Prof G on Why Young Men Are Filled With Rage & An Atheist's View on Faith
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 06. 2024
- Prof G, Scott Galloway, joins the podcast for the first time to talk about why a generation of young men are filled with rage and shame, what to do about it, the biggest threat AI poses, and to offer an atheist's view on faith, and rethinking how to be the church.
----------
Welcome to The Carey Nieuwhof Leadership Podcast, a podcast about leadership, change, and personal growth. I hope this episode helps you thrive in life and leadership.
Subscribe to my channel so you don't miss any of the newest episodes: / @careynieuwhof
Find the show notes and more at careynieuwhof.com/episode646
Follow me for the latest leadership insights:
/ careynieuwhof
/ cnieuwhof
/ cnieuwhof
TikTok: @careyniuewhof
Interested in what gear I use to record my podcast?
I list all of the equipment in this blog post: careynieuwhof.com/the-home-st...
----------
Brought to you by:
GLOO
Did you know people respond to direct mailers 5 to 9 times more often than they do other channels like email and social media? Combine that with texting, and your church has a new outreach superpower.
www.gloo.us/GlooPlus
GENERIS
As a Church leader, you know about the importance of generosity, but do you know how to inspire people to live passionately generous lifestyles?
Whether you're on the verge of a campaign, or simply looking to transform the hearts of your church through generosity, the team at Generis provides custom solutions that will meet you and your church right where you are.
generis.com/carey
Intro Music:
Song: Alexey Anisimov - Always Be Beautiful
Music provided by Tunetank.
Free Download: tunetank.com/track/4144-alway...
----------
Chapters
00:00 - Young Men and Rage
02:26 - Scott Galloway on Becoming Who You Are
06:30 - Generation Z
10:19 - Loneliness among millennials is a crisis
18:00 - How to Help Young Men
22:28 - Ideas for More Moderates in the Election
25:16 - The Biggest Threats to AI
28:15 - Washington and the Christian Church
29:17 - Atheism
36:56 - What might be a game changer for the Church?
41:06 - Scott Galloway on the Alt-Kingdom
43:47 - Tithing
51:18 - How to Get Out Of Financial Insecurity
52:07 - Carey on Liberty and the Idea of Surplus Value
Scott, we don’t feel like we have no opportunity, we KNOW it!
Prof G admits and takes accountability for his generations role in all of this. Very admirable.
And then he gives them advice that depends on a level of economic stability he acknowledges has vanished.
He doesn't even read any of the comments. He admitted that in several other podcasts...he considers it a waste of his time. So unfortunately he spouses his theories or whatever they are ..he repeats what he has been saying 3 yrs ago. He doesnt even live in US anymore. He has tons of money but he isnt investing or creating any programming to get ppl involved.
It will no way even happen cause all dark money in government and bribes that politicians take to do there bidding of craven people 😂
I’m 28 and been working in Church for 7 years. The pain of young men is something I have experienced and been passionate about. Thank you for this conversation, it was a potent reminder for me to see others as an opportunity to give surplus value in all I do.
Male loneliness is a feminist narrative and their are the ones who are peddling it..
Cool
To many companies and rich people hoard the money like drug addicts and refuse to spend it no matter what .😮
The rich need to start paying there taxes and quit always looking for cheap labor at your company so you can't keep up with share holder values which is bullshit
Omg you are the problem … f ing ridiculous
Prof G is right on point about the struggle with young men. As a retired principal I can tell you I saw this coming 25 years ago, but none of my peers wanted to discuss and/or consider making changes in our school programs to solve this issue. “There is no empathy for young men!” Many would say in anger that young men are getting what is long overdue them. So sad. In the end women suffer as much as the young men because they cannot find an equitable mate.
Well spoken
You've hit the nail on the head. I'm 75 and men of my generation in many aspects of life did not treat women well, culturally or personally. Any woman who was able opted for single independence. We didn't have to suffer lack of respect and physical violence from a mate, as women before us did, but as you say, it's not a full life. However, it's not the young men of today who are responsible for my generation's actions. It's we who are responsible for their pain, and for helping them grow to be men who can be proud of themselves. As a teacher, I could do what I could to help, but I couldn't be the good male role model and mentor they needed. So frustrating.
