Enlisted vs Call of Duty Vanguard - Weapons Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- Which one is which? - First, Enlisted, second COD Vanguard.
0:00 HANDGUNS
2:33 SHOTGUNS
3:47 SMGs
8:23 FULL-Auto RIFLES
11:52 SEMI-Auto RIFLES
14:30 BOLT-Action RIFLES
17:44 MACHINE GUNS
22:20 LAUNCHERS
"Which is better" playlist:
• Which is better?
BATTLEFIELD playlist:
• Battlefield playlist
Call of Duty playlist:
• Call of Duty playlist
Rainbow Six playlist:
• Rainbow Six playlist
Far Cry playlist:
• Far Cry playlist
---------
All content from this video and this channel is recorded and edited exclusively by me. I NEVER use clips or any kind of content from someone else. - Hry
![ENLISTED 2023 - All Weapons Part I [USA / BRIT / ALLIES Weapons]](/img/n.gif)
As someone pointed out, Enlisteds simpler animations work surprisingly well with the time period it’s set in, since that’s pretty much how people operated firearms back in the day.
Elisteds shooting sounds also fell better and more powerful.
I also appreciate that Elisted uses the Real Names for the guns instead of some dumb fake ones.
That said Enlisteds animations can still use some rework.
the enlisted nimations make sense for the time period i just with they used proper loading procedure and didnt waste ammo or like in with the mg42 just not load any ammo at all lol
id also like if they loaded the proper amount of ammo into the bolt action rifles after wasting the round in the chamber when opening the bolt
@@isaiahdennhardt9409 Who loves you?
@@Higashidoitsu1128Why are you an asshole?
@@Higashidoitsu1128 what?
Vanguard: *muh reloadable Panzerfaust*
Meanwhile Enlisted with one soldier carrying up multiple Panzerfausts:
Nah bro Enlisted has a panzerfaust reload animation, it's just really goofy (another panzerfaust shell immediately appears on the weapon after shooting)
@@rouxgreasus Least it doesn't involve your character loading a fresh rocket into the spent tube. I'll take that over Vanguard's nonsense xD
@@icy3-1 Also Enlisted is free, try it! We have 6 campaigns (Moscow, Normandy, Berlin, Tunisia, Stalingrad and Pacific). Due to being a half-sister game to war thunder, there are also lots of tanks/vehicles in the game
@@rouxgreasus Yes, I already have. Too bad my laptop can't run it anymore xD
@@icy3-1ah, sucks
In my opinion, Vanguard simply looks too tactical for the time period.
The game is a re-skin of mw2019
This,why would some 18 yr old draftee in the 1940s reload like a modern day elite force member does,dosen't make sense
@@marcowulliampopirers2216because they’re not 18 year old draftees
@@acai9130do you know nothing about world war Two?
He's referring to the goofy aah "Vanguard" Team that are supposed to be elite operators in WW2. It still doesn't explain why they use techniques and some equipment not seen for a few decades. @@James_Randal
I’m a big fan of Enlisted’s gun sounds, they’re incredibly punchy. Some the submachine guns sound more like Maxim Pom-Poms rattling off.
I second this
Type 100 and As-44's sound like 20mm
fun fact about pistols and the way they were held. it wasn't until about the 70s that 2 handed was preferred, it was adopted because body armor becoming more prevalent, and for competition. before that soldiers and officers would be taught to shoot one handed to decrease body size and the belief of being more accurate by just pointing at something.
Its been proven you are more accurate one handed
@@torinjones3221 depends i guess 2 handed is far better for rapid firing but i could see the one handed version being better on a first based, i was commenting mostly on seeing all the pistols being shot 2 handed which was a big thing yet.
they were told to use one handed because they could carry something more important like a radio in thier second hand
@@torinjones3221 Proven where? There's no way anybody who has ever actually used a handgun IRL would ever make a comment like this.
