Yasir Qadhi: Ya'jooj & Ma'jooj & Muslims Leaving Islam
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 09. 2019
- Yasir Qadhi: Ya'jooj & Ma'jooj & Muslims Leaving Islam
Please support Ilmstitute 🤝:
❤️ Patreon: / ilmstitute
PayPal: www.paypal.me/ilmstitute
📚 Islamic Classes: courses.ilmstitute.com
👕 Merch! (shirts, hoodies, etc.): teespring.com/stores/ilmstitute
🔗 Social Media:
📱 Facebook: / brothersaajid
📱 Twitter: / saajidlipham
📷 Instagram: / ilmstitute
💻 Website: www.ilmstitute.com
🔈 Soundcloud: / user-1260072
🔈 Podcast: itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/i...
“Verily, the truth has come to you from your Lord. So be not of those who doubt (it).”
Surah YUNUS 94
Minimal X 🤲
Best to doubt all claims. Supernatural ones especially.
Go-go 63
“This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for the those conscious of Allah.”
Surah : Al Baqara ayah :2
(Sahid international)
@@claires9100 quran is not supernatural dont be one of those ignorant like apus
Gogo why dont u doubt ur alien big bang fish -> monkey -> human fairy tails ?
This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for those conscious of Allah -, Who believe in the *Unseen,* establish prayer, and spend out of what We have provided for them.
(Quran 2:2-3)
@Vat Abraham
you can watch this video.
czcams.com/video/YT_H8WTO0sI/video.html
Allāhu Akbar! Alif Laam Meem. dhaalikal kitaabu laa rayyba fee. Hudan lil muttaqeen. Alladheena YU'MINOONA BIL GHAAYYB!!!!!....
Sadaqt!
Allahu Akbar! Indeed Allah covered every single topic regarding His BOOK.
NO MATTER HOW STUPID AND NONSENSE THE KORAN IS- AND SAY, ALLAH KNOWS BEST
Im a huge fan of Yasir Qadhi. But my view about him is changing as my knowledge of Islam increasing. Alhamdulillah. Allah is opening my eyes.
Yasir Qadhi is misguided. He used to be on point before.
Just the face of yasir qadhi, the face of a Shiia to me, for years, had me hate opening a single video of him
Only came to know he is considered Sunni this year when I saw his views on Sodomy and Sodomites and more of what seems a "reformist"
@@idiotshypocrites9547 please explain
Those Muslims who are leaving Islam were never Muslims by heart. Astaghferullah. May Allah guide us all. Ameen!
This is interesting to hear especially from Yasir Qadhi. If Yajuj Majuj is just a tale then where do we draw the line at what was a tale and what was real in the lives of the Prophets peace on them all? I mean forget Yajuj Majuj we believe in angels lol. Beings of light, that don't eat it drink that have wings and can travel through space and can be large enough to lift entire towns and cities and destroy them. I mean that sounds pretty fantastical. But we believe in them. And the Quran speaks about them. So where do we draw the line at what is real and a tale? Allah can create anything so why is it more unbelievable to think that Yajuj and Majuj is real than angels? I'm frankly surprised that Qadhi has this mindset.
@Tom Edwards Actually that verse is very hard to read translates from the Arabic. When it talks about "it" preceding from between the loins and backbone its talking about the actual baby not the sperm. The area where the womb is and where a baby grows is between the loins and the backbone. And God doesn't put people in hell for not believing in Him without them knowing anything about Him in the first place. If you live this life and don't know about God or His message you don't automatically get sent to hell when you die. Everyone is given an individual test, if you aren't tested in this life you'll be tested on Judgement Day. Authentic hadith confirms that and the Quran also states that God does not throw people into hell unjustly and without them knowing anything. Not to mention anyone who has an atoms weight of belief in God will go to heaven and God made humans with the fitrah (in Islam that's the innate belief in God from the moment we were created) so eventually everyone will end up in heaven. Obviously some people will go to hell and be punished first for the sins they did in this life. It wouldn't be fair for God to send Pharaoh (the one who enslaves the Jews and who Moses pbuh went up against) into heaven and not punish him along with a pious person who spent their whole life worshipping God and doing good to earn His reward. And look you don't want to believe in metaphysical realities and ideas that's fine, don't. But let's not be patronising and make out that you know for absolute certainty that it doesn't exist, because you don't. Really your position should be well I don't know, you believe it but I'm not convinced. And that's fine with us. I'm not hurting you by believing in God and tbh it's none of your business anyways if I do believe in Him. I mean I don't really care that you don't believe in Him, I don't have a burning need to change your mind and show you the light lol.
Aisha Arshad Alam sister, please be careful with such statements like "eventually everyone will enter heaven" Allah has mentioned several times in Quran pertaining to the eternal (meaning forever) damnation of some to hell who are deserving of it, mentioned in Surah Yunus, Fussilat and Qaaf to mention a few, and Allah is Al 'Adl (Utterly Just). Barakallahu feekum
@@Ubaydah. Yes this is true but there is plenty of discussion amongst classical scholars about this, for instance the fitrah is a part of every human and that innate sense of belief in God is a part of us. Of course it is completely in Allah's Hands who will go to hell and heaven and if it will be eternal or not. I accept your comment and take the advice you have given. May Allah forgive me if I said anything wrong, it was from my own self and truly Allah is completely perfect and All Knowing. Jazakallah khair :)
@Michael Cameron We haven't even discovered what's in the entirety of the ocean. I don't think one undiscovered tribe is all that far fetched. Anyways I already made the point about angels.
@Michael Cameron I don't see a problem with dinosaurs. God is all knowing after all, so He would know why He made a certain animal and why it only survived for so long. He's got the full picture after all. He doesn't have to share the answers with us about it. It's His creation. He can do what He likes. We aren't in a position to demand answers from Him.
👍, Salam from Kyrgyzstan!
"...and they cannot grasp any of His knowledge, except as He wills..." (2: 255)
Selam aleyküm Müsülman kardeşim seni sevilyorum
well said
@@muslimhaitham4247 Wa alaykum s-salaam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh kardeşim! Ben da seni seviyorum.
Yakjuj and makjuj is definately falls under mustashabihat ayat which can be intrepreted. To unlock the knowledge that has been quoted above, you need to be a solihin. And the Quran is send down to the people who thinks. Li kaumi yata fakkarun.