Saying women suffer also due to the lack of an equitable mate is not really a suffer if they do not want what is historically spoken against.. But the economy is exacerbating this issue
Conservatives are very trashy people and mean spirited against everyone that is not like them .
The problem is we have no wage cap. The vast majority of the resources are flowing into the hands of the few faster each year. Feels bad when the top 10% get to eat 90% of the pizza.
well it's bad but not that bad. The top 1% in the US own about 30% of the weatlth. But a wage cap won't help...these people don't earn wages.
I love Scott Galloway because he's so spot on. I agree with him about the reasons for rage and shame, related to income disparity between the old and young. But as the father of a now teenager, the affect of the covid pandemic can't be ignored. My son was 11 through the worst parts of the covid lockdown and sitting at home playing video games for only a couple of months had such a profound affect on him. I bought some mountain bikes which has since turned into a very important hobby for us. His primary friendship base has been built around it. It's been huge for his self worth. I hate to blame video games for the problems of young me, but it was making my son miserable. Video games don't build self worth.
Galloway is a coward who dont debate
The main problem with the lockdowns was the inability to see friends outside of school or college. I’d argue that playing video games is a symptom of social isolation, it was really the only way you spend time with friends during that period.
The worst thing about this interview is that it will likely generate a flood of comments accusing the podcast of accommodating “wokeism.”
Don’t let that deter you; not only was this fantastic, it’s essential listening.
Carey, thank you for your courage in once again opening your platform up so we can hear diverse cultural voices from people with wisdom and compassion.
You know this business, called “Wokeism” really is a load of non-sense and is really just a right-wing invention to put people down. Any hint of caring makes it a target. It makes me laugh how the same right-wingers use mens difficulties to rage, particularly if you point out violence towards women. But, they’re more interested in the rage, than doing anything about it. The red states have the worst statistics regard just about everything. The top ten violence states are red, starting with Alabama. What are the governors doing about it. Obviously nothing. Trumps is all talk and not likely to do a damn thing, other than use them as soldiers. If I were a democrat Id be campaigning on just this issue. It would be about school, trades, encouraging mentor groups and bringing industry and infrastructure to these states to give them meaning, purpose and opportunity. Isolated men are just dangerous and serve no purpose. Just a thought.
I love this dialogue and the indept transparency. Watched the whole thing
Thanks, Scott. You demonstrate the best of humanity. And that without religion.
His politics are what brought this about.
Now THIS is a great interview. What a healthy, helpful and refreshing way to engage in thoughtful conversation... thank you Carey and Prof G!
So glad you enjoyed it
The collab we didnt know we were getting!!! This is awesome
I was excited for this one!
What an awesome conversation with Scott. Please have him on more and soon! I have a grandson who Scott described. We don’t know how to help him because he is so indifferent to life. I loved Scott’s observations of the American Christian Church and how it contrasts with many Christians who think that all the problems exist outside the church. I loved hearing Scott’s personal values, personal life sharing, and his suggestions. Again, great conversation!
Thanks for sharing Gary and for watching
I so enjoyed this podcast. I am a parent of two young men and when going to look at colleges with them, I was reminded of the complete flip of % men to % women on college campuses. It's such a massive turn around in such a short time.
It's great to hear a professor's thoughts on these changes and our society.
I found the political discussion quite interesting as well.
Thank you, Carey!
So true Leslie, thanks for sharing
Church is very authoritarian mined and want everyone to do what they say no matter what or how they get hurt
Fantastic conversation. Prof. G offers brutal honesty but a fresh perspective on life and people.
Scott is as sharp and insightful as ever, and his utter honesty in this conversation was so refreshing. And Carey did a brilliant job guiding the conversation and representing Jesus all throughout. 5 stars to both of you! Thank you for this.
Thanks for watching Jesse
Young men need fathers and or male mentors. Everyone needs that one person who believes in them
Absolutely one of the best interviews that you’ve done in quite a while, Carey! I love Scott’s insights on a lot of different things, and it helped me really think through some points that he had about American Christianity and how we refocused for the future.