@@notmac1853a simple example is Olympic style pistol shooting competitions which are all about accuracy above pretty much everything are shot one handed
A reminder that you can play a free WW2 game that plays like Call of Duty and Battlefield that respects the WW2 materials better than a $60 game filled with anime and godzilla king kong bundles.
one thing i can say about engaijined is that it plays like proper battlefield
@@Klovaneerengaijined?
@@thej8656 enlisted but list swapped for gaijin
this video barely scratches the surface of the amount of guns in Enlisted. I think so far there are less than 500, but i could be wrong. But that's a lot. Nice showcase tho
Well this video only compares the guns that exist in Enlisted to the ones in Vanguard, or vice versa. It’s not a showcase of all the guns in Enlisted.
@@hihowrya370 I know, just saying that Enlisted has a lots of guns in the campaigns (and more in the game editor). Enlisted all weapon showcase when?
@@rouxgreasus From what I've read there's actually around 300 guns in the game. Which is still insanely A LOT. So, if we ever get to see an Enlisted All Weapons Showcase vid, then it'll probably be longer than an hour. But I see that as an absolute win.
@@hihowrya370 If that's outdated by now, there are more than 300 weapons than the game. I love Enlisted
Quality over quantity.
The main difference between Enlisted and Vanguard is that Enlisted respects WWII whilst Vanguard does not
Ух я бы так не сказал, дешёвая донатная помойка
@@arisaka8272после отмены разделения по кампанияя на счёт доната я бы уже так не сказал. Но вот за то хоть какая-то истортчность улетела окончательно
Enlisted is kinda better overall. BUT the animations in CoD are too modern but are very nice detailed, but those in Enlisted look poor tbh
This is very correct. Devs need to work on their animations, but atleast we don't have speedloaders and laser guns (instead we have cap and ball revolver in game files)
Also this video barely scratches the surface of the amount of guns in Enlisted. I think so far there are less than 500, but i could be wrong. But that's a lot.
Finally, someone who has something to criticize about the game compared to CoD rather than just full-on praising it for everything and shitting entirely over CoD.
3 buts
@@MaryMeKo what yo talking about
Enlisted is war thunder with playable infantry
not suprising when its developed by the same company using the same engine with many of the assets and mechanics ported directly from warthunder.
Heroes & Generales on war thunder engine
@@TamamoF0Xno it’s developed by Darkflow and Published by Gaijin, but I’m also 100% sure Gaijin let enlisted borrow the tank combat mechanics to an extent like the penetration camera
And the overpressure isn’t fucked I’ll take it
@@TamamoF0Xhmm
The flipped owen sight in cod is crazy
fr
Also that CoD got the VG 1-5 wrong and made it full auto
@@itskyansaro and they appeared on 1942 battle of el alamien, talk about a time travel eh
@@bristleback3614 Another cursed thing is on the Japanese Type 10 MG, Cod just detaches the box and tosses it and attaches a new one to the gun, which is a really long reload, but also, the gun is fed with stripper clips, that get placed into that box
@@itskyansaroanother one, they hold the Thompson by the magazine
Gotta say wow does Enlisted sound way better holy shit lmfao.
the only inaccuracie they have is the hand held pistols
Both are great on their own rights. Although some of the vanguard reloads feel too modern fr a WW game.
Well vanguard basically threw out historical accuracy after season 1 and i believe it got so bad there wasnt a season 5 for the game
I thought vanguard reloads were alot better
@@CZcamsIsSeriouslyFuckedwell probably also so they can put more focus on MW3
@@kevinsteelflex7371 I'd like to introduce you to the FN F2000 and a laser gun in vanguard, see if thats putting aside vanguard for mw3
@@CZcamsIsSeriouslyFucked doesn't that also prove my point? lol you mentioned there being less seasons than usual and then modern weapons being added to vanguard. its starting to make sense
5:03 Owen Gun is so Australian gun that its cases go upward instead of downward as irl 😂
I never laughed so hard reading a comment
Casings came out of the magazine 🤣
Enlisted has good enough animations, they're enough to portray their respective weapon but are definitely rough overall, on the other hand CoD Vanguard's are really well animated and look pretty good, their problem is that they'd be good in a different game, in a WW2 game they just look so out of place, at that point they should've picked a different setting if they wanted those animations.
