Enlisted vs Battlefield 5 - Comparison (Attention to detail, shooting, animations and movement)
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- An accurate comparison between Battlefield 5 and Enlisted. Comparison of animations, movement, shooting, gunfight, destruction and attention to detail.
00:00 Movement & Animations
02:43 Shooting & Reload
04:53 Gunfight
06:26 Attention to detail & Destructions
14:06 Thanks for Watching! Sbscribe/Like!
The most the devs of Enlisted need is to work the movement, feel a little sluggish, otherwise the graphics are good, the optimization is very good.
You're just use to battlefield shit unrealistic movement, image a soldier with multiple heavy MG mags running and sliding around 10 miles per hour
True, it always feels like I could be running faster, it feels the soldier isn’t even running.
@@yourtypical1722 Bruh in Enlisted it feels like the soldier isnt even alive when doing anything xD such shit animations. Let alone weapon sounds they are awful. And the reloads? you gotta be joking right?
I may be late to this heated discussion, but I am sure Enlisted is setup for realism tactic wise and strategy. Not with graphics or even some animations, but the game is better than BFV in my opinion.
Why is everyone so mad the game is still beta
Damn, the snow in Enlisted is something else.
The only thing they did good lol
@@Jujarm I disagree. It's a fun game. It has its flaws, but it also does some things really well, and has its own niche which makes it unique.
@ADOLF HITLER Absolutely, the grind is by far the greatest problem.
Thats right
@@Jujarm dude enlisted Tries to replicate the ww2 its also more realistic as possible battlelfield is more like an arcade game and remenbe enlisted has an awesome grafic
Enlisted has such great potential I’m excited to see where it goes
It has already been destroyed by f2p and blurring the playerbase by making different scenarios with separate progression
@@bremsberg True
@@bremsberg It's like War Thunder but instead of the countries, it's the scenarios.
@@cepv_2305 it’s made by the same company Gaijin it even has some of the same sounds from war thunder
@@ProdNarco-vf6ro Yup
Why even compare them? Enlisted is a free game with the goal to be very realistic to WW2, and battlefield is a more arcadey game made by a much bigger studio and has a much bigger budget. Enlisted is still in the beta and will be improved much more in the future. Playing it is very fun and you have to spend a lot of time to unlock everything, so it doesn’t get repetitive. The planes are fun to use and aren’t very hard to learn to fly but hard to master, and you dont notice any of the bad animations when playing. If you have a pc and about 25gb of storage, download it, its worth it.
True true
I’d rather pay to play than pay to win thanks
@@cripple8339 lol even you are pay to win on this game you still get one shot by most weapons this game was mix of realistic and arcade unlike popular franchise.
@@greengonn3676 I’m sorry your comment gave me a stroke, what are you talking about?
Oh yeah because the 82nd Airborne hitting the beaches on D-Day with 1903s from WW1 is totally realistic.
some say enlisted movement are slow
people who play arma3 🗿: damn you guys so fast
exactly
To the people saying Enlisted has sluggish or slow movement you can get a perk that increase's run speed by +10 definitely speeds up the game.
That's not what we mean by sluggish, for example the transitioning from prone to full stance or crouch to prone etc in enlisted is sluggish meaning there's a short break until the actual crouch/prone initiates, jumping over obstacles fixes your pov in a weird unnatural way where your hands are tied to the fence/wall and your head is moving wildly, small things like this.
The experience is medium on console/ps4 where I play.
@@shapsugh1864 I play on Xbox One X the only time the movement is janky is during the train trying to get on otherwise perks really can help the games movement.
Movement is shit in general, needs a new animation
@@Toulkun not entirely it's better than other AA games.