So glad it was thought provoking
Wow! This was such an enlightening conversation! Thank you!
I am so illuminated and challenged listening to the discussion. Thanks pastor carey for the podcast and thanks to Prof G for the Wealthy of intellectual knowledge and challenge for all to reach out to the youth and those that are not with us in church.
thanks for watching James, glad it was a healthy challenge
Such a cool conversation. I really appreciate Galloway's perspective and personal honesty, especially as a Christian who works in branding. Thank you for a terrific interview!
So refreshing to hear such honesty. And great insights and social commentary on top of it.
Carey, I love how you spoke so respectfully to him about your faith and allowed him to speak about his spiritual beliefs.
Cool
What a great conversation and great guy! And I love you the way u ended the conversation with the appeal to the Kingdom. After hearing Mr. Galloway, I felt the same way. This podcast is inching it's way of being my favorite. Great work. Thx..God bless!
Much appreciated!
Wow! Amazing conversation and teaching - Thank you both 🙏🏼
Glad you enjoyed it!
Carey, honestly I had never heard of Scott until this interview. Perhaps I’ve been living under a rock. But this was an engaging and informative interview. I will go back and watch this one again. And like Scott, I agree that if the church had more Careys, perhaps the church would help others know they are closer to the Kingdom of God. Thanks for this platform and for doing this interview!
So glad you've now been introduced to Scott!
You're talking about an America that never existed. He's been privileged for so long that he can't see the 99% AT ALL.
He's making himself richer by pretending to be an advocate for men while continuing to profit from and denigrate men.
I was poor, not an "immigrant", didn't qualify for pell grants while supporting a dad with Parkinson's and a mom with breast cancer. No one lifted a single finger to help me, while being a permantly injured veteran that couldn't even use my GI bill. His class and generation completely screwed me. I spent the winter mixing concrete by hand with a torn meniscus and the VA doing everything they could to keep from fixing it. No one cares.
I volunteered to defend this country in the infantry while having the highest GT score in every unit I was in. No one cares. I was in the top 10% of my high school, a famous one they made a TV show about, and still didn't get scholarship of any kind. I had to work yhrough HS and never did homework. No one cares.
All this began in the 80's. It has only gotten worse. He's promoting the policies that helped me so much I can't use the words I want to describe the level of disdain I have for his social cast and politics.
America is over.
Welcome to amerika comrades.
Keep voting, cause that's working. That's sarcasm.
Throughly enjoyed this conversation. Thank you Carey and Prof G 🙏
Glad you enjoyed it!
I loved every word of this podcast. Thank you both so very much!
Thanks for listening
Wow….so powerful and relevant. Thank you!
thank you for watching - hope it was helpful
Great conversation guys. Thank you
Glad you enjoyed it!
Amazing interview. Thank you.
Glad you enjoyed it!
wow, he's very clear.
Like them or not, he has answers/things we should try and do to try and fix the problems. He has obviously thought a lot about it. Thank you for a great interview.
How is he going to fix the stolen wealth?
Carey, such a great episode!
thanks man
@@CareyNieuwhofTerrible interview you didn't challenge him.Scott only goes to safe zones where he won't be challenged.. Galloway needs some serious education...
good honest dialogue about money, life, and faith!
loved Prf G's honesty and humor.
good job interacting with him with the gospel, being urself carey. May he come into the Kingdom soon. "they will know we are Christians by our love..."
May our Lord Jesus raise the next generation of men, tender in heart n fierce in Kingdom of God agenda-love God, love people, make disciples.
This is one of the best Christian resource out there.
First time here on this channel. Great discussion ❤
thanks for watching
Scott's view of having companionship with his two boys and the dogs would be analogous to Christ's declaration in the Thomas writings that "The Kingdom is here" and the many just cannot see it before them.
More people need to see this video
please share it :)
Hiding behind an old story gives the opportunity for some to creat a world of instant solution that don’t work out in the raw heat of life’s reality. Facing the world head on is at times very hard but at least you can show it is solid and real and provable.