It’s not just that, Vanguard Fails to do the animations right. Take the panzerfaust at the very end as an example. In Vangaurd you reload it even though your can’t the panzerfaust is a disposable weapon, you fire and then you either toss it or bring it back to have it recycled. BFV dose the weapon better than both games.
@@anidiot2284 I only remember the Panzerfaust and the Volksturmgewehr as the egregious examples of getting everything wrong (not counting the Gunsmith or DLC weapons, if I count them then Vanguard is the epitome of doing WWII weapons wrong, heck, why tf are the F2000 and the Advanced Warfare EM1 in there???), most other animations are just wrong in that they don't look like a WWII Soldier is using them, which is already awful, though within its horridness, they are really well animated, if these weapons were in a MW game they wouldn't be too out of place.
I believe the modern animations in Vanguard were purely for Warzone integration (still irks me tho)
@@ColtonPrice095 then they could have kept them in Warzone if that were the case, wouldn't be the first time the original game and Warzone had different animations (The Kiparis comes to mind).
Ага и у некоторых видов оружия, взять тот же ППШ гильзы далеко не улетают и падают прямо в патронник, если это для вас офигенные анимации, моё почтение, я выхожу курить на балкон.
While vanguards animations don’t take into account that soldiers in WW2 would mostly not act like modern day special forces, I can give them credit for weapon accuracy, like the Luger and 1911 locking open or the Thompson being the military version.
Except you can put the drum on the M1921 Thompson in vanguard
@@Leopard-2A6.. I though the military version could use drum mags, it just wasn’t that practical
@@PinheaDipshit don't think it could
Not sure tho
@@Leopard-2A6.. I checked, you’re right the M1 Thompson and variants couldn’t accept drum mags, only the M1928 Thompson could.
@@PinheaDipshit , the 1921,23,and 28 versions of the weapons could accept drum magazines, however they did have severe problems with jamming due to the clockwork mechanism within the magazine that would feed the rounds. the differences between the models are the 21 had a faster cyclic rate than the 23, where it was reduced to better accuracy and lessen ammo consumption, the 28 is simply the 23 adapted for military service for export to other countries by changing the barrel and front hand-guard. the rather fragile front grip was exchanged for a simple wood block fore-grip and the cooling fins on the barrel were removed. a muzzle-break was added on the 1928A1 models. the M1 and M1A1 had a much more drastic change, simplified to a simpler blow-back mechanism and simplified sights in order to make the weapon more easily producible, making it compatible with the box magazines, but not the drum magazines. 1923 and 1928 models were still used by other countries during WW2 due to surplus military stock and stock bought pre-war, as by the 1940s, it was a weapon that was nearly 20 years old.
i hate that the guns in vanguard are labelled wrong
THEYRE NOT EVEN COPYRIGHTED THEYRE ALL 70+ YEARS OLD
In enlisted the Weapons don't have cursed modifications, like VG 1-5 being full Auto (face palm). And I think it's funny that some Cod guns don't have their original names, but Enlisted does XD
Did the Vanguard reloads for the Luger make anybody else violently angry?
Yes very much so
Why?
@@perocigla4425 it's trash
Just downloaded enlisted despite technical difficulties its one of the best games i played
Enlisted anims may look a bit too floaty because they're the same animation with the 3rd person view/world model, or at least they tried to make them as identical as possible
True fact
That's why they look janky compared to Vanguard, because in Enlisted you're looking at the world via a "first person" perspective where the camera is actually in your character's head. Meanwhile in Vanguard, they went with the more common route of having two sets of animations - one which you see in first person, and the other which everyone else sees when looking at you, and generally the second set of animations look much jankier.
Vanguard is one of the worst WW2 shooters that I ever played in my life, it's incredible how a small studio can make a better game than a million dollars studio, it's just incredible to see.
especially when Vanguard's Developer had far more experience. 100% agree
@@fritzgamer9031 ever heard of sledgehammer?