Increase FOV for smoother feel
I like how the vanguard isn't comparable anymore with this two
Vanguard is literally garbage, hell, even Black Ops 2 looks better than it; but to be fair, Black Ops 2 is like, the best Call of Duty
@@themightykv-5410 Agreed
I like how MW2019 is not compared with these garbage games anymore bcs we all know MW2019 is the best except for gameplay bcs MW2 2009 is the best COD
@@nonoman3246 nah man imo MW2019 was trash I still stuck with the og cod games tbh
@@nonoman3246 the story of mw2019 is trash
Enlisted constantly gets updates that are wanted by the community while a lot of the big developers have been caring less and less or being strained by publisher demands.
i dont play enlisted but i heard they removed cosmetics or something
@@Glumbus1 the only cosmetics ive seen were pistol reskins and a rifle wrap and they're only from twitch drops
@@tylerberthelot3703 i cant remember but i think the guy said that you couldnt use some skins that people had bought or something like that
here is the video
czcams.com/video/Z9JfvfgMNLQ/video.html
@@Glumbus1 when u get soldiers they have randomized looks which you can change with orders from the battlepass after the update everyones soldiers got re randomized so people lost their orders and looks from what I understand
@@hkg207 ^
Enlisted has a nice balance in authenticity, classic FPS gameplay, realism. Even for a free to play game.
But the grinding and customization is way to complicated in this game. The customization of the weapons is to restricted. I don't want crazy customization like in COD. Just want it to be easier. The movement can use some improvement
I agree, the separate campaigns make it harder to grind but what makes it harder is that you grind on separate campaigns AND on separate teams.
@@feathersswissfield8514 exactly
Hello, gaijin is the developer of this game... I'm a war thunder player and the grinding there is disgusting.. The game is basically pay to grind or spend the rest of your life trying to grind it
Note: war thunder, in case you dont know, is a free to play game also developed by gaijin
The only thing that holds the players in is that the game is really incredible on what it focus on, planes tanks and now.. Ships
optimization is a masterpiece in enlisted.runs smooth on all ultra setting on my 2 core 4 threads intel.
seriously? because game looks interesting to me, looks like good game to play on budget pc
@@codittOFFICIAL not sure where an 1660ti falls but I can easily hover over 76fps on all ultra settings 1080p without FSR ( not even going to touch that since this game looks like an oil painting with it). On custom settings I just keep getting over 100fps and it's really nice since it doesn't drop during battles as well.
@@quartermaster2809 thx
@@codittOFFICIAL my spec : pentium G4560,1060 6GB,8GB DDR4, runs perfect
I have a i5 4590 16gb ram gtx 1050 ti and it runs 90-200 FPS
Enlisted has the Eastern Front in its WW2 game.
Enough said.
Meanwhile bfV - What is russia ??
@@piterjacksonpl0776 meanwhile in bfv: what is Italy ???
Russian bias
R.I.P the Soviet Union
That feeling I had when I first played Halo CE has returned, Enlisted has that same kind of fun and pace. Its been a very long time. This game will go down in history as a great. I can feel it!
I really do love both BFV and Enlisted. But to me, these 2 games give difference feeling. Like as an infantryman charging objective with tank, same senario but difference feeling. BFV gives some kind of impression of how epic the game can be, sound, music, destruction and all. Enlisted is like simulator. Not as serious as Hell let loose and other but still less epic, more thinking. I know it's a long way til this game will be released but i love to see improvement. But, man, bolt action rifle sounds like aluminium plates banging together lol
battlefield : Anyway, I'm still better than you
Enlisted : I have soviet union, and no SJW
Энлистед очень молодой, а вы уже сравниваете его с Батлой, у который опыта за плечами ого-го. Дайте годик-два развития Энлистеду, и уверен, что он сильно изменится в лучшую сторону.
Но даже сейчас некоторые элементы из енлистед красивее чем в батле, та же проработка земли и как мне кажется интерьера.
@@user-wf3yp4lf8v ещё и бесплатно)
9
Also they are different type of games albeit in same fps genre. One more on realism and one more on arcadey type gameplay
Ten encuenta que batlefield v es de 100gb y enlisted es de 15 a 20 gb no esperes mucho ademas enlisted esta en fase beta.