Yes. Pay congress/president much more. The current crop are either looking for deferred compensation or insider-trading during incumbency. We need competent, ethical people to run and the current incentives keep them out.
True
I do agree with you however that social media is absolute crap!
Moderates need to participate in primary elections. Without them, only extreme candidates advance.
Has Gary come out? Is that allowable in his church?
Scott says empathy isn't a zero-sum game, but sometimes opportunity is zero-sum. If the goal is to promote/hire/recognize women in a company, that has direct consequences for men at that same company.
Religion is not the cause of strife. It is merely a pretext.
A wealthy capitalist trying to explain the dilemma of 99% of men who are outside his caste?? A total rationalist, logistical and statistical genius, who can't explain the first thing about how to parent... Thinks lack of money is the most important problem of most men, and makes it sound so convincing.Trying to explain what my dilemma is?? Really!!
Really!!
This guy does not qualify as an advocate for me!
I tuned into this guy a year ago, and was turned off by his narcissism- still am...
Wrote a book...Wow!? Keep up the Ketamine. Maybe you'll have a breakthrough.
I'm accountable for what I say here. You can trace me through my channel..
Glad I'm not the only one to see what he really is. A grifter.
56:10 “You’re not that far from the kingdom of God”
Man it’s so hard watching someone so close.
Only if you have a blind belief in your personal cult....
All this stuff is predicated on certain basic ideas that despite cultural and economic assumptions to the contrary simply do not apply to everyone. For instance that everybody wants to make a lot of money, that everybody wants to be in a " romantic relationship", that everybody is interested in tech, social media etc. that everybody wants to own a house ad nauseam. People are people and they want different things for as many reasons as there are people in this world. A lot of the sadness, rage and anger among the entire population, not just men, derives from the powers that be, the establishment if you will promulgating the idea that you're not an ok person if you don't want or are not interested in what everyone is supposed to want in this totally heartless society. Like it or not Jack it's the people who pay 14 million in taxes and the corporations they serve so enthusiastically that make the sick twisted rules and impose the perverted ideas on people and their lives that ends up resulting in so much misery. I like guitars and making music. I like riding my bike. I like animals and would never dream of driving around in a car as if it's what God intended destroying the little creatures of this earth and turning them into roadkill while destroying the atmosphere...etc. I've been in five relationships with Women and had some other adventures with them as well but it never really worked out for me. Does that mean my life's been a waste? You talk as if everyone should aspire to being like everyone else if everyone else is a property owning car driving corporate ladder climbing clone of the capitalist consumerist ideal in other words the very sort of sucker who believes they can't make their own rules but have to live a life that ultimately serves the interests of the very wealthy
Prof G is the best. But he can't speak to the restrictions, self hate and negativity that children are immersed in who grow up in many religions (catholic in my case) Thank god' religion is on the way out and maybe we can take the kindness and compassion of the sermon on the mount and bring it to discussion, the streets, action and economics
Lol. Whenever I hear the statistics that single women own more houses than single men, I would love to see the details of why. It could have nothing to do with women getting the house in the divorce settlement or that men tend to die earlier than women, so they are now single and left with the house.
Young men are falling behind. The obstacles are online porn, video games, no adult responsibilities like marriage and children, no money, social media, lack of sexual contact with women, and staying longer at home. Parents are also enabling their children by allowing them to stay at home. Young men are also not passionate about something. There used to be families where kids took music lessons. Many turned that into a hobby or even a profession. Spending 6-8 hours a day on their phones is not a passion.
No, those are the symptoms. The problem is fundamentally economic. And even this smug mediocre prick acknowledges it.
Someone needs to interview Scott right after a mass shooting in US. I wonder if young men in other countries are actually as lonely as those in US. I would guess not since no other country is as individualistic as the culture of US.
The same thing affects people in other western countries like The UK where I’m from. The isolation from the Covid lockdowns, the overstimulation of social media, and the lack of third places are all problems that affect young men in the UK. I haven’t had much luck with dating either mostly because I haven’t had the courage to ask a girl out.