Wa alaykum us salaam wa rohmatullohi wa barokatuh! Uzbek guy is here too!
I am shocked about YQ !
He is famous here in Meddle East .
I am from Saudi Arabia and i loved his videos but Alhamduillah recently I found your channel brother and thanks for your clearness and show me something I did not notice about him .
This feeble minded creature is doing nothing but yaling ever since he left Yale university. As Abu Musaab Wajdi Akkari said in a video.
He YQ is at same page with Adnan ibrahim.
he is Reformist
the brother view is apologetic ....
Yasir khady has said the truth. Now as human beings, we hate the truth. I think that's the reason why you're looking for conforter to confort you in lies.
A brother from Africa…..may Allah reward you with jannah for standing with quran and sunnah.
I am in public school and I really know what the brother is talking about. Thanks brother
Alibek Kuanyshbek Lol Triggered Hindu Indian. Tell Me Do You Watch A Lot Of Apostate Prostate, Dead Wood And Chicken Prince?
Alibek Kuanyshbek it goes back to you!
@Alibek Kuanyshbek 1a
Bismi Allah Quran is past present and future ? Things not seen what verse mention S 18 A Mercy do the work as serva its as Muslims long. As he say it's his understanding show respect Next Leaders and share as you seem to be doing what someone said or say and what the Quran say for instance the verse just before talking of ribs something my not understanding the LANGUAGE SOUND )IKE ALLAH ABU RAHIM S 3 yet I'm sure my ears are. Trying to deceive me.
Bismi a blessing don't say anything about your Muslim Senior talk about that facts of the statements don't decide That's what Satan cbuh want us to be ungrateful I'm grateful for older and next leaders of different tribes I laugh not at words or people the latter may be better joyful seeing concern getting to know us with C 19 and S O S Gen on all levels may we all be teaching and learning even the most Evil refreshing see young blood pay Attention and dissect may you and your Gen get with min Lewis Farakhan and the elders of different 1970 and on what we have done and what is being turned over to your Gen as the Others who have been united as Quran said and they ask I think it was Iman Fuquan yrs ago Christian or Jew we wish you were dealing with your group ( talking about the Muslim in the Prisons like I always warned my Children if you are not being a Muslim. On what ever level you know then you are taking me back to slavery the same who would beat the skin off your own Mothers back. To go three labor and give birth and have any child make a claimed of being not that child a Mother held and excepted with grateful Ness maybe wanting A girl yet grateful to Ilah _The giver of Children is like being Inslaved all over again reguardless of what who we the truth is only One God And sent a angle to Ahmad Muhammad the guildance.
_“For to Allah belongs the dominion of the Heavens and the Earth, and all that is between. He creates what He pleases. For Allah has power over all things.“_
*[Qur'an **5:17**]*
I Agree with you, and while my kids went to Islamic school until they were 12,they still got brainwashed and they are enslaved except to Allah.I worry about our condition and our akhirah.Bro Sajid,I pray you are heard far and wide and may the youths be able to hold on to their religion of islam.May Allah continue to guide and protect you and your family.
Funny name 👾
SlamboGaming TM Wy allah never showed his power?
SubhanAllah
Alhamdulillah
La illaha illa Allah
Allahu Akbar
Subhanallahi Wa Bihamdihi
SubhanAllahil Azeem
@@mrfrancisko1 You're living. You're experiencing this world of sense. You see the different animals all scattered throughout the Earth. Have you studied the DNA System??? What about the senses we use to experience this world of sense??? He's manifested HIS powers in every thing that exists! Open your eyes, your mind and realize everything has been systematically and strategically created and placed on Earth including your own self. The Water System, the Solar System, the systems that are within us??? Do you know of anyone else who claimed to have created all this???
Anas narrated: “The Messenger of Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم would often say: *Ya Muqallibal-qulub, thabbit qalbi `ala dinik (“O Changer of the Hearts! Strengthen my heart upon Your religion.)* “So I said: “O Prophet of Allah! We believe in you and what you have come with, but do you fear for us?' He said: `Yes. Indeed the hearts are between two Fingers of Allah's Fingers, He changes them as He wills.'' (Sahih)
Tirmidhi 2140
Ameen!
Barak'Allahu fik akhi!
The Quran mentions
“Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, then We separated them, and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?” (Quran 21:30)
“And the heaven We created with might, and indeed We are (its) expander.” (Quran 51:47)
I live in Algeria "a muslim country" and because i spend my teen years whatching american's movies and tv shows that really effected me, my dad onces told me a story of his friend who let his daughter go to france to study without a "Mohram" and my dad didn't like that and said poeple are getting away from the religion , i got mad of my dad and told him that things changed now women can do whatever they want ,i was surprised of myself ,so thank God there's channels like yours that remaind us of the right peth, it's already a blessing that i was born muslim it would be a shame to loose that
Very honest. May Allah guide us all. Ameen.
Its a shame how the north african muslims have been compromised.
@@Yusufmaghreb well this is why i put "" because i don't think we're practicing islam properly ,actually things are much better is Algeria camparing to Marocco or Tunisia cause we have no tourism ,i watched once a surveiy done by frensh socialist about how islam is effecting these 3 countries of north africa in order to show witch one is "the most backrounded" -_-,and Algeria came first, i was so proud :)
@@theregular6229 man u r wayoff, when amazigh been introduced to islam they embrace it and they fought with muslims to conquer Spain. And for the fact that why people r running from the country we both know it's because of the corrupted systeme
@@theregular6229 I'm Amazighi Muslim ! and I tell you that islame came with peace to Morocco they found Amazigh more smarter than you and people like you ! people who knows the truth from first sight as they said ! and like Allah swt said !'' لكم دينكم ولي دين'' very simple !
All this comes downs to arrogance, thinking that modern humans have reached the peak of knowledge. This is exactly the same thing that led shaytan to disbelieve.
it has always been like this. People always come along and think they've got it all figured out and their ideas are finally the superior correct ones over the others
@@45facial also Adam sinned out of forgetfulness. Satan new exactly what he was doing. He sinneed to show his rebellion.
cannot be said better
This sajid are real stupid man. Rather than response other man.. He Should give his own Lecture. Rather than drugging others. I saw every timehe waiting for counting him. It's better he should give his own lecture without creating conflict.
@@MohammadAliAhasan he is only advising his brother.