My brain is so bad that I read Enlisted and not vanguard
Gaijin isn't small...
gaijin is considerably massive
Day 46 asking for Winchester Model 70
0:00 Pistols/Revolvers
2:33 Shotguns
3:47 Submachine Guns
8:23 Full-Auto Rifles
11:52 Semi-Auto Rifles
14:30 Bolt-Action Rifles
17:44 Light Machine Guns
22:20 Launchers
No thanks
There are indents in the vid
The type 11 hurts me. I kinda wish they made 2 different reload animations for the Type 11 where the user takes out the whole mag when it gets dirty or damage and when its in normal condition, they just put in new clips
the magazine is a very important part and would likely never actually get taken off for any reason other than cleaning after battle and would likey only be topped off with clips
I need to say it, but despite it's flaws Enlisted is MUCH better than Vanguard. In fact, any WW2 FPS Game is better than Vanguard
you are tripping so bad if you think enlisted’s animations are better than
@@vitzel33 well, at least it's Not Vanguard
@@anthonyriego659 your biases are transparent
@@vitzel33yes the animations may be better for vanguard but Enlisted is a better game in general
@@vitzel33yes I sure do love tactically reloading my weapons 50 years before that was even a thing, the animation's are so much better because it's modern, in a world war Two game.
The type 11 in vanguard does a hopper load if the magazine has a multiple of five remaining.
Kind of funny how similar the quality of animations in Enlisted look to 2042s Portal ones.
Thank you Kevin
Hello Kevin.
Разработчики Vanguard не знают, что рукоять затвора винтовки Мосина была изогнутой только у снайперской вариации этой винтовки. У обычной версии рукоять была прямой
Это было бы логично, если бы её давали только в снайперских миссиях, и падала только со снайперов.
Enlisted is much better than vanguard. Because vanguard have 2.3 star and enlisted have 3.9 star.😊👌🏻👍🏽❤
Am I the only person that notice that the Enlisted Luger that is shown is literally Hermann Göring’s platinum Luger
It's from a event
You missed sawn off mg42 with forward grip and red dot
A red dot in ww2 and a forward grip ahhhh
Enlisted feels like I’m actually reloading, CoD feels like I’m trying to do some weird as hell trick every time I reload
Yeah in WW2 we have tactical reload, fancy mag flip reload
I base which is better solely on how satisfying the ping is when the Garand's clip ejects.
want those enlisted sounds on cod vanguard, i would be amazing!!
6:25 you gotta love that there still is a round in that magazine after it being completely emptied 🤦♂️
That's nothing. AT 12:55 the SVT still has a case in the breach.
CoD things, they never know what they are animating
Он не все патроны выстрелил, умник
100% convinced that AAA game devs are ordered by governments NOT to animate proper gun use...
Why do Vanguard weapons have invisible sound suppressors?
Now we need Enlisted vs Cod WAW comparisons
At least Enlisted have proper reload animations, unlike Vanguard
Cods are copy pasted from their past games.
But pistol position is wrong in both games
The way the pistols are held in both games aren't very historically accurate. Back then soldiers were trained to hold them with 1 hand.
@@Scav8835cod ww2 has that
@@Exonica34 Ik but I'm not talking abt cod ww2
The magazine flick is a quite new thing that originated from John Wick
How the hell does a character in CoD shoot a Mosin rifle with the safety on?
The issue with both of these is that they use a shooting stance that didn’t get popular til the 80s.
19:31 lmao wtf 'lil bro literally pulled out the whole thing haha!
I like enlisted overall to be honest, though the animations could use a bit more work. But cod vanguards animations are better animated. Though i would still prefer enlisted.
Why are the shells for CoD: Vanguard's double-barrel shotgun are so long? Or is it just the high FOV?
Also they look to be red and plastic.
14:17 glass canon sounds lmao
It sounded like metal canon shot sounds, lol, or mabye, it sounded like a glass bottle.