en fase beta o no, con 20 GB metio mas campañas y armas que los 100 GB que pesa el BFV
@@Warfaremachine0095 y yo tengo una version que ya no es tan beta ahora y que aun no llegar siquiera los 50GB de espacio a que ocupar aunque y es muy diferente la forma que se juega que en el Battefield
Creo que battlefield anda en los 70gb
Y el echo de que enlisted es gratis y su optimización es decente al igual que representan cosas distintas; mientras enlisted busca una representación más realista de la ww2 pero sin ser tan simulador como hell let lose por su parte Battlefield es más arcade sin llegar a tocar mucho el realismo
@@iwasking9174 BF llega poner realismo y todo el mundo lloraria con las cosas "OP"
Enlisted maps and sound design actually feel like WW2, BfV feels like a corporate cash grab
Enlisted is a tactical shooter. Battlefield 5 is more dynamic and arcade style. Two different games, it's pointless to compare them.
Enlisted is a new game it needs some time to improve
Ok, I totally agree.
And i played both games.
It's not pointless my dude. They are the same genre, same setting same idea of gameplay just different execution. Just don't watch these videos with the mindset "which of these is better". Watch it to see how two studios made those two games differently. You migh prefer one over the other of course but they can both exist :D
I like see pleople crying when some one compare bf5 with enlisted
personally i have played both games, but i don't like enlisted or heros and generals (almost the same game). However I must say that you have done a really great job and that even small channels with quality content vome this can become great
Battlefield V is more like a COD version of Enlisted.
WTF is this supposed to mean.
BFV is large scale battles, incredibly realistic graphics and sound design, incredible animations, incredible music from BF1’s compositor, incredible level of detail while enlisted is ss arcade, but cartoony looking, it even gets reloading animations wrong.
@@melcorchancla9431 bfv battles feel like some asg shooting compared to enlisted, sounds are also good in enlisted and who tf cares about music 💀 i could have hey we got k round as menu music, bfv tanks feel like toys and have hp bar while enlisted has very realistic tanks from war thunder, "cartoony looking" bruh just set to max graphics it looks very good and reloading animations are getting fixed this is still beta and made by small latvian studio
@@pispompaisterydy you would be surprised how much music can change
the atmosphere of a game
As hated as bf5 is, the movement system is the smoothest I've tried on console yet, you gotta give them that.
it's supposed to be somewhat realistic. In a combat situation you'll be slow because you have your gear and weapon, they're heavy. They make the movement hard, it's true that in Enlisted the movement is a little off.
Enlisted gives you what battleflop5 failed to do.....proper ww2 emersion.
Enlisted is 1000x better with battlefield
No
@@shogun897 Yes
Yesn't
you just dont have battlefield dont you
I'm fine with both and I'll take any WW2 shooter as long as it's not Vanguard !
I feel like Enlist reload animation is like third person level with more detail compare to game like BFV
Are you aware that what you’re saying doesn’t make sense ?
@@melcorchancla9431 I am aware that just comment something that make literal non sense
The fact that Enlisted is a free game is crazy to me. I know they have a bunch of overpriced bundles you can buy, and that a lot of people claim its pay to win, but I never had any problems in enlisted. Im at the top of the leaderboard in 95% of my matches without ever buying anything. It doesn't take that long to start unlocking SMG's, Semi-auto rifles, machineguns and so if you stick to one campaign
You need tons this again as enlisted just had a MAJOR overhaul on graphics and stuff and despite being cross platform they utilized the next gen tech on new consoles and my god it looks amazing and everything is dynamic form pieces of dirt kicking off your boot to the water being flung off the moving threads of a tank driving through shallow water
Even the audio like the diesel sound of some of these tanks has me thinking like UPS guy lol is out front every time lol
Спасибо за обзор, товарищ)
Enlisted is FREE, FUN and very well optimizate
Man battlefield 1 & 5 will always be the best immersive best looking fps that was ever created
Батла для ПК бояр, а я в Энлистэд на минимальной графике ношусь с ППД несмотря на 22 ФПС (и часто занимаю хорошие места в рейтинге боя XD)
Верно заметил)
That DP 28 in Enlisted is Nostalgia>>>>
My one gripe is enlisted feels a lot more rigid then other games