A reminder always benefited a Muslim
Keep the work this is eye opening I didnt know Yasir Qadhi reached to this point
This feeble minded creature is doing nothing but yaling ever since he left Yale university. As Abu Musaab Wajdi Akkari said in a video.
Where was the Malaysian plane when every nation was looking for it,claiming the earth geography is known in entirety is proven rubbish
i read somewhere that two third of ocean is still undiscovered.
Subhanallah the retardedness of knowledge of the physical world has diminished in the Muslim mindset, no wonder people are leaving the deen.
@@icysaracen3054 The retardedness of the knowledge of the deen you mean. When will you realise that western logic is very much fallible? I guess you value their words over Allah's.
This is utterly shocking ! If you can believe that Allah created the heavens and earth why can’t you believe that Allah can hide Ya’jooj & Ma’jooj from us until he see’s fits to expose them, The Prophet Mohammad peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The best people are those of my generation, then those who come after them, then those who come after them. Then, there will come people after them whose testimony precedes their oaths and their oaths precede their testimony’ so how far are we down that line SubhanAllah, that he thinks he knows better than the ‘medieval scholars’ ! May Allah guide & protect us from such falsehood always Ameen !
Asalaamu aleikum. I have trouble with this. Dhul Quarnayn's iron/copper wall in a valley shouldn't be too hard to find?. I can only assume that Dhul Quarnayn, yajooj/majooj and the wall are not real/literal, rather metaphor..Maybe this metaphor is not apparent to us right now, as we are not in that age yet.
Why i think it's metaphor is that if it was real, yajooj/majooj wouldn't waste time trying to bore through it, just to have Allah(swt) seal it up again?. It would be more logical to just go around or over it.. Allahu Aalim though!. If you can refute my belief that yajooj/majooj isn't real, that the wall exists etc, I'd be interested in why you think so?
Says One Ameen and may Allah (Swt) guide our brother Yasir and all those affected in the same way back to the path of the Qur'an and the Sunnah
@@jasonthedragon73 Yes, it is difficult to comprehend such a thing for me as well, but there is a principle that everything in the Quran is literal unless it is mentioned to be metaphorical. Maybe they are on earth and there is an actual copper wall but not visible to human eyes and maybe they were visible during the time of Dhul Qarnain but Allah made them invisible now He Subhana wa ta'ala will make them visible again during the day of judgement. Allah knows best akhee. Correct me if anything I said goes against authentic narration I am just a layman.
@@jasonthedragon73 Yajooj Majooj would be real in my eyes because Allah is the Creator of Heavens and the Earth
Whether humans can or cannot find it does not make it false...secondly what if they actually did find it but want to hide it from the public
Imagine people actually saw this tall copper building they would accept Islam in a heartbeat
Mustafe Abdullahi Allahumma Ameen
Alhamdullillah, We need more brothers with firm Imaan, May Allah guide us all. Jazakallah khairan brother Saajid.
I can say with confidence that I know more engineering and maths than Yasir Qadhi does. I have a PhD degree in chemical engineering from one of the best engineering school on earth. Yet, I have no problem whatsoever with the "medieval" interpretation of Yajuj and Majuj.
All I see in that clip is just Yasir Qadhi admiring himself over and over again.
this was an amazing rebuttal to Yasir Qadhi aw well as the insight in the beginning about schooling, thank you so much I really appreciate the knowledge and awareness Iv just gained through this video. May Allah keep you safe and guided on sirat al mustaqim always ameen.
jazak allah, you are saving musilms by these videos, I hope you will keep uploading more.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 From falsification of Islam.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 Imagine a professional math teacher with a large platform claiming that 1+1 is not equal to 2 and tries to convince it to people in a sneaky way. It is just not right, whether you fully follow a religion or just leave it, he is misleading muslims. The story of yajoj and majoj is in the quran therefore we believe its existence.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 No , I used to listen to his lectures, but not anymore.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 I used to listen to his lectures but not anymore.
I hope Saajid's videos reach more and more Muslims and even non-Muslims. May Allah make it happen. Oh Allah please make it happen.
Eyes opening. Alhamdulillah. May Allah save us this kind of fitna from Yasir Qodir.
What fitna? He just said the truth so open your eyes dude and make your own research instead of being that lazy and a coward who only wants to hear to some imams and thoso dawah people. Islam is a lie it is a shatanswork..
Ameen
This feeble minded creature is doing nothing but yaling ever since he left Yale university. As Abu Musaab Wajdi Akkari said in a video.
@@rooobiiful yasir Qadhi is a deviant and misguiding the masses. Sorry to break it to you about your yale boy.
@@mobinmirshekari4884 hahaa.. "Yaling", new vocab for me.. Thks..
There was a time i was so obssessed with Dr Yasir Kadhi's lectures for he's a brilliant orator and very articulate but then one fine day listening to one of his lectures on Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) marriage to Hazrat Zainb(ra), the interpretation he had made was totally different from what other mainstream Fukaahas had made, not onlt it did not match with the previous poplular interpretations, the interpretation sounded completely ill informed and was particularly tasteless.That was the last day of my association as a student with Dr Yasir.I stopped listening to his lectures completely.And today after finding this video, i am extremely thankful to Allah(SWT) for guiding me through in those dark years when i was hooked to Dr Yasir's videos.
May Allah guide us all.
Oh Alhamdulillah 3xs. Sister, how wonderful it is to be guided by ALLAH. I'm so happy for you!!!
@Syed Aman wrong all the way. prophets were guided through revelation and they didn't speak of themselves but what Allah put in their mouths. secondly you have trillion people and chosen few among them as prophets and who chose those people? Allah the most wise. so your initial premise is flawed because Muhammad sas was human being therefore one should automatically consider him capable of lust. you are making fallacy of composition.
For science cannot explain everything. It always forked its ways to " relative", "apparent perception" to try explaining the plain. I don't trust Yasir Qadri, that's why I don't listen to his lectures.
Although I don't tend to believe everything Sheikh Imran Hosein says, but he explains everything we see today and that's the reason I trust Sheikh Imran Hosein. See his book Gog and Magog in the modern world.
Can anyone suggest me names of some authentic scholars, I want to understand my Deen?
@@default2740 your views are not based on a fairy tale
You are doing Dr Yasir a great favor, honestly.
I swear we are in the end times. Yaa allah guide us to the right path.