@@MW-dd8vk my personal experience ...I had to go to a different country to find anyone attracted to me. I was exchange student in high school late 1980's...only there for a summer, didnt make many friends nor could I talk to the host parents as I didnt speak Portuguese. In college, I learned Portuguese, did a year abroad in Portugal, finally had full convos with them. But during that year, I dated two guys...in US no guy had an interest. The two ppl were not even Portuguese but they were from former Portuguese colonies. They also were different from my race. Not sure of why I didn't fit in as I was younger...to some extent still don't but do not care anymore. I would think it would be much much harder now with everyone's eyes glued to their devices. But from my observations of UK students at a university or in a university town in US...ppl flocked to hear the accent. (However back then it wasn't as easy to hear other English flavors.) Most of the time ppl become friends before they do any asking out...if there is an chemistry it will happen naturally. Takes the pressure off...though making friends as you get past college age seems to be harder than it should be.
The Age of Materialism is evident everywhere and technology and social media has supercharged that idea.
Edit: The Prof now lives in London. Perhaps he could move to San Diego (the nation's most expensive city) and help solve the homeless situation there.
I loved the commentary on the He Gets Us campaign. I agree, the marketing of it was brilliant, but for me it had a fairly dramatic backfire effect as I see almost no actual evidence from modern Christianity in America, of self-professing Christians comporting with any of the imagery. I know the Green family helped fund it and they have a very dubious track record with women's and trans rights (not to mention the Museum of the Bible museum antiquities scandal). Also, related to my first point, based on how *many* if not *most* of the most vocal Christians I know actually behave toward the LGBTQ community, it was just a massive message about hypocrisy. Final point and then I'll get off my soap box, imagine how much food for food pantries could've been bought, or homeless shelters built, or women's shelters funded, with the money spent (and being spent) on the campaign. It's just a massive "talk the talk" rather than "walk the walk" which is what I see out of almost every loud and proud Christian around me these days.
I love God, and I dislike the church. The preservation of reputation (which failed because it was counter to the nature of God) over justice for the victims and acountability for the predators and the treatment of LGBT really soured me on the church as an institution. For a church, reputation should never come before the primary call of being the hands and feet of God, showing love and support to the othered the poor and opressed.
Nice to hear a woman say this, spent my youth actively involved with church. As a young adult lost a number of friends to suicide because of the church. Still haven't been held to account. Now I'm a member of a Christian Church in a Muslim country, I support my wife in her church activities but leader knows I just want to practice my faith in my own manner. The game that is being played is evident, was interrogated by church leader, I just communicated that if he didn't interfere with my marriage I wouldn't rock the boat with his business
No "solution" that refuses to stigmatize divorce the way Jesus did will ever bring sustainable well-being to many people for very long according any reasonable metric.
Atheism aligns with a correct view of Reality and I believe it - I believe Atheism as spiritual philosophy. I'm not 'kept from Faith' in the sense of not allowing my Will align with that of a religion by some lack of attachment to the mystery. By the way, most people in any religious group don't have the same belief, otherwise that'd be called a cult. And rightly so.
Young women would rather go to college than get married, and so young men have lost their number one motivation to get off their asses and do something.
Exactly.. like why do women prefer to go to college then get married 🤔
@@ashleyw9852 That's what I would do.
Stop having kids. What 4?
“That is my god” says the atheist when talking about love.
Love is god, god is love.
The atheist’s god is god, he just doesn’t know it because hatred likes to disguise himself as god.
A lot of hateful people claim to follow god while following hate, so it makes it hard for those who serve love to realize that they are already on god’s side.
Remember Matthew 6:5-6
Why? Fox news and other right-wing grifters. Your welcome.
Jesus Christ of Nazareth.. I don't even wanna say it but I'm filled with rage. I need the blood of God in Trinity and benevolence from Jesus Christ of Nazareth..
I watched this podcast. Then, I took a trip down memory lane and remembered the virtue and caliber of woman my grandmother. Hmmm. Yeah. Sorry. Way out of touch. Need to recalibrate and jettison the woke goggles.