Algo que siempre me gustó de los Battlefield es el típico momento en que sientes que todo pasa a tu alrededor mientras intentas avanzar la posición los aviones te acosan, escuchas como los snipers se ventilan a tu equipo mientras que llegan tus blindados a brindar apoyo y dar vuelta la situación, en los últimos Battlefield siento que se ha perdido un poco toda esa magia (ya sabes, cuando el dinero importa más que contentar a tus fans pasan esas cosas) mientras que en enlisted fue como volver a sentir todos esos sentimientos de cuando eras solo un adolescente jugando al bad company con tus amigos
Pero sigue estando lo mismo xD llevo muchas horas jugando al V por eso mismo la sensación de estar en una guerra y que tenga una jugabilidad tan cómoda
In enlisted almost everybody fights with rifles even in Berlin, '45
For enlisted it’s just the animations for me and some of the weapon sounds
algo que me encanta de enlisted es que tiene varios escenarios como el africano e incluso Berlín, eso es de apreciar mucho
enlisted is impressive for its buget, also a lot more fun than bfv
Parkour in enlisted is so fucking cool is better than battlefield V that's why I love enlisted
Nonsense mate the BFV movement/climbing was far better
You can't grab onto a ledge and pull yourself up after falling 10 feet in enlisted, nor can you roll to reduce fall damage
Beyond that its pretty much standard grab and vault - where battlefield has the edge too
Lmao yeah the movement in BFV is still the best
@@rambo-cambo3581 ok but u had to pay for it and it’s a full game not beta
@@thatonedairyfarmer9051 Trust me, the level of detail will not be like Battlefield's, even in its final product. Cause Gaijin is full of a bunch of money-grabbing shitbags who can't make a decent, enjoyable game...
@@nepnepguythegreatestofall6032 I mean,Enlisted is very enjoyable though.And apart from the Normandy campaign it isnt a cashgrab,only for the Impatient
As soon as movement and animations are improved in enlisted it will be even more amazing
If your looking for realism trust me. The boys on d day werent running around at usain bolt spead carrying an mg42 and the 5 boxes of amunition they give you too go eith it
yes...
they took the assets from their other game CRSD, which is mainly a 3rd person game
CRSD was the Test platform for enlisted, basically they idea started for use the Dagor engine from Warthunder and make a simple Battle Royale to test the capabilities of the FPS consept into that engine, the idea was molding into Cousine Royale, what was basically a parody and used to substain the proyect until are a proper grounds are made for enlisted, so basically Cousine Royale turned into CRSD and served for test bed for Enlisted when it released it first betas
@@Warfaremachine0095 the april fools joke game that became real game lmao. they really tested everything on that game, even flooding mechanic. i hope they use flooding mechanic somewhere in enlisted.
"Enlisted movement is slow and sluggish"
Remember the weapon he was holding was a very heavy machine gun which just makes sense, you run faster with rifles, Smgs, and pistols
Enlisted is better because its free. And vehicles are most realistics and same for every fights scenes.
Le me guess you didn't play bfv right
@@corvoattano2757 i played. And you, you didnt played Enlisted, right?
I agree with the vehicles. Since they use same models and system from War Thunder it is realistic. Cuz at least from BF you can destroy tank with one shot.
@@davidkala3671 u cannot destroy a tank with a shot at all
@@corvoattano2757 Direct shot into ammunition and tank is no more.
good job
Enlisted NAILED the environments and overall gameplay. Physics are great, but movements are jerky. However, there are also lots of bots in enlisted, which get people lots of kills. More kills usually makes people like the game more, so most people (including me) are a little biased towards it. But bf5 has the gunplay and animations down beautifully despite their historical inaccuracies, and they have more vehicle options and WAY less grind, making it more noob-friendly. It also has far better destruction, and it's more chaotic. Plus, there's no bots, and you can do custom servers with more options, making it more ideal for mil-sim communities that don't do things like Post Scriptum or Hell Let Loose. Battlefield also has more vehicle customization options so you can do things like turn an m4a3 sherman into an m4a3 76w or an m4a3 105. Not to mention the better laid-out maps and larger scaled combat. I'm leaned a bit more towards bf5 with all of this in mind, overall, but enlisted has MASSIVE potential to become a great realistic ww2 shooter.