Brother Saajid i wanna give you glad tidings! You are indeed educating the students of knowledge more than the average Muslims. Please do not underestimate these efforts. You coming back to US with knowledge from Madina was a blessing to the Ummah. You are doing a great effort and addressing issues, clarifying misconceptions and exposing misleading treacherous charlatans in a way that no other Da3i that I know can!
ماشاء الله تبارك الله عليك. نسأل الله الثبات
Ameen
Well said! I love brother Saajid in the sake of Allah. Beautiful heart he has Masha’Allah. He has this pure Ikhlaas.
May Allah bless all of us with his Rahmah
I had defended Yasir Qadhi vehemently on your video about his podcast few months ago.
Watching the video in question made me flinch and filled with rage and I couldn't stomach it.
Indeed he crossed all the bounds and is now actively misleading the youth.
He kept contradicting himself when he said he wouldn't dismiss anyone believing the classical interpretation and then actually went on ridiculing and insulting not only the believers of that hadith but the early scholarship. And then he didn't even present his opinion and he showed such treachery by mentioning his friend's opinion as laughable yet believing in it himself. And when everyone laughed he said laugh at my friend and not me. And he kept rejecting any ideas put forward by the audience that would relate back to the classical interpretation yet he would find his friend's interpretation plausible.
Unfortunately I will have to distance myself from Yasir Qadhi and not watch him anymore. Although being critical of brother Saajid in the earlier video I didn't unsubscribe because he didn't say anything against Quran and Sunnah but Yasir Qadhi has went too far and unless he publicly apologizes and reverts to the correct opinion, I consider him a threat.
BarakAllah akhi
Well said
SubhanaAllah I'm shocked as well. I heard things said about him but gave him the benefit of the doubt, but I just can't get around what I just heard from his own mouth. People blame brother Imran for outing him but I think we needed to know the kind of danger we expose ourselves to by listening to this man.
Also used to follow YQ and would defend him but this and his previous video about celebrations opened my eyes. The worst thing was he thought something that was "laugh-worthy" was more plausible than what was in the Quran and authentic sunnah...
Why do you have to be so suspicious. Yasir Qadhi is trying to understand certain so far Ununderstable things using reason. He finishes his point by saying wallahu alam. Why would that be taken as a threat! Come on. You can say i dont agree with his opinion on this and that.. Khalas!
Whatever my beloved prophet has said - his sunnah - and whatever Allah has revealed in the Quran I truly believe
MashAllah, tebarakAllah Saajid, I’m so happy when I see that you’re firm on the Quran and sunnah, whitout doubts. :) Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu from Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Tako jeeee :)
Slažem se
Baš tako :-)
Once Umar bin al-Khattab radiAllāhu anhu (may Allāh be pleased with him) was walking in the market, he passed by a man who was supplicating,
“O Allāh, make us of Your ‘few’ servants! O Allāh make us of Your ‘few’ servants!”
So ‘Umar said to him, “Where did you get this du`a’ (supplication) from?” And the man said, “Allāh in His Book says ‘And few of My servants are grateful.’(Qur’an 34:13)”
So ‘Umar wept and admonished himself, “The people are more knowledgeable than you, O Umar! O Allāh make us of Your ‘few’ servants.”
Sometimes when you advise someone to leave a sin, they respond with “But most people do it, it’s not just me!”
But if you look for the words “most people” in the Qur’an, you will find that,
most people “do not know” (7:187),
“do not give thanks” (2:243)
and “do not believe” (11:17).
And if you look for “most of them”, you will find that,
most of them are “defiantly disobedient” (5:59),
“ignorant” (6:111),
“turning away” (21:24),
“do not reason” (29:23),
and “do not listen” (8:21).
So be of the “few”, whom Allāh says about them:
“And few of My servants are grateful.” (34:13)
“But none had believed with him, except a few.” (11:40)
“In the Gardens of Pleasure, A [large] company of the former peoples, And a few of the later peoples.” (56:12-14)
Ibn al-Qayyim (rahimahullāh) said, “Go on the path of truth and do not feel lonely because there are few who take that path, and beware of the path of falsehood and do not be deceived by the greatness of the perishers.”
Great comment. Can I use it to remind people bro.
@@synsept absolutely bro, no need for permission.
Well said brother !!! Walahi i love you for the sake of Allah !☝🏽
Thanks bro
Jazaka Allahu khairan for this. Really helpful.
Yq. Has lost and has no manners with scholars. May allah guide him.
This feeble minded creature is doing nothing but yaling ever since he left Yale university. As Abu Musaab Wajdi Akkari said in a video.
I NEVER write comments. But wallahi this brother talks so much sense and is so humble mashAllah. I have now watched like 8 of his videos including podcasts. I have watched many videos of people like Mufti Menk etc etc that are so popular, but this brother is so on point. And he a revert SubhanAllah. I mean come on... a revert who went and seeked so much knowledge yet a born Muslim like me doesnt even know 1% of what this Saajid akhi knows. Well brother PLEASE DO NOT CHANGE YOUR WAYS. Keep the same approach: humble yet no no nonsense, straight to the point.
Whenever you come London please do publish it if you give a talk. I would definitely attend inshaAllah, and shame on me when i use these words.. i never attend any talks. Firstly may Allah swt give me the ability to attend talks..and secondly it speaks volumes on the impact your style of commicating your message across has had on me.
May Allah swt preserve you and accept your ibada ameen ya rab
Wallahi I deeply regret ever calling this individual teacher. His PhD from Yale has really gone over his head. This is what happened when you look down upon the real scholars of Islam
Alibek Kuanyshbek can we (human beings) understand everything in the world using reason? Don’t think so. There are so many things in nature and in our bodies, that neither science nor reason could explain or even understand. Our mind and our reasoning is as Allah created it has shortfalls by nature, so we can’t explain everything by reason.
@Alibek Kuanyshbek another keyboard warrior....What makes him right? Let's find out now. Plz explain how zombies are more reasoning explanation then sealed behind a wall?
@@user-fi6sb6ey1c amin.
@Alibek Kuanyshbek You are a Shaytan trying to create doubt.
Yasir spit some truth about the holes in the narrative in the quran that was his career ending move, I tried reading the quran in english and I couldn't make sense of it it was all over the place, I was told that I had to read it in arabic, well I dont read arabic, so how can revelation from God only be understood in arabic unless it's only for arabs
Anyone who can't seperate faith from science has neither eman nor intellect. May Allah preserve us all.