Sounds like a 28 inch Tungsten metal bat being hit against steel
Funny how enlisted having an inferior animation portraits the weapon better and more realistically
You notice how the automatic guns in enlisted correct themselves when fired but the CoD ones just go straight up? That's because the enlisted devs know how guns work.
You should do Easy Red 2 weapon showcase at least after Ardennes DLC
I totally agree with the common sentiment that the Vanguard reloads are too modern in their technique. Technically they're nicely animated, and there's a lot of skill on display there though! Enlisted's animations are serviceable, but I have a few issues. The weapon is framed poorly on screen and there's not much natural reaction to actions being performed or weight of the weapon being shown. Outside of animation related crits, there's a few mistakes the animator's make regarding weapon operation - a lot, if not all, of the time the player character doesn't use the magazine releases which is quite noticeable on weapons like the STG44. This is something Vanguard gets right! Comparatively, Vanguard is a lot better in terms of animation quality but it's a shame they had to use modern techinques.
Oh god the reloadable Panzerfaus hits so hard
God there's so much wrong with vanguard I don't even know where to start. Enlisted has it's own problems as well but it's at least trying to be historically authentic. Vanguard just makes me shake my head everytime I see it.
Animation:CoD Vanguard
Sound:Enlisted
Does the owen eject spent casings upward irl? I think it ejects them downward. Can any gun guy confirm?
Im pretty sure it obviously ejects downward
All the guns in vanguard fell like they’re all weak with no weight but all the weapons in enlisted actually fell powerful
Just listen to them vanguard sounds like BB guns while enlisted sounds like an actual firearm
Why do they remove the hopper and put another one on like it’s a mag ITS A HOPPER YOU PUT MORE IN.
Vanguard: *gets filled with a whole mp-40 mag* well time to respawn and get back to milsim Airsoft
Enlisted: at the capture point, crying in the corner with a mosin while the enemies artillery strikes true, followed by the distant rumble of the engines of a bombing run approaching. "Good work men, you've captured the control point, move onto the next one" 💀
The tanks, I forgot to mention there'd be at least 1 Panzer 4 between point B and point C XD
Every Enlisted gun sounds like it's firing a bigger cartige than in reality (except M1 Garand, they nailed that one), every CoD weapon sounds supressed.
also, You cannot eject a clip from the trash rod (Mosin) by operating the bolt. It uses rimmed ammo and crimped clips.
Enlisted's Gewehr 43 makes me feel that bolt is going straight for my nose.
Enlisted's guns actually sound like guns!
Also they don’t shoot faster then they should
Vangaurd was so lazy with the Type 11 it hurts.
Automatic fire is a really scary sound to hear in Enliated, dont know why
I don't know how Gajin managed to make a game in 2021 that looks like it was published in 2011...
Darkflow is the developer, I think Gaijin is the publisher
@@ultimatedeadp00l would make sense. WT looks a bit better while being far older.
@@gervinschwarz575 Enlisted started as a Kickstarter project so it doesn't have a big budget but hopefully it gets better overtime. I started playing almost two years ago and there were a lot of improvements since then.
type 11 and changing whole feed tray in vanguard is ridiculous xD
Its looks like that every weapons in vanguard has a bulit in silencer.
The Type-99 Arisaka rifle animations look ridiculous in Enlisted.
Enlisted Animations and Audio need lots of work, but we all know that game has the better gameplay.
Am i only one who enjoys vanguard animations?
Lad wouldve gotten a C- in an Essay for how many "buts" you used
the vanguard PPS-43 thing hurt me
enlisted does some weapon reloads incorrectly but the mistakes from the cod guns are even worse.
Why is there a semi auto PPS43 in Vanguard? Nasty.
That Garand ping is sexy 12:05
I wonder if this cod ever got updated recently 🤔🤔🤔🥶
Anyone else found it kinda funny that when the pistols fired, it looked like their barrels were fixed in place while the rear ends rocked up and down?