I would disagree with enlisted having better destruction, BFV is superior in most aspects.
Nvm, just read your comment wrong.
you have more vehicles but they act like literal toys, also, enlisted is slowly adding more and mroe vehicles, so far, the t-60, t-28, bt-7, is-1, su 122, t-34-85 dt-5 and zis 1, panzer 2, panzer 38t panzer 3 (there's 3 version of them), puma, panzer 4 with short barrel, panzer 4 g, panzer 4 j, sherman, sherman jumbo, sherman 76, m8 scott, 2 versions of panthers, tigers, jagdpanzer IV, Jagdpanzer IV A, stug 3. also, let's count the planes, stuka, bf 109 f versions, bf 109 g versions, bf 110, p38, p51, il-2, yak. Yeah no, enlisted can easily make up for vehicles without mentioning the fact that they act more realistically in both movements and damage. what does bf have ? panzer 38t, panzer 4, tiger, stug, wirbelwind, sherman, greyhound, valentine, archer, that weird british AA, staghound, 2 jap tanks, for planes, f4u, p 51, some bombers for usa, spitfire, stuka, bf 109. thinking about it, it doesn't even come close to how many vehicles there are in enlisted already, a bit of vehicle custom isn't gonna make up for the huge amount of vehicles enlisted already has and the ones that will come in the future.
@@spygineer1076 having a mot of something doesnt just make a game, thats why enlisted still feels missing,
@@flow185 enlisted is literally in open beta what are you even on about ? the devs literally said it isn't a complete game yet. Despite all that they already managed to put more passion, historical accuracy and more vehicles than bfv has, and their budget is like 1/4 of what bfv had.
The camera should bob while walking or running. My only suggestion.
Hay un factor bastante importante aquí y es que enlisted es un juego gratuito osea no esperes mucho de un juego que esta hecho humildemente osea si no tienes dinero para comprar un juego tienes esta opción, y a mi no me molesta en lo absoluto el movimiento del personaje yo solo juego para matar a jugadores y hacer misiones no para ponerme a ver el movimiento del personaje con que se mueva y corra es suficiente
XD
@@telacreiste984 XD
Cool that when shooting mg in enlisted he actually racks in a round after reloading where’s in BFV they forget to
Snow is Impressive ngl
As soon as I saw the MG 42 on bf 5 I was like holy Shit!!!
Enlisted has 5 coffee cup budged, but Battlefield 5 has million dollar budget
But hey enlisted is more realistic
Thats cap, i dont like ea but credits were credits are due
Protip: Dont play Enlisted near your Veteran grandpa
The best thing about enlisted is Historical accuracy. No idiotic things such as women on the battlefield or weird sights on guns or black german soldiers.
What about NPC animations? Those are the details I look for in First Person Shooters!
Enlisted snow effects are incredible
The picture is gorgeous in Battlefield 5, but Enlisted is more military professional
Графика в Enlisted такая, будто е гуашью нарисовали
i rather play enlisted ive played battlefield since the beginning i remember when BFV came out we all think it needed something more and playing enlisted has filled those gaps
Ощущение, что анимация в енлистед похожа на анимацию бф2042.
The reload of the MG42 in BFV is closer to the real deal for he locks the bolt back before reloading Enlisted does ot the wrong way around. :(
They fixed it
Nice vid bro 👍😁
I mean for a free game, enlisted is pretty good
In Battlefield evry ting fells a bit of
I want Enlisted dev make a movement animation better look and make a wrong eye posision on scope
Enlisted, looks like a 2017, sounds like a 2001 and plays like 1990
I enjoy Enlisted but BFV was more fun to play
Only if you're not against collimators in World War II
Now do hell let loose vs bf5
Hell let loose is way more realistic than bf5 But bf5 is more fun to play becoz everything is so fast-paced and brutal
Hell let loose is from I7, one of the best game studio of simulators ( HLL, Squad etc.. ) Post scriptum is good too
movement and gameplay: battlefield 5
physics: enlisted
Casual and Cranberry: BF5
9:30 Russians know how to simulate snow
У энлистеда очень старый движок. Такое ощущение будто в DayZ играю
Enlisted i feel like a robot
Играть я конечно же буду в Энлистед, так как он бесплатный, да и на моём семилетнем ноуте выдаёт приемлемый фпс
BF 5 is a complete game from my understanding and Enlisted is still in Beta, until it is out of Beta and considered live comparisons such as this one are not going to be fair. That said there are many things in this video that Enlisted has right.
It has been beta for nearly 2 years LOL.
@@MSC-556 yes because it takes time to develope a full game. Part of those two years have been closed beta.
В Enlisted ты ломаешь окна лицом
Brutal!
Ну отлично конечно но Энлистед куда лучше чем Бателфилд 5
Вопрос спорный
чем? тем что ты играешь ботами против ботов управляемыми ботами ?
@@user-fq4hy1sw2y «Но игра ещё находится в стадии разработки»
@@arsenicos576 эта фраза уже мем ,игре год и ничего не изменилось
@@user-fq4hy1sw2y Так есть же отдельный режим где ты не управляешь ботами
Though I will say that the fire effects in Battlefield V look better, but Enlisted doesn't look too far off.
12:10
Прошу прощение за выражение, но когда ходишь по грязи в Enlisted, появляется ощущение того, что солдат...плескается в поносе.
Еще раз извеняюсь.
its like comparing apple vs onion
i think battlefield is better than enlisted. In this video there aren't all the animation of battlefiled, for example the destruction of the huoses
Guys remember enlisted is in beta version
I hope he knows those are different guns
Now compare the farm.
In someway enlisted movement somewhere better. In crawling to be correct
But movement in water dont realistic nowhere
enlisted still in beta and the size only 15-20gb.It not bad
Also, don't expect much on a free game anyway
It just like comparing 700 dollars car to a million dollar Lamborghini
A
You don’t know much about cars do you 🇦🇹😂🚗🚘💣💥🔥
Bfv is fkin cheap?
@carrots with internet connection it's most of the time is in discount like 20$ even in my country it's 5 10$
but only thing Enlisted is en Beta batlefield V no
Ну тоже сровнил платную и бесплатную игру конечно Батла 5 по физике то и по эффектам лучше чем в энлистоде жаль что в батле 5 нет русских
People just wanted war thunder with infantry
Enlisted actually feels like ww2 unlike bfv bfv feels like a kids game it looks cartoony and doesn't feel like ww2
The animations and gunplay look like they were made by someone who has never animated a thing in their life. they just look straight up goofy
@@stephencoppedge8001 i like this game but yes, animations are shit
@@stephencoppedge8001is a Japanese soldier running around with an stg 44 accurate?well that's what bfv has to offer with way more historical inaccuracies enlisted might have bad graphics but it's accurate
@@stephencoppedge8001 still better gameplay than bf5
Just remember battlefield is made by ea and enlisted is made by not a big company and is beta
They fix reloads and movement...boom enlisted becomes real good!
By now the game feels old and rushed tho.
I hope they add asia server
Enlisted это free to play игра. Даже если и после релиза ничего не изменится и останется, как сейчас - всё равно для FTP это очень неплохо. А вот BFV это ужс, за которое еще и нужно платить деньги. Смысл наслаждаться мелкими деталями, если игра в целом полное УГ? Да и сами разработчики это поняли, что забили на неё.
надеюсь, что gaijin подтянут графику
Some of those Battlefield v sights make me want to vomit.
Battlefield 5 🔥
Енлистед намного реалистичней и красивей выглядит
Nope...
No you commie
Sorry comrade but bf5 looks realistic
Не обманывай себя)
At least there won't be fucking crabs dancing on the beaches
НА ДА А ЭНЛИСТЕД ПОКА ЕЩЕ БЕСПЛАТНАЯ
Enlisted.
I wish they add tactical reload for Enlisted
No
@@shesssssssssssssss6078 y
nahh, would hurt the pace
like for a military modern game, yea i can see tactical reloads being there,buy not for a authentic ww2 game though,
@@kacpernap2863 that's tacticool reload
@@hmstransit909 That would be unrealistic if you load in full clips every time and the half full clips just disappear