What Mr. Yasir qadhi says about he doesn't believe in Yajuj and Majuj which is mentioned in The Qur'an and Sunnah then what he is. Wallahi I believe in every single word of ALLAH and His Messenger Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam
Finally someone speaking about this topic. Exactly what ive been struggling for over a year now, im 13 btw. Using logic and societys perspective, you can get many doubts about islam. But ill study more and inshaAllah become better and stronger in faith.
May Allah bless you brother
@@mohammedahmed1109 sister* JazakAllah khair
@@munt07 wa jazaki Allah kheran sister , and my apologies
Bless you. The One (Allah) who created us & everything knows it all, He is the source of knowledge, we gain our from Him, any wise person knows that our intellect and knowledge is limited.
@@reptilespit4433 mA, make sure u study Quran and Sunnah. Learn tawheed and correct aqeedah.
I stopped listening to Yasir quite some time ago .... Shetan is very patient....
It is important to learn islam. I hope you changed your scholars and didn't stop learning.
@@thecuriousservant5549 does it really protect you from evil? I know it is the sunnah but like idk I never hear about it specifically protecting you from evil
@L Lawliet I mean idk
SYED MIAH can you please list some scholars you listen to I’m having a hard ty
@@ummtamaatim I recommend OneWaytojannah and Mohamed tim
This is what the Prophet SAW was talking about when he said “one of you will do the actions of the people of Paradise until there is but an arms length btw him and it, then that which has been written overtakes him, and he starts doing the actions of the people of the Hell Fire and thus enters it”. May Allah guide Yasir Qadhi before it’s too late.
So true. May Allah protect us and guide him. His going down a dangerous road. His questioning the Quran and Sunnah
May God keep you on this right path forever !
ya Yasir, the young kids are not leaving bec of problems with yajooj and majooj. the issue lies with the imposed philiosophies by the west, ideas rooted in agnostic/athiest world views.
in fact, those who look into the quran and sunnah actually strengthen their imaan and get rid of chains that one has to the west and its cancerous ideologies
I wonder how one can believe in a living thing coming via chance and have the audacity to reject miracles.
That's deep subhan Allah
Soo true
Scientists didn't come up with the life from nothing thing because they were bored..They believe they have some kind of evidence that points to their theories..The deeper one digs in looking for fossils, the simpler the life forms get, I can see their point-even though I don't believe it myself. Miracles, to a non-believer, have no basis in their evidence. They have nothing to base the possibility of miracles on.
@@jasonthedragon73 life from nothing is not inspired by science but by philosophy and ideologies then the proponents of this ideologies try to use science as excuse. But in reality they contradict science . No fossils are not simple and even simple fossils cannot form by chance. Miracles are explained by God perfectly .
Alhumdulilah i was raised in muslim country and never in my life had i looked at yaajoj maajoj as TALES. I have since childhood felt scared of the time when fitna of those creatures will be inflicted upon the unmah
brother yajuj majuj are humans children of adam
@rod kemp
Yajuj majoj will come from beyond the two rivers, which is east of Arabia.
It'll be like the Mongol invasion of Abbasid.
It seems like his ( Yasir qadhi's) friend who gave him the " hilarious contemplation" about yajooj and majooj, is the iblees himself! Allah protect the nation
I dont knw why this guy came up with this nonsense. Doesnt he believe in Ilm Ghayb? And whats so controversial in regards to Yajuj wa Majuj? May Allah protect us from kufur
Ameen this is unbelievable
I really respected doc yasir ,and after watching this video I feel like crying 😥 may Allah guide us all.
Well Yasir is the only person I know who's admitting to the obvious facts and doesn't encourages moronic religiosity.
May Allah protect and preserve you brother Saajid. ma shaa Allah. You are doing the service many of us wish we could do. Keep it up brother, in shaa Allah. Baraak Allahu Feek.
Does he also have a problem with someone building a boat and loading Animals on it before a flood?? Just saying
No, if you watched his video you would no the answer to that.. So basically your a person who comments based on rumour and heresay..
@Fragment Traveler "if you want to approach Islam based on your human logic" you a Christian? Because that's is some stupid level paulian statement right there. Would you prefer people coming with horse logic instead?
@Fragment Traveler @Fragment Traveler - Yes I do know that story actually and my position on it is what the Prophet may peace be upon him and what the classical scholars have said. Now did you not say and I quote " if you want to approach Islam based on your human logic". Yes you did say that so how did I change the topic and lie? You're the one now saying you didn't say that but it's written right there in YOUR comment so why are you lying about not saying that? For someone who just suggested not to use logic when approaching Islam to then say "research what you are studying about" is the single most dumbest thing I ever heard. Run along now and grow a brain, maybe then you could start using it. Majority of Islamic scholars say logic is crucial in Islam but they are all wrong because your uneducated ass says otherwise? 🤣🤣🤣
@Fragment Traveler - this is where you messed up, Islam invites believers and non believers to "think", "reflect" "ponder" and "reason" (reason is based on logic) by using these things we come to the conclusion that Allah SWT is our creator, He sent the Qur'an and the messenger and we understand the things that were revealed to us by using these faculties. When miraculous events take place, we understand that they are miraculous and supernatural because we use our reasoning and logic to see that it is by the power of Allah SWT that that's things happen since He is the creator of all things. The fact that scholars used reason and logic to authenticate a hadith should tell you how crucial it is. It is something Allah SWT has even told us to use.
Look back at your example of the Jews, if you tried to understand it, you'll find it was the jews being illogical not logical since they were a god believing people who had previous experience with prophets to whom another prophet was sent and found He was born miraculously, even spoke to them as a baby and performed countless miracles amongst other things. If they did what Allah swt tells us to do which is think and ponder, they would have realised that this person was not a normal person and was actually sent by Allah swt.
@Fragment Traveler - I'll repeat, did you or did you not say "if your going to approach Islam based on human logic". If you didn't then why is that statement in your comment? I don't remember telling you to write it so explain to me how I put words in your mouth🤦 Since you did write it and now you're denying it, you're a liar. Do you know how we come to the conclusion that there are things that we can not ponder and think about? Through reason l. Just stop with your stupidity already, now go and learn something about Islam before spewing your crap.
To me Yasir Qadhi seems to believe that Allah has left the world 1400 years ago and Miracles will no longer happen and every future miraculous prophecy is to happen somehow through human processes with no divine intervention. This is some form of disbelief, astaghfirullah.