Yeah I noticed that, maybe it’s meant to make it easier to see your target when firing because the recoil for the pistols are quite high
Quite sure pistols do that so it’s easier to chamber a new bullet in.
how do you get lee enfield?
I know, that CoD is a game for kids, but bamn, those guns really sound like toys.
Vanguard guns sound like air soft rifles
Tbh vanguards animations aren’t to bad…. The Panzerfaust however
I really love the sounds of the weapons from enlisted but I like the animations from cod only because the animations are much more smooth, enlisted needs to work more on the animations.
Over all in my humble tumble opinion enlisted is a much better game plus it’s free (I think)
enlisted feels like a source game. meanwhile, cod has audio resembling the 90's medal of honor days.
11:31 For Superearth!!!
unironically the vangaurd animations are more indepth and realistic just with modern handling tecniques, enlisted is more time accurate but most of the animations waste ammunition and would down right just not work
Enlisted has greater weapon variety, but I feel like all of the full auto guns sound the same
^^^
Yep. They need new sounds. They just keep reusing
@@rouxgreasus they just announced: "In the next major update we plan to please you with multiple improvements regarding weapon sounds, models and animations. But you can already notice some small, but significant fixes." So we will see, AS-44 already got new weapon sound and it sounds amazing it's completely different when compared to Fedorov or Ppsh-41 or stg44
Notice that Enlisted knows that the VG 1-5 did not have full-auto capability. It's a "volkssturm gewehr", not a "volks sturmgewehr".
Sir tigerfield, can you compare enlisted vs sledgehammers so called cod "ww2" ?
both of them are good
Enlisted is a very good game , and CoD WW2 is a very underrated one
в вангарде, будто бы один и тот же звук выстрела, у каждого оружия, только с разной скоростью
Sounds: Enlisted
Reloads: Vanguard
Model designs: Enlisted
Vanguard takes it way more satisfying
I don’t wanna hear it with you mr gold ass panzerfaust💀
I’m still not used to how the recoil looks in enlisted.
As a player of enlisted some the guns they have is poor examples but example the C96 you’d use is a bad example it’s in the files but you can’t get it anywhere else it’s a poor comparison
But unlike cod they’re actually accurate on how the guns load at the time and getting the models correct and not being super modern pretty good for a game company that just not a tank game tbh or insert vehicle game here
The bolt on the PTRS 41 doesn’t move.
It does, Enlisted's weapon FOV is just really goofy which is why you can't see it
enlisted has some jank on the animations, but game play wise enlisted takes the cake
Omg those bolt action reloads for COD make me want to fucking cry and whats with the Lee E getting only 5 in the chamber when its supposed to be 10? Jesus christ save us all
i feel that the enlisted shots are more powerful and the sound is better call of duty just feels like using the same sound again and again
Do COD Vanguard vs COD WWII vs COD WaW
"pistols were operated with one hand in ww2"
True battlefield moment
У Enlisted вроде анимации хороши, но есть какие то проблемы с положением самих рук и камеры, из-за чего анимации кажутся дерганными.
Enlisted needs a massive reload animation overhaul cause man that looks so rough lmao
fr
Then you are lucky guy they just announced that: "In the next major update we plan to please you with multiple improvements regarding weapon sounds, models and animations. But you can already notice some small, but significant fixes."
Nah they need to work on balancing out Berlin first
@@Leopard-2A6.. what's so wrong about Berlin balance? It just lacks players on Soviet side and is-2 needs a buff that's it. Axis infantry weapons are inferior to Soviet with exception of fg42.
@@Dregomz02 Germany dominates
How the firearms are being operated by the user in Vanguard are using modern techniques that obviously don't fit with the time period. Enlisted, on the other hand, more closely resembles how firearms during WWII would have been operated.
The recoil on the Luger is bs, IT’S 9MM FOR HEAVEN’S SAKE
Look at MWR 2016s P08, it has so much visual recoil and its a 2 shot kill
@@CZcamsIsSeriouslyFucked It's the first f*cking gun to shoot 9mm what are they DOING