and Labrador is known as Newfoundland English, and it has a distinct mix of Irish, English, and West Country dialects.
The ‘little Britain’ photos of Bogotá blew my mind
The pronunciation of Columbus was hilarious to me 😂. I could hear the voice in my head continuing with something about an extended car warranty.
America is our home good to see ya you look fantastic happy holidays ❤
America is a continent & an American is from the Continent of America.
Your hair looks fantastic in this video :)
Unrelated but do you have Native American ancestry?
7. One for each major tectonic plate
Hi, cartographer of 25 years here. If we consider a continent different than a landmass, 'technically' there are:
1. Europe (includes Iceland, Malta, Doggerland (now submerged), east to the Urals, and SE to the borders of Turkey and Iran)
2. Africa (including econzone island)
3. North America (including the Aleutians, south to the Colombian border and Trinidad, Bermuda, and Greenland)
4. South America
5. Asia (west to the Urals, SW to the Sinai, S to the Seychelles, SE to Singapore, E to the Kurils)
6. Oceania (not even getting started on this one. Its HUGE.
7. Zealandia (mostly submerged but contains NZ, Fiji, and thousands of islands. Also huge).
8. Antarctica.
Hello, Electrical Engineer of 23yrs.
America is a continent & an American is from the Continent of America.
If not, what is America?
Ahhhh the way you pronounce New Found Land!
Most canadians i know smoosh it together as newfun'lan (sometimes with a d on the end, sometimes not)
You look very pretty here, your hair looks really nicely styled :)
BTW, some nice looking houses in Bogota - I never imagined seeing those architectural styles there.
An alternative is that is named after Richard ap Meryk, anglicised to Richard Amerike (or Ameryk) (c. 1440-1503) was a British merchant, royal customs officer and later, sheriff of Bristol. Several claims have been made for Amerike by popular writers of the late twentieth century. One was that he was the major funder of the voyage of exploration launched from Bristol by the Venetian John Cabot in 1497, and that Amerike was the owner of Cabot's ship, the Matthew. Ap means that Richard was Welsh in origin, ap Meryk means son of Meryk .
Probably the most known Chilean music up here is from Mon Laferte.
Tormento and Tu falta de querer are great music videos.
Canada and the United States sound similar because all the cities of North America share a “metropolitan” accent.
It’s only when you leave the cities into the more rural areas do the accents come out strong.
I think there are 2 reasons for this:
1. Cities are generally filled with people from all over, and must adapt to better communicate with each other, speaking more clearly and pronouncing everything as best as possible.
2. Rural regions are generally more tight nit with people who grew up together with a lot of inside jokes and slang from families going back generations. The accent is usually thickest with the elderly, and comes out strong when people are free to be themselves without worrying what anyone else thinks of them.
I grew up in Atlantic Canada and would always talk a certain way with my friends and family, but then I travelled across Canada for work, eventually settling down in Quebec.
When I took my SO home to the maritimes, she noted that I suddenly started talking completely different and with a heavy accent, which I didn’t even realize I was doing.
On top of this, my family remarked that I’ve started to take on a Québécois French accent from living here so long.
Went to school in the 70’s (Florida & Colorado, military brat) and was taught to reference USA as “The United States of America” and as the “Northern America of the America continent”. I guess teaching has changed since then.
Translating names is a good laugh since it wheels back around. The english john becomes sean in irish gaelic (anglicised) which then comes back to england alongside john.
From that the already anglicised spelling of sean gets further anglicised to form shaun and shawn, which also sit alongside sean, john, jon and jean, which is the french john or another spelling for jane, which is the female john.
The Scottish version of the English John is Iain.
The English version of the Scottish version of John is Ian
Fellow descendant of the great aguas of Nicaragua, you definitely have to look more into our history
Map Men actually have a video about how many continents there are. You should check it out.
thats crazy love
I'm Australian and was taught there are seven continents.
when it comes to the number of continents, the channet CGP Grey has a fine video (How many continents are there) explaining the problem with counting continents. (spoiler: what are continents)
I always wonder what's going on when you cut away from the face cam in a lot of videos. Could you fill us in?
I was always taught there were 7 continents but what we call continents is about as arbitrary as countries so 5 is also fine
Map men is goated
i was taught there are 7 continents (people who was thaught there are 6 probably considered Europe and Asia as Eurasia and that makes sense because it's a same "piece of land" but for some they are different continents because they're different linguistically and ethnically, and people who were taught 5 probably considered 2 Americas as one)
Cristovão Colombo in portuguese (and weirdly enough we have a huge mall in Lisbon named after him)
Bogota looks nice (adds to list)
WOW! some of those pictures of Colombia looked identical to England! I'd love to know why!
This was sooooo informative! We have Fun Fact Friday where I volunteer during the morning planning meeting.
PS: I was taught 7 continents and 9 planets. And the reasons they Pluto isn't a planet are in fact not true
Continent can either be land mass or tectonic plate. For land mass there is Eurasia, Africa, Australia, Antarctica, North America and South America. If we go by tectonic plates you have to add Zealandia and a bunch more.
America is a continent & an American is from the Continent of America.
If not, then what is America?
En la Cuba, en Geografía desde la primaria nos enseñan 6
1-America
2-Europa
3-Asia
4-Africa
5-Australia y Oceanía*
6-Antartida
*Australia y Oceanía se enseña así como un solo continente.
*Europa y Asia tambien nos lo enseñan separado como 2 continentes apartes.
Pretty much the same as I learnt it back in the 60's in Britain. I like to stick with this as it annoys the Yanks!
@@johnp8131 Sounds like special pleading because Europe and Asia should be one continent, then. Or Eurasasfrica
America is a continent, not a country. Therefore, 'American' is not a nationality/citizenship, officially.
Furthermore, an American is from the Continent of America.
@@CaptainAmerica001 America is also a country. You can throw all the tantrums you like, that's the way it is. Canada or Mexico doesn't get to keep both Mexico and Canada AND America. America took the name first. Tough luck. Hate America in some other way. There are two countries named Congo. No one says a word about that. You don't get to tell other countries what they are named.
@@ejtattersall156
There's no country named America.
There is a continent named America! 👍
The seven continents are...Asia, Africa, North America, South America, Antarctica, Europe, and Australia.
So you think North America and South America are two different continents? Do you realize that North America and South America are connected by the Isthmus of Panama.?
It would make more sense to consider Europe, Asia and Africa one continent than to consider North America and South America two different continents.
You have such a gorgeous smile
Hello from British Columbia, Canada😄
You have the same thing with Oceans as Continents...the answer to "how many oceans are there in the world" usually ranges from 4 to 7
North America, South America, Europe, Asia, Africa, Australasia and Antarctica. 7 continents.
Some say that John Americ of England gave his name as his family coat of arms is similar to the latest usa flag.
The flag of Canada has changed in the last century too.
Check out "why Paris was built like a snail" by Bright trip
6:42 There are seven: North and South America, Europe, Africa, Asia, Antarctica, and Australia.
Depending the country you studied on
6:58 It is not offcial yet but most likely the accurate number after the discovery of Zealandia, an almost entirely submerged land mass east of Australia. New Zealand, New Caldeonia and a few small islands in between are the only parts of the land mass that rise above sea level, is 8.
The final classification of Zealandia hasn't happened yet and there are arguments both for and against classifying it as a continent, but as of now the majority of scientists seem to favour the classification as continent which would mean that Eath has 8 continents (Asia, Africa, North America, South America, Antarctica, Europe, Australia and Zealandia - from largest to smallest).
It should be mentioned that the number of continents has varied over time as continents collide to form supercontinents (Pangaea was the latest one) that break apart again after a while.
I was taught there were 5 continents.
What country?
Born and raised in California and was taught 7 continents. I just don't remember which ones they are but only that there were 7.
@earthwormandruw I think the Russian alt 6 is the most accurate.
@@johnbattle7518 Apparently an 8th one called Zealandia was discovered several years ago.
@earthwormandruw I thought you were pulling my leg. That's fascinating. I never heard of that until now, thanks!
If you want to complicate the question of how many continents there are you could always wrangle a geologist into the conversation. I have vague recollections of semantic arguments about using tectonic plates to define continents which can get into the weeds over multi-plate continents and submerged or partially submerged tectonic plates.
Here in Portugal I was taught the six continents model: Europe, Asia, Africa, Oceania, America and Antarctica
That’s surprising. When I lived in Portugal a guy used to run up to me in the street shouting, “Norte-americano, norte-americano!” It irritated the hell out of me, but he wasn’t playing with a full deck of cards, so... What can you do? I guess I just assumed the Portuguese counted the Americans as two separate continents.
That's pretty common. We try to not use the term Americano to call the people from the USA because we know that America/Americas is the continent.
Yes, we know that there are other countries in North America; but this others have proper names, and calling people estadounidense is a mouthful.
The way I studied them, the continents are Europe, Asia, Africa, North America (including Central America), South America, Australia-Oceania, Antarctica.
If you're really picky you could technically split Central America from the rest as well as Oceania and Australia.
I've also heard the words Afro-Asian and Eurasian for language families. Given that the Suez canal is artificial and he division between Asia and Europe is very relative, I suppose the Old World could be considered one continent, the Americas or the New World another one, Antarctica obviously and I suppose Australia and Oceania could be separate entities. That would make 5.
The counting of continents is the same kind of frustration shared with taxonomists, regardless of what methods of sorting we can come up with, nature will always come up with some strange edge-cases or exceptions leading to disagreements, so we come up with more precise methods of sorting which not everyone uses or agrees with, so we end up disagreeing on what the categories even mean and we end up with different answers depending on who you're talking to, like whether something's a fruit or a berry depends if you're using those terms in their botanical, culinary, or legal sense.
Che, qué onda? Por qué doblaste tu voz cuando mencionaste a Colon? Y son seis continentes. América, Asia, África, Europa, Antartida y Oceania
Continents are subjective
It’s not just that there are other Americas, but that there are other countries in North America. Canadians often share a similar sentiment. We often refer to the people as Americans (mostly because anything else is cumbersome), but I generally only hear Canadians refer to the US as America in a disparaging way.
Edit: I have a bad habit of not waiting for the end of the video before commenting 🤦♂️
Hi! There are 2 points of view about Earth's land masses: the geophysical and the geopolitical ones. America is a continent in both views; you can divide it in North and South, geophysically, and North, Central, South and Caribbean islands, geopolitically. Antarctica is a continent in both views. Africa, Asia and Europe are 1 continent geophysically and 3 continents geopolitically. Australia is 1 continent geophysically and geopolitically it's Oceania (Including Australia, New Zealand and all the Pacific islands not part of Asia).
I don't see the point of arguing about how many continents there are. It doesn't seem like something you can really disagree on, it's just different meanings of the same word. Like arguing about whether the word "last" means final or means a form to build a shoe around. Or which of two forms of fried potatoes the word "chip" refers to. Multiple meanings exist. Multiple systems of continents exist.
As someone from Florida, I can always tells when speaking to someone with a Canadian accent while gaming or in Discord.
Coming from Indiana, we kind of have a partial southern twang to a flat dull accent. So it would vary depending on our mood how we spoke to one another, and the fact we have been lied to all this time on that we are not actually in "AMERICA" but something other named than that? So, "VINLAND?" Interesting video non-the-less.
Interesting that the debate was between 5 and 7. I feel like there's a good argument for 6. North America, South America, Eurasia, Africa, Australia and Antarctica.