This is a huge part of why we homeschool. Brothers and sisters, homeschool your children. When there's a will there's a way, Allah will send the help!
Good decision, Alhamdulillah.
But always seek help from Almighty Allah.
@@mohammadbayezidalzobayerfa6918 Ameen.
You can call public schools indoctrination cells.
Talk about "terrorist sleeping cells" throughout the world huh?? That's what my mother's atheist husband thought after the 9/11 craze may Allah curse him for his disbelief!!
@@neilcastro836 It is the uneducated masses who watch news and poloticians as if they speak the truth. The rest knows it is exactly these same people who set up false flag attacks and blame them on Muslim to try and make people hate on Islam, but elhemdullilah many have embraced Islam after doing their indepth research
@@charleswatkins8695 I knoe what you mean, Im an arab in America living among muslims, from all types. And I see how they sure do love the west culture. They are dating ect.. and doing everything that is against Islam. I also do avoid those, and it is hard to find good practicing Muslims. I would start by going to the mosque and from there, you can find better muslims.
@@charleswatkins8695
Lmao what?
Read "Jerusalem in the Quran"....IH explains Dajjal and Yajuj wa Majuj still in classical way...
Please keep doing what you’re doing. I think this is the first actual video I saw of yours on Facebook but you’ve been a friend of mine there for a few months. I’m glad I came across this Barak Allah feek.
I remeber when i was going too school... after Allah guided me.. i really felt that school infuenced me, and my iman bad.. so i tried always too listen too quran islamic poems and nasheed while i was in school that helped me alhamdulillah
SubhanAllah a “Tale” is exactly the word used by the kuffar to our prophet (pbuh) أساطير الأولين
Brother I enjoy your videos a lot. My Imaan gets high when I see your videos but after a while I get into as usual lifestyle and forget to be a sincere practicing Muslim that I should be. I try but cannot be consistent on my religious obligations. All the time I get a thought that I will ask forgiveness to Allah, and there is time. I feel so sad that I cannot be like you, man! Want to prioritize Islam over anything else in the world. May Allah include you in His blessed servants, keep you steadfast on the straight path and increase you in knowledge.
So then how does this ‘doctor’ explain how did Isa Ibn Maryam (A.S) brought dead to life?!
Doctor: Yani yani if you believe yani I don’t believe... duh!
May Allah strengthen you and give you more brother Sajid. Ameen
Exactly God in the flesh, ameen
😂😂
SubhanaAllah... I've never seen Dr Yassir so confused may Allah guide us all...
Brothers and sisters in Islam, please pray for my family too. May Allah give His guidance to my love one. 😭😭 ameen 🙏🙏
Ameen May Allah guide them
@@AbuYasir2023 ameen. Thank you 🙏
U r welcome akhi which country r u from?
@@AbuYasir2023 أن اخة من اندونسي
“Mid evil times” is a condescending label for the era Islam was spreading throughout and had strong influence in Europe. May Allah protect us all from callers to misguidance. Ameen
By "strong influence", do you mean constantly attacking, taking lands, enslaving and raping / selling of European women? Do you mean pre-emptively attacking Spain and taking it over for 700 years before being kicked out the year before that country became the #1 world super power in 1492?
Didn’t Spain do that to most of south and North America? Islam was brought to many lands without fighting. The purpose in which to make the law of the Creator prevail. And to warn its inhabitants from worshipping and joining partners in worship with The Creator of the heavens and the earth. Slavery did exist as it did with every other nation at the time. However the prophet pbuh was sent with rulings to eradicate slavery, honor and respect women and the weak. Which is why Slaves, women and coloreds were the first to embrace Islam. Pow’s also accepted Islam after the kind treatment from there own captors
M3
Is that what your mommy taught you about Islam?
If Muhammad came to abolish slavery and help women why didn’t he ever free his own slave Bilal? Muhammad could have released Bilal while he was dying.. but didn’t.
Islam is for women? Why did Aisha say that of all women she ever saw, Muslim women were treated the worst?
Islam is no different than every other man made religion that takes the idea of a Righteous creator Most High God, and twists it with a religion based around earthly gain.
Land. Spoils of war. Slave women. And dying “honorably in a war for your “god”.
Nothing like what God intended the world to be like.
@Doktor Hachi Roku That doesn't make it any less correct.
He's calling them medieval times and by that he means they are old and outdated which makes no sense whatsoever
Brother Saajid your channel deserves 5 mics.
(وَإِن تَتَوَلَّوْا يَسْتَبْدِلْ قَوْمًا غَيْرَكُمْ ثُمَّ لَا يَكُونُوا أَمْثَالَكُم") (38) محمد
سبحان الله ، جزاك الله خير يا اخ ساجد وثبتك الله على الحق .
Masha Allah. I’ll stop listening to Yasir Qadhi after this. I can’t believe he used the words “medieval Islam” and he’s denying the existence of Ya’jooj wa Ma’juuj. May Allah guide us.
When you remove people from the ulamaa you can tell them what you want and they will accept it
doesn't this work both ways? At the end, truth claimes have to be checked critically using our rational capacity :-)
Hans
1: according to who?
2: what rational capacity do you have with regards to the unseen in order to be justified in making use of it?
Yasir Qadhi is in crisis of faith. May be Tony Blair whispered this interpretation to Yasir Qadhi.
This feeble minded creature is doing nothing but yaling ever since he left Yale university. As Abu Musaab Wajdi Akkari said in a video.
“ his own alleged intellect” Lol good job brother sajed
It is good to see a native speaker of English with a good understanding of the Deen and explains it to a broader audience. Thanks Bro Sajeed. You are helping us. We have to be careful and seek guidance to Allah all the time .
May allah protect us from arrogance and keep us steadfast. Ameen
It's strange how relaxed Dr. Qadhi feels in expressing such views publicly, as if there are no repercussions.
Hes waking up, he'll come out soon.....
Where? What was the problem? I watch Sheikh Yasir Qadhi's video and I don't see what's wrong. Educate me
@@danoneall4013 see this is the thing, some will accuse yasir of being heretical whilst others will consider him to be moderate. No true scotsman springs to mind....
@@jinn_1891 - When he said Medieval, I took it as the time frame, not a low dig at our early scholars or writers.
It is very dangerous to dictate to someone on which words to use. Slippery road my friend
@@danoneall4013 lets face it, there will always be a tension between those who believe literally and those who take it as a guide and it is more often than not that it's the literalists who accuse the other of deviation.
This guy (Yasir Qudir )just forgot nothing is impossible for Allah and science is just some knowledge of Allah s creation but nothing. Thanks for the great explanation. May Allah protect our iman ameen
Subhaan Allah,
Only Allah guides the HEARTS, Yaa Muqalibal Qulub thabit Qulubina Alaa Deenik❤May Allah Guide Yasir Qadi's HEART and All Muslims.Allahuma Ameen❤
Ameen!
I realize it’s a years ago when i started to listen Yasir kadhi he is none but a paid scholars. Scholars of dollars..
One of the top scholars of moderate islam(kafir).
Thank you for posting this video. I really appreciate how you are never afraid to always speak the truth.
Sadly I saw a CZcams video pop up that was using what Yasir was saying on this particular subject as fuel to disprove Islam. They were basically saying look a scholar of Islam is saying this stuff. Someone that knows him needs to talk him into going back to Saudi Arabia to sit with some more scholars. Yasir's misguided opinions are causing a lot of harm in my opinion.
Dude! May Allah elevate you. Keep doing what you do. We need more bruhs doing this kind of work. I applaud your efforts!!!
It goes to show how strong his Eman is !
Honestly im shocked my what Yasir Qadhi said. You honestly smashed it brother
Smash - khabibs word
@@moaaisha1155 smesh😉
I listen to yasir qadhi a lot. But now I am thinking how stupid or maybe I never give much attention or think what he was saying. I will keep respect yasir qadhi . But the point you raise is 100 % rational more rational then Yasir rationality.
Abdul rehman Malik true man. I’ve listened every lecture of Dr. Yasir but never realize how he calling Tale etc.
Realised him calling stuff tales legends and folklore especially the Great Flood
@@luisgatmaitan9897 Yaseer Qadhi should explain his stance more often
I have watched his videos and he tends to say things like that
@@luisgatmaitan9897 his observation of the Yajooj Majooj wall is 1...second I once watched his lecture about Noahs Arc and he indirectly called it a tale legend myth whilst trying to use other methods to show it may have happened
same with me bro ... And now i am thinking Next time He will said Jins does not make any sens , How they cant be seen .... It does not fit scientific view .... We have thermal detection devices so why we cant see any Jin ? And we have horror movies like Ghost busters So why we cant capture any Jin yet through those Machines.. Lol
Brother Saajid, I would like to applaud you for coming out to point out what you believe to be wrong in what Dr Qadhi mentioned. I know well that you can be attacked for that. But this is our DUTY! When anyone says something publically, that we believe to be against the teachings of Islam, then there is a duty upon us to point out what's wrong also publically. And to those who say: who are you to refute or criticise a 'scholar': scholars do not have 'sanctity' in Islam! We do not worship them! We weigh what anyone (whomsoever) says or does against the Haq that we have received from God. Umar Ibn Al-Khattab himself (may Allah be pleased with him), who was known to be Al-Farouq (the one who had the ability to distinguish between right and falsehood), when he was appointed the Caliph (so we're talking here about not only a scholar but also a companion and a Caliph!), he asked his people: what would you do if I ever happen to stray from the straight path like this (pointing with his hand)? A man from the crowd came out and took out his sword saying: we shall 'fix you up' with this! Then Umar said: Alhamdulillaah (thanks/praises to Allah) for making in my people those who will correct me when I go astray! So please do not worry about these misinformed calls for you to not talk about what you see as munkar under the banners of 'unity' or 'avoiding fitnah'! These people really don't know what they're talking about! If you and others stay silent many people will be misled by falsehood and we shall all carry the burden of that on the Day of Judgement.
The truth is, western/secular academia presents popular (scientific) theories, as undisputed fact. But that isn't the case at all. At BEST, 'we' have popular working models; supported by research and evidence. But they are often subject to change, as soon as new research and new evidences comes out. There's a lot of ego and also politics in science. Some scientists just want to make a name for themselves, and sometimes scientific research/announcements/dogma is influenced by rich and powerful people who want to influence public opinion in specific ways
The point of not understanding the Quran due to not speaking Arabic is a real problem with many Muslim countries. It is really important to read the Quran in the language that you understand so that we get to know ALLAH and really understand our religion.
The power of Allah cannot be limited, especially after we witnessed his creations of this universe.
Mashallah brother Yasir.
I totally agree. They're teaching our children atheistic beliefs in the schools such as gravity, the age of the Earth and its shape. But we already know that Allah created heavens and Earth in six day and if Allah said in the Qur'an that the Earth is flat, I'm not going to believe the Google Earth under my fingertips on my smartphone, Alhamdulellah! Takbir!
Whenever something in the Quran and authentic Sunnah does not make sense to me, I remember that this religion is called Islam: submission to our Creator. Therefore, my opinion, ignorance and desires must submit to Allah and His messenger.
May Allah bless our brother Sajid Lipman who is always on point and is always giving good reminders to the Muslims and saving Muslims from deviant ideologies.
Let's not forget that our brother yasir was once amongst our guided scholars whom beautifully thought the correct way of the Qur'an and the Sunnah. This is a great FITNAH for him and us. We should make duah that Allah protects the rest of us from such fitans and guides our brother back. AMEEN YA RABUL 'ALAMEEN.
AMIN.!!
@@brianclone9583 we will see who had common sense on the day of judgement.
@@brianclone9583 we will see judgement day stop waffling...
@@brianclone9583 A loon from the 7th century? It really shows your ignorance about Islam.
@@brianclone9583 OK.
May Allaah increase you in knowledge and safeguard you my brother, your work is appreciated.
To all the people defending Yasir Qadhi; why is it so hard to believe that there's a tribe hidden somewhere in the world when you accept the Israa Wal Mirage of the prophet peace be upon him?! If you believe that the Prophet peace be upon him traveled from Madinah to Jerusalem and then ascended to the heavens and returned to Madinah all in the same night then how is it hard to believe that there's a tribe hidden from us somewhere?!
These are clearly attempts to make Muslims doubt their deen. May Allah guide us all and keep us on the straight path.
الحمدلله for this logical clarification
Fitna is all around us. May Allah swt protect us and make us from the righteous & pious believers. Ameen.
Ameen
Ameen
@Vietnam California, yeah? Surah al imran ayah 85
{وَمَن يَبْتَغِ غَيْرَ الْإِسْلَامِ دِينًا فَلَن يُقْبَلَ مِنْهُ وَهُوَ فِي الْآخِرَةِ مِنَ الْخَاسِرِينَ} [آل عمران : 85]
(And whoever desires other than Islam as religion - never will it be accepted from him, and he, in the Hereafter, will be among the losers.)
@Vietnam California, yeah? To begin with, we have to keep in mind that before the quran was revealed their were other books such as the torah, injil, and zabur that were revealed to the past prophets and if the quran or in this case the hadith says it just comes to show that it was just confirming it. Like an example many before claimed that surat al kahf(surah 18) plagiarized the syriac text when it came to gog and magog but later came out the Syriac text came after the quran and even referenced it and as for Dajjal the Quran doesn't name him however the hadith talks about him and the prophet (pbuh) talked about him more in depth and taught us something about him that no other prophet before him since the time of noah even said about him. As for hadith and the chains of narrations we also have to take into account that their is a grading for each hadith from sahih to maudua and scholars such as an nawawi, bukhari, muslim, malik, ahmed (may allah have mercy on their souls) just to name a few were the ones to do that grading and if a hadith contradicts what the qurab says than it is weak and not acceptable but the ones that are sahih are taken as trustworthy but even then some scholars have disagree with them and take closer look at it and an example of that is imam albani in which he regraded some hadith that had a broken isnad and texts. Plus the Mahdi was never mebtuoned in the talmud because only the prophet(pbuh) talked and explained about him first and also he(the mahdi) comes from the prophet's lineage. We juat cannot simply reject hadith and take the quran only because if that were the case then we wouldn't know how to pray and how much to pray regarding rakaat. Plus the talmud was first translated in arabic 2012 and the prophet wouldn't just hear some parts of the talmud and put it in the Quran a long period after he heard it(more info in the vid below which refutes a dude using the same arguement). Plus also we have tafsirs like for example the tafsir of ibn kathir, al qurtubi, and al jalalayn to name a few. Anyways bruh I hope this explains the point and in the end of the day I don't really want to have dispute between me and a bro of faith because it is just no right but just correct what is needes to be corrected✌
czcams.com/video/SL3GLr7XW30/video.html
{آمَنَ الرَّسُولُ بِمَا أُنزِلَ إِلَيْهِ مِن رَّبِّهِ وَالْمُؤْمِنُونَ ۚ كُلٌّ آمَنَ بِاللَّهِ وَمَلَائِكَتِهِ وَكُتُبِهِ وَرُسُلِهِ لَا نُفَرِّقُ بَيْنَ أَحَدٍ مِّن رُّسُلِهِ ۚ وَقَالُوا سَمِعْنَا وَأَطَعْنَا ۖ غُفْرَانَكَ رَبَّنَا وَإِلَيْكَ الْمَصِيرُ} [البقرة : 285]
(285 ) The Messenger has believed in what was revealed to him from his Lord, and [so have] the believers. All of them have believed in Allah and His angels and His books and His messengers, [saying], "We make no distinction between any of His messengers." And they say, "We hear and we obey. [We seek] Your forgiveness, our Lord, and to You is the [final] destination."
@Vietnam California, yeah? Bro I already most of it and sought out opinions of others on it but if you really want the quran in a well explained manner to what it is befitting in the message it brings the tafsirs I mentioned are the to go bruh plus I never really asked for you to answer or in this case any answers from anyone(just saying)
Our eyesight has a limit. Our hearing has a limit. Our strength has a limit. Our sense of smell has a limit. Our speed has a limit...etc. Why is it so difficult to accept the reality that our brains and intellect have a limit? "And of knowledge you (mankind) have been given only a little"(Surah al-Isra' 85). In the introduction of Sahih Muslim is a profound statement by Muhammad Ibn Sireen (Rahīmahullah): "This knowledge is deen so look carefully who you take your deen from."
Great clarification brother, we have gained important thing Alhamdulilah.
Assalamualikum. Jazakallah brother Sajid for uploading this video. Your sincerity is amazing. Love you for the sake of Allah..
Assalam 'alaikum,
Sajid this is one of your best videos without a doubt. People should really learn from that a western guy who is amidst all these tribulations, his belief is rock solid by the will of Allah. Verily Allah guides whom he wills. If we believe whatever is in the Qur'an and sunnah and accept it without adding any of our own interpretations, life becomes really easy. The heart is at peace which cannot be described otherwise life becomes really difficult.
Masha'Allah. Insha'Allah you will always stay the same, and speak the truth.
May Allah guide Dr. Yasir Qadhi, and all those who are struggling.
Jazaakallahu khayran brother...a well rounded, very balanced and thought provoking rebuttal of Yasir Qadhi talk regarding gog n magog. .. Some of the UK students could learn so much from you....Baarakallahu feek
Saajid JazakAllahu khayran for your efforts. Keep going my brother.
Honestly Yasir Qadhi should reply/respond to brother Sajjid's concerns.
I think these are serious points which Dr. Yasir should clarify even for himself.
He has given reply on Facebook Page with regard to his opinion.
On point once again! May Allah bless you and your family. May Allah use you and your family to spread Deen.
if yajooj and majooj are hard to believe because of modern science , then the judgment day is way more impossible to believe according to "science" , nice video brother saajid lipham , peace (Salam).
JazakALLAh khair, dear brother. Thank you so much.
Why can’t people believe that Yajooj and Majooj are hidden somewhere??? We will only understand this when they are released. It’s not for us to understand now!
Just like the following Ayah in the Qur’aan about Firown: Today We (Allah) will preserve (save) your body so you can be a Sign for people who come after you. Surely many people are heedless of Our Signs.”
(Quran chapter10: Verse92)
Firown’s body was only discovered in 1881, so the people didn’t discredit the Qur’aan before his body was discovered, simply because they didn’t find his body.
Thank you Brother, giving us excellent disection of Dr.YQ's speech and explaining step by step. JazakAllah Khair.
Allah reward you my brother. I appreciate the manner you address the issue in such an easy and respectful way. Let this be a lesson for all Muslims, that Allah guides whom he wills and can bring a person born in a non-Muslim environment to teach those who we used to see as our teachers.
May Allah bless your efforts. You truly go beyond the surface and hit the real